Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Booth, Marcus Dwight

Booth, Marcus Dwight
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided January 23, 2015

Booth, Marcus Dwight

Opinion

•>mpiMAl onf pii\l A I UKtbllNSnL Couer Shs&k. /Y59VY /Able /Icosfo^ Cieck Cou<4 Of Cnwioal Appeals £upr£(v\t Ccuri blelg PC &CX l220«-23og' FILED IN .RECEIVED IN MOTX 7*7//' COURTO^NALAPPEALS COURTOF«NALAPPEALS jAN 2 3 2015 JAN 20 2015 U£6r LlerK^ Abel Acosta, Clerk Abel Acosta, Clerk koelc££d pi^etje r\nj my Pewion ^or QiscfetionGfy kzuicoj-.

Please Ale W\£ *PoA and ixw 4 fe ^e cSenhcn o\ Wie Coot/,

address sUemn he\ou), X also fefuesi ihaT you mk$y /vie of ikt Ca*ds calm &n

O locerely )

(3 (W>7/. 7W*

i Ab. IHH-00259-GIL /Marcus 0^ feoo +k rm state of rate Jclenliry Of P^r-ft'es o^i Counsel Trial Ceuff: A/ppe/Zanf; HoAor&Ue £oWn /X Oarr Marcus. 0, <WA"'^ A/ Lorai^e 5f 3?6/ sfct aS/7 &cJ fVlidW^Tx. WO I QPasojTey«5, 7793?

POidlQAcli CouATy yu. Lora.Ae Si; 5uik 500 MyU^ Tx 73*70! „/lpp&laAl(5 Trial CouASel- BfeAJ /), /^tarcaA l%i U r/l/nots Lionel ^T^WS. W0|

J» J- v * C o a e

rurfieS. . , . . . fi Table. Of Co aW-B ... . . , li.!* Ir>fkx Of /Utarrhes-*. ° • .llii bfalemen-f Reatandina Gtol /lr<juA\£ATa, , • • . -Z

firaunoU -for ^vfe^.,. * . . ^~°

Prayer t6r Kilter,* * c *. 7

CoAnicxxhofi Of Service, „«„ • • • 13 Cases! -LnoUx Of /)u#\QnfieS ager

/w Ex Parle /Wa fee.Co*. %) 67? SW &I, Hlo^lX,.. t,,7 E* Parle kro^A £t^C<w.%) 15% &d 2d, ty53&)4,, *, « 7 G* Park Torres (Te* g£%) ^3 Su) U ^t «%.„ . .. 7 Oodcn v 5fa^ fe V I®?) Ll SU 3d 691*** -> < 3 "Htirv\asoA. V 5fo+6 ffo.Cft'iA>%>> fifr?) 72£ $M ;)A "3l&,„, , ., 5 Tn/.h v/ 544 foy 6^ V ^ 563 £W. ^ #to> 923 ., „ , e. 3 a v z>

SJricUaJ v/ 5f*4 (Scfe 2051.2°) L\% US. S.Ck UP) 6*7„ . , , , 3

J 0 *' «

nu braremeni Ke^ar^ino Oral flrcjumervh (Madams/Sirs, X do no-/ fully understand uhah X am ^g/a^ GaoI X houa no attorney Ko Kelp rm do fe n^Kf. IT -feel // ooa/d bett&r WeA'} me ~fc> i/erbal/ £?a?6<£ my case 0especially in ceqerds ho cjM all hanspiced a-} my inal dale. 6jA<*a X frW io fire my attorney* £o many hkincs are corona mmy OQ£& hd ai -/Ac fi^e X aj^s faliAcI Ac fhe -Paahs Qr\d oy (xdhw my frusT mmy oiferAey X 6Jas oiAakle -/o avoid "/Ae oafoo/vie.

POy /ack of knowledge and re&oucces art hinderiAc me^ but -fke, Operjunify +o be asked (freshens Qr\d ask questions uauld make up for fkof Q(\c\ possibly brine ho \\he (v\ish&k>s X Cm uncuJar^ of. X Coa^ afford io aeh 4\\S tJrorvz.

