Bonner, Don Anthony
Bonner, Don Anthony
Opinion
.. '?Oik\D~~- This.document.contains some
:~ • - ~---- pages ~hat are of poor quality at-the time of imaging. ~-------·-- · .£~~--~Do_M__/IM_-/b_QIY.¥--/1C¥YA.L&.. . --------~~---,--'~~----'---~~- · llt-/!.__,.1 z· ,:) a>_y_.-_ __ ----~__.-r~CL~A!:o_._Lfll"f_6J._7 c.,_ r:__ ~_//~/lt~_L:____·--~------------· _ _ _ _ __c____l3_tlo_Em_6_-.r_s:______ _ _ __ _K.o_s_~G:4--o~~-lii_~tf:.t fz_~s-fl,S_ _ RECEIVED IN ~----~ -------------------------.----;------cotJRi-oF-eRtMINAi--APPE~ 7D :__ /!h£_ (_~d_ce~l~/--c_f.£JL__~--- --, · · APR-1-4-2D-15 .· ... · ____C_eG.',[_,t:_~_f'!..~C.i;'M_;,u/'l/ . . ,, ·. _ _:____ __IJ,;pe_d-__t._s__ t!)_/!__ __f£Jf tkf- . . ·/1.a_~c.liax~t;;3_0__8_:_ ____-_.:______ ' ,.' ' < . \ ~ . C~_~__f_Clt._ ___ ~/l:-.LLo~_l/mt;/V k ~ ____ . . ?_eJ ?/L . . .. .
• ------ . . .o ______ -,-----~------'-------.--------.-'-------------------- · f£_:_wM.h_~_.()_ ?__fl1~~d-./h2:1~_.r_____~---_·____·-~_: ' '• ' --~u~c_l~~-A/o_,_lft_6_f:L8_lLO __· - - - - - - - - - - - - , - - - - - ------~--------·-~------ '
----~-------~--------------- -----·-:-··-----'------ '' ·~" ' • --~---- -----~--~-'-----..-'--------------------------------·------- . . -/ / /._ t..£.L j, c -. /A ~ • ./ G . ' --=W""-/!l.d_or~~J"J:2--~'7/i._ _C._ ---~---~-':/k;£_~-~-1!1:_ _ _(9"U&..L_o_r£__ _ _ _ __ - r__L<i2..U~L:.'----'--~--------'----_.:.__ - _ _- ~- Z/.J.o/1-41_'-r ~ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ------~-- ---------------------------------~-----------c----------------·------------
--~-o- ----------,-----·------ · · ~-- _ _ _ •_ :&u~t'i-~~- -----------~Do~- /:1~~a~~-&aAL~~----
--'---~-''-------'-' ~~----------·-·------------·---_:..__·--'---~---------: ___________.___________ ~~---
-----c-----,-------------------------------------'---------------------------'----
------------ _____________________,__ ________ __:_ ~--------------------
---~---------~----------------------~-'--------------~- ------------------ -----------------------------------------------'--~---'----___:____:_ _ ___:_ ___________
--------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------~---·-----.-----~----------:---'-------___:_ ____________ -----------'----------------------~----------- ----------------------------
------'------------------'-----'-------------·----------·___:_ _ _ _ _- ' . - - ' - - - - - - - - - - - '('
1:• ...... ------------------------------'---------=---'-'-------------~---,----------------
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -------------,-----,--------·-------------- --~------------------------------~------------~--------------------- '·4~;-- ___:_ _________________"'___ ___________________________- ' - - - - - - - - - - - ' - , - - - - - - - - ' - - - - - - _, ~ .I:. t"
----------------~----- ---------------·-'------------~-------'----1'-·'--"···~.:.....,.._;__ _ __ • -·------------------·--r-~--·----------------·-----------------~---·--'---'lce··l;2:::Lc.•<_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ____:_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ~--- •.·•--'---;::l.!....__'-1-;{,.---': _ _ _ ____:_--'-' _·:;;;'-; 1'1 •..:--'-.-:'-,----'-'-- ... 'I ~ . )
• ___ · . '•·
~--_-.:__ __ .:._ _________,.....................--.~---·~------·---.-----~---~~---~----..:...,....-..___
----~-------= ------,---·---------. ·------------...,----,---~-
--=J:~tll&vl~k!_ ~~L_c~p{,r No~_Lrl 6 9/Bb ----'---------,----- .r./ . •.·• . {J ~ . r. --Z'M-:__~~-~- l.f.3_£X_Nd!. . __-:iudt'-c,~L-._~LM.cE t-sUd.L.--______ T~Nr___:_e_~u_'L~ · · · · · -~- _ _ .Pie s}~~9-Judy.e_·i2_tL6_€y___~At-z.4LM~--- . • ._-----------'---R.k:Sj1d~ollfLLL.z;;c • __ ·----'-
-----------,---~. - - - - - - - - - - - - '- - - - - - - - - - ' - - - - - -
_______________ :._____~----------- QoJ5J_I/&.iho..,v..y~l3.ohL~£& ---,-------'----- ra__c-;; _No . I 8L!L6_.32__ _ _ _ _ _ __ __ _____:______ ~--------~---.J3-o__a_ F m_ b·..s-s-"-----,------~------ -c~~_j(~£[_~~~/f~------ ------------~---~osl114/Lo!V'"1:.7l~_n-::r _:z7.r8J_ _ __ ' ' _ _:__::PM:..= ~ s €.
~--------~--· -----~----- ............ ---~-------··--- '
.• .......1-.-------------~----------~-------·-----
~~---------------~------- - - - -------------,--.......,..-'-- _ __ _._
-----------~---------~-~-------------· ..
• ..L ____. -· _.:_ ----~----------- ----. .. . iJ -~
~~ 6- ___________.,;__~------=:=
TA-hlf.. o/ U()_~itu -=-~- JJ_j__
- ' ------~ ---..,.------------- -------~----:---
. .. -------·--------------------------------
. .
I£.?'. . . '. . . . . -------~----------
i1 . /' f)·.. -~ ----:-~r~_£,&_~&__-~_l_L ______,__--=-_:_----·- - - - - - - - - - - - - _ _ 7rD------'--~-- ,•
I .
----------~---------------------------
• __ 1Jpp.~_Lf4 I -~__fu/£S________~_:__~-~ -'-'-------------------~-~--JJ:__.(o_ ; : :~ :_;_·,. -,~~~.~-: . ' . . :: . : ~- ·::;~~\.'/-' \ ·;· - .. .. i f<t-1 .. -~ • ~c-------..1 ·,
• - .- - - - , - - - - - - - ' ' ----------------------~---
_ _ _ ,fi!J_/?E._f}_o;,..[_~#t_rt~>£y__&oudM.. 12£_fA._1JJ~__fAa£k&~~/rJ691/%.""'-=-=-{)---'~ ___ ______ u;N_}::___o t 111_/b'r/_~w~ . . ----'----- -- .·. • _ _ _··_ ~---------- ~- -~-i ___.~--~----~~-------~~~~~~- _______1 --.----------------- _ _.f1,1J'__ ,4LikP-#-~---c-8_ou&&.-.___ r_oG_:;r_Uet_____LBL£6J_Z ':.;_t/z_£~~'<!'::..:~"'---'----- ___,M_~~;_J_-:-c_M_£~-~-.:i.r___~r~ __A_-7~rl4~--~u_h'~u __ ·. _ , ~---=-.4_.f_-'f4_~t_s:_~_L.~~f{__tt_,_;_.j._"__ BtlOL& 6r_s:__~s6~~----,-- _ _~'1L_~~-__2__?.Q.B:S__:____ _:_ __________~
•• ___/hL~pM._S'fcb~7-~---J';_4;£ __ lJ___ ~~-/b~Yo~6lL __f.u.6~~'----~----'- -----' COOMz..~-L~s_~_t!)_f -tlt~----!t.J ~_Nd _ D,~[~~LCtP-li.~c_eJ ~~---- . ____ ~z_CQ~IY'.L7!-_n~·-----_____- _ -------- __ __o__f},~·-=-o~W7M 1/_*~-14/fr/M .1-r -~L_~~~'L7-~f1,~_r~t.CL:::_~~-·_ __ __·_·~-~~-lc:_____/i:f. ___'-{o_/___W_tu~r_ _$.£,L/C,v_~ .s~f ~Mtft ~H1___;.·;_____ ,.,r:.7L . .. : _______:_________ ~~ ~., ~_
--------- _ __,fk~~_ _!lA_-y/Q~_Lj___'fl:fL __ CQ_u~r ~?be--- ' ;I'J-i- ·flo l_ _ _ __ ---=W~t:__fi£/~M~--~L~f._f:OLf={!;_ tdoA._th_ fL~~. - - - - - - - - ·- - - - - - - - - --:----------~----------------
•- -----------~-- . ' ------------------- __ ..:.._,.. __________ ~--------------· ---- - - ---------------------~----e------
. .J.. .L -~-------------------~~~- .. I
• ·-~----~-~-~----------------~-----~----------------------'-----------~----------~-- 1 •
. ' -----------------,, .. ·--·-~--=·-----·------- -----~-----.--. ------~--
G ~ /'/'~ . r{.{ ;"' n, ..,.... . -()a· . . ----=~c~~.¢__\1__~_;- __Qh£0~--.----Lt:>_.SC--_l_. __L _ --~---~-~-p-fJ~- fl2 ---- -----------------~--- ----·---,-------·-----------------c-------------
• - - - - - - - - - ' - - - - - - - · - - .- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - --.---c'-----~~------ __ . . . 2_ t.=~,. . - =-=_- LUi.. __ 9_?:__'-L_S_,~Y-J 4d _ b_B_a_:__~--~.-----c-=·---:;-~-~-PPr-~-.s;_:__·- - - -----'-------------"~"--" ~-----'-----------------------------------'--
_ _____,s_4_{£r_7~t_t.M-M.. __v_!.._ __(~A?<-c;,:,. ?¥r s_, Cdzd. a~ 8..--~-p~-S:--------,------'- --------------~-------·--·----~-----·--------~-------
---,-----'-----------~------------""'--.:----'------------'-------- - - ~--~L£s . -~-5.:J. (__/' ___S_JL_;J_,-_:____:>- J , 3 _j:--L~-=-==7--==--==---:=--=--f....§-·'1, Z..._____ _ --~--'-------'--~----·--,-------------------~------'--------'-----
~----~~prj· to .. • ----'--'-·-------.--·---------------------------------------~-----
- . . : ~-· r~ ,"i- - ----'--------------------------'----~----,-.- - -.. -----------,----'-...;..__;_:_'-----'-+~-- . ~.- _r:_l· ;.~f;·f-'_' ~'- ____;...,. __ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 1_____.___________________________---,----:...____,_·b.-,_~=-:-'=.--,;:-----c-'--i _: _ :·,·1:YJlG)\:/ ____ _:______}._ .1 ~ -----~- .--------'-~-----",·\_·-_·__ '. •f •
- • -·-------,--~.~·-~~ML.SJ£._/J/o_L_Id-bJZLf)_{, O~~-·_ _ _ _ __:__ _ _ ____.__
. . ____,·'I,v· u_·'_f}_OM ·~~&_~h_y_flo~MM__/ Pli 4rt7&. --------'----'=-"rv.~~·l-- .• f '0 / &L/lrlc_'d~-f'._________ _ :-e·.· · Nat.U--~as:~:-fJQ~- ~lfo~ .8oN"#M. /-LL~Z.il-<--/~1!.~..,...'--,..-'--'=-:....r.-=-=~,._ __ .. SL£L~y.-·rb .!'hft>]Lt£.~-i-4'.!_ C~"-·L- jkL~_SCL_~L· lc fi'M£._· _ ' -./. •. . . .
