302fS .. ORIGINAL M<=>. 08-\Z-Ci02)CiO-CJFL

COUfcT OF CWNTNlW- WEftlS iNus-ra;vsi -re.-x.AvS

COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS R^e^err c^vek MAR 23 2015

Abel Acosta, Clerk vs.

SY~»\TH C*-TE.*.AcS

On App^oA FVowN ^(ol^bxsTKLCT Osuggr t>a.rs^-€>y\ CouyyVy^nVx. c\^

^QSePCT CttftVEft^yre S«_ ^ILED IN -rbCJT-:Cb ^ \%3>C3e>o^ COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS G-ncAa.^ U<\\V 23'2015 t^SS Fr>\ -2.32S Abel Acosta, Clerk %\esVfr>g. j-^gxs, 75&Q3

ORM. A.RG-UrAHKjT REQUF-STEh ja^Aeva-fsrr^ oF_V>&j^:x:es>_/M^_<^JUs^E:\^

KfiP^W^-»~RsA=g<V Cg.<-Nf^>^

fcfr*AW&s. C^^^NsgJL o.V~Tr>sA ^ FcS^sy *V~Trs&£^ loos Uor-Wx HImw £A- J^o^^_,r5a>to^J!T(oJ^jJL_

fex^frva-vj VXruV \-2>SS F ^ 3>~Z2% PoXesfore. t"TV ~tS8^3L

^^o^V'^»--StWr«^_<^Zr<a-\«^5 ^^d^e>jJSj^pg,rT Brv^^^|QrX^F_ttr\l^_ _Qfi._&»p£££l.

CWkcW^ Oc\p\sg>g\_ jS*^^J^r^y©_^2rtoc^33SL ^Sfr £. KVS&rvr^ ,-Tyr^ TV. ba-vsW ;T«Ok<*S. 1UX^ ^Q.tA^ ^Tviwas^ 1^2~<^\ -r*! ~ta\9>vf_ of c.QKv-pEiKrr<;

xbEKmTV o f pa&xxes KKkk cjpgKi^e\_ -o «»-

l^BS^^^F^C&MTE^^ttS . „ W.

XMb^ of Au"rv\ot^rrrxes •_ \\}

SrmHA\F_MT WEg^ft^TCWAfr C^PA- M>£AJL/*\F_KrT . _eJ\/J_

STACrE/AEtsTT OF -tvae: cfsse „ „ . „ .. V\

<rnftrg»VE.wrr OF ?fe,OC£NggA\, \flxs-re>fr?f , _. . VU

<5-ftciUi%sS Foe. fiEVX^W , ', , _^ ^ „ * _SlY\'\

AtR£rUr\eMT „ :

V. Co>-*<"V err p\pye£>\s> grCg-A t«\ •SUtyya-SrH'Va g3Vw"vSS^Qy\ O^ CLpc<-o\oorcSXlc>rv.

C& ^p2.o\s b^A<V^^^ • - - ~ - » • - - -^ - -* - . - f''

XnV\cA. C<sv>cV ^r-reA^vy-WvVxv'vov'rvo-VQ Q,rro^ov\ f^^WvsV ooAw^ c^^<^<sju>..^JiC i.

/:...i.,y SVJarAM^aV (5F TWF1 PQgLQAJJAglVO"r ^ - . „ - ~ .^b . . . Prt Appa.r\cV\)C . _. _«, %.'_ *. «»p*\5 •

',

-

_

T' .' i

-

~---"r -'H '• tu XK\b£l c^f AurWoaxTxes

CckS^S

CcxS-VrxyNedcx v. S^W.W, G=,g2. Saq.zA SB5 (rr^.o.N&. V^ZA) . .__ p,5_

Cru-z. v. S-\tA~g_, (o^O SvVjO). 2.A Z^o Ct^oc.Ct^A^ v^ES^ \ v „„_,_ . - pH -VWrror\ v. SV>Xg-> Sip S-l^.l^ W*-\ QrmXrwN. ftrfft>. 2-gft^ ^ , „ „ __. rx~2- Har\<3_5l V. S-Vo^, I^5 S,U).\(3i 2-~l<\ 6r<oc. A?fr~Fac\ bOoc\^,-2.00^ . . „ - . . . ^2. ryVqr\OTL v. S-W\^„ SS3 S.v^.2_A5SS6r'ocCr.fttffi\^3s) - , . „ , , „ „ _ . , p3 «So>iAV\(^eLC\s. v. SV^Ae^ RM S>^.X<J> (c^CT^Cr.^.m^ , , , - _ . . p3 \ oc^\or \f. S~VcA^_> SA-^3^ -?3Z.t-72l ft^ft^-\W*^fr^s£\ lyv^., - .- «. I p'2- b^oMjLir v. S-W\<^s fcuWs

