Miller, Robert
Miller, Robert
Opinion
.' . -\)~ r~ ~~-\\t~~1t t.,\3.1-. p~~ ;Lp, ya;~tpl,j -01 5/'J)/t? '!-"' W: f '-1: ' "-~ \9 "£., LL \, ~= L-\5 "' :I AIV\_~ V\ clellp ~e IL>-etl <::£- 'I tJ vnt 1,.\.t -t-.\es'Pe rdid Y "'-e<'J ~('{)\ec.t;oUl~UO IYL 'r.\~.~.. f.,rh\e-ctttJ tv\y C)-L'l~~.st~cvt'\ +~rll\t\j an.J X he.~ fotf You_ -\-o e~tk(l,f -\"'~~_ ~\\\. C--\e~t'\ts u~~t\n~\\\c...'<~\\.o ~>< ~~"~~~)\\f-~'lJ LA~ctt\1\~b<ad<-,~ . 1~ ~-rt \.\)b~vt~r '"e Q:oV\ 'LolA w0LA+ ke~~- ~~-' :r:J tl~e ~or ~Du. 1-a ~\~5~~~~~<lcrMv,wu:.~yJ_ esiA:S- \--\.o.-11' V\.~~~1.-, he LS l ex.ab ~U:V\O}e'lf '~ Cc ~ t ~AS c\'\.Xl S-~ '<' \l..o' ~ c:il5 \.(. \;l, Y>'l_:~ ~ \.(:oh~~/1e:~Me_ of-~ ~c1"-.e.D\_\ U\'\ t·1- {M,I'b\el."ow.te.\~ 'b~c,~<;eJ\\y ~~t ·15 ~ V\ '!\\'Vl~\'\~ ~vr~ ~\(~v\ ~~'ia k.e~- UD \;\"u~ ~e.c:J. uv~-v\:-· '-'a_v ~ CA 1 j, ~ e1 b~ h~ ·\- <Dul- oY\. Me.-+ Ai. v·r'l 10f'H ce·VS \A~~e.n.-t~; s :1 ot}'\"J cs· ~ ~ W(J\ ·,~: \.\ ~ t t)('-\ hlL y\ B~\ C. \r.ru,cc!"of'('..:>Ytu.~;ty -\\11 \ e±'-\hervt k; t\ Me_.:1-UJu.~ b!J'IA.\-J(y be.d \""~-\-\.-. ~g ow V\- Co\tU- ~ o t· \.,ac~-( ~ V\ .1-t>Ol-(~:-~..,~~ VL~ c\ueJ \.;'f ~aV\C! ~~~ \,eJ} \J/i. H~AM~flt'~DJ\. ""(t_ \.J.)c.t.S -\-f'tiY\.Ql t-o c..,\\.ec\ ~ ~3.\)oo . . \\."i·Y7Ao">\~Y N.(!.~ S~t,ff\Je.:rrYFratdt.li" "t (.l)v.. \o.\t.n Ko.. ~ ~0v\f~e at'\.-\ s \) -"v' ~·n, ~vv\. n.\"e.ve o.. \fe. uklt\J- ~o r-~ltu.:t.l e:> Nte.. 1-o ~ o t>LAla~c\1'. w~ d) ~\1\P.x.~ cu)"\--!.hA~L~J w\\\ \{~\.\ ~ $~x~f.f ksMJ)<\'iveJo~ u.!>GlY\t~Vtct.J.-Ile d~.cl, :t:Wfre.v:.,tA.A~ ~("e~rite..t'\.~~- ~ () t~u ¥,~ ::J:.,. 0-~ 0 ~ MlJtt\ ~\e. "\1\\t../1.( ~ v(5 ~-he.-wo.S fe.v-.s: ona:.V.y Lt'\Vu\~_ z-11\y ;~c\ ~J~ n~ \-ko..'M.vV1er o& Mv.He1'V'-O\\AI-2 \~LA'(\JCA. <D·-t 0\.Jovw\e.\L~~.~"'t<t'£'? ..:1 \.Ceo ac..c.e.fteJ WL.+o Jet \f' 't's <9 'f.g c;-~. V\ <. te~ Clf ~ M(_ v\ Y\.t:11 ~ v:>~ ~(~ +-'-~ccicJ. ~ u q'\k( e ' J\ t~~ o \'l_,uV~LAU.t ~- Lrq (A f ~ t e~ £>.ele (.) V\ or '\oh~ \~Q.,\x. ML ~ {\ ~1 ·~ \e~ t\fS w\cto\ W\.e_ t Jt:A~~o-f\ Vo.l\q,lAe 2. 