Carver, Robert
Carver, Robert
Opinion
30 MS ORIGINAL i^o> o8>-\ 1-0025^-0^
Cov-xfiX QP C_gcx.rAx.M(\.\— K^^EK\-S AUSTXM -TE.KA.S
Rc^^eKT cftAv^k court of criminal appeals _ : — ___MAR_£&2015- _\£>l_ Abel Acosta, Clerk STACTE OP T~F,Kft%S
Oa kppg.o,\ -g-ro^-v 3CcXu>>b>ls-t-r\c.A- Court. ^^.rcVorv Cjg>v-urA>y >~T*<a->i.^.S Co^S<fc- K^q!^ F--2-<aVO-\-t\S-b , ^-Z-QVCa-nUo-^ , F-7.Q\Ca--2-"Z.H3-tb P£TTTI&\^ POft. DXSCfi£ HOKiA,fr>/ "RglSfXTELW
'Ro^.e^T C*om\z^ 5V^ s^ ' FILED IN COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS 2U1b Po>\g^rtcve_ .-T^cns ^BSc^ Abel Acosta, Clerk
OPAL Afrs&ut^^KlT R'E.G.UHST^b xbEisXxxxy <acr ^frgcvx^S »*ifc* cjaausev-
fcffiaXWsV ^ RjaWjcA: Cfeyv**.^ kp^flcyr&L Ghom>ss^. <^c"Tr\to\ £ **W*fy frc.To^s S\o^. teox- *^>.X^)^^-!^ \^<^S K^r-\k {3^ S*r. ^r^<N)'T*0*S»Ss *7yaxA T^Wafr^vs^ Gn^3f2S-nS^ E^% far^ s?^\~ 0^5,
<5rUOTQxj WvV •_ \3>%^ WV 3»3»^S .N\r^Ac^:,-T«om&a> -7S^^3>
KfipoXVgg ^. Sfe&g .^ ""R.*n>S ^JliAy.* RoWrV fcr\AlL^ TTWpyVW^
\^jn\^^> jTvm^ n^-z-^^ fc**y^y\ j'T^^S T^'ZSA ^Xo^re S, (s**^3*¥V--ZkfeC> Px-cl (<VA&:3HF1-3SJ^ \ /\B\JE OP C QKiTE MT^ <*
XbEKXrXTY OF VK^TX\=S KMk ODUMSELL. _ .. _ _ , _ _ \
-TAB\JE OF COKJTF_KTrS _ - _ ... . / . .
«»* XM^F* OF ^THOCarTTH^ _ , _ . _ ,...,.
^TrATTE/AHKrT fcE_Gr/\9vbX^Qr GfcAL M^GrUfAFlKTr . , " _ „\T
.SrA:\"EL r'tfElsrr OF THE! CASt _ ., . . .V
STKTENVFJsrr OF ?RJXHbuRA\_ HXSToM „ . . _ JMV . •
G-fcoavs^s \=op. s*s:\;xf:vj . _ . , , _ .
M^G-UJ*\F_kTr -
\. GourV c£- f^x>.o>\s> ^.CC2jA \<\ ca^vrw-Cvrva, Ac^eXlcxv-cVs QfaON/foj^arx or-Ve.\ov\Nj vTo\o.-V\oy\ o-V- fiC<a\g_ejov^g- oeA<aX-? uiWy\ A\>ja.o<_ «ooe>S *">&
5UfAMft&Y OFTHE KR&UrA^Kll- , ,, , 0 ,fr\ ?RPiV^.^ FOR. R^IX^LF - . . . ^ >' . JaZ }ii1 • A^pg-Ad>X „ „ . ". . . L. _«•_ «, * - : ~-~4& o ' ll .TK\b£X.QF AUTHQR3mE£
CgvSgJ^.
ApprevvcW v. M^j^ 7fe-r^^>y , 53Q as. H_U„Ut4^A __„ . ^JL_ fiu-rv_e_r na 5-WvW , 139L-SL±j$^-23±y2&2J^§L^^ ___.,_. ^S £v/cxr\<; v. 5-WW (oQU s.oo.2-4 8^<o;^3^Toc>Co^.ft,^.lc\'g^') - . , - . pS_ Frg.rsc_Vv y. S-WV< S^O <;.iQ,2-<JI ^q-7/CpQ^ (T**-Cr^. £99. V^?^ „ :«__piL_
<S tv\v\v\ y. SrVcODg^, 02-3> S.00). 3. AC^0jU^ -T7 C\e*.ft^>-~r<^okr\C&yvcx ZOQT)na^.. p. 5 \/\ \VQ.e c^_cx\ \a„ SJ^Vg- > ^^p S^^^j 33>1 CTepc.Crxw.^.Zeg^) . * ., „ * iLLJ^L.
