Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Carter, Stacey

Carter, Stacey
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided January 2, 2015

Carter, Stacey

Opinion

MCQ>10(Q)INJ [Q)~$~0$$/ED C L£1l.K t)F COo/l:t [))fi\'1f!E: t·-w- \s RECEIVED COuttr 6r CP.iMt/JA L .A fl'cS<lW riDV: pv DEC 2 9 Z014 ~o~&x £2S47 THIRD COURr OF APPEALS JEFFREY D KYLE ,4tJ5Tt.AJ iTc~S 787 tl-25'17

JJew Cieri:... (J{~ -ffv.,J evufLJsed a nuhiM ~ f~uesf ~ttt ~ppeal baYd do -fD ·1/re ~- IJ.i/u.re -iD cMSwer; di6(Jdfe or CL>vif.radtct- t¥(11~ cl~'Pu~ lJI!ti&r hi5 //,IJ7 mhea-6 corpos -fOr re(ie.f.. IJpp~ r~s+ ~ reivrvt LD(>Lf o.f ..fws vuttltbv£ ..h1eJ ,Vtfo -#le reaJ,Js , ;).trd ~-fdlM(JeA kfe .{;Is::£ • ...

RECE\VED lN COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS 'JAN 02 2015 Absl Acosta, Clerk

RECEIVED IN COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS DEC 3 0 2014 Abel Acosta, Clerk c,JWS'e' AltJ~ ?2.t 4'W-J<l .5~ce-q cAf.l:rei!!- Uvff ~ Ci<.tM.CAIAL APPEALS V6~U.S FIFTH Citcurr 7/l&~~~~s;' AusnN /t;JCAS l C((j9f~~fl\PPEALS RECEIVED DEC 2 9 Z014 MOf/(}A.} FOL A;dPt;A L BOIJJ:) . THIRD COUR;T Of APPEALS Abel Acos!~. Clerk JEFFREY D. KYLE Now tJJTO CtJu/41 ~ Af¥ll~ !.mo-e &aceq CaAr:Y ;~ ctU;oe ntJUtJ,·er ZZ,,L{lfl.f-A whtJ pur$~ k d(Jp/[Gide Te~ CoJe cECrim/MJ/I'lJCeLII.;re &ovffAI~ IJws . r~cffullq suh,_vnil/6 41el- Cl((Jit~ ;g etttfill~ h d Pt. &v1J v ~~~ ~ hcvi1 no NJiJre ~ lltOitxJb krh ffJMaA6 sei--Ev-111 ~; .:J_, Ap~ hk brtkl#tf' #!is ~ fP"'f .JIJe stole ~ Ulhe/J fMif uAtier .JfJ(i!t;J-iM -C,r ci lullir t$ i/APLM GJR.PU.S se:GK1AJ6 fEU€F F~ FtAIAL FGUW'ICIJA/Vit!l7/J.AJ " U~ ~ tF ~AJAL ~fl.la;O~. Altrlc:LG I l.07. 6Jttf011it'vv1 ~f +m¥er K. lJUttfAd/A ~alie, a~JJr S-eiz.d ~tG4J a.{hy-fhe,fvfitr£··caifiM h Ji,ref/a.Jh-c :s-/q7 enieJ .fOr 5119~, fr& Y/iva.{ tJf 01. Cd.vll'itletK..-9) l/ll(f.Jo urii/e -1-vda cJ. .free04:r f!eBrdA :¥tl.IIJ -lfAe v&u·aeitJ gkA {JIDb.Jide CdvcSe..fo ~8drc/IJ ¥fJ(t~ v&aC!e. .AM #fl~ receivd illefkdlve MSJ~ ~ caM5el .. U.s&v".Dorf&t 199 F.3J 193(s--ft.1ur t9tl9); .A«o- o(kcer tiMJq Tu/n.er 4ne K:-9 ~ J.rrivd IS'IW~ lakY .dd..Jue p1acduro ariJIM!-/he llebtide .s·erve/d.l ffMt:,, -lire K:-7 dii Nor AI.E:/lr~r !~"cbalie 6wr:e -1o ~de. 13~ .fzr d. St::a-rdtzihj af- il'~ :; Bvrlt8M vwaJe -feJ~e .fe.flivudvtlj df evMetdt~ JvtJ· SJJfYJ!e!SiLm hcatifj1 ~ flfal.Jtef & K..-7 dieAl:tl !Or~~ wi!JMJ- a. Wd.l'r~.