5"\ACU:..Sfu\l Yde\. ('Itt'/~.~ ~ 6~\le.v t. \0 ~\'\a \ojj ~f C~CO-~ V~-.e- \I) J ohMY \) v\S~u t\-\.CMr-\-~ of-~ f:IJ..k bod~-~ J Vc.c-lvt..- &_u.~ whtY\~ \)t ~o~;r i \'1' . \ A:J. ~JrY<DV.. Ul~s ~to vev~fy~_s.~· J.~}t\~l'e.Je.r~-reve.d ~c.c:U V\e.1 ~- r- dr.l \~ o.n We~.-·\"'" lA Cusrc'M.·;z_eJ. \'\1b V\1\.o.~:\.,u c\a:SS whA chfoYV\'\eX S~e:r\ff~:fuck fl~ \l Pr 9~ Mp Ll.)(~t},\io.:J;" M.tLot CSu\..,G\~ w~\e '\~ cu.v r-ea'tst~~~d. ~o Skv-if-~ t~ft\h..r ,We_w(•>-te ciliX.e.A~~d ~uH fv.\l\_~c \~t-\lx.t cu.¥~ 611\. ,~ fo\rwt'\a.\t)\<cAu 0\~j u V\OW\.€~ t ~t_,P h-.cAc\ e..~kt <1\,(f-ests, Vtfr;__ uJQK e--@ Avt..
C\v~ll\t.~-~ oV\ Q. ~tvep:\-·,~cA.ll' v~e:.1etl.t-o <~q 'ts~ek~ t~ s~_:ARf wM \~ ~ ~ lt~J1tt,.VJ wvv!l \c.de liA~~ \~o\ 0 ~ crot\: L~~ol(\J\e~e .ve~~:y w.Xu~bcotKt \)(c skrt+fs otf~ce,l Kvaw cJ\. ') VVLUI!je{S _: w\\\c~ c)Q,(\fY ~\o)fe.A \,\~ V'"O\e '1Ar\\ref'~ t$ MY ~{o\,\e·U'f\,~"'-e>-'l S~IAt'\:.\ ~WCA.fJ5· V'~.cnd"fy~ M_1 CvV\. nV\\ '\-,ul~ \11.~~~ ¢ ~\ s t-'\lBt~el o-f\)"'\ \\?!If:~"' .. ·M.\)..~leve.6.\;'f Ku-\,t-1\.Dt-\e.oU\.n& ~e.Jo {))( 6-~~ Do:\1\.~e\·t{~;}-i~~~w_:z:. 0,_ \)e\.\~~o,\10,.\ ~ v-l·~\.te-Y ~ ~ ·h\e.~\ eel Gr~ ~Vc.. SS\~~\re. s e., --.:1\ Vt· Me_ 2. vJ l.(.) . 1- o ~e. t" off 1M~ ckecJ.. iAV'- Ltl ofkk Y V\\. v..v·J k.e :t., ~ G\-te \ 0 w e..ox 0\. uJ bu_. ·iH GeJ Cot\fe.S7t~K5 .t~ovY\ 5 WOW\e.n t 2- \1\et\ ui~ \.Ai e.~e.l@f\'\'( ~'<L~~ ~\o~ V~l\trii'\'-H' va\ rr'ltJ b~ \ \.t_t>VN' \ h.l~~g \Nk_e_y r(N\,'tA'PJ'\ -r Fttt)(! w-efe..5V\\o \!~\fl._~ C\l'CAd{.~ 0 K\N}t \....o uJ Fo.~Hti1 h\ul~· \J P \'\..e.y ~~ WCAS' 5V\\1oScl \- o h.OL-ve.. 'b~ev-. co~;V!e..,-~;h.e.. tl::)(lh t>\-\\ :t\.~ ~-~ ~_lllhA e.~y'l~--e { 'SeCA.t.J\fex\ e.\t~e.< 're_\~ XB.e vvt<llhcie.t :::. -r R.\.LKY G.txr \ <t.(v'e ~ t.h_~\~~tWB-\1\b w/be.l <t -fV'<lf'Ci\. .~a.cl<- se-o.\- :) ~ t~k~c;tr-"' 5 Ccd~'~\'\ \1\eY_'-Nef~ Sa.Y'i~~ ~~~lf~l~~rr~~~~V\: (} LA)~+_th I
e.vYL l-or ~a.' M.ttr~ ~~<".. 1 Cu.r\ ~\7o ~ \:)~\"' CoV\-fe.5S v ~ ~) MY :l. ~~AA'f~\N§ljt ~X~~ Me. \.J ,fh 1
