Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Randall, Ray Norris

Randall, Ray Norris
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided July 27, 2015

Randall, Ray Norris

Opinion

U/e/A/,,.

314 ' P/@,Q€/ )C)//@ 3,_..

£126_/13126_0_/ _616 7_41_110_(2_3_1771) ¢/1>17 613066/17 1174 //al@€@_§’_ 1_¢7/@3/:/66_>¢_/1317 1311)4 O_{) ¢/76 /8</"4/1)/56//6¢ ('1'30/’6 //7 1‘/61/'/5’ 6131317 >_¢}/_,_16)_1015- ¢//0/ 6131,/’)4 113/114 "“4$928§ 19 177131<11>175 413 66 /}/60’ 1-_17_ }/1>131 613131)4 d/e;

/_/) Mm¢/<)_D 601 /`17_)"5_/%_<1)47 A€/_/&_QL 43 /14)4)416’61/1)4

_sz 14 p,Q/11617 315 1110 >!_11>0_ 1151_ 7131)2_1€1__ 1)_14_ d,Q/J_//<:a)_%(?_m dz?_c/ 1411 // 161/1633_ 1{7_;/__&>131/ 1314 §11117117111 §11611/$

136 1631/19

14/6&6€ ` 141/6

11)1`15 .-' '7» 21>-/5

` 1?61$,,6,6<:1 ><1§4/1/ 15116/7?///6’d

1121 ??017 61 / 1612/16

/of/ Cour% @FCr/m"znc;'/ /Qp/)¢zq/§ ` mal <:@w~¢ 1/1//»/¢ n/<>. 953 g 8§»/@ » , » 33, 123 ~<>¢

E»>< faa/sle l ` 6 k fn T/')Q COQL§{?§§@FSMEMM ______

_Z?_@),;EG;?_CZG // 6’ €r/m/o@/ /OADUT/§C§\WN /A@PEALS ` __ /S,Qp_z/;_,c_an )¢ § /Qas,>;¢_//;,_Z€g.<a$ JUL 27 2015 __ n ` .» ., blib@m@@@ia;©£@vk__ /¢,.@0 //@Q/))/S ~

/M/s;i/n/) r:'<>/ Wansfé/ d F , ~ ,/§,qo//z»a/¢/cn 00(>/ )Q/// 365 v/€c¢)_ by §Q;g£¢o)£ v ’ Uf/mm@/ 1€’/0,,0€0/3 Z>e ~/1/@1/¢>

_I>_Me__do@`<o.c@m&[€_YZ/q/g@“@L&aLc/_COU /’>/ .' __*_*_C_O.MES-__/_(/&ZQ,~Z@;}/j@_zo/L/[,AEW //66/7/,, //,7 ¢A€ ,IU)€ 0_»6<)</€~ §)£>z/_€</, and adm/owed aaas_€d moves _>_Lh_f.§;__@a/_’/ >Z@ /ss@@ @£A€/@ 110 ¢he /SQ/ %/) Ais“» ¢r)a¢ UOQ/>L of f/@/»"//S C<)QQ_%/\/, `7€9(0;5 ¢<> 770/05 )F€/’ ~__Mlze;aslp,Q/_Mdi/;>U,_£%aa£zm€n >'/.s; and feca/d s ~/g> ___`Q@wf)¢ 020 €w/)/)/m / /Op/aec?/S. En@/ also M@</€s ¢/7€ @¢w)£ )¢0 '@/0/€/‘ /-Z/// /’.Qz//ew by (/Z)a/)L of ___C£zzz/_z/Q/_/_/§p/z<:é§!/§__»Qe_/_\/<;¢/G_,_,QQO/ /O_\s_c/,Q,QQ£L§ZQO_ §§ 149 //<)_¢L) :

mms-paz //e£uw Vg / of ¢ \

,_q'-» l

Tr/cz/ 606/)¢ no -/Q/)_aé/'“ fws »¢c///a 0’/<:¢/<1/) <3_\/€ r_/_/a /_26_@§ 661/156 '

:U:H,

761_6// _C_QMALLSA/n Ae F@uj)¢

~`_- _LL/_ /$§,Q,o //cc) ¢/ozz__£<>f AUIQ€QSM_C_"QL,QQSM s F/ fe d <3/) H>@ 2461 day cf @6¢<>/©€/ 026/61 Cse+e T. 6 /~/d»beczs i§e;sfd§)

:__`IV

__-_72/_@_/_6<;><//“>¢ /ssu@_d QrQ/e/ 065/give lime lisa/65 @r) >¢/7€ 524/ day of /t/<>\/€mbe/ 520/d '_5_6: 75 6 /~/aceas_ 6660/0/8)

