Gibson, Tracy Ray
Gibson, Tracy Ray
Opinion
\\`C)~U`\ Q\cv~>'\ Q\\QSON¢[L\?>LLWLP _ /V\M\§ §§ \Qg \)\\(\€{_ wg qw& O| z§§,§ E:d\f\ 55\1§ l Q>'eo»~)§uv\§w§'\ `\'_\k. 7"(705' /§§§§§ ;\\§‘2 §§ \§/ O\Q" LJ\_\`(‘~ (l@ x C?(BJ" U/ m §\§.\LO§ §§ AM\ §§) Bc\c§§§/aé§ \5 (\‘\ \\C‘L\b\>~§§¢§§\(, §§ `\’§s\/§ QL§QM§N\/{S o<§\€w< \<€> S\U\\\ G§§\\CG~D§SS w\~¥)§ §e~( §\o/§>€O»s Co(pw% __L a\N\ J§o§ a§b\€ §§ \NWQ O~QC<Q,SS §§ O\ P§\G§`Q>COH MM §§ Q§`o\S §§ Co?`&§ §§Qco~»~)\@,& §§ i\r\% ?$f\¢)§°§%§ 5§6§§/</\$ l Q\%§SQ_ mg §J\C §§ \I\M §‘\' b L)»§ Co~c~f§ _:__\o:»!»>§L-_:('di g Y\CKJ\ § q ) QE§EWED w JM\/<g sever oF cnmm l AUS 25 ZZE;PPEALS _\`§`o§c./»& C§'lJP§JSH\/\} A'@@U@@S?@,©K@w< j':. § §§€ Q§\w\w§§ bmwva erc _AM€#Z,S /[§u\s=f~\v\l, '\/€\(Aé __‘ ~'§_-c‘.\o\`.\ (‘G§X§ Jkso ‘. §;\L\q UQ~Q~£)G`T cu~c\§ J\¥'o `. wv'- U.Q\ °HO(;* O/ ` § d § '_Y?\§Q“\ Q/A\%,§§\\\ §§ \‘§Z>(Q§§Ui ` A<??\\Co~¢\§§\ f N\¢Lc\§ 6§<\§§ U\v\;~\' Q\e\>wt_\d\\ ' bomb wm §5\\§ 4 Ha§\mm§"¥§ 77705 CR va fall J§€?§§Cé#\$\§)
»\I~ S§A§€ 0§ TE\IAS \L\§<“ 60@§<;0< b§§vr@§ Qa§f§ ` N§¢@$\§<§~Qé ~\E€(\§:§Q:'LN\MM /\§o§§ cc\w\@€ O\S?‘P§lccy\§\§’\'_\p\~aw C¢\@§)§e)<\\ fl§§$(og$`q; wax é§\m~§§ \{\:S " R§\>\»§l@l " 40 m 00 §Wml§ 'O<§w< §§ §\§x\§ -O\Q§\`&C¢m§§ c,ml§ §§ §\§§>€.61.5 Ca(Pl/LS, `T\\Q Z\e§w\<§m§§ §\Q§z§ cl §\§§u §6\5 §§ AMS L>S.`>§ lea S.§\f§ »~¢~§ §\Na §~\~SQX §§ Q`§§m`\'(\c\)§ (§§Q~(§ 0~§ /§WQ¢}S.