_ _,!Lui&.£ . o/. ~fl-e.C/d"L<. . f!_~udu.;i£s .:~~ ..t'tl~L/- $';;. 3 . --~£J-~~ ...s ~-·ULLIL shot..V M~t Co.v"'-r .' ~~-~&u;~~L;y~_:.___ _ $1/t[/i...pvtkft eC ~c4S£ ..~: . . /6 ~\ · . , . . . I . , . .: . . ~ •: ,, . 11:~
-~-_---"lt"""""&_roL<., · IJo¥ /-hv_Mo~_~o~u/.A.. ~f,U~~Co.&Vlcr/id. _ __,__ · · hy_/!1- Yu~~~4__j_ o/ MA- /d.L'a&-y_' o4tVs.;£ ()_£~u:.- · / ~~~~ . ~hLtuiss_~tss~~ G)£~~~~ 6_7- /1 ·M/o/V,__,·"'--'...._·_ _ . . . . . . - . . . \. ' .
_·_~A_,~~· ·S/ZA/'L~4Lct£~~ .¥e:L_yL~ . /A/' :~L£ _ 1;}(~ f?~)gl-_~."---;-.-'-._ . ' ... _ ol , ~h--1;/U/.4-'1 .J(6fuc.a... ( "7'/J C.~)~-~ .. -- )., f/7£ ¥3_r2._;::JCL- ... .':.~· '
' . . ( . . . .--- ----=-cl' c~~L 'DI..sZ~e-7' Cau~'<--L /;)·~ ~T ·C~,s.d'y~~·~-=-~-__, ___ £f.:/&~,_ /J.p,A44L__·th/J Co_~v;~i_~1L_ ~_(}Ai /Je.~.6£L. ' _ __;__; . . .
--~ '11 · ~ oL3 7J;,z C<!?uA--r t>!"' ~,4&./!zs ., -?-/i_C!..~ fJ, s~r..Ufr__ 4> •
.• _ EJ{ 1Ji. 'I·~. IJ/'h~ f4h. c~M-~L~n~~Afo~J. -I:A ~~~o S3L . L /L_/3_(1M~E/c.. \l' s r~a_c_e .J l. ···-, '- ,. \·· - ';·-:::; ' t : /t.';·." --~---------------~~----~----~'~--~-- . ' '• .. -
-· OA./_S£,a~6M.._L~ ZO/~ '
ol' 'O..x_~~C_at9_Uo_~--<:;a. ~ t~- eOS:?_'l ·- c /1.~·fl£bkt?~-~4- d j ·- . ..._ . . .
7J;LCt!ZtLA.L ... a£ eu~~¥!L.tlp(J£!1lt Cu£/za --.- ' ~~- f/iJI~.(d ______lu.,~ llt~~~~~~ --. -.. . . - - - .-.-~ . 1At.hL-£ih _JJ¢__ ' -- .,__'~ ~ {d)_ 1,_ - ' /? fatt._. £JL4~s;~z;,;;7~hil_:_tt~-~.€ dM__o/IJ {)_,~r__~L U~tM.._h/:hr_.S.v~mLik~ SL.~L /1-faT~/Vs ~;__EML e_~k_Cl2)0;u t:>/ ._@&_·Ctau~r i'.£caddr ~...,.~~~~£. • -~ ~c_a_~d.c_-b:b_ll-IEA-~r A_p~b"b~ a./A.-iI 1- o ~ C£,_floM-ILt' .b_~£ · {/_PZL~~~_Sc.,_~£-· . C~vt..L A-·~.<J ~{JlL~Wr-·- ~-/}M.L /11- .s~· &.L,u_La C L~,fA<~~t.L-1~~ ~:hr'k_{J3__J_~j_(DJ /l&chkL k ~-/Jp{l~~; -. ££_ dJ~L_p£bk6/lf' ..
-j£1/1...1.£• cite rio d._ ,, ' -
., .,
l'u~ sul!1~_.fo_~fi~·(~r,z,_k_/J£_s_~_._L, Sd~d • .. _ . !b¥_O__:_S:c~.. 3 .i_~+-6i..i_Ct!Lu41~- ___: hM .:IU~-'-~cbc lio~ ·k /;~. · · , _ ~. r ' .., • 1
__f::hiJ_,oL~£~6£- ... ££~~ A_/hf_jlLr~l-s~Ap~ 0 · --~a l&r_ik__~ &coA-d..f ·1-o ml'iLJ:~SL~~-~~/'~~'----·~~---- -----,----fMU .{._~ L ~#4Ar ;-"!fli/ .i·J_utJ_'LA-_f1.UA - t3A..z.9-/k/V -~Cdf~-~·-~-------~---~-----------
\ l ;'
• _ _._'LI1d4LCd:le.tLTs_fJt£;y_-~&L~~--:~_;_[u.M.S ·ko-~/£ _ . ~--~ ~ ~,u~~,~~~~:' ~ < : • • \ ,, t 't < t ----~---------(~~----------------- '
,,
/
~ tu.s~/Ll&M./- '7L -~-- .. --~-~
' ---~ - - - - " - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ·- ------ -: IZ£ult!d.. _ _~:s:~~-J-¥114~r£ __pw_c££ dL;,.-9--:~-/!_do.:...s. ~- OA/' ___(}p/),£_Ltf -- ./JQirc_?u.Y.lc.TL~~,.---~ u;_lta l.s'_ __J~~~&M._.Z_tt.LMit_ -- -~·r _ _£u_~df_'-o_fJ~--cfisr__.4Lj)~U--:-~co/Ldi _., 12£&~ ----"-"t:.l Cou_k~£ __ A_t__~£ __LZ:. r/iML/1 {/o_;j_ 1.3(J(J kb!L6.£J' _ _ tLastt_tJ;u~--n~----------------------~---- - ' , '
. f.£ -~roA- ___IJA<f. ____ £~'h19U'SZ"&.L_/uj__/1&~£.-d __ q_,u_ t_lfJ -- :. __ ·c/t;~x:___ 4JI);f-.erL____-L&- No~ 't2;1 -LJ._~aa£.3~lf.. -- c L.,_j)O~~ C,tWk- _ _____:__·v~.S[b-~_;___~{)___ f! D__ ~ -- oq_ o b -I~ ·- w d:.S_-_ JU. ks~-d ---=o.U__ S£f.f/~_} }a,__L_71 Z!LI't, ~~£-tlt_~!J;_j.------c-(/1_) h-~6&../'/ ~·_- -...Jo___yt~---/}p;J~~-c~r~~---(> £_~d___p£__b_:/,_~~ .. IL - SL~c£- ____Y:it_~y~-&~To&_ _c_hM _&~d s~ ~I hfofrQJ-i/ ~------=-(ffy_~-~~-- ~~--~~ k/-VI Cau~r--1!1-r¥/J. Ca..u4r. ~-
-_____~~Tli~--~--S££b~7---/3~1i&__Z£_c~~-z.h_~{)__&_A-L .--·--r~s-~~h~__ LiJ_____(J-4__d/U.~__ rlo___fl~~~L_.L-1____w~l- . __:___·-,ttf C.u_ha~-:--f.C_'-Mk. ___{/h;~d' __:s_Litl)£:LCQ..i.?~L-~ ,C .,.,- ,·.
