Allen, William Andrew
Allen, William Andrew
Opinion
~ 4-llf a-f' (!,t, rt1 /l)lt4 (i <S /'!)o~· /2.. ~C) 1 '?P ~Is " :5~ft G~ <T'~.KJts 9:P;1.~..t·~lltJ .. ~~ rRt, wQ-;tz; rJo. e~'t:>cr...JZ..91'D -ar~a:;-,i!R~";JJ~~ 1:8 2ll1fl» Ctz_l?n &IA.A.-+ Ho. e>~'oc:ii-12 9'7(p cxP.t~+J!:. ~·:11,8-tn Aula~ !J,tl~· ~beiAcosta,Cierk (!j~ILk: . ·--A,:;Sl.P~Jg- ~ :::h-t t<~sf<Mce. ---rc ~"J? ly\QC~·s Jn... ttJ.f.i!tt... ·-ro y~u . m'l ~6f "'1"'47CJ W A.:J+s W£P..( ~-1~c1 IS'! -;hf;~~~~r?\ #tUm NUf OJ:~/ ~~IJn•\ 66ft,/;~ ~~ru- i?fA-/ f)Ji/l~f Aw~A-1 IJ.His E)( h~{~Jo l/?.J.J~ ""' ~V.·A~ I ;).tJ I'{ A~I ~/4 ttl) f. ~rc:J. (s€<!..-id->... .;;4., %'/- G~cJ~ilnt~--1 r!A<:f i) ~~~uJ' Atl C!V->~75 $$. -'1hc -6.s:2?t~rshJcl -n, "1Jt6 SObZ34> L /IML ' r/6 ~61~ b.iih ~.%'l --JJ,~ (j'J.tJ 6/a.-m T'S" -?71AI 6'?1 . s~g:xf.smb6~ )~ ~oof r :W/1-s --:::hc:J.ci~J ~ /b &"-'nls tl ::; wAS #of- ;::77,dJ/ckol' (TA/ 6f'r5~-l-2.9l7. ~ -rh8p ·~cP,c-bn4Ji'l-4r t'&tl~ f;J,~: &~J Ju~ ~ ?ht ~U-?1~ e::>FbJJYIIe.e.. lfflJ ··fh t- ShJk. .c ·7£ A--.4$, 41.4/i ::;.dl!'e:h~ ~A1VJPnelf,o!, S toa/UJ ~ cJALg-J/ <l..
A-h.J tJ f-:J tWn z-2-J As .sud A/ '1l <; J"" )1l. ~ /l-?1J 1 A-]:),. ~8 &' -r/1 E. (!J
;6s--:11J ·vJuJ:I:; <::JA-l'U/-6fe,c.t &u.ttf- 8~ S'tJ1.J C1(..L..(\ J-v 1 1 Au~ ~,J <J\2- 8~12-~n'\~ ~ d<A·t/L~ vn l :n.L~7~ A!UK-f a# "77r~ &~~~ 'h~rta, ~ .s~p&iflk:e. ' ~o8~ -J,le. 4-st 1?1tmJ~ ·::Jn S"¥+clflhc.e.. -p,~ J::r.s-Z?.~,c~~ /'J)/s/£.J-c I ~u/l.f to~ f 7lJ ~€-HE G;;~~'fe> :£ LU~Jh~ /hJ{lk) /JJ~ /Ptrs ,n/~.t /Jt<.~IJ tun!:/ S'~pfhl1j¢se </ ;Jtr<J~ o x w-45 ~i ~a~ tJel.VJ16d &vn /:I s~tJ~hl ~ J?l oa()g PJ1 wl-,GYh '7.- wEtS Al6d ~J.~+~J ~2- $4-m~ D~.o Scpfb11be~C. ~~. ~~ Af lb:J-J frrrl; t:rr\ /0 Q.J{'llfl.cjZ:8o /t.J4//6(. Ck~*11);J 1\}cJ- 1-/JWt- '1l1"'l. ~~~~ &,·c-~1~ o.9 1"h ~ /E>S":O "lJZ>f~/cl ~~.<.~ ~'epfUr-. b6K!- 1S .dafJ~ fht-d /)Jd t/~J- 1/AV-F UL(;tUscRtiJJc-?- 6'Yl ~ :s~ty~&w,; hu 'f f5Dar> ~ + t: m ~ & cr· AK~U ~ f .As :/; hAV\ ~'ZfArc;J (1\~ g1l'STh.ft I £/,~ z.U'ELC. r,48m "1JJ£ ::7?r:7~c:l~ ' ,g<;;"./h1 /J.tfi!Jtvn4f' dtt-lvivl ~IR'6 ~- ~1 1 ,~~ ai>l~ ~ ~~~ uriJA 2?
