Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Allen, William Andrew

Allen, William Andrew
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided March 2, 2015

Allen, William Andrew

Opinion

/`l q |M "68)3€’)1}0¢\'" , L/'Z'U%,L,|L[/LE/ L/(a . - . u'l,c/ <€<@¢A€ mw 02’»0<:»-/2¢12¢ 6 “~ ,IA) TH.§ '7’£)¢»¢§ awth 5 §§ 0?"0¢;'~1¢9’34> 3 § \J$ §§ CR.;rm\ha-( 9‘),06!9’3 j y M §§ w @YM"'Q' 1 AK»aQ-I<QaéC-,. @41>'1[».~4 7'§)¢/15 RE§E|WED|N §§ coURT oF cR\M\NAL APPEALS ag»<><z»)a<mn> - o~Y--<r¢~:qu'(o'b, 4 `° - _ ` MAR 022[]'\5 § wm ¢zMALLA am nw @Q@S#A ` ._../ a ¢ l ¢ta,C!e\rK - NED Q@')'Yl?/S wl H)e'v\\ A')LJE,£M) Q(“~Q/'\ jfbe%g;d `/YS ‘é,.,. n /__p\z O,<w\¢:l _z$<§) QQT/mr\'¢\ l A@p:.'@'$ @@é.£a &%BQWML |? SOI<{~ if % 2027 - » d 08"/0"1-‘\2.4‘@6)%6. 75 7)?£ /{;Zm/D,'$‘/<i<}f QZZLO')L<; C/\j::k(,é;/j,%g;j£ ¢)Snww¢” wl <Qmm<d)g¢§> 13 /lh§®?§l_/z»'d QJAM¢¢} ,¢h\¢)\ ne I5§7'l'/".B;.Sv[afcf @,GM`L'/", /)59§ /[;\'\'5 /.DA+& Fél)qgm.b._,j \Q, Q.q;§/ ~771',5 H¢)S N¢‘{ B£s.'\l `Dczn&, D/{ £')[ 7 201¢ ,F ££C£)Oc<,° A @A.QJ¢%>/l `/D°l 66°*:"“9,/13“*'+ ()jcica }/A &C`é{ds¢a //’})'Z AW/,‘</-) )/¢i»r~. £,,Q //,07 went 6<? F/@l)éaa O,ee,@m, //e_m/ Q@u,¢+ /~/d. @F»c)¢;'/a<;%g W@¢,I¢ gf»-O<f»/Z 9§¢69 we-'?§’»§§c,~i¢??z@//Xg we '7<) ‘352¢¥9¢, /J# ///.,¢w, /z/ga;/<. - £5@$6;71'£@0 A A/):>ws£ lam Wz /5?5’.2’j @;’5/2/'¢/ d@¢/A%@ j:/»/ Vf&/A//é~\ §§ //`<€X`NS QQ<QE'*D<§"Q/Lm§/m/l %deé¢pu 2 /'.0’2 SZC}¢Zm 3@8). 77?5 Q/é.eé 3<§\/6€"@’@/.`5/2/&/ 00¢¢,¢‘/ Lda/颒 own/1775 /)IS¢ 591 U)bl&{',é§- 5? //.z)? .§,ngé, ,M_C/ 5“./,;,,\ g,Q,%,; LU`I€"{ F//i:s //5;1;/: égz»/ <Q>Qu/moi;</ 73 N)z /€§Q'Dfs/z/Gj Q@L¢ du /.l%'c_ Qmu¢elm_\ Qj$%,eh, 3d ,<;'/s<) '%z @<mf,cf"~ \ Oau»/J“ /;LAS /)/0{' 564/y ac 692.<‘_"'1 §<Q m "Frn,v( F,z~sqz<s @§§&, A\_<.<:;Fm~\)ie\@l\a»\ §§ 1107 §£@J.m é», W<w, w% nwa/a m 'l-/£A'K}"‘~\ c>'Y\ 7)'\€31 ‘Fs§q`z'§- §§ Wz g{¢¢c/Y, 50577"5 Oe'm)¢&.{ ' QOHL" HA’$' /\[¢"/"51=54/ /7'*)2 /L<)»z’i'/S //.Q”l Jn.d$;z Jmné$ l/£s$k»mp Als< 714 l)\`a,e~(,éw §§ 11.6`7 SzQ~/'Zm 7» HQO\)QMLH' v§»/¢\:’> /\./<zTQé'_ viii A)\i§wé.a.\ m 8?>09~129%¢§ ~»~ 2€~09-/2.9%5 md msd a wm §§ ¢-{/ams O:W¢.s //.<)7. @M€//a<?-z¢@a » 9§~®@~/2§%.¢ ¢m qqu wé.{ d - //@éw§ 621sz 1167 g>»@z)!z<;?e?> °`O$'<Sq~/Z?Z(;D¢ /Mz_ C),@#¢¢f o<)@' cilm,,§.¢/ /QWWé`A,[;_ /.-/:-5 /.Lnf/¢"=g ApplTaA{/é- ilq?é>l§ H§ //¢m O@vny/A;ncs.. 4/,~,5 w,a'if WA<»'F'"" 0£7»10?,¢`}0')€£_ [,LJL¢/n ’)J wfl$ ms?/ 73 /Mé /§S`T’\/D':S‘(£/'Cl' GQML‘L CI€L& amend §§ QP\m)hA-( AW¢A(F \~/As nle €éQéivz@Q A /\S#lwé£@@"’\ ¢z- /s's-F“’D;S/,I/<_/ OML/ 677 W/-,»M/im vao¢~/z'm¢ ~0%¢42%5 ¢¢ HW)Y<A,;YW @?»@Q//@%a-~@g"~@q»/zq@éa, ,4§ §§ @@7'.;` /-/)90? //6/ gun /,€z§@'n%z¢/ 70 %{ /5/57% D}¢S/a/'c @ng,]"; `F?/»§z / gg'@<;`zz€;?¢/@ -0€»©@~12€%6 ..@@“:~e<>¢»/z<i?c»€ ~' 0€-0€1`~/29<%<:. _ ©3`»09~12<??<¢®' ~ z>€»o<?~/z€"?@®\ .