.. .. ... '~
!letJ£p:y_f_s_~o__tu_&__t:_ __o_LI~~h4:1' ·c<9~_ U- ['__j/.J..( ______,s- rJ£ ____~t.J~£E:d~VtA,{____Cf!UL4T..r;_~_f£ tvt:CL/!._ ._£__ l</A.JI- ___()__Lcu-r,:oM::4d-,-_w..M____ ely_~£. -__ t6/~IJ~~6_~ ___0 ~ -----:--__ao_L'l:._·.sfi£___E_-th_;i_; .f__[ftl_.___fb.L_ac_tQ6u~L·o-F z Q_!.Y..-'-· ,.. • ·· KK.~Lo.Lf~_IY!~koH_i€~ca u£s 0~__f~_ -P-Y-~- Cc; .'(£,. ,..... '---- -- - ~ I '
__ • •, "1-! eo )i 1• ' \ "; ~ . '- ,, , .- ;,~ ~)..-:1_:) L ,.r _____ L'Y.kL_C.O(.LAr-r_~. ~t._s ~!{)_-~a&~-J---.}_c~t;l..fl:.!,e.4 ~,.. r:- ... f;"'f -~·?1:.. .:~.: , ____-________·- ·___· ----,------E~-~~ - / ,, "··~ .
. • __ ' ' .
: .
w~_y,tv/£~-~ ~_Co~~~d~~d~ .. /ULa_cL- o~ !J_y~~Mif~--- ' . '
' ' .
co.e;.~a~h--~~1---~~z -~.sC//:6 ~-~-<-_GU_~ - - _--"---"----= . . ' ' . &QL_·.- ' - - - - - - __:_•_____:_:,4-!J &__rb__fk£-~-~~IO __)J.•1.£~-~L I b_;_..r_ '' ~i;;(l~L-"--io'---- - _· ·t:IJ~_{h,;ftL___ Sf~.u__·_C.c!!:£L~?: __G. L' ~~4-:L_~i_~ /u~~~-,-- __ ---'-ti:..M_d__in__'ftt£___ £Lco~__4r_~_.u;AG£o/__!J_~__ dO.._/ld$.""--e--'.__ of'- cHiA._~@eL4z;__~Sif£ __£_'6_6_;'1J~_'f:~(,8_J~A~_A_d__6;>__"/dt~ __-_ _ --·-!dtl-4~ dtL_o_[__~.L____(J..th_frg_t<f.~ . ___________ .. -~.. f}c(d,'b.ou_&'/y--,--~,g__ -#/rKA.._~~-~~Zl:l_A- __£~·-- - tJ~C~IJ-Uf.___/J#a.k_"o~s___[)&!L,£d.__,1/o_tL.-3r_WL'-L_~t:)_ _:_/)£c··"-'---- _··_·_)_i_Z_o_tv &tt-u.Mu~r~-£ML_fJ#M-_-f2Lc~~K) L"'-~~~'-----_;___ ~--_Y-~s.~J!'r...r~..~--/~~&vu __~_o. ~ ~~c~~--- • ~£~4-L, c~a...Tjvi£_V'..u.~Mt<ld.-£_ A·!W&~~_gA£" _-_· _L__,_~o_77o~..£4>---------------_:____ _ _ _ _ _ __ ' ' ·&u:..__'EdJ.Ltu~-'-~i- ao_(_J:~~A..-~I£~/41_£iZ/_o~--- __k_fh,(o/ :__4___ _A~~~~-?---~--f£!u1LrZ .£-'!-_:E__I'f./CL_fg.______ f • _ _po~LL£.1!-S__ Ziz-.t.'«L-~'L~.s~/-!-P"____(.__~~ Ce2/llfi_Sl ·~,_,..,~,____ __ -,___~ . l2£c f~LL~L- _ ___l!!1~~ ____ Zlt~' _L_ &__Q&L__~w~ .Li___ ~_. ' j ____ h~cL -~ ___(26£...:__· _ __ . IU&ch__L'i/-ZatJ- ~Xl-- . . M_Uc/_/1£~L.£cL . . SL~k."-----'-.___:__···_ _ __ · l?-i_&;__6_; f _[.l)_l__~~it£o/ riO -±ft~b~o(L)c~o_£ ·-----'-- --~--=--~tj__ IJ£bk~~~-' ___ · _____:__-'-,-. - - - - -----~-~----------------~___(,£} ) ~ /] H4(/t'/4r<f&& ' ,.· t.s __ ra.£SEA£Ua {} ' -.: .:,_J
---;-----·-------:--·-------- ' ('lf.) -------:------.-- -- / .
• '
~..-----;------~ ------~-------'-----~---,------'---- __· ·_M.__.__ILl_.&_/_Ct2CI~:f~_fl.£CD.ll_dS.__6}~/J_l~{hA..f'lt.M ~MSC4.;j614_ _ __ - - - {;,A-_LAldt~9h-:NT_ _·. P._tt..o.:::.S£~_;I&wn#--M . · ---------.------------------------'----- - . . .
---------------.----------------·- _ _. ·_ ~_6£,y;_~. ___/lto_n_~-~l-r ____~pk&L~~-·tlfi:_cL~~--~dL~-- __ --.. b~_ kd_~-l ___C~M___~d£_~r_----Q.,C Ce>~SFd,u;~8-A&__,__ll~.---,--- I
----'-=~'-so(v:/N:g.-~_j_f-_j:s_·__ mt~;s_Tiue:.L~u;____.ZM"'KL_Lh_f_4Y.£""'-'.z....__.. ---'---;-'--- _ _____:{~-~.:__S.: LU_$d_.___i}_QS/_c_aJ__8~___-_:Tk?_~Yh.d_ta_·_co,v_s~~:_clh.A. /)y_o/"""-_-- . . -. ' -~ . . , If .
-~ ilu{l:, __ _._vp..o_y_~/4__/1/!o_li..o~-~LS__N..or /!!l_c/ts_CA:I[. li D.M~~'--=-=1'-_--.--- _ ____.,_l)e_'C_ s£k_--, __4:~_@-__ &ru_·_~:,_s-__slc.wJcL_l3 .3---~~'-------c-:._____ __ • . _ ----'--'·~i..tUil ____t:z__'Z_~ __s.~_w :;_tt~.__ ~;Iifl_C r£~ ~/l~_l9?flJ~.l~.16~__c_A~----'--- ----'- 610.~-t;w_:__L~~ ----A~fJ-/iAL7----oh'ad'. ~~-,4~d£~__:kftli~.L__r___ El{.·CatV-~Ldti-u~?--~~-.a__ ~t:!Lv:..(.Y_.p_)_Li_.i .nt/u_/sZii;_;.Pil.t&:.L-1___ _ ___ . __ - -~4-~_~-h--~-~~L__ c_{!~~z IJ" ~--~ut:-4~ lo Ca,usdk_ _ -_. __ -~- ~~---~a_ _____ ufl()i.E:__~It__R!ft;:ft_f:?A.L_ tvii/t.Lf'...L_J9,~_1l£A.SoNAb~ · _--.----~L-t-,SA.~-~7_;::_k_[b£u_ C~- v · b~c;_~_U__$_, 't~ ~""-e~ ______________.~1)1~d_~_f¥J ___-L_$S_q_L.S__ejpl__ -k- C'o--~~ A: ---'---'---''---- - ' ~ . .
cu~~~ .4.tJus£ __p,[email protected].._zz~~~a_&...; ..f-lt1i' · V/(JtA-r~ ' - ___· et_~~~.-~ L¥--~IJ_(J~g_c£__6_y--'-~-Lv_6_,€u_~~ ~r"[,__·- - -~---~(fJ___Q{A~_____ B~~~Uff-'iZ_~~~L£.-dy~h ·~-{A_~._.S~,___,__~-- ___·, Jo~iY..SotL1L__ EtS!:O~#,___C_~~~~L~-~- ~a£~ 7tJtJ5; w ;Jd__ __ __--.____51b -r---TLZ _(1£_x_L1t!/l~_l_'l_B_f').~-~-ol_l_k_f2A-LI:5//y.~£~'f:__· _ _ o{_gj_~cL_~-~J__:__~;£$_ufL__~f\./~-:-~--C(n~lJ~l~_~ · ~· o·l' · ; 's_.. !U~J - · · -- ~7«'--_-----; -P-~'-- ___ -~M..Cii..., _ _ -'-8--1"1JJ.-Mf'--_l£_ ____l~k::.~L-CJA.._,~-=-:r~="'""'-,.,.---,,--,--- - . - . 'ft. . . ·' - . . ' -.~ \ -:oJ2t ;y '/ \ 0.(!__~-a,~__v_l<..L A:/(~ ___La:_g__s_ . . w zr/._t!J2~ --. ·>: :~::::~ . ,-. >·· . . .-.y,_, ~·d ~ •• • ;/;·J ~.
____________:_-;-_·--.----~($-) -~~- - - .~f£f&roA..-_-:-Cof..L[£iJ_t::d_:__j~~-t:J---jja/;_;~l:f~aCL·L__~f±l- ~L.c__·---------.,-- __- ilM__;zivV__Q~/a_c/ __~_7€::fft:f~-ILM__M.:s_~_o ,£-~CtSL~"-'L 4-r-..Q_ .
