Rocky Lee Ellinger v. State
Rocky Lee Ellinger v. State
Opinion
No. O(o'~ \"'\` 00 10§~ C.\>\ -Iv\ >~<\~Q. Co\>r& §§ /X€Q-eo\\$ S'\`)c‘k\¢\ AQQ e,\\c’~xv€, ‘>Z'$&¢T¢,)t §§ T\Y°»$ 0\5< T~‘L>¢ mr\€ o`v\o\ \ _Y~Q_>c c~$ *FI?UW!|N Th@fCGL./"*t@**/\ivp’eé'.'s O\ o c)G\\ \,~Q_e, E \\1 v\c\€,{` S'Xth D"`Svm‘¢'f F 'EEC.E=\;': 2sz ;,,G_,;Wea,s £\“, €\\M¢c \FEB 1 9 2015 :>'¢xtn Dzs.'rzc'c cr _ _ , _ m "é`>'<'éi`f*k'ah’é- TFe\/as H;d ? 9 ZU}‘ ~'»~… 11 ,» ,,’ " \l 6 ‘ before 4<.. .»A'wa=r@;y, ‘cr@:.'~;< T@xaz’§czm:»z: `2':-3:23 539er A::‘zrcy, £§‘;i~erk Y\\o.. S\`o~‘<~e_ ¢>Q Y~=)._)<KS AWM.\€A wm 4<\~1 7_“<\°*“ 5\,<\:¢@\\ w;¢ma cwa \(V\O\(?OA\C,S\>~N\\.,\\ `Y"LX¢‘~$ \\`<`:°\\ C.°~\.>S~e won ?\\"\ 503 <`O SQ_ %¢TL'§ o'§ A 'C\\Q.v\,'\` _;v\ §\> oc`\ mg Q@ QG’ Mc>¥~`¢v\ gov `\I-\'Q \'__',`,< \~Qw<?vv\ ouv\c\ §`,{<Q\e_w-e~\,-\'M_¥§o»\ O'Q' A\QQ,\\Q.'\-{ &~Q,C,c>f'\J_ l S`.\., M:\§NA \>\\\_ ()\ec,\€.`\ \...Q_e, E\\Zw e,(‘ !\Q\)‘€\\o.v`_'\ Q?co Se,\ %\~c~cl$\/\M.~» §Jv°~¥e bmi %¢»¢ °\€>e>c> \¥€v\&~e(`§ev\ l Y~Q_>c k$ `:('5(¢5`3 A PEC\\O~V\.-K a°`C~S v\,°* v€,o\~:€,$'% OC\Q`\ A(’o\\) W\.'Q,V\,-`c xc\ev»\;\¢e$ est Pc>w\?~eS awc\ Ce\.>v~<.e,\ Q\»cs~>ovv<" :\~<= _Y{\l\§ ?>%.\Q\\ A€QQ\\“*" ?\°@\‘\ ‘~“ E\\¢»¢\U ¢l%»\z_‘+o (P¢c. sad vw 3a %m\¢\s\,»¢`~ §&00¢1 §c,\;\ Fq¢;\;sv \\ %o)< C\GOO Prtw:.\a<‘sov\l rings q§_(o$z A‘(){\\qw&,$ Qsov\$~€,\ 'Q>o<` {\{)Q‘€, \l(l.\/k\ <'&X \~e:o»\ &\Aé gv\ A‘)(){o¢,\ '.