70'.2'1’( p\;ww»\ O€»OQ~/z<;?e')> -_@?’»0€’»/2$¥?<.,®; M¢)~s ,1/¢)'/ gum /qS/m)é,< ed 67 -£/'Wé»c U/§/£/é/ jj%zméc/ “6£_' %6' ` /§5~.;4\4 ”D'{$j(`r.»£>f G@M'/- 775 we?f cup ,L/A/L€/»)$ QQL§NS //167 _'P;s‘é-é</€ gmc /\/£¢d <§J/G/m¢¢_, Yf)/)`\`l§oo M(Déeémbé/a_ £9~ Z\dl¢, Wfi$ /‘Z:z £U'icpmcg gang //@‘f¢ _£éCé/Zé.@a 67 dz§aJ.Q-A‘l~ L</“J»,’l é?><iloéf//z /7 9014 311 /fhé. Té><i‘\'>`/Dsg>'¢\d md»/t+ ZJ<()QEim/A-l \;1»¢$4’{'<,.<_1», w‘,¢é.b 91 955 z -w,//,,~m /<)»Jew ml¢»/\ )€ea"wz.@? ,1/,,%;¢€ ~//'Z,y/“' ’fl:=. dowd af é.¢;m,;.q/ ///rs a?é¢:fg,g£__¢~! 1qu ll'df? 10an 05 ;-/Al)e,/)§ - CQLFMS`M -/.Lh @gg.$;e»n#d? /)7\2/», 73 viii deu./v/~Q `771rs 73 ;z,, ihb/4er §§ `\/é£rlo'/\ Q»m "'/"£;v'f?$ @e¢p:,¢-~p @£;m);>e/"l 'QJGFCI»¢AL ,4,¢4,-¢/¢, ,~/.67 3_{,_ 3,,<',”,9710/ gdc :7.,.” 47)»»,% wm?‘ 2€'0¢~/2§7@ “W,e_¢¢,g¢. 721§'»0€»‘~/2<;€¢® )/»S //¢/ &m, name 67 cS/'%€'¢ _7'71€ "D'#j§?lvz»"€~’ p-/'»)l@wnz¢j¢ @1€ ,' `//71?' dewv)c~}'?r~<,). @.GLL_L*/ w)"’C`/B\TS 7712|§§@)`$*1/£1_'¢>1 02ch of wa~),é/L §§va ' ' . »5>‘/` <-‘N£é '/M `. 1//1 51@2¢1. 191 1146 117/30 1 Q@u/:zo<( O,Q'»mjm,l j:pp.;»}s would A&`l' éxa£c€)"s'.§ '/'/S &vs{¢/¢r'm// '.' 4/ \{“/?':5<"/-/`¢!;°‘77 MO/Q=..€ ;6/47¢7 O/;§é jury /¢;S ;)£ las iam W’H¢ 423 F“’/"/’é'” 33 677& 733/mug />éz ima/en /J/ zg,w[/Bn GCC<Q°°/+/ h/}e/ LéW/£i;$a"" ' % Jua/§z of @am)s`o{rhj @e)u&"|£;, /D¢<Qme§),w¢` fespé@i\gzu\‘ ali a@u,,y-,Lg §p,, ,4 ja O-'-Im@y\,'l" AH’“/C>M 11-/\\&6(1 \ ép/VK;`:Y\EM/l OGH,L"|’_ 6"§7 QB`)m'\"'Ale,'£GQ/éJ-%LEJ {/\1)_12¢4¢ /“.O$‘e ,TL 7}6 ,j»v¢¢!