_ _______;fkR£ ~~;_---~~s_-~---~--f£_1P- . ___4~~ -~ '1. 'ci1cc) uJ ~Ll--~ . . .
--~ur ___~(J___ ~d.£_c&vu.. ____ hlf._Lj_.~u..dL~~L-~A _·-._,-. _/2~&--~-lll__:__c~-~~-'L-fJA¥---CP..S r_~f:tJ~~______:t:_6f.---~~L -~----:__c~~r__s__ ~_#{)____c~A.-r 4#~rc~--.peq;u_flL~----- .. ~ '.. . ' _ _____:.,·~0-~ I ~S-~fJ-J:r__#_____________-;---- · _-___--_-&-~ob_.__co.l'd.r~d..J.______;,_£___(,~~_€~c,_iil£oLri:o_c..~k---- _ _ fL£S~~~4-P-"-£~1.{:__~~_£)____ f.kl~~~!S-~~-&t£g __7J~--·_·- - - , . -~~ou_'M._cL__deL~~~rr___ ~__J!&i2~--~c~...r._--------'---- -n, . .~_~r_~~-T~s.~j)if.__LlM-_£~~/V"r;~; k~_- --------'- • - -_ . _· .•... ~-Yr()A,___f-o_ R£S€ALC6 . ~;_;_· IJ~l<LJ-. ~~u~tr~-/'--=-~-:----'---~- _·, ----~ Vt.;&:.L_:_b_ __ ~ry~/4tJ,()_t'£~--:£fJ£cLb_c:~ll'7~4.k._IY_d.=---/~ _ _ __ · ~s c;r;.Af£_p~£i____f!L_cl!2_!1-c;/_..f_~1E.l&Zi2~flo~u:a ~z---'--------- ___.:___ __ --_-.___:_tk&L_h;J__Y.~d___k_:_~·n:l_~.s~/l"ZL-_&.4__"--4~-/_ _ _ _ -~ tl-HY--'_Ad~~~~~ · -tb~t£;4L_~(L_6_d_~ -_f!£ft ~-~·-·_·.-'----'---------- ·. __-__· _-fk-4-ro~---~ul&.f--:_-~i__~_ou__r___ +_h£sA- &__c__o_~d,...r. -J.o=--~~- . ~ 72; . _____ . /(;!_ /-, . j___c_o,u..S..uZU ___ y__[~_ :.,.._L .r' . _/_, -~.t!t:__I__ /Y_'/£l f) ~ I H tv;// _______ / L '\ /." / - t__L_~~--V-ItltLf.Jh:L_ _ -~-~4___ w_~ld_/lM-_'lf£·1(..,-T_!u~ ·-. ~-/JUJIL.i-~~§=7---~ ,_·____ . ___niJ_-_~__s-rMx_~~ __:_fi£d~ __6_~~-C~u~~/lpfMA::!-"1-Lc~- - - · A~-?J-u_~,d_<r--;/----dutt. __~--:-~~-~-A!Ji~C£ . et: ~L~-_,_ _ __ · · ·_._fdt_t£, __~C~-:1-!L~--~~1/i!LS __&eo"'J .;~~.o_ /14p k!!!~---""-J_-,_ __ .· /d:/__~d -~M:--~~~-~~r;___~M_. Gv_~M~"~If;-~bLlo...q-'lfs>LL;_J------'-- • ..- ______·--~1_fo__~ C L-:__/:..b <2-~~-.o___ .tiu~_s _ ·_ · . ____ · . ------------~:___-:-------. - - - - · ____ . _,__It_:__. __.0=---::...L-/,io__2!!: S c /. Ill:,' C/
. ( ____:__ ___________________ _____ &)._ ..
•• -- -------·------ ----,··./2£~CfM..~I:.;_i'Jd-l,_~----lkr-qM--:.e~--~t-·Ht)<L_~--~r _to_ _ . ~--h41~£_·3udc;;.~L- Utl-h~~~MA:.t_··-MLJ.._c__o_)_i·h.li·_Lfith._ __ ·. _ _ ' ' ' ( ' ' I
_·__.·Ct>-u~L,L '__/t;,_~4;{M_ __ bLt:f~~-'Lld£oL __Lj__tt.SI!_ /.bf.S rio~---- __· -=:r_~/d4~--·~~ 7lti£ __7J. ;x~___(}_ft/)~'T~~L ~-l!._C_ · Qu ~,..tV'-=·.-='4:.. . :.____ _ _ __.·"J(L4...'L.~clf._A:r_rM.__ rc_~-~-ll~t/Rt/f_.,. lb£-C..tv~_-.----'-------,-- ~~ . 'fJL_·_~_l:6~~---s~l'k<~v_i£a~ A~_/&._~Ld....~ - _ __-pLL.o_v_L dJL~ . --C~fJLU,__ ,{;,~__it£(ArtM-~--J!£.&r-ziu<.._·~~~ _ _ c-b__e~g-~_·j,~_/:_J__ __.;T&oiJ...p~L..·_~_-c/o£:£ .N.oZ:__bAY-h..~-- . · '?."· ?J,t~d . .../l~z-r-___4&:L.C#4:6E_:_tkt__/9-Lq__. Ce.xplU_,(;_,c_jli~-- --~-~M4.._·_[c__b)_~_· -r---'---·- . · . . . _··.-;--._ _ _ __
---~- ------------ - - -~n._i/,iS_L____ /!£MOMS . _,_jJ/I.k.S£~JLd..,_,4uLJ_k_-rAL1JYdi_ __ _ ___,Q /'~:Zt_~n~L __~Io-f1U~L-~£~.fl~ ,. R£1Aw~ ..(J£hl·£c~J'=-·-~ --:-.JhiJ, CQUI!kr~~::o___c_~u.:s~d~__'flt.ll ,4Lb.k...~AL-~9~L_r_·~- .. I I/ . ' 17- , . §)., /,' /'. ,. . . ' . _ _"t:h..fk.._/l£.~uP-S..t:£a--~ll..kJ_-_o-.-:-::---· -~-----------,----- --,--.-,----·W · lo · (!)/l.du_'~An.. · ~~/ ·c-~~7 1-o oA.d'OA..___._·..f-6..=!.~£.______ _ ____,___·. Di£rA.d~LCU4~~-·;72t_Q_m_tH_ A. _h;(d~ __dbe.a_·.·--,---.--'-----~ --~-··_.__..Lt9-u~Z" Rk/)..trM,Z:u___g~ 9-;~)(hLd._fu_·~~~V£~~'.>1-· __
----,-------=&=J.4]D/L _w_i_f:A- ·___ F/f/££ ___fl..t!t(J~__CoP-;/ZS.. o~ ·+4 £. . ·. _ _ _··_..:.__~A--l___Ct91J~~r . _e_u;_L~~_t:l2floA-l'/i.A-s ··Ike~...._-_ _ • ' • • • • 'II ' ••
---"----1!17Y....o_:__TM.kL_'~··.s ~.~J.At · _ _·(_J__)_ _[)~---~.~~~--*hfi.___L/L 4 TlLA_ __~_Ciapy~ ~-·44 ·~-~~/,_____ . • :· ___ ,. bc._~k..~I±T~xL d_ • __apo..~TiiA..s_fl/I._co_Ad_..{_eo~--_(~}. -/ /_ , . , . , ''./(' \.• 1 'fif.(.-_ ·:.
JV/. , ·.·7,'"·. 1. '··C' ~ ·'JI"-':...::_.;l, , - - - - . . -y-$1J.N __j__tY_y.__J:PTl;...__~ 1M. CoA..d~ ,1-:o___C_dA.,L__....:...O • ~ ,;-:~::, •· , ·. . ·~ . ~ .,. ·_ r::.·. --:'·if; , ,. ~ · ~----------------- ' . -l:_q~ ,,.('\' . \' ' ·, -- -----~------._:_.-~---------------------- . ~_Lr;,_.r~~LL_j,/n;£_,1/_c:c_c£s.1., rbr:>-C~~ S,/fJ.M ,, f..f.---=~=-:_'-------'--'----, ~~~-tA~d~~-:i~M_-;~-Al:_ _L:foa F~ 6~-~ld_~,v ~ . . 7769.3 ' '
--~-~tu. _ _ _'h~1iA.L'--=. -~-;-~!_~~~-e.g ~~cea:S)_d~M&Lr fL ~JO.,<_-=--_·-~-- -. ,__-P~'.s_ ~'fdt~l- 4l-L_~_!Ptf7i_~_/2~:f.ih~~ _/:s: -9~ uoL_. ---;----------'- ..s 0 if.iJ /2~~d~----~-----· _·_- ·. . ·-'--- . . · - · r/_ .-. . ..- / ' / / J; / r1L,. I ----------·----------.,-~----.------------~--~·.n~/--~EL~--v-U~I~'----- . . - r·· _. , , '·, .
., . . . ~-~-------------------------·--- LiL._d~ ' - - - -- ...