A\\\\` 56\.\~\\°_$ Q. F;ASX`€¢M %c>?‘ 1_'\’(1> AQ,@t¢$o‘/\' `§_Q.,)c¢>.,$ ‘-'\'g(¢§_-:" 3\`0\\~¢_)5 Co\>v\se.\ c»\ -&¢:¢,,\ cw\¢\ @v\ c\QQ-go`.\'_ \\-bv\. l\v\c\€,\o\ va\¢>m\{~l C,o~.)v\'\\»\ A@rou<~v\e, \Ol L*-)~ A~J'>*<Z~\ S\- )Q,QQ~Q<`ch\ ,t`&><c~€ :Q‘SC, §:\- \.\ `\` P;c»\\ >\.rc§.<§€,: \~l<<>v\. Q\o\oe,¢’\ (§¢.~»\e’xe>v\l QVC\OS£ /).,"\'Lp_\'\` _>vc\{r_o\_\ “'\`S‘\`<`:C§ QL'>~""\ momth Coov\`:\§! `Y~€ond
Ta\b\z QQ~ C¢vé~=e_v\:&s `Pv¢$o°~v\:` leo T R ”QP 38_\ &\>\ Po"€. '. : A'Qv\-\;\.\_\ <>& eqc&;'gg cM/\A Co~.w\<'.€.\ 1 `\°`\,,\¢ o&~ Qov¢§zve<s 3 IKA';>¢ §§ A`.t\~¢.¢:\:t$ § S¥o»\~e,w\»e,vck' e>"v ~*c\~¢_ Co\§e, (o X¢.sve, L>¢~esqv\):cé 3 Iss¢e, Mo. \ ,‘ ooes ~\\,`Q_ iss\>¢ o€ w\~e,&\~<_(- -\-\~¢` vegemc§ §§ Covv\?\€~§% L\o`vg v\~¢e§\~ ov\ c¢.q§>~e¢>~\q. -XS$Q‘C N¢`)_ 1 1 b=,{§ ‘§\~L C<§\_,Q w\~~e,"<\-e.c~ 4¢\~1 X¢`;`o`\ L¢,V¢~‘\` "\¢>\cl 50¢~:5¢&¢:,5<~`0“\ \/\¢>\,`.r& Me,e;‘¥ ev\ q{?q_¢>`\ .7_ :$§v€, a\)¢>_z: bh<e_$ 'Y\'\~Q, C$§uQ_ w\/\Q_,"C\~er '\'\~{ A@()<»_¢`\c,\w\.'§ %v`§\¥~\ Q\€,¢>\ CAJ\` ec\{`e\§v\o\\ §\'\C<>\\ Wc~s v°\ow\m<~:\»\ MO`¢LQ L>€/‘Q<>~z_ \¢_>Q,lv\,e\ ?\e`c,e,é ov\ cpa\¢o»&?ov\ \/\c,ve_ vv\.~;<~:'¥ o\/\ § /\}vv\,vv f" 4“9;("_ MAA` AW .( - "_\`,Gs¢e, No_ C)¢\.Q ccc,<.&o¢ve¢\\
%0€5 §\’v€_ \`SS\!€, o{ W\~€_,*\~~Lr‘ ‘Y\~{ (`QCO<\<§ \`$ [_OW\Q\€;`C€ \~o'..cr€. vv\,e,(~l"c ev\ aee~o_¢>.\_( §u\~\¢v\o\(\\.\ @’§ '\-\~Q_ R<~¢\\_rvv\€,v\,"(' A<`¢\vv-<L~/\k §§ s¢;v<¢ Mo. \\ ' lo ':S$uc No. _\`wo <cee*<odvcé\ \D $°’*"S "<\~€- ;€9\>€ w\~'€)<\~<’/¢` ‘\'\~L ~\c~v~`¢>»\ ceach \,\_¢>..é S~>¢;`$c\\`d°~`ov\ \,\e»\,@ MQ,¢:\ ov\ q§%~¢¢~_\'?. c>v‘/W~»¢>r\\ 051- ¥\~Q, A<`¢\\>vv~€v~jv \\ A<`T\)W\,e,v\§ £'SSSO'€_ MO` ix \,\ :$$L>L NO_ T\/\(‘€:€, 11 boe-§ m C'~.€oe w\/~<,‘<\~~Lr "`€\~L A@()@°~\ ow\‘<\S d\\)¥\`v\j \>\C¢\ G\.X O<`:`Q\Ev\c»\ \~\`:'o`\ W¢»S Vo\uv\,¥¢~¢`:\\.\ ~A.~o~<~$'€. r\§~€.€`v/`Q \‘5€:\~<‘-\ ?~s\` ov\ Q¢~QKQO\:`{CQV\ `l\e~\.)”€ M'Q.»*`:"<' Ov\ q€€*€,c>\\¢>.
S\)M¢v\_¢\(~v\ §§ \'\~{, ,\»FC\\JVV\»~O/\A./`t K'::';»€`)€_ No_ 3§ \-L A\"‘»\\)W\€v€`§ :Q§o€ wm'z§ \z Q{"o~\\e,(` \\_1 QQ,¢¥§QCQ_Q"YQ o“§ Se_,<\)¥c_€, I§ \)v\$we><\~/\ d£c,\od\o"\\`ov\ Hg § 'V\A`Q_`F~ O& A`j)(\,`°r\ \:L\':'€.,S ch`s¢c».~"< ¥° `Y(\P\Q 3%- \Cc,) Co.$¢; '.
