Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Hurtado, Michael

Hurtado, Michael
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided June 5, 2015

Hurtado, Michael

Opinion

: f', '/§ h zL-oz‘ 01 Th d t ta' S 4 ' " ” ls ocumen con ms ome 4 RCQE|VED_IN pages that are of poor quality at the time of |maging. ' CGURT OF CR|M|NAL APPEALS _ JuN¢os 2015 {.Y__v ¢wé,` <.-\'.§°* WZ m)\-\&*" 2@¢¢~@2- z\€\v\ wz.

§ ‘~` '” Abemcosta, Gle§z< § Q~\)`,`<`:\\€.c».\/\j‘¥ \M‘\C-\»\c`e,‘\ \&.).\?“l*ué.f.» § \C¢<~\- ¢z'.; \\ 0" '§\~L\BRM‘> CC)¥‘{"~.)§> § dam `\\fL'>/\§\m£.( \é\\s> Q>mr\s \)\c,§¥`@v\$;c.)dl 44.,\‘§~. ailmé,-¥\\MQ, W\uv<:.\,\ §§ z;c-)\S\ mJ\/_\\Q,\A mob \’z<:.\\.»~)c§`\_, \3\{ %\A\;~_ \\`~\3\»\<,\ \/`\\`&.)\~\,\¢%5 §X\Q,<` ¢\'i§\\\ 20 2015 A§§\\¢».\ § \»§mv.~»\¢\/\@v ‘»"b»\\»w\¥\<é_ `_\\\\%> wa¥ w\v> 3 w~‘\z\/\ §v\/»E_ GM'&' § C\~*\\M\ /~ch\ \A.M?¢cc§ C..\Q»';\L \A\>Q\ \AC,Q,J.:.»S g ¢)`<>%\\3~ ‘J\/\Q\§,wmv\<x`\/`,M y _.`: irs S\Q-¥€d§ ‘2~¢1\¢5€,, `\r> \'X§Q\\C.;»/AS L\N\`¥ § Hu; C©‘Q \~,m> llo~v\é_~ b§\§)§\\@)m\§% _ O`b\\<.~;}\\_,v\~ \\z;_\ 'Mw"`$¥ QC_¢~;J\&\j ‘2< <L\L\)Q,é ;G`C¢ `: w\<\~\v\:j§ ' ‘ C\v\€':_ wwc\mmuv*\ c§ `\c»..v~) / c\,v~(\}, ‘(uC_C£JV\/\\A/LQ,\A£&;)¢&\.¢¢\ `\v€> \)\‘i,\/\M»§> ‘ , ' _,\,,;__A/\é\`c\.\) w Ca\~vm\l~/~c,v*> \Mm~j ‘ \/\L,,\J\`X E> .

- /\)\c,\w\m$ L\;\j/\uo<§. §§ $€)&mr é@~.\.v\ j \A . .. z ' ‘ §\m\»\bc£(\, Mm\§ \-\ Z`Czw &>\ bMB<L\ \)§Coz.$x<k.: 615 .3‘\/\‘2` v .- ::'_\\C.m\¢\~\§ RQP\ v M\\\\umm§“mwc \<5 265 ?¢\A§ §§ \,¢\QQ\\CL\M‘:> k _ §§ 39 \\m\m@ C`<><§\».> Cgv\é, v\»§\\\\<`.w\\$ o‘o§c§§w\ \> §§ L<z>m»mwé<v z . ‘\u:>~\§c> UE~.\M~SS bomb Y~/<,j\\-¢\)\Qé `\*© V\b\>\\<mm‘\ ul\¥\/\ m \€L A<;&& ' § 511 @:€A§;\@Mq\wem _'};~ \5¥\€7 o\_ `\'\/~m@m \;\ iewrc,\/\ c§\ ¢§.._\:\; mc,mé‘> m g

`;:\\AC.. gx\.f‘{,;{,& uva C£(_.,» \/\£;”’l?` M\]k C»` w‘~`\"< <‘§Y` \:\&.U~mb G:)‘\~§‘\;~§ `;\\£Q_.d» \\/\ \r€v `w;§§ §§ gm mm § vK~\/.§., ""' _';(_%\§1\\\ ~\w\,\e, A\ umw M\\Q_,cmj `¢ _, ’.f( b . ~\

..¢ wl£$_i @¢M L\QY<L\¢O\`\\/\ \'t‘.§»\\~\!\\\:\c§ \,\U`)X C§J:uw\w\/¥b l §‘“i, -c,m\&_ \M§.j \\s zo\§i _

