Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Allen, William Andrew

Allen, William Andrew
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided May 13, 2015

Allen, William Andrew

Opinion

tJ.et.tJt.f a-f (!a,l11,~tt4 ~p~/s ( ) (j (!) 0 ~ /2.. ?:)(:J 1 $~te. " a.¥' <T'~.xJts 9::f;t~..t~~llfd · · ~~ rRt . wQ-;tzs tJd. t!J~~'l>c;-1L91'D -ar~oc;-ti:R~'-'JJ -1L~­ CIL~ c..caiA."'+ Ho. ~~,o·<1-1Z <rJ(p exPtrle.fJ!:. W~II,J:rrn Au/a$a1 ~~/~. AbeiAcosta,Cierk C!/~ILk: . ·-A,~SlP--:rJ&- Cf<f ~ t<~s~ce.. -rc ~"J~ ly'\<>CA·\g Ja... ttJf.Eif.. ·10 yau . !Yl'f ~6f --rtoC> W A:..J-fs W£t.( ~:/L.J IS'! -:hts~c..flif7\ ..#tUm tVUf QQ~/ C!~IJn'\ 06fL{J';~ /l~ru- J?tAj ?i/l.~'f Aw~A-1 WitS Ex. hP4-rl~o ·1t.JJ~ 0?\ ~v.·AM.( I ~ 14 A~'-:S/.Q Jw & Ac:J (s£<!.-1;4>... ~4-" %'/- G~cJ~¥1m~-1 Cl44 V ~~~u.JJ Ail ~~~ $$' -'1hE. ;s-_s-:1?t~rs-ht.?'c/ -?a fJt.c so~a; r HIJVL -tltJ ffoa b/~ b.fih ~ ...-~ .-1J, E bf~ l O'?J "s~pf6/!J b6,e_ } ~ ~00[' (}'1-tJ T'S -;71 A I -WII-s --::hctACt~J ~ /l> d»~/s- ::t JVAS Ne>+ :7?-u:J,.c?J (TA/ l!1f~'7-1'<..9'z7. tP

~ -rh"'l ·XcR,c-Pn~~ l'&4~ ~£ &~J Jutut ~ ?ht. 6tb11>4r ~f'bJtrllee.. /JnJ .. J'ht- 51-rJk <r·.C ·1£Jt/)f'S, 4..,11 :5dlf(!:_-h~ ~A1rpl:n1c.lf,e:!, S UJoll4J ~ cJA~J,.

AJ tJ f-(j th-1-, 22-J /J s .sud A/ "'11L s. J"" ,E. -;;: /l-#1 1 A _p,. ~8 ~ &' -rn e.

J6S'J1J ·\i}ujj:; c.:JA-1 'Utsle~c.t &u.~t--1- 8cf' 5JJ1d C1LL-1t J-v 1 1 Jlue-g ~tJ. (j\~ 8~fl_~n'\~ rto ci<"·-M~~ \fh 1. :n.L~7~ A!UKf J fh.t; 6-~,..~ \llArta, --:ht s~F111heiL I ~08~ -f,lt_ 4-st IJ?tmd~ '3n ~¥-k/llh6L '/llL I.:J~Z?IV:;uc);cl~ /~/s~~-c /' ~u./i-f t<J~ f 7ZJ ~6-HE (lr;)l.t~·tre> :z u Jt ~ 1tJ...J12M<) /J 1~ tull-s t~~ .t Aausi~ tun I:I ~~~G?/1jSR. </ do?J~o :r kJ-45 ~ii!al t:Jel.VI16d ~;vn /:I s~tJ-k#l~ J<j oaog ::EJ1 wt,oh "X- Wh5 Al6d ~J.~ts-J c-rh~ $4-m~ ~AG(.o S~p+b71b6!?..

Jg. ~<( A·f ll>:J.-1 frrrl) t:rr\ /0 c.J{~q!fU:JE8't. ft)~J/6< ~~~ -:j);J} 1'/()J- 1-//iUL '1l1~ .J~,~ Jl,·c-~'~ o~ 1"h ~- I E;s--:D. tJ<&~~:)ct ~""J-.

