Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Miller, Kyle

Miller, Kyle
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided October 1, 2015

Miller, Kyle

Opinion

A&.

Kuk Mtikr TC6- /g VS, /€*" -foe. State e>Pl^Q^5rtfeojoc\-

RECEIVED IN COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS FILED IN qrp 99 20]5 COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OCT o12C5 AbelAcosta,Clerk Abel Acosta, Clerk Lxsr of ftiirvteixES

AWAVlCcupV of ft^ofe 7rtblpeeHi} held (A^JI^/DeS^ank Vflirg eV ftitiohs. WrSe 4t> be a hubnd re^e:^j%Jtdr\.

f^llW owk' wA dfeKcr^.er mte formal ^y^fc CW&\ tWA-ef Pteaxl? hdIrcorrecyu held 4a\r Shte^^nW Aohen 4Sr too* nAfcs,a*5 procedure^ W-^ Stefc ard C^Auto** • JStf^rKosete ^^ns^^fefePboTn^^fc^- corn** en •K.fef^L^SfD^^e\/X€lO Altefovrfo ia«4ifcis^ ctm be, cwer-Wm to ^^A^rA^

ft ^ "for*Cax& opto ^fa&Atal-™d^tt^wa&^^Aml-j^

4^ tlfen feftfe ordAfer Magon ^6§i fie wft^W h^Vi ^VZ\ ffiwa. fefeVferiabk ink rtnVvW. offer heansf^^^W^i^KW AfW teudas fed* mCii^cdu ajnd p^UtoM ^AX^."fo Ate (^Mska^n.ofeakl ^iWM. '^1 all, jKfctek-+a«ih^v. c<K£her^a&Win*«ta*W*£ii

excu^ajflfd wttapMrg ante wfts>rt^V-fromctei ^ ,e(yfe.4«\>4he cucm QjsnrtJr rejfkeir a-firtMlcj-tSundeci dalm,&6 AppeLtan4-dc£s ml-or maW- n^f KnuJ o*>-war .V\&sWn ecnrorft^nfe afeo Lthderwums 4kecebnselS v6 dW ih&WuweirYVJcty bJtfch^fe&ujadCan te %sd £<&er-fe\ Cbid tv&Ts'SLC'k -mi Pip(KaWfecA^TP"diauad-H\e ^c-sl-ahd onb OjJalUolfc ^metai dtbedo dwre^cfohs is dftd-appeal. Pin a,%r\€ii\& n&ter Coddna -scof-h> bcfti avk-M a-sfiesfeUis otvi^ errors,4tas xemm £MW4oJi^k4te $m-m ,do reuse dai?vt,a\ Oimai 'in ccacnd ^dW glTha ddMe-s.&4ks inePfMTi/e ClaTTh. P^eiWll 6\5^c_Ae6 &\&k arid'tedeml oasdowtedo \ftlfoode WscfelM ahd <^pphd- Q6 Ws lo£kc^6miaihq uftkessani. '\Wtper or (aciATm af^LunenVs 4d fllla^€UideriCe. wader /3^)^j tad &diVfci- e£6^erv\ta codrecwe eP-dnal wd &6uk\ taJe. noa&t rvvl-fir wi^-hia I(A dW V\r4 run, \x\^oi^dy in accord luTdh rules orti C^dmtons.

3ZI. C6*JCUA<sr£kl AkfD PfWEft 3n:,CEfnrHrciPFrE of asrMce

fcumid ctunrcf we^ls opined list ofAUTHc^nres ilcpsbs Pv\corAaV/."^xas tastis.a^s.cd-dc^aL.^iad^cmi; . vra filf^dVSkU AUridaetfCc^ll qa^%^.(z)C»CS^Gr:CT^,ncc^ . .11 it55ai],5ciC>a6"l0c.C:m.^aCWGC\) 4 ,5 (uOrker V, Ulirao 401 ULt>. sl4,QQ6-Gfe asaQna) . .4 fect^ U SWfe.

14k EOchaosQRsd) . -.1

biliu-E^oUlKklSicte DraduV/.M^Iflirl.

512) L\.S.^IS?) S.&.IiH^lri2d aV5Cfit3) . .t faradLW.Upland. 313 ILS.. -SSOfKcSD. da, (Wig^Mctndcurl %> ItS.331/11 5.Gfc 12!Q^ LklOdd^TD ,5 feredta U Siak Cbae. y LU\siflncj> <te a.s. muis.Gt 3 ^ L.ed.ad mcmti .c Caraii%ysWe da L^UiAiVl.'EWe 3>l4S,id 3d35lCfe>6 Ppo/Sou An^aoKft .