"_, JL

M<>/c ¢hcz_/_/)_ /&L_c/Q vs have was and ¢//0/ MC_QW>¢ 665 ne/)Z/v€/ em¢ew€c/ F 6 8 cf ¢Qamsfe(fed app/mahon >éo 600/vi cf 6r/mmc7/ ¢<preQ/S 03 mcm~ dg%€d by /_o¢.>_ under >¢»f)e csme //<H 6>1$@ Cé’ee 6 H/<ze_€czs Ae:c'c>r¢ls >

me vw_a/ /7//'_6 den/ed H,W//ca/)% Ac/< Ff<ac€$§

6/70’ >Q_¢/:)o/om€/v¢cz/ Fd/mess of M€ /4/<>_.6€@5 pma€€c///)ds 63 )@@//0@):

/) 777¢+/ 60_¢!;/¢ 1466 heard cmO/ G/UN¢@C/ éW/”V

6’//7<3/6 n/)M/Q/? )¢`/{e@/ by >6/7€ 6¢0¢6 F/As€6a/z¢d/j

Tm~s ¢<?r /,azzu/ew P9 2 <séz¢

25 W/@/ 6@¢//’¢ /:05 //07 _/E @/»GC mcf g~/’@n¢€c/ 6c/er) o/)é mmi/08 bc/ /QQDWQZMA md/{md,cz// &_a_)é/`<>ns' by /Q,@p//e@m/ 06 ,</<> effee¢`j (-"6‘€€ f 6, ,¢/00@,5;/?660¢/9) 77»/6/ 604/ml /)65 mfc/se 549 neu/ad 6/@/m __;__of`_'/Ya)éa_d;l*/z;zc;eenc€ m Q/@w/)O/ § <>F fm &,/0,0//66/ '¢/c>/) ; (_See> 77 G, f/aoeas ,€éc@m/)

K/) 77”/6/ 696.0£_&0,5_/’€>%/.:€ ¢<> "f)e@f or gram ¢ ____/gage a / /Q__Q)£QQ/ Zn/)<>c€/>c€ @/denc:e ¢o~w/)L: '___/_¢2@_//1¢;€_//@0:€ dodd/vwag decme.<;ee 7.@. m was ,€ec¢>/'c/ ' , 5) 7/"/@/ 660/)¢ /QGS /ef@_§_@ »4:> /35<16 <9£@€/2 750 have E<//o/ég)¢/@/}/ AéF///\?/Q of A€S/.g//?d)l€ 755¢/€5' 60_/_26_6_07//_29 ./7/5 /Q€)Zz/&/ _ZZW<) fence c/a//)?, ’(~53’€ 7; 6, MM§ Zg@:)rC/)` .ML M<Q;e__¢/_@A/;$,/;/Q¢J /7@¢/6__,0_@ 33 'Q¢zc/ wf;/&/ 6@¢:£7[‘___ /_m‘s’ l`a// 110 /6;616¢¢) <°)/ >é/U/?s' fe/`_ app/when m THO_L/d_o_/` 6///7)/)76 / N,Qp€@ /.5 65 6_7@)70@¢€0/ by /G/LJ, ' ‘ 77/3/ 600/8 /76 6 0’60/€0/ QZ/Qp//Qo/v% doe /7/66€35 . _@A>@_/_QQ;QQL¢_/?_Q_)sz?_€/Gm€a¢@/ fG/_LW€§S 07 <,Lh@ f/ab€€¢$ lx?/GceQU“/@ as w/d¢<§cz’ Q/y<)vé.

moyer /¢€6¢//@¢» /¢ 3 max

’/1,/0//@061 /_”6_66637¢ 606/1 671 @///77//76/ /Q,O_,D¢w 710 O,€AC':‘¢? [3‘71"’~6/371/767¢@7` 116/613 606/2710 /6,_¥63 710 ;%¢iq_o$/”e/ 71/76 /</66665' App//- 061/06,_6757166/76766713 666 71/66 666066/ Y~© 006/674 071 6/’//_7?//6_/_ 6,0_,66_6/3 666/ 71/76 606/171 6///6//76//1/0,0 66/3’_ 667£6 )Q,/// fec/1646 16 U@v@ *_6_y_/_713_6w/) T/////`$ 616/766 m 7166 //) 716/631 6 F 463)¢/66 _6/)0/ 716 6//6¢7,\ 6,6p//66_/771 Mé>¢/o/? 710 166 W__/?6666/_ 6/_6_6/_ fQ/?_C/Qm€/I¢a/ /6/¢/7633 0/` 71/)6 ,0/“6 ~ 666@/7/79_