16&1/w'$- cl w_,s-s ~~ -z;,~~tc. /r~·.::s- 4'0-n1 rYUf · fhJ/r)Vn ~ ~ ;z; HIW~ ~/~J 0 t0~1-f-> erf:' ffir/;6RS Cbifu:S, ~E t/rsrf- T?Vd tA.J6U lfbctvd~ /')E.WI~ '}>;rs<lJ)Juu~cO 6o~c.e"' l,Uhe'-~ ~iAJ~ tl\<!Gtlf'd &-rrubs 1.\p /..vr/1 1J S~tp.l(fl.A-J ~ T do rJof --t'lldl.Oo :I: Also· ~I\6W \fl\4'~ J~~~ Yf\<:CA-C) Jlt5 -~1>'1\em~-l.k~ )d~ ·:to Af m ·"7.3 /71 ~ ~4V4f o2 &~.~ j ~@6>~./}ls FJs ~l~-ls4J -thE cSn Jvr !1 ~ b.eL6 7im t --rs ~E"iy Ct.e~-I~J 47 -~J??- /f)c.(!A'fj· 1/3 :Tf -:1A~ Jo--o7?'JJ,(',~I0)'JI!JiJ J-/Ad r/e; JLA~/z;~ic-1,~ ~ <Jvt~}s~•cJ, ~ (2A-1'1 f\JoJ & V~s;~ -r6 ~f cS1Jto-z1!.J~J,c,:t (U;~~Rld t~ ~~ J.AS f J;',nf- Y ~ Rk( ~s-E-J Ch/orn 6A-Wt~ ~ J1r~<·;( .d3 dbJD .. f J!Mt n'6.1 ~ /JIJo~ 72J &x~f 7b J1ur . /(}~eg ~~ ,1/pp~B-f· t:JI( /J1j ~~L ,.,,. ,-i~ftrl mdk~sl As~/ QIJ{vivz Ji'tr. Ar-5. rr?o~:~ Wt- f\1~ T~~-41 .. Intel £:/s:.cJ Jh s ·-::J:n 4d.£9~4'/-L 4p;pell/ tlli£( U9~-t3-cfA f Hl'f 46ttJI~~ ~4 {j;,-flaJ"./f.rMj ~~Q "~t ttefk/(._ cs:fl (!6 JGIJ?Ac::A./JCIY! Q.c_ App~ { ~.s He>rl )/-me /iUj ff:gn A ..fu L ~ 071 -1 ~ tu to i :d: o~~oct-R.'i1~:D -CJ<g-ac;-tcct~~ 1J ;/~. ;10 ./: ~ 4~tueR-;;d &t ~tt46~<- --/Ae..--TJ,:s-hz;ci ,4-lku4 ~.s $-c., d'e_ 4 (J;sk,d d'w~. "/A4--f ~»c;-( &1/1-5 1111Jr/~ I 671 ·-:JJEi&$7YJ/uu ~z:_ Ci-?JIL/~ p77 . IJtfR.;( d'l O<JJ~ ::£' ~ JU~I( ~f',a<:;-)297&.. -CJ¥'<J9-/2..Cf :Y~ . t!9cP ~-"-i'(t"s~lc{,~ wh;cl... .jL,~GJ,c.-1,~ sb~u~-~ 0~ be., .6tti/J1;Jk/ AJ ~ tflltl f /h d Om, n7; l 61 kJAJ 'i.J.£ cf~ Cf1 SfiJ ~~ iP'dS". ''·1:+ Ad,·~~c} GvtAIL+ -$1-ls . CYH~Js vi~ c/uiU;ct;;.k.;;4{ ~Sfl~(jJh~c .·, Aa.EA1 'ifJ\ase:.. @~C.6~~s A1t'Z: ~.<\ ~1-1\-11'1 of.s:~l>(. J;p\J . :~ .,.
