Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Swan, Thomas Lee

Swan, Thomas Lee
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided January 13, 2015

Swan, Thomas Lee

Opinion

-!'<>; COA. WO. \^-\\-O\OH0-Cfc TV.CV. ^0-\a\^3VH-e, UJ^-7S>0Mq-o3

IViomcvs V.. 5vwaw/ ^ op AppVic&u-V

TOfffOFMfNAL APPEALS PTioKoM U DocK^V Cousc DEC O^Of/j Corner rv>o^ , TKonv^ U, OUiaw' e . . '+pputttwV „ . Abe,ACOSta CleY„ eippeci<(s,"A»g pro St, no^bivj re^u<-s.is +W ^-s IWc^lc Gov«4 porsua-4- +o U><^_ of Co^.nooV ProcXr^ frrVrc\c U.07 SuVsecVro*/ 5 »dcc-U^ tWs Coulee ^ be Ko^<A da. n&Vo vp&W +U pcxr+tcs,i«r claims <Y><vU -VWrtiw ^i-VVi rc^o-rds ^o -VWi d^or^s p^oc Ko\cXi^gj; ^feJi arc \*eJd <h *>c S\«Ac ,-VW+Tt<xV CDOrVCVv^W^CooA} Ko-s» misLc^©^^ parVx'coU*- cl&rtv.s /naolt bg. +W. AppUcwuf mjiVvn r^w^s ^o C<-A prccxda^V arvA Vkurc feet. V\&s. <A<tAH.r^ +W. eq^,'+c,lft£e

TVm^ A>f>p\:t«r>4- V\urv>b\u pf^^ V^t> WoN"^^ Cjoor-V U"'U docVtJr-&v* cOfS«- 4<> ix. K*«u^. iM \W fcesA- vKjVt,«-aA- ©* 5>osV^c 5m oedex- ^> ?f*S«-o<>, hcWs Corpus, OS a. c«^.cU,Jo *?2»

Respect4* SvfcmtfkA Accept "^^/^ rr^s^^'^l7'!^ V^°\\ ^,f«N. ?>312 ficWow* Tew*. GeAo>^ n-* "7S3SO RECEIVED IN COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS JAN 13 2015 Abel Acosta, Clerk CokNO. V^-W-OVOHQ-Ck Tr.cV.lOa. l3ilo3H-e> W^lSjfi^-^

OF Arf{A\ ca»o-\"

i

Loma?» Ncx»j, TYm>,y*-* L. Sw«iiv», AfpVicoivA c^^e^co^ q>ro &.*.; humbly r^ucsh -Kc-V +Ws \+©A)o.\ibV«. C&orV oxt«.p-V VWso ©^coVrs>-S a^A c^w^vvjpatf^.wg natw»&rawt*ur^ £ac-nc<b Aoje. !

CMvA. Cm-CCcAc OJV<X cV^tWc 'VVM'i CAuSre- +0 W Wif^ <k MOvIO pu-TSviOAJ f" Ao C.C.P. CX«-V IV. Of SccVvOti Saw^t.KA.^. "7 3.MUo>W) <XS +W exceed. co.U s^ow +k follow »Wj •

\. ""JW T6K&S Cock- of OvwoMoA WoCcdJfe a&o<x*-s'iW S^W- \S~ d&up A^roor, "rU nsceilP**

UcV<^^l Do^Vr,fc«W .v . ^^.ceWo oooo ,2c, "1# •^1? ^^" i. ^ a-n_4U .^.uiVnccV, AW 5^-Vc eVcc+5 ^^^ • 4 > >v V AW »s*. o^« IwAVor 4W «yplf^ ^»

+W *W.W W « -Wk W*\c - <^ eec***** ' .^ reS-cVtoWj, oV,cJ^> Vo AW WW*V ?AnNcj of AW SWfc* Orf3,'A»l A-A/Su*T .«**• «>*» b^ m'.cW o£ prot^a sWo\£ NCV Wlo WcJ Co*»5\A*rf<d b-^ AW N^e** ca*r\r .

