Esthay, Kirt Allen
Esthay, Kirt Allen
Opinion
1 •- Jf PD-0463-15 \ \\)0. O £ ~\ M * OO 3>Vi - CM
fbr TV>%TV»rdi $\j?rwn& W»cva> Ws^rycT c£ W>s KirT AHer* IEsWoH, VS. RECESfCDSN COURT OF CRliMAL APPEALS Tk&SW^ ©f i^c.%, AUG 14 2015 ' •A^eWs*. Abe! Acosta, Clerk
SOPreme ^o^cno\ $uVc\<^ oV'l^aS*.
Come s :jyouJ, W»cT XWfcfx L^Ni^AVft^u^ Pro SC'io \W ab^e-enV.vWci u\-id ^u^Wad Cause, and $^ V^O/tt^v ^ A\feW*^ v« a s Va>loa^A.r _ : - .. _._ _ \\XXO3T4-0G2AS>-C.fr TN THE" TUXTO DlsTRTCT OF TuXAs
KiRT aliem EsJHaH, APRaWnT VS
THET STATE OF TEXAS, A?P^\ lee. ^PPsaI oV CAUSE K>0. QAS-^3-0)&Mcl' Frex^i tue JuDlcxAL cooler of cdwicWO ccoTorn nesrro^OTb SuYF];^eoTc^iS\no\ Vfto se Brie? O^ ^S?e*VJ5E \0 Aoderk BrieF Td THE W0UoRAb\e- JWsTiceLS cPTKe CoorT OFAffkAls: Comes r\ovo \<T9T AYleo tiTUA\ APklWJfro S£, • PnoTtOPiTo SdfW\cr\<sr\T©T Arv\e,r>ci OKe^rveA fcMtiorT as^?er TlU? *oW feB.VO, A?co Se,
^X noTCee. bH VWel Texo.3 D^fecTrnec\T dr cnmlnql 3usTCceL mcill room, aV A-W. FTgx^V^ vjJ. SVlWs OnW, ThoT ATTarnM V^oici Pi Wdoa Aodecs WSeP ac\ci A¥^\W\Ts r\o^4- Vo 9;W a ?ho s^ WVeP or fesfbase- to 4-K& A^Oe^s brie?.
OTU S^terr^beeS^o^/ 4-Vve aWe^WVeL Veco^ u0o5 PvTS-V r^aekL aVa\\ofc>\e Vo ci?Pe,lia-W*T^e CoorV rnaVvoc^ blecxdl^ne Fe^ococvM ali^o\5 rtrKUoiQ,
\_\rrvVeci aCCeSS \o \,o>ug VW^H \o Wxj<T5 a. uoee-Vk iP UucXH, he*6 opoe. Vhrooo^r\ urvYY V-aoK dooJr^ S^de^s. UbmrH c\o5^i for K<d\i ekiu>S- A??q.\\oy^V PiefV Kr\ouo\r\C^ ^jKol-V W cki\v\o^ boV \<^vn\r\£y 2ZZ- yfac VV\e. OackSor^ 5FaVe<ri above, ATFeWarrt or Qmed Pro se, W\e9 or Ves^oriSe \rv SoWoft €?
K^T A\\er\ £-.sA\xuH Texas 7^7^05 f\l o. o 3 -14 -003 \ B>-C9s llNi THu THIRD OX^TftXcT oF TeAo\s SijfVeone. ^u^lcXc\\ <D©orT ©PAWecA^ \<vrV AIWa C-sA-UoM-, A^eAW^V- V-S
TUe STATE OF TEXAS.
A9feA\ee.
AP?ea) d? Caos^ K)0- D*S-Y2>-o\8MS V=rom TWtalXcAAl coorT 0P Co^cWd CounYH MoT.o^ To £o?PUr^<2-v\X OVt^'^^ V^Se
ToTbe Uo^oCcAdW ^osVvC^S oS-TVn« CoofV^ JvWecxV" CorveeS r\ou^> VV>cT >M\ecN ts+KaM, .AffikWov-A- ?ro Se ; ^AoT^orv To Si??YvrP>e/r\\ ©<T A^enc^ Or^l^ ^.VvVlov\ c^s ?^r Trcx? <rVol^ Gfc.lO, * Vro Se. \\V;g,cxvnT \?eT<3C<£ Vbe Cxou^V rnciKe.5 \fs ctejFerp^vfAaAvoo iDor\clA><~
?«,* /Ar^ilanl rrex^vs -y-Vvcx-v- tne ooov-v €^revr\-\- VWvS VW©V\or\ T© SoWUrr\ersY ©r Amer^d Oci^\r\e\\ feYWVoo. o<c ^es?ooSe_ V© A^rvsW-^ fer\eSv
KlrTAUen CsVW^ ?eV\T"ior\ejr; ipo Se.