Tgj(,.fcUcp •^xW $re£. Gav^X - RmW wssO^>_, „ : . ._ _«,__j?,_\2>_ T'm,-.^.^. fiaoNft-S frr^-CjaryV CUW V^OVoC.c^ - ._ . . , „ -__^A2l X<o<. »^Wg- fivxW ft^£. CsrA &x\tt. U^J^ . „ o -^ ; £u\3„ X<g_y.-\^\s>c$>> P.vj\'^&. ^V^- CovA- O^W \AS CA\ _ . . _ . . &A3 •' • •

"T^x. RwXa. (^-^v 9roc_. cua* t „ ' ' . oA3>

•

. •

.

i :'

' ; ^ .-._,

' •' - v l^KfM^ x .'':^K.•',•/;?- ;•• V STPCTHME.MT WEfePdWPQter OfrAl, ftQRgAXrA^^X

XVfe. ftqppoAWrdr \osiVfre.\]<a^ -WnoA- ocqA ovr^o^rvA^xfxV wyo^ a\& ~VVnr_

W^-CxOsS?^, *\pp»*WavX CJSAoXA <\X q£W~^ VCvr^X qvsNj \^>vT\.C^X~ «X.V <o^g>£ SAVRX<b\ w>-^<rnV\s. \oAgjc Vyg^o^. -W-qXctoA. GjsurX ^cn\jq_ A^^Wv^r qffi^tsreA Cjoqcos^A -

Ovrro^g^vvvaAr^r S^vv\y 4W^r ocftjre_ rvso^c- r^cWAvAaA oerW' W^cx^\u^<rQA Cjajiv^g-V . :

: srr^Fjv\F.Kn- qfxhe cjv^f:

Ml ilwi:.Xf:Jl/

_ _ _ _ _ SXKT^MFNJT OF?^OCtbURA__ HXSTOP.Y '

u On. "3cNV\u.ci_r-y 22, 2D\S , Coo.rV ©^ A^patAs Pc^-t r«v\e_^ 4Vv\_r CjscWUjV^oov. ,

z_ Or\ "Fe.\or«*c*.c>J 1 ,Zo\S, ft\a\s*sr^ -Po<- (^Vi__£tri tv* u^us-vAcA _

3. Or\ YWts.TC-L'v 'i.iOlS VTVisrV^v -?er R.«Wr> r>a v_J<_kS <_eim^_i »

• -

'

.

!•• --

, .- -_, •

^— ^ . p . > * - ! t. >'• /

M*\V G^ou.Nlr_iS fc^p. p__vx_w

xssu._ kj>o. \

_r__r

Z-Atrv. ev^.r-S> \^VsV oc_c_juic-oajc, ooW 4W. GenxcA-ofc Ap9<_As XcCv\.«5_jl A^> <_,<s>o_q _.<*•<-- 4W. \_>r^gj^s. OCSS^O-c-JcaA Q-VAA-vAVSS. \s3>iA._ , cxS oo=_.\\ QsS -AW C_p\y V-C-^^-^ (lg3a-\7_-OC)-seo-c_ft_..€)^v<arN> pH_>7 (x_T <x Q__^Ur; ta-ppoAWArAW\s ex pcega<~ WcsCtrr-v our—A-ySvS. O^^S ClsST" cjitans*... :

,^>- AippeAUvrsV g_A^__> <_,<a.N^jrxA CoorV tfr Q^<w-.vnoA ftsp^x*_<As; c_o>.s<_ >

XSSU_ MO. 2L : : \."Xr-vcA. Cg-ivc-'V <_rpgj[ WfcuA^ A^a a<rr-ciVy\ ftt^pe.lWvCT~ ery-Kora c\v>.o<-iqS> •