<W\uV AV>^ c&o^ V* V«. WcA Aa. a;cu«» oy&n VW pocVi^W-r tl*\»s m<^*- 4V*x>e ^°' 7,,lC/j 4W. VJf)^««r.t.V\ £>r^\NoA. <xtos\iJor <s*^ ^-nsojM^- or.'^fwcA «^swJtr> +" *^ e\t<AsAW>v: VW o^^NiCCiOVs PvcsV ^Wfc^t^ ^CoC;4-W.V +W aff.'rrr.^ oP krs CO(Uv/ic4-«3^ ^uctsA*i\-OoMc\ n<xW ^r f* ,4- oc^a-c^cv «, ?OAK**m«A/W\ or cow^ii^Woa/cJI rv9hf (Xmo. ^WiCcfocc woV CC<a*JVZ-CLbU. ck»j&. u><\A\ov> V rOcoiVo TVu, pxxv-V.coVor cAgv<v\<s} avc +AxA-» TO aff<rt« tx. C©WUC<-Vfis*>» ^a.s«-&- «"aI O. Soff?<-<.vJO^ o-f AW CA/i'dUxfce clq,W c)f a c^rhj.

uitx> <x o*«>W\co*» 6»P cLuc process» Aco»r&o»5 W Vvwj CoorVi C*J VrurprcWr^aP of oSCe<4o\r>S**) v>jWV AW SoV>s-Vftt\)We- cVcvYMuJri of a*J 0Afw=>e a/"C pe*- 3acASso*0 V\ 0/T<ji'vi'X> O.HoO'^ -fta.

1 CoocV or Ap^<»As V- oA9rrna or>o*/ 0*. cW^y. ^ot rnauhi Uvhjr- -/W 5+*A\j4- ursicuM-^ doc pcoce>> . <6^ A^vs Ceoc^ V>q\<^o-$ s>* CacH-W^ MC» S-^. ^d 25^-^-5%, FortW-, +W App).'cM- ^cVnXv»W>tV^ tWCtvvi \WV <aA+VrYMV«3 Vv3 CoNu*cV(i>W ou a. ^ t*s*r moAl /vtr QuiamiHc^' fi> 1-wS ivif^, o»oV°^* dw<^rocc-« a*. cM^coUWA. b$ AW Sopfu^L, 6oorA" .V Dow*> V, C.5, H^C/.S.

Itf<3 AWs o>N\/<"(_Vf&i^ uporf -fta OusJ-fueA-ruV of /V4tOjl<iot)hUr ty a pt,rtc <*f o^c/fci-o t^kroh vu&S a/ciW pWA. i* **> r«A«cA-m«vMr6*t3v<«*v<0 <v>oc pocs«iM fc ^jur^. 7V po.^oipU. of 4^,^ dut procc5& crolaVfoW tpes furfW cc'AcraVcci by AWis C©u<-4 >»> "Mi Ca<><-of W^j Ca^ooU^ 2l3 S.UJ. 3d *COy o. PeAiVvo*, &c d^C^Afo^o,^ ccuei«>/ f«~ -|W o^ sc,rr* \«* C*>A-of Appc«b>» Here +k<* CeucA Uo*d -fUf Supcttr* GsorV preckWt sAaU AU.-V ,A uroiafes duuc prcceSS &r* Oj<"A of ApfWs V> oA^Pfrm a. coim\j<c.V,>ovv) lDoa«l ufo^i fccA;/fA«>rfc5 &)<& Solo/y>>W?<f 4$ <?/jUru ^- Am «5o<^s ^o 4kc appVvctNb 3CCo«vjd 6roo^ for foVof, AK^-f /vs co/uorcA^^ ojo& ofeUieue«< AA^roo^V, V^ osc o^ cmo oww«v.sA/4oVroA*a<i^ t!m^ -/W S4C4,C irf ^j, ^f^ ok^/mJ cw^ Soo^esW AWV AW CW^ ^^vo jvi AV>,^ oxusc -5 ?c^cr j^ ^ 4>vlJtx. ^^ ^Dm.'^vfcU^ •^c ^sW^W occoctA.. iW-ecv+W ftfpNjca^Vs parVccolcr dafm S *Wt of^s*^\- ioo.Av.aWc s^ AWV AW c^eVr^A *\iM*y^ A^wWfcjh AW skk pro c^cded -Vo use r-/ +V>c5 caos^ cUc5 /ooA> lr5A oxlftNo^woft w^^ on ck ft^, wU^ S-klc (^ Mti+W

