Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Gibson, Tracy Ray

Gibson, Tracy Ray
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided March 12, 2015

Gibson, Tracy Ray

Opinion

_ITL\W 727+7 Qm>%) 17/7{3@@7 Slvt\e§ -\)\…7 wg,élL/?OL#,¢)S,UD Zom<> \"\N\ 55\‘* ' Q>chdw><\¥ \T\F~. 77765' ;vz w / j\’\@<¢\\ SW \ 90\5 F\L\%&`a€°"‘b ` \\ {‘B¢JOO?F‘A Q@. \\ @~A mm @\@<\LGY< Q… /L\Xl AM ~ Comv @§< G m ml\ A€Pwl§ ' RECE'VE m COURT OF CR|M!NAL APPEALS fm Q>ev\ 19~30% C¢<P j“”°\ 5&7`3°`”\°7\ MAR 122015 Aw,\v\<\\ \7. 7$7¢\ ) Abe|Acosta, C|erk 7;{\(‘,|04,€0{ `ifbx wm <p¢f\c' cw\ 0`\’»~35/\4! COFV 01C a/V\Y R€`>POY?SC/' *\‘6 €"\`1 `l"\`i aj CQ\&,({'S/ C/L/§ H`§°LV€NUF p??£) G\->\M ida C\m\~f we§\' \\a\c)eu§ Cm'?u§ §//¢07, I<C `f€v\ hamm QnY Twes\fé\‘w\§ of COv\/\v\./\€M//`§ mr 1~@@%»@¥0¢1\§ \me\ 11/\:5 mom)e,\e mark 77a/ac S€N\ '\“\Nw-. 1a w\& o\~§r m 0§)1€§§ Ce‘l)m/C,. 7//\¢~4/1/3 SS/HC‘€Y`Q// \// 377737/757@n lWa</j Qaj 67 l>&%/ i-M /\\\»6 C/\"\ W\}‘(\OL\ c/ou»<`§\~ OQ ./Af{>é° 1045 '~J:N *X'\‘\é C/'\`<\"i mr Arv\s<r\v\)

Sv'\`wv~€ 011 TEXA§A

"\`<z\\s><¢'\\ \3\9»1 Qa\¥>¢_r)©¢\\\%u%§¢l § mac NG(§) § game \?N\ 351\7€ ‘r’-N‘i'\oél‘£da”)» D %wmm<\'\`§'n. 77705. § FLL|¢((O,_S`;L@O7.. A (?n'>` sL QQ§<`\¥\\AAU\ § `F~U(CY,(oL{,"gOG'7 ~ /4 _\;~ ' § v"Ye>€a$ (\`)Qc»<§\/@N\e>r\\“ o& C,r`\m`\na\ `A`,\)~QQ`\Q£ SM\¢L e§ TU\Q_S <\?L§l¥< \6 wore (‘lté>?m\§& 40 T\` CO»\ yQ\`c>\,k<‘<@ ®c>\e,c %U\\l`\r\‘§ AYQ\`~\L&\¢‘\<><\ ¢Q¢c m¢l\~ ©Sv \{\o.\r>€az CO<PUS w`V\\ Q»`\v\¢\`\h$>S c-§- godva a<\¢X (’o~x\c\u<;¢`m\ 0£ l.a<.d

Nam come§ ?vo ea 0&5¢§~\%¢».\<>_» ,'/l`vab*l god @7[§>$4\_~)) 1b F\“\Bto€a~vl_`> mc<~em<k\j `\z\ “~W\e_ cudsz a¥H\e ’Z)~¥§\P§ \§l.v:~l¥k 50(»(> \:\I\f\ %S(L\ \ Y>@vasv\¥\`l`r§ 7776$.: :'L` now §§e'»@¢\i< \w WL \¢\ov\ova\o\°` Qow<& csc C<r\m§m§} '/&PP€Q!§>M~/ ?\@.99<>7\¢_,@” 45 rm ‘\71§7‘“ Sa\>u\¢¢ ~©z»§w:¢l Q@Wo¥ 052 /Ua.<;@§)~ c§<oc\x\l§ C/oam¥“l) C/\‘v`( csc /\)acoi\<§loc/\~€S’ 0\~&&< Jvo AU\`{ <\‘?P\\»Ca&§®\\ S<e)€ \Qv\j< 0§ `4\¢»\00@€ CO€VQS § //\07'.