6\1 'S'eptt.dl b6e. 1g . d<1o~ /hi-d /Jid 1/c-1- t/AV-f oLt;tisc£,cd,~ ~ :5;:-p.f.~ hu 'f ~ar; A-+ 1: m ~ 6' &"' Ar<fu.s, f .A~ :t. hFW"'(_ $'Ar7ci ,n~ gll'Si'l\~t·l £/,~ w€LE rprm "1JJE- ;7?,-:;!PMc:l~ tS~ /h1 /J-tf~IUJ~'f (]t,.)tJiYJ ~IJT'6 ~.. .Ju.( 1 .~~a<>!~ ~ .fil~ kriJ-A .ze 16&-h-w~J tv-A"5 sa~ -:z:;..zh_~clrd·,..,:.:r 40-,., nut ~~~ ~ HIW<:. ~/~J 0 tOILi-/-> t!rt:' ffir/;158$ C1at.fll6, ~E tJrsrf- T~d WelL lfbavd- rJEWI~ ·-p;·s~uu.~cO 6o~ce o l,Uh.e~~ ~"'j~ Q\<!CtA'd &-rrul,s 1.\p IJ.JT11 I J S.5fA'Tl.A-J ~ 'X do Nof J:: A Is;,- ~~~~W 'ThJ¥1 J'-'~<:fC ..(ll()lOo Yll<=-CA: C) ;/lt5 --ri:P'flowil-1-k...J .)J~ ·;to h-; n1 ·'72 lh ~ &IV~ o.P ~- j &fr., ~616>(!;-~ls rAs ~l~-ts I) ..6E.,:!y -rhE em Jvr '}f.\- b,e145 /im t ·rs Ce.e-PJ.f~J ~7 -~J?!'- )1}c. CA'fj. 1/3 :l'f --1A ~ 1-s-o:t"- J J '", ~ I tf) )'.sfI!JiJ 1-JAJ r/6 U£-\~~$~tc::J,~ ~ <Ju.~)-s~~C:J, ~ (!A-7\ 1\J<;,J & V~s~ '-16 fh't 01Jto"1110~J,c,:r (f);~J~.'~ r.. ~~ ).,t(}S f l?mt J' ~ n1<.f &~6td Cl}/;irn 6A-Wt ~ lOfrs J//J<)t /V&./ ~ J1fpl { .d3 dbJD, f /11/o~ 70_ &-nah1f 7D ~ /11~.a ~~ J/pl.s:l}/. ~I( 1f1uJ &/lcL ,.,_, . -·-·~7/(1 mtrflce-s~ lis~/ QIJ{vivt Ji'lr. Ar.s · rY1o..J:~ &;tIll~ T~~4l . ,. Intel £/s:.d Jh s -~ ..lkl~9~-<f1~ 4ppeA/ />n;£-( te:J,~c(A f 1t1tf 46vJI~JlfR- cQn4 ~..11.a~f·f"M1 ~~o ·~t ~s/kl(__ ~p (!t5,eiJ?Actt.faYI Q,c_ f}pp~{ ~s t/C>rl lkvc /JUj S':-jnAfuL~ d?1 -/ fo /,UR.f/ ~­ o~~DCJ-IZ'i1Gt'D -iJ~-a<=;-IC.<t~~ 1J ~~~. Jlc;,/: ~ 4~tue£~d t6y ~(fie,... --fiu,.. ~sltz;c/ ~"01;1.5 o£llc., pe_ 4 7.)/S k/s I d'w~. fi,-1- t:<.h<-;·1 ,0/1~ miJr/~ I 6-n ·-v~eS7YJ66~ ~z:... ci-?)14~ P7? - All~;( c}'l OOIS .::L ffk k.Jtlf ~y.-d<;-)2976 -8~<J9-/2..~ ~t;, . ec:P ~-~~t'"s~,e:{,ch- whlcl ~l... ~f6J,c_4,cn--. J"'6'~u~-~ 0~ be__ .&t,i/II;Jk/ IJJ ffluj {rm f /hd Ck-n nl;/ &-t kJAJLJE. cf~ 94 SVJ~&. &~, . \'-J::+ AcW~~c.l- GvtAIL+ -&1fs . cs>H~Js ~~; ~tu;-~~k~41 ~SRAqJh~c .' Ar<E"A-1 .q}\ZJ&:. @~Q~~~s kn.'Z: ~,(\ ~+-1\-ll~ of.s~l>t. ~-,~ :~

