Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Blake Carrington Gee v. State

Blake Carrington Gee v. State
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided March 26, 2015

Blake Carrington Gee v. State

Opinion

Tl\i UVE UbOCl 0\ f¥PBfc\b VWdK ~TV\ "^ tb%\£T 0 \ fefe FILED IN COURT OF APPEALS •TNii rft ThX f^ 12th Court o? Appeals District &\<&e /LM^b^O^ btE \ uvfpuuvrr) CATHY S. LUSiC.'ci dr> f<Pm • ^ \2. - \4~ CD WH-CfL ~"lVte 5A'Me D\ VfeMV, i_. WPtlVkfc

fWfcLLA&l b T*iCr <b£ ftflief

O "T(\hVe_ of LDfJTejJT^ ^„ „ r •* •«> •» ""» <r,

* *"• vts f^lk ^^

/MtbQN^T fuo ' Ax)lk>'{\-\7 ---- - - .- .. _ _ ^ P^V&.X o^ t\vS~T?OuT\\£>x error - ~- - - ~ - .- 1

ruuaiyv?oi^6\ error . ,. „ _ ... .

PveAxtf .... .- - - - ~ .,, _ .„ _ i& 0 <* rT.

CD fo\PALE_CP^vtelck GeL."Toc^i 1<\4§Z&A APRUfcTT IAoTcUS

(2> P\ft fXtAS ni ViC*-fe_ ^S^ SluicL &t>4 ..„.__. - i") ;\^oe<\s fbft_\e£ ~• - •. . .. ~ -, - , •., .._ . ..._....-.._. j% £CuU6_X '^£Clvoi vci "Ifey'A^. COksTTiTvIT.c^ . - - - - •- - i^ b.tLL \i bwifuft ~b^v u^_\^bo LSti- c»v- \°m . . - „ „ .. _ , .. •. __ . , ij) i;.

k;

fc^fwere L\liV fe& Sujad Aft <Vfc IT&ldw/W5 ife , ,.-> ia — Lp b\\\KAfL Ni S^3a\e. 4fk Buaid MS >^ M Srfc^nte ^^.(055 _ ------- ,7 rv-e^Tv^jL^ m <o\xx^ \ ^ y^ ht " ' " " " ' " " -- "*'A

let 0^ ^'-TAos,^ ^0 -»-.. ... jW^,3

akV "Ittfc. UxiYl Of AfP^b ~TM\t1b "fckto (Vbftk- Q^^Tck l^6slj LwtiUbD M^ • UWixD \^\VLX^^-Ob

AfP^l^T fft> bE fofotf

"TO TUe v\oi^RMb\a_ ^viSTvo^ e£ bAi&coirtP Aha^stlAbi ^ ^aKW^i. ca^_ f^r2ec^d\r Fvie^TK^ AtdtL/wb aw-m- ftWeWtaSL^ ftlev-^ frfU-bf Tu^jQuSTTd Tex. ft, m P^ M.\ Ab

~~^WjAL_ ftisTfh<_+ UXftT Of SmTftv CDuHY T&U^ AiAbTf-bt- COucT Hli\b. uvitor t^L bolb^o.cToA # "^L-Tb^XH Dinto /VftfA | Coall •MbbOicTDv^ £X£r Tki;_ cDl<*l ^ATkneST Of FACTS ovx or AhDvH tml ISA nx-f tf Oerej^r- Oo\-i Ik. /vmioljt ubr

(4) ^Gbb. boubbV \o ikfCKa^_"bbb Pois^kf^rf PbfxibbT ^O'TQpQi bob_ becT^bZbbi „'Tk_ bt>KL Dih v^ouseue^ Aite^HL. The. malm Av-THlW/" toebxn t»A T^moiLAKif l^^rrKdxJT C\Tu^-Tk_ btaii^L.

AllbcS^t mtk. hDki DVTte. ja^-H^rr ^k>\Tk_ APfcil&JT b^_b . 0\_b~ \0 XIbm_ bj^ lim AibJ 'fc> Hfc/i*. Ajl. K£) U_NbG_ uj TR__ ^biar^r k>£± Ak. aLi^MLn- A(^l^_ AGOM bp, r/lcY /k OeiWuL lib (WMi& Si bAbb_ ,_ JM Pvb^oT^ 'fcr ^VXW Jki OlMZC LfLiKnuOL. AcT^f\r "Ihe^Kun V^e\foW_ £>$ Ab A^v^imjt bv7K_.