TexcxS De.?sxfTrY\e.>nT O^r CTirrvvrvoA ^os¥iCcTr\^¥iYoYW\cA piv\sWr\ • O^evcV^ uo, SYWe-S Ov\\¥ T^CLA-T.^/^'^dTS exY 2>o to Tt^n v3S\4
CePT\F\ccTe ©T Service T VxeCeb^ Ce^V\?H ^Vacx\ ov Vfoe. Co?H cP •FKe oboxre. ^^T \ov\ Y^oC SoPPUvY\er\Y or AffTeLadied YeV'xVion. or br\eS wio^s served on b^ ?\cic\nc^ exu)^ \vr\ We. OSiY^exW cf^dLAre-SS<a^ To \ Tor-s Green Goovy^M GojcVhcose^ CoorT sVcee,¥ Ar\0<£-*/ Y^ oOesY fcequre^ar^, 5qr\ Ar\gelo,Texci5 76*103 ; ov\ VW\S Vbe dkxM d?
X; FT AV\^n LsAkaM ReAcvVoc _£&£: . "Xx\3 order VKcxV Vhe nn<^rnV>eC S o9 Viae " C«djcT POe^W deTerrn\re, disayaWftcoAxorx OP refusal furSoarTTo \IoW74(gv) of VWTe-^oS PcuWs ©9 AfteHoAe ProCedoC£; A??eAVa>KX ceeV\9;&3 4UqV VYNe9o\Wolo.Cv \sex co^YV^Vgl Us-F «£ «x\\ ^QLrVxG-S \n\e.<323\e^ \n AY\e, ©crYc_.ofYN.Q_ emd-Vbeir
O AffeWcxYTf, KxfY A\Wn tsVinpH **/<?/<?o78, 3C(oOFrr\,3S\H \^e.cxo\-YNO>rT,lexo\S 777oS- "X>> Defense, onci Yn©\ oHomeM, Ge.rc_\ci 9v.
SWVYTT-, SVaW 6^Wo. iGSC^gob, -\-\^ Sdo\K XrvlPio^, Scrn J\ne^ta ,Te*QS 76^03.
S^iTToroeH o9 O-eocd orv Q^c^, KtlKK ttoju^nS, S^tAc'Sctf 1VB. \4>B4>6g^ tfo^©* 3(.4S scm An^sAe 4,) TKe. Won^rcjvbVe Ben Uk^diuoeacd, -Vr\o\ ^od^e,
A-VWoeM, qy\c^ tTV Y>cHqv> cAav^W* / As^stanV Ov'sTr1,^. ^-VYorneM , T^^ Green CoorA^ G©uftkouse/ C-OofT S^eeV #^^noa, 1}M ojx^'f- Be^^^^^ovod Jan JWo^W T^c^ 7&4g3> ^^ AffeUouM, KvFTAUovO CsVbcH, ujqs charged uoiFb Q^royQTed >QSSQurt uOvVV* a de<ad\H uOec?oo ©> ^nd deye&Wb^^oran oPP^nse Q\ie<3©c)t ^Wve cDCCuCCe^ on Aos^osY £4,^0*3, TF^e. \n^c\orNer>T(c.rBi) a\so ConVatneA an enhancement PaCac^a?ns,-VWveSoCe rcus\\Aa> AW foSS'ifeie.. ?on'\SV\meoT or aSTo.^S HeciCS or \;fe. Tk CcxSe uJ)OvS \c\& WYoCe. a ^ocH b^vnntOQj Ve)oroovcH Yl,^oA4. TW ^ocH rc\'urne,cia vefc^cA oY c^\\44 on fe\oruaxS iS^M, TW AWe^os^T PW^ true. Yo boVH eYxcxnce-m^^Ys and YbeA\1e\\anY vjoas Se-Meoee^ VoT^anYH FxveC^^ HeoCS \^ Vne VacvS Oe?af\tn^nT ©T CpJn-Nv^c^ YosYsCe TnsKWV\onc\\ OxwsotnY)^ We CoofT. The Coo\T al5o Yeox^d VWV Vhe oJe^?on. -W<i <=ye*v\enT (c^. \o\ A
^•SP I.S-S-_-£S VreSenTe^j WT Tbe. Skate- ^Ted io rcwe beHond a ^eaSoootoW doub*V fbaF ihe Said \jOeatWx xjsedt V*\ YW Commission oY Scxld dvPense uJQS ade^tHH The Si-a-Vc Uv\eci to PfoVe. lo^enV.