£e‘;;/" of \S¢¢é//"c.z:. \,(a$)[`}cz, v/')7€1¢\/)\;'"-47 :Pn momsz w»,~h` wm }\11“»5 @§’/'?§,>11)6_@ 'D§»,Mm 11<6 ejwv@g 1¢§1.¢.(,_1 ~,111 »n@;.y»,,§ amca 1111 O/£*:m.m/l _ /1>|~ kessi / § Q/€.¢lf §§ ZOQ»//e/L.; dawn/41 73@11{;{ \DH"¢\ /lé`&<l)»é coe BOB‘M»`/ml {§Pp£@lr md <Q)<mm¢¢j ,1;¢’):71¢ //.O; O?oc~/zmm> 'r)ma 32 <>?'o€;»/a¢i§¢.’® 73 :/7=; ';J..<;J»,z,~z:/ /Q M;L my ’/~ GGWJ'CJ’"~</' @@¢L/L+-:J:n |A'¢'/)Cg L¢)`}`H\ ’!i}\i:, é-MJY\ .. fl Té¥/}'< § @g> Qéim~mr PQS@¢¢QWLE,, )/.@'7 311.._3@ md 336 ' @Q@MUY v _' wew, @M@@~ 6/19.‘3‘119 a )/Q€ r€ L*”””‘J?j <»>1%<2@ ©€wzx W‘Q“‘§’*~‘ /11-» <Wv Ge»m+ fm @/ am +m /z,mg C.@&£ cf Gmé{,: m.,;,,| gee£cpwi /OS,/ ,'<`s ¢~/L 54 @ m )IQ€ i»€_ lrvvvaqz;[ CE¢€'L‘(>CAH cf §§/€u)<,a ';'F w //Sr»~ jac/eaa /9//‘4) `Sl/"% '° 77¢"¢5 @6/“47 6/ "Mz aed€;¢ HWO/-h»'l*wl.¢.,\f qz> |5_§0\ 'T S&_R_\"Q} ('_),Ou,£,`l 936 pc{$J:l/n S," QMML op )~1(€"\/;57§44! //Z)<es "77‘/2‘{ M¢/ 4 "?) Mz. @0307//)4 '/ AZ}p€e/y f""$/QBOY &U,," H/ &@¢Ia//`/m »@'46//(/)’) r/,;)'£’/b"7g7// 61173¢5 /H`¢ ,7<¢”’/£)4»] aféé»zu/MV Jo/§/ /`L>£ \Qeel¢>,#lo-‘ j L()¢///`qm %JAM</ %`//~f\ £L¢S/L/;»Q /44~/ Wz Zj”/m/V/¢Qr:~‘ F$ M“‘? /?"4/ C’J/UL€¢/'L % 447 ,K£A';ZA"> Md¢¢ FM/»/§ rf WJ w zx<@HAQ/N¢ Wz J</”@)y dfé/¢m»y 010/§ Cgusa /J@.. @9~<§<?~/1¢74 - oen<z»¢aq?¢ .

