Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Allen, William Andrew

Allen, William Andrew
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided March 2, 2015

Allen, William Andrew

Opinion

/~)Ol ,©@u) ~€>3,@€1»140.\4) . w»z,uz,qu,¢ls,q<a 6‘@$"\€ Q\\or~_ Og‘oq [Zq? _,. q’|,qg "_\ .- __ 45 6 .,, . .r» \l 5 UF'U__IUSB 8 ,J-/~/ THZ /£m¢§ (',Q…vy ;;;" by C `;' .- ` ‘ ~£` $Mk ap /- @$'0¢."¢?.<;7¢,¢._ g m md Qp’gé'°'"j j 15a-hs , es€-czQ~/<Ciaéc-,. LL.§,L,,¢ jaws . v RE€E|WED |N _C` _\ ég,Oq,, Zq.,b,b ` 69*6<;_@%$! couRT 0F4CR\M\NALAPPEALS h MAR 0220‘\5 § ‘A "'é *¢W /¢AL)L.. Q|¢Lk m, \ 4/q \LA /¢m.> Q<més w u~ &A,\Q®S ‘ - Ab@a asia clem l)e'v\\ JE,€¢<) Q’\.Q,.` _ 5 `»'£.__' /.p?? exhaust 6<§) QQT/mr\lm]- A@PZ'Q|S OT; in 51506"'5 'T¢ Gh`$_zbéwml. l? 301 j » »' of¢c)‘i.- 12.¢!%¢,`36_ 72 44),[`5_ /{?Zm/§;$j:;:}f sz/;OF»§Z:;’ €W’Z"“j£ ¢>S/'ww¢_”l¢»o' OQMW)A>P mLE:-;l/z,‘<r QJAGW; '/ZM';\C 116§7”?[6“£}\&“&+’ !)50§/';‘"5 /DMLé F€l)qu@-J] \}°1 él<)rb’ %;§ N¢B{Arés;»l Dm§. D/! ¢e"»[ ') ;@1¢ j ££Q£,O§o\) a QMJN ;/3"~1‘6 gm /'M T§‘°‘ 1//’ &@é?'vgfj //7"§ /}W/I<M»év~ §§ ,/57Wl cf~:'¢--/;?S¢:§/G l::)‘:gvg::;§&:zq:£;g/ QMUL A/d" ay'a?'/Z??/é£ W*"O"‘J‘ £é@_`é`)'?/£GD /} 9/7 swé£' ,f/g'm ;z w;;-:)Z;S;?rg¢a du /Ww' //5"/‘(’< ' _ ' . "” ` ~ /'S/£/E;/ "'7 V"'?/'"/"*“ 50(\/]`5"`1°'3 QQ>OQE"@§ O/l'm’/'\A/| faaé¢().,,,:}&qj{;Vj§:’c}¢&n 31\®` 777§ Q_/Z/Zé' 0<§`/5/§"@'@£5/2/¢/ C)`eu,@v¢ Ld&//é£ N,A¢V/~ v /)/56 f:/:n U!o'/H'/ér~r~ cg //.D’) ,§K~j?y\j{,, md jac/jam '5 0:5%,5 é\U:‘ +*//?5 /`/de iad <QQWgzao/,// 733 %z /§€~B'D;s,/z//c~/ L‘L ~ /")"'C,_ GQ'*\UIO{'M-\ Qj$»c&+_o 3d ¢)'/Sd '%'Z. Q<-,-mf/cj"' Oz)u/L+ ]l/i$ /)/0'!’ _66¢/1( a< aged zco o’)_'\ 'Hm»( §§qu 0§,)~§’:;;§ }_I/Q\S<'fi'.j"m'\)\él,/<v\l`@\ aig l|'.c,'? S£Q,~L¢~\ é, WML LU% /l/£Ué/i ’/~L 'O_:A'K';'~»\ m 'D'\z§£ .Fszqz”§. §§ Wy.$ _\{¢,,6/$£, 50[7),,, @ané{ » k/£;;i Hmi Al/:'{_ S|zz`“/ /"“ 'W“`/$ //~"7- J“-dzz< <SM»¢¢S I.w ~v\'» /~] sq’ ,_m 1)\“» a'{,sv\ e.,§ 1167 gzaj,;m 7, g \QMLH.