•.jvlfilllil/ % p. ,'/- .: w
CcAe-S
C_o(^_ Cc\<v\t _ rro<L .. Psav,rv. ocA-w'-\2..0\-2_(V<*.roc.>rv S^p* 25^=5^ _^i p±3 C.<sA«_ (_.CAYV\_v Prco (\r\. \ i.ixlCI} - - - f.A_r^i^ c^ae Gr"\or\ . Pco^..(\rV . H2..0V3 ex 3
i-c^orvW CeAe_ S<*_c^W\ ~f\ >OOH d\ ^—_ v- „ ,. KJ...S T
rxxr\-\\\v C«sA'^ l8S.02t_,-£M* 4 - - P-i,^ # «k. ^ -^ »
S-WsuHa.
~Tk_-<. v«a_<c\c>A C_jade._ 3 \-2.^3- C^) m . «, -%» « - « p-3 ,
- •
• - •
TV •STftTFl^F-MT 13FGrafi£XMQr ORAL. <VRGrUf<V5LMT
~n>ta_ Pipp^lXcu-ft- Vr^Ug>Je£ -U>N^T QO\\ Qravav-tv^kV rryp?y cx\4 AVx»_ Ceteris dl^Os^ orsu\ prs>c»,ss. TKx^ c\pyaj\\ IrwoVv^A 4W"*-q, ^ffarg-vNT clc^s^S ^AW
b^^x^SL. 4V>e.re- QoaS> on otlWyA c*sS,<*oAx, ooK^W r^-W\vS \r^> ^g-^Tj M^c^r 4KvS QQQiS &.vm\ ^y\ gA£a£X en "^Q" c^iQrfe- \*-y cujasA^^cv . X.y\ <^SS<gr\ca_J ^Woe-
U^V\vq.V> ore, us^cxs -rV^g. cj^rsVrsAV**"^ ^>r<Sre.,e ."? Mso, frspp'a.VVxrT 5;vj^y.SrTS.
STftre>/\F_KiT OFTV^L O^Se
'« n'C^^ftV r-••'•'/-r- STATE./A'E.M'T Or" PfcOCJEbvxfcAY rVXSTCtfo/
U Oo-~3cx^v^°yy 25.* _20tS, OotrV <£" fVp^acAs k££vrwui4-%\v£ CBVwTc^T^^V ,
: Z 0>*\ V«Wusury S . Z&VS, 1Ti£>-Ucv\ -Wr RgW-OicZwcv t>sicxS £v<a. -
3 Orv mcxCcJK 4 xovS j r/vcm^rv A=«sc RaWa-'TM*^ \j*30kS cUjt\\«A*
_
W G-ROUK}T\S FOR &£VXF:Vv7
i s s u e kio:\ \- Co^M" c£- Appesxk errgr^ lf\ affirm W^ AppaAW^-H g-^«rvv/\'g^g^L g£~
•2.. b>t J> -4Va_CW<r¥ or |\pp«aa.\s TrNCE>rQg.cMy PVpp^N ex \gj=yx\ ^u£^<^nc^ ng.yv<a>iO cm^A ^rr ^<s CJE)^CL\vx^u\r\ti -VWA- ^>Q_ ^S/V A^aocJ^- v^aca& S.o«=rVo.^)<sV- \
,'=/<?•
\l\\ ARGUMENT
i5>^ue Kio,\
CDUOTV OF ftvP?^A\_£ H.RRFfc>TKA A^FFXR/AXK^G- KPPH.Y-X.PtMTS COMv/ICTlC^ OF fflj^k^Y vxo\_jorrr:osi of P'ficsx^crrrvgr ORfc>Fjp^ whf^J ~mg.R^. wi^ss Mo F3rKih»^r:vJ& op FAJAXU.V vxqi-EikAc-h; rc^ A^Y o f ^rvAg: 3VAtafc-)*\\=:tsyT:s ^
-SmnMARY QFTWE M3feOA0E.NT
t^r^ xtVE. cpupct o f ;\£>p^:fr.\-s x>sice'Rft,F.crruY M>PL.V a. u^GrKU s u f f i - CJar-EMC-Y R£VX£W Ad^Ss ^R,R, XKJ CoMCV-UrvT-^r-r TV^iKT TftE. FVXSS^kLCF: Js*J-K5„S^uFF-^C_T^c_\^Xl_l^