Thank Yea for YoucT'^^

Introductory T7C HQAlomii 'JUSTICES Of TH£ COURT OF OZIfAIM APflE/)L£>: (U/Self IKe QppelloA^ (AaccuZ D. &oo4k, respecl& lly ^aUifs •fkis fer/A/on fir Discrel/dAQA/ £Wa; in accordance uitk -fbe-lms duks of Appe\\ah& Procedure in response io ihe -trial C&As July \H& £o\L{~, jucWneAf &f\d Sertkncina of Auen/y -five yeafSD '/eyas D^oWa-I ef CnWnal v£tff<<:&;, QAd s\\ouj$ ike courf as folUajs' LOLL clement u \ l r ^

On [Aacck 11^2G& X uos arrested arvd charged co)A Possession of a (LoAroWed Su^s\ancc^/Jasper[An t*)Ab Quidence-. _2- -fdd rny attaches/ brent fAermn T cJonhed ho ckeJIariQe 4ke. HrrtshnQ 0$icec$ probable, cause for puma me fro/n pay ueMe ouhick led ha fke. fr\d\i\Q of clruas., and also AAe Shhcs accuasahon of possession of cl.muck larger omsuM of druas found in Ae shfeeh CJhiU X uqs already CuMed in 4Ae paftok Osr. fOy attorney qquc me -Rake -fccfs about /ny nohls aad oih.eC \^crcryGMo/\ obouA my ease, He. also cjflhheld ciafAenlno euic\ence fro/*\ iwe u/vAl/ oJrler hucrunQ dc^n my-fi^l-pto 0I lOymt^^cjktch uxxJA kaue e-Pfecred rriy decision ho hum doun hUe pU^. /ny aHornty also a((ou>ed urdue l/N-H^ixe <3^d cteAdicA^e ghatcmenk from People of <jvW pocj^r Ad influence rny pr^Secalcrs -decis/oias /ai/oIlwc Aiy oase, /4f my hid Tub I^^ClH X hneJ h fic-c my <dhmey atyer cominc \o ike cphcLsfcn rv\y affawy cltd aoA Kquc Of\y hesh inhcesh ah heci(4,Tud<j£ Rohm Oaff refused me rr\y &IA /W/ioUenf