LA:; ig<>l;d£é'_ did ~ANSL¢J£»L_ ¢s-m @F>OC?-/Z‘?‘?黣 ._~2§..0@€/,£??¢6 af~é)€;~/zq‘%§ wm :§§<fwd% w //"07' @EOq'/Z`?Ha l -@3‘<3¢)~/2?$1§’3 diaz @RZL'{¢:L ldz;)&’?'§ Q/UW5 j/N/,/@g?@:;:mj g z °` . ‘4 “ 1/)')~14 g .5 _4; (/¢€, ép£l»`@/H/¢- iZCIKé>L§ Fl§ //:m O@v;/WA,;,,C&_ %,jW£,¢/:f w,e;F"»/\ QQ) mojam<c@z. LL)LM jj was /YMJ/ 73 /I)\a l§§i‘\_/D',s#(£,’cf GQMJ Q]é/Ll:, 'm_ua§'<i~f'\/DQ_Q\m¢.a?-{ A'W§.Alz |~/As ‘/'\IH‘ €50§10'€@9 A /\SWWW§P@"Y\ z / 5 ` -,,.5‘//1/<; QML/m W/,@AJ/`@»r\ z§“c¢~/z'??¢o ~0>?<5€7€?&;5 »z/- Flpp},¢@l,zm m»@¢?'/z?%a-~5@»@_¢»/2<;%€. ,Q§ » 652 ¢@[f /!Hvz /)/a/ 6¢=»» pasth 70 755 /5’$’/? 'D;:;//z/CY ab 0/ j 'Y”z€ / 63©<;~12¢?7¢¢ -~a€'¢><i~zz¢<i<,£ .,@@-.@Ol~/zq?<¢@ -' 0€~0<;'~/21‘<%@. . ©Z»Oq~lz<€'!<'@fb' ~ o§»o<z~ /z.<zv-@Q wm 9?,,\;¢&4.;,~\ @€»oQ-/zo')w -_@F»<)<€»/zv?<,,®' ms ,1/<>¢ w 145/vwag aj 67 -£/'Ws»c /_D/§/.e/é/ A/%£A'SC/ "ég_, %6` /§§'¢\ ”D’/-'sf/.»z>é Ql@»m'- 111 100/000 »//>/l»m_z QQ¢@M //.61, 7,~:@.@</€/2 mg /\/éid <SJ/c/M¢;¢. Yn/%`\'zoo M(:Dé@émbé/L_ 219 S€H¢. 475$ /‘z5 £U]c€‘Q/nc;g, w¢r§ //O‘r"' _léCé/"Oé.e” 67 dz§lA/Q-Aj~ \,¢,,\J,”] ¢@¢lc)éf//< ’7 9€>|4 3¢7 412 szns/Dépaml m<~v" Zf)@£m/?w‘ ;§wsvl‘f‘c..ia )Q€ 1»€ "“*»1<111 €m¢‘éb w 366 1 w,//.,'m MM) mm fewsz ,1/@,1,¢£ .%,,,.// 1244 @¢-qd. @f Qz;+m)»¢r/ ///)'s £é¢z/;;¢,£__J m¢¢,l 1157 wa,~_f op +M,SML ' CZLP“S~H"‘DO '“[’“ @7£5~§'31»1§00 712/m 73 ‘d']\é dew/ch `Wh-s 715 »_-;,, V'Zl‘?`l';$" §§ \/é'e"‘@"\ Q’M "Té¥`i?€ @e¢p;,d»~p @£:~m)`nry'( W)QOQFCL¢..QL 1424#'¢/1»/'/'67 3-1)~ 3.<’. md 340 2 `//>»»¢+ wmf 27»0¢1/297¢1) _77’/?°‘!5/¢\ .3'2?‘0@~/2‘£?&® }//)S //d/ &¢7, AS»m¢)e£ 67 5,"7/1€»¢_ 77q "D¢’.:shzic~.’ @-vanz¢jq &£ /57%1 Ggm)>QJ‘m<,) QQLLL>/ LL))\,¢'£.T; 111%1§§?®;<.1@,~¢,\ QM of 1014/m §§wa - » .