Q\ `¥X\ivv@a\\ cm: C\l\eé

:<\ o\CCcr<~§m/\ ~L{ §§ n'_\rU\a€> C,< `\w\ U\a\ Q()§ €_ ach Q€oc§\st A§X Q."{».,®<l (35 QQ,\¢`€Y\\¢\\L§ QS(\\-Kre§ `\(\X@ 0` »P\{o\ 0§ - ”3\\'\\§<`\ '\<> "(\NL CS`\N\`&M\ Q\(\o.§§&€> d$x \¥\T` g A §\>U\CL\ CLS§Q Q,Q~G\~OB §°\°Lva,\s<§{§ Q\o\)\m.§`( wl‘\')\\& °~\'Y/\& vod\°m 0§ ?\Ln`\$~ `\§“\m¥ \rf\“-C~}>(.§\;Z.§;l 5~°?°( ~Iem§ 7 ~\`Av;¥ §@mee » §e\¢m‘( ia€£@\>¥€» a ?\aa ‘Da<§,a?v\ fec 30 ware ao§ q&w\o®\ `O\~e\ \o`\ `\’\M \\VSW §a?€‘ `\C>< ®`\§¥v rods C§o~<§v \Y\<>N)Y ab\< Q)o\o`§€.

Ca\»&\&\\ C§)c `£§f ,Q<\Qg`§`u\¢>; w§‘*€v\ ceac»¥»€j>%zn¥d q\%sr\€f> N\<‘ Q\QX\L Q§>i\@b\\ q o<\ 'N\Q#\( QM>}?O<>'L Mf\ inl`i>%v\\\) wa§ U\\¢e,¢ §§ `<:\¥€> _\_Q_Xa¢y VQYQ»< §m~ex\$c §§ Cr`\\\r\`\ ¢\0§ :\)J>§v`\c&> -I¢\S~ &z¥~\>évde~<\@b\ D\\u Ls?<m 04 o§ `JM\Q\ 900'7,. n /\1¢.&1\%@»>, §1\9§ m >;Wx aga mix @.~C \x\o§)ws aos?ab § L\\O`T ec>w\o§v`~h`e \>Q\v\~>€m\ 3\»¢<\€ \91')0`7§ w A~\»~¢>W,l< . ;Lcw; w we 3¢¢%\@\6 034 \> Ae~fec§\a!¢ rc\§?§ B\\QX§ 35 1¢~€§»§1€§¢1¢€ ags?s¥w<\¢e csc Coa\\<z§\ omni Ae,d§\*\ wea?cfv §§¢~§`\n$ , _\\\‘€ \H§+"` S»A>Qx`\<w Qis\~¢;§¢ y abuse vwqu 15 1 j\\c.©:»&ww§' , gum ,C;L<J>` -»q_ NAMOC/ Yvo ¥~>~1\'\ m¥§'c>`<\ ,`\<\ GG§&\N\?'\' X<> C,ovve<§‘ <Y"f\€ §Q§&§N’\ d\§\§vm€r\\' \O“( §~<mh`¢/\"a +\\€ cv`\m\\¢\¢.,\ a\/\ac$€§ §w\:\ @;LC(_OZ ¢M‘S. IL<SRD\>LH <\>o '“r\,~@ \€99»~< §nc,\uo\c) OQCCM€ Q\ age 26"6\~09~ Q\o\§\cz<\{ )~\11 w\<\`\¢\l\ %`\wQ/> axw~\“\\e< C<M\IQ Q\»J\`\S\mm‘< \f\“i`~C; A- § /éz~bz 3“'9 §'earee j\\-`e.\cx\`/ ~\re> kwok ¢uo \QS»:» `H/\w~n 3 \1€0~€> o'wj ./Oojv 110 UCQ€¢D WQ w\c>\\CI\N\u/-\ OS< 20 \{Co~vz. 