nierneni & Pfoc&Wal n\Sro(\: AFiW fnofon vor Hppoirslmend' o4 CquaczI io Conuichri CouH- Sep!, £.01*/ 2. Hzci&jaa response ArcKi HDislnch Cou-r\ 6p Appeals ashnq uky is my appeal b^iACj filled unlinely Ckfd uky am X -R'/iViq /'o &pie(k dec,I case, £>epT 25 QO\H 3.1 fiW ray r€Sp6nse *CW £*2o^\ '*/. X recia/ed /A<£yVe response Och lip 26Wx 5. X 'filed 4 AlcAtfn Aof e/leahom o£ A/Kwe1 ^ -fi/e my Pi)H U Qourl o& Cnrni/io/ 6. H&\vJ4.d d<z$por^-t her A^<? £xA?aAg^ Oct ^ 26n &rm(\r\ fW XneffecW Ussishance af Cou^Qel due ho my akhrney nof okalltwiacj fke arresfi^a oncers probable cause for physically puling ma frcnn my uebick %uhch led ho drags hzmcj -Pound, 6>pguao1 Ga^ Plrcjumenh On. (Aarck I1& <20/3j X coas pulled from my uebvcfe, by a police officer jusf offer pullina fnho a club portinj-loA(/^x. Code., Cc\r*\, Proc, Ann (art l£M) a p^fSoA f$ acc&sfed u)\w\ be- is actually placed under reshaink or {aker\ /n-fc cuskody. An arr^si occurs af Ae. mor^nf -/ne pe^Sc^ freedom or rnoueswAT is restricted or restrainedJ •£3 by physically puling we from My i/ehick ond fercin<? /vie q/5 ciqamsk aw car fly WdarA cA moje/nenl uas reskictea* f\ dollar W' contain ins 03Gq/0d. /Aa/ tjes /n my jap pncr ko heme pulled ouf of my car fell on \W Ground and CJoS cedrieOed jy tke. polico, officer. (irui* 1/ Skate (cam fipp IW)5CZ 5M 2d %to (/fores/- ll,m)Xn order &>r €\j\deN2.c Seized incident \o acred- h he admissible,^ ike Srchtz wost shooo ikz, eysismnc^ or pfcWJe Cause eJrkUCstt SwM 9X1) kme of arrest or SeaccU oxs mock)jke.affe6hm officer did nor ask we for license, or insurance, ror dd he qiue reason for fulling me &&/K my v<A\\d<Lt (Gccdcn \i S\ak Ll S'W 3d 3>X tttmind tom ^HM^/Or^s and tfarcok.cs m>lo) Xlieqal actisk or defeidio/) of defendant frJirkout probable causes rendered defendant Sokse^ent cfhandancAenk of Cocaine, im/donfary Mas required Suppression of eudeAai. of cocaine OS $J e£ ifepl defend ($**^ ^ Measures U,fc) fthcrdonfAmt o( properk/ occurs So ash authorize, pclice b iate possession of prap&rfy if He. defendanf intended io chcjdon fie, pc6Mckf and ki4 derision h ohandor\ if cj^s rxd due to police- misconduct USCA Cms, ,4n Hd Xf lie officer UfOuid nol kout pulled me (W\ wy cor /ne dollar kll ljoM koue nof fell er\ jk gcoukIi f^S X (^cubi rA hauc b^A d^ar^eA ^(fk possession* The Aifsl Ame- n\y attorney ore/i-l morao/s come \o see. me at (Awa*d County Af/<?*4//o Cenkr X kdd h<* ohed kapp&ncd Of\d fk^k X ddnl feel ike oQicef kod Me ryk^ b pjl me fro/* my i/ekicU. /fe sWaJ lA^-f 4c officer uxxS uirkir\ Ao rkkh\ bud af kked kime he htf<W<V of ike eudeace So k^u) c&A<i he. OWC khaf decision, Xrr\ no cWomcy \xd X found qrautds onA ease loco Sc^forh'irfj my belief oP u)kcd kfpened^cjky cculdM net (SfriSand v/ Wa^rgk *4 US JfaiWJoytGd. 20SSL.fr) 7"W r^uirei sAo^j^g ~%ci K\e councel made CCrors go Seriousc iked Counsel tjaS not fuAediGntncj as mc COAfisd Quaranied by we SlXtk nrnendmeArd

XA^ffecAic^ Hssishoace of Counsel due to my cwomey nof cka/tonciry arodio\lihy of Stakes accusation of possession.

LDfourvd Iujo /IrcjurA^AT On fAarck 11^2013) Cxfbr U^ arreskd and Cuffed iV possession of e\ Cjydroled Substance, X ljos escaped by 4&o officers h a police csui<ex that ljcs parked ike sweety X u>cs Scorched and and put in ike back, bJkm in ike keck Od the poll CSu\ser Tsfoded trytno to tefnwe anoHer small hw of cocaine fronx My boxer briefer Onca.