514 <-{x‘@»@é ‘//aw». , 1//`{` 5¢@2¢], ?<9</ )./, do @/30 Q@“:?°<§ OIQ"WF»~{ p€o}s would M¢+ ex<szdr's§ 1"/5 U@vs/H%r'»,y/ 0,€7§7)»4/ \{u/<’/'__Sd/`c!)'¢m M¢/l=_,¢ £/07,7 @”Sé’ W/¢;S 571 [,cc iam NY%ME pé/F//b? 3'£ 077& @@w%Ap-;Tn?' /`/ég 5500£'1 A'/ FS')Q~'/IZ>"Y\ e=§`&;ed, h/H/ Z)éwy,ez.san/z¢/ 73 \j',,C/S2 af &,,,u,`@{,h? @@M-[; /D<Sg»n<§)a-WA¢ fespé.c~,\ig"~\ 04 Q@u,,"~!-S §,L ,g 74 ~Jm.p,,\/'{*' A’+*éF/Yl M&éf¢ \ éF/HO/:ng'rm OC'»LE,""‘O~§`) OB`\Yn\"`AIWHGQ/E&-WLEJ ~F\p_J.‘cAz l£.O§c F»'A 736 ,Lv¢¢!££¢;,“/" 05 \Saé/?cz.. \,(a$)(`/cz méA/A'm,% "~Fn )QQQG&C°Q/"Cz writ 7}\1 }\Mos §§ //':§M'<S¢ .'D§,/ 4 wis 'A‘S<s Q¢:EQ,<QQ~H)$ €¢@a¢$_`( °/7~+ ’l'hz")";.y',¢§ dead cr¢p O/£*mm/| _ ol~ mag / 43 @/€.¢lf §§ w@//e/L dew/41 73@11[»1' \D»~M ?)¢<1+5 @9¢ @§Oe'wm»,l 9@>/)5.@1¢ mall ¢Q»<MMJ /Lj;[:“/TL //-O; 0%`©<1~/29‘7@®‘7?140~5/€ o?'oC'/YSL’D 73 t/?z "D.~§!»e/z/ /9 1431 919 ~/ a@q()`.c~,/M/| O@u./L+. 'L\ QZ`W\@|A'¢'/)CE I,JI`H\ /i,\i 6-9//1-6'" = n _l-E¥/K mg @Q;.,m~mr P@a§»¢w&, )/~0‘1 311-3a md 336 ' &Q@MIQ . _ M<LZ@M &JWQ @WM~ @/192‘1)¢2 a § ' <»19%<2;5 ¢>€/w a/€ ®zQR<QIA~vl /Ilm, J»LC@V G£e-w$' 114 dol gsw +Td llle/5 C,o&z §§ &°él,: mind VMQZJBME /0§/ »‘<x c 54 @L, tm j:)<?€ ?v€_ ll~vv»aqz;| Ce,e€l~(’cd& cf §z/w/¢;_ ‘j" w,//J;,»,`. /%L/¢:»<) /»?