Aaron, Ronnie
Aaron, Ronnie
Opinion
CttfJ^^Cj&ZafctiL jjmfccsj RECEIVED IN fctf',/s0f/2>3S0 COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS GjH&teGfif&frS JAN 09 2015 /fa£722/> 7fc 70&/> noeiAcosta, Clerk
&-£*?£•<? y^Ki^'y/uer'c^/ri^ -ei^Cisuzstff ^r-c^<cr^otjo~o
i/dr^LsJar'tf-c^ 2^ twit's' teccr^-
7/tc-^i^fCci^a [/&6Cs T^u^wyCcs, CTnW/ teu.rt a/0, f&&?7&7-&J
&/ t ^ t C0Utr £f:. C/&HZXAt£ APi&t/Lte) A6Jsyyiyy jz&ts
£xm#7E Att#S/</y fZfaUl^
L-7f2t<, A/at***,; ^, VS. •"
n>) Apjrc ttarz,t- r~€5j0-ccIjC/S/y Sat**, ? f&, rs ytfjf) <^o
feffrp&s-t^ 'foist dstst^j <0r T^cc <sgzt ^ ^fc^Cf^ A^\fc>t<f&~ey
'yci6*HS y^gtt-c?/' '$etrt*f <W/^/-r<sv^ ?%-e e*Sc~
&^Z2frCf3frA/
A^^trcatrei^ *Ks*,y/rS7 cs^sfc fc^ 7£su<s •Wj&vsl*- f*^ *,s^r*o*crZt#'c£ /y ;£**/, *?*trsum*f t^ t%€ Cgctsf' ?<t^' //J /, testes*tfctS Tfcr^c^ 4rrv£6t<c4£ #i>c 7*rf^,
C2-).
77/ '<s%7 C&urT*TV&vtf' T=ccer^S & TrU ~ks6 czu^se^ dr^&ai- •^<e/ SsXAux^c^-^t^c^^t T"-e4Zt£c7**£ 6z%7c J^cyvc^aC^s 7%&<s!&&^ Ts&tcsf rUt?^*?ft&tccsj C^uf^ts c/ifetf v*c7r& &ett^\sc &r&cc~
tvtfr &J*c4m£Tiy ^ai*S Sat//'c/~*/J-€x e/~ ^V vtt*[/&s$ «*i<S *>^ A^t7-/3?^* dz^& rfVaS^stc °rc^-c^y €&
4ts*f-<eciA,s:f /he?v?/it~&&&f7? "*K+c£tHsLs <5?^zfer, tca?i*v/&-er^' 7kl^ *2^i%0 ^//(VJU*^^' •'recerTtfp ~n<^&&z 4*<7-J&Sti!y titties<tZ a/Ctcfe^fy *f^*yj&*t>yr st*** 'ti^**^ && / 993-9<7 7Y<h+, yj"7frW^ ?*£/ <6e& tZsf***f£*// Act jfAitef 2? /993s 73 r^ £€*,#*#-. cyL- ?^f Yr*y a«*7 Act. Jrjunc zUfSy 7Y*tty &* 0^3'***"' '**<% 6?L ^sts/tW/^7zi^7i*t^c^t/ vc# sAz^ycy v^A'tA ^ yf^Ae 7^^^ t/chccfAjpye#sA\tK,o<ziSK&€y7 py-c^cAucjA €A7Lu<&A AtvLs iCuTzvA &ks i*czjr&acArV-c 7feffL an^^Ms^Uoep<yA austA -tpiyc ^y 6CTey?/u c^f As ~<?t^s tA7A£#£c 7 ttpty -c A^t^ci v*^&z746w ^ j£7§fau^A7y< rfttAtAnAys CT^'i^cs vot-CrZ A& ^/^> -ey7- U-c^ AAarcy ybcttyiUys **, ^/Lycy7 c^*^ ti#A &*& 4-^tt/ # Tirtu^-iyt^iAj- c#*ny/6.4tc<cc aCS tt&^Utt Tk$Ar/&*7
J5<7/3/foAc CjA/srmi^/AATjTy^^T&TA
$ni,h'&77a, AL-& i4w7&v<jAuAfury ^Tu^^ycA^i^ss/ iA/<y-t •n-cv-cr' #7[terv ^At^t^cs) fr ^ Acrn^crTt^ 7-zss-cy At«-cltsd<d, CyAiesstbfce*/ SAtfAl/YgyUlazy' ^Ar-cr^s^ eAy-e At A/Cc< ffl-ecffyutiU* visCi^y's^-tyAs7&A7\y-c ^TccC^r'c^A C/h*ti^7< sA&kJs 7^ cj^^^^^/^^ci^^^S^^^^**^^ -0T&c<£5 s/*tt*7 fay/hAs 0ZC 4%, Tr^'tfyA C^arA Y^tdGAr*- &77Z/2' At y?re&*eri&e -c^-u$u'access Yfr <%> y^A Swc* Aff/< Caas-c jt£, 7A<fS?