'T\x\& who ~\~v§o~\ €o¢...\'\"\' 0¢§®< mae §'\\Q§ 07\ @C>LOQ<>’L< \§+M/ <QOO"(, /Héo 14\€ cho\ coa¢§ §L\Q§ \"v'é> §¥c§§~ Ov§e( §_U\%ti<\a a??`{- c@<\.&e ;§a\Q wc;¥ al mbw§ emma 511‘07» T“ke {-mqf Coa;év §§ v\o¥ §mmw<§ f*c`§ Po§¥~ccmocc}¥$<>/\ coav`¥ Mc\ev icc /\}\Y~Q\`\\I>SON, \\1§ usa<& ~a?\>o¥r\\c$\ O§LN¢\M 3 cf {\se,v\+o *\z\»a `YSC`§\ Q~Qws§\$ §`\\) ;9§<:\\_ ~\M\¥§\ <5> <QE\/Q `(€a\;s q$`(¥°\{ ”`v\s\e §aa\v ?<\ `DQQQW\\'>€K sg€)l<§. ,/V\§ ~\ C:\`\`ve@\\> ) wa% Coi\xvn£§ § §>\\ SHIWE 50¢»0$€) i:`-o< (`>(l¥@w§\wé~ }‘v?\?a\\<»§,\¢c )Av*§vex\\”v‘f 3 /\F\c§` 14a-7 (§e Z:`/w<r+}>\ lp\<\o \r\;¥\a¥<§\ <>\ \Q.°~§»\ \K?\~ow¢; c.a\\“ M<maa€& b\r H\€ /V\c(:@i\v\€,\\ \1\1(~¥ -\ `\r\§`\-\k»\-»`*m\c§ \oao \`\`D\~<>_s{ah , M(~ /\f\at§€`u<\€?_, 'Dw~<`\r\f> `5<\\1 ?C§oc)»\€ CO<\S;'€.<~UL€/M(§.

E\w<>c“dr\ > aSz\s`\'-zm§ wm `Wa¥ ~»~‘<)\~A *vv§¢\\ Coa<'\ LH~W>_€J 04\ ~W\WQ/< vw§~v, .…\¢ m W¢_ :c q§/.<ej hmw `Y\s»\ %g<agcw\v°~ 01 \\\/w§'\ lré§~§d¥\$ `\/KL '\'v\\a§\ Cou.§¢\' if\q§ qH ¢Q`u§lc\< we md §\r\L §al\€§ S<c> <Qs?<m<§ ` `II \0€")1><\ '\o race`\\> c \?a®\& N\\vu`\)l€w$ @C~.@L‘L\` ( 31 d "'"_\"DCI~S\ W`um§:'> %-`\oto*\o\n cq@\¢,u;\a\e§ m‘\ Pav¢\<>. @\`\°>`\\7'\\\\~'1 R\ O\Q.Cc>c&mca 3m \T.<\"C`A` §§`6@./“{‘1. /l'lY ‘Q¢k.<z»\& `\<\&a_<\>.\<u>s~ owe accm§d~ml\r »' Qav\a@w1 J¥OF§ 3 ?Q\>ma<`\ ,-¢90\\>\ `1 §;Q\mv\¢>~v\\ ¢'lz>l§`, @Q\meq¥\ é?O/B»»O?o/S` J\C.Qq\"\>@o\b) m<\\qb ?\7;1\\@3<\0<\; \\¢.\ ¢'>Q§.\LQL\~`& C\a§s YQ\QQS?\»§ \nw\ §\`z>m §§ `S€S §¥v§-#~S Avc Cv\*"\ \v(\€,§`\\m\\ cus¥ec>\\i mi*i’\\ \<\zz \~1\\& C\a<>s \.