7"/(6 STAFT¢: 69 TZ)<A:S_, v jZ,. vwe,, j /s@'& /.D/'$éz.;~,l' . _\/$~ . * Gz:)o_uz}"e<@ ' w`¢\lp¢}v(\ M/Léu) Q,,~@»v\ l w%\]éf'~. Q$hwv»"‘£,_ MKS. _ voluman ' wine \S’ 1st 9/ O'C 5 f L““"V"’j Q’?:/ f @@£€,? Q PRQ‘MTMMT §§ Cow§z€l., v C_ON\ é’§ A/d¢() ’.I}\T§ A~ ga ®`NS/Co€€€v”hrm, `7//15, O|é<;n<§ 5 ` €/ - l “E¢L /\@Pc§`:§:+ '\'r\¢wn"v ;t§`@.@'(]u;$el °T}L:l;}j$i'<.; " ' 'V\\‘m 1",T’/,¢\ R?<§;:i\);'#(¢#/ &nc&‘ n fan 116 ve"$ , QAMSE.. u£gugn» 737£9()95 %z¢%£k;b§) O?~"rr£\{»%:\é/vl ;Q£eCécoJL£ ”/L}¢‘c'& \,O§(. 77\<?@0¢4£+ )-[&$ QSUE“ZCQ @éoénamk @é¢)md.;m y sMW>/L+ @_g> e;%qz qz> eép ,Qéo¢@nm,.zv\ b1 C,<bu/'QS€~\ J:n_/I'Ws fT\A/'H'éiz mel '/* 75 haze/qu . ®R/L]¢'K<<:D: /])‘~{' A/y\ ,(Hq[¢p_,\ §A'g'[/ /3&. AW§mv/?<I 776 5°»/\+ ` c§z`gden{/ 6).,¢/16“,9.,\+ ~_17> T;:,‘>c QQ<Qa.¢-s~§ @»€"'m`h~( pe@ce web _

