120-tS XMTk ORIGINAL TsXflS Court oh Ol\m\m\ RPPinU

Thomas StW-W?- Ra^- / TrvL STaPl oF Tsxas

Vit\T\oM Yolk D\SCKeTioN\AM \Wiiuu RECEIVED IN COURT OF CRhlNAL APPEALS JUL 3 0 2015 Aibf!-! Aon-sta, Glsrfc PPxO S<t_ Pd'AioN

FILED IN COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS JUL SOL,j Abel Acosta, uiem TpJdW. OF ConTT^\TS TK\dSNL of AuiW\V\ts 3 SlAklT^KVT R^AudtN\^\ orcnl A^ummr M- S^Wm^nt ©P tW cme n SkWrnivtr of PRocsduiinl lA\5>Wll Ll GkzouMcJs FoR Ryjttuu i,L>

\\\ ftdbfcA&g- RulfNfr ftuaiN^ Ttlifi\ qu oWsteWi eg maliam cA>Tdu^^ To md pR<LomW.d uPom A KMntau of i-te RK£\Um?tfrS (i^avxxidima of ^oiclmtL m rW cjns&. Ga^_ fl-\kmPT£cI vK> TW ^m\iu hjA?, cp>\kd uPgm to m&k<L Aai<Le\iVilc-W ctteW FA\KmV\oM W-ki3t£MN SkUm^ ®k\ lW_ GM£. W\d Atfdl fcfti.

of £.0£MT, > II 1.1 III •!•••.-- II— I— . I ••- I — -II— '•• •——•.., -HI • •— -I———— I— |, I •••. —,.-•— •••••• • I ~ l l l - l I Ml ——II. I. III. Ill •—...I. I lll.lll. • II I I

Uf\\ tW_ uuAfcftSVaKted CdutoS&l -\?> ui Fall flftiscm&rr uovvh TVvrvT Couxzr £ftft?d ua £xdt*Jli\&nW £.0\c\?iU(L£_ V^L SousVif To PUcduO<L SPot^W Paesodifce to^s ttisM To stfck cAwl fcm?> ^V^tW^J^M^AUOUV1 ftkVdi \?A\S>2 AM i^U?_uU^rnAV^vl dctom?ol To FfttUMUL.

XMdtel oF RjAiotuV^

Gmo\A u s>Wk_%l<i S>.lu. ad. ^TT £m.APP. Cowpu^ daaisk W\ Aoprf cWuo vj sM^SSo4<x>io.ac3i k3& C~TSt APP. S>A)4 HuWto WU Per Rtf'd} P&U WocAs u ^ttW_ ^11 ^.uj. -hA. 9ftIC T£i oa\m. APR tolo) ps n p£V tKPd J) pq 1

SVaVU9S

Ruk TFiA^ PsUk gF WP^llruvT PR&eJkiufck- Llos\k ?sU T^rn^, \Uile_ oF P\PP^\\k^t ^Tloe^du^ MI'Dl ps k TWp& Bute.oF fVPPsltaur PRoc^cluu^ -b\\^iA\ mi

% STfTOJfYYLur P^fiftdm^ oap>\ APautmivr

To ita Ccutrr t>gjC-ftu&€- tV\s_ \ssats Rnis^d ar^\ssuls oF F\dST \mPR%ss\oN\ Aud Tke Public Pol^H bslniud RLScbiukoKToF tVi^s<l \SSu<ls Could V>£_WAf£ft dte- Cussed tuTm Cotfrfctf oF or&I AP\^um^MT, ujKsii^Tne CoufcT CAkV Ask ^O^skoU. AK\d CoMS\dtR fll\£.RMlAt\J&£ ThrVT Couws&l ftfte PftsJPflU%d To discuss.