~TKb bAa.^ JLK^ic^eJT Npjuer- AVW^eiL A1s>TNl APMiburr qj^^jL M_.r Abv^ii. -te> fwrtvciP^ris ~io Aa Hb&LiHu- i& RicT THb AfPdtar vslk. a&( mSeb^r mixklL l^ l^^<b^a Tta_ /ypeii^T tLet.b\e_b_ "v>\ea_ 6&c.0h&nb Ab_.P'\t^&-b bo\\T/"lbTMb XMbickib

"/ear- ~£ ieo_bbv^j^rf AWjk- Kab k&) b^^H_eii. by Tte. bbte.

A\\ev- kQb^x } UCK Ca^Lc-teA. ^b Tibb^ ""TNl. /Vfei^lun ~b^v_b-^_ ^beAiaj^b_ \_hl_ APmto '10 ^b Yeaisr bM^^/v^rr lOKJbb. DivJi^i^A P\Wr-bTk., "\(Uab M\orM« T\U_l a. \j5[i*l. $- Mfeoi bR_

U--

(S) F\(VbT PtMT OVg^T- XTvbThb, TO\/WTb UM^ticA "d<& Wbbi v/ear ^te^JL- fcLCbbLb Ak<_ fb\o\fttotftf fW^L Ctf T\)^Wh^T vxor CL ^£^L^^a_ x€b^\-\bT

^bMS^bi La^oj^b. CX TQv/^ fbxxfxL C£x_£b ^buoA 11,02. CA^ (£>_) LVb^i^TWb AfP-bii^T UiiTK_-b^^mi^^ DPtWub-d CJPvwu^PtL AOVMiT/ A^xb Aitb 7k. bib^btKuJT Tftftjfc, Ahb batuin

Vb O(YK0\b,\^Lbes^^ Bb^Wxb-^ bto^^ j^trWiT^ M\bi\hPiT r*xb AiSPonT/, V^V^ T?\f\x^.oW bVt DCl "?0£££blC& £X i'^Tcft tjo&- mK)rHTo\

YOSb^bet, ^a^Bft^Or \y&L\^ \D Or K)C^Wl£^ikb bb or ^^ ^ RbOUl O^lkjfXtA Wb:£ TVL M\.KWb^Tbk_ otTb,^ ?0bbe^>ec_')TRi<i^vtbOr \wjl vb vD lot Koi^L X^ lV ^ ^'^ ^TV^fti&L CA T^q\W\voa TWb 6.~b.\\>^L\3i Svx\vA 33-Ob. . Tfo/W<t\Wt SW> tYvM It \KiXb wt AWeV^ i^HL lXV6,CbMe>n Wxb\ "tk O^^^Nj^CvDKruWi. ASCLuiST (G) "V^btb At CTuR^iJb^ CDKnvXM^. AX)tiO^ A^£\<Wb\f f^-^>\ fat ufcs bbVft C* Abex^b^^L.Hb0A7 ~\SrO± Tv^ Pm^^T^r'^ ^b (10^lV\^^^^^•uil^b_'l^^lf^TeD£^ DbWi^TDb Crum^bl5\)5T\cbAJbsb^-- TUb (WbilewT bfc\^ t^t W xbb^ b&^^ too^^^^^ bAb^LW (\0lk&> 0^ fWlskj^&TT \b>r~ Pt b(^b^L kis^ Ybvobl Al\L . ^V^^te^L, t£ (2& } beO/w bWm\Ltae_ Kib\\ fciL MbtL ?&b\6 0\^ ^\vsv foi*ST tf &NOr~ ~AKl. AfMVb^i bn^b\Wc kbeLfe (\lbi6 Abert -thv_ VfcMOJ^e Umfbl Xivbbb i^oe_ Ajb bU&r tbbt- V^ObL Cbii^b_ ii-b_ fWbWb^T s ~~bo be_ bt>T tacui^TD 1H^ A^^Vh^T item^. of T6ft\_. nSu^YK "lb ft be>*^iASL -bK^ &£s Nok &.wJl (Lb> Tecw^.

TT \^1,k^ h?%\\k^ uaW^ ThAV ik. \-toM)^b^T0uAL.