'T<> bv\¥x' \A~Zg_;~\\,\\s Q'»x~\- C§ \\cc~\/As \`\/\10/\1~`<3\/\3 C@v\<‘.évw§v`\c,( Zv\é,:\`\&é_ \1)\~`~1<\ J\§§\`\Cw`v\\ 1 \1<§$1' C<)~/§\\P-_M§c\~\`wv\:wm 111\<"5 QQ`,\\~.-\§ @,\Q~IL\R 1 1410 10 Pe.’\;<e\§`¢c_‘ A \\ M§=.% YQ,<;'¢»_;/A\v ;\\e,é, 65C_11Wv1; 1\1;¥:111.£11.;»1;( 113 -1\‘\3 1\»05‘\1<1§><,<»\& dewng 110“£{’\_0\11,\.0.\\ 3 SM§§>\QMc`/c‘vu\ RQQQ\‘LL Qm`qe;>"v<-IL `\\J\ \1»&§?.\\€;1>;\/11:"ubM§bAG\~oJ\/\MW/ 0\;\\€¢1¢ v\” &\1,“1\11¢:1351 suggsv\» §§ 1;0 \\ 131 »'1;§,\<@11£@1111/<~1‘ f;,\¢\¢;\)~\@z 1\01\\(’..» 152~€1& ‘1*@1/1§€,¥€.€1, \)~3 111/1 `1"\/\1§. '1A¢;`>€11CU»`11C)V\ `11-`> \1~5:>3\)\¢.\` \LPPeq\S C:>\)»AS . 1 . 1 `_\\'\`\‘.> (\CR‘“\ !31€\€>~116,. \A\\BQ, 1>€¢ vu:¢q/§W\ , 6.\¢1¢.~ 163 YK\"<):\" QQ,\\LW;~' 51 l *1<'>1\)\(§€, 15\` `1\/\`13 Couv\% C\Qv`$\ §\\\`v\€.( § 'C1:>C,1,11/1Ac1/\>1S)`11/\Q11 1 \C"~ 3‘~`3\!\.\'€11\/€1' Q‘x§\f`\;\“§o<\€,. § 5@~£1\>\¢€_ C,\C.Cc>v\»q_\».m)¢¢_. 1515 \:1@\§1»\» V1'1@111<) 1®1111\)\/1)(/`(`>1>5@,1(<>\/\ " ®11\/\ <LQ`;P\<> §1(&1&§§.1:\>;1/&<11 _ 1,§;,1/.€§?\11~;\@\/\~\3 § c 511 461<`.5@11<::<@_\>) 1,;>\10\,\ QM\~QM, § 100-mi 11§<'_\§¢11@(1,' 51 1"_).\1 "é.§*é£"‘?e <;_1/1¢<"@;§ \ peck 1.».,@_ RC&£.\/`\`MYQ\)O\V .1/1<;( 11va AQQ\`\CWAS 911\@\13¢;1/:3 1§11'}'\01¢\§.»1 C<.)\A\)1C,11c;1/\ 1113 n 116\111 C(M"\ ~ _ " 111` \\cq111'5C11\~1w1111{1+13 q 1116va 0 ”`1§)<@5 G)m‘\@zm mud 1113£11\/\‘>1 1311/\\1`§ " 1CA 1113$*€€§34,, 11/\‘?1`,\)\151\ c\§$&é,\\\%§€&\k, ad 115\11/\