Xreinex/ed 4Xemptied if on tke seed and stacked fa iry and gn^de, rt into ike s&d U&rq my skcrfs- fill my mouemenh caugU He okntion o-f jke officers and /Ly eewt and opened tie door and discovered 6jW X6j^s doina* X coas pulled fn/n lit police cruder and edrznsmly Zmcckp Xwas jken placed on iVc^tound at ike beck of Ike cruiVeA One, Officer Shod CJaick euer m^ ukile He. oiker collected Ike evidence tU ike. beet Seat okHe police cruiser. nfler jk evdence u)o$ collided lit officers helped me io my reef ^UJhle kelpnc\ mc up one or He oNicecs noticed a small account of cocaine en IW ground od&ce~ Xao&s Jus4- sitting, TA-c Cocaine came from my skods fnom toUr\ Xwas /'/> Ae. hack seed of ike pot/ok ear One. or He officers Grated cmo^er evidence- bog a. tried h coned uk<\f ke could off of -/Ae ground* Xuas Hi«2A fUced back in He. patAt car, ft fe^> mmidts laker Xmkceck lie hjo offxetb dom a peritnehr Stearck of tke parlmcdof\ One o$ tkz officers look underneait ike front of jke pafrde Cor, He sfood op and Jcid ike. dker officer to pa|| tke- pakode car up i Once tie pafrde ear uas pulled up one of ike officers Owe io my cJindoc) and showed Ale tux> lanae ormunhs of ukne pou)der^ later tested to ke Cocaino* from jfe kn& Xodas usdf^d ftun my Car by 2 offcecs M\fn*jk a club parknylai fill cS c&& Cnd Qecple kl X<m put in He pofrde oar I aejar tod an opportunity to kkrocJ /Ac eocene uM ike fc ffoda^lt pcWe ear Uhn Sc <&*ecs pJU mc A*<\ fie uekick h collect ike evident | 6 O o ~fr<3m D\e hack Seai^X u^s exfensMy Sea-fcked Ond pieced GA ike around Or tie, back of ffe pofto\& car by Ike tuo officers, /yfeuar cjs-s X (dole do ^A^xJ #\e coca/ne ui^w Al W of jta par/ok cur L)\fiodr one c& Ac a^t-iceo Seeincj me do so- Urine simric or- tie around X ojcks rjoieiid by one oSS-icer Me ike. <dW cdledA auiderte ft*~v ike keck Seed* The inside cawefox 0% ¥nl rydA Car sk^s Aa» ciiffcx/r ord ksu> much rnovemoxf X rnade h retrieves He eooxne XgfAnkied a*\ Die beck Seat^So hou> uzdd X be atie ko repeat ikd Sarte^actm fa retriejje QAyfAin^ ifai- loca not fLrd tden X uo5 stroked cd\(U benfo ucJeLtd by fkc c&cef, UU^s a?& Jlla^kcS^lpZ^lJi- Conuichon &r possession ol illecclc dfucS regu'ircj v^d jit aausd mA hofarki tout exercised actual ccrt^codrd] or custody oh sobska^cc^ bui also be, conscious d\ Ki5 connection uitt Mr Cfd knoun utci it c^cs j evidence soXrices akick artt'rr^aixuely jinkr h«*> k> f^e Substance, Suffices ^ (p^l ik*f he possessed d b\°u\/iciy•. lire, o^bkc cannof Dc6o\fe llvis uiriouf c\ reuScncjole dcubk Dcu^S ord JUarccktS &* 65 -UeiendoAf rmst U cdfricrwdwely linked 001H drws allegedly pcsSeSSedi but Inks does rd- hade k> he S6 stfbno iked if eludes euery otter oastandtnG reasrncbk r\fpoiies\h except defendants guilt.

Ihe SCeno, u)o$ a crouAA cUo pedum-lot m a kef cn^e cd druc, or#\^fhe- ctcG«\e, <tau^ on He Ofou/d couldU udonqed h anyone ol a hundred people ft&f cjzre out ibrf- nakf, Wr's q nitfeo fhat u\w\ H\c police sto^ (*f> you drop your -drugs and uoqH o$f.

Himascf) v/ Skdc (TexC«« fro? m) IM M & 2(o3 Oaks \J S'tak (TeyCr^ fipo m) IM So) 2d I1H Kut %0li>'./packing Qf\d Supf&rfvtj Credit)) lit/of Defended. /linc^inc X cJcakd htfjlh tke ckatues u^y uedd my Mamey no\ file rmU to chalice jUts.j&jen a%r kWiq h^ foo7. (x>found Three- Xne*rPecAi^e/ fissis \onee ol Counsel by fcimcj Jo Oct as locoyer QQenh'