Cb>xAT 5^*l ftwxi. bb <U>ck^ txikb V^ iwwiruW -^ o^b^bbLW. vow (\akjvl o^ ba^no^.^. rb)T L^v-tKLA T-u\- -He&LW >^>r i^05^Akx*x \5i ^l£nv br- ]_\fe, A*it /v f iml c£ ^° Tb_. iiOiXDtD* k3\W Ob boo U^rTKUbi^f V<

^^-^Ll) NMWdv biDfe ^ Fbbxl Of Tk Fx^ c^bKJb- XV Tk^kilWW Of 1T'£Y& £\oWtfjL ?OSc&sse.d rb&Aj*^ 0fv\5>bb-\b \Niw<&v b5 eCLNifte- XA x^ C\wk ftow IVjl bfofcs- ^VAm^SA A^bA TWbX^6tctf^bT "bXuAb^ 1^ OO&JNLfcrl A^b GG^b\L2_ LiL^tVA^b. AAbibTHb kfo&&2\ \Nfob C-WirwA x>o>n'K_ W\x\»bv b^b AkOA 50 x^jn^ A^L. AH^fc>

vbTV^ AffdVbj^Tb Co^^^Lioi AMA A^b Lovifl.7 VjoLteaiKCtoAr- i^*Ab TY^cAxbcf^. \iNAkb rx Vxiv o^ rVV)-^ ^X X- \\ Tnj cq/?T •P$S^^ti^\&\^^QKjrf\l^& bo\\Ai T0~l'KiL iKibcoHNbTT To&if ftv^Aru i^Mlb^Avl ^K^iN.vXi^T^LNiovuTO^rf b^cbdj^ Ti) ^<^bb: ~AW^ 0^-^VC Or^miL 'A^u^sT "t'ax Vrt ~TkL-^W v^TWL- jk^cTT^JT V&r t>\s^£>&ujv- vv4 OfbDANAUL CfUruw2L- AcJTwiT/ ""' TK-Oefej^uTT -fc> bvr, T\\p- fAyfT /W^(bi v&oier UJd- lOur ifAe^_ <Df i>uiT/ Tb "AKtb A^LvcThlJT ~T6ib.Y Ab A W^ovb Qv A^1H7Al '0^&UuM.cb YoJ v\r\Nte_;' TUp nogp.^.rr ^ c^ tAtPiE CI ib CbXbar ^A^'AV^ LGufCT xx^b AbW&-7V^ fcofei&saT

Vtf Ai$b S^e_ A^b -A^ lb APR\\0uJT AuSv.W_ ^Tkrtffirm- \\Mb .... Atb bvr 3iA vsTHl. APPb\\^^ Co^TeA-LcA Ucec Acc^u&Th T)3-Si 04: •.H ^liSTLTliki^ JM^brK^vbTi^A Vk. Do\1 hj$e*m_. liX A. Fxvst f£^b_ A^b. %ecc^L Tte^L_ ^AOKxi Lb •\H&ter ~7ve, won-ber Dt XTe/^s u£fc^ Osiar bb t>r b&^ Akia bo Mb /Or ubOVer br mo~ ~"TKl bAA.HL.WOb.Wb CaK^^A. A3bbm-n- AA £tkrA7 PbKbki "JVfe. AfMLun bv^ a^a \^ od^ k,o Nbm^ bf ma^V Pb^ m a^. bta^ ^ ^^ MDr ^ TML ^^ ^ 1K -TK. APMkuJT (\a.TuoA> To T Ku W\cT Ul+ 1 Ik. ou\7" <L.tte*u«L. ^ ft 'oeco^L •Qeawi_?U£)k)y a^ A r,sT (Qea^ VtKxiY ib tk, /W>lT of xlbis. DS^, u**V ,* .ui*. u^r %D A<3to^ AB*3LSe\otf"or- « OMe^ ->o iTen^ A W «**_ RaooY. i-_V ^ QeOr ^OK. "TA^TvOuJa-tr,PU- Ucrt Tyhl CCu!?T tf&rto V£> \v«_ iw^y^t .^VxvoK. Ac-uilVi Oartte- u^Tk uoto-^a A-T&JVa- fc£. ^^SQr- * <^^ ^^_ majy ^ ^ A ^r

^vr:iTi;^Tr"TKi+ T^ ^ ^ *^ _ ^ bKdXbr Yub Pbo. \juQs- :mbiubXrX \M^JjXgXX EROOr- XT ibTWl APfeAViXSTb CovuiiHbxl Xk^A- rxXcXill XXTki.XXX iXOiLiMXT \u^&m<Xr/ r^xciwL. j b^A XT Xb> jvot A/lbb^ A\ 0YXu^_ XX A^XX^ ^oec, rvDA Mest X^ 1XXXX bbbCT "^ ^ X Xb X ™^*™ A.1^ fee -0, A**, ^ aohat Arte**. ^ P\fllJl ^ x^vu^b^Lo,,,^^ ailtk KrYTiLn&L tX-tMJT, £jV TKl__ OfeaiL. U&r*L£_ jV^,^ y n)