§§Mkm\v~%w&eo&`vu@$ 3 SA».BA %3 T@\w¢“-§a¢{¢&”m#% 491 iuaza'z%b &mm»¢l»h%»&€o&x@wé A%u auqu z&% RWXL Q\Ayez 1431 Su)zA \4§ ("\¢¢>Q;AU_ v- S*m~¢¢ o% Tu¢~s L\‘H S_vq 2a §‘1§ 3¥0»)§\:€$ `. ‘\'(g_c,‘?_ 9 7_¢,. \'S T,(\,P\._<>__ 3»\. L,Q>\ T__&_ A'<>, z»\. \p_@\ \O \\ \l \’L \'3 S~\’°\XQMLV\;‘Y o‘%` ‘§\'»q C,o`$£ P\.M‘$o¢-_v\..& §§ T.R_R.©. 38~` (C,`\ A`>Qi\\°w\-\ w¢¢:~>¢-A Iv\<\~`c,j\vv\c~/\X Cgv\c§ Q.v\?v°.€'€_(,\ C` P\CC\ ¢Q <‘3\)§\\\\ ov\ ‘D€ce-\\s@c‘ \Q>, 7_0\3, '\`o cw\ EAQ~S¢M¢\.\`M\ c\\\ve¢`\`v\¢§ ‘\‘\~t S\~q\t 3‘>~:\ &~z_\ow\ v§a-$t O§ aceé`£\~ ouré` o\\q~.>€€ ov\ CC*O\QQ_<‘ q‘ 10\3, q~/\c\ <`ec_?c~>&é. 0\ `rwc C?-\ \31<:`<~ 5§~¢>6@€ `D¢,_{\ sev\¥£wce §><`c>\o~¥e¢\ °v°¢ 3 gum WO\ g 33@0. 00 s;;_v\e_ (`c<\ \\~\z\ 0,\ ;\,\\ \\o. 'Lc>\»i, A(>QQ\\P,Q ‘%:\QA S&q\es QL\:\:°A *vc (’\w°\<¢ P¢O\m\eé <\\,A,,S<,_M¢W\` (C&\L\~\<p\ Ov\ N°\,<»M\,,.,<~ l'-l\ ')_o\L\( AQ<Q\\¢WA €vew»<& q \,\Q.k eve &`~Qg ¥<> q\\<<i@,¢\ v:b\@x:bwz ¢v\ &x\< \>Q,\:&¢°v\ w P»w»\@& /\W@\\°.M`s (>N\Q°_\>M, §QMU.~_¢M\ \,\:M >v<> ’L aims ¢QWQ:M_\M¢W\ ;,\ 5&@.¥¢ S@:\_<R<\BL,,- QQ\ \\`zo\ A@Q£\\Me¢ cjng &§M.¢\\, \>m ge no»»¢u»_ 02 q€cu,\ OV\ M¢~¢M\m.» l% ,zo\b\, CQ(§ 1\\ CQ\M<@\ £s=\=._é\ wm q€<,¢,:.¢§t<& w NQN,S?,W\` AQQQ\\M¢ @v\ /L€PU\ ov\ [email protected]\\mq_<' l ` 10\'~\_ (C/§\ 13\ Co~>v\<,e,\ §§\£A %c\\`~e_’t o'@ {¥QQQQ\\MG\ <>W\<\ Moi`t¢v\ &o w:&\,\¢£mw ‘l<\o-\ t\'~f ¢o~<€
Q(\ >¢Lv\.~) '<\ \(° ’L ¢,` ,_,\ , O\§, AQQQ,\\¢\“)\‘ d`~ec_¢<,\>~€_c\ ag CQY\S @'Q QQW\SQ,\'S PD<\C 'L {~ o AQQQ\\M\X :v\ awqu OQ M.,\:~v\ 4¢° U\)Z'X\\é`<~<>_w] M<:XC°\/\ ¥o UO"%\A ~ ¢X~r~o»w o`g Co\.)v\€€,\ '§<,~¢` /'\?§>Q,\\O\,v\/'\ l ‘: C l l o OE` `\I\.` \L( g c, § Q ("~ § RQ,( O< § &\l\,é` ‘>(`f)€,'e,‘€,(g§ \A>` § k: \§° \D\)~.’\v\ c(‘d> ;'Q ss cg \'\ \'\.*Q, \ q {‘ @-Q A~€QQ_\\ av\,“¥ , %‘:t' : $'>oe_ Q<`~€se_w\-ec\ QW~$`,W¢- >»o T'RP\ 9 33-\ (e§ 318st \\)0.\ ‘. kee_s “‘€\-L \`$su¢` V.)\'\L*<\-e_r X\-o` <"QLS¢\A \`$ ¢¢M<\~Q_)<Q `\¢\o~v-e W\Q,¢J-\- 9`,\ qq<,e,o`\ 7. `Eqs~><_ NQ`_'L`. hoes `\'\~L CSS~>Q. o-"c W`\~<k\,..~¢r '%\~L ¥¢~\`~\\ LOQFX \\c.~`.>e S~»¢:c.&>¢)<~c§.\ \,\¢`§,L W\Q<~€X ov\ QQQ~Q¢~\?