•*3 a tOvjaJ^x pn=3cc«ATJw <dm a ^w^V^W-r Ntylr; upo*J \W uifO-WicV^ OorOcvdaA. o^Co^cA QisJSkxJUC, AW 5Wk Pcv<6c5 AW W fb^ *pWV 'vV 5oWsb \W.d^c<x\ of <:cW,F bvvv 5-UJri^ +h^ +W app|,W oUd /vcrf ra(Sc \W \asv»e. o¥ CW5<- trroc o«M d^cc-^ app^.1 ujW«- -VWv^ "^cv^liy1 /wayr be ca.*vS<A o^w^ \b \WrfS-boz, MoV Gs^wO-cuAc!^ . "7W. sWk AK*aJ cjo«s o*/ AA» proofcHi. o, icsh-or- [McW^ qa/cJ^S bcs,^ oW uAvrfW+W S^li booe V>~* <^ ,vsVrocA,W <^ +W offovrbt- of fY>a>«sWvjghV«r- d>J£ W cw>J •oJfcbAAi'fc^ MaWfe- Tk*- parAfeg ley" cActOw •'S Ak&A A-W cW^, VcvV^ H Arc*V AW CvA^Vrtv^alWj^rsws arv/d 4W^rt $Wool<l \^ c*JvfiA.

AWc^tJXo, Vc SVcVc t^U . " KcVouro^ (vre^ Subaom<JL/co^Vuv,o«d i* AW TKjdftAm^ OuA Sob^,- AA«k A* Uml^oc^cs WV<^Vo V«. vcoor^(\>W «cor b^ AW u>ocV. . *3<^cK3orj af VKo-Ti^J E<v*r w> AW c*o.W cWjjc sWsuNA. W o^& om a.T«A- epp^ o^d cj/M n°t\>^ co^.'cWl OM * o^<.V of WW^ CocS^iSp ua»\cs,s, +W «c©«- Cc2>o\f<A r>J *. d*A,«xl *P a 6ur -frr^l or d*i«- ^toce-ss^ CuppVW^hW MlMUS-iHt/MT/'lOku o.jy^ oWrr^ fsioc is coatV^^ <W ^W <**WS,+W a9p\fc*V>^ aWW<^ of fcoc«So ,* aft,Ud ^ Alr»«**Z<? /' S«« //>»-'** ©P c*to t>j (<uXAa>TM. k>gWc«_ cuxjd. Ws. ajoA \>€£*J W&W- fo^ AW Vo&W^s oourv. "• Xn rayytd-s V» AW o^UcjujVs A\vtd_ ^oopA f^<~ ft\ufj +kf h/i cLx. process <-.^tn+3 AW AW sWW ^° produce «wkJjia;c<u ?o»^» sWW- <-^W.b/lr IMO/CLfc/lops^ rtporf^ a-s» *> f^icw AW °vp^\vCo.tjVi acVj sWobo^ > CXoj'bxfl, 0.^1 irrcotJrsvW CtS&cVokto cf a^^ojWivicooS CATCculaU«M. gv*v4 CcS^^<io,Vo^ tviMcVfo*/ u^V\rtV\ »"S \V\r5 (LoorVs CK^AopWi- c^jlV".>j<^r&«; of d^&ff> ujVmc-W v^jes cUc'cWi. iM A\vc5 CaoAs Wva.iwg co G.foA\; VsWAc "2-73 5,^.2.73 S«-aVso VTCA. P*v CaU $iq,t>( . 7^;$. it> Ovto cv^vWA^-m c-WVWjc^. W ArW vv-uWpsu. ctr>ocA- 4WA cV&.\v>r3 VWA- AW sVb uico^ b^ AW c^VoJr i«>."o^N ccuov- of deATW bof \s AoWU*> <±euo(d. of cW^ «a/^m/& g& f^. /way fA^f