r% mv ftrsl pre-Wl in fit r*cdk 0l (A^j 90^1\my aUomy tod me. Me pcosecukr /"s oMennj /6yrs for Hie Possess^ dT«^r^o^ rle Xds&dk, Xidd my attor^y-fa See if M* prosecJer till drop He 2e&zdfs aJ X*)) kk He /Oyrj £*- lie p*ssestp*/hir«,pesin<j}f$ not X'll He "" -Re iGyrs fcr tml r>°s3esSiGn/tar\penr\c aod ac fo fried Son We ^ essaulfs, A'y affofAey Came hack end J&U me fie prosecutor Sad^ He cant drop jfa assaults because ke P AeiKic pfCisufed \>j )ke dveriJfe dept k> prosecute me, and fkei X haul fo plea fa cdl &&^r czk&r&eS to(\e%&r or kdu all flu-r to> trial, X informed my oAwey that X <dd not c&tck Oia. chorees •faselW <>o X skaJd he able \o pk out ho Hem seper^fdy. lie idd me tkc,fs Oof kcu^kkd f(ie prosecubr doesW- kavt to awe r^e a, pies, ed all (Pea^l Cade Ziffl-Seu&rance) rAy qfe//^ kda (^eX fed no ricikV [o sepeccde my cfacces kdr X do kcjui IW cidd> X idd my attorney Xdid rof coMrvjA lAe assaults io lm rtcl -fe\bi^g jke pl£<^ Mg ^uc/<^ ^jqs rumwy lede So He pcosecufor idd my attorney X Can Consider fie ded unir'l the nexk fredncil m"3une ol 30/7.

Pi cjfeet or tujo law wy ottorn^ Said io Como see kin imi he hod new euideAc^ cuken X Oz^c |a Ke Idd mc ahoid He mdask camera o^ fk paffok ond it made me, loot bad, lie. Tad me X Srodd \oke H»e to years IX tken asleJ km tf JocX uaJd tre^i tte asSoulh S^i he fede-d kts Wd yeS\ X tken idd nmn X JJnt commit He assaults SO X* net johny tic deal* He Sc.«J *C,l Xll sfarf prtpairmc He tad ,± J-umd da** He jQyears JuneL XiH^ &cuzek k&hre my AW cdafe o§ Xuly IH\7oM\ X A^J a meeknc uifi my attorney and ke -kid me abood ex darnpamc pkma coll X nncde.'iMU in To/, X osfod kirn cdy £JGSh* X kdd atoouf Vus before fuminCj cLuin Hi (ilea^ Ac5 fopy uxls X Idd yju ^ bke ike lQ ydars ! (Ay alemey and proSecukr denied me my rtdk k seueranct, f^ly attorney musinW/^ me Oibojc Ac assaults heme 3b hefcte X turned doj« f^ 1^years} W en XJy W^W/ oi my W Ae Idd me inlodr oP my utters mo&er 3ep*ank U^S *ok yect lis not 36?1 Mlomj h^n iked Ufore OJauid kout pAcde a ^ dfffeAwe \n my decision concern^ my plea, /Use cyhdJy hack eudence of Ike dartacing pjlnone call uMI after X-turned dou>n <He plea. td\ey csased Senouse dammt to my decision rAabng ca^ernma my pko. ny attorney Misinformed mc^ ckmed me my riSs^GnduAddd^ evidence ix/ wAch ke fc/U to Oct as my h^yer eyed iiuS W<WiViq ^/ Sdtk Ifmendfnenf Aghr*.