766 __;1_6_,6 WH£_/§E£<>_,_€_& 666 6363746)€60 pr/7<6771 pm\/y ¢/76 406/74 2336/6 6£.0€£ 63 666/6 7/6<76637160/ A/l_z:‘.‘ ¥- 20 /> / my _Q_OJA)@ /‘/7 1)66 666 71/6»/7 ”mm

_I /€0>/ _ih06/6 // /ACJd/&?S<><¢§g§/ 66//76 p/636/)71/t/ 1/766/66/67166/ //7 ¢1)6 J6m63 (/ 7411/60’ 607/71 611 7116:!' 610/0 1066/16 C<>,_, 7€7¥63, 0/66/6/'6 660/66 ?6/)6/71>/ 75 166{66/;/ 71h6 /`0%’60//76 73 71666 6601 006/6671

£»<66 1166/low ‘z-~z<>a/s- _g_ay gaa@@// / /jj . , j 0666)12)‘24/# O,?A€Z» /€{'11///76/ 1)_66/'6’ >1~66 /1/{6)1/<)6 71/)6 566/671 673de Mo)L/A/] ' 710 766 5 » €/'607@@/ ' ,O£?/ll€d ;5"/_57/)66/ du f

p,€éS/o/NG 7666'6 v rmswe,a / veev_/¢w v 66 4 01 41 F"/6/ C06/'71 fur/71 A/c>. 959;,205~ n 1146/wa C06/)71y, 7610$') gg) 123'0?/

E?< 1061€ 5 l I/v /h¢¢ /6_6/’71 0/’ h 7 590-y }?6/70'0// § 0///)7//26`/ /Q,a _66_/0" liP"_fr_-` ‘ j - 79607/66/771 § 746371//7 . / 6165 ©OUW GWQM'M' WEA@»S _ - " JUL 27 2615 _M`_071/0/7_ F0'/ 6:,</711”7/ 6 70 m -Ab@m@@@§@;@”@%_ 660/71 60 /A/pdaw¢ 7

227 [Z/_é_ 1/066~7/61?/6 ]0666 C)F 66/0’ 606/671 /C/é/»é _ 676/1463 4/0166_7§_’6_;/ 356/706 //_ 64,0//606)1 m 71166 _67607/6 3_71y _/_60_1_ 060/ 66/1766._/_607_66636 710 man/6 1163 60qu 767_2336_6_ _C)EA_€/€ 01 7136)166_/71 571/d ~ ':?:6//7571 £1/’/6/ 606/71 )[0/ /07/`/3_6//671/0/7 6601 71/m6 710 /6 // 07~ 666/66)1/_0/) 710_ C'06_7;)1 01` 6/1/97//)_6/ 717,6,060/5’ 6601 //7 60660/’71 6_600) 63 7431/066

q~__ .z_ /Qppizaon¢'s 6,6,6//6611/0/7 // 07 1076 Wm1 071` _61019665 606/963 W63 2f1/601 by )1/>6 C/Qrk 01€/‘/0»”/”75 _@66£;6 /6)<6_3 /6 71/)6 /6</"1’ A/371//_6/_ 606/71 66 64 "'/"016\/ _0L@7_1066/ 62_0/`4/ C 366 666/666771 611/1666601)

;ZZ' 71/66 665 /7€/6 /_5'06/71 /66660/_ @/f’ 601/6 6163/6/76/./;66 _09¢)1[63__6/7 /{/6</ 66 60/4/- 65166 /7/71’/0’0;<//71 6717166/; 601)

fA/,[/V 0\/" AE/HC/£)¢ }79[0/ if n

M§§ ¢§§§ /§/ §§y_s §§5 0§55 §m§§ 25/2§ `_§§5_§@ §_F §,Op//<;_§¢/§/Z §§/f?_§ ¢//§c/ §§C/ §5§25€ ¢§§ #/§b§§S //”/_§_/ C_§§/'/5 fss§§§’ c?/€A€/€ Q‘@§/O§§ff/_?O /§s§§§ §§c/ 250/§/ §§§§5 §§§ §§/25§§,¢ /§s§§ d ’ "F/§c//§§§ §25 /;§§_25, _C’§§§/c§/§/?S §2@ Z§§) §§05 3§§§§7§7§§05§2,5/§§ §§/’ §§3 2¢/7§ 25/'/§/ §§2/»25 F§r» a,§/K/ 25§§ §_,§§//§§ 25/_<>0 25'§ 25/§ (§§/225 §2@ 6/2§7/§§/ _/_QW§§/S §§ §§§§§§_)§§d 267/2/ <25//7§ 5¢§25§25€ //.§z § 25, §§ (S_§§ /<?f)<?§f§<//)§ §25>@§§§_0/>