S^y, AW- ao?Wa^ feorJ^ ^cooa^ ft,c r^^, AWf he ^? c^vr<:4 a, m^v,^ ftl a^ ^ Vnvs o^p^Oc C^ov^cX ^>r ecr^co^L^ co^V>o-<^ cxSvrfPrt/ai^ of AW o/rdLwcc cUv<v, W>»'AW <x cAu«ew\ oP oW<f*y- WCOC UnJlut A/Vm. VcAiV^ of1 0v. 3>o£frtX ewoj. a^AVxi.

CATrdwJ^e Vt<o.di>i^, tW CoooA mtreA^ *SSoeA. \&cO0iA, c&W^crf^. autsVvwi-i ©£ S SWW.

SpcafcosAW vuoWcAWr cqo*js«X cnucsVc«j«AxA <x\\ pos»'\oW cW\**s 5upp©r4vw^ cWAV«*#t& Ao A/W cvvdiAjce,. 0^ aATf«Uu/fd, AW app^a.iWtc coowsc\ >Ww, me.s«.\V-iAJcocJl; sWW AWA* SW CcScgccWA -*cW \cwoj Cc^c-t^iv^ Su^F^^uu a-A l-c^Vb, 5«<: e,-CFreWf f- p$ LTkrs tso\d woV V Ac*c «.<> oop€oA\tie ooowStA /Jcjut ©*vjcc Cms AW covoAr&Ufw^ Icu^/ s<Ar ^W,V\\^ OuA \tJ rrVa\iV^|Gi*lUV)or uf>& rtyrJs h fV /mW< i/ar.'a^e U-f^w 4W rwdfcAvvWc, o^-W «w£iuiAJt<_o3: VroA* TUci CeorV WAd ArW3r*/''-fUc V\>cus.oP INO^U'f^^ OK/dw fYVxbW cxvtKCapUiWr C5 opo^ AW tAciv^M of AW offWs<- ; <A/ucL t>sf course UWt 5Brrv4AV\v>Ju ca«/ W «vo eVcvwjL^ of AW. ©ffeo&c ^ -fW M^poAWAiW^. correct cKirtje i< mo&V be <xoAVvof;z«-Jl W^AW ^^RAma^A;1' G»o/IWr% S.UJ. 3d ccfzrsG^n^ fV\c.(.(< •, 5WW <\S3 S.OO.ld j-^- . kfipcalUk. CjDU*&<\ vcvor ofci #vs ceuAYoll »imj c*sc £</^ tfft><:e jY\c/cb WsS f*, regards W\W v*udfcA-m*3c A*>A sWWfl AW eJbsAecW \n\ 4\<mJ(of rrtwsla^hfa fuaweVj; •tccVA'-ssucsa? toKrcV^ s«p««^cs fA £r<j\~ a/I o^r homrcrchz,* TWs coi/r-f Ws <?/&a /W</ TV*t"!2Td porArcvU-r f*>Vf CS * rncLWral e\cwoivf of fW cWttjcd. ©fFajS^ ^W cWnjflf^ iVst"- fu/vuAA- most" 5-UW VW ccqu<nd .xWK' Smiih V. Sfahc. 577 S,Gu. 24 ^H» For fW, App^MoW Coatv^cX tJejaoc caVs W^c o«»a c*j& (tVtMAit \W3c ck»e2> tot>V eWrejo oto oFf*>Jbc duties roo+ t»rof«- 3„or<^<oVo»o Ao a A-rr<A OoocV 5to 3S0& CWv«yc- AAtoA o-ff<A;s«. ^ iAs eWftve •Ao a