2-- b>ees Ptpp-ile-Ay \nc\>J^_. ex r-T^W -\^> Cs>va<>&—\. Au.<-"> w* ex. c.o>AnS_0 sW<j_ _F Ua 4r^\ ? . : 3. A.ppa.\Wy>Ax S"\X;AAv ft*r<^ajA<VN-ijs\r A^5> AW OnsWA <SfaW CteV^\<jA^€yy\f rtoV^" 4c> _sv>r4gJ| qqqR vfr&WAea,oorA-l\_r>y\ct o_TAk S-WW. arA Fa__ar-\ 1___»ajO ^ -;i _v(—j—s t./

f" -'''I'V'-;

V w I AR-U/A-.MT

XSSU_, VAO, \

CQvJ.gr OF kPEEAVS XPJ^FbXK- SaC^E_5Tx_»\_- QrAXi__SXoM ocr cx>P^_-g>-^KTXC_^

•__Ufy\mp.Ry OF -TV\_. K^5-UfVV_MX '

„ME_M ~TVH_gX XS UC. C-VAie\K__- THPCT A. -TOtg-V C_Q _l_h» V\l\\/€: APPLX _K TVt-l LAV OF PS£XJC.<A?LX__. \aJXTKJ___ _-f^RF_T__V, __S-TW— OMXSS_.Q»». OF S-CAA ft. |CJrtA<RCrE HftAA\\_S ? ' • A.ppqAVc*r\T cxcc^vj__ AWA~ AW. P^fp_AoA_. Gsu^cT A^A<^ Area CCOxeioO AW-V>r\'g_Vr cvSSoc_x:c_x^a oj\AAn AW. c.Ov&a_ \r\vQ\vvv\a -\Vva_ ojcjcj&^v^>\>^&_. o>>TYNg_St- oc AW. ^"^\>Vf W>sar o\s^ o_S_o_\<aA-q ooT^n AW ocg_o<vvp\vc^_ „\Vxva_ss V^A^usA^Qt-v,. Cs<ag_j os-\Z.-o«-30^-c-g- j OpxrT. or., p.H\ ~TW QavAc\ c£ rVypqp_\<s $A«Ws 4W.V App>\WsV W—A\\C<e<. cxp^-ftS, XK\<; \s \<Nsjpccec__r- P^WaXVy AW. F^y^WAr -PWcV AW^a. ooQ^irvpA K^^WnA^^sury \_vrv<_As,? ex S-.po.ccore_ _.v_A^><" '^jaxjn- g__ _, u>^AV\ QrQUtvxQ.vsVs Spg-cIA*\_Ao AW?r c.o_> _ °itA o. W»v\.<_o>_tP'\\fcfey\ re^S _r>sg_y Nvf\ ^cxO\ <__c\S _.t oA\ oF \_c_rvK_y>> ooQ.og_.Vn<_1 __r\_Wr*^.J___^

arsA2js/±z) ; i XKg- CoixcV _t- k\^y_A.<s _\\_S Arv»X>' Q.Q-RS Vr\ AVv^XC Ofri<\tOr\ \(\ ___&__________ ynsVruorVoA poos c^^Wl. Xn. ^-rroAj -H^sc g><v\v_.s\o>r\_ vj^cxS WxorrA'*•££_ _-3e_^__i-_—_A__^__*o__ C~x) VVa-<"Cov\ _ cAoAWs. A-^v-xv>A o_r AV>^ cA»r^g_ scls-AS-) (S) S-WWvx pC-^qjW Acag-fA m.V\\S y>o_ss,^-SSX^VN >CAj.AW tH>vxC<Wc vx__^p«-V\ Wv-v*vqV\Vv\S p _SS,;e--C\-.r\vJ oof\x_) C53 VA^.rror\'s ^rv^erpcVrAs Wv-v^ or\ S-.V5.rcA ^vWyv\s »-o\\^v-v -^Wl- \Ac_Vvrr\-_ A_coip£_. XWi_ 00o_ uxo \y_csv_\<^-\v_ e-N^>\.c-,Y\cxA^g3VN Aer NA^.c-rooLs cA«c^r>s_> o_oA A^v\g^cp<-\^\s csV AW, ss-RiPvg-j or -W-VCvS, pg_s__gL_s.\c>Y\ gjy sWWv p—^psa.cAs oyA AW creoiCcWc xj^^cx^xn. Fer AWj&<^V<-XS<scnS_ ^W_.«^.rror v-sSOsS V\gKy-rr\g__5. \W-c<mv