;./\/

25/§&§__§5 >“/~/§/ €_§§,/’25 §§ /§§§§f §§_5 4§2”:5 ~ _<'/1§2§;:§§ §§§2; 25§/5__ /§525§§ 25 §§§s§ §§§/ /§§27 §§ - »['§§/25§@'/

M//JEK€F©RE ML U§A/S/AE/§EA /Qp/v/}§§§v5 20/§;/3 2552/§ K/§§§§§§_Z€_C§§/@%’ C/“//_§_§§/ Q,§p€§ /S` §)/ // /sS§§§O/@E£ \F§/ §§25§/ §25 A§F§§/¢ §§§2§5’25 /@</."“ §/325§§25 C'§§/% 2/’/ 2557/5 §§§§e 25`§/ jaf/SQ//§%/M §§05 _j§/§§_Z;/ €§§§)_§£OL:?/§§//§§ 2_520§

0¢31`£ .' '7--?_05/>' Z)GS/O~€Q%//}/ 55/&7555[)(60( §§ z Z§lw€'§ // / jjj

Z.LII£\/ of Aéf‘é¢/L-r /¢2 op § _ @/?DE@ ' . _§b/szg /730/5/ ¢/7§ M<)¢/<w /_'C<'>/ [m¢r</ of Aé /@a/z¢_ sé§_e C@¢//‘)_/, hec§ §/_/_6£¢/€_&/7 Oi.’éé'/<°. /0/ >L/?€ M¢> ¢/<>n )¢0_ §§: .

___§6_/:@§)£€@,/ _ Ae/?/§Q/§

6/9/7§@/ ©/o:

F,eEJm>/n€ JQA_€E

E,u)¢£y 0{4£&70‘¢/;7 . pg 26_;.»/ Qf)F/§/§c//¢ 015 /F§é>§ /(/(/ /7§§)2€ /5 ??Gz/ /?§/7§§// 745§/¢/8_®`<%§47¢ ZOZZ?

Oz/§/‘ 2/ r/§§/>§ §JF §g§_ l:_§§¢_o/§'<;QQ/) 07§7/§@/,§ I§ §/27§ /7§/¢/7§/’ §_o§f0007, §o/ §§07§/‘ dam I §§X§/’ ¢§€ fo / » /`0¢<»//)§ t/<S/cmf§/’V §/7§7 §/ fi)/§’¢ §§/7§7 §}0§¢<) /§c/§€: :§§ C/§/§ c>)@ f/§//’/s €§¢,/m¢ 7§;<§$ 07/<)7 f/ /§ §§ f§§`<>/‘§' my §0,§§§§ §/cm f'O/ §)//?7' §>F /</§§<2§5' FOGDQS,

6/§/5 §/)§7 §¢)¢§ §§m§m¢$ §/; >¢/)§ §§/§d§y§§f§()c%§§§/\ §§ //z/ / §§ W/§ /_ §;:)_u_/;)§_/§:§a§d 6/0§/ des/ona f/_/?g*' 1654/§ 0/2 §1/ 770/00 §)F /</oc/§§z§§§/§Ozo/</. /007§1/ 7/§<2¢//0;. more %/7§/7 /&B_/ 070</0’ @/oc§ §>€/§///7 WY_OQ?§ §QF §pp§§§ f/c)/? by §§/w§ C’<>wo);é;/ €/§r)é ar §0;//'¢ O/d§f d§§/§/)§¢§mg) /§S§L§§ §/707 W)§ :::w‘f Z)§§ >@§//§07 m /§1//§@ m§;)é§ F C "R §c>/' ' blm/575 f§/ §0,0//§§ ¢/@/) >¢c> €<></.»% of €//mw§/ >Q§,w§§/s

é/§§a)¢>//v §§§/§/§ f/o/) §§L: gay §/?§§§O/G// / A€J *”/§SOM/Z, _§e/§§ w/§§§m¢/z/ mclar- 05/§¢§07 m ¢f)§ J§m§§ |/ §///§07 §§/f ;;JF /A§:/ €/A m §§Wz§/)§f§§€<)§_/)_ _, /§Qx§$ 07§ _§/0/§ w)o/§f /§§§/¢v § )C /§_/10§/1/ M§§ fy/§g_@{/)g 16 714/§ §n07 (7§§§_§

fai€ufédf “7-2€>» /S‘ z W /(c'z}/ 7570/70§// ~Ae§_/Qr§/)\/“ gym-y 6/ A§/§aw §§ _4/0§ ¢/

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.