CbYV.CurAtti , Crane VKentucky m(o q^.loS,^i:^sa^m)] D .5 CracKer vfitak.. 5~T3 3.Ud.Qd faorCec.OriM.Ptap. \q-tfrt. ,5 39L Ga3\$p(A 6.^13d. lCC3n\ib) .

U.S Slvd. (U, (ltt£). . .2 , 'DicKeyU Honda 3& ILS36,qo&&.\6(/U(o LEd.*ad%C«qi6) .4 3C£3dxl 2jilfoS,TlCy"Tl ICfoc 6tujl, to aocffi.

B<j (Meters ^\5cl3j„M^fe%~l)dxQD^CC£l. -b in s.oa 3d ^sUo-n Cfet. (^u.<w&c&) .. ©&sul. U35 ife.Cm.A^aocrt\ .. r> ^a\Wmy^AjAe '^SUi.3JWI/OxseOftbc-Crrw.%.R^\ .,1 ^rd<A/.SWe % 5.(0.3d 9^naddfe%rto«a^M™ .1 Ornery5fok 4(^iii3d ill te.Cnia.%:ricriO, r\\\ ^d^sylk\-y9mes 4^it^^)/afcs.(iv;v2)^\^Ciqi(cl . ^\i ColdeCftU iJdiimjno^ Gcpza le^.y Sdude %°& S.LU. 3d#6tTsc,ApprUeustaC1stV&3mi) .6 £reer\ V.6fcde 35S.UlL 3d(o^Cfe. AcorTaler5cdD . . 13, 2CB UiLISCnW (3iU U. 2615) . J' Ari^yehSe tW 3.ld. 2d l55Cl&c.CriM.App.mO 1-kwe.i y fdak Hardin y LoLm^fedq(Ki."Dn^.aoi4) . _ .6 Vkmortk^A/,' .a (dMftb^V.Stak 4L3id. 3dtol6e*. flm. HflfiionH/tt4. X(S .11 Hoin^V.Sdjdk Qomliixt 6ffl U.S.3iq Gtt& . • 6/7 UuctoU State Qsk 3ia ad to&fApB. Qt)"^L ifiOTs. ,6 ^Vf^ysy^ mis^.adn^i7ic1^-enw,%dqqd\ N C&66\1 \/ Virata 445 u.^oi/fi scdrangi^i L&i.ia^oCiaiq) .6 \Sls.Cd.33q4a.3.Kl.cXQ£)U^. .8 ^enViiAsV-SWe U36Sui.Qdm^CT^6d^^mi) . .6 IGflSlO. 3d l^Cl^c.Cxdja.\%.2c5S) rtekrV.^We ^ (a Keeder V.Sictle 34s,(A ^3ly^6e^Crtu.ft».acoii tokr V.SWe KuWsyilMlai 514 LLS.^q^tof^. .(d 4?& as. s^Lo^^s-Gd-^^maqis) &

^NS^.Qd ^rtfe- <Mu. %. ftp) .G siasiacdditiLriadisaqco . .u MaltyVl%in tt,S. Sup. &.(W0i .*S MannySCrte, S5is.(ja?2d^x?3-3qfe.(ir^%.ms) . Jo ai^3^3dU\5fe.^k%.^f^) * .S Q/3.^£06Qlc£&3 .11 HeGr\sV Stock 2eR us. i2sd^^s,ed.o^ii^dAL^^^iQ(nl Jl ^nei^ystcde Q[\ S.L0.3d^fe, A$;T<*arWiCaOtfto. . IX HVlera^csy.Stak US 3 Ld. Id X23fe. Br. <w ft8fX -11 NftrardaUflrizana 34£ U.S.. 43^44(4^ . n MoPiWV/.Kolb Morrci&y^ye, 353 S.LO. fi&K.%rlKiiQs [%% pel ceOX 31 Mzm-y.lla'dgd^yee MurrayV* Garrver_ 4ii u^.Ma^qiuaodmiLics^.aLSR^Q^ 3^6 u:3 a(o< 3 L.^d. 2d \an/iq s.cd. ui5 (iq^ •kJeroV WacKhirn Kl£iisr.OMby.SlDrle Q6 3,aU^3C^tw.QdMo^aHclD\ ft^V. State (oSI S.ui. 2d 31,31 fecVud.% 1^4) .7 ^GSt^J ^2^ &A^ 3C*rf). 3 3,^11 "fte* y Gxwsrderwov\ 6£x33i3nCSM3i3yJ2mY 3 \i ' ^tfasacn V. Mel3fili3a\^sd- (3H3\de3<3c:, Sl4- y.Pc^c325e,A-5/j4i.ss.ld4'd.dl jhc&vscnySWte it S.LO^MS&tecA'tfUApp* 2xto) , 13 3t3iftsm\^9Wre l^SLi2*LWfoc^rComs CWVii 3M). 12 3u3i\ V. Uoeeu 315 i.\3. -33%\ 6X3.3i4 3 L.fed, 3dto CWU -4 SK^yskfe mbS.lA.cA Sen(fe(W teTbi4 2Di^) ^ S.lA 31H5fE<%r Ud- Il341Qi^ , x 71 3dncW/:^ V. llkd^tn 3lric.Vder V. keane-' 691 U.S.X^QK2GW) . <- 5 A "Xike. V. Skde %1 Sl3 2d Wfabc£h\. fyp. ire) - -5 Ttams y.Stok 6\u as. ^ iivii*s. edV^i/^ usU) v 'ms)M leuy^erdV. GurKe ?MLis.7533gsr3 \:32/i^L^i^oCnm) At QArWi £Wb&u(Wb MX lll.s/c^l^lQd^qfcS^/a^^^^a%lflnfc) 5