Wlvvct cjarr\<Y\vA\:<g.c\.XVsa__r sA<__Vory<urNtS c__rr frW>c<--\_A AW- cxc_^_mpV^^ \i^ror«__, An_M^^ocvNj-XVNSur<g_V^>-o_. j -AW. ow<\S.S\g><N c=F AA-si. c>4^___5£yv\o\,\Q^. \_oA\\ss-SS \k_A:- co^ASk-^n ooolS. V\c_.r\Y\WsS. X^v>s5Js v. -SVA<_, V^S sAaX_<\ ZH^ C^.P^r^t\vW^,_ aoo _>. : • . ~T«n~Vc-sj\^c- J4W_Air"xcA CovxcA- svjS<v?AWA cxr\ ^-rr«3Tv3.fe.vA5- c^.e.c_e<v>c>Vcs»_\jSw_g_ \r\sWxgAn e^-XKe Osu<~A-e£- P\$p*As c^y_._c\ AWA", ClVvV _A \\_t V&3c«v\ -\W- 2\VAry AWA~ VaS.^_-Kg-fc cwA G*-\Wc v>y_r<_. o*c_ci._vv\p\ScA. <-QvAwa__;^-S cvrA) C^OW-vA tvcAt V^W^—fr ~ArV\Q. \vav—O -NWA~ c\<L.o_.of>ryV\lc_«^_ v_o\\\rv«-__S,-S> c_.^™rvoT" Os—roWrA^. _vxc_W -4Wr-X_Y\r~ _.. <:-WA^_,Tr S-V-Q. _«3i T3^,^37 _^-X.A^9--H^v>sAo^QH^s^mc6 "TW Ce_.rV g»y A^_g\s \v\c_acr<a.cA\y clAes S^^-vrvcWcs WAWc -^r^\_<oS V-v-Kt-—n _,r>c^vj_-\_;. _\ Sc-vxrv-iC-r--., AV&_. ivmdsV Arvs_c\<vv\<\o^<f>^ ^_y\ cV^vnca. _p<cY><a- A-rOYv-N AV>q_ AgS^yyyotyj OT cm\ OcC.C-Q<v^V\ _5_-. Fo*vWc_. -\<a \\r_y_Cw\ ^W-^xCW %_\ .Sug-K A^s^w^vnvj rv_-As WV_? c_^cfc\.^c<aWA orvatees \Y p<^iV__--SW \^^^c_\. j_x_c_ W co\^vv\g_x e_vcar\ o^osajrY c^r\-o_-reswear. o_oS_\AWj \avnq cxatwX.^'os^, _S_sS_cjiAe-es_lv__cx_^^ IA?esV AW Cjax-xrV ix-g-S. WcWy ^ Acres rvg-\ op^Vy Irv AW-V vx__y >Wv <v.._____»___ _W_*j_-tV^s_kN_AW_ Kppo.VVcxYAr ^uqc^_sAs, AVv-A-AW_.<-rc-C WAY^l. \cvsrV-,'<sV catsj_ v>-.^_vc\ g^STvf^ AW. V-ororsQ VAwA crt _vc»—^g__ ; W v-Qc»- avsficv-, rv.O c_W>>rcj5_. cA oA.- Cs^a., ro^Ay _<n W<~ R^Wjc^Voa ^"--v- Xjf AW\vAC>y W-A \_>^s-.<n cJr_>cc»ftA gycxAW. \cisvx> o£ o^c&cr>pWft-. g_, ex ctvSaWc cfc A^—V oo^A AW^y cxfr^W AW, WvS c^yc^grW AWy v-s-A\ r^.cxcA\AW. c\qNrAr ygSv-xW^ Ss_ \of\cx c»_ AAv^o, v>x>_ SvA.WvcA^.rvA~ c^rraWc-Aifv* -N/XcW_r\!__-. —i*V t"VF AW.c-_ \s> <>«a Oo_->—^_ cAr oA e»r\AVsS-.