CJi..Jtt.. b~.tol ern tnf.·IYl 7J tJa/dJ 1 . Rtskt:.tt. \J C1m.rva·iss)(s-).. ..C~ /-.!JUh{!IL r:Drs~-, @II n(~ AYn' ·-r~Lu.d1 So~ -:k~ \/'14,rs #/~s-s .. Y?..fs JJI/ 6ee-146£- r:r-P ~ I+J:krvn~ ()4rlvm 6rtfi.§1~, £~~~ I() Pi.t~i &;5d.P4lc~ _ &;,JfJ.4le1 r]h~ W'IJS :SI.bps£/1/.tt-.a.:::l ·lt'h.CI 1\/tu~~ ftU-ser~fzJ -n> ~'$ t!.eu/(.,J 6/l... -j7,1_ ~~~ JUrh~s~r:-s -dlt~ w~~ dM6rL ~t.. tfa~/1,(j-d ~ /Ylult$11-~?AJ ~ HDt c::h.-~·hJJ. "'(b ~ '7 ~urL{, bt.ficl~c~ -fo,:y/ ~ ·-~,y}.5~'~t~-f A71c/ tJiltt( -76 hl'-( 01}6'L -~ wrh/,~// ~i rj1~r;J;S..Jil.lcl /kf,f.r;Jf./11 d' 9 ~ ~ tn'-{ ~~sd~ T A?n ~rl<)·<!P-71·1 c;~ 7h sse; CJR~ AJ/ :P A-sk 15 £ L A chtriL {kit+/. thtd~ & AJbf~ 76 {Jft~f-· (/h·? C:U;d~cc -ftttr-1 13 51/~t/ 6?~-1 -fl~e? --:76 ~;£e"vf... ~/1--m h-4~ , -,~:;{; /JnJ;I ::Z 1'/er~c:l -~-. ;/ ~.£eJod ~ -:hdh:::~ f' t7R'-c9- /297·1- -1116-ec_ -;t:::5 .H-.4 :f c:::nuz. ' E>hua V S"M-t Cfi<l 6h2ei <S""19., ~ Q£lmlf1tt / ~~~, M Of~ ·70 C:iu'd G~s \.JLtrL,~~c.~,~ r.a-n"o-+ b~ s"'b+kl\t•A-\1'1 :J;,vob~~; -:r-r €.1-f/Ju. A+-IAJ.s- o·/2..-,f cJD~5 ,.Jo·t, -~ (ik~ ~~ QJ~{\ c_A~ Wh~~f.. (?~~4-, dutt~~rctd- ovU A ~Il--k; Vf\~ ~h~ YY\~ R~l1 b~ "fhA+ (j>AI'-~/6-$ f+pp.!AI/./rYIC£ ()'$~~ /'1h1 det-1/i.f1 /Jvtf~ i2.tJ 'VG~(S({S lml\ T£xl15 ~Jf:S e~ Q-;v·,f ~~u!.£ 1 &di,;,J ~t\~,clrd\--.. ooca..·1/l~ ~~ Q.tm"~i ~c am~~$Jl ~PIP\ ·YA"f:. Q7-s-l~c.t ~~e.+ ~~~~'f ~'-1 7Yt'f.. Ll~~s~Js htd(pe~471CEJ h'-41 1!-kJ~'e.~:;:S -r;,~d~c.. l.:s:ki/Yl <S:p A- ~kn..y ;:t;d,~~ f 1 o,e. ?A~ Act!.wS zds ~6~A( Alli~rn- 7/ue WArua -rh~R..~ o~ l'nt.d 'lh!... .l~~ a£' .4 t/41/J h/~ ~/bn't~rfl~ u..pon ~(j)AA~"f\+\\ ~\l~ll ~~~ ~o~s !Ul-f h AQf. A VA\~ J ~ J~ .h.J /'cfma-nf 1\S ~~"Se~k,.e_ )Y o<StS'i/. ()'II._ 6</=r\ S~~~ tf- tut;Y//G.L ~kr .:Jl>()g' v;J rlc:.'f f/P$5c_ .Jui,~&,d:J~~ .cu~ lh~ J$"s-Lh "j);JLe.,ct ~ue.f-'! /h, du~6~tc~A~~ e;.P Jh ~ ID'~~ Jt.{~,c.41 v~&k~cl ~uR.t iVJl.-1\ t- r Ue~-~J 10 ~c.A~ Ckl.vv'\~ 7€-JMS-?