LkTMGkdesV! LefcmrL 3t2> 13in\5n3)r8dh3r 2CM). .& \AAd^teAa3liie 4&E^\\*6.U*n(fcHideacon ... .s iiiuy sWe^y cto .3 linked 6feAes\/.fUfee 3>533iiinrcftii%Gl , d\ ,7 i3s.y Pw\lw»T iilf^lC6CC/i3liW3 - 3, Q:sA/.Gra\ic. 4(^u3x^leftSjeU62fl,SDL£LaclG^ntef). II 113.3 Micfe 4(3 ^3C3CASG3m,lCd3. .2 U.S. V-(33 m^3lS)3^45(6lhGGWH)/ *2 .

L16..V'3yca&> iTFM^ XMd)a%?f93LL3^63X SGd.i6\d0sL.^3li(PO3 115,3/. "Rivera 5cfi^44(CA53^^/ , ii L\3t33ker (3^331141(3142613). ,. fe tL3y%ii 51331 icnccfiqm^. . fe,%i \kUV1»fe\\e 30832d45dC3P,3id^3). 31 \Ml3jtt33rad ^ 7(3E2d 1611 fCFH W3S), .fyll ,. A \Jl4^&tori USVxf ieyTis WzlX^MltlM !623,S1 S.c3. R3otRtO ii LLfe%ccky^k aq $.13 31 l65dl5fe(3R^.at^. n 1=^.

u3mthS \/ Sku-Vh 531 tl.&^6^Gt£tf$. , \3 LUTlSfciftV. 5>kde 3113(3M4623^fe33, kp,2f,\(3. . S Ls^ocq y State 3U6xv)3d3^fe,&cx3:^ CWW&/1C6S) 3 . LxJctd VI State . d^3a).2d3^&..ri%d3fl) . 5 liOGha SunV. iM-W 3llU3Tl^73Gqra . .7 "federal HH\ OiA«.nARAe.rd- 41 'YeA&roS ^3dV\ flisAffAftcrtd .31,11 3i^i &w£sdf/teM- 'federal H4h Auerdufl-d- Skte de\§4 M'rii .11 Skde PVdic.Wd§lO .3,1 34^ Ar-Kcktfft Skd^ ftr^clellld nr.srmutfe di 3e<Bs ksderronexvl- Qc^k Am. s^S.66fc.

Ibcas (3d£ e£ CriKOncl KOQEtWe tV3elei.c4 , "WLSC^fiTCruimoil £rdtadiife ftr-fcdelGS.