· ·___. ____:___~__:_·---~-- __/)o~~C:ZIV'~--:-~O_MM~U'-=--~- . _____ · ---------------~-----~------~-~~--_c_ _ _IfJ_c_-s.~Mo_..__LB_I ____ ?_~d_Z _ _ _ __
• = _.. 1;~__11Q&£ ~our__/dQuM~~~cr_do_6~-Y--i:LILn.4--tJ_g_£/J-'-.- - ----~.~-£---~~<J____CeuYLLc£____C...ofJ-r . D? 'f:li~~/?£.i;__fzo4JL- kA-' _ _____..lh.~_f-__tt_/.. /1/~d~~...r· U/.M_~If.A.Vk.d_w_C.UJL Q-=C_ _ __ _____.. _-c~d-_&sad!- ___6_il~-- fi~~*~'(j{ ot..__(lljJ!~_~iJ .. 7· d· .- . £' /L,.A :; IS: ;~: ..· ~--"' .~--Q~-~~-"-~-~d~~~ --~--- -~~~//~----- _I ' '
. -------,-----.------ t~.u~ e~:_~-~-------------~---------------------~-~----~----1
·--------------·-----'--------·-------~------'--------------j
- - .R&y-·-CI)U;c.,'{:__c;~-~-r:-. h:€.~-----r.~~"----"-~l~V__!!~a::!--____!;;~---~__y~~_:_____:_-,-----1 __ ____,~J() -~1!-fl~lifd.s__ /_ ~~~~~~'--~~~---~~~~~~.R-L-'-~---.:....---~-1
• ___.:__p~_eu~L~~1Ltr----~c-~_e,6-/N-~~-:____,;.v___t__T::!2.___...,._o:.~~~-t-~--·n~~h~--__:__- . . _. S7:_~7ZcL ·~----------------------,----·--------------------'---'------'--------' I \ "A ,
-~--TltL-~.u~-~~-!M.t?-~r-~z~,/--f::;!__r___~~~·~~7__!___~~_!~~~~~~~--..:.___~_
_ _ _ _ _· -=.T,____=St!~L---~~-· _d&_U_Nk.___SmA-/~-~~.IJ.!.'!.~-r.._L___~~~..£..:.!~:.____,__~,~ - - - - - -----------:---·_______:_______ (--1-')-------'-'--------.- - - - - - - - - - - ' - - - - 1 . • . . .
. . .·. ~··~· ' .. · . . .
· . _.--~-~Q~£'i---:-~~----:_ -- -~-·.~/~ .*~!{]_ hd_J£~LL-~.la-------,-- ___· ·flcb4..cdt~g__ ____fbr-,~1£..-YLas-r ~~&u #'~~~ .T ________ _ _· /fvvJ tJ.oe;_..i.._.:L_c~--:~~o_Z .P.A-7_k,_~~flLrtJ£A-·_ ~()tfdr.:..c..._·- - - - ---~ £J___C6i&Lk1!__Co_-i_Z:L_ ____
------:_ ~--_Oou.~M.e;Y-_tio/SRM~--~c~ u~al~ ----'---~-'-#!~L_·p~A_f4~-- e.?' -tJRdL.j. .u.-t.l__'f--h-~L#t.£ .£<'l£_~e.~~"___ . ~ . . ~ -----'--=-s- ___ ~1£-'--~~.~:_C_~r:.._~t;,_~~-CGLtLcL._afSJ'_:__:__~;_.f_ ' . cL~_o6- &_~L-~_g__t_...r___ ,
/l?t..rltu~/'-J ;_ 'B~~=~----'- • Df!JIV --~-----:_·__~----~-----------·__.:__'CfJ_C- :r . -Al~_. /fl/9 b ;3_7.
-----,-----'------- -----/ -------
• - ----~ .. - - - ,----------·
____ · C2.J____ - - r,
J
p. 1·1·1 ., "/17tbtt c /l) ... 'Iii
'~ STICKELS & 770 N. Fielder Road P. 0. Box 121431 ~)~ ASSOCIATES, P.C. Arlington, Texas 76012 Phone: (817) 479-9282 -~_...,-:P' Fax: (817) 622-8071 www.StickelsLaw.com
John W. Stickels, JD, PhD Bethel Zehaie, JD Founding Partner Associate r:IBOARD [email protected] i:l CERTIFIEIY SpodaH~a!ion TI!.XM Board ot legal Angela Stickels [email protected] Septem9~r 18, 2014 Paralegal/Office Manager Angela@StickelsLaw .com '· Mr. Don Anthony Bonner TDC # 01819637 TDCJ- Terrell Unit 1300 FM 655 Rosharon, TX 77583 Re: Your Appeal Dear Mr. Bonner: The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals denied your Petition for Discretionary Review on September 17~ 2014. I have attached copies of their decision for your review.
The next step in the direct ap.peals process would be a Petition for Writ of Certiorari to the United States Supreme Court. You have the right to file a Petition for Writ of Certiorari to the United States Supreme Court. However, the Petition would need to be filed within ninety (90) days of the date upon which the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals denied your Petition for Discretionary Review. In your case, that would mean that your Petition would need to be postmarked no later than December 12, 2014. You will not be able to request an extension.
The next step in the process would be that your conviction will become final, a mandate would issue, and your conviction would be final. If you have any questions regarding this letter, please feel free to contact me at the address listed above.
Yours truly,
JDMJ~h John W. Stickels JWS:mg Enclosures OFFICIAL NOTICE FROM COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS FILE COPY P.O. BOX 12308, CAPITOL STATION, AUSTIN, TEXAS 78711
9/17/2014 COA No. 02-12-00534-CR BONNER, DON ANTHONY Tr. Ct. No.1269186D. PD-0706-14 On this day, the Appellant's petition for discretionary review has been refused.
Abel Acosta, Clerk DISTRICTATTORNEY TARRANT COUNTY JOE SHANNON, JR. WEST BELKNAP FORT WORTH, TX 76196 * DELIVERED VIA E-MAIL *
.. ., . ' '\';o
.,..
THOMAS A WiLDER, OIST. .CLERK ("· TARRANT COUNTY, TEXAS OCT. 10 2014 Cof1f. ~ CAUSE NO. 12691 86D TIME · c:2l9. g ~~~ BY ~DEPUTY THE STATE OF TEXAS IN THE 432ND JUDICIAL vs. DISTRICT COURT OF DON ANTHONY BONNER TARRANT C~UNTY, TEXAS
DEFENDANT'S POST-CONVICTIONMOTION REQUESTING FOR FREE COPY OF TRIAL COURT CLERK~S AND REPORTER 1 S RECORDS AND TO AID IN FILING .
A PRO . SE ~ETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES TO THE HONORABLE JUDGE RUBEN GONZALEZ OF 432ND DISTRICT COURT OF TARRANT COUNTY, TEXAS: Defendant, DON ANTHONY BONNER, pursuant to the provisions of Section 3 . 0 0 3 of T ex . Ci v . P r a c . & Rem . Code and Ru 1 e 2 5 of Tex . R . Ap.p . P r a c . , and in conjunction with the U.S. Canst~ Amend. XIV and Art. I § § 12 & 19 of Tex. Canst., files this motion requesting .... for a free copy of the trial court's clerk's and reporter's records in this instant criminal case and in order to aid him in the filing of his pro se petition for writ of certiorari to the Supreme Court of the United States, and would respectfully show unto this . . (./' ibh. 5 '(,../.iJ / - /. .\. / honorable Court the following: i ;.·: .( ·.. ·· :./ .
;;!. , I ' 1•.' I ) ' • ,. '' ,1 ,• ' j I { I . ~) l ·' · ..i t-· ' ~ ' .• jJ ,·
On September i2, 2014, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals refused the defendant's Petition for Discretionary Review filed on his behalf by his court appointed appellate attorney John W. Stickels in PDR Case No. PD-0706- 14, styled case Don Anthnny Bonner v. The State of Texas. Therefore, the defendant has until December 12, 20\4, to file a pro se Petition for Writ of Certior~ with the Supreme Court of the United States. sc~~~ :t'I.
Defendant's court appointed appellate attorney John W. Stickels raised -1- the grounds of review of: (1). The Texas Second Court of Appeals erred when it failed to find that the trial court erred to denying the defendant 1 s motion to suppress evidence seized from his Gardenia Street residence; and (2) The Texas Second Court of Appeals erred when i t did not find insufficient evidence to support the defendant 1 s conviction for the offense of possession of a firearm by a felon . . . in the petition for discretionary review he filed on the defen- dant 1 s behalf with the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals. See Bonner v~ State, P DR No • P D-.0 7 0 6 -1 4 ( Te x • er i m • Ap p • 201 4 , P DR f i 1 e d May 3 0 , 2 01 4 ) .
III. L The Defendant will present the 11 question 11 to the Supreme Court of the United States as: "Does the JACKSON v. VIRGINIA, 443 U.S. 307 (1979) ~taMdard prohibit a reviewing appellate court from re-evaluating the weight and credi- bility of the· evidence presented at a cr:iminal defendant 1 s jury trial· upon considering an insufficien~y of the evidence point of error." In a~, the Texas Seco~d Couit of Appeals ~uled that their court of appeal~ can not re- evaluate the weight and credibility of the evidence and substitute the judg- ment for that of the factfinder. See Tex. 2nd COA Opinion at Page 6~7, Bonner v. State, Appeal No. 02-12-00534-CR (Tex. App.- Fort Worth, Dec. 27, 2013).
IV.