C\M©\v\\ws arc :ACL `"\'.\\1 Cox~\-¥~&¥Po\v\\-Q¢Q 'Ok\§o< i\&`i j N\v_ Q'le,v\e U\\ ()oUqu/) l ul\\® JOQ,\:‘U< \`%&\\\Q\R)C§ `Y\\{ §\\§§C§‘\N\L\N§ \ 000§ \00~\F <5:%°~ Q_`@QCLWQ a%d§§c€u\c.€ agc Cm\>.'w\¢v)§ \>`\ O\\\o\\) N\@ »~N\? ~ Q\» beard 3 H QD\-QK`

~ 1 <\¥o a ’\>\La j\mx°>c®c\ o\\<\"\§.v;\\`\%U\/*</\ `f <>< M\\Lv\mo 506 1 `f 20an 407\ a §9§-<§~1\:€ `\r\§§<§m\r\§'~‘ J(/\{`\ Qs\§(>§o§\) , OLH*@@S "H/\€ 1<';¢\ c;>\m§ §§ \>~L m 1112 §@\\ow€r»§ exva s §`\\Q§ *`§~€ `\\N\\’<`OPL( -1`©<»\£§“{ 3 A)M\c Pf`o 1~@~0(» ~\*\\<§< Cax\ cs\\\~\ M¥ \\§m`\ca\ arms g`( Qx\¢\ ./\)H\\\Iw ~ \c `\Q\To§ §xvo~(`% 1 u>\\\br“ `§’\/\‘L P\\o‘?l( \\`QW\€<§`( ®o\k\c\ \\¢L»JC *>€.'()l\ vi`\\\§dc§v -\ N\v- Q»\l\>s<$\\). &. ' A(¢;§ c@a<& \N§ R>ro‘?v§< m§`¢§v§cajv€w\ ax\)\ 57 1043 <)R‘?§c>\?v`wx§‘{ \vo\>~‘§\/\‘l` lTr> k\\\S Ok§€)(\"r"\@m<§ ({<07> OL'H\P §Q&v&é¢`\o& \m`\§o§b\°~ d\§§c,\nw\Q,\/\\~ `ic\ )<9067. w ' ~ ’b. 4¢<<\¢§\ Qc\»<¥< S<<>'\\e§ ¥c\ Con\c\a\( F~'<’\\e Coux+ O\?‘PC>`~<\¥QX~ oé§uc¢\®i ,~ N\<~ CC\\A \QQ,\\ > `Y€)C?`S,- @€_c.ov§$ ®NCS\`¢N/ O`x\d\ N\<» Qs'\\nso\)\ cu\¥ l\ %€QQ#Y\\>L\< »§O\é) > w\/\Z¢\'\ boaz SZ~“\M \\€<»€‘> QQ¥¢( “&“\1~€ gal/iv T®C'I-@Q¢o€§§ D\\ul;§\`c>v‘) ¢)\\ow@ %eceo¥ \\`TN\\Q~S\`\\’$"` o?c§oévd\j~ /\}\\`k Q'\\§>§c>w\) 37 ) \€”;Q\ e¥m\vw§ ;®< ?<~<&\L §\`c€§`\\>;\§¥`{, ‘\\ ~R`\¢\ Co\»<¥ macev§ G&\ 1355 ;>M bo`§ci%cm@) ‘€o\»w<: <>A\A Q»\)\V\\v<'\¥`i u>\r\u¢\ “v’v\+a €>¥o\\~§§\»e 0& \`\w\}¥- LSvWS \\.L\’ ?ve§ `\`\\ <>\CCO~QA¢»<\¢Q ‘lvo WQ§ CNKMM\ (`Q)C `?w&d\m& (_T..C¢C.V.\ A<‘\¢ /61.0! (L/) 69 ...