§ 43 of Ne_ ?> `. `B<='€.S Y\~~L \`<<-»€ w\~€,`<\~`°~" Jc\~o; A`>()e,\\¢wv‘<‘>' csu,;\\§`,\ ?\.p`¢\ ng UO\~)~/\lcc~c`;\\;\ W\c~ci~€ \5~€§00£ \‘d~Q.:~/\c\ P\qc,~e¢$ ®v\ Q\"o\uo.-\\\¢~.\ \/\.c,…}e W\Q.cf& ov\ o\,(>§>~¢o`\.’, S\)MMQ{\~»\ Q'Q `\\~~L A<*a\\,w\_~e,v\)€ \>uo<¢owdq ‘vc, TT\[\Q 38.\£¢>\ AN£\M\X ¢ev\¥~@»»¢\s +>»w¢\< 4¢»% q@@@b\o\*@ dowd cg ?v\ cov\,\&\o_>§t “\o &\\ew \,\ZM -¥o c[£\\<`»~\?\~€_ \`"v *\-€_<`& a<~g ow\,`\ Q¢§QV\_>.¢:¢\\ \`g<`»&<, o<` AQ_"§*LS=S 1~/\ \/\15 cl\)l\&\.\ Q\t°.__ T<~re,x\,\ar M°FL' WC*<\~Q¢-‘< 4 v¢~\:¢\ ¢\\,C\&~\ \>\<Lo\ \`\/\~L §_¢:M\ moore -¢>Q\<S~ v\o~% \/\c~\w;. S~.\¢-Cs&tde¢ov\ \`v\ '§.'\\0. Mq`§~°.<~ e&~ p~o~\>o\so"¥\`ov\ c>'% \/\\`s ?f`oxae~.'.\\\o\/L. l w\~<:"<\‘~e"r ABQ~QO`\$`,\/`,>< 0\\<'0 ¢.ow\`%\~(l\g '\"\/\¢C*A\'\.CS C\UE\\"\ Q\Q°\ S C\\ S~<\\`Q\Cv\.w\ ¥~&\:e\\ \)vo`$ ¥<-6$§ \<vLC>W:\/\e\\\\ O~v\¢\ vo\¢w\a¢f\»\ `/v\o\é.e L`S o\\o\{ ¥° \oQ Cov\€rc>‘l€r€cq l"'\ CS~NQ,¢,¥§OV\ <9~/\ &`EQ~<°`,\ Or< Wv-¢`-e¥-\`-M @{`J\~&(` c>'§` y Bdé\(\€vv\~~ev\..* ('~0`\)¢,\<:\,.¢\ \A:S QI`O\QO\'\\\OW, ,`(\\""Q-$'e- `\`S<,\>€,S \/»o»v£. W\.Q_<\:\` A\\ <L;¥~Q.w<:c>v\ o&~ -\~t`~»g \-o Q<‘QQ°~<`& °\ $»EQ\<MQA\K\ \D"?*=~"< ¢~~\c9\ $\>QQ\QM~‘LVUC )<\'"L ~F€.c_or`é\ IS q\<.o C~R@c\oer~'€c>.:\€; Qv"$~/o\v\X -\~° T_Q\¢P\_Q_ z»\.c»Q>\ ©\ @W\ 3»\.§;§¢\\_ Ac~cy) Me,-"< ?\)~<`$.\)a`v`_st ~\-o T Q\ p` 9 38.\ w\ `I€€v€. MO .\ §F“Q.S)\~o\}`~&_c\\ AQ@Q_\\av\"< C,om§\o~¥v\% "¥\~K‘< ‘§\»`.<L_ (L€Qo(`*\~v_<"$ {\Lc.¢>r‘¢,\ §§ W\:¢»‘»?VL<K ¢>¢/ ¢~v\c\ O\_\o$e.v@v §<“e-\ ¢=\qu“ou’\{ r‘c§,o<~¢§. Ev\ \"\¢\“\"¢\5 \co °Y\ML e<\.`c\i`¢~x\ »\¢<`:¢~\_ §~e_e RQ\» bJ\`§<\/\o\)$v \'\~1 record AQQQ,\\¢»\~Q is W\<>~\>\‘L ¥o ¢¢`:4£ ‘w\~\ ¢\atmg “ve<~ cev:e») ?v\ ¢\QA:\,..,,\ q»¢kc‘s$ ov\ ‘\'\~L \-v.