oe.Ju.. bAS~ol 07) />lt·IY) TJ tJo,cfJ I Rtsk.c.fl.. v ~~~<S'SJ~ ..C,e. j..f¥Ji-1tlf-. r-:Drs~-,6'11 )\ !.~ T Aw-J. ·-r/1..-t.u.k/ So~ ...kt<.. ~;s ff/~s-s, J?.fs JJJ/ 6ee446£- ~ ~ ff..f.fctz-n~ (}kfvm 6-rtll-V'~' f2~s;~ JZ) Pt.e~i &;5d.tWtc" ... buJJUU:.l ~~ WtJS :SI../;ps~/11-+.eJ ·lthd 1\/i.vt!~ f~<i>erz-/zc/ ~ ~~ t!.ev~J 6~ -j],1_ ~!Uf 9 kJf./n~t5~~s -::j'J,q:/ /W~"t- dMGrL $t..bftJ~/Ir?-d"' /Yfq/1.571-~fAJ­ ~ HDf CJ.u@71·~ '<(]:) '1?t 7 ~uQ..+"" 6u;cl~c~ -ftt~l ~ ·rn~.5~i~l A'ncl v;.f~t r -te hli..f 04-SL -~ ~rlh 1,~1.1 ~1 '11 ~ ~"J:);s)lucl /kff.olfAL d' 9 ~ ~ fnCj &~sJ'O 7 A?n ~rJ<J·<!I2-?I-1 t.?/' 7Jr lfS·& (]j~ AI/ :P A~ 1:. 1"5 ~~ A 61 ilL ~tid -R> & !Jlbl£ -JZ {Jft~f­ PIA-/. ifh·<e C:U;d4nlc~ -fttrr-/-13 5h--t/ 6~-1 ·fl~te.? --'76 ~;trvL ::;:= ~ h/ld'~ /Jnd :::f NE~d f?Le>cuf ~ -:hd/c~ -f l!ltf'-c9-IZ.9'?·1- -t1?6.re.c_ ~ r/t!J:f cf'"Ju2 ' ·,