6 §E§(Uv§cua\\' Cou<\ \>e f%}m§f£l{lb 5 ‘(PGLTS §ww\ "T\\{ C§m,\v{. O;~ "Y\r\€ CO\N\\N\YSS\"(N\ d'£`- H\€ O"{lc/€/?'\S€; (A\ “N\QC¥ <5\~ V\z>\j\>u~\/_ 5» ~\/\\e ¥r\\o.\ C_o…f¥$ q<,;vicw\§ §§>veace\eoo “\(’[/\C Q\€GL"\WG~'€‘.’)C\:W 'QA \"LQ N\Q.‘(\‘\ CX\Al `!\Cuf> €MSGO( `QLJ`Q°CZ/Y\€(\M Q;<vo\_‘-> \§`\6\0§<\(\‘> ,/\\§~ CT`\\>SMS` 3 <`1'3`"‘% P\`OL€O£€O@ PO }\<\/v\ \0\\ "YN\L \)\.€>.C<.K. `LU\` m \L\W /Ll»(\/\e)v\Jt Q;QL\EP / PQME-A Q®c`$v\s\\ex j J\)\</ Q,n`\\§>:-v\x}'» sQC\£-z ~\/\\e_ v@\l£§ o~v\cs) ?W*`\‘L`< QQQ 1~/\`\-\\¢;& Q\Q`\g§\`\g\_\¢~(\ \>~1 ~H\{ C(\ §m£\hcc/ Gw(-.L 09< J‘RW<>~\S §§ smwj< OU?A w… \r\>> Co<\)\r€c)¥&c)v\ 5) - _.\@U~V\L \<<, \\@ A<--Q\O¥ Q@»\><\ \As*`*\§\qmzo{ §>¢$;M C_ow<>v z N@L,c°>§oc&\%é CG\»X\\‘”( » C`\¥“\ §§ N<xco€dc\oc!\\\~z§ 154'1§‘€ §§ fwqu 1501 Le\ . Mc\ @lbw, £`~(H\W veme$\% amf GAA\L( \)~x\wv<w\& ?U\~QA`\"LS M\< vol\\ &S<Q@<’<\ /'O»v\\v\srl \¢\Nv\ o\ <A~éex\¥m\cb<\<>§ \\J¢MN\°_\ d\ \\Y% X<§o\§ Cm)~(¥._ ::MN\Q.\Q. §§(;\Q\j<>\§<`\m\§ /(’@c¥`»££ca}r€ oQ SQ\“\)BC€ `l ~\ _\_r<;@% Q\O~`t C€l§`$)zm.\ “H’l~qzlz)@é\\l \ ofac/dm wm)£f P€f)» q\¥~\ 09 \>u§»~cd +*~,»¥ di H~L ~C@<@o;¢\§ rda/rank and `\/\Sro<w\()~§\~§d‘l\ owe lvv\)\~c <w\<§ covv€<:¥ 40 \N\*t ~CQCW amp be'l€€‘ Q>\< u\-:\`\z§r\§ *~t'\¢\{ KM\{§ 63 SH)LQS 'POS {v;¢,/ §QIUL`C)‘I a %w»€ *L\c¢\<;§¢ C<sP\r \`é be§n§ malleo( +6 1 C(\`m?'nq/V QM§¢ @&- Awm\.s, m w /M<< cq/).M 5'¢@¢;>1#,%15/%>», -T)<` -'_7‘?571! @.r\& a Covw?'ir\/\Q:AL¢»H 60{7‘( 55 helm //1/)¢2[/€/ /¢/5*“ S»LFU¢W D\\SL¢\~J GM~% , /o/ w_. /Wm 5¢.

Qwv\/\` 130 s /(/aco:)oqoclw_¢ ,'7'§€, 7§7(0/.

EW\CM{~&¢O 97 /Y\'c Ov\ H\~`§ / SND'o/@W %/%rc//>\ v§015. - - d '

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.