//"f) `§1//1% 6 7/@‘»¢5 of%‘z bald ;;Wo,,`¢,v,_b,\( 423 1557/0 md de aar:?% p¢.$,JSn»sl» limmij //?)<@'5 °77¢1/{ /!71(/ 11 75 71§_ Qdue/' ap' @£1'07/1')0 / A]W€@/§ 5’5°>7;13@$7 Chy" &'/ &f?jb//'/<r‘/\ AWT)/f/)') r'/;%/D'VW[/ 6")77'/%5 ’H; J¢””DK;V of ebel/1117 Jc)/§/' fbi \Qee}¢>(#w-‘ j wl////¢‘~nq %JAIK/ é//~\ éz’gA,/)¢@ q¢! 43 Z§/z'/rna//zzx- 771~1 761 Q@M¢¢,¢ 1 »7 g£/z/’ M¢£¢ fay/7 J/ 1111qu 35><'<@4-¢1¢/7711< Wz ¢3¢[4'@/17 dfé//,<a/r/V o'M/§` CQ<AS£_ /\l@.. @§‘~o?~/Zq?é ~ 6€<39»/&‘£?¢ ~ 771/6 §I`¢FF<: 09 TK><_AS.. _ % v*/¢g,y_ /5’6*’2» /_D,'§éz.’¢l» \/$` _ - Gmd'»<g<@ ' \)O`¢\\,.‘qm M/¢£@ Q|I@m ' ` w<a¢\lerc Qsh<~»~\»g m eleman . mine \§ \CZSZ> Q/QC 1~1'€ L"'VWC?’?;/ /- @@ae,: Q P_%;m”ma~\T w flows/do ' Q@’né’§ A/O'@ 77\75 A~ gm QHS¢‘GO€C&NKM, 771£, Olé<g:r\<§ §§ - l '/,\"@PK+ 'm°#\* ;§`Q@Au;;se| T‘L:[§sa;;§h\‘m "J>»~ R§\:|‘)»'SWE#/ M&‘ q j:'h j)r§ vé."`$` , » SE.. u£gugn, 73 VZX¢K 6)@3¢%£?§’@?~\'1:?:&~] F&Céco¢m; H/Lhcl& \,O§(. 771£&@0@@+ )J»AS £SUFZW¢'J) @é£n§mk ®ec`)mll~‘l¢'sr\ Fn Swpp<)/L+ _<9_<§'7 E£S/W 721 Eép .Qédl@f\{’#hg"\ 51 Csawns€.\ ;1¢»\’/1\15 m»(+l»az mw\ drs hézzbqf . @mzérasb: /1)~~+ M A»HM SA.@.// 611 AW;mM*/?> ;1/\+ ' J‘zg\oqen{“ @u/z§u@n+ TZ) Té%c Ch<Qa. §§ 02‘1111»`11~[ Pe@c,e. web _