(V •kxcAmrr FAXb X> AitX^_.~rbXLX ArXUbtX )X\iXXra>^ bPvrX.- UMk Dr AcAX Iki GbXi>iuhX uifTK. Ai XAmU AX^L, OX—- xX-O^W AXi,AXXX KlAes b3 AAlbJ^AA 0^^/A.b/T^bX' Meuer -^Hb^b^TX. XX0,brbA DbTHb. DlsTXTOOUtX (bXAX TWb Xb\k f\KXbHu5T ALXb fVcbdiibZI XcXX iO OrThSL- XekX XXxXgA , RXbiX AXM- A, ^UtdXiT X> b WiX NJOfidb.

Yx^oal/XWu l£ XbHX\x)vb.^c CXb c^Tti AcaaFilX AAiiXTX_ XX^bGLu\^_XlkrAX^ nk.KlflAciL.to XutAXnX buVhafiJT Ci NaT/ XxL X\Xb_ A£> EXAXlTX- ^YbXXrTo iVHiCi/WeTTk 6XX. bvxx&yjbi^ AuLf^Pto. A- f(XfX- ^efe*jse_ -to X t>^_X Ffrsnrf m tX^X ^41 XXX ta \^b 3'X2. Llt^Uu^ftfPWTl) OtoW i^xdeXLi SeaueX vb n^ f\2&u\<&TlL kkJn>b Kutt XVVE FK>vX\X VAc£_ Of TX XXVlicv- ^^XKlTT. ^L ) fo'?Muh \i XTA1X Tbl -SwXiXl9 LTbLIXrv.rW> I989) •ft-

XT xb ~X_.AfXllfXTb Co^TJ2XT(bxi AX^A A bv^XTtXBeKbn Ot tisi^^vv \Ki iDfl^A^rutL CXAniMAb Aznuflf As, fMi*XL n\ AiTTicX^AiXX—^:X^ (XmAL X X lb LX AcTOr KusT X4X- lXXAy^. uiOK_ . pAKuaPAX u>HK bf AcT 21} CO^urSm^ bX Av Xb>£_ Ahvi&_ djuer F^scX aX -Akaf bie^&JT ls NiecfisbX XX WXii^XsLX :iX T\x SAbxe^ t^^kct-^JC ^ ^4e\iJX^Xr HIX x ^ 4&\ Xle*w t ^ 4-k Xx cb.uCTXi'xTb Y^XXMtClXA O? OfXfWll^L COvvKioAL ACXjfT/ bk^ RuX tt>r\nrt_V a- (XbXiML, XxjHk AA Ui^ Xhv*L £rB^- j%^X&. •X B^^x^ h s4Cbx XA XX4HH TX. x^zn XaA X XubT X tbb&kjai_ c£. aA A^ho/h^T X ?Arr\umJTb i£> AcV ib^TUv-

(l o; XA \<b TXb. rWd\A>SX (Xrn^Xyi AXX XXTPuAL MDfbtfzi $ tAX (XbfX XX ;Xe5Xnb^ /^iSiX^ lX XumiX ^w^Xe^-b^ XX_Td;\XXi 6^ TH_ X^v^TM&ib Tjo X^eblbX L^fxX Xu>

Xvx APMVftST XXa- ' 6bunx~ix ~Xcl voXak^TX Qefenk. ibXx- f^^bbT • \KiK\av. KbA bXT X \ t i X A\\b^L_ (X E^fXiAAL hle^XT 0fnWL_Offo£>fc_ Df BbX^-u^-. ia 0fi_2> Akvl&L CbTUMj/JiL AcTioX XiT FALXX^, bibXkOX^bibTX XAKL Dbm.cb. CbXT AXTX_ A\XaX e£ Xi_xb. (XibbL Mb^r XbX X K)TOA "X bXXk.. brX X^ Jl^ £ icA h&TC Xx AfXvx,rr bvtw aXa Xb( b\uXx_ ix^- cDb^liw^A- cW,^v-.