Dhua v s~-t ern 6h2J <S""t9~ :;;1?-. QR/mlfut I CM;~~ AS Of~-~ C."iu'd I

O~s <0~..ttt.,:sJJc.4,~ rtm "o-f b~ s"'b +~ t. A-\)~ :J;, vob~~ 1 ·--:r-r €.1·-/11u A+..IA~..Ds oiZ..-,f do~s rJo·f, -~ llk~ I"S Q.Jt-ol'\ C..A~ Wh6-~f. (Y~~A-' dt.tft~~1ctd---­ ovu A ~fl-~ yn~ beh~ m~ R~l1 b'-/111A+ (jH\/'-~/6-$ A-pp.:!Afl.lrnc:£ /)~~££­ :/~1. &vr/L.f, Rvtl~ 12.0 ·v~~Ci'f\s ~" -r~xA5 ~Jes e~ <!-7vd ~~u!£ 1 &di,;,J ~(i~,c..lr~ ooca..·'JA"'t._ ~~~ C!.t-m"oi ~c Q;nr~$Jl ~p~ ·v-k~ (})1-s..J.~<:) C0~Ae.-\- ~l~t 1 ~t./ '1}1~ tk~l-\s~Js Psu~?s~4-YICEJ h .... I- e~~'<t::s -r;,~d~e:.. lski/Yl csP A- ~kna.y ;:hd,~~f 1 ae /A1 Ace.wszds (J6~Af Alf~ll\- 7t'uE.. WArua -rn.~ll~ 6~ m.d 'llt~ ~~e-n a£' A vA-ItJ h/an<j ~/l/n"llt'll~ U-pon ~ (]J JA~ Y\fa ~\l~~t- ~~~ cyo~s r/.l)-f h AQ<e A \)4,\-~ J ~ J6">(t ~J lc-J-mel-v\f ItS ~~"5c:spkm~ IY o<scs'iJ. O'f(. 6V~ S~k~ ¥- lDJJ-1/G.L ~kt .:Jl>()g' v~J rles~{ f/Atr~ ~i,~&,d_4td-r .au6/Z. lh~ /$'"'$"~ "J);s-h~~e:t Clsaue..f-.. ~ ~'-Atli!i~t~~~~ & 'Jh ~ ID'$-"11\. d<.tjtCii~ I v~&h~cl ~ut<.f l;.JSVt\ t- ( Ues--kd 10 ~ c__-+k ~LtA\~ ~ Jt-AS '!f> . J~~ ~f\ 'li.x·AS aovE:-fo-1'Im~~ (kJ~ tJ'f, ~C<{- JS's--a J4J,~~-+f rp;·~~~<:J (~")Jm,~t'~ ~& Lu/\-ll~ll ~-h~- ,,'',l.th' (C?t)·-1'J1 -~ ·n.thf'l~ ~f}l ~ 1~ -p/~-;vc.t tk>4J- l:Jc<;-n, ~ Q) ::t=n IJt-t s.fm ~UA'J~ dY) -th £ .dl.is--1 tnond ~ tVo6£mhcR ~ ·::;::::n tfp~Z r) /1JLOI ~;;:;:, ~ t::..fk e14 671 ·/JJ! i1_~t 1()6>lcl,. -'1)\ fZh Rvt AfU( 1r11d ~ ~o,e_ i, @ :1=n IJJhrlle/2._ <k\.c.A'\f<.r on /ht- fii·,f>r n1~'1 :vn JA1\\.\Aflit ~ ~u~ ~ \J~s -*'~'~ "T.!.K-~tS 6otJ6/hr1.!rA~ ~J~ ~, e,o9 Jvt6ll~t~tJ->-.

