Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Montgomery, Benny Lee

Montgomery, Benny Lee
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided February 26, 2015

Montgomery, Benny Lee

Opinion

ItJ lk ~u~raF t~~~~PI ~Is flus /-,J.J l ;;%'.4-5 BevrJ1Lee_ lt'lodt;v"'ec -v- llfftl!tJ4 lie S-M~ ofZ ~KIJS /ly;pi//ee_ /1 fftl/nA's /?.•it- :t. 5u.sp.us/~tJ !Y1.i7a~ 7(; /fte J/.#oflp/;/~ Ceua-Tof !lft"-"ls; C111e5 tie~ Resfrd£1~, ~o/ k ;1~.,..~,1ltt~;!..d­ ,;; 1k II- bov< 51., /e J BA/.1 .,;....,_~ 04u_se.. uk ,_f f ,LaW.£_~ I~ f rto s~1Flks f/..J s~i..w-6 ft, £$ 1/pfel!eki-5 k:..l~ ).._ trf.lz;,J t~..-l,j £..tto~~ fk_ lltt£1~.v1' w:JI show; .· J;.., /._ -rk li(lte!U ~~ hk; 11 ;Y4 7;,',.) f..- ft/,.w,~ ..f.v lftv<-11~ J(esr~!i.ll 115k 1k C,~--/. )U5f.e-l ik_ £k .J,;ci. tf'Jw;#.,.J nciJ.fw:Ut>/ CoftPs/ d.. e. -fo 1k.- fAd M 11e..!lrt4U ;s w-,16k ~ 7,~ olr/;,.,;._, e'f,es, ~hi<L, IJp,eiLf fMJ5 r!kf1k C'.._f "":11 1~ras 01•-6.~ 11__J Su~r~J 1'k.. R.. /-e., r.eyu,l(~ 11 dJ;-f,;,Pnl a,/eJ fe>fecllft Su6~:ffi/ RECE~VED ~N COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS FEB 26 2015 Ab84 Acost~, Clark rk. t~f- of{;(~;;td/ A,r~fs l/us{~1 ftx;a-.J getUI-'7 Lee_. !it4ti(>.Ltt1 /J;t('etltJ~-r - v--- 1fze ~t4l l)f-ttKP; f!tfti/u_ r·-q f•. :--) r• I 20 15 . ..

;(lofz~ ~ Jte/,Ml4~ EtJ f)_p,ve, •Oil AL'OSta, Clerk

{; /'~ /-4voJ(.8~k CoVJefof ~/s/ t/v vJ Wm~~ , fl..trel4.vf; /3e,..;'1 Lu /4~u'' ~ 111/j !'~~("cr/h..l~ {;ie5 11A s~-tM;-6 rls A,s ;J1o£,J h)it Re ~l~ EtJ /f/ltifc.- ,:; rfk- 4h~Je- Cn~r 11~ /:J !lttffo~i 1k- t1f~I4Jt tw~l/ skw;; fk ;;!uw~~; Ow [)ne-. bel< t'k /2+1.. /Jrtd~f liie.d J...r IL 07 .,_,1;\ rfk- 2!,f dts~:~f CoU~Vf 1;..; (11;J!to-./J r ~X'o5 lt5 /lef't;~ 6y /IUJ, ~'/ Lee/N:; .A wlu"le ~ f'no/Vl 1k ~uft,rf df Cnl~;jiJ/ /J-pr~ls w/lu.$~1 t~ If/Of- ONce k.J~ ft;; hftt:f- fun !fpj$JJ (';Iff~ wts fi tic/ tJ tt k J ,1J h't f.At~J.Pn h/( lt-,5 Wit~~ ~ ~ fti~ IJ /JIZ,tJJ~"> w2!A C/1t,s t:;~.e t wK--tlo,oC)/-03 ~~~,.;/-s~Pie.s /u_ Aflv4_ IZI'C,t~vt?d (~'11/hn.~o) tcV- ((k_ Cdu~+,;.; (Vi6/A~1 -;;, 1kf Jz,·~ w~f w4s ~vhf 6'/ec/ 7Z Jt~ks of J!o7 o~ flfJ,:V t~ <fkl'te sl~/e, 7ks CtJu.~f-,~ /J'Z:Jt.vJ ,..;~ 5'eJf~ W'wt of f/IJ/wx -;. rJ7L ~,;J...:sd- 11#.~ "1%-:e ~ d, ,{g Cl~e~-ft.:.s .-1_,__cL 1/e_ rAt;! Cu!A--yLT-;v ~ft ~ /lAck ,.uo c6~eLstcJ~ ,f ~4,.) ~ rflu\ fb- r:~ of~c6 fiw_ Co~fof-~~~(;/)J /Jp~fs c4;;ed ytk_M4r(-@vVr[k_ t

(;;JrM;s of- fle__rf>t(Jyl eu~i, wW W(,JL -f/-Rse fzMis?