> . J~~ ~f\ 'iixAS ~~fo-rtme-,..J (kJ~ (}.'t~ 'd~ /6'6"''221 JL(J,~,.+f 'Pi·~~~e-l ( A."')Jm ,~t!-rh:_, mtcP W/\-ll~ll ~.J-.1~. (~)·--th ·f.. ·n~s ~-fh f /~ ---p/~-;uc_J- tkJc.e};j. l:Jc$711 ~ Q) ::t:n JJt..s./r-n ~UAJ"'t l$"Y) -% f ./lis-! fY7ond fk1 -~ tfuJilf} /1JLo/ /))ob£mhcR ':1 ~~~~..fk e14 on·fhl rfk~t rt76>lcl~ "1l\ .fi.hRvtAp.y ~ntd ~~6L.'& {$:J ~ /).}hr/}E.tL (ki.VY\-kt on '/h1- Jt~.'J-sf n1~lj -:Yn Joo\.\Aflit ~ dune..~ v~ ~~ J.!X-r.ts ~IJe~~ Q,.d~ ~, bo9 Jvt!l~t~tcf->- EAd &at.t1z.J 1/sf~J ~ -Jh1s ~'-i bcJ,P<pt:L /)A--s Jlr ~uiL~~ .~~~~ f(a}O{d.J bt../ <::A7 Gz;-tt.r)..~~~M ~" lh~ ~ct<h) IN-<Js e ~ --p,-rs &-4/e ~.e -u,6Jilt} C1e Cit IL-k . "V''6 &,"5..{-fc.,.frh ff'lt.d l~&ta~ &.-nfilcl~ ~..., 'VA~ I ~·sJ~k/lz.. d~li'n£ R"h~ c-s~/,~' ..fw.IV;J,::zj,t:J~ ~~·41~ &s~,c.l &"1Z-hc :1ee Cv!l!U(V bJ,15cn'\. <{.53 $£0 !laf ~ 1 t/$;~f6.K·(!.e;m 4~ !CiCT'3J: 6br/l Y J~hf>&rn ~d){ S uJ U G;IJC( 1 &12 1 (1;~ C!ln~~ ~ 1q9/) AaJic.)~ S" §''if o~ -1J. z -!i..vtS ~sl~/rA 4-nd k~c/E l.j.CY) cF '171c, ti.xAs W.t csP0-InvAA'f D f1aa~uRL VJI4c.t Jurl;sd,~.e:cft-:-. ~-P AJ) J1brf &-sq :::M. '1Az d/skcf &/!--Is ... II~ ~ ~oeibnfflP.?Zl &Jc.. b<f.,~¥; /~..s;-t!l. dud5c,4/ J)/~k/clC~-lrn, ~~f<k,. WfJ/1)6!. de,u.-nJru) ~ P.;,;/( 10 ~~ 6n.trll~J .?P'\ Acf .. <6'3 ~7<-1-"l ~wtd-'P ·HoB d~Q IZ<?f "'1A£ -r~ tbmf>-/;:b.£4-r-- lfP-J,c_ft S, 5j? A'S .4-m~cffo..e/ f!_,4Jvccl~~ ! .• e ,, -/h~ /)fij-~f/J"l.P71+ bp A71 ~d/c~/' o.e. PndtYl/n~.J/d'X- 7C A Cel~..tll} ~ v.t-~ls f'JJ£ ~L~ t:.v/h cfi.,/1/Wrci~~ =+ -~ t ClAU6·E-Q \l~tlsns P.,../\·-r~~ <:b-c>ulf~~~l OcJE. d·i o/6 -r;~ ,(Jnc/ 5~£S~s CAC&.'::-ott:.f-l<.,o,l" fr"\d C~nmn ll-{---;:J/~kre/ Ckt.tll)- ho/Js ll-/ lE#S'f /e'Ucl ·76~& ~· ~t--+ t;~a_A ~t;fYL 1 ~ Md tLJ(v,I'J*f ~ 'VA' drs·hu~ft. ~\l;!(_. ~~ NWb-it.. I~AJ/ ~~;;&tc.-~io-n a_Q fnt- ~~~·tJr 7Jrs-lli~C'( ~do ~ L ~ . + ·~..,;-~- ~ AWl NtJ 1- A- A~~!(_.. :r do der-1- ~,'J()tV ZUI~I¥r ;P;, ua·'d. .