XX SCxX. X AXl_. /VP-MXbT^ V\L>-e, , MLvovTA Or UiiTK AJTlX XbX. XbXXT LX AaXnX OF XL fo&aL XXX X) (bXX<T bX XilWi\5(" Of X^ X^jb1^ cLX AX 'vjJ&mMT, LXTter rA UuQv fbx-^X.

Oib TVokX_ CbAi^ AX AtX iX A-Xi^/ X XbfeciXXi^: XX. iXXuii X^b_ is rv V\ux PvLXixni' AXv TX iXrrV X\en^ \)bXX \W_ W bms^eL AlX Ak_ OX XklX^X^ TauLb^bLX^ Wx X^XeAbT- "X. A?Mlxrr b'HVsb Abbb Xb AAXitob/ Of XbcbPvecO^A feoX- aX_ X^rf- iiAeSxecriv^A^^AX^^ c^ (Xi^^X xmV^aX VXYOXbL ~Xb LLkxWuA n x kXrrTTwi, XvX_ Ox TX JbXX^obX XXrvo -to nv^_ wbivcxx \bbcv fXbai:K_~TU>b- £ie.rv^b^^ \X>X \kXYX WXilXTX V^ML. X-evJL. Xbb bmb EUXWajL- lib TX_.(XblL X-O.A KOb OkAA Wbb XHr- LxXl AA TfA_ KOHt, Wr CX40lXV[ X^o^juoX OAXw LUX b£^X XX\_ Over tbiXY i^esb AL Vb>b Xe^X AXTX.X, ukvXTHL

XX Lb XX AfXVVixbTv Lbk5Tbbrb{X XbX \\l\L Kib> iXXxuof Q\ (\xO(lX AXXXXl Tb^ ^hl -XtbTX-^ (\b jb (V hXi. ftoXuTY -XX Tte- AfftbXbr uod^j^T Kj^tbXbbX APlea ($ LTlhTYAX PL \r\i^K PbXX/ Xb^ X^fWXIxT XxXl X^. i^,AIbXOfb ATTLQLb"/ X?b AX X. Xbv rXXXX XbXTX.

Obi" GDi^ ,5 Ki^ TXbb bubOX XAul XkX XXXT IT te T\X /VMlCOTb ODiOsX^TiM Xb> A Y\v& AWm^;/ cX XXibX*?A •XX A<X*X Vwi-v b£ XX (Xlkj*h_ O5^ ftioiiKhe-TC rX^ \\- X o£ "^XXXXkcCuPA Li.ul_.£V S-b. Aa^_ ib u<la_ \-r 3X fxTX XXXXbl Of fXotX bbAAXA XXb Xb DvBlX AX_. MPluaT Xble^v XbTXAXXX fifaA PA/AX AXXXa- ?XlXX T'Xi XKl APXiXrr bb^ NXb X^.rCio^c hxx BXsr Ab OXj PltX AiX/OrX X k>esX unib^ a-U Aobl.TY 6ei/4lXXbka Or XxXnijh!^ bioxe^b) X XA lb Xix_ /AfPXbbX OboAIXTibA Xl\+ XbAXX/XxX cX bXA iAaaDnX ^OXloX hX DIuaI iD-X/XXfT X^vt/^ 72>b X^ X uXL K^L VsnjDVM^ AXOA h&£bL&fc_ XX blbAbXAXtX AX^bXAX. fVMXT ibo 3& Pos^X bx-lobS b-0ux bD ibfc o^ iXb! obXNXXX XXx tnl.x^uX-/a a^b Xkjl Pelob^/ vufT\ LA XrXH^r Xb^ X ^-^M^v ^^u\Wfr mxxkX^*TX 4bb xb U>£>.104 5x aosa-Cw®t) KX vbSXxz X b€fcte--\V(a 5U2JL 46 (XX Obm^P if66) "IX AbtO^Ablb b^lX L\AjS\ P^dRkOj*&_ ^IXXXkLxX^ OuA CCHL X Tthl_ IX ^ENfW<v- X ESbML AM %X \Xb CSXX'vr \A1V) T^CDubTXteL

xi cxirXK x XxyM^ 4>X \oix LbX c*rWiO Ite^Xxir

(X IX feeil X X ^QfL^iA XbAXibX \bloO XLXb\XXT] j fiMlk TXXf ben b^oX ^oa, XTbA CiivK.fsflP Vita) fttXfuhbi xxiX nbb^£bfiv^_ ^bfAvX*Lblb lidNueaTtaafe. Ax MXbX ^Feus&s Amixl&IX.- XXV |WX \XL( bbL> bx^'bA% CT&bCiW^ i'^b3 ^Oul&X XalVo .AX^toXvX \ute*_ f$uXO NOV COkSLYlX totf\Jej&^T , dX/Xl (\eaa»a fK^^TEK %1\vOX^ot CoutocfcVM iM^PeXoJT aimix X X ^^ ^ Wsae»_ive_ a>ar kaHi^W aw** ca^ Vo (.0,..!. l... X '^mjei£w *<* * w /asswi. Fwo^.it