<\is^ fOojcr o«x.V.*»«sy*\*d%t% V«m. v)wrUcuUr c\<\ir^ rr*>dii W UjVi^tJb ^W Arr(<A Cfflurf- cuoi v- <c A *>• IE n regards AA> AW app\ia*n/b frfAW ^rouAd fcr-Yt-UcP;+^ci-A*, ^^sd^^col AA^c, fiArec-Vvoc o^.S\S>Ariocc of brs VrCcA. coow^d* 4W Ao<cA coorV CaW^orJ^As <x e<u» 5a.4-r<s^ dLe.Pwcjt kw AfoV AcsV(V^ Ata cVoiv\ of r*i<.ffecVtu:.|utss o.^^(VvsVAW po<A(c«j\alr ckrcums^aivi,^ o^+W ttppl^cn/Us <*&*-. WKO.WU* ,AW ouWrt ^^^ (uc ^SSOt w ^ o.pplrcwr «« AW^ h-3 parboil*, a*h (irdtocV C<^^ 4W cWVK o? V^W c.^^A^.V. <i^^ fVo^ ^^.^ ^ •^-^ppWca^V 5WV>Wd VW d^x^da^o^ 3, df«**J- cCCaS^ ^V ^Arv>oed At) a^c 4-W^ AVvv-s c^V c^s <^>A AV exxw-^ ©f dvfloA^ . jAouj^u- upo^ fU avvrc^ Gow-tYrtf/ucc Ti^t ^a.5 Wo objccVv^ WAV pocW oP AW cW^c +WAr urdaAcs VTCA A^.Cock G,o^j '5 H ^ IW ^a^aJc Ao s-oWvAV c <****** .-.WW +o <, ^ cWy. +WV ^ W,«W WAW s^ ^UW^WY^ ^ ^^ ^ r.cAowvx- -TVVX.V, -H^ acporA CevAc^W /TK_ <krud Vo Id rwj. u . .v . ^ X*^ ^^ Wa^ sW cooVd vodA sc^ «<u>^ -^ deA*V,. 7K,5 m&j^ ^ 56U3C as ^ suW e^^ UWWe« , (U*r t.AW, i*W ^ ^ tK ^h9% 5WVA AW* AW *Wb uW a>wd ^ Qxks***. VW <W&\ o^ voas;, WW\oW^V\f?k , "(0\ ,%o t» ^<w*. ^ of£ .Asei -4^ u£(f coca eA,<sv3 Uh ujcrr&A- c*.

Cao«*x.Wi d*Wc q,V J*W dr<W\ pot*»V o-f +W cW*^ c*N£«*/<*. ~7. Xro C^e^-ds. Ao AW <spp\icatAs SW^ <vnA. eAoAV- yoOroAs, (uamntl^ AWV V\rs Cj>m\j\cV\(hu wc^s obWr^fd bv^ AW- <J^e. &A f«Wc WsA.moA^ V>»^ cv sWWs u>rA*vK5£/o>"<^'ir,£ fWTwWc) OjJ&- AW cVa^otv VWV VW apoViCbivA lOaS co^'-'fcfcd b-\ AW U><- b$ VJxAoAjex, AW\ « cm urAaV;^ of ^Vc of tv^c^ucc Mo3, -W<^ \W Wccn^ of AW <u*«pWooW«vVs <^oAW voWo Wd n* proWV^c <m'«W<. WVW *ppUc<^W: apiW or ^^^at fcot-o^s.