TgMofc Cede cd'CrluLim' Toesdure ^cs <3*k.cf OriLunal .7 bcas Ccde^of Ofiwii\al PrdCcle. 2d^3feTa3 3/ Meie. 2,1X3' r\ krdfcW 3.C4, .7 ""fess. (3dec£ GfiMinal .. Ardtci^ fe,22r .3 7e)fc^ c3d& c3 Cflvural ncoate TaaxsCdkfiP Cfou<vtl Pro&duce Atek 31.67. JI "faces Cede c£ Gtvvmy\0i1 VfA&ate Qcteie SSK . 3 "p«K>Ccde.dP GauMI xrcfietkre Mek;?g.3a, .7it f e &de.cP Qfouwal ulteibfc G<dCck3g,:&- ^^v741 *%&s ^ytcf Cr'tMlmi Vttfleduife, <V\idk3&^tbJLua). _ flrooedbfe- "lexite Cxd&eT Onwkil ..„__ Pw3'd£mi4. 4\ Sllo.oaCalffDQQ. •iSto &^l CbAe *" -™ 41 §3^66fcYa3)Cb2. •"fetob Qsmal Cfl(k 1&G& $wsi Cede ,7 Gem I Cede _J6 &mi Crik I 3&^<M37 . --T* leyfcPeml Ode. 135^3 7 WMxf> feral Cede, § 3q.o3. ,3 3exz& &mi Cede § cfl.cfe.. . . 7 • . ,_ _ ^^ vWWc Vwfce :4rf>^ ted VWJ-Sd&n 3 fcD, 3atekf) 3.52. .7 3ffiA UrtWfo Twice 30UILES fias fukb eP (WUefeeedw*- 2I3QM, laafe fades ef gtobk^cftdue 33dCC&. .Ul -fern Me?> of Af^llrde- Vrcttduxe. 44,2(a) ^akscr^'\dence-^ale ^&g£9. flulto C^ £3dft\££- Suk %S(cYb) . .11 V>i\\e*b 6? ^T\d€5f\oer ^iite AbL,,- .11,, 1\ui^sc£^\ckhc€.- ^e ^cstp, .1 %\€s(*^idew3^ Rde J0O^> , • 31 . l>ia^pKnorii9itite5df> Vfefe6lom L3ndurd-\\a\£l.6l - 43,ll DiScMnoni Ikilcb o9 ^o-Q^tcha CwducA- Rule UG2. .3,11 . _, t)3c\plfnafflBaWs ef fcftfecmi Cdrdiutt- ?uleb%...Yn -5/1 u<4). .6.7 fc,\l Md._ : . "KukUilkr ) ' _^ PicpelU/Wt+ionef ) 1^4k C3wd ofCnuincJ Rj|mte \S. /dcTr 4ta Skde oflec&s B\£n^ q4 *lta Stale dFTejos ^ Aus&v~fa©s ftTxH2X) FOK fOCDQO To dW tdohcrable Laird oP Canawxl finals: .SiF^MfidT GPTtfE CASE bn 4W 3nd cW^ ftpol, 3&\, App^liaiM-/l^eAnciaird beoam* €3rtMxaeim an (tfMiiv\eiad dW4- began as \J€rtaxt uTrVU TmnQis rftmdy^Du/k, ourS evrkl iu4V\ fi^llo^/fiefemoLrrV skVfcmg vTiO^m ClXuii^ one-(Win ^el-P- ififtwse. as> \Lo&4esltfted 4d od- dwto -\Via\s.. lAppelWrlr Atefendflu/i+- W>c\ wo vmrd /OruviAv\a\ Vu-sbfa tmlitae uTc4iwi uk&e u&s £xWdU£. 14 %ill of BoeecdAon u)h<> Mack fc^ Picpdlo^/^^c/d- cd his ModVier a^ 4ro suA awd >&\k, uJds fet4- cdh of^wy £tesenC£ as. 4- -shcu^ d^od- ^^\ojri:/OeRy>cl(Lj4fl^ jU^feWn Uf£ c£ cWdlij %ce mselfckftree.

On ar* "mdleWta'vV eWr^ir^4W (k£encknf w\dVidW<s£fcen&e6p Uturder; he. djx^ -Wveci bualuru krA a£kr aWwy^aa^ reeeivd &twsdrTal ohlu4 Wfe-dfied or^jWievnAana^dW bjeek^ loder cj\d xee&Med a. GnuToATen tfaudltej uutdU c\ sJuActeft pys&ToK -ClkiTrg weaMrvj dhe aaf ojss toadied uTvWa oA<^uod€ Cau&e and received &punklnwimf 6Fe^k4 ueafs Tvnpn^nmenV tor €2c®r& day^e. murdaf. lOo-tel of aj^ml lxyx^ &I\jen IndW dried (LfcLurd- <3Jrd Ca<£ ujos appealed -teddie dwdViLWf oP Rj^te.~Tta (Wf sf repeals 6pu\im d^i^f^litd?3yd^ed-^a'\iiAd'uJas <k\I\J&raA cn4d>& P1dV\ cW oP 3uie, 3£lS.

UL 6R0UIMDS fbR f€\/IE.W (Vita CVA o9 P^aWTnODr^cd-ltj held dkxd ftppdW/1>SncUvk GVwiaof &o-Se w^cfecyfvs -(or ^afasAj4rialJfe a h^W\d fef^^dtd^v kilter V\c\<k tk\d CflA^Yfia camse.1 ol-V dtm di\AAe ljg<, meHechv/e a^ 4\ie "TVe fo^'d of"Ov^jitjfecuu Appmk o£Rr«i\ai 4fe oa fthuaru i4y in^> m\d aJas RtMa^t oPRrvid \xj cdLAsefe t3M(o^o,\ on HaicV\ \\ ,.3^)3 CC:fS.^ 2&- BdQkie. -te uUlokfcos c^TecasWscA^rar^ Rules cf Vtefesstcoal Cosvduc^ :

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.