&7'jA•+*€*& ^Acyr^Vc^A £t/ -preftcoiterts) V^A^A'/AatV* a^<A'"Ct&Acs Y*t<Ac,^y ft/i*/ x js«g.f«y<'c,k*6c«>c/i' -H/A^y«c&^ & c^rty c?J- At&i^ A'^U* sYA&A&zy ifry,rt,A<,Yyry*tA AAi&s& A&pt/s, &kcc7 7/Y<^> C&iASu/AuA/&U'<%As&i<^sfsAtfS/& slks tAcAe'r'- Tny^H^£-^c^ c&iwy< Acj^A ($7&Ac /^d^ucn^y Ayy^t,A7^Ac^ £CiA#/A&6A& -^Ay^^^A^K^sJ y^rtS&t~cY/&iy6sy-t*y't$' ->w&A7cy&as -c fr^oyA^u^s Ai^zruisyr^A^i^y^Ayrr&ss cd-cmc-ctA c<7H*v-e 77iALy & -yyr'eiA.yAy c#t^Vf'c7e*7A**A g-ct^Tizii, c-c 7* s*y3 A&At^, ^c^ c#i*us AcA*c ~A#^*fA A^s* sAAA^<y^y 4yiAsWaiA.Ac*A "yvetAr Ceu^S-eA ZA*As 'T-ewreeAy caAA&A^y&Ayt*J <tyy£>t^ <€7" *6rw&«y< <$AA*tAA<?n*A $7*Au ten ZAyurt ?A* tAZZ^ ^ c«s*s ?v* A*i^ycr- an, ]/7'07j0T*\7Asi*4s~' erAy^& A* i^Cy v* AAu YA* CwA <zA CrY^cA^caA'Apy-oAs zaJyx,cA SA«& &A?Ay«*A*£Ac &c^<A & ?ff*AA*Az G,»pc- ft^t JUA< eA*A c^ayA &**«; t?*"*&? *A*s ^tAAA^A Cvtst/tysr&t ^A &*«**£-(***
fr*s*cuA*r- #^A^A7#A*A A^** ^A*~y*A*4A e\/€A *t Sca-yvAtA^tcs AaiAiAetAy?&s$cS£A4H^ &A* c*^tr*A7* A*f«^*> trA*A rcsf*^ j^'J^ . # AA^AAAAyr^^ ^^Ar^tAA^ y?*Ae^r Yh^A Ar^A '0*^fAr-c^cA-cA c*a*s*A «7Zcyut**ifc •cr).
Air^AtvLff /r< 1^aArt*,y <c\y/AeHsC-e C0yiszTtz%An^y <yy#f<s Y-Ckvv&Ay rfSS/ywt-ct^A A^ -yteisJ ^yy€yA^7^ £7Ac #{Y*AAAAe i^twcAy, C^ui^s^Ay AmA C&rvy*~ A>^A Ceuyfysuy7sAAc&r*t<-Ls) YC^resvaxAcAy *y#? puca^A^c Y"cAy?#cAA\yt 4y e^uyA^sy?r*c*A€tA7^y^AAA MA, STPAv^^AhACkA C****, S<+cAc ^At*7cLAyrS z*?&*c A i*seaA'A tfc/t%p&t#A c&77y c&^yeA Arz*^A C£u?A A«Ay s#AA r<-i^*Aer*iAj' gyy^vA AeA**<yz cA&ssA^TA <5A*A<Aery £7^s* &AA-iy^s* ^Aa^AsAy *As*yiyys^ #^ /Af7ynr*i/As*'e«-j£<c- caus* YAo* tAAecCVc AaAc cA<tt*y*z Av A**st*7 : *ye*A<A ttyyAyy #AsSA^ fr AA* y?^A*fy n*^ TrAzA &t*<AA*A;ct5 A'^y^^A -t^AA*^ AA-cA-c- *,*A*£>ve *A*tU< Aeru ^A cAtyty' y*^ *'*"*, A%c*7 *7*<A*tA<AcAuA*A ^A*«*5A &&& c^A*«y *zyc*-7stAf^ Y€<sAy#tAtA) piycr^-c **y*,7asAyrzss yC&i/ c*
,. A * ^r'S // . . ,^^^^>. yz*<,*i ^fj* /A W/fc/W <r#Ct0j-&t#s -H/*s :* J<*<*f *~yJ"AA~^ ArA«v*tr,«.* eyt&"^'<yscf^ AraAAb-cA€^S'C AcA, A^ tiU AtcAsAe^ A"S,U*s s/,A^^^A^9 9&z ^^ -z-A7/3, y-re\/j Wts WA*^ •cfifccz< A* *7&i^ eA ATc-^ -CportcfaAAcy75 7tAVc cAc^^cy^yA^^^ we*A<7' affAy&tAyrCK^y casAsJy^A^^A T&aA^cAaA*. r*fa*^AM ceujfAaCtesc'AtAyy, ct/s<r *7-csrA* A &*<?