XT \5TUl- WellvMTb COKiTedTiOKi ik» TtoLts AWei YWIiMl. i^pkxS- f^TLe_fteMiX_Tniai_

SKvtji Ui-lh., Uiijr\ULt_tki LiDli^DraTcOi Uiilh. (Or jwC£w3*t7Ws TX3 "w,u- ^T^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ Aft ~rle_ WPei\ch5T *UeA»e& -tta-t A-tTk. cicse. of Tk, /^iJTfe.ai, fcuu^TteJ^H: f jeusocaT Sto<ML Of-TK^i^Ack.'lituiLTte.&t,^ iiSJO^uL As-TKis, us vxiVfci ~tte, £>**_• uxct Wi. aJt /&\te^ W*~Tvfc*or.P^ ^T^ Rudttti. ^ ,+ Vo*, KDt- tf&ei kjo 7XIX* ^ >^ ^ Caa*C1^ UaUv-TUO Or- «*_ XkL ^TVe*^ ut_ s^\e TteA feeing ^k* rt- Vol fa, I^L^ 3U T\^ PmOo^ ot -^ ^^^ ^ flea_ ProCflaiW ^^ _CA.\mkA(_ fc<rtwm Tk>+ tvoj M^ toirtxtr to Tk^ Plea. ^te-A^iV

^^TXA X^X^H_rn3K_^T^1^L 'Vx-r iu_ uurvW 0^ xim%-1£^-akx> bfb ^fWeiUbn fci**W«* TAX- fX^Ttoi^D( *xaw A ^uQ^icjr,,^ lAJ F'XlXik£- V4bb_ AMidori eK-^eencA ^,^-u^ * feoj i<w,^t^

A.

Li I bMili UStfL Or P DXeX) l^^lC^sU^ XKlfor hrtTcX XTX10 'XX BO LTAbtAb 0£ ^XfvrXt^ bl^xorVxAToX K05 co^HAXi bki OX^ft^ruX ciXf\X^xbVo \AcTuqX( <Aob& TfTfAu^ufenlY b%L lV JPcfefc5b xA^XTXaX^ iXforHCbTX A£> &5 cubed, ib C?\XTY• -CK-ft TivST &>&&, rXtbMX ~WQ& fQ^AfXX^xOX TX-Dl Xo/XXlX . Tlx A'ttD^r fif /^CvX U)n^bST%~ Aib £j^\PI^Tiol\ (kx£S KOV MIX HeOr XWlXXTROF CCusP- IvffXi ToLXxiLXTKiMb fX^rvbX A^rTV^iiB^ AObOiX tftftcf X_X AlXA^Xck) TlXb^jXAKbT /Vt Th&bX AfuXb)L \llVL\NxX_ X xVo\ XtxXiXVb^ 0^^cT(X5T/l(iX(W- AkX x'Kbi XX btoXb XXfrXXX To toxx xf i$> xet\ e^b^^ct^ AitoToO'^x LaXX kb UxA^O ttoAOX 1 (X Ctoi<H- OrTfX ftU/AXXF PO'^XKlXuT fXbXt bx MriMbLb b^TSX ix\ctMXTci3 IXOfTTbl bXa3Gx coxjp10NL_ COuXT ^XilXxj MXi^lL

-^ XXX LXLXX^cAXfXsSb TX Xk fWXr^JTf^X Xeba,, X fcusi Xc^ \SW^ AdXr^ Mil Cok^IAm&L ikI f\ X^ XYbf HA-'-- '^aTX ubCiX CokaS-T Aw^ S. " ^-bM ^X ^ ^ XR TX six fXA^rr bum^v^xx, A b(\,n,oaL_ X^e^^jr LuiLW-IAveb ouW Du bX^ A'\\b^_b ,0 bbtX XiVi ,i_Xvc4f^T. ui'Vwck. LL^jKi MOt X h£X<buiX Dfb AJte-tub -tb^X ':X X^XtX/ ObXA XmCT /i^oAkX b -X lXlJXM bAgX-bbb Su^bd XtO- \| AfUfcOL OCOXfc vNWfci-ewLr- b^eMLfe A XbCrePAkCi ViLTXi tk AbwfiAX bb "Kit jiXvbr^rr XbA X XX o?W AT Tfho l_