A@J"C/£ lloS’/- F)CQoAcV/sq / ,7711 §//Mw( A%/m.» B/ézl /)lg am¢z¢j md %z!£uc)%§#%% Ue>zMZ/Y/%< C%¢;; )éj/yg¢/,(§ »7),7\, /~/;/)M'P%M.t ' /l/Amz, ADP£¢§S\

I~/' 7§ AL’/Zé4, @£Z)é,€}.¢/ 7}`¢,,//' 4» delay 6/”,; page §/‘;/]// bd S¢/\" 75 W\z dallade laz/ %1» C'/e,e£ @f/O'-’? &M,)L“

\5\'\>@€ ?zas¢ AVWX¢ R£&mz§‘r gina ama MPOMT@ @OMgé/, @HZ_Sub)/\i” ’1?> Qe¥"€lé 1'08`1 . 7`£>€4’<$ G,D®£ 66 C£HHINA( We@c'¢<_du€ -, Q_Qusé. /Jo.> of'oq-/z¢%-GFM-/z¢§~z, STATE 05 ‘Tz_>ms. nw 'f/¢é /62"1` \/ ` ' ` - COM&+ o? ,wA-\.'ee. ~-roc:vff' outerqu 7 'DA'L § &c'ozfz\ (o"/§’§D ,,s¢<>z:: 7>€ /Ww_gz;/ 'rHé //GMGKQBLE duber: cy 5,9',~41 C@u,j'y Qow\f.s /\/oa) , 7711¢ oYz.Q¢-&H+ w,ll¢`/>m'\ 4»»@0/1;,-,¢) QH_§_N Y'DCT‘¢ 6/&3`“1\‘€€/ / ;,\1,¢/ ;€é?uzs/"§ "77)4/' 7712 dea/pf ,<rW/d;,,/ ' azamse) 73 H$§'i`$‘f him 1b f?§<s/w" pmdl‘?‘<b (LQA‘)€S;,$:%/ 77»£, Abouz,“$+y/zd CAQ$£. 53¢,,/25¢,/,\»,'% ;B:) 733'#5 C@c?é 550,@;,,,' .TNA/, p@a¢fd/W¢£ 144 76 3 /.O`S/c S/»..-)/z<< /€5~=@//¢¢<)5§` 14/\/ J?¢v¢/i‘§z/n‘/' OYz¢C»»AM+'\S éA/{,‘//.¢J 73 )m\)a A»y\ A¢H@~¢'Nz,</ H¢>pc'?\h<o "12> €é(?flésw\+ \r\\'m 334 )Q¢\~j A-<§uz,£sAR~/' \Suo\‘¢c.'al @HQ)Q<<.FJ.' Th»/%- m»] »@65\>1|)' I’r\ Gunfzkmwf mr Q¢m§ms~ ynQ/,J',M:;@Dz§;»¢§qu (D£QlA¢zA~\S¢w\j/’n 84 poa‘\“ 500 ,Q¢X€\f Tz> ey,za=.$em£¢{'wv\ cs§` Q@wn$a' 15 _/.)HACL\;_, md %MR€M#{_£Q\ ' am 'P> A$ <:<><u.L-..f 10 . ‘ Qé' éc*;}Q.\| §ubm;`{')r¢@o how w <w~ ~T‘r)cw\+ ll5;2(<>2<:1 lqa, wQ»'J"* £’//IS amf m lzzq“\ v:/n Q€D H-¢w\%w‘£'lz Ti\m€ ~17%¢!?> §><ad§¢:/zcy 711/§ %z, 94 ®411 of 664-why golf :.PQTE_ éb,eq/m./ ;W lo/{’ .-‘§~$IY`D_¢L"&¢'<>" QLuL`lL. £E wol`\i §§ MAbE,QS §hl!_/‘M§. l 101 2 , °`Cm$¢») .,09~0¢-»2€7¢¢, 1241'1, ;q ¢, . ' » %6€*'24% z / 7 /2<;19,,124@,/&%/,/;4§&,/z¢/SB,/z$~;</,/z§g( 'D€Aiz Cl€RK ` £Mc.\os£c& @{e¢sz_ §zw\ol mova mo~%\`av\ L~,/< C¢»wl'l_ A@p<)'m+?o\ st/nsé\q O,<clé)<, Gnai "Déc".(/-\<G?ll'¢“r\ 7a §Mpp¢»€+ .

§§ K¢'S/Ll' '}`£> @EG’£é-SP/\"|~:\`(fn\ 1044 C‘,ownszl ",'pn ’fhz Algo,,s_»-S`/y/L md /~/umé)mgd? C)_au¢a‘ W/e/zsé 5le 77\§.<_ @>mpza nwf taxing 'F'hem 773 /l)\& QH¢>-n+)`m~ op 7)\2_ Qauld., ‘{OuL ASS`?.'S`~/'A'V\C& j`»\~l’n'\’\s { {\Q‘H'&/L TS éng=H~{ /%V&;A{LO [,);g@§, 22 g 9¢..‘> Q)£Q» G>Qes*§. w.\l.~»m 444 ‘l\l~<»- 011¢»?>"\\€&2. ‘ £H’i-S (,M\.'»t wa\kél'LQOL¢/fb/"q» wlqu Fm <?S'<'> ' dawkqu ’-.l?.>ms “l')zq?>,