oToaAcf FqlkC J^neWecfwe Assistance, of Counsel by -fhilma ho ach as my legal Gchiocaht by proheck^Q my rights Do** (oroud\c[ Four /^Aaumenf Oa July /*P <2G/(/», Me day of Ay Trial X noticed my crftorney ojos Ce<o\ nerdous and unsure ajkick caused me h fe( tke Sonne. X jken told hm Jo See fP ike IGyeorS ojcS still 6r\ lie kah\e> He Cxxme hack <W mfront of my clauckkrs m,olAef ^Xcqaarick LeuJiS and myself ke Said^ Xke prosecutor Said unite, prefairiny Hr my W Ha KeeJ M lereSci J. Clmaman nadtced my nome and hold him tbad it X cjanied io plea, ouf fts rou c\ minimum <25 years! Tke prosecutor held my attorney JkaJ j-ke, heocd Q/}> Said eke kcxs Inr in for me tr&rn a\ pc\$i case in XQ®5 oUn ode. a)qs dke profecuUr. fuay 36/V; of my first pre-tricl ike- prosecutor Sold my attorney AaA he canialfop ike assaults b&^arc ike Sheri&ts depi. IS pressunnc hum io prosecute me. /vol he-mc an attorney myself SC do not knaJ a^toi all rny cdromty oaufdOe done Jbu4 X do knocJ he Snouldue amm SomeHinc, From ukci X haoe reed tkase interferences fro^ Ike Sherds and head (dJI, are Undue- ia-Piu&v&S'i h<- ah lea&i skculd haue triced h change ike uenu& -So moh X cjcotdle hod ex fair ek&ncci, Ev Ue IWn t/5g m 3d HS2U)(Xey Crtm fa 26QS>) OS a vast mcZjcnhy cf clams of ineffective o\ Counsel^ tke trial records ace- insufficient Id allcu) appeW&Tes Ccud io resclue Ake issue, because applicant could not provide suck eudence. tuikout aoifK ouhide trial records^ he may raise cdue process clrsitn- £x ferle Torres HH2 SLaJ, 3d W^IS CTey CnnsHtf /W) U fade Itcosia tft ^ 2«d l/7o, cm [fey Cn %> /W)

Gcormci [\\J€s X uas Aen\ed my 5ixjk ftm_endm.ent AcKk ia eiffechii/e assistances oi Counsel by ^uAqe Kcbin Oarr, C^rounc! Fii;&> /)r^ume/1 f On ouL /V^ 50Wj Anc cdoxy of nay AriaI X came Aj /As, condu^/on my cdkmey &a£ not properly repteSenknn pne^ especially after he made -the cpmmeni f(X<2ot hm d plea deed beeaure my dauchtess mofA«f Xeyuana LecjiS asked km out nf •trostrahiem 'iokak kojje you- done for km mins case , X "told fam X oJanwd to dire kn^n Gnat be jold me X had Jo take if up usitk dine Xud^e, Onc£ ue t^ere inrfiwk af ike Xudge X VOLceJ 4^k X coanked ka hire my ecjn cdiamzy \o replace my Court appointed vHocney\ She hid me Mo! Tha-f X had enough time to do So, X do Aol fkel X Incd enouQk Ame >X oo^s inccra^ccxfed AWw r^arck \1& 2oiS until /°Wk IZ& 2oiLl. Ourma iked year X uzs unacjarc my at%mey IrJOS not properly representing me because tke last h months X ojos ineareercdrd m o\ federal prison uitk no confacd cjffh v\y oSorney. Upon my release (AacoU )2^k2o/1/ Xcjcs broke, and homeless ond discovered my d&oc^tcrs mo-fker Gnd my otacACikkor Uoact in a $kemf} So uken X got out cntrmj on my Peef and heipnc my fismh ejeaz my first concern, Fro^ (Aorck l&left lili Tune IH^2CI</ CJas not enouqi kn\e U ge-f riyself and my family sducded plus (]ef enouqi money Io kirt an cttlbrAzyi o^f iUi ooas all Ha kme He Court Qaut rV\e> AfW I Cozephed ike, pleo^ of <25 yeans Ike 'Judge asked me /A my attorney represented me r\qkf\ X (yoemted to say no huf X ^^ da aPPr&id jtaf ske ujaAd -hfce my $dec back and force me to eje -fa rrio.1 /A? ske already -fried j-uiioe ^Jki/e Xu^s On One stand once ske heard n\y fecscnS t^ky. X Teed rXudqe f<okn Qarr ch.me<d rne my -Sx/A Hmendmeni Hiqhk by olenymc n\e ekfeokue assistance of Counsel Declare- X cJontaJ to fire my CP^<d appoind^ Cvdarney ajkc do ine^ecfi/e,

%

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.