Xs > nbb- /WXXx i fXhiXb' \A\b lTGju>DbX XiTo fX\il£.ubTNL- TbLi^T^rA \be/b)v3'^. Al AX X\\A/ iuhlmAul. Xa^ VXX-?l_ ~TX bXX PQsXA TkbtiAX f\D bO\^/Lj__ OVAcsr Of. Am/ IOm^P \rac7* .1^ fXXXbA A XXX. C<oiW^jPXAA„ b)b f\X&£.cXX ^. rb(X LAMbO^- bX Dfii^rux (UPohikq^'AcTTinjiT/ Ttet. hun •ta_ e\U&*iL itf X) AXvs^m^ X PrAbKamx to Act TOXtW- ub A XXX - aov Xtff>*_ of ciZfK.-KAb Xtxa Oux_ A^clikX AX rWttiXT XurbTb x TX SAbXs mK+MUJT uXX ^ AX^, AXh-XX f^mi/XT OKI hA^lA hot AX Lb iW -Of ^X ^-L^JAX/TXPAfX.rcfA^ b)AaXt^^XX. .^ lo - XftL^urr MANX x^ Ahl 5-Xe, i^Xwt: ^ ---^- vb "^ ^^vlxlfb XXliuTTibA XbH AX, COvjtlT Abu^A AX **bc**M X*b a iXX Xl ftfXXX bXlb tf tM^t^ yA on^ vi

^ ^ ' ^ AcTmT/ ^^o,X^m^b^bO GAX-W ' lt\UX,ld_ AD XX tASecAj Xi:^Xbfc .liXrTHLfr vb,UXTj AX^'sacA,

Xv^ OF TX ft&xXT(lXX k£> EXto4X_vXX A^AXlXl^ ^1^W:XX^ ux*- M^ Tve SA^K* <*>«L T^ ^WT Ac^*^ ^ ^ fc*. VhlW.^ "TMl 0i4If ^tCfe&_ iT <£a*jL uA^^ hA\.»*_i^R*^**J7

Aii. v^£^T^aiiTm^T^-lie5eo>^<rr ooAiTr.

XT is ~TVL. MMt&iTv- UfcTMTioA to bt&Pi+e, his^5>K^ "TVub BM^^S- OXiLkOT be.u^_ a^ ftDw* c* M eOi*&ci- ox TXfe Bfx^LX, JLXdXoX Tf^XuiT kx fo^XX AXcX TWb ank^xXX^iA XX~X> TX XXm?t- ^ OlXX M>jillX1XX XXX^LJXbJpJ^aAfX A: CO^Pveorr, XiTkXStbXXTlrbSm PxkxX TVOATX rWelXXT XX ^ h£ rX^D.X AadXTXo X IbX X^TKIA ab X<kXXA*-- 3^bX^xJ x\\ieX (XoXV? /H#Xt TX ATVtfX W^^Ai^X^ev jaXXK^T Nieuer- AlitXxXTKX AmiW rXl£X , •pfeuaAYteL uCW* ^ N&L^ Ca$3«n^ fXTtuW XbiP ^ Xvx^ /X ^a^^- x EM v^OLb is LtaLMVi bbPtxcA^ir a^l^lte. Aax kx A4tvmAr- V\l Xli Pftovtkl QAduiDf Tte 'Ba&fiiAL BbKuJTb Of TKl 0&lj^ lXl01lX\1 ^^LTb^Su^XfctB A0£LAX\f ^OXb ^b£> bXbcb <&=£ AuXTlX b&Aes CO^fAXbHOiT ^F TV&bL A WttefiQL. \fAXifMb bbW TXa^XcAMT AteOToA AXtX PteAx offAXX ftATr?,ab I>A XoWiiBLX \i bX^e_ Mo SuibXMb AWtifwoL. Oaiabs UikiiJ^L Aoob-^. Pf^ at T^au . „. joj ^vLv/to_. bxLATX TX MX_ Xa^ XpfaiX£b TNL tokXbl X\T/ 0^ AlTukl-. Xl "h/fc fAQ\*b iXs bdAnv^vbX :M a KANl^er 4kw X¥\.i£s hOM^TX AlleyFTuk] lX~\te_ G-LX:,%-ik&~ Ji^iit^^^n XA H_Li±x M SAXa_ A \\ Sx^sX Abb \i/KiAjxa_ XX«ib A\l^CTTiOM^ AX fOiil>T_. X IXXlAn^JT Aab f^S MAY ftiXir £\ii&uxiL ^iSoXcuLT