E’XF/IMT / iscLA-ka'.ri’m :EN 54 PP@U' of £¢@Hi‘ §§ ffFli£$E/~/TAT`IOM @¢C Couhlgé{ b _ Aca¥de ').06‘< 'Téms C‘»<)'Dé O§ C£Fm::h\al_ Fz.;@{pqz&¢ § b , § %é£zow:‘ OéCJ/*K”¢‘;°" 75 7')~ Swppo.d-' af ,4@¢¢2>}5 '7».05'/ )6{¢/* QJ 72> fe £sQ»f\ 4"¢\ low Q@u/nsa| jim /..)'Az ’I`ewrs Q,z<§£ of O,¢imr'n»/( _"`\ (Hz@ae ua,z,,. . - ‘ ‘ .. . \\§ /</040@@)¢163' ;stéozc¢,E//j &I-///`m'a /¢M//Jz~/ A//én 6/`43’)/9`2, 673 md c{é¢/Aezj '/7)4/ 7_/}7»" .Lvmrl)/e 7?) y 7711‘ QO‘M’/' deals ;;, 07,.,5- AC{/}o`n end /é?aé$f_$ /zm)a amfsz dequ //Z /,QACSZ¢/ F)’» a@£m/l» /5\»\098)€`15 FAV'TN§ A<‘QO‘W\(PM?¢,'M§ ACMM /¥rvo\ 'wowi.<§ glad 771£ @Qamn.l ’I7\9 gl/soo:‘ °.. jon /o,ezM//./ %c/mcaeéyhd’ J;, 712 £///s a/,.,’f af :/4)4 75st /Ds@¢)¢|w@n{“@<§`€é.mml dwisz wheel :l’ Aw\ No+ (péf¢m;jf`\”*‘p 76 "WA/‘m°“ziw @17 /r/#UZ. h/O 5011_£<3<€ 0¢5"%6'0/16 0'£ gpauSA// Hceméo @FCH¢€O/n}'/f/\Aoz, A/o -C,zgj','?[' 'm /,15%. 722 ‘Z',m.<y'é ’//Lq>'/ ~Q'/¢/o @ Dwm>-§ mq Fncneaéz@l¢kv\ Fh "/M 7?>0\€ /D‘epm¢(`m¢r\l~ ¢fOe")m»}ml \\uslicz .Tv/noz. /250€'»0509 Ay,o£omm,d¢|{ l\lo /f?dv‘€‘j /9€»@ MMH!

HS él)¢@'< &)>Zs~m Qel,g*§'w::s Am.d §>L}`a)\o?$e . _ @I//€?Hé¢ own A/ae /A¢vé_ 417 ,//4,¢€.¢&$7[5 771 647 pso/vj(/S/?'J'<>Aé$, S>za@, 0»€ AA%£ ACZZ@c¢/né fin/7 /&Cé/'//s m/d%@©'$/ di O//'arc/@n@/s %C@?)/¢F. @ j /~/HO§: 6>7& @épo»n@?§n§[¢ @.1’ M VZ‘/n/ a/z é/z cf %g,e@></m¢g¢g,/(/ Z¢Z/Jdo~‘-’} @17.54»2 /1/@ " pg§A'A%M @m»{ mo`v\+k\‘f gb‘¢~°'m§£’<f /?/Lz AW/zoonm;/z/y @. j w>//,,'¢m ,AJM</ M.w 0/¢37¢§2 55 /éz§@ln`?%/</ %wcél@v[z¢l’ 712 5)/1\5 /14»»'»»'/ of%z TZMS”DEWM)/me/yz' C’/é/;n/h/P/ da%¢["(€f mdka um\-¢\’)?M$~I Ué/h£ A/h£p &i€lmz whd¢/L 417‘17 affé$;v :;?/G%?» Y¢“"§°"`é ka{zmmk v)szz_’T/L¢¢z 444 dMA-€¢?L 76 37 51 "’ Z d"‘é" }X¢v<w+/'wdm Wcs F)£ 0/4'7 a ga 010/15/ Z'~)"'//lf§)rw\ /Lé‘<) JQ///‘-"/"‘ 3/4371€’2_

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.