XN 7 We Coui\T OV CfcTtoTML fttytftLS

pro-5^ftPPl'GG/v+ bcJk V%k ^\s" RECEIVED IM I0TIOW DEFIED COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS -—' jAN 28 2015 %XN DM CouftT OF CftxN\TK\^L tXMTL SftPfEftLS §ftUSTXVl,^XftS XHXLVXtU^^NM PtPpLXCftKTS N\oTX0)Vi i\tGtU,ESTlU(3 CoUSXt)tl\- ftTXCHToXWt fcfcfUSftl OV ^LiriVXN fiftuiC-

on o^cewftUv w.^oo^ftp^wco^ f\\M \te f\cst \vcf| c^- i\(jsiV\an ^ W^ \\4^ tf^Vn^r Ccutt r^s^j s&ue^\ cXci ws nxAucla^ \oeffecY^ uSSisKnct of Couo^\.XK^'\o\y>tvVt\p^ V\Ccvy\oft gjc\S oWied on N^rc^ L\, *o^. t\N&-^llS&S-oW\\4-xl(>V o<o-fty

YncY CcmCV on S^no^r\| z\, a&\\. Xh YW^ ^puccYton, YW cWjwis 0^ Co^nss_\. The CoucY d\Sttes.d Y\»^ c\^\JcAViofl c\s a SuloS^iuerH Us^ ftpp"\icaM f\\<,A VvS -VWrA \Nf\V <\>p\\CAfcGft on fcug^\ ^cRnc^ of cas^ ffoper-h| shed- hcd keen <x\|er*.i( £J|d to ^^ q* Suspejd'i naivo. on ?*; an4 lading te+U iHw on pro^f^ ^^OjaSnoVaoccvAa^ for fcMHtStingivY i*** Vhen dUStouejx V\ 4 YWl^M*Cou\cl huot b-efi-n YeS-f^,exChatnof Cu^Mh ^i M"^ S^xduc^^ tt*H*"* K^u^ ^ W«Hd; Ww^| b^ IcoanV +o fte. offrnSft-Cvna Conoichcn, posi03 Support Yo fc*ce*V^ Pursue W^^ fWro^ba p^s^o*, ^omd u^ l^eiup* ^ kloj C«.\cW Yo Y^ WH*f ^Pliccdion-se^ Anderson M-SY^ Wt s^A^^os.^Cxe^.ervw^fH^OL^ ConY^cV of \>esY e^Uence. \^\c, ^odd^cY^ ov cTn^M doc- uw\CnV d^peoas On c\CUowsWeS of ^ch CaSe,^ °nK| r-^uiro- W\<Ln\ (a^Ing -VYcfvvca\\ f£G,sonoJok Cajcou^s o£ Search sWoood b^ Explored -Vo YhcCxHn+^^V^c^onQy^clU^e.nOi.^na^ +h^ eircu^tont^s ojou\a didkKW Mdin^ AW-Copy ^ouid L-c odiAAiH^d cohort lvc\ Cca$ono.Uc effort V^s ten WnadcYo ot^cdo YYc oa^n.a\ and AWc v^ no Suspicion Yhcd Y^CoP7 vwi^WVdv9f«r froMYYt cc ^in^i.''3 * Xo fcxcY(YYe. Skk w\c*k c, s\»3W c^ucvva^ in ucUre^rg AW,ssu*, YWY \V,c fe^^ ^ ¥^ C^uesl £>r fcNfr HM~ i05 /AAa 9-MingS wv\d«< i^ A^ Gou.rY and Y^ failure Yo rt- Wn ^ cesuiH c£w ^\ic^\Y w^y YWc^uif^mB V> W-* \WHsYConducH^; \s'nf Gcgn^Uc on VU^s Carpus Oxpus andcr sccMCc\)-(o) for-Vta purpose of ScvYsfvpnj Yh^dicfaks of Vh«- ^roccdar^ ,ft<rYvc\c W-01, Houe^«er( c\SadetexMvOcYiono9 coned:exs \nfenckd Under Y^pfo- CUuf^ of s^cM^-^J^ercxrYiacll-ol, \b VYcd" <x pc*- 1iw\ inarv\ sVvoUln^ o£ ex/vcX&nCa ^<lY W^V^d, o^r q Cou^cY ori^r^^W -WigJY U^r^ponde^ncc of AWu; - clench o,pp\iCaAf LJoodd aoV Wac \o^n pfbSCGuHd orcon^ u\cUd \f exa^pccW^ r^SulYS hc\cl lo^en o\oWned -l-hro^h bNftKSVin^Cou^d hardly e^ef tc ConS^defsd^fedf cdwv-.msVr^f^or^sKcc. Ex KH Bangui s-u^J