App^-^o-^M" c_e>v>-VeJAA s> 4Ktor AWx-gi io<a.rst. -Vuoc pc<sWgJcW<5_ ocAgj?; -VW. sojfwo \ovAXv\oUOl\- XVyfa. .se^orxA <ac<A€_<- ijOq*S Vv <g^fi&g3~ -Vw^
oc4.g-<- ^a <^r^g.cAr. ~TV>o^ oacAejp u^c\s.r\T S^r^^-A Are> AVQ_y\<xA^**N i\rA\\ riL»*->gL 2*0; "Z.QVQ.'TWl. sovmw5_; cAc»y AVvg, s<5.cjarvA or A^r v-»5<5-!rxV v<\Vo <^ffi»-cx. r\pp^\VcopcV ^o^qt^esArS AWr -VV>o_ TZ\^^r-gyg.v\cjy ^(>aW.or>N^_, OrAa-CR yjs^e.^^ xrv^/dA"^ - CcaAe, or CcV^rvcA TVocstAur^ ( (WtxcYp IT-Z'l?, C^J} cl'o^rVy sA<s\g-S, AW, orjug.<~ IS. A^s 05.\Wo.\W "vrx e:r$g_cX~ uiip -Vo S>\y;Vy-gyr>^ Aoayis ; V>oX- tr^A- \o<^ \V\&.\r\ ArVv>cT^ -^>dg_ A^.^rw\^ ocA^r-s VtSSivg.A A^> -rWi_ tgVpv>s_\\.cMrrV s,ooA AWV Wqj yj^rg,^ ^•^jf' -fi>r~ c\WCxy -o<\q cicsySj r/\o>\<vric» AA\a_ or^CS 1avoA"v A- ~TKa- "E.\nn.^.c-Q <a-yy^y ^Vg>Av.CJ^^_ Or<W*~ 4V\<jcV tjQooAA. o»pp\y VyA^^s>-Vv- •sWvsV clp^,^ Q3Cy% 4Vv^_ orvg_ \r\ ^rSa^A" prve>c A<a So-pA^^^Wr" \ , Z€>U •» Sea-A^vx 1 C\^> , A<sArs 2.^\\ , frZ.^ La.v cK. C3.2- Cs.g.. gv<f) p<-ev^ :TW g_W>,y\o^ ^ \o,w, w\o<Ag. \sy AAvvS Ac_V A^a S>*£.cA^ OT\ ES»0^2-Va PcxvfNvXy Ge>&0_ ) o-ppV^y orvVy -W ex prcrVe-cAWi- QcA^.-c- \s5i\<s.A oy\ or" o£\g.c SRLpW-^Noojr \ , 2-^V\ o£ AAnxs f^cA-/ f\ rpc^aWc^v^^ g»cov*r- ^ysSvA^A Wj^aost. AV^. gjRA- ^\)«g- c^<^W ofi-W^ fVcV ^s yN/^rifvaA Vsy -AW. \c^op V\ gjrWcAr csevAW, cAciW. AAnsl QrA^.>r- \$> \S£VJ^A °fl^ "W-s^. -Vsx-c^Q^T \^\jo X^S C-.^vnNt\v\va?b.A sry
&pp^\VcxvSA SvAc»Q<a.s\S AAxc>T Vv ocA^c ~W <sV^g£vr\ 0- C-g»rw\^Ar\Q<"V -rW- v\<aVgA\g3/\ or ^ px-^^cAvv^. QCcWx-; AA^si. S\c*W, otmasA- ^>PavJ^.AW •^yCvsVvTNCJa. or ^ \kA\A. or<A^.C ojtsA AAtnsl- rygj^fa^S^c^y ^Wvw^vxVs* To^avx V. SWvT2 ;-83K -SAO, 1.\ (e»SH, kV7 fTW. fVpp.-No.Wo^ sV\\Z. f ^g> p^rN A*pf*a.\WrsV CjsrvWv-sAiS AA-vcx-V- Vr WAV>, rjr^WlVvv^- orA^-rs uo^c<g. sjcvVv A «V \An£1_ S<XfVNa_ •V\w>a- , <X p^eS<a\T\ CJSVAvA A^lS^<r\\^g>AW V)^ CsaV^CA^ TJs^apcxrAy _ ^pp^.\\<xv>Ar p<aAte>^S AAvcCTT exesy v^^s^vrvcAoW- p^rs^ry v>^g>vAA Qg.\s<S.\>g_ AAr\<aA"-AArSL .SR£.g>r\a or^XLT U^QvAa W- c^c\£\As>c<gjA A^s^ Cjar^Tg>VV\T>A or-AaJr) 5^v\.C^. fr^p^\\o.vNT vmcxS. c\c_tjl\tVs.A e^r A\nsl_ cJrs&cog, 4A^oA~ r>x^r A^r>s> 4-\rS-V or<k<Lr \r\ 'm-e.CA. '