U), .::z:C, PeL~ d f- E~/t{)f{ ~ Be ?e ~ -dte.- J(',;;de.~CL- t5 lt!JPU, T.vsc.dh'td p,; $..~sf,._;.; 14 /Ld¥] ·1h. JJ~. /}L,u.ecs C~se-· (Jftl>L li~, AA/d PK'M &NSrhfJ~ f14 ~f s- cl~ PJ,9~ Co/lithOiz;r.J ex-c~f tA-fW peoor ~a~ ta ;iRASvJ/fik- tf

dowfof o (!-- ev-erz; f/J£-f A/ece~~A~ lz> Cowsf/-4/e 14, ettl~ w":ft v.IA;j, ~ · ,1 e-~,~Jj ::CrJ Rtf" WttVs t;o ,.JCJ7 vt ~~~ 3S'il; 9o 5, Cf JtJ69 (?q1o )., Sa/JI!'o _Rt~dsuJ--v- s1A--r;_1 871 5wz.ci 81'1 (i;x.Cc;...!Je;~i~s), ~ 8~tJd/:'s-J'>'[:y7e .323 S.JAJ. ?c/ 8'13 2o/O WL s81'i's (FJ(~ llfe, ;?olD~ -fk fa"'a-tof- u,_;tv<;,;p/ ~f&~ e-hM:VIIIeJ /;,c~l su.fftc/~ R'ec11'ew &o"" ft.,_ 14-45 c(L;(W.~AI iA.w J: fl-;Sft-"'J-e#C£-, lk- CCJu.~t-/ Covt:I(Adecl ikf 1k ~~~pI s~Fft'c/~ si~,J of J;clso~·v- Ytti7t;u,;, 1 is tle s-ule.. 1:-.sf- ;;L, Jr/eR;,;_11v5 e0 l dJiff><t £ u(f/ct~'J ~~ "1R11>~ cMes_ 1',.; ~ Co«au. trf .eft:••/..r~~ f;,o/w./ sufi,C,~ ,t~.;,~w,!k- Cv-f RYf~_eJ 1k- 5e.-d..~ ~~.. ;'1 1/Mf;s /lff"'be,--;..b l f 11 I.RYI Su~(~ /J/I/f}-11s's u.k $.~si)~ .,.v~ V:rz5tMtil ~ dvd";(, 1£s di~~t,~ou-> l~v7u:~ /t5> -{v /e1!}/ Sv/{,•c/~~ 1 1k .e.;,'Je,Ja. J~ Wt '/!IJOf/;e_ 6u...vti.

5ulhct~f; rA fl,'-lefy1 --a_ ,;.,pow/&.vd- D f (]~.Jks -t/- 5 ~'li ~ ;:S 1f....f- 1/.2 t R-e.Ld<j 4/!zd tk-f lep·l S'tA(hu:.•"7 ts ,</d esfpih/.ed$';..,4 c6/.lA be(Ause_ fil- w~iiVeSJ ft~es fr:sf;~(),u'J -thf -e-s(/Y~is4~.s 1k e~eA.,;-/5 1J f- fk of~YL , fi; ite v) e.v'~l Co14rt.-f- Mu;rf- de~ ~e. ;f11 /.~:, f Cfu,JI t's II !hrhOIVe( f7:...J:,'"5 ~/a ,;t/Jiv~~ /hd;<L 1/....~ /us!-t+ R.eu{ew or ((k_ stfco~j .fv see ;f ~ Co!!-/1-f!e..-f-wD~J> we~ ~(oKR!.l, ;:t;..; 'fk CA.>e_ nf IJA~I 1k. (Jvb'c..e..- l#~ ~ ({k_ t'w/f;/ &~J df t~~s/;~~ A c~ S-l.f~s IJf t2e?t'h<d,~ r/k_ -Y-t!e cJf NIJRcdt~ wi...J ~;,k{e_ I