A@l\‘da /,os’/. immle / ,7711 QG//M~ A,%M 75 /é¢l /)p drmls¢p md %)z%£uc)¢é$. % UG>/Mé/Y//%< 6%¢;¢ »éj¢ygo/,§ 17)»7`; /`/)’)¢///'/'££. /1/1111/¢ A'DPZ£§S\

I+ 1§ ,_6¢'/`2¢,¢ @zz)é,ez¢/ 7)»¢///' 4~" Ce;~j 6/%»$ duke 5/'»;//4 bd S¢n* 721 W\z' @/s£\da»nf. br/%? C'/€.eé af /41"1 C’aw/r£’

\S»G>c.,z ?¢ese div/dx »Q£¢§>us§’r give C,e>qu“ HPPOINTED coa/ng¢l. @uf_ZSuQM” "12) AR¥"C}& l.OS`| _ T<’,)ck$ G,O®£ 66 C'€ym;w/-)I page/aha »' C_,/;usa /Jo° of'cq-/a¢")c¢ ~G?oq-/z¢€¢ S`TATE o§ 'Tz>ms_ F¢J V'/{é /5’{1'1‘ X/ ' - - Courd” o-F wm\¢lee. w”¢ll,`m anp¢éa) /~)/}-m. "mc'¢`li' cwdequ 'DA!; 05 €>.'m. /,,~»/5/150 ,_,§\/¢<>C 716 /'>'v'h#g?;{ '70 'rHe //0»/6»<1:)&§ dubel.=_ cg 563-y C@¢,Jg Qomz:s /\/011.) , Thz OYz¢Qr-¢QQ-A+ w»‘lii’mf\ »Gm¢o/zau) QH@_,`_~ Y‘DC;T¢ 614»?>'11€© l m,¢/ £5,7¢1£5/'5 "/71=1/'.7712 dea/cf np/¢;,»/ ` aea/mel 72> HSS'i‘sf Ai'm ja izzs¢/'w:rp Wdf)\<;) Q,QM,_Q;SW Ab<wé‘$+`y//w/ C¢>¢»vs_z» pwzsu@n~~f o 723-es &dé wiggw BA/. QZ@QZ¢/Wc£. 142/123 /.O`$'/Q SAg/z'g ,615 ,:@//dw$;‘ ,4,¢ f”G/iY/"+ OY’J;"AM+‘\S v<'£1»/%»'//1¢1@ 7?> haas ¢w M~F@¢Na‘/ HW°';"L“O '_'Z> €“(?eé$‘°”\+ 1\\’ 11\ Fr\- »QM ' A<§uzas/my \$uJ~¢c-M @@@Qez=¢?r ’~')7\»/* m\{ pasle Fn @Mrzkmwf bq Q¢-n§’ms~ Vr\Q/r\+w<,:;&§£vc§qn{$ ®£Q]AzAJ¢i<sv\j/"n S'§>poa‘\“ §§ ,Q.é>?\{* T?> ey£é$@m%d'ov\ c<§` _Qawvlsal '\'5 ./JHA<;L\;» /<)'nd %¢o/¢G)Mhho\ fm w AS wm la Q éQ/+Qn 5 b 11 00 v 63 ` u. m3 5 -'Fc)c;sw :D;i(o?n 1<;2, wQ»T** £’//15 L¢/»".?‘ n HQ.Q“} rim O‘ZD H-Mkuv‘L[-,, T’z\u\€ ~1') 1415 E><EQ»F/€J 711/ls ’Mz, 9‘/ ®11~7 of i';b'»eqmz? golf f'DnTE_ EQ#/m/ .;h/ .ilo/s" j 55ij 5{&¢'<;" C,z>u L`|"_ §§ w'l`\i G<? '|-10(>¢:.1)§ §LF_,_‘;M§. )l.aj, "`CAMS€-») o @q-)zqv¢. 1241"1 /aq¢ z JFOQAIZQYQ ._ '_D€Aiz Cl€kK £NC.\QS£A @lé*$£. ;VY\O! m.¢u,qnq-‘g mo#\§`r\ &))& CQ)`L‘R'.[_ Appom{'?o\ Q.ou/nsé,\., 65,€0\£/<, H'r\ci "-Déc",(AKr-}'}ic~r\ ‘;1’»'\ S\»\Pp¢.€+ .

9§ K¢'$A\l' ')`b WEG>£QPA~I~HFQ\ 104 G,ownsd inn ’V%z /-Hoovs_"'~§f‘f/z,. md /~/umb».=.,zsc)l Q/,zu§s_‘ p/msé glé '.TZssé @mpe£s find bg,'n% F)qem 1b /D\e QH->-n+)`<s~'\ op ’I'M_ Qau&‘*/¢ YOuL ASSTFS”J'A'V\C& l\~\"n\’\s { {\c=r\~"e/L T<._. ég~¢<..m/*|~{ /.W&'m{;¢o hhl@¢_~;%‘“’ ®~QQ“"` 63‘2@5§~ w`\l|l'm"\ law (AHW\

011¢»?>‘\\€`12, 4 £|h_s LM»'»\` wa\ke&QGu/AW {\Leq'] Fm C??<') v

lJu/ql'sv"zni, T£¥AS 77 391 ~7>.

E'XF/IA?T / ’]d:<'¢`g}z¢rrj:m gm 5a pP@/<T ar £.:@.¢+r §§ far£<st/~/TAT"£-or\¢ §§ Cou~gé| h .