3~ 4f -Hle evdeuti3i~t.fJ.IIItiSt!pp1!11Siiu lu:Ki~~al~o-friaf !Ju~ a.bwtled k~ df(frtntAf ~-~he JUslifitdilb4 -f4r.ffle fa-ffc, ril(l r:vtktl £-& .Jr/itBI ti.fhe K:9, h~Je CaA6ewf- fD Sea.rdA vdtUde IAJJ.6 delllid" if. . Sfcie OJperfleMJie w~·-fl'bA.t r~ J)~~o{ fvhfic, ~'iu'~ Ldh -fe:iilieJ ~ w~ .#Je K-9 is frtJ.Jvted -In Jllltf auf C~Jultf AJOI!Jni{f +he iJIIgrr:dter!s iK ~ e.viJ.'IJAbe ~ vseJ ~sfayJpfild1Af/ 7his "verlflhelwu~ k1f~ ~cki:ll3urMIHf£ -iei'~ -lor prtJtsble GWJe J.~ .#Je I& 9 a.lerft-Li. .

S· . ~lJ.{e ekfJe/.f wif~~t?SS ~ 7iJ17t1er-IVleofiiar JJg.,. h$:. :-/he t:.-9 jj;-#ze J<X:Ue :vouwl·-h1e rtelutie -fesfi~iezl;~---111£ 1&9 &tf WIAl..£fl[_•.fo-&e vet1J6e-f>.r&~-io ~ (Jrolaa./de CJ.Vse ~ $eaa:lA ,f,. C/..15dtU_'-/ {.()AJTit41JtCIED R,~s~s6nuuq .f;r..ft1e5earc.~A. ..

j_, ' .· '•"' (p. , · ])ur~ dost~ tY"~fJ~ 9-ade {J'b6ec.vtrrm&fe imper""issihlest~ fa~ ,jurvs -lhJ;f a.prJ:cavtf ~ 01. Jr~ Je~ f'~ Looi6~ wht> COIUe -lo llw5~-lo .bu"f ~ tefuM -lb Lalit'~. Ccum Jn,f reptdldlq sfres.rl"~avr. 6Ccw-ed ~J,&JI not-- he -fridl 16r exfffa.nea.JS ~~i4se or C6U~ C/i'itUe ~r lbr heilllfJ o, cr/Atii~tJ.I ·At- kJ~ D\ IJaJ C3cfor tJ61UdJ!Lt • AJJ,rechf tr, 5f~ lf8fo 5 JJJ. 2J I{)().. Couvtadi.f~~(vro .--It> ~e8- -fD tMprirtUiss·ibte ~, 3VIJ if sv&I-Jind cock/~~-lbr a. Mttl$-/ri'cll.

Jfr~~WJJ~ 10'1 S.~ ~:zaSZ-~ '7.

COIJIIJd eq[eLf ill Mf ret4l~Mf} 1Jvrll64 -Jo-/ftze -s-fcMd -~t, lfupeddt w~k:Jtill/ld4tf ~ ~ if, q a./e/-feA -for (Kthide C4115e Ja.tfty- ·/he IWO 5tafe wi/ues(es CoiJTit4DfcTED 13 u~.s ~ Jx ~Cdv6e, ~ .Jne eviL!Ma sJwu/1 hwe hetn svppt'esxd~5 f;ud-ttP-1/e {JOi6WlJXJSfreetfotri"Ae" UtSf i4 lbr+dlt 19'1 "F. 3:£ t93~Cr- 1~9) .. f:/.