rX^VsjXpAr -tWnV AppoAVcxrAr IrxA-'ejpcT^^VNcAXy <=>^ Vvr\^vos^v\<Ay c^t.r^^rrVe4j 4-WW 4 <xv\A AtrV, \~l. y\?_ or 4W. ~T^o<v. OsAs, Cr*^ > rV^c_. "T^yc. QjqAr- o-r Cr\<w. ^roc, <WA-» H~2..C3Vl> ; sA<^A\jrWr\\y <ApV\^c^s ex -Vr"\oA e_ja\_\rV A-c> <S.rxVa.C ory orcVtr yc\WNf<L -X\r\g\o><^ cjr -\<»<v\»Vy v\^W(\qj^ \w AWi_ ^oA^iw*-vvC) Vc A.*ar\r\a -AW. ^vjTxW rWvS^. cR-VtxqX, -AW. CovArAr A<*A^r-rr\AvvvS AAva^-AW. c£AW\S<*-- V\n/<s\vJ^A -Vo«YvAy \I\sWmv.
OR A^yyeA \ay £^w\AxJ CsA*.- S^ArV^^ ~7l.QC^i\ l^xV\er V. SWaa.., YB^ •SJUK*^ Z^ , 3QZ- C?T^ac.CLr\tfy\ . <\Yf-. ZOQ»o') ) T^oC.CxA<g_ Qrl<vy, PraO Ayv(\. Q»rA.
4Z.OG rV«gjrf\e»\ Smgp. 2.oobY /^ppg\\cyysV c\oAfvx^> AAvxV V>R oac*.^ C-Wcsrc^A o^A. OSS^-SS^A Cx. ry*.v\o>AAy Vo^.ye>r\Ai -AXnS^ prg.scrW^'^.A sAox;v-rV<ary xr^o^>c,\>rAo>wv A^ay 4Vq_ v\^VgvT\or\ OT AW. prgST^-cirsV<g_ <s>C~<Wc f 3>VvC.5*_ W*. V~,<a>As rv^vJ^C \p^-g-vry Chsvn\/\cA^5-A car- cxwy 'pcx^r A-cxw\\\y N/"\.^\.^xs.cja_ o£>£<xoWs> dr" prgW^rrX\^- orAsa.<~ vVs\cccx*ar\S. VVas> ; AWr^g- x^oS rv^ ^V\Ar\vNcAfw^- -p\oA\wa Car AWvAy v\g>V<5.V\CL5g_ IaAW iw^ojr^ CL_oSg_.Cc-RA ••VVIiV Avpp^VWvsV o^sc^s OvCc^jTvA^eA e»£AW. oryVy )\syy-c*sj c>A^eJ^ (\ss>o\x\V / /App<dWAr oA-Ve-cyg,^ AVxoAr AW.r=it_ <o^cxS> rxo A^*y\x\S \A ^V^rxCjg- <A^nr\\Tv^\ c^rxyissWr^ 1\rv AW. xYW-^sArroA^s e^^c^^^y ~PrxA^gAfvvq. OrAgr ?Cs*.*-, SVtAs^s, ^*AmWvV 8^j qaA AWAt \nsl r«t\v<aA o<\ AW xAx<-v"*\<\ ^ AW ^coWAxn^. oc-Asbr 4t> WWa>*Q. AVx&A- Wg_ o>ae>vAa orAy V>3_ VWAeA-^t Ar^f ex cAcvS>S> K was— A<£xv\g£xV\gW rQ<~ Vv^Wrervm, acvy o^-AW cjqr\AvVt OC& . ~T\so cvCtrggiAW^- c*rAttT trx AWs Csx^cl sAcAsl.^ AWAr o^ NAcXoAtn^x ct^AAnvS pcAls^" Wj. Ciaw\yr\Vs^\^r\ Or cxy\ O.C-V Q^VnxVxWA V^y X\^ orAfl-f- WNc^y W po^sX^cAoW. Wy c^ Ar\rva- o^ o^ c<m\i\n cv.