•3, SilVof infcriM U noVU ?^^ ^<f ^ ^ (*oi<u> L)U<nav sen* du«.fe U*. e«w4 .rv^irg ^W

W ^ u f S ^ C*noi<*o« ^uUat ml on

To VWis regcM-A Vv>e sWk \^<k VvAA^cr no $^ou?aA^ Ao c^oc Su^WU*VWiSSue.afeoer Wn^Af*- SojY product oJfK WUaW^Hl ord*fSW\ ^0 Wkd d^o W( \WConuiCfirq CourViW«ir>,<xv\YWnjs SWcUdUsYiAcH cbo^donv^aAofAWsSu*,AW^^H3 ^ C^VofCra* tnoA ftpp&us foW^r^di'cdiixA of AWteScxn for feSctafrtfV CofidusTon,CJiYKbuf u Serious gcVHvvapiA° c^uji or Sukstoo- Y\<M^ AW isScue, "i5 <a u^oer or cxb^ncionvwi/i-}- of YW i5Sue).

3.

In ^YeoSpccVvo^i YV^c <f"\Vn3 of VWSulo&e^atnA corif QW^ed ^fOundS Vna.\ Cou\d UoV Woe ftCen\ouSl^ Wr> ^CSenftd uWfc AY^erc u3cvs an ad^uc^e, fcyv^N cdr W p^d^>xVic^w\v[ fj\^d CW^H HoVonD^^d prooC- ^WA 9uCYfec facAuoA unfcr\McJ^n a*v CW103 e^vdene^ used ad fu<x\ CwYuWoY^i Ao fA>c GwoioYw of a^pfounA L>"v\W>od AYc (Luvd^nc^ e>uer (0^05 HSA^d-TLn rcuvcUrKj YY*, Cc^cYs order, Y^ Oonolcfio^ CourV vWc a r^SonaUe clcferwuncd- \on of V^c facfSf \\^cA \d^nY^ U)<\$ an t^ut io YW CaS<l, end YVA AA\<L Ca^Vicc-nV nod W^dc <a sY^ouovn^ L>^ <a preponderance o£ fA>c e^du^cc, AW nc Loou\d noA naoo Wa^^1 OC ConokYcd \Q YW e,X- Cu\f>^Hv\ exdvdjina WV Uotn H^fcd u-^Wa f^SiAAi> oUain^d A^OSU^h VNM\-\\^\\os;fKow\QS\|- SAd-^.Wv S-cj-^d iss^ioi CT^-CfivvA^pp-iS^^y In ConAfasA, U3\A^ud °^j r^frS Vvwxog been otWn^< A^ Scvb^Y^C^ On aoAWn^Wa WB, foc\d U ^Oo-U^ Of W, Y\o\d \\c|u^SSucA> as \(,goY^vM^A^^ OVvUh VW ^ CAV^H cVvSC^axckA \nVU CW (cK ^0CcccU3( ^rWs SYvoudd noV USul^Yo anv, proc^ur^ uteVAw> coW\WftncJl^of VW^o^ro^^^dJ?.^^/^ SuVH,S^onOdWo\j.^^^ of txaoi™ W ^\s %AnM^ A* Mi^'O,^ Sei Ex p^rfc -i-i 9^^P^daa,^McT^.or^appdclc(5VN\^ou^lfYc Thomas ,*••»' .