n) X\X\\A PO\AT OYtftor XT iSTNb APM\fMT bOXTabTibrA AXT hi \b QXTTXXX TrXXSXAXb_ A^iSTDlmSL Ox XlXi^Xl TxXkA Af/Xl TKl_ AffXXX bXvxfe AXx HXi PCXiKFibX a cbxr/VffbbxtX- AHXX TbAX^XpeX fAxbTXr AiXtX XbntV^ATW lXAXT/ dXX iXfXxXbxb (Xbitb ,llu XVcll AX X co^Xfe AXk- ^^ dl I ?KAxeb XAbb Xk TnaL A.b 6eA%c,_. fXcoX^ tXiT^/ YX**_ ttK&t^ X^eAX/ /X XXL X LXX Ryb NO L^KDW- "\X fAXXXXA\fb!K*0 \MXTOA AX fA^ AA AjXoX fXX LXXb^Aj CMvFob^iA tXb AAAAlXXA , iSl bX )Wj ISLtcL a^- ^ L vqx0 "\X C&XTb Xb Xb :uo XXjOX A bOXCT OXXbX- AXb Xb X, A^l XX AX iXXXXX TXAl^ ca***j ^ k^ Ah,. IXl (Xb^ATh^/,X^3^GX. j^1-^ ^M^ AxxXmtux IXX7i,,. AX X,ufm/bXa,Ka.Y ~\Ul. WfbiTui AMI^tt ftito»yif LaitiukAAiter Kld^d^TCu,

^\mcK£ my^ ^(s£i4<^ ^ 6i( CTec^^ wp j<HQ TV*. MfeWj^rr Va^ ^ ?rtk^V w, ob ?R3- %«_ Mm (Yd &•

AvGklP_i Pfo&M>i_ W«C~ XKi eSfeTfcfL ^.sT^^tf OuJxU :iU £Mili> vi LuCtf 4bS ud ^Ki ,iOb bc-t *iO ei?tO AfPeM V)ku TKl 5bX*_ foah&b /, f^TAffci/bPMl^ (;*) f\b\\X .

Tkb AfPellfXT SxibX A^ 'XXifA XbATKib iX)»AXbX bOXT bb "nXXAfAb'ueX ibbxiiv- AoX TTvjR^oiaoki X a^XXuo XX.h__ Vve^Xu^l_Ak-SXX> :\Xvrtf%jT trXXcATo A'XcXl Aki o^%*M_ XX AffX\jXbF bi^Lv /b (XfftA TXAXb V^uDObib COLXTlxXCb fW/b£- ' \Ab XkX\i,eAf^ for aiXXcibT EXhXxll_ /\Xb iXX AXA TX APXi'XX CXi NOV X (XWJi C'^ib OCubX XAX.X/. ~rk Wm^ct seek ^ ^ imiahta_ ^ ^ fiol£_^4 Tw '2XXA '*^^to^L tt^MMor( POjj^. ac p^^^ry •***** tor (X '«x^ dam. fewy.7 A^t OfuW- Ik. WtilATT

Mai A^ \iOi^.

XMAuboX (XXrlXxx cX^ V*_ Xa^bX AX AXWrX AXxxl X iib^x bbru'i'X&X

X I. QfcM_rlj^jEfc mitalA'/ irta-OMOer (MTKTWt ATrue. A±co,m *Pito

i)u>_h^ Wi MJ.UlX. -t*Mti. C»\TU>. ^ fitat (Sa«_T2J ^k SfvCTK.

IUJ^ ^ ^X^b X'l£y~ Ablov CO XP, ^ ^XbA^ KitkAEL XeX bhX r^ n - ^brbTVe^Ate_^ A?AW ^X 0bM/^ to (XjAAlkA? "TAX I&c^tXIox (A") LOP? bbs, KLAXX DXfiX X^/nl Ahob_ Xbtb X Tlb_ touZT OA Afteib TL^rTAD^uA 0<T<K* T-Ale. T^ X^ ,-J^^M^^j ±& AMX X^vk- 15^ 03—

/¥fettaiXT

XX

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.