Wv_0 <sF CV.C1_-_^vvnC>\aC-^. 1»mVtV- .*_<-_. }AWf _ \s» WS£_> C>s&JCvC_«_. AWAr~AW>J; VVsl.

Ao^y cubvAA V_x>jta. o_p9V^A AW_ Woo cj&c-r«----V\.N.

X^AW-YvnsWvAt c&>S.-j cxsacW £c<s-v\ AVo_A<a-sA\<yv-*rw cfr AW. <-w^osrv^Wo-. v>^vAv__s jAAvz. SA<*W pr<^_S>_rsWA A^-sAr^nrNowy AWro exA7_e^j\s_X _ s_ -AxsA-j rftT\<_. pfe>V\c,-_ c^rv _5JT_. j nsu^r\-_r xjcW VwrA Q-s-C-C ____; AW_ sA-r^sCT cvTscV ex <NsaA^r\_eC VX-W> VvV __ Wr\\<ssV o-pp-vWs^-. Wy_,y_. ^ypttAWrvA p<~-S><a-As_A rssss _>AW-t otAW. e_>,_\VV /\>rvr\oc.^.>r\C-— pWa.s._ <ac~AW_ p_\x^V\<y_rA: pVva>s;_ or- AW.AtncA.> M>y>sa. oSAncssx-s. Az-sArfiqA WAr o>rAyA^-vac oo<^<—t_ pr^S*_/A~ cArW,S^<£>\c_ c_r_ ~I_.rv? t_,2.g>VS; uoV-*.Vv App5].\_cA vjOc_5. cirr-sWA orvAA^ 9^S__.eS>S^Syf\ cW^- QnVy Avoo c_cV csA AW_A^x\<~ offi-^.rS- ooNvo i_Ky_c_ pre__i&.rA~ <A-AV>a__s,c_ftJ<rN5_ c_._\t_ ^cWfiV&y AW r\^yp_vWfcvvr\ __.cA-- V-WvAWc VV^qV^NooC CL.c_>>a\A \iW\VJw AW. A^^yeLXWvAr \w C-uxAr. Cs__.^ WX^A-Xtovy AW Q^WjxcV-x y£_C-)> /^pdWrA- o_-S munc_ v. S-¥<Ae_.r 8S3 s.-,.__.«- S52<_T^.Cc.A*paV__yfrt. o>r«5V-V_ AAnccA- o^ c,«a>v\.\/.c A;\ e^ C--Q.y\cjt _<_ Nf\sA vaS^-r^ AW_,A*_A-yrrvoy^ cjr cvr\ Q-.c-.cmNp^cJ- _rA-.v. c_j_)ero\--e>\'cxWc\ \__y c^W,r •_>.va_:_» Ar^rvAvCM^Wc_e>rofej5_\r AW. P\ppcjA\cxy>cV vxa*\W AW. C-^A^rvSi_ C_C»nrVYy\\AW-t <xr\A AW_ C-Srre-^peaCcA^orv S\S rvg_V c;o\7^\eve.rvV "_£ \V rwe-C-^Xy <_V\<-»V->.5> ~AW C-_mm\-SXof\ oF AW oA^Wl\se- - Xr\ rV\o>x\c-zi, cxS^cN^. A"Wyvx AW AttsA"\ ctn&vsnj c£ AF_ cxceg»rrv^\\t__ ^vWe&S-ijAW <yA_W pr->_g-,:riAr—q A<a^V\rfNotvo AW<v\ AV_ yw^AXoa\ __e_.crv\<va.r}\*tx\ ^e\^-L (,^-g.r^p AV>sg, sAot^. rr\cxv___.c_.e^ cxrA ^vvsAWr Sew-S* c_WrV_ A-cc*~n -AA>q_ sWp^. . CY\v\t\o_ pPaseax-vV-cN v%*> _s/\ eVa.t>c_ oAt AW_ <WAA /WYvo<L.Q.\rvc_S-- pVya>S.R_ <-A~ AW-~W>eA.«• XW. «-.VcW.Y\cja_ c_<arr'gaV)<!_r-_A->-S AW-A^SMv^y-roy oV AW. c_JEj^YYvpVicj?-. vj^Arvass \_x\V A\c\ r\C_V oarvfyj^.—T rf\vAy\c_,_. W AW e^_Vv-vcrAs_S_'\ csr\ <sA AW <AW*\S!_.. C*As\cW AV^. Are-sA^—vowy c-¥ AW. cvc_s^or<'\p'\\c_s»_ ooA—uass ; AWc<gX- >fvo gys Wrvo-_. rfNutva _ y>_e_£_ xv_a><-AW- 5_'^w-<\-_ oA-AWl C—~\c*v_ exr\A vr\ca _>i\cV^nc,c_Sr\<*. \jocxS_V\ pa_-,-_<-s.s\g-Y\ o£ sWWr\ orc>p=a.rAry .XW. ^vj\cWr\c_,q. v»oexs_ \<ns\j^\C\_r\V W <_i^<-Cg^c_\'TA?_ AVsa_A^-_AAvvs^vvy <sA- AW. <-v.c_C-Ssrf\p\^C^. v_oAwa-SS..