""J-J.o Vk Mo/e/~ ·/k ;7vt£e clcd tvof ~ue frt<>bi /e CA~s-e 1a~,4 Semt~ ~,A-- ~~ed C)fo' 12wr It? 1 fJttd_ C/k ~~ 1},/J ct~Lt</YI~~{j9 c.z), 1-eJKI,~ 't{J fv ~ ftJ ltc~ vf/{Zus .eJ; ~ J fVDj-,, ~ (fk___ (lrZJ ~bk ~u_ .fo eA (k_ ,eDuM.. ~'~e._ ?fft.k -v- "&~Jil :J-13 5w3d_ ], tf {?PK -l7ff ... ~,J /l!V-/w.;;a 2000, (Rf. Rdfij ~ {Po f tt:> tur6 k_ C4w-~ w ~ f~/,~ cwd,uft~ 11 /lllfJUoi>~ ~~vn:·f/,1'"/,:V ~ /h/J-Ie( Jeo8n ~1-l1h f/.(-bJ cfoo.,e_ 11-f/eK. 0) Seetf'Jj QCC-ufn1 /Jb~&fr-//7 (U>£ Corv (Uvr/lo~ 1'1~ ~ /Yl7>/e/ ~oorv~ 4S (u/tce..- .Aj1Jl'o19c/, f1/Vc£ f.2) A~JU~ <lk -/ol/ef flus/)/ x~ ~!so S-f~~- )-/u/~ Cf?,{"~3d to~ 0"'""7 i; ks. ,vvl- t:d,..d. ~-k f ttail'-0-.

I tJ fJ ('fh -Ctt_;;••. llff'. 2 ou '1.-) Ato<.tS ~...s~). ~ 12,,; ,;.; a<d slrl<.k5 olL- t'c).v ~1.'-f...f,u;_; /Ler~ ,;<!,& '7 c,-/. .w r:t> ~S(:>~ rh ~t>ck Ot/ ~j c/o;;~ b7 d~.tVt·'f ;t; ~e>de,jtte'2--./.- 57Rk P .t53 S.W.J.-d 3D~1 su7 {1'>4C/l~/Jf(lt 11fJV. 1k Ct:ZcC<,Msf/Lve.eg k~DwtJia 1/..e. ;;v lfh/s C4se- t.»~t/ tVIJT /ud /1 tf~su;ok'~ f"-'-' c:4vf-fR~<-SoAl f-v 1/c£-- .fv be/,.;~ ~+- .NA/!.(diz;_s Would be_ lucn/ed l~ 1k /hd{e/ AJJM., f::4JJ,Ajk_ (A .. ~ W"'5 ,JD~ fttPSWf". ~ rz~lrc'e.. W}t(J!p,_-f/m .&/~ (;v-/v 12.. ,-./e/ 'too(//} t>cc.'"'f,e£ b( llffel/,q,__f W'JS ~~ ~rt/wd f!ld£Jfp C4«¥l- IJ,vd. . ~rft--f Cu,.,~-f ,q.vJ w95 1 ?J.;....,__~ Ufo/1(.4SJN.J/e., -tk h:...-!h /J..~ f e<Cx;/s .t9 1,';,,/.kJ f4<>/ev-lz~ ::.wee;; 'j,J Co"J~"'"-(?~ WJ1f. /1,./t;;/hafUILSweR( OIL ~us f'' wkw 1/..e- (J;)Itc~ posse5ses ;:~- JU.t4JtJ~tJLk k)~ tk-f .1/k_ /htll.4- f, k {,1-.Jo/'f.k/,o,._s fltvd ,:Vd'J~/ faSt;;, fJ- ck..y~ ~ r!hasL- oto/ 1/k ~,.f sce.vq_. eu.(e...-, wr us. t~-f .337i Rtl.A5UL~ ,z [;wJd l}ftlli, !If fk ~ar ~ "~e!f. ""~ f7u's -h.~ r/M,;,_ kd .b.uw cl.vi ~tut~t-e'!!f e,.;(]lus cAR-- 1/AIJLfoYi "ffvr-tr' ~ ~lffsf /JAde o""--/r,'de_ of- {k /hD/e-/~eo~ M-s #J{- U(V;Vec/ed fa cfk. /hufe/ /lODfl/1., .1~ \fk_ #tuJ.f-/W(J"ck "U-Js;c/v d:it1/t"Jf / 1.t rt:IJ 1'1 ,..-d.. 9.~ (A o ~<- ~ (l,r,Juk.:-e rw<!Lf ol--fk_ tto~""' o~<-- h/JtJ,.,cuJI", 5e.eI J:ll~-hk J((l/1 3 I0 5w sduf '1!::2-- U-1.-h~ 1!..-ft'd« .e-f •.htf.£4/; wt5 I