Defendant is urgently in need of his trial court clerk 1 s and reporter 1 s records to aid him in preparing and filing his pro se petition for writ of certiorari, and to further argue his preserved insufficiency of the evidence ground for review and to amend/supplement on the claim that the State wholly failed to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that he possessed a firearm after conviction and before the fifth anniversary of his release from confinement following conviction of the felony and/or release from parole. Thus, without the trial court clerk 1 s and reporters 1 s records he will be precluded from meritoriously arguing this insufficiency of the evidence claim to the Supreme Court of the United States in his pro se petition for writ of certiorari.
-2- ,. ' ·. ..__
v. The defendant's questions and arguments to the Supreme Court of the United States are not frivolous, and also the defendant has been already de- clared indigent prior to trial, at trial and on appellate review to the Texas Second Court of Appeals and the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals. Therefore, he should be provided with a free copy or loan a copy of his trial court clerk's and reporter's records, and in order so he can adequately, effectively and meaningfully present the substantial question to the Supreme Court of the United States in his pro se petition for writ of certiorari.
VI.
The best ends of justice will be served by this honorable Court and by granting this motion and ordering the District Clerk, Thomas A. Wilder, of this Court to furnish the defendant with: ·a free copy of the trial court clerk 1 s and reporter's records or loan the defendant a copy of the trial court clerk's and reporter's records for forty-five (45) days by sending the records to the defendant's TDCJ-CID Charles T. Terrell Unit's Access to Courts Supervisor Yolanda James, 1300 FM 655 - Terrell Unit, Rosharon, Texas 77583.
WHEREFORE, PREMISES CONSIDERED, Defendant prays that this motion is granted.
Respectfully submitted,
a4vlldtlk~ 8[; DON ANTHONY ;R Defendant -- Pro se TDt:J # 1819637 1300 FM 655 - Terrell Unit Rosharon, Texas 77583
_-:;,:_ ,· ' ,, . c· CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I certify that a true and correct copy of the foregoing pleading was placed in my TDCJ-CID C.T. Terrell Unit Mailbox for processing through the TDCJ Mailing System, and for forwarding by U.S. Mail to the District Attorney, Joe Shannon Jr., of Tarrant County, Texas, 401 W. Belknap Street, Fort Worth, Texas 76196-0402, on this 4th day of October, 2014.
~ -~er
-4- CAUSE NO. 1269186D
THE STATE OF TEXAS IN THE 432ND JUDICIAL vs. DISTRICT COURT OF DON ANTHONY BONNER TARRANT COUNTV,TEXAS
ORDER
On this day of -------------- , 2014, came to be heard Defendant's Post-Conviction Motion Rsquesting for Free Copy of Trial Court Clerk's and Reporter's Records and To Aid In Filing a Pro se Petition for Writ 0 of Certiorari to the Supreme Court of the United States 11 and it appears to this Court that this said motion has merit, and so it is ORDERED that the District Clerk, Thomas A. Wilder, of Tarrant County, Texas, to provide the Defendant with a free copy of the trial court clerk's and reporter's records and by forwardLng the trial court's records by U.S. Mail immediate as possible to the Defendant Don Anthony Bonner -- TDCJ # 1819637, 1300 FM 655- Terrell Unit, Rosharon, Texas 77583/loan the entire trial court's records to the Defendant by forwarding the records to his TDCJ-CID C.T. Terrell Unit Access to Courts Supervisor Yolanda James at 1300 FM 655 - Terrell Unit, Rosharon, Texas 77583 and for forty-five (45) days.
Judge Presid~ng 432nd Dist,ict Court of Tarrant County, Texas ,I
, I ' ~ /,epee'- (r '
c:~·: )~i • 1 " • '
·!
II. Ol
---------~------------------------------------------------------
--------T--~n~~=~~C~~~~£~~~--~o~f~~~~~~'l~~~~-+----------------------------l 5v-dtJM..d ~~)£__ -h:Vc/ 061/i (~Py £?d, o/. !}czy ------j------!11L.··L~·,/I.L!.j,J.A;~· /JcwzvtkL 1/zh/,(;tV/iA 's· iJuL-..sa. II% fZoA/ ------l------'lu~/;~-¥r--tJ'JI'(.d/'(/£_~_/~.A./9 /Joc.£L.h4&<.~/t /lzw-q h.c&~h, ~.0 AA~ v/1- o / ' 4ALLJ6i// ly /0 ,LJ~ C(J1ted( C&6l- · __ &v~~:J_ hU..r . 7Ju Ji.,tlj£.. & / . {~tlV/1. /.,.. 6/J:i' 91 vttv-1¢- .
1- _- - - - - + - - - . l_l-tf2Af~~-;21£a.4-rli-';;iiuA[_k-4-fl£4:L._I'.lYA~-/Ji;_/n/uM ___ ___ H __________________ _
----+~li M9M ··h hU /l- lJ.;A,/f ol he£rtJ{~.~··._____ -------+-----1-J/-t 5£/AALl 1-o 17z-l-;ct£ 1/. ti '/_ o/· 7lta. f&.xAf Cot:/£ ------~----=oi_~~L~-1 //{..~) C/itdr/{,t. ~ ;:Jtz,f.r'll hU ./tt£.1/£ /JAJ!tE.f.J' /k-dJ 6-u;,9 1-o .fit? C&t//Z~--""'U""'-'1F.~r:~V1L_{_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ , /9-i4tV Ito·;,__/- .:f do c;&t.&70~a:.(~'d?- r~vc___ _______ -f..t,/~li ;hvrJ /HJ't~fA-&'C£ dl/ -.14/J ll?/f.:/~--~-.:.::;'X4'-'------------- I ---+-----------------------------'--·-----------------
~.... "• . ~:. ··:-- .•~.. • ;:!}. ;, ''· ;••• - .. ~ .... :·· "•
I ..
• I
... ,..- .IJ.v/ih,/, I
~.(~-~.~~~/~------~- _., . '/ ..--~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~----------------~------------~----~--------- ,. ......... _. •. ~ .::......,;,.;;:.;~ ·----~-...oc:-:-...: .... -'<~ ·:..:-- • • • • -· i'-":·, ......., . ..;._
. 'k
..• J ,..-.
' ~- R,o,,' ·'·f.. ..
''.... , .~- . ., .
. : .. ~.
. ;, ; ~ ··. :: .. . . . . •
_..,..· .. }"J )'
11~:~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-- J; .- •
. .. ~·~-·:
' (/.)
(3 .,~·· (; '•,
-.,· ....... . ', ' ... · !
. ~
• ( .ZJ. .1t</·clt~ rnA?hr../r (¥; (" ~lf;4/LC . -:6. WA/'~/....,r /9-.-v a /1- f'Ca/.4 t/, f. ..
(S) CcOiJLJ c C CoIV(//c 7/r~.I /J.;.;./ o 7~a'YHM:// . .. ~· " ('-1) lr.:.l-r' h (I /Vb._ w;!/l;t£. · li~ Jv~-4c~ /~ ~/~r; 1.-o fJAAkcr tt_,, lt.~ I? r rt£.rL ' ~/..! A-:iJJJ/£,4-/ $W-S'/G. /[,{:;(CJ;(d'f /-17¥/l r C/C/~-t-f?" Oo c..£Y ,-J;?~/S.. A;»-; .a d.,wN:/ ,.
A r~n,£/J/../1/'_;,.; , ~/ k;/.),.t,4"( LJ/f.&a..J..(' ; CSJ fo/l f.-ht[f/;_ /lf. .;?-:{(},-<./ /Y"/.I~;V"J/ P/V h_ f-t'h tJ/;_,M I'1!..4-(-_, ~i- l
dA--'J ./4)/ roc.,..-tr tu;(/ QA--4/../·T -./-41'1 /M'ltf1/Mr //V. ' /II/ .£4,/:./~1 , ,.-; ~'> () / I'· '/( .1/d••A-v/£//, .. '
..
.kHc. r4~, .£i~;&A ~•; .... . /Sl·.···l·~· ........ ! . .. 'r•"·-..---··"
-- ·-·· ' . " -' ...
- ' '4)(.-- -.~1-AC?</.t.r iJo.A/N';Or:, r 7"/J CJ A/tJ, ·~rJtC4-·T/etL~~ oL. _c.A- V/~ !" ,.. .
/1~./44<./4 ,fo!VA/M ·dt) \ ....
1: ()0/</ 14k -~Avo//:.--q, ;tl ... )I k/._ /-).~ h/tAA.61..;__ ~, i:;n..JU_c-/ ,.
CIA"&£ - /J~J tU/1-...fl;.. d:F'.· ' ' A-:. '•
!.<~V'hc/ "lc ,r ,__ /JIA:c~/I,;Q ..t-£n..· •• .,>~ ,- rLL //(./ // f/r L lfM,l .J!l&i.f t':);(,j --../-t/r '•.:.<·J---=·'- dr~ 0 l' ..{'Lf'T. .2vlt/ 11//~( .. .,.. ... . /''.k ~~ <II ' .., ,(~ . ............ '
/_{.{;;A)( ot ('CQo~ ~, .... -~ .... ,_. ' lSI .... ._~_,.
' '•\· ..... ~ ' r. /J&v IJ, ~0.A;"..-v..i<. ~ ·"· -' ' - .L/Jc1_ Xfo • .. '.' .
-· " :..- ~~-:c~ f. ~// tlr4~·;.. tJon k"'t b~~ ~ ...... ~-·.