Xv\ Ccva- v. SVskg_t t.^ SAxV-ZA, ZAtoC^^.c^.ft^.n^^AW. SVA^_ pr_- S-M^jj ng>xv-cxc_--c_>cv\pV\ _t_ ArsAcv*^^^ pc _\j v<v\ W*. vx-toS> rsa5-x~ AW- sg-j*r\5*, _r AW cr\<v>sa- «oo\\An ex p\S>Ar<A cx<xe_, oVs._ s^w\aA\<Y\s>_ pr\c_r W AW.A^<yv^. AW_ Cora^WvYA:«a>rcV i>ocx_ _,WA. Cc\>._., V<\s vx-vW 0.0A cxc-.c__<vv^\\cc^, c^\_o^ _cj,c<_A -AWev\ AW- cxc<*jOt C3CV Qppc-QYA<v>.cA_\y AW- S^orrva. AAttvS^ C_j&YY\\pW\<ArcxfvV vjc*_ SWV. K ^y^V W.Vavv^'rssx W AW. c^s>prvc\\^<>N\c^<<t vx^sS A%aUiC\A ^<x C-rxx, _'s •yAvNcA- o.v>A W^. uoo_. cxcresWA W CL-\\\orcvXex-.XW. rv^\ri-c*.c_.euamp\^5*- A^sAXcry^x^ c_uc\ xvA: A^_y\A A?_ oar\<N__: Ceo, __ W AW- cAAVv\^ N_^c^c_.\JiSg.

AAr>». ^.v\omf\\\ft. orOw ^^cr->\6^re,cr,g_A ^>sVcxxv\^-c>o_. x^o^W-srs, exfA Afty^.

S>AoW- x^s_>j«—c qc _xt**A AW. s^\^XNm_B_.<\Rj^- crt AWl. yrV, .

X__\ \x^\Y_c m. S.W) VAS S>.V>o.-^ ~?2_- (X-ii-C-t_l\*ft.. X^V&V^ . & poWsfc.- w>c-y\ xoOQS. rv>s_vceWr^A .~XVnS£_A/_sA\>rf\g>Y>.y cjc c_^e^_s>rr\^\Qi- oc_sj<gA Wl. cvfA OOexXVLer vx**_—=*. V<_g_V^<\ci Wc~ <^v_,v\s A_ sN^jxV pry AW-^»_\\v>-^ <3*r AWcAA^as,.

XW peft\<__*. —^.e-e>\>«ar<aA -Avoo ._2_. c_.<a\VW<" r\Ar\<_. -Acw'n AW_ \c_W_ »V>^c>.v^e.r._ A\rv.^( |ar»yAs oo^-C-. r^ctgayg.c<a__t AWrrvAW. 9\___,v_vp vx-Wx^. AW. r\^\aS. ujftt. sWS^^ta- _x.p_rV W_A\wv-<Ny A<^W. At. pos\AA\)a\y ^cNq_Ar\Ay AWr^-g>\7-reA r\A\ _ cx&AW tnrvucAsLr v_oeaj-xPt>Y\. XV>s^ —sAcNe-vvc._. OJQ& ^r^uAxx_\--\*A A- c^^c-eo-^rc-WAA>RL A^_aA\o»>owy <sr AVsa. cs.c.c_.orf\pt\c _ uoW5_.> = \ -' .-'•'•< ^ •. -