STrtfemsKfT of T~W CAS£. tW lftPP^IlnK\r uuAS C-Wa&d uoAV\ tW pFFmse oF Cu\ftitcAl OF iW-VicVim. TW APP^llmtr PkRd^d MoT Su\\Vl of TYV\S oflrSMSS-, AUd Follouot^ ft ^uRM uuAS C^Mir.T&d. tW WP^IIaMT sA^fTCd To ViAUL TVit ~SuRv| rTS£>^S& PuM^bm^tiT, ft kid Tn<L ~3>u£M RSTUttKKd A VJfcBdU^r of \mPO.^oMmsfJ[T Foa s>»l M^acs ARd A A Loco Fms.

(c5CflTSmgttT oF PPiOC£jd*4E-fl\ \A\sToW, Ih Dftk. oF buAtfuNdm Bwdtns vi Cf\\iFonwif\ Nwdr\ ?&> 3oi5 (J2) d>(\Vl. oF UtsPoMsfc. To CoumsaI AUduis ~3unl IX 701s 13} DgVl oF oP\kUom FU-om Cow; oF RPPtris "5vxl4 a, 2o)£~

* GrRouiuds FoR P\E.vA£Jju Ik RduS_RS>9_ RutliMft buR'iUg, TRm\ ou oks^ckoMS oR nQoWl - AS cheoue^d SuPria riuratNs Tbe sMarmw of Facts, The StA^ OW3;eeT<rd TO AK\d PReUA\kd upom a wumbgR of yk Rtt5unr\s.tfT Pe^AttdA^ oF ^.u\dmce u\Tb\^ C-ASe Pfte, AfemFUd beiK& A sepml \iAR- A e&immn\ rkPziud^T \e P£.Rmkkd To QFFftt Suck ^V)\d^\ee OK\N "TWRoUSh OPm\oM OR R£.PuM\OM TeeT\moMM Tb<tReFoi2e, kAe Could bAue OAlkd ART of hs Aea&\KT\ftML£_ oR FaieiAd To TeSF\FM dW SkiUK-V^R ujas \<k\qujm tv\ The Commuiyickl To be A \\AR oR-rbm ebe VlPd TVie , Pv^PaV^oKl of biiMR SorneoK\?_ujho FA\S£14 A&iu^e mBl She )AM©#M UolVn of S>P90\FiC 1MSlftMC£S oF CcMriu£T TO PRo<X- ^k\VMSft UbA^ AdKUS tivl CoKlFotzwtkl UJi-W\Tmml ortTUs>dPte- tW^UUM VuftS CAlWd UPON To A^ftW Ae&fcdvbihVl dfrtifc- Ammbom b^koj^Li ^kvNm^R oMTbeoMe bftkd A^d k^e mi TWiWft oki iV\e co^W \V \e (TPPAttmT FftomlW\R V)£Rd\CT -iW~\Wm W^S^eT^d $_WL_ AV\d TWldw'S ULR&iort oF £U?MT &} PfieXudRee To Ave APP^llAKtvk PiVmVAh To oW\M PekF lW_ QK\deaA\^v<;a Ppuueil \s \\\ Pul\ A^K^emmr uiUh ^uske kenes. ulA\u?_ vvV m\shV be Pos^vUe To CLWm nW tal Court ^RXKd \MV\ PtCdudlN^ ~tW Qu\rhk\CJL PAO SoUSht TO Produce blTtmA\iW Suck A ChAlWivBe <joou\d FaT AS> bpfcrm&S o\l M6T Pfcee>eRo?d. Fi\$m$ a hw\^\- RAieua°\ oNiUiThftT s^leAS&ue uoouU e>eueadn Ppe^udc^e PRe's WsW to ^^kokwYboms fttti^wa \MFFPecdiue iftsets^fTceoF^ouMe^l P^\WtW TAkeTY^u<eASU ooam out^ ftud ftiVvS>2. ak\ ISSaeukm^ doon&l T6 PA\\uae~t\neuMd%Q_e\si\i^d Coujus^i uoould \Lm\%t Pcsssfcr This CouaT ujilh Ws> P^as>qa\ d>eekiv& to uudkd^uj AUd fternfr Kfte Wrn^F A ChAkVoe To b^_ b^td A^d To PR^^mt AM cShtfi pRim^ or defuse uubicb Luiae Mot cm$>\A*sud h\ t\iL Miw-K^\5K\«?d (Louisa. " ' " ' ^ APl\ellAUT CreF\^iiAllH eummAPrz^s ~dV\e eo^dmce \krmodu^d AWr^I Ak\d ^vke OoaT^Kids d PAtk To pRoue K\s ^u\l\ W/©md A k^ASoi^Ue dcuibT m keu^^oriM^ Tw_ (euFF\o\£iAcM of flie &jid$wd£. Aivi APP^\U\e CLovxaT U\euus tW eotd?Moe t ^ tVie \i5VP IfboST FAvxWbVe To The vj^adtcT To dd;£emi/Jie u>WW pm Rf\bc*m\ t\i\^ of TRcr dpu\d hai Poukd Tine se^/vrml