33 Tbe sVqV^9a^ed Vo Prove. aTnCeort bW been made, beMondi o reaSondofe douteb 4.) Tbe sVote FoaWd To Prove. Q.+ViCectV <jO\\V» inWot For \mon*nenV bocM 14 \niurH * 5.) Tbe sYafe QAiW -roYrcSv'e C\S\^S^cxoYV u)os Corn m vV Ved • G.) The evidence i^b le€^\\4 AnSuPFlc^x"^ To SoFPocV Vhe Convle^on- 7.) QeoA'cA ©9 6oe.?coces"S oncier \h& si*Vh and FoprWnfr* Amendmenb £0 TKe evidence \ s 9acWaV\"A xnSoY?;c^eoV To SjfPorT con^tT^on. <?.) R-oSfeCuVioO^ rvMScoodud. id) XnaFF^oYxVe oSSxsYbnCa oY coov>se\- \\0 InConslsTenV o'f^d conVrad\c-V^na
-?^S STMbM£\MT OF Tbe EvTD^og &K^ AuBOsTaH^ois vbe ^Q\a VoiunJfer Frr& DefetrTn^enT be\d q \pc\¥ shooV To Va\Se. Funds FoC Tbe^r de^rTmeYnT" FTrs Y)or5hV^ V^sYxFo/xng Fop YY>e SVcAe, rTcs SYacl DorobK uoqs V^e dUsPoAcben For pCre dePaFYrnebT-, She. b^Y\P\e<^ bhcd ob Sonne. ?£>voX <ioc\cv^ VYieL ckH Vbe, <siPfe.\lanV> ¥^FY A\\e£\ b^V\nc*H, had shouoedi o? ex^d be Tte^ed dr o)oDnoh APfe\hhT uJQ5 Sovid Yo\\exve. been Caosino, A-coobW, b©oVbebxr\^ \e£>TW ^ifTdSiVln^- POPS CbrobK cW\nnei aPPe^Wonb Vicxdi been bcy\no> Vo Tc\l<^VbbeaC3RR^7;\o~-\bJ mrs OonobK TesVvfved sheYvcxd bdd E\Y?e,\Wn\ Yo To leave f^ep alon^ c\nd To Wve. Vwe. evenT- STcJe asV,ed FTrs PocoYn< i9 Tbe Vepsov^ she hcxci TosT etescn^beb oj^s In CoocV -YbdiaH. PQrs CbcfcAiK hjOcxs unable Y-o TdervV»P4 <s\?PeAW\V* onh\\ S-Va\eb Ve£xd Wr AJHere fefiR 2&^ \5-OS:) (qhoI .3K^^T^-\M0 rYrs^orcA^s W^ \oa\ned Wr Pbone To Some one. so AWxV ¥ne>\ oooVA CsA\ Vhe \cxoO por V\e<T« Sbe oWvrned \A- uOas dose.\o oWcY< vjjWo YbxS AooV> ?lace. 8-00©r^\00.'TbeH ooere b&aVxng ev^r^Yhvne^ olouan- THrs CbrbhK AesYvTVed Yhab 4-WiS ci\\ haPPened cbse Vq cU^VC \doV she ebdi r\cA Y>no^J udnc\Y Vna^> heXPeneA ujben e\PPe\bxnT LpashV VYvsc-e e\n^ logger- C3RR 3S',7-\S"0 The. SYovYe Cabs T<~\r CervanUs vbeb^eh The Said V' C^r'trn. PTr C^rvQnbs ^ociSend?\oM<i<d b^ en Concrete ComTarH and bad woocbeci CXA c?
Touljo oiU uoeeb, He \wed \not~exnY boose. ou.)nedi bH £rne sV Yocce s, udvYb b\s Y>ro-Yber -\c\~\avo GaQdalufe booatir, alon^w'^Fbs u^nFe and Si A K»ds ao>es M~Va^eobs , (B\WV 3B,? Yo-Wd fbf Cecvanfe cbimed on YW evening cF ftu^o^T 3TS,ao\3, u^os uohen he bo^d Firs-V- rneeA K^c\\ar>F\jdbo uoa\ SYandbn^ ouYside alonoj. covVh buX uJvFe a^d browner in-U^^^MO^XSTH'd AFPeHunY bod ashed obcoY uoorK c\<yd uJtU mFor^xed jY oocxid beoFVec Yatoor AxA boY Vhe^ ^aH be. WT^3*(3R\T4o; a\ *d (dl^HUKX:) The nexTdaM fto^osV^M^o^ aPPelWtf Come bocK and bad asKed' Sov^ve Due^Fons ohoJs ujod<^^M4 V1H\^ APP^UabT bad D^v^e bac^^^ ashirvQj ahooV ujopU Qop;o, buY sYocbed geYY\nq ?o^fe^HSBTl-W^ HV CecvanYes YhoYh© bo^ ^oVYen mad and e£ber coords be bd\ AWeNhrT hs> ujaSnY o^o Yo beb o^eVF^ o\ ^ob and ^o"A »<^ave£d^^Mc^ b%^ PV Orvan4es TedTbed +hcxV APPeHanT bad ujaXbed ©Y'F bub u>a5 reovUu^ ad Vbe bacK d? W*5 Yroeh &nd AnVUanT and R;dsf and b'e 6ivdn\ Kt^ouO rV)boV ApF^W^bT rnosV bavebaerd b i«^ Qr\ YbQ_ Vbon<S- <jyh iW be. hod Fa\ Hec5 Yob»S uovY^ frovA \oV»<A«u hU YrocYbfeR^Hu;7A3b (3«tiHi; hat) Cam; hv, fh90 ^ ~ "~ ~~ ""^n^
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.