Scd§ \\\Q§x:<\°: §§§3 N\ YQ,°§O~£§S §§ Q§.§§§>\\§\p {\,\QM_ QQ§NQ o@qr€§;m£ §§ Caw¢\§§\ %@§§n§@§§§ ov§§~< §§ c§§\r\~r O~QP\YCM§§ wc(§ §§§s §`\\Q;\ c)\<\ }§»\‘i\\§é§ \&+§lg~é)l$. 60 H/\P <C`\YS§' ‘ Q§§Q_ §\\Q §§§w§<§m§§ 3§`\<§1`\… §§ §f OOY)§JGY~€@/ Q\§\o\§§cs §v§ §§ GQP \§c§,§c»@\,\ §@¢ (N¢;l_ @_§ L\&],,QQ_S (\ \ 7 ,, j § § § § §
(‘r.)s?\»é: §<'\\Q§ pm .F\§o\m\~\§>‘l~< \OW\C;>@{"/\,[/ TM§ r§ m€ (~,~§ zQ/\)M`ow\ %'~G‘)Qq)m@w§ §L\ \0/1[5 §`\\Q<§; How&.u-M(/H\€ §~<`\<X Cc;\>»<§ S<£\ § Cv<\§ \\QZ§\QC,.§S §<s ac§§v&§§ §\/\€_ G(§- ' TS`\\\<»\ §(\`®'W wr`»§ \\w\)€wé Cad’v@-§ / :[ QI\QJ Fm A'V\€\“ \!\6»§ , </)LGG`T o `§\~\C CGW<§~OKP§>o§-<\§ CI O~>('LVI\Q"/) Qlév¢\€ C€\jé}` ‘ on\\ \\Q”A\Q.C§§ §C> WQX\§ ton cr< O§<»`v€§<; §§\Q (`Szc,»£ HW/ \<\Q. c§\\§ N§ Q»§\\'\SQ \r<\?- “\/§\w§ `\’§r\_€ GT§KM` `I\J\§\,,.`@l'¢v\@ml w°~’> '\~'\\$O»\ES \DQCM¢J& §§ oW\`¢~UrCo! CL\`C§QMM‘{ w€a@°<_)\n §§\;§§u -‘;\L<MUMQ\ mo '€’CX§:)(\§' @P?v\ row v\>\z C\o&v<\e& as a §U\§§'r\°; cs§ £&LS€.T}\Q-\~C ri N@ M§&Kco\ al mcon §§\<»§ Yma<§eg Q,\sac§\mce ag §o'~()\~e cm§bl\\((e,\ 0§< ‘\/\v& \"?v¥\s<>§& CG\¢“\§&Q!\C€“ }>€§wl€v\ fvvf%€-)~C N\r§ cm>x§» QS€V@N\§&& o\§§@vu\°~"\ 3 /\§c_ ()»10,\¢\€ Ca'§olm.ml(. L/AJ k€ \>LM\ @\QSme/§' o\§ -§’\u\& Q\{¢x \Dc\(`$m\\ \\\12¢»4’?!\3`) \\€ mead \\m€ §o§!\m\ "e\c\f& GRPGY§\MM§% §e» 1\0§§‘<,€ OLW§ C~Am§£ ¢M€ \€\\¢.¥ §\\Q crc`€§w§ w§bc§\mu\§ v\c_.;»c.(§ §<\ c;Q»/w ¢c§ owe any A>\,\»\ Qx\\\@x\¢@ m\Q,\x\§ §Qx€>&v@e\¢\ g §C§;\JA CM§ ¢\Q@\Q,@l d 45 u§§<m a“<§Qo§§*t os%o>?o<\ §§fgb<\?\.{' ms aw/ Of>]`l VLM/) mow\i§ `~\’\\\§€ W\§@<N\o§u\/\\ \7'\`0\¥ 1§,-€ `Hs\w§ j foa,U AM€ wyo Qd»§\\g\@é gee q \Q§»§Q)<. m\\w\d @§Cem@_ `f'k,€ ' v 0<`:°@1\0§ Y§£cx §>M?SCM\ j (Q,Cc'w\\w\ U\o' €J <\:m~\ M,§{CEL
`A<~\A©v<\&;&§\ OS<S¢<CQ;) SQ‘U-Egvbc@.\\i Y\vou ball/3 M I`~\/ w~&§ 0\ \`SAC§\QBVQC Cvzm;\c\w\ c\w,.<°>’< g e,~\r\\~mcw\` "i"{\r\ \/\\L Q\Q,PXX&Y‘~; \O\€Cor<:@ 02 +\¢\e_ G\~Z‘Z\M,' Q\Q<X \DG~<"§<>N\ Hc~»r\§€rl€‘\v M& lefqu Com”l/ sf\v\L€<z HL€ d S;d\c»\ \&\Jm<`;<\°; o\z `o; §AA\<Q`(?§¥CC, wv\zv vial/ch for \\ \'é)`/\/\ c§w¢& G§' j§r§<`;\.)él@\"l ,/' 14 (S A¥a¢o 001‘{ H\-€- 7€0~€* ;ELO\"S- ‘_/V\\\ ~\*v;o»\ wa\'§° - d\ESCCQP€Y\ci€S ComL/` v \\_\;\_&-_3¢<> QQ)§QIS\~. 61\ QO\O;'Q. "\ l,`\n<(s) /0~(§1 ,`Jv SLKL£S \;`%`_’) 3\>\&’>(. CM~\§?