`o\\ gv°r-&`s 5¢4~»`5&¢¢\¢®~/\ Cw~é~ vo\\~\&¢\¢l v\e<.s <>“Q' qu\&\\ Q\ae\. `{\~<L vec¢»,:~é \`s o\ ¢ev\¢\;&\\ov\ §chh~cv \_@ M\ qqq.;.»\ ¢LWC\ w&\~oo»v *<\~@ re¢°\~é\ ;& rs rm&os<:\\€ \-o C\Q\UM:.~< W\~C<\~%.~ “<\,~o.¢{ oq~£ ¢..v»\,\ Q¢'\Qw\:o`\ C'Ss`.>~e,s e<~ c\£r<~¢c&$ `v\ 'k\w` Q\Q_o\, '\$ee, §o`-\<~';\»\ V_§ `§~‘on`$ 3 3_\)3` 'S¢\ ( "‘13) Y\/\Cs C\a;m vw~.~s\- \_~.<2_ RA<S~¢¢$§<LC\ ov\ {*cs me.¢\'¥s, <S€€_ §¢>~w.\<` Q\X 2 `§Q.)<°»s 3 5\»0 _S& ` "\_3» X» 55 v<L w o . /L Cves\x\~;<k`
'&\~L ;SS\)Q 09 W\~Q-W`-°»f '\`\~'~‘L \<`Se\\ 4,0¢<~"? \/\,¢\<:\ g\>¢\'\"»c\\`c,&\`ev\ \/\C»v{_ W\.'o,c~;><' ev\ O;QQ~L¢>»\§¢ ]/0 §\.»MM¢_.(\,\ o~§ -\-\,_¢` A¢'\va\~\v\,‘b P~"`€~)O~vx’¢ \~o `¥RP¢P 35.\£¢8\ SeL §va~/~c~.¢\\.\ QV~QQ~Q,~.A,¥'€£& ‘%»oq- '§€SQ»~L N®`\ o\`oe>o-e A(`C\\) \sz\/\"T ©u(`SJ~o»\/\'\ ‘\’o TKPCQBB\\§L§ Is$¢€ NO~ {L A?Q€\\ow@¥ Cev\,\~@wc§$ `\\M>~* ~Q,<`c`er% &x»`<,'\ m¥ oo:¢\€~\<\\ -¥<~\\\\ rzvc&~€¢`~`we\ \~:S L.c>v\v\"c,*<"\`€>v\ ¢>\v\rj\ '\'\v€_ SvA\Q\/"\€"\'* 0~\/\¢51 oha\€r ` \` Q\M:M\ wm w q>~>\m¥¢w`$`;‘l£` »<»»»~>< M~\a e§wo\:s»\ "C\Q 'Q-\c,’§ °`<\1»~\_5< `&'\~~L X<`Tw»\ va(`~*v \Qc,\¢~€cl S`»r:€¢_\\`;&\`ev\ A-§ 0\ E`Q_\ro\go;\-\\ov\. k~Qc\<`I~/\.c\. ]\'\\‘CC\<LC( €,<`¢`¢>¢S ¢L* acce§.\c\v\§f' ¢>":'C\`\~’\'¢`~\ ~'\~~e€<>`\ MA\,\ v\o¥ ov¢.<&\`v\cm\'\\\ \dt FQTSQ_A O»* \’\3$ {`tvc\¢~¢\_‘v¢ov\ ore QJ~Q\>Q"¥~`O\/\ LSC€ _\_o.\\\or` \-|-j S\`°»¥{ `Y)\C¢§M_A()Q-` \“\%'L S\JU '2`A 2_\*`0\ `~\¢o\».:€.v°-(`, l_&’ c\QQ-Qo»\¢vdq ¢Qv\§-¢_~Ac\<‘ "C'\~c~`% l l\€, bucks W°‘<‘ ?(o?~e.o\`\ ¢~¢Q`MOV\\\<L~.'€C( o<` W[‘<\/\@u-‘c c,cs->v\€~€.\ ‘k\~£~/\. \~c> ~£\~o.%v€¢`€. o\ \/\o\\z;~e_~r$ -cor'?u$” €;-Qc_~¢_e,oa~`vca\ \`e 0&\\~0.,¢\€~ %`)<;\¢\ o` C,ov\_v~."c,&\`®»\ wo~..-»\c;\ ¢£¢\'\,{¢Q_ °\ u<g\€<( ‘\'\'\¥v\,e.