Lcd^S Cdurf vn<xpViCvV\\( found +WA A**, cdtod^ clocu^nfs VMI ta \W SA4& CeSpoovt Ao \W fovft H^j does n^A C^n- sv%V ofvneco\^ a«*w*i eo*W Sfncc ^ ^ port of H •U* atocci \n^CxvW>n4 proc^a;oj closet Ccntfvk* or^jr<, WuaV HU*S PoSS-.««.^ V^SVaH SfcWfcf ckU^d 4W V" Vuro S^ro^ ^ °- ft>rVAtddt,k bocfier Under

KnoYio^ ftr ^ ^T^^ wW ^ J i-UGourff-

C\r- 9\oo0- TWW WsteurV sWld r^AcoSlcUr AUwrl> on ^

_ Sc>Vw^\k;n3 dvW ¥**i ^°cA W*J t^n aisQuer^),Q,)-VKreH5h U^3 VestedSL^M' ^PP^'S fe«o^ W«V feVj on « ^OW <^Ppoiv\H Cooo%J Hor SV^ toWt> U3« Ofcinr -\c> Con s' clued- ond CoWvpl^k AAul pro^SS.\K(AY^oY^o^r n<uji>g Y^+e^ C-eSuAYs Vu)0 C^uid ^wa^r^ ciKd (ofYh ^c-MCO-fc)^ YW grounds -\V»cJ- Such (j6uld hcu>^ L,^ kroujM- up [n+tap^~ Uious uppl(Ca,fronS ojVoo VW, f^oW| t^tSLs (r-eWY^ K^d n^Y W-eiV)ckY^r^^^ }fu&r ^^ W ^5<M tc^sft Ccourfs Rinding io Ki\o\w *ror WW b^Ln ScoksReJ in ofd^c (V cvppl(cc^f Ao Iamiu} e.iVW°f AWlYuo e^ptonsdn iArYYYo") (f\Y ^n Yfi^ujrffi \W CobrY oVu>uid noACowip^A^" nc^cY Ao GnSickr YYaY o\ppl|CC-nY MUcU, USkjoUKng CvS Ao Ojhvj K^ tS ^Ydlcd A^ noa^L Ws cor(Y Considered, uU^l, UJiAWi- Yk. <AWe5.eduvoAW* oKkv^^^nd YW UlY^f^j Of cloU^iuiVvfs cluf^S poy^processr^YWCA^Sup^s Advc ociSfc^cc o^ao^ckinc*'' inujWCh ^pp^^ SWdW- U fc- SYr^ned upxv ftcarJ^5lVfArUu[\injOf Cv DK AKoY^V f*gofc)i|€5* Of Cv^ pi€^ \%n\ k)^d Uvf YU proCactani,| W/U)^^^! VY* CourV W\cxsy \oo\C Info YW CvUe^lonS 5-dKVA^) ^ VU record/1* ^ &wft N^Vron;tn C^nedibn LdvVh VU C\caWiSYO YU SuU^u^Y Ur v\,c*ocl Wi<*R ^vndm^s AW4ta ft-eoiouS Xuri'V^Ca^^.LMxl^C^-oM; 6on>W^ Cjunf-^Solued ftu+5 to\c4*r{*M AoYW\<g<Uty of (App \\C6wfs Conf\Yii^A^4/U>K*r«, YW-e iSc^Mpi^ e^d^ci [0 'AW foGord fcv \W CourVA* fu\c 00 XMher^fbr^ ^roMlsei Considered, AW uppucemA pr^v/s AW Yhi SCourY flod Vnci c^lroc^ Ce^u^f C^u^ C^sidar- cdvon AnYo YW ftxTr adWn5Yr4ionOf ^ M AWc «*>- i^d YW ncuess i>v( fo c\*fa\riW> VU feScdYS of YWYesWj, cjVhLAo appuooYvf SougW as cv» c\cUc/u4c fe>A&K| coA \caApr,> A^YWf\\inj Of Cx/voYW(^iYr<^ fCvODWvwvenA AYcY, SThc*.ftppliC&nY Y-^YaS \^^<xpi^p^^W^Tng,Us«ac?n 44^ihoYi^5 ft>ov,J Yo Y-c f^\ouoo^vf \n AY^s prtcQiid;nj;.YWp>r^ponderc,nOL of AVY eulclsunCiLt\nac\ Pp \y*M oYklnfidi buY fofC\ UfoloYfoo Of AWUaW Sf^S consYvYuYcon(no pxYiwkJ) ^uror Cocad Ya^c fbuod o.pp. \(Q^- 5urvf^ Wtyohd a reASonatk douYYKqd CfcfQ -Yes+fog U^najL)^iicO,kcU>rviQ3 Y[S C^wvfn.^ Yrv<d proceeding, 'nespecYfuiivj SuLw^a, •pro-S^ lAppiicAnf ^eYoOneUorf

n.