^ ^t^OQQ or V>y Ci&v&v\^YVNa*Nrr v^\ ^^A A^<~ QS, \<^f\<^ 'cxS orvg. yesx<r; e>F \s>o4Ay . TK\S> C^WcA^ 4W. pu^ry^V\.tY\'S-v\V \^cxr\<^g_-V<ar* ^ ,cdc»&3 At yy\ig>AgLrY\sfeCv<\o'r' g>r ox<xy <A<^crg&.'^-o-^ ^g-V^wy ."TV^.^v^cAGsAg ^\il-»'A3C^)> ~TV\&_ r^rc>xegA-\\r^_ oCcW-c- o<s<g^> or\~W> Soy, oxx o.CTAAnjAt oa_-
1£ AW ryo_V \^ pcoyaj^xjAr^A c>S, o, SQLOcx<~ccVs_-V^\«g>rNvj gjrWxS<l_., \V \s> \povvN\<A,\cAc>Vg_ 'Wy c ^vxirsrx^r^^vvr- \ry orVs.oY\ A^r cA: WcxsV Avjoq y'Sft.rs . ^p>pqAVoorxV SUCyQt^asVs AWAr AW^ pyxrxy S^<V><^V~ r°>YVWL ^o<~ cxAWcA, c^<g.ygsg_ W\*>YNy ^S ty^sV cvx^ryVx^rxgA \v\AWc prTsVsgArxv^L ocA^C VW. x>^o.<*r\xv\<^ wy^yxVv carxS AWl ^OS&xVA UTy <sA- Vyg.xrvx pr^Ss<gS-»jA/< oR, ^ SRjp^c^xW AW.Wrvy; 9x_xvxysArxcAo\a_ oA1 cxV \<WsVAv>afrx y^ssxcS ^OAy a. w\\r\"lw\yxxw loo^s xvya^AN\^v\g.A <ryQV, o^AVCvoa A.^5yr^s_ WWrsy pun.- \S>V\roayNA V~xxrS<^S./.~TVs'vS YVMV\\xv\xA\fv\ QQcxSs. AAv*- S»xy^L <wxv\\w\xA>nrx A^>r ex S«a.Qjs>~vA <AQjar^s^-W\<av\vj exs o-3*\V. ftAf^o, cy Ax-Q<a yoixe- SQ-v-\W-vx^aL_ cj^yAA "\ro^>\y;o. 5rWW ^^\ ^.Wy« AtppgAWyV cx.c-^o^ AWAc AA^_ Ul.-iocAs*va Or\AW- p>r^WcA-^>^- oeAsur ^S LXY\cig£\r cxR -W>AWc rxvcNvsVy-- VrvSLv^A- A<><~ nA^AcxVxvNCa AW CScA&T' - TWl, S"WW. ^r\cij^rC^jc.V\y gy\VxcxY\vij^A AV>sl. V\<a\oAr\<ory or-AW^ ryeAtaxApNt^- orAsbT Vb<x?xg.a o^N- oy pc^C'-W^Vy va^Wynsl.-1*-- cisyW^g^tsri, K^vjo«5.vgjr fAAvtA" CjscWVcArx^ary v^yx^s YygV Cx -¥xr\s>\ c^v^xT^A^aTv Q.W31 -Wtr_ locv^ rNoAWrvyAy r^\cA\<af\sWp, Pt^^WcxrsV AxA yv^r-\?\M^. UMWx -AW v\xA\<vx orxA Vx\cx5v V\cA~ ^rvJ sAxhgA \r\ Q>. A.o^rs*^ C^cA^<Sary£\yuft > f sWWs. ^x.WW>V §\^). ; "TW_ SWApg_ cwxasA- prov^ rypp^WcxYNT/ CxcA-xA<x\\y xjfoWWA AVvS- fiosWcA^v«- rr-Asu-j rv^Ar .Su-^W^rAr W sV\t>\jo orxVy AWxV r\pps^AWYST~ A^rxVVA**vS C_<s>rAoAtYaA ^rx AW. p>r<£>xj^ garvS O^- WAtx^Vi CfeAfe.^ j.. >^ / "Elyy^rx v-£ AWce ^ RN>^Cvay\^^, or A^r^'^W vV^AgjrxCL^, ^-AVsS, SWW^fn^J^ , "
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.