\_ KS€,L Reu/\~IP~CL Y_S SSY°~'\‘L YX `C(`va\` AQ(\\ L`%L° 5\'\-) z<§"' »»~+z> w 3§0\:\`wi ¥° U.,~\,£\`\ v,;»<>\ »e\w` O\AM<,»:'Q\~MJU¢¢ J~UV,:¢Q M€vc<s cfc (..c,_<’ 'z.c;,\?> ;$ §`,walmw,%>w;\ Q¢N>¢ sovg¢d< \-» &AM’¢ \):@\ \,\%\o~ev$ Ce(\§vs($e€. EX pgc*<~< Q\»o»vzz T)L C¢¥\~\ A`>Q »\@1 sw z.; \=e§`) Y\.`Q~L &=,K q<\~.~$ moe \~k. W~.U:\ ev\ “Y\~I<, @v£cew't ¢\CQ{¢,`\ a\/\A \`s Qfo\>@» gaf gev\<:o(~era~ &:°v\ ¢v\ &QR,~U.\ <»S< S.*&¢\€Mzw& ew\~i~;¢& .\v\ ¢¢>vme<,e¢¢v\ w~'~‘<\\ EN\>W\:=>A N`,Q\;k\:¢»\ ?N,¢£Qérv\¢€ L-§e:e W\w*r'\€?_ ve 3&°`\<\1¢¢»¢\,0 xqu 1\<\»\ sw 24 §L¢§> A.\ Q,<w\¢¢w ex ¥;W_»L g §®€om,; k .»,»QQ\QWL.CM\ (Sp:@& egch O\OBTD~TV\ C..E>MQ\L‘¢'C R`Q,QOF`\<'QF`$ R€C°¢C{ \`S OL()e ro(§\"\`d~'\"€ \>Www¢ sm Y<<M> QL\,<¢.Q>\ cwa B»M.,Q\\ ' :§4\>-& wo- 3 res¥ee<~¢<§) '*£rn`_ é~' ‘-"¢\\ … bo€$ “t\~t (`$So-€ v\->\’\`Q,\>\~C/<‘ ">\-L Pr@@¢o\.\\o\v\\'/S
q u.` \\`\,\ ?\¢,c,\ og\~ e<`:C\¢`“\o\_\ -\-~rdo\\ vo\~w\¥o¢<\`\\.\ vv\¢\,°\~a` \o~n__,§¢.~g \'A'*L:v\¢\ §>\c.c.~€,c& @./\ graboc¥\`ov\ \/\¢\`.»£ v\A.»Q.»(`:'S< Dv\ O\€Q~€C`,\'?
SQMW\'G\J`\_\ O-Q- 'K'\/\,~L A<`c\vMQ,W-& ,P\:¢`$¢c\_v\:¥ '\~Q, Tf<)\p€§ 33~ \(3\ &”L §`2'€- §~>v\~v\~c»q~»\ gee \`q,$v\*€_ N°`\\ -o\\oo'o-¢. /`\<` uw\¢.v\,’v pof§¢&v\,>¢ _YR_P{Q B%- \§\’\\ L`¢,s\»£ ‘\\SO` 3 AQQQ\\q\/\‘\ q,¢~\‘quu>@s `Y\/\o~>v covers -Qx€<‘r \`~/\ q €€c\owc\$ im \~:; qv:\&\\ Q\U\ mg o¢:C\¢-»o\\ %\~:»o`\, akch +\,\K\- \\~"s qvi\\~~»\ Q\~€,c\ wake .`v\\)@\~»v\’vo\¢~:\~.\ Mo\_c\i, Adww.»»?c\¢\ MQ,,V\>< ¢~Uv,:»ewvccg 92 cap cc? ’LL,,\“§ W<»_¢L m@-& Ov°\\'ew~ec,o, bv*v Y\~L re,U>»A @V\ KQQ~<>,¢~\ \`S €v\¢ov»`>\~e¥€ O\\/@X c§`b.@g V\o-& M\\ow aQQQ,\\aW“< -\`<~. 00\\`<,9_ '¥\'\Q C$$\>€ c>§- Q¢ve¢s <>3< e¢~>c\tv\¢\\ \W`:¢>\\, Q\¢>`:\~»s -“r\@a< a°QM@w\\<b\M@W>< v§ov\ Q~>\m~¥:v-w{r`s <»\U.\ 04; ¢:S\>:\¥\\ q>v eca»¢\cw%\ §`~;Q_\ Wks rusu<€¢¢:~e_,d\- v»\¢l~».