`D’LL\ COX __C) 1 mas kdcm Co(\\n`cl@€ on M‘N<wo»\“@ Q»o\b\b@"(' 1 Q.M\°){ csx \>MB\\Y»\€)!\=L 132qu oJl/\Jo[`\ a_<mec, U-W\'\ <PN\/€; ®<'E‘BM'D\&Q. &PMIMY\- AASO,GO P‘C‘ICv ‘K` \\\\<\Q§ '.1 ml§ <\/\m\~®\r\€é\ b‘1 `B\N&M C@KI(: S@LL€$ ~\5\\\»€ CXT¢(\R\®\ Q§l\c>»i?_"sc as ABJWUTJ/€J R<>M>‘>~K"(' /Ar[$@, ml< :\\c\\,§.g§ omz <‘<\v\l Q&M<\ cz\;\we,\r\,\S G§/ \H\e CMWL n§/ 3<\\@ m\ R»-Fc>'<\<)\»x\¢e wC/r\>( 65( =\/\~Q P'wu»§i?v\°> £0\/ v‘TC`@< ac§v~§b\§\\§ 29(’)) 3m bd\\¢¢>‘\ \M`{ 3"`)5€ O\;Ol `Y`"@W(\ 21\ @'QQ#<\ com“`¥ \>\)§C `\\¢§ !\R>*¥ N\c,,\ u~ob€ol J»L \\UQ :)(- wax N\»{ mal wm .z ‘\£`U“\ bd‘l\\ T€\\:<M\z\&€\l 0& ""Y)\\& Q,u'exx&$ ') b\\:\( 'CY\\( (`Ow(‘(’~ ¢\RQOQ<\\¢Q€\ O\§©<\\~U §§ H\P m\\‘i PQS§<,NO m\r\@ 0\\";<1<3 mfg “‘M\\ <v\i\{ §w=\\ QM§§ §M§¢ lm&\\<\€»$ Q¥` mLmJC~/[o£ §c»£§< ‘\<\x\c)§< G(\)\‘\ SWQQO{'&S O\SSVCWYW\'(<Q \`0\\'>}>2£"{? (3) z .- ¢--,/
\N\& oQ' N\ 'Y\\\Q R`»\CO<Z§~ \V\OL» §§
C_m\ 01 1001ch ` :'\\ 000010\§&>&\ » 1100 10<\\<»\ C,Oo~<1“3 0~(15%01 001\1\0000§10~ me>(\15 ova ~1\\ 10£1 1¢\ 90:\1/11‘¢1 0011`1\ `11\?1\/ Y`Q.CU\1 GVO1M' 3000 011\`\¢01<\131 0<11~ lex 1\0~\0€05 CO<P0Q T1\9 11501 CLM§§< \'5 a\éo \\¢\ 00(\1`_0\§'\00 913 10 001\1`01\ §1107 <1:1 15\9 <0<12<1§ 10 r\S?<><\A 10 3007 111\\%? 013 610111@/01)_'_______.)_7 `\\\L 10201 Cov~€)v §1`1 11 §<>\'13 6103 {\59519015 40 F€.,`S`W 6;<°>1>~< 0< 051\!~11 1101 0001~&601 ‘ 01€1 1001 1101 11»€ 0=<§°>`1\01 \<1§</1\1\@(\1 \3 \c\ 10 `TI\\Fo1d¢1” 101 am 11»\(\3 0110€111\0»15\)€,$1110¢114 ()~5€0~1>®\('\ ;;1¢1/\.%
YKWWR¢UA’AJMQ /AR‘?\KM\< v~CO\/qu% 1€¢»`\0‘< <0(\¢1 1911 61 1101 1113 \r\M\oco~\>\Jz Cm<¥ 100 :1\»~)1`?30\§010`=\0@1 60)\1101 11 10 U~ (`QKC\S£ &1/1-3~1 1510 §`9\)01\3 \<1~\311(\0\1&¥¥0~1 01 \1;0\£»1'3 MSO) 002@\\§0)4\1 QQQ\LQ 101 9040< 00\¢\¢1/ 1111 01 10 L9M 011 1\0\>~<1 110 110ng \<\?3 wp\aki\`\’lf\ 1>QCMSQ 01 411/\911\”19\/~ ex¢,`\\>\va wa¢;( Co`u~;zg 101 1102 \~\-1(\01 Cm.\()r C;€)ue)ro`1 \11¢®<`, \01&>( 00000 Av?\>\`cccu(\§< \0140 §&Q1L_`3 PG`M€IGN/ §`Q\`\‘l§< 10 00\09¢\`\111 1\¥5 1031 1\1~111¥¢0‘3<110`<& \\1=; 11:0\ C_ow(\' 111§1\\>099,<®¢ 951-601 01 N:CO:;AQ 10101/0
60 0_3333/3»4
' ©~Q€S’P€C§v;»\\\`( §v\\§w\l-\jr €’CO) QX\J UC ch»L€J/` 104 M 0\\ *V\z\t<z 9\\6&¢}\0~“\ os\( /A(\X%\>SG / 3~0!5'.
Tv<w; C¢\M ilng Za?il/_ JA/wba M@\/\ F/ L/§é&ll/ g S~,;<!~/s`
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.