1115 dq:~>s @\ 411 1\/11"1 111111>11,§ 310-11 ('§,\15;1 § U_`\ @££13.§1\@¥\2®`§1 _ C§&\`Qé’ B€'¢'\ 135 LLG v`\ ‘%m\alé/ 1315 C¢~LY‘§\ l'("1>_\‘;\.\.“`\'»211/~1'1:1~{6)1115 615 1 1111 § 1113 1111\@@ “ Chm¥%“ 111 av\~d‘@1@`s-M 111 ,\11~§@§&1,: _'\*\1\0;\ 111\`\ S\A\x\)(111cé d\§(`,c,\)@v_j <?@<<\ACS‘FS)P` \\§OQWROW »~. ‘ @»v\¢@¢\/;xmc(` 11611\”\`@§<11 1::3); 11/\511111/1/\£1/€1%’( 53€1:>1#3'1/\/\€,€1@1`§`<;¢ G"‘>~\\Cv\:\\\/\C\ 11/\13 C€>\,u-\g ®/\\]v&, 113v\ .. 3 t 1111 §1’61©`\1_€1 "11"\11<>10\ 1')011\” va“\<§§m\dd< psc ‘1\_/\ l ‘ 11\€ §mies§ 61 10 ~ 6a11)@é,quwl:1 881/115 _C`;:"_C,L._;% 111 W\€/ _1111§@»§1/\ `\"Wil §\/\1:;1\ § Té:\<a£» C@\,A»C@\/\Sé\m¢jdjmm§ 1 4 ' 1111,~?@<,;1¢, 411 1115 11 1\,\<;@1\,\31011 - . 4 .~ _ JV_W,‘W,`_,`. . _- .'4 ;'.,~,`. maj '. Jr.». ’. » ¢ \uz'vqw W.'a.k.»n"'»‘,,, ~\\m&»\ c@-v\ ;>:\@ fm /QCM\ 2¢¢<-@§»:. `\';> vw W_ baby \\/'\\evc§\") § \A\\ KPO\\~§+KQ.S §§ xv\\k)\\)W+‘)va‘\v&Q/"Lé_, `w\{ \'\AU_) l QC‘\,U\‘E>Q L><f;,u\" CG>\¢‘\¥ C.)\».`r\(\_.” CW(-:.`\Q;\§ \\C> C;»\/\\%\ v CR,.§Q\TQ§\\~\_QN\Q,\\j \,§/\ ogccsé,:~.wcc_"~ l@`_¥?’_ ms QLA\@§ § C:wv\ <,@\<‘. `t’mm§e/L 4 ‘\A'\\ /)\)m:>§w:~\v -.C\:~.C,\m'\"@_\/\`\*;;>') )\)QY.AC.S, dfw . grow c§:;>~`\“& Q\N\\v\€( _ Ou\, Jv'i/\€ .V"/Xb§’)¢ RQQ;.\/"\§ @~.\‘b\/\/\\¥-'\QCL th\>m§@@‘<\®vé>) irs `\'\A\'i ' " CC:)~\.\"\“ § *S\L‘rle<§\c::\nbv\,_.' `\:>L C\ ' S\- \J\;`\Q<.~.;N`§- Cwm@$~\‘ § §\\M€_, “ 'C»` LS:QQ}\ C§QQ»~\ § 3;\\\'.5\<\ <S;,;uWW-{-; \,U\j@_ \3@,@¢\ Q\,Q,\qu\? w . &XO:\§ Q).nl\ `c,\v»é"_ .\&5`> §§LC"_°`\S’ 6\©`,\&_3,~\1"\’ Nm X;C`£ \_CS"“`*§°°\ §§ y Q;Q\\o® \§\~OQQ>M\`€S C§L\Mu.v\c&e_¢ &d\ \,€NLS (L).C_ G_)Q§r$€~, §§ (c§\u§;‘ ' "\"\~\:\. \¢\C@ §>w\k§vdc o\/L "`i%w<z; '\A`L_\U¥§Ov\ §§ \\&/»z ..Qm}>v.~&&a CKMW\Q\‘L\YLQS, &.\c>v\._ L\)'\V</\ ~19\'/\§, §§\“_<:@ mr \\~`Wz §cv.éa_$ 1 V\\S©Y‘\f\€.* F G.\/\e:ru\`\ ®,\é_ `.`§\Awgez § ".5§/\-€£. U\N\\\`€(t, `S\cAC-S_ . _ C\c\`\\/\,\ . \‘~\¢S() SSW‘. \v\_ m\/.\\;’C,\/\,:"\_`o‘\m c\_ PQ\`\\§ \\@ C,J>. 30 ii o C\\s`\\ 2\`§\\1\'\§ \/'\'E>\\A¥C'>\/\ . ` ` . - Q\€@®C/ 5a $\»r<:» "-c,\v\.