¢~ C_C_\>, "L(o_\j> §§ Q¢OE€<~ gap C@v\$:oq~ewodm\~>--\ Ov\ m€r€~z.o~\ Qv\ 3d &°\’%-»‘L-`\ QV\-'\QA`~¢ o\ \`v\ rt¢=> "~°~'\"°’ "` 0 § § robo~\`~`°‘“\ roc€»e<§~¥\~ s'. 4a1 W\Qc\`§v»ez \i_‘ §‘vo§vc T>L,Cc. A \°&¥`$§ ‘? °\ 99 b\c\\_\ SW z<`< 5|'\§» `\§-~L `Q._><\~€~w€~`®v\ o»v\c\ S\NYQ\vaW/\/Jbo»\~$ow @£ w -(`"€§c>r\<§ :S O\QQFOQ(`:\O`A€Q `, :S$\r~€ \~k§ M€,{`:\ . vs §"‘oxM ~Q(` \)Qev\ ~&\~L Cs§¢e€ Q_<\<Lsz-\-£c§) A°\><€e,\\av\*< &e¢`€\.\ \.e,e_ \::\\~`¢u;\';r @>¢~o <.e\‘ \`$ O`Q "c\~£ O\>?v\~\®v\ J<\'\°~* A§>\>€-"\Q\~Y`$l qQQe¢.,\ \/\o~s vv\e<~f*v qv\¢,\ g<\¢.»\<> '\-\~¢ c,o\»<~>r q¢o»~/»*c mw Q,)¢&`ev\srov\ o% X;MQ_ *v<> Qc<;Q<.‘-Q, svc(?\o`w~ew‘v¢~\ ",>p:¢;` )¢c.~»<», ab Q»AQ¢ W§>Q\{M@W\K\co.,\ @£ J¢\¢L Ce;e~§(\ aw\§ ek\\ew c&QQQ,\\¢w\°\¢ \`o &CSM?<; qg?€\la¢w"c Ce\>v\¢,g,\ &er rv\c¢\~w<@,&£v\¢e av\d\ ‘><\Ou,€cl §J¢~@ $Q,, AQQ<,\\@W& xvqu w\,.»>v )\-0 3¢¢\.¢< <\<»,\:Q£ &@ w\\:¢,\\ B<QQQ\KA~WX Me~.\\ \D~L Q_-¥C\\~QA , \§\r-\\'_>\ C,<~>f`c\`\o\\&\/\ &v\c) \ 4 g €.SQ‘QC,¥'Q\J'\\\-\ ‘>`,\.d M: \A-LA, /90 Cl<\/ f///‘A/je/" Roe.\€~»\ L~¢€_ \;\\Ewc\Q_(‘ (Qf`o €€\ q‘1&\°\(,»\73¢¢) %C`¢\<§S\A.W S'\~c\\-»` §o~`(\ %o\¢ AS®O \$ae\~c\~e_¢€ov\ `_v`°"><°`$ ¥Sc§§ \"‘\ C\,Q_{`¥:'QCC¢>\ €_. ag §Q.<\.>:v_& : C,Q<~\;"Q`;\ ’§\l\o~,¥ t (AOC,`G\\ \"&L E\\:v\c\g_¢\ l/\-QQ~Q\\O\\'\.K'GY`O $Q\ \/x¢&\)£ At\:v€,ha< g '\»(`\;-<Q_ L®?\,\ o% +\'\`~S Q‘(`O $Q_ \O\`?Q:Q n '\`o -"€\~L S:>¢‘%\/\ AQQ€\\K\{ ©Is‘v`?¢:¥ O‘% -Y&><o~<`\c_o~v\@\ TQ~><¢~€ \¢>\ \)w;§.;.a sake <\/\°\:\‘ 1;:~,1< c\w `>'OSJW\Q _ » \-\~ " EFC’?O\~A "k\l\~$ \L` Ao`.\_\ (>'Q \_`€.\)\->(`G`(`\\ \ 10 \§. , Roz./<7 Z///)’\/Qif '# (‘ic, 141 ‘+c) %m£<\~ow €¥¢\>W _\.°`;\ §`:'>¢,>.