U~T~ Cctte4fCv~ I/Dc.eJure Ar-fide 3g,23~) CouAsel e/;ed/;;rntrt- ~ef!e5f.V~g ,jilr'1 tftf~Tucfrtu uA!u 9fJV61vti~ la.ws :MJ ar1ffi-tvh~f l~s i ~r. ~edit7g tD 1-r~ Cllir:f-s i'a(J/171cf'IIM ~ dtir_ge. ~ ~z s.w, U 1o3 -110 ; FiiS.bi(:! s.so t..2J df 3Cf0 : ~:z ~ ~ 93(0 s,w,·z£ 33 c , 9, Ctwv;d e«tl! lbr ddv1'sl~ d(fif~ 1zJ 5(9u a w~ no-f ID .htecJvt cilrecf d(JfleCJ.I' Cn~a.!l&u 6J'I{d3 C./1 -Afl(it~ ~tt!iitJ /Mlredi've a5sisft:A¥e of ~el hl!!NJ --l1ut hvrLit'lt111f.Mxul'rJ ~his CtJuJKel jJ/MuMdrllee 1A86&efl~ellff'.. .Alb cuvA.Jel 4el~btYuilt( igvttJr .ivtve.sftjdfttte iMf».rltMi rde ,"vJ hJ.r~W~ -iD s~ wd#Ve/ 4111fl/ ..flve.e t3) JUMJ.Ik:s 'iJ.I*r ~ ~~ !.ummel VI esletle m F.S'iqo 793. 1), sC.. A. CtYJsfA~ li.f dt.e pfiJCe<J~ V~tfJ/1. tletE ~ ;W{/'e/eL(a.cfua.f {Jf'~e I'!'~JVU (NlJS~f-ilPt ~ CCJ.M.Sel preceivroJ. Jefa.ulf, CD:A~MelS plb0~ wo de6'devtt wdl hekv.J 6fo4dhr~. Sin~ l()l.{ S~Uf--. 20SZ.-201P'f, w.

UvJv Ar-h'dll lt.o7 oi-Hte Tey.;u; CotkoP &:iMii1al fJ/iJcdu~ :J;;{fbr.ls -Ute 59le J:,qs ..f.c ~we.r ~ Clflf~Caiidf4•. tM A/ovevufxr IL2£Jill d(Jfl~ f71flt~,<u_ fA.BS receiveJ tMtl fddilllo& reCtJ4s ~q{l(-A fdlL~ ;T~..r:li<:.i~,L.v,;y.?J~ ~,.

NMJJrdftJ{e ~ca. L.#dtli1B! il/1#J ';T'LJ,~ lJiJfnt;;~, avJJ Brk3vt Fa/eL( Assi&fiM+ Dl*;d- Muv24f /JciK... COuvtlr( :Te'IGS 101 W~A41i &; 5urfe 2f~. tl. .As ti D~ 17,~Cf -H-e 5trle ftJs AU avts-t.t£/'e.l,Lit'rf1~~ or Ci»tb8Jierffi0 . d.b2tf d! ~!fOIJ/dd ~r re&"eltJf 4uiHol.fb H1e ~ f(!d.SMS ...

. For .Jil1e ftWiaAS ~-lu!reiA Apf6aJ !htJli! he~~ c4 ~eal ba1d ~ s r~ vtlllb- -lne, ciraAAt5~ d-5. a MtJ:flor tJf !)?vt¥1/iN] fd.w.s ouctll da.ib1U!. ~.-sstY+ed b~ d.pplildVIf' /awl Gl-cJie l'ckftJre -lb ~ d3Jvu6 ..

WHeREFtJ~ A#fJLJcAAIT fl'a<.~s-IWJ.f.fw-~· CaJrf!}/tMf- hts 144ofiaA hr ~ d(Jpea./ ht:it7l.fWJf is lB~ ~~ r~ k hi;J !JmMLI flr te/iel' lor"Sbbe l:klvre k dtltsweri avrf1a&rtJr Ji?sfJCife daw'uts / ' vnr't:I3Ea,6/1/e dei21Jf'eAfltg:f ld lo if~ ~.&1 d¥1d6ei2.JK'G willutJr a~/ i1 e-lfecfi/e assi~aF~~ IM!t1 H1i5 ~ Mr.J.Ke i1 re(Jietu of-~ rewa& alAI ellller fllsJ~Ifi ~'iJ!I-IAe ~ -kJ cusf~ bf orJt!llfj hiS re~e o1s il1e h.w dill! ::tJd..s tuq JVJI-ifq,

c 7::~~- st-~ ~#l~{O()l(l?

Cofri& U~~tlt' ~-FM 2o5CI ~~~, Tx 715"88~ A~ lfo.5e

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.