^^cHyLc*,, *& <% *yyAc*A. £*4y*A>M- Tlu-cAA^: C*ccAA A67AA#v-e A-ee^ tAjc A-cyaA Ac'sAeTU'&aUAea&&t«^ Si.yic.-e AsA yh?fA Oau.sc At, ?Y<7c?f&7-A tLe J$A*Ae J^^eAAcAyA'sr AM £ist<. A AAlsc; -yu^sA v&y-e csA/At'sAcg A^ c&ses weuAtA &,&s-ciA.C'C ^Ag AuAcy A*^c'*^- 7'<Az£' &A A/AyaAeyy 'yesyzcyss'AAAt,Ay 7y see, A£*AAfarA;c& As A*cue &Azc^ <&A7&s& -ettrAyefAu,«A£*'ZA Acw-e case5\ c<zut*&-cA£eA^ iz?^Aa^^A^ AAc^Ac^ fk7<,o^ J#*cyA V. sA&Afy &6£ s i«y z*A 7&Y, J#e Aci^e AAAZ^^ v, st^Ac, fAA 3 vi/' £<AAtfZy tT&^rtyyr&er' A& &A 7&fF- <Zi*<ei«A £i2Aluf g/%Am*.-cc*A*wA y?*cAecA <3&&yA Ye &?r^As> <6*A*te«s. A*y*^ </, 2&&, A* 77- &-*/*2A- CA, 2^77 (TeAsAyy,^^asH^/A^2>A^y Wtfovc&'Ve Aac<7 a,^uxccAUc^c<A ^e- ^^ -UiA^e^Ui^seA^ "re ce.rA^ £AAyrUeAAt'AAy zee- & Pt6H%cAAA &z<yyA/£cc&sA A^ AAAAy *yyrt*A iJ^^A^^c^AA^c/^^y: Set TfiAf, $~3 CjJ'b+tJ797Y *A f/&c^~ AAV ^oAAA ^c Ac^tu status c^ose^ XAcei^ ^eiAAeyuce. *AtAoA^ AAxnA^cjA^Ae deceives ^^/^y^^^t^^ -eAc*ci,\/tcAi***Ay ^A^^T^^A vtAtZA^ o*c^ Ty/zA&e AtsAsA? ^cAaAer <&As-^ -CytA^^cc^A'j&yt7A A&AA 09-AA 76 ^AAeyeAYy £A#A7M/<? Se^^coc^A AA7-c/&A7y 7&Acr- Yle YeTreA *cr&t**i-A Y7&f~fY S-cA^r^c lyfac Aec^A^/^cc^ Suyy-a^uo C&xrA\#A £e^yi^ £A*A;7 *****' SAe^ *UcA*ftAA^ A<y*7 **** At* ayty ctf&es -WfAAer' StAe Asey- -ne^y A&t*?s> Alm<cye>3? ^ Y^e Y993 et^tccAeA 7eAFe^AC&jAe gee t2^3<zT &c^Z 3ec, /Z'AZy JtyiA 799s* AL/cAAUe Aki^&Az&fry A' AuAcAifKy scjyenp&s-e Ake^AAyc^ &t<oAA™ TeryriyeAy ty^/ey AA>-e cAcut*csA^^ces yxy^i^yA Y*&Ce rvfe- ttettVe c&(*sA?AuAt0t^ArAyArft*/r aA7^c:7?r S'e**^ st/ALf ~c<y&y<y &yryAi/As Y^ <jt*Ae ^y^A^AAe^ &AAY%<~ Azts"#A Y'e^eeA^e f A^yAAeATi^^s Az&t</ re-i7*e<AYc?) ^yLAfA€A/ a,K,AAtA^ a> /sA^fAAAyr'tyKs TAure^A -resf'Atte o^t^TAeiyer^sy^A dA^Aus c^se #A Z&e, cZiZAfcAfA sA&ye -pc/&& AactAsAeAA#Ase t:\yAAjy^e& zAjl^ecA T% Ae-<z?yci^ A&<s^A &c^ TeceyxAAAcA Ay^ry TesAA^^Aysrs^rtAAcyT^ *y&#AA-y?jy&iye *#AaAJ)ZUyr AZsA Y*A"'*s SC^AeA*** A^7e Scritf AAscaeAcA Teste YA* ftccrAe S,UcsA^ & JA&Ae ia •sOt^.
•J6*,rv36f«f*f''«A &0&ZJC s«f*xi2r c*u>y /0**t&<? aaftr-r, * jtr*,'Sy*«y*ylf<&"s*J *^'* A1c^' •«<uU *.**«>S**"-*"? ~*'A~se '^AJlA*A 'tuyyi* cyrfrema* «,&<!&*-a*, **&»**' . *&cy<yert, * Cuta*S;l6c&*««Ccfr*6<x* ** *"#&"*
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.