·--·-..-. _ I
~">. tkJsA4~Jv -~-1-A..>Vf/ \,,
!'lJ ./...... 7~. ,..- '· ·~ ·. . ....' .. ...... ,,;.- • \ .j
'.:~I ··"; ,, .
.....
....... .
1-" ' ,' .,.
J..AI >/77~ '11• >
1/.S. )
• T l
/l ~l·fQ6J~~'.$ t\-'.;;. ~~;;v/ '1~~-;~ ·, 7_~'----,----- lh/.J~~ y bf.#(.JA/ $'C/I;.;{pZ1 U teglfl..t . r IJI/f /JoCt:.rP"VV(i&~'S.· J;v ·· -
. \ .. · ' . ~
.v, ·~; t); r''?t{;Ji: _?&t;;..} ·-~~:.1' . *!~~4:4 ~i/~,. ~~~;A.;.,s~,dZl~ .i!V o!tcTWV~A4'F·'·irt~A:.i ·\a~t6ivc.-.. t_~f/,/fi: -~~~;.;_.~b~:ts~;·~Ji14jj4··· . . /k:J(/,oh.HL4. /IJJ£~V\_,~z~~· /l ;_~~f:.·til'6ifi'··;4,. \~~ ~d&. ~.;[;·; ~ ·-M/r /k;,,:,.J,. 1,/v ·s-,>,~~~i~ ~/ ~1.4P7';;_._ ·lit); st 0 Lt./ . ~Aiu'! W!o~,r.)L~it~>~. ~· .-·'---------,----.:.:....._~--- c-- .. .!!._> ·· •• - .-· __:>._·_ ·-.·_ · ,,. ·--------~~~··----·--~-- . tll·. ·-b.~-ltll'~, r:IA~<J-1-:'s·. ~ 1/g~\,~/fr. · ·~:· .·fh ·f>tJiA" 'd.6YI/i.~:,;::: · .· '· I.e . 'Mit ..C' ff ul!. m. C~ FTr . .· /llt;/(,':1/A. :f:_--:~-.:::._.:. . ··• . -.. ' • ' ' ' • • • ·- ·~ j.
... {l.) . .- \
... : :·-----,-----;--'---'--------;----~----- ' +64. · /Jr.;AA,;.::.r r;t_;r · ok i&i; rN~Io 1/oA/; ~ ., . ( .· ·•
·· (;/).'~tv;~/ ...1A.-- s·~;?M"'"'-;r ·oL'· Ho lrt.~/.._~ f.·- . ,... . f.: . . ~-- ... '· .
/J..p;i;~&. 6 64Tf£ . lt~if..c · ..J<t, .-(9-~ ~·N,Q., 3";!.':' {:~/l l€ I .· ( l J i_~c.;:._·~-c---:/+0'-.L-·- - ' - - - --~ /?SS~"'lT -Ak~o.t:} }· ~-c. . -~A/L. ~~ f.J:i.,.:;,;A~~"?/It<v:T: .4~0.-" C../'PA-1' Alt:!r ~~ -~D£r 4'-'-··· ~oA-t/A.J, ltir~1d:t·ri~~P: ·1~~-~tp::.;(/Ac.__:_:._#."'--'--'r..r"'-.·~·----'------- -/i t:,·huN~ >1 liAr' t-/.H /A·~ lc teA- /M J~..t 67.-/~.6ttA4 ,....-. 'C~;;I.r. i~IJ;i:. ;f .:~~i'~~~4J· ··#A'fn~:J1~4-~-- --iJ/i. ,L'£f#~:.(iJlf'..c!! dv~~ rtf\.,fr:J · ~a- · ./lJi.c.C?,. 611/ · .dA. sc.~ Ri4d/'. Jp:/o~d ~- #'$$~,._//;4/ ~ ,6,~·- 4., :~4d/4c4:. ·~4~ .6/tk~~~f;- .Mille,-~·: .:1~! .v/~ I . ' ... .
{Q . ·-.?t~- ·._ i¢./wA//&. .·.$:J::,jAt(J.. -t:>"~:!;if.f'/( 'I· -··; :·,·.: ... _·,. .· .
-#JA'i\.,.:s ~Aftf ·~ · -" vt:hri.·l -k -~J!..~iy : -11~;!2·t~~9~ .A'J3#J!-;.~ / b;r~ . · /J"· :' ' / · _ . · • II ·· l . . P ''l ··fJ14bti-4& ~ 4/f.r,/ .:cw t'fl1-~£1' f .. /&,s"JAJ; . .!i£.--f'tJ~tt/4·. -.~Hn~ALtffA. e.: ... · _ . . . /!A yUrt~-· Aiy'J> .t4~~L~ fJ , ·(J(I / . ;;;f4k' ... t. 2lJ . (!OMSU 'rabtJ~A ·.tv ill Ott, Vu;/n,tM-~;9 -~'-1eiald: /k~~vfl~r Ar~- i~".:: __· • ·AI"- stdlvj ''Ai!.r · ~y.· of !/J64fft ·. -C:~lt4 >~ ·;a;;,~(i: ;; . . i , ,_ , , . ·-: . , ·Le:J < ~ . .., ;· : . r ,·: . , , I • .. .
l . ·t: .·;,_.--'.-' - - - - - - - - - ' - - - - - - 46.s €_;vet£ c £ /J£ C:t!JCL~ T /It.~.!Jfir r..;;W~t' ·4::> +fr~t . f.i_.c?tt&Lf __ d£su/6tt/ ~-/k:;_vA:. s~~ ·./€~.:!fi:!;~ ~L·,~:-.!:~it::if·q~'.~.~?l~{~( · . ~f._.:£_·:~~-~·-.~~~~.~~-·~~~:~~~~~~~~ .:.·~t,f:?~"(~ .· .·.: :··~c{r4/~,-c. ,SJ~~f:?J :·~tk~f ~!. &tffu(.i.~t?A/.. ·
t$;,,v -~lr~ z C't:",,··.r ·~.~·-· ~dc.Tik~- Jf;.~:. ··.~:. JJ,:. ~~~c A~.,-~~<J . \ . /JtsM4;,rctu,l:_· zf,o~JH 4.·-.fv/liiM. 11.t: MMA,.~7" f&u..v~~-. ·1Ay;.P~-.$;. ~ ~hb~A/~. A/1:~ t~~fh,C!;c.~;V/ ,4, ..&~ · 4MI£.;~·-~6·L ·
~._,, .r -··.· :;. ..,,,· ~ -.
•• _ __:__:_~---,-~~..:...__,.,--~--,-~··'-'-'-'--''·-·-'-·. ~·"~;;;:-----:--~~ ·,. ~ ---"-"'-'--------.-c:--· .,_.. ~·· _.,:-·....--,--- ... _. · ~~·*.·-. :. .· ~.-:-:~ ·_,_.T:~o.;z.a~·OA=~- =~.~. . . :.,•· ·: -=-./2-=". . :. .·~·&~~aT-". ~=1+M~··.- "- ,:.1\': : :r!: ~"·'~!·:·-:-·; ~··.,~,..,...,-;-~.....,--- --'-c-':·(·__..·:-.·_: _·.. ;,<.::.... ..
;.-. ·. .··~j r '\ ·-. ~ ... ' •• ' -, - .,·)-1. I.. :~-- I" r~~:. t--··(: •.•-' ~ J • . . . , ·v . . ·· :;.~:< ·'",'.: ·· ~. ·_L.,<'?-tiJf4::1,-. tVu· i /)/ f?lf;_tfi'fl2. :··.~-··:.c....·:--'-- ....:..______:__-,---'-__:__ __:__.. .: _·._:·.. .,. -·._,_:.,:·. .~~----'--'· ,-:· ':. _· .:·-.. . t:.-.t3·.·s.,· -~,' .:,. . ~:,~:--~--: ~: ·_.·~ ·'. :> . .:: :'::\:· . ~-:: : '\,·'>:<- .:-- ... ·.. ···. ' ' .... ~~ .. \ : ~ "' .
·.· .. -:----- ' '
- - - - ; - - - - ' - - ; : - .------:-;-.--~---___:__:_-,-- _ _---:--_ _ _ _- ; - -_______ _ t:,· /Jo;r IJ, Aa~,./;4:4 ,1:/.., · ~ _/;~ . c.,e;-e,'l~ IIA-1-· /l,t. ~~1A_f-eJ;;I;,9 ·/~f ·.k.~t£- -~~:-'A ·cl~~~r _n:~4 WM. sr~.v-~tt' ··Jy "i)~CJ-;.../5' . ....,J%~ SAR?lYA.;l~N·. n) '· t/;. f) .·.l)(il.r~t~:l !lox . ..
... ~------'--_.:____c:_S_-·. _. "'-:··--"· ···-;_-·-· ·. (f~~~i> .. ··- ~4: --~,d'·. ·~ llR~·t.r.~:,: . ·· · .
. . . ..
. t . '·
~ ./ ... ' ...... ..- .f~:M.tl -fJI/ii_f.:' . ri·.t . ', . . ' . :; . . . . . .
~· .' • \,., ~ i~ ,:.r _; ; (Y} "')_ , .
\,
. lllih~ ~·~ ~. . )'• · . :' 'l.ti4·<'~~(~ ,.· 'v ,t4: .. -~: ~ ~-·· -1/.yfljJif.l.~ ·. i.u__!L__ :Zct Sv,4dtvt7' ,(;4I_ :~M;j · ·;j;afPt1: ' - / ·:h.~ ./i~),.y J,,-<tr;~~:¥(~~tdi4 ~
.;.' .