J d\
·-r dd /11ow --11.,_-i sd Jl-\n~ Ia dOlO YYLlt AiJc~"'t 6.-lum ~6 / IWIAJJLme,. 761/~ 111c. Jh41 1-k JP4'-1/t/ .w,f1dut.LJ ~ flU-J ~.tK41 :r-f ::r llJ~cl.. Jlc_ IJ->hc/ "7E X ~AI/ tot»t#cl ;. /i7r! /15 #f.i;U~~-- mi /J.S/JAJE/'2 W~ ;/£// /lkJ ... ~'r~.j -r4.Jo '7)~5 lt+-f.k,e, 14 c/Jd /ld·r lbir:lltdt.~ ~'i/J 'J);d dorl n~pl-71-l -rA·~ &/cl-"':tc. { ·~,y/ ...:£ b40 e J/t);Y]. Jhd tf-~ -:::h.,u~s/,;ifhi(.. .5'u1ffl; ../fl_J /J J: Is I ;:1j;{;J4U rf 7b ·'fll!. r:u:s-k;cf gj):sllm'ti ~ L1-rr ~<5- ~L~s; .:z:- ~V/It~ ~dt~ Ill!~ <j)IJ~ --r7t 4'1 fu"' ~~ /JD,f, --JA ::~ /n.tr}letZ. J.gYt'J fA»; fi :k/la~l ~~- .:Z: ..-:D,d no~ dk ~.P.·~ ·76 IJ1_} 8lt.e 6-P. ~ "7 ---,-;, llE~ 6·ds 0 d b.Jr I I Jtk;l a. u( r ~~~ I :I y --Jhf e~s<s:e>Jed~ ::z: i0~S csn/y /£y;.;·f /2 .,({'$~ -IJt? C)/d?sl- a/2, I Az.v/Jej ~ 1J -rh4 blc QJ iJ'[E~ ,k.JieJ b.J;IJS A- 'Jj,eu[ dG~Jf(jR,.. #~121~ /~~~~ CJt<o,~ltCC6 .. ~JI;s ~:f Jk£1'1 P)11~ ~o~tfc· ~~ '11'3¢-3 Qsvd ~,(\ C: 4- +~ cs·~ £avr6-£ ;;:z ;0;,///nY/ /h-d~ 4-1~ (}vt/;J:f -t1t4J ern /)J-,5 ~~ 1/'73~ ~ m~ del.$": .:]: -IM?zs-rn~lhel (1Pi ~ A- -~-;~ 6~1 '10 Sb~ ~<JtAJ,c;4(l)Js~cf OtauJ A\ ~Y2-t rn c~··~ J~- ~\.\J~ ~30 ~~\([ &J-. g~~, !c: $e>7 J"(\q - ~;>siu~ 7·7q« 47zc/ /6 ~-'l &~/J-1- J(J4~,'a/ ~.M(~ 1d-3D7 <Pc ~~ ~l-'YJ S~-/.,6-n /Jv,5J-,f /2xAs 1<?71) ~9kJ·~ ,., •'.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.