é_ `SQ~/\é, Q\`\ E@C(wrec‘__ `. C\,C£`_\x»/\A@\/\:&‘> 46 `V\/\%_ Q»X`& § C\~\v\/\`\!v’<`¥<~ \"`\QG>QQ\$SJWW/\é#\r " v\/u.,s \\©\ \'\c#\>@a¢> Q~¢\~Q\§,' Cxu~;é» q \Q.L§&Q_ § CQ,¢\S\`\~/£<,m~hom §§') <;,`\"§*:u\f\S\/\Al~'\j\,uf O‘Vdo.\` ” . ' .` . 3 ~_ . 4 .; g J\Y\`;,;\\ S»§M_\\~\<LL . , ; : `va_\¢&\,_@\é;\ ., x\T\U/.&> .- \L~\L.\§A@:>i . 3¢&@111\¢\5\§ \33\.1€“.»\ 33 33 ~ .' ..|., .~~..s<\§\‘g.f`§"v.‘:;o“.“‘¢ f C¢zz.§s:@\é. § 3¢@:¢@ _T§/\\S §§ §§ Q,Q'X\;\X O. 4me. <Jw\é- <*®cv@,c;li` <`Q\B\'\ - O;.."€/\\S - 262un >‘\‘ *&€> ClQ»\/\/\.(>\:) db\~'ve,<_,@ovLC¥J/\¢Q; wcc_> V\/Lc,u \<>.é, 41\70 \SQ\/K\,'\C_\ "¥\';x\_\ \/\/\¢ K{§¥Mq\ej" 36 XCL\’ Ccz:\.>.y\`\*j \)\'§\»*€\<~,,\' 'C»\e£LV\ <W\ ~;`>_;);\)\e, _m,\ <.W\Cf, \`3 \<=_> §C.‘. <E>'V\Q\'LCL C\.C§:D@:S m\H\/\Q;,\\j&\alg 'h>g§oa;o‘- §A§o\,\< umw C,\_ CQJQJ - §:B<L\v§` V\A<»:\\c>,¢(, “§e> V&v§§<>.( ` §f§<;c;>:§é§ ‘C.‘\<>.©;\‘~ log .¥\/\<a_ C\Q>w. _. §"T\ C§\<`\M\uu,( §A§P<QJS. , - § x 4 _ , 5 ~_v§§§¢%x;¢'> UU\ %\.L\.\c;j- UL\,G~'§”`C§`ALCS v ` § C£\/)\<;\'L\§"S\,~é@`ef$`P<'-~J§.)Q,\A , . ` \:eé,' `§w<.w; \\$\\)e'b&.~= \000 Cbb\<:§`" `_ v ~Pvc»;é»c; -,@w<w\'\w/\~LQ\~<;£\)Q_>_ \§c>'\\m QL C§c,\\§\ks\>\x¢,¢` LO`\)\Z<,Z%OF€> § §>Q<f\\\cé.$\vu\c. CQ¢AC§'»§LQPQA§%$%`C\¥C\A§*F" -` § ‘ ` v M®§\~; §\@¢Q;. 3 1 ' ' L\!.?S`UW§§@Q\U»L C\Q\~§\ _ /UCZM) 0\`\€0¢'6`>. ,L\,L- jo \°_>Q' ii _. 4 §X)QS\QW\§¢Z.XQU'\`§TM@\L<,»S f _ _ ,_ 4 S<>§ _UO'¢>§~ S-*\'\- $§v-Q€%S;\§c_\\©d` »°?- .C_\\)\\Q`~Q>s`\/¢\S'§CQ°\"X Iv\§)é:>`\ - 4 t V&\‘\,C»¥\u\ T?\ '7@}0\ 'L§\S:`§e{y‘q,§§chlcc, k ~ .. v -` .' - q$(>QQv\ws\j\\)mw`\q §AUQ_. Al.u}. v h § A) \C,`\¢§@\_(;‘> \/~c»\\\<§vé/ Cw\w\wci\ §§V` : h 'M)<é§\i#vr({-§\q \ ,¢52<>:~7'?>§ _ . . ~\\/'.cm§ \:/`\'{z;>.v\cle ~Tcl»€,~m. §L'>\ §@\Uu&QQ »§>v\ \Aw\o\,\;<; `,~\*X 7%€€)§: 1 3 `4> ~TE\L&BCQM§§ Cw\$e\md §§\\zc)c,§\§/\§~Ak _ »~ QC®WC\:\,\\\@ $,\'R\/\»\\§'.§CC_\§ “ ' .. `§§/\§§_`>\€°€&C» C\<§‘~S ch$\m\»~/L md W_\\C§/\<x@_\';\§u§" ‘ `§L\‘§‘S'¢§()$T ~ \§D$\O \9§'>1\`\5§ \§§\ F\\/\ BBZ,@ _ ` , §XO\R\\`\'\%C<\\:M 5313 / `i v \Q;/\\/\ €0§(;\/\.\'\"\§ j§@@ _ j ~ x l v_\Qv_§\J\@\;,\/\\,§`Y)L jmé

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.