OScA ^Vnl S.W W> CY>£W<y\<. Vvvt. w^wXi of fW yH^> \a»c<-c *J*V proo^A} W2WA b^. VW \(\qS>o>A CoorA as vV CS So^tsVtd Wr Vwasc c\<v^<yn5 w5i>'\A WSx-W 5WWX cs dWU<A^<y5 -ks AW Swfcc^c^oA-of -turda/vce c_W\-r^5 . H**"^ AW W-'^-l COorA-C WWi CoyrA J mtATtU rnNS<LuW^'^<rs AW doot qroce^, cWviw 5 as tWW^-^ WAW soffWe^ of VW <vrcUoo< as <XtO avJC*JUC Uo.^: Vo \-c4r AWw ac^atw^V t»r*Wollo^ ^-CA pf«c*<At«A, 9- TW^ App\-xca^ (7) SoVoAV c^vA Wr fcWr;AWV W0, acfoa^ MnhoowW*^ AW CcCcfs*. of vrvx^sVoc^V^- '^ JPirm^ W^-cd c* AW- ^Jfc «focV VVvic W<V> ^^ ^cV£^ CJW^<A v»:vvs n^^aXou^VvW-fti^^ Vo p«Wo\o<- a^Matr^^l^ s^° w<uA*Ld^of- <O0jo'5<- AW AaffAW ©^ XW. CjomoW'vtoWyJr/ lW-W^Vx»S CjOurV W-s too cc\yiW\X tc^Wsc c\c»?t^s amcX cv<xao>J rr>\5oxW)t>'r»%«d-Wjo- o-^> o» v>jco^ ^<k ^» c*AiS^«-<- \?^ yrtWfowM tf^ pcoc«.S • \ . ~CW CoofVs LW.W3 Cc-^rA} cxdo^>V<A ¥i**&\t*af of fccV <x>^ oaiocVoVvows c^ Law £>Vo\«- VW appX\cM>>ss c\c«.\ro of ecvor Vso^ AW V.o^coNWVe. tourA <W> tOoV <^sSc*"V a.

30T^dw.jcV;ot*x\ (WWc^ *»«>,»- is W Cc^ox&^n a Coa/<Awvua>1*A ar uoMsAi AuViovual c<c>V\V. UdujcocTjAW- oxpp\^c<**»V W» rrvuA*. £^ccifrc cA^tr^s of djjc protest vf<j/*fr^ faj^ Vo VW OoAc»rr\o of AWJr <"«/<***, o.,o\. <?<-<• AW Ox>rA oF Crcw^xcA A-ppta-ls , O^V- ».oi Cc, VK.

C\»ocoorc<xW •cW^Vc Cor YcA-c^ due process uraUVr»v»s ;uTcy«.s. ty P«.cVc, ferarfdl^ 7S\ Sj»w."2©\. XoCo, 2S7 ClVCriVv App. i<tt*0 2_.~TV\t_ V.o-V«-o,s cooAs Cn^MvK^f, cc^^cV \WV Vw cvop\<a^A- d<d 100V c<*.vsc ^W vSboc o£ ^vi<"^»v c^Vcccoj*. e^rcr o«j <^rfioV app<A a»*<^ cWAla^c* -W iW jur^ oWoye. 'r^<x/txxi((<^" mo&V W cavscd. om AfctcV *pptcd, *«&> *WA- AW <xpp\rc*A»V- ia a4k*pfr»j fo cWltu^ VW SoVWcn*v<o. of IW cVCdiAic*. lAooJcv/cr AW afpW«»vA- W* AW bu*d»» of slrv&w rv>^ ^rcgrws W«n 0po* Wbt^S «**«*> p^< ^^ O>or\s b^d.v-3 ,-w Almon/i^Cgt* S.W.2A I7^('t<-/ CLrcwx. ^. X^'M; Ac uiWV AW. ap^\;co*>V Ws pr&ctd. Sov^W^mWI. cUR«A »m -VW ccotAi cWro^ 3.TW. AppWcwvA-W-s sW-mjm AWV App<*vY\cAc coowsoV 3o.tvtl-00csd< Wood d'td mot acK<u>oiul<dLg<.