Acz%Hr-. 1.0<§¢ 'Téms G»<)'Dé. 0§ C.O.Fm'r,h\m` p@&»pm&_, § , § QAw/' ®éC)/*’<”¢°"”‘ 75 % Swppo/U"“ af A@)L¢é-}é '7¢>05’/ )6{¢/’ Q,.

76 £é 559:;"'"]"®\ b~z Qewnsel jim /.)'hz Téurs Qm§z cf C¢imr'n»/( ."`\ @€Q,('_é ua}.,. ~ ~ ` ‘ ~ . . , \\6) /</0¢0 davies kzs(pz<z/£//7' &I//,~Jam /¢M//Jz¢</ A'//¢n cs/`dB’I/?Z, 373 war J¢¢/A@:; /m/ f_/)M ,LWL/¢ n y viz dow 605-145 ;, 116 Ac{/Zm end fé?aé$f§ /zmz, mfsz CQWJL 73 /,eo¢zz@/ 171 ¢Qfm/.L Auo')黀`:s ’P»~`_//Ais A<‘Go‘w\(pen?¢,m§ ACL'M mw\ 'wowi.eo glow W£ @.Q)Lm.| 'U\z g|/cw‘ ', @Fm /0,@ M//¢/ ZcAucézS/Fs¢/ F',, 715 E///’ls L¢/».,'Y af<N.£_ //é><f?$ /Ds@n¢|m¢{' @<§`Oé¢m»;\~l walsz wks@a T Aw\ No+ ¢péf<mijf"“‘{) 75 ]M]‘m°“éiw @I //sz_ //0 Sou£c£ of%c¢wa m gpaus¢v/ F~czeme, @FQ“¢@@H}'/f/\Aoz, /1/0 .C,zg,pz{; 40 me ja Wz ’Zm.o/é '//Lc,s/ goa/o @ D;,.,zr`v`§ mbi chn»ecea/»\l¢b'\ th ’/711 7;)<'@ /D'ePAmHn-¢nl~ QFOE'\m\'rm l \\uslicz .FP/nos. /Zécs'ws<& A fgo¥'lmA,<(-a‘ ' 010 mms 62 WO'V[M Hs- él'§/< &Z.sm Qé,lM\.,;S fw glrwvl 4 , . 7¢ y @In/€?”€/L dam A/A//_ /191/¢ my f,¢€¢és!s "Dq @»n p€A/é(/$/S‘<>Aé.s', wl a< H/m/: ,<?Gz@¢mé 411/j ,&e¢/’us n/dj»»%m/ de div 7-¢/@,,.@/5 %c@wé, @ :_rz @/Aoz 6)1&@&,¢»¢.0?;,1§/, @-I;%Vi 737¢"‘/ 6/£ AVLS Of %9£@>(/)7/)¢9,7£6/</ MJJG`?;' @I’Jzoz /f/o j Fzs!/K%J‘~m _@m~»( mo“+k\`f €WM£Q /-“r/Lz AWM/m;%é/y 31 ;F w>//,"M 6&£;</ w 0/¢2')/§2 59 " /0@§5@;/»"¢'/ %wcézanJ j,, 712 5)/1\§%/1/-»»1'/ o%£ 7§/,\9]5 ®é/J;y¢fme¢/-/yz' C’/Zl;n/h/JJ z/w$oé(cz well/ff 'u/nl<-\Tiw\$% Uéh;@ A/nd cOzC/»mz omaha 41+7 of 6§§% ~ ' F‘?- ’¢.¢,j°‘~é ESMIz/nm(s ')£wzz,’T/wz ¢»c/ d@mezc% VB %7 51 d g dw*';/ §Xa¢u~/sjm Bcg %Z Q/¢J<-} dea 0_1°/‘5/ w://,/aw\ nw M/% 3/¢37)€2_

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.