l\\ Wk)£flee kuhu&s baem^ TRml oM oV^obc^ oa mokoMS. - IAS d^oae^Pd ^upra p\uu\k)^ -\W e^Akmsar oF FAae ~rVi£, S:R\e oVserded yo Pmd PReurvikd u(M, a uumWrz of tV% Aa^uim^T Ke^AadtM^ Tf.YAe RukoP emd^M^edosAb) that Ruk P(lou\vd^e tWt SPeoifco \uek\iwce of Ooi^duex r^fie Mot Pd\m\ee\Ue To Pbcos_tWt A p£&eoM na tM tofdfcftmibl vuM A SP&UFiO cbARAcASJl TttAvk \uTb\e OASe Rrit A\W\PT£d To oFf?U £AJ\dSM££. TbRT ^kmmR kRS the ChlPfcncAfca T\mrr cf hSAMa A S>eRml \lRR^ buT A^kmPkd To do S^ urn SPscAftc \MSm\oeR of ^ZoMducT. AcooRdiM?, "\o Tbe cn^e of Grror v SvRTe 9AT SuuQd Un C\2k APP.-OdrPu^ dh&isU fflf kiq pnT~A CR\miK\Rl cd<cP^blAMT ie PsnuUsd To^pffeR Such SoUfiMc£- omFi nbaouRb opmiou or kePu\AV\oM issnmoM Tbm>fc>Re Pv\e Could bpuecAlkd m\ ofb\s AoquAmWic^s aRffeMd To Testify TbAV ^kvK\K\^R uuAR kuouuM, Md Tbe OommuRtkl TO b£. A Par oR-rbpr <ebebpd TbeU^Pub&boN of mp SoimaMe... uA\a FAisdq ACOuSee m§-M She \S> KWW uu'iFh oF A£&AuVF bur u,as K\c5rNPmmk\^d, U!TkeP\A\N\ IRM^unee oFibeRulL To ckecju^-rbese SP^fic unices aF.CoNducr Tp Vfoue. \w\ a OAee ThRT PRe-dabd Tbe Ourrot Rulecf eurdsi^e din? ^AU AU-VoNWo Court of APP^ds be\d ]W Ad^dtatfT'S R\4d To CRo^V 2^LAm\K\AVvoK\ Cjrr publish Tbe P^sFed-io/as WpossdV^ buk doslbb ^Peo\Rc^l\M, wibw op&e The d£ft^(\ir So^U To oFFib evMmce of Abe VApbm's S^urt Pftprr\\s~ Ouikl To ^Pte>PT A deP^u^e oF <f MHmPhomAk^R1' To A dn\m of- SeiuR\ Ae9>Au\b vjuW\eTeiAS> Pvxle of eo\dntce ma bJou\d Mou) PU^9tfr tW ^\Uo\u^\okv oP ^ach eu\d?uoe, toe Ukd^R^\mtd CoufASil C^^de^d, WaWimftWW dou\d Mc5F R^ ^uPPouT foR, Tne ASS«lT\ok\ tW PAek PaKHiRm^V^ k\^bt To Ad^ft^e UoAS> AWo^RV^d toM bie Uc5T tas\U& Akoujid To PuT om ~the ^lo\ud^d SJJid&MCJL. \M pARkoulAe, PAe uj^S AltauEd TO