AVv^ CeurW b^VcoSAi. \_cxvo vw Ck SvjAfvC^MC^of -VW <,v;da^<-c CcueC»j ya*"^ O^ul.'k V SWW 4S2> S»v>».-2A tH3,I3H ^iAW records Ao \W W^oAWWcad^ Gtf-c^V ^c^ cW*<&.a*«i ' <bi©A\iW<- Mltf j.w.id 2-^S <ojV\rcb WAd> A/WV-rw&WrvaA uaovOjncos Tcv>*W-ojfcUwo*. fwiofA"- lCxC\>V" arod. AW^fC^orc <W)<L W AW &iJE;^e*A SjbMdUcf; cA~- ^p^Wak. Cbow^V ^ tJtfV eAirJC) AW WoV AW\- AW CudrcV roovjV \*j A-bv-s CUSC cM>eS fJ^A- oJI^ ex. coWorcA^W 0lv cw^ rtckkii acVjAW fVo?\^«A Ws, 5o^^<d- orc^odicc b^ AW affWmf^ »f ^'^ cjo/ooaAraw of aw offt/usc mt»V (xWovwtA. V?^ AV>^5, Cj>-r\s Co^Ar^V.^ ;\m^ \-a\o• H, *TVvt_ f^9p\;c<».*>V Wi pf&Ocd^ Vv«c^ ^W da-^'cvtAA- p<jt?c>c<vnwmoc. \o^ \^(^ \rtcx\ CxxjwSrd. h«-4 prcV>dsf«A Wft CS^'VsV \b W<«~ V^<A "b^> w^>r\^AoN^ Svwofw affrA&yrb Warn W.-?, Cor-cjvi.-j.

CyocvA-ri—v <i.w affcccrvuW*- dft-t«^S<- <a^d M^V vy>CcVLc»a AW pcccc?? ^tjrV. <V AW p&cV^Cv)\oY- c<^>C S» TW ^rQ9\^Cfo.^\- W^> oWs^A oj^d oro-J^ AWdr poc ^r*. ^<.c»i<-d , SWAc-s e-yW.biA lMoyfW SWW> -m^M -oovA^j^s 3c^xyj^ (TO^XwArro u>OA r^^V-eMc, cktffcruJro^d. fcAse «,WWryv*dts <t^ceA«AW d*Jcc<v>^V\r5 W*»V ."tc^sy*^ .

I©. TW AppWc»oV (LotoWdi AWV vK&WVoxj of fWV. of ^iTidtwcc Ho3fu uA>rcb kc cWvV'b <-*, MC>Y pf?>c<doroAW, Viu^crcd, Cb \\- ^S <X C_Wc*v\ of doc precis VioUWa) WWcW c> (L-C^iMv^ab^ opo.\j o.A.V\.^7, Er P^cVc Uj.Wjc^s ^>S S.^o/idi*S1 '• TW WNxas CoorV ^WVa. t*J (W Co^cAusrir-* of lauo / Wo*™V>«-o V II p<j,7; AWV AW <xpp\\c^A" W.«> AovVd, Vo WMJ&.A-Ws \>urd*A> s^ proo-f. hrb ©..ll^Af?^% art \*M&off rc.<<*Jr oj^ W W^> W;A<d. V© dAwv^-vosVcoW. AWA- Y^-v tojjvaAfowj yj^i sWcacAK o^oWvOtA.. ©• \W o-opVcsuA tsctiW-s AWAr WA W'i, •c.Vc*rr^*> axAueU^ te^u^ WiAcd aa 4W &je pvocc*, oraXaVfw* AWV AW3. o*ro;.o*A ***" nr^sc&V^orat^ ^ ^v^, W^ , Wujcu'cI Woo Cjo^ffcC«~VA^ ™*A- W*> ^oofdoAj of pcecf b-i^ c-W'T Occord cvrdudec

W*cd. cWN&vfO OO. VW -C^iVs Of <W S.OMWr e^S &»<- OTaCo* VJ\-*Wcf6M3 Vo voNfN^oV VW oyctaAr Wt^V Ci 9ob*£»A upot0, ToAcct foe a,\\ WcV >^sA some f<S()aA9olU^ SoVwWeM.

AcCtpW KcjCcAeJ.

T^N-CoW^T-jr 7S3SO

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.