~l w heV\. ,J ~: c\<.. ~d.- u.f -set~~\ \'\,\\e.'{~ o...~la.c KM..ctr\.:i roh'ft f \) s~ -:\X: .~- LAILL5 Vt'YY J vlA.t\.1:<. t )yvt_t>t(~t\9 C~Q\~ W~M lv-(,\,tY ~f;Cf C:r>~-te;5~c\.·\-o~. ~1 ~\A~~9~~~ <rt·tuhJ'\,\>c , . \~c.lej~j__ h01.~ be-lit'\ ~l.l~ J ~y \fQ.,f{'rt.:. LJ'I? 1-ec...dt\ U.waxJ--~vt~ruZ-a te.s'5 bV\-f"ov h.-~~- ~tA.Yti'I.V1 :\'€-r(Y J~ \~ t"eY,h u:J f_~w al wa.s V\..c\ h.cwte .1-~Y'"4ov ce.J.'c. ~he·\( war l ~t5~d-e...lA Wa.lfJ ~ ~VY\e.i c,__J:. i ldkt- hro V-.12 ou.t.,{\uY'be.a:t 1 ~l~er\Y Wlu·\\<'\her-- .se,t·ti\--e \o ~~-WCL'fr? ko4l>n..\.o~ 5-\-V'ee:-L ec.V\h l'rtfJ \h\ s f\ ve wcu 'f u \~c\ t.c c.~A i?.tt.+ut \:, \.Ai :t:\ \ C}) e.~ 't Q u. 'J-. c,~ess ;o VL5 i h.e.lr '1 c\A w\\ vi c.. t J'err-Jt _h~ ~( uY\c!.e( Ma.fQa.'i':-\~\ <t Mu..r~o Ck~~~ t:o..YV~\L o.c<e.~t-~~<1 ~f(Adj ~1!\e.Y ·htb'M.~0"'1 ;f.d~ \\\ec,!fi.\.\Y 1ts> ?elfu.te~ "'""" \"' \CAh.D\'(a-:\~ ... C'CA.\\~..\'""1'\v_~·'t"' ~a_vh': :r w:\l'J e.tt.Ji thes~ w~tJ-te ~·f''5 ~\) \-~~·f'f 0-.CIG\-\\\St 'Uc'f~Y· \~'i~ \ouJ. bu.5\V\.f.SS' \1\.t~t\tJ\lVwO\.ue..tCA.~+ottk~> c..V'~ CA.Ve 's \~~ \" iY\.9 ~ . \ "'-.e ~\.V\ rea.s 0 v-- :(~ \~-\(f ·-zr e\J qY eov--._v \c.. re~ ~ b ~ CU..\A.~ e.. ~e.- ~~eu\ tle.J. Sj+.;' I es~~d-" ~e.\ h--~~ @ l:.A-\c\\e.. un.t.-t .k>. t:~ j~~~te..U\'i K1. . \f. \'v\ee\; caJ'\oVl tv~ 0\ CoWl ~~er;. vJ. -""1 i e c.~ LY t-\ \ e~ (}. 1 \ l~ ~\1\..·~ \\ ~ " l'-. \ &\. w s u.~-\- .. -:1 w; \.\ tA.\\t o... ~ u\\'-1~\!.\.~ h ~ 3 e~ o.ll w~ .\- M-~i· e-( \ \) t e1· ~ ·~ fY, 0\.\\ '1. AM 01 rK i t-ta.~ ~ \\. ve.+ tAi if\_·\ S ~or Y"u. \ o. ru l< :l\~e_ c\.os>~~~c.~-t~~l'\ -~'rlt.-1)\~v~tlej \b!(. tl!l \"'c:u~<)te;~ ~ ~~~-~~atL~~ to.M.oV\.\.fot~ \1\vt~ti~ ~h~od-<.-tk\~ ~,(li>lJl-\-CI.G+J\{.~4' \{~Js .. ·lM '5eiJVl~ \~ft~ s·e . . . tel'c.e. :r U)o.')'\.\\estl\lY'~l\.lf~c..keJ. .,f Pos-se.St~ c(V\oV\Q.H£>-\ICA..\e.c\.' o... ~\AV'" ~LJ.t u.~a ~ to f-to vt'" o..t't'~..<.o..:l .... 1 .. \ . . ~t\.ii\.D ce ~ce .. 1. V>t ~\@rN1 en ~'l~et (.<)Vev- wovlt~.!. W_eN. uh.