E'A~ ~c..c.fl..J. j,~f~ -:n, -fh·ls S'-tbcJ.,#!'(ptL /)~-s "'Jhr ~u/L~c)..~!,a;_ fPIXJ/J.J bq ':::M'? C1:-tr-d.'.h4tm. P.rnd /']\~ "i}Unc/(4) /H-()s o ~ --Jn'~:s &4/c ~.e -o,6.fll,J C1e vt/1.-../s . -<P?~ &,.,-s./'-k-/r.h.. lht.cl /~s b---n/Jcl.s.J ~'1 9h£ f.s$,is/.q,kA£ d~li'n£ khal c:s!A4/,~4 JL4tu;J,:zl~a~ <$!~- <'f).-s &s'/,e..-e:..f &1.4/Z./s,. ~ Cvll!UfV bJ,1~c:rn.. <;T53 'SvJ !lal ~~ ¢$;~f6.K·(!~,nJ 4tJP1 1c;93): 66Yh Jl J~lin&rn ~~~ su; u <dJCf, ~~ z., (1i.~ (!lll?fl ~ JCj9/) AftJic)E; S" § ?f D~ -rlt ~ "/i,;VtS ~sl~/cffot ,fnd !k,f'c/t l./-.6') d7 '171c. !i.xAS D w~ ~0-Jmt)vl (Jpa~uJ?L VJI4c.t .Jua7sd,~.e~ (j•P All J2brf &-sq ~ '1}£ d/51/LJJ ~~Is-. /1~ .5az ~~IVnnW-?t1 &J~ ~</.,~1, /~~-tJJ.. <fud:c,4l J)/~1-a~~f(~.J.'rn.) ~"'* r WA-'IJ~,.e_. d.e,~Jru) ~ ~;/( 10 ~~ ~4-r/I~J .t\7\ Act(> W3 r:.1G<--~ ~w6'-1J -1/o/3 hdo IZ<?f --1A£ -r~ tk-n-s-l~kt:ir- lftL.f.,c_/1.· S, 5j? ff5 ..4-m~cl~-1 f!.,_41v~:cls:-~ ~ .d., --fhf.. fJM~f~+ .:sP A?l ~d/c/-m.P-,..1' o£ _h-1~4-{/pr.. 7a >'~ 01411.{ ;JJ?,v.t.-sls f'/J;!. ~L~ c.v/h c..kll7ucl~~ c:s-?'' ~ -z: C!/l-Us-ec \l~tl>hs ~/\ ~~~ <:b-au~/YlliJ-r'\.-1 OcclE. d·i oiL- --r;~ .&ncl 5~£.Ste.~s ~~~,t:.-.k,C-1" trhd C~~m'" ll-{-;J/-skr'cl <1t»i1.1L/ ho/Js ll-d .f.5#S"f TeVd ·~r::ms ~- ~~+ ~li}aA ~~IYL,~ ~ cto~*f ~ ~' drsk,~t~ ~\t~~ ~~ NW;biL l~t+efl ~~<;;&lc,~i<m a_o fl1t. 1~&--t!l 7Jrs·ltc~C'( ~do · + ·~Nti-1 -r AWl l'ltJ ./- A- 1~~1(.·. :£ do ll!v~ ... ~J'dl lU~~ >?n d;j'dq. -~ dt:> l<'t1otU ·-?h.,..J. erl Ji.\n~ 16 dOlO ¥YU.t Af.k~~'f CA-Iom ~i6 / ILviAJJLme.. 761/~ me. J714f 4 PJa1.1/~ _,w,f11dut.D ~ ~ A,/K41 :r-f :::r u.J~cl~ fie_ IJ->tsc/ "7£' I ~AI/ Wlf11kcl 1~/im n-5 #f~.e?t7}-- mi /)diJIUr/2. t<J.fri ;/£1/ ;vb.., --J~w~i -r4Jo '7)/.kj-s 1 +lkte,. o/Jd /10··-1-' 14 /v..rr11td~~ ~'i!J ·v;d dar! A~~l --rA·., eu/cl. o·:u; c. --;-7t,..-/ ...r. 640e )/')IYJ. /hd tfs -:::h1ut5£/,;iihG. .SUim:-1fij /J J: Is / /1 l!u rf khJ . Tb rJ)E- tJJ:sklci gj):s~tf ~ Ot,n, A~ ~LdlS) :z- ld/lt~ .thdt~ 111/CA.._ ('?"~ -J7,. ~1 fu"' dPf -r.s-kf -1A ::--; /n4-.fletZ.. l?Jt'J f II»; fi :k/la~l ~~- .:Z ~-;d do-l- d/tJ ~~~~ ·73 ~ CS1te 6-P ~ '7 --/1, tt£~ ~ds 0 ;r b:Jr I I N<s-1 a.\,( (r 0.-t f, I J p --fh-z e~s<s:oJ~J~ :z? ~/IS ~Jy ·7£'/J""f /2 _,({'$~ -l;h :$ o/d?sl- &~/ Azv/JGj ~ IJ ~4blc m~¥b/L t0£J W*5 A- 'JJ,eu[ cJGtJitiR.., £l~t21~ 26~ Qj1..;) C)QL ()t~~-7tCf0, ~JI;s ~-:f JlcEi'1 P)11 C7?U ~ovllc· ~Wk> '11SC/0 (!svd ~"\ C: 4 +~ s£?- ;;e/Wfl~ ;;:z; Zb)/l/n.1 /J,..d~ 4-1~ &AI.J:f .-tA4-J en, fi-,5 ~~ I/ ~ ~ /Y)~ ~ /.5": .:]: --;/!A7l S-l'n ~ fh eP A- (1ft1 o--.f2- -'1h7-s 6~/ '/0 S'b~ ~~£AJ,c;4 {J)~s~cf ~IAJ A\ ~f2-t YY\ rf\<; ell··~ J~- ~"'J~ ~60 ~~\ll SJ-. gt.t~, {c $e>7 - ~f1sitH/~ 7·7q.~ 47zc/ 76 '7J,·-z &4/l-1- ~(J4~h!J( ~M\(-s 1d-367 <Pc ,fp)\ ~-{-~J S~~,IJ-n IJ!15J?t /2xAs 1<[;7/) ~~(}Q!L_ ~·~

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.