= clE>e® leew&@rs ov\ ( T~z_>c °~ S "('S¢§B Uv\swc><~v\ §Qc,\o\<~o\\~d¢w\ ¢>& _X`,v\m°`&z ‘X. KQ¢;`\»@¢ €Rs»&grl aw_:m~»k¥g ax §§¢m¢<k@vg S&k$g "S¢»t\ Ao \M;¢\g \,V\ gwe,°`<- ow\'c\ o`q;rm v\,\°&£r QQN,`\`N_` o~Q @G’_<‘S\H`L.\ `Y\'\°J< `\\~‘L I~/\'Qo<`w\o`¥\`°v\ gew\-c`\`-zc\ Tv\ `X\~e Qo¢\e,c\o¥~»c\ Q¢o §§ \F>{~\\¢;€ 69 A@()<'-\\°~v»'§ <>\v\oq Rec\;.)€$i Q¢,` \':,~<%ev\sbov\ @'€ ~¥EMQ is 3eva c~_v»<£ C,o¢c€_c;\ §§ \*\~L \‘a~QS&' o{ Vv\`,\ \<wow\~eé(c\~€_ §’v.)o\`v\ ¢lv\<>\ €;`c\v\.~cc\ T\\:S \L\‘<\ C\¢M\ 02 \:<»_\§\,¢M\\\ zo\§_ v , fgoc/<y 5///`/1/9@/” l% LH_WO @vo`&$\/u>- S£<>NXQ 5~>~1\ Q>b>¢ qOOO \¥€WA'°_<`So\/\ `T‘L>< o`g ?§¢§3 /(Q q No_ O(,,_ \L\- @Ozog` C‘,Q\ DES‘§<\TCZ`§ 04 `Y~Q.><¢>~S P<X `Ym&¢¥_gwo\ lT'e,><c~$ §\bc)€\>\ Le_€ E \\;~».;\Q,<- (\ng, \\0\v\,JY \|6.
T\¢\€ S)\`o`k; QQ `§txe~< AQQQ\\€,€ T 9 SO»:A \§°V\'S(` o`\o\€ C,e \,.<-\ '. moXteA ge " Y:M€, E>< ¥'€V\<:OV\ C)\V\(,\ 0 (`A~Q_(` \`O Q\m\@~\ \_;<», '\§\\:M\U( epa se, v»\°»e¢ &\ML Qe\>¢* <¢o @`¢We< k 30 AM\ \:M<», 1,¢\~¢.~<:°\4 w \,NLQM{ AUU\&WX \M:d Mw\ 0\,~¢¢\»\ &Q@@_q\u>v;r Y~£¢@»~C\_ wmva [email protected]_P. ?>~\.s‘g¢\_ 3“\.(,@\~'3*~€@&>\ _\`\~~L~¢\< \M-¢~o_ \o‘o'ev\ v\.o qu,\»\\ou$ €.>c‘ve-AS.`®\'\~S Clv\ow\."c€d \>~J\ J<\~¢ cou.~’v_ 911 AQQQ,\\¢~-N' on\\&< gow¢*<- c\r`ow»\~€ \-\[3 vv\c>'¥\`e v\ _ ge$€~e,ci\§`_>\\&\ §g\>vv.'.\§\-Qc,\, 1 Rec,¥v\ LQ,€ E\\leief`<@r\o SeB Q>¢>x qe©® \$.€,\»\obc/`$`o ¢\/ v>€ ?'S`G$`% Q£r¥i*§:CO~/~\~<a €>Q_ §Q-r Q»?'o~€ ‘§ l R.,¢_~¢~K E\\:N\Qr t '¢Qr§:~;»\ 4<\,\¢3< § »\w»{ <»,\@\.\»e,»€¢£ Le<»»\ e";~ \l\/\¢,-\-:»~¢v\ l&r e_>o£-cv»s?o:/\ o~Q §:-~.»Q exon OCA\U gm §W@\QMV¢< w NU»A §§ AP(,<»_A¢$ ch<-¥ ¢`>Tx“v\'\ \D:a&¢?<:‘¢ \`-L><°~¢"€-°»V\°\.( \`°*><°\<' `C\:< ls'+”\ ¢(<L\\ o£ pew`,mm\( zo\§, »<' /C@cz< 7 E///`n/j ar P>-J~;kw §\-..\~1 §°_;\ P>@>Q 010@0 L~¥€\~OLWS¢N 'T¢,>¢=~"> ¥Y¢Sz
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.