• •.. ...: ., . . .I ...() .I I _·I . \.,,______ J/---·---------.- - - i _______km__;_ [)"M · Avl4~~a~· xA~-~="-~ ------"---'-=-=~.::1~<--.1£, LS:_ 1(L;..,.• ._.·-----' Z I -----------------~---T.OC.·_-:;_ Ud. LBI26J 7 . ---------~-----------__c~_:z;_____rWc_A..z/ tkue~.-~- , -"------------. t..5aa_~LL!L ~:;i-..c . _ · -_ - -.. ______ - ... · ~--- i ! ---------------------~4..1!f&!v . . 7 7A~M . .2_?£9.?. ' l 7: - 7"1.. :... '- ... . A / --~ •/ J . i' I _/
·_ _ _ _ _ _ ___LL;:::_~_- ~-·U2ljg"-!.L/J~!£!-·.,____·__:____- --~~___;_ . . . -I 1\. -- • (' ·.··. ·_.· /..;_}__, ·.
I -.-._ . -----------l.il-..fL~c.r- ~tfl&,Lif Ct.tt+tt:. ·. _-_ ___ ------------~- '-lc9L_: ~Jf &/Ly-&Q _-.-._______,- ,- - - ; -------~£ /uM-t£_; TA.Yd:f 9{;/ft .··..... . .; . . :
-~---~-------~~----'--·~·-··_ ·---'<·-'---.. FJl.E{) • ·._. _· _ . .·. .
,;-- ___· lk,. : C~ Mo . lJ'· 2186 ~ -· ~ld:-~~~~~-~
\
\ ..
\
r l;~~: -··-· · · · ·- -"--- . ' . ' ···-·--·- '. •·. -~.; -~ -~ ·~ \.
I I i - I I !
.j
I
. : : : ·.·· ···-·---:-----~·~--·-·-'----·-··~~----~<.--~...:__.. ~--- .: ------------ ---------- ~----- -----------'--------,---- --1-------- .,,···----- ,------.,-.-..- .......... .{)
·\., __ ,, ...
/ 1---·------------.---.:.-----------..---~-----'-----'-,..---~.......:.C--~---".......c........:.C_~,.....;,...:._~·--.,--~-'-'---..:.......-...::.------'·--..:.....-,--t,..:.......-.:..-...,:-'
··.,, _____
I \, _____ _
·..• ,·. ---- ----·~--· ··-:------
'·''·-
-: -. --:-----"---_:_:____......:__ :_ - - · · - -- - .
I I _______ ·_.:___ --·
i I
I . I I i
II .
·-··-"---"- ~--~--' .. ~-. ,••·----~-·--~·--~·-·~·-·--•• -••••" ·, .. r•'·..:-----------··-:·-. r .,« •-·,·-•:-•-:-·• . - - - - - - · --~~. ,~--:----",~"''~•.-·----:-- .,.-·--_--..,..___,_,- ..-- -----...........,_ . 'J ' I
;/' .\ 1.. ~/L._ _ _ _ _ _ ~_ _ _ _ _ _;__·- -- - ~:-----:--~-----,--:.,~-~,----'---
_- ~-------?4£-- · ~.IJNd - _ _....:.;__,_: . I '--------'- I --·- v ·- • ~;.Jf"M~r -_ LP«4 · P ~ --~- ; __ .. .' -----.----------------,----- -----'--,---:---~- ·7etf4&.£r _ C~tV77 ___:S~TIL ol'-li..x:t't:S_ ~s/£· ~-- /Jb1LBJ~0_--_ ---fkN -~Zhau_y g~~u)M, .#/'~A~;~---- t!JFf6o!Ld~------+--._-.--.· ---==-~-~,~-k~-~-~~~~~M~··--~a~~~~~=~·~~~~a~~.~~·~~~~~~~··~~=···~·~~a~=~z~·~~··~~~i~~~-~ 1 ·. r,. l).,~4vrt.d¥'t•lia~.~c&nx··&-c-q·· d~,£.· · ... ·. •·. ·.·] .\ ~ ~s: ..... ·· . ·. ·. . . .] \_ _ _ , _ m _~n.,_l:r_ &ok ~t?M ll"'u,vM • 1 7 r~ -(9Ydi_ _ ..
------~cMIL-M/i ____ o£···/uL~Ly~- PM/!--~ • 1)/:S~;v-~- P,j~/£~--- ----:~---0_£ ~;,~A;J_·-~/bd..~w~._-_.-·. _ -_-.- ._•· .. -_·_- - _.- #v---~~&tr/ _______ eu a-!, flzli. · bu,~& .s~d. · ·- . .· . ...t. . . .: . _· .. . . . _c.~ flA.LS~Z"t .· _- 4 --_..rN;n.nA-Fd.. · ..jMC4.!L ~d_L,v.,___ . :_ _ _ _ c ___ :__ _ _ _ _ _ _ . .... ' __ . . : .. ., . .
--~J(___J/4,_~~1)G,~nz~ ot" ·c&<~tval ~a.·_ -(1~ :r~)_·-- . _-_- it~~~c-, r ~-l'i : lt!J.q.if,<;//,;,---k.r6~&£__?4.)t'ic. -_ · ______ .fu .SvNJcu~r kc.. M7 «.p~T ._._-4u__ E:uA_ : l;uir-L ~_:. .· -OtiRM ·EJ&.a tru..PI hcCJAh 1&. iui;M/.1. -tv- C#L ·- ____.)J=-0--- liJfo 9/'BbO S/Jff.[A v, 8o&~. f r/ttc~ i6......d"---· - . 2 Ay~a-_ $vdt9A.vt: yq]'JJ!f_(L_J? . - ()4,~---.- ·
.. ·- , ......... ................ -,.. ---- ... ----- ------------~-------------·---- ...... ·~-- . . . -----·---·- ·---·-\--------.·-·····-·--·-··----······--- ' ·• .. :··----'-'-------'-· . ------.-----------------· --~----.-~-...,------~--- ·-----------...,. -----------------·--·:- .
' !
( .\. \ .\----· ' . ---·---- . ~~-----'-----
.srec..ks;·4f,_~r:r,·--s~ CI4M•~ foto #6!L :£,4'(£ Arvy ~L_. _. _______ . hDU5£-S 1 .. /!l7 ·.· S,1f1C2CbfA:. ___~Q.?-Y_~~ _ 4r!L. ··_ ~d. .I_ CCL~- _·:.___. _ ____ o_ _ _ _ _ au_r~.uu1vA.__If_.S/!!!t~/l._ ~aJ· -~ l'_~k&~J ·-~ . _ ~)ft_1 ,<yrL,<J -·~~~~t/o ~Ao.MJ!-_· 'A/!kU1'f,.>/,)t..r At"-L... _ _._L·_. ~oAL-n / ~Ay9,€.v4J. < tuh'M -..r~uuxiAA~+TA.d. · --'-~,.---'-'-----~--.,---c-'----":c--"--,-~-c'-- _ _ _~----
. __:~~--------:£ cl£~c/A& <" ~-4/4, -q~/J ' ~'vd.y: ~ -..J4..L_ ., . . ~ ?81"& 9 )• /.a i£ ~I£ _·_ ·A:by4 c~~r. . ,F;.Il,dund ·- ·. _~. ______1l1V~..T1tiJ.. . ·~· ----6 ot~ Q£ . /lf~~~r=.< ·-1---.'. --'----·
··_· -· t1 fJ. ·_ · . ·.A. ·_-CJ .. . . ·-:... t.fd.YtnU··:CA:•~ ~---.;.;..-'--·_. ~-'-----~~-~-:-'---;--_,·I>J.D-""o~-'"AL-L,-_ -~-··.7h~A-LY • AD~_·· · -,!-c•I}&LL·
\. .'--""--'-'----'---"-~----:-'------:-..,......:.....~~--"--t::---=IJ"--"C~::J~-·--"-.:~M~-- ..(;, 4 ·. 01 81'lK5 7 . : :.·. _,·,' ..·
·---·- .':---:-.---.-·
.·,_:·,
- - ·- - - - - ·
.- ' .. . .... ... ..............................._ ...........-------"---------~----.--c-----------~--'---,-:-'~•c·c·---'--'c-·--cc·~·.c .... -,-....·,,~--,c.....___ , _______~------,----;---"~c:..___...:.;i2;;;,::::.;,_.c...,~..-.,- . . . : . . . -··- ........ -~---·--- ... ________________:.,.:.......____ ·--~--::.: ..:· ._ _______~ ___;_:.~--·· : .... ,, __ _ ........ ~ ... -: ··- . . ' . . ·-·---·----· .. --------·--~-·-------------- ....... . ·-···:·· ----·---.:.....~-~-·
. '·
... . .· ' -..,... ·- .. - .·.1 ··, '
X f- ---G.!. ~ z .. Ci ~ ~ '. !L1J ' ~ - a -.L.. ~ c:; <C ..... ~
p.., i:i 8 .... .;;;.
•'
...i
...
,..i ._., ..
...
,,·, ..• ·.: ,.i
...
·~·----·-····- -- ~------ .·. . . ... i .! •• .· . .. •
·
' ,I >
.. i
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.