I; ~ f t, ~\,\a.\ f\e! c. o ~\ .f.e~ 5 \ D 't'\. ·f" 10\"'l • \~WI. cd"e... ~etV\.0\.nAo 'Loft 1.. 6J o \ b Co. j 0\:\ t t\ Lo.~eJo;\'(. l~~( 1 ":J..
OL\~., w ~'I~ w ~ re w \,'\ \e Ao~ ¥\9 \A \'\JH U ve"J\ vJ o><k ta 't Ma.tt.\Ae\ \'ZeY~ £Jt Lt...~b~ c k-;f;c--.l>r~ \'<i.iKF"i>{(e.~ v~IA.VC-"Ctf~.(.:>U;..7t'\ -:-,\\.l'\'t.~ .. \...o..tev'\~&~e.tA.V :r: w~n<~~ w:+kJ~-\-ed\Ve.l B~ilYI~~s 6) lubhoc. K CD, 3 t.\l\ l heJt' e l. \:,u~~ ~u~\ \e., CCA.nieV'o!A {l"f tu\<\\1\@ ~lfo~l-\ +~ (i1.W\.~es1 Tve ~llJ\Q {'\Q~tYo+ tANitvc.ov-el LA)ov'\{Ao'r-\.O .. C., ~ \N~\eVef'lctAJ~.~~"f""'~ec.(J~t<> \d J& h.e1f d..o"'Y\xlt\\ \0\\\\ t-c tLA . ,Je.vry O'f CA.\t..Yo Y'\t. ~iS@:z~/»t~ ~ i"' ~Y ~ u ~y, 4.~ ~\e.et.b·t" {'\-eo.Ae WYo \A~ e._C\ J e 1- u \ 1t-'1 Mo. ~~.lf 'You, a.l\ '1 a.~~:~\~~ Yf!Jv.. ~ e.t- Vie. -t~ ~n\·4rJ \A ~1 t + de f\.c:~t "Sfeo..\<.. ·\-o ~V\.e.. \u(e" '!'·~ su~:~ Ya u -\~s \rt\er \A~'\ S..o\'Y\toY\~ e\5-ec.s V\.<A..~ i,;~cet.w·e CAf/'\'r D~ \f: Lt\ is''\.\ \e.<:\~ \\'Y'\~ 'QeAY\.~ ~171 a..\\ MV \e'l c! M~' L"J:. f(o.'f~ h"- \he \i\:1-e.fe~t D& JV\. ~-\; Le Yv c...~~ f\\~. +o e:~V\ ~\t-IM.e~~s iAV\\.-\- G'i ~V\·\-fc\f.!,~d Mi'so!e ~\'~~*\~:\'' Stfk..-\-LA.s. V-e.fY 'hlt\YYoWtr.: i. _ Cl',\ile:-. • ~V\ tt~ b~ ·rt M~ \tn' ~lo& J._q ~ M( t ~o.L u.~ ~ '-bt,L\ f M. )..o 5L\ t e.MeS5€( to \o)\Y '_-(Yc:- 1'5&~ .
D~un_L~rn \{ ~l.u.n Q \'-"" ~0\·d. .\he f',V\r~s ed. \~<\ttl( tu tl-1~ y lexa_s\2[.<. V\"t(S 1!1 r -tk.:._ r B1. o....J lJJ\w. \- ei' 'f o u._ d_, , 0\ fnt.J>P d<I VL,o\- Q.e._h..._ t\. ldte~ 11.'rJ )1~\(Cj "1"\j 1-vu.h o.r vI( n ~ cJ-, YMl-<. , Ve v~ ~L. \ c_)oulu? t.c~ ~ tle.. . 1:JJ lAJl eJr ~ h~'{ t Jv\~ \l e 'f ~ lo ta ~'l ?> ~ (; ~~o-1 l.LV\~ t- ~~~oli rM 1o0 ~ -r ~ \1\ V\. L3 5 ot e_ ~ ln lA LJ(l)4 1. ~~~b
. ' '
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.