to d It<'c{ 1;_, Lo..-c/w:ft;_; 1/.rf / /l ;kc.-1,.;. ~ w eo/> d, j tvdJ Zr.-/,'(7 f•J!,U Mlf ckwv Tk-/vJ//Mf)~~ f}aand_l~/~ 1k ~L;J t'(o~f s/to~fd ~ Svff~SRcf (.$)I -fie_ ~v~d~~ 0 {-/;e!'ved ),1 fDft/~ &'~ rl~- S w~ <Jfrjk l'hv/R/ /Zo OfVI.c /J~ cJe«-1~ fh__ /Vluk! llt>DM 1 1/tvJ eutv'dt...v.f.t~ ~ (l,(J{e~~~;~ S'w~ tlAJl /hl~tesf,~ ll(l(UJ!tJtvf Fox. -hM(I~~~~ ~,..;-~fA e...~,~aL 1 fJ /,a_ oJrb~ i_o~ddr ~o~vse.v-f·-!u 5~ 1k teodfVIt 7k.. CoCflt~ ~r- S(lf.e!/o.yf-- M-5 CtVVte-/ecf () f- fo5'l<!-SS'I;1 M~ ~u.~J cluttNt~ ~f Ccl~(}v514J/ s~rJ, :(AJ .A /Vt1hfsfA,vJ 6'1 1L- kJ (k f Lo ~deL J/Z~j_~ ./Is 1h- r~-ICSo.~ wko (Z.f!~j <(Le /]/l-ok( /loo(Vl, LJ~dd ~J ~v~/.~rfhuyz;it r/v Co .vSeA' r/v (le_ 5'fA-n.cl, /Jp te-l~-v-f t15S"f!ked 1k- .,e:S k. ----!tw f- .Lou dd {6u/d Ca.v~ /,; ~ 5.f/wlcA 6,f'{le ~OVM !J,vd__kiL ~ ..v~ d-o~~~~d f ~~ J~vh 14/~ ~~()~ /J~~f: ~dd £v4S r[k_,oc~f­ rzw& dl- fh,~'; IZc'Jut''"; ;J;) d~5'> M-S ftu..J dvJ /lp(L2/~ dvt.- /JrZo~A-tvd h; l):; <[2.c. br4h~oi>ll1, ·jk_ oc~~A- of r{1_ ;lthJ;vL tS (Le Yf:J·~;lle- ~ ((k, ~Ow~ b~fdv~t~J, IAe OCC-"'[JJJA- l::ueev ( k 1/\/iH. 7 J ~~ 7v j;tJ/ / ttNd_ i<-J£ tfo dM I o~f1 t p~fh~ ((k_ blet-R- r1~ /lpouzll~ Jk ~[tv{ Cou"'f' &hused ;-h d/sCF..ed1o~ b7 /Jjr:,tf'.-v; t:Voc!J,..,"J& evlckt/~ f;L(),..,. A W/tu/J4/es~ se-d, /J.JJ 'JI,~I/Jaesf ~""--11, f.>~ cJ~b/J,..d /l.f//0 e.Ncou~ 1 t,.,fr-~~ws~tJ ~ ;r (J;d (.,tluwed /e~-fi<A( fo£;.__ fM~N-1 67 l~"fe~ o/.,1.,.,~/ A Mkll-q.v{- rl~ CcJ,v~ev-f V:./{A.uw/- 12>LffuJ..ft;J if: 1/f'kll ,eeue,eC4/ O,J /l CurJ5o//c4.hi C~Je_ 1Ze.- Coua-f ;;..'/eel --/o EJJti/•Jerftil- (/Z.f -ffJ.~f ~J tt/O+ dJs~(';/.J/ed fo ~. folr~ ~~}to~,.

1-, fl buS-L vf !Jlssc!lefto';.; 67 fk_ ~;.-1 if..J;fl- ~ 1/i;/,,/-,; lltfe!InA;, f_ ,;hf' -/v CoN/;...;(-~~ OJ::~ sf )z~, Ci!tJS5e/AJv<;;u IIVj_ !k -/;.b( ;;_~.,___ 19//owecf II~ 1'1 fftc/W/ ~ k_ s v /,.,//Jed ;,'1 V2c_ (?ll r;ecu.-ft ;~ k7 l_ovtdd w!to tv4·! ,vtrf f~teSe.vf ~ Cou,ef rfo ~4 o

Vk Vv•'f..,e4J d ~ ,q._,d &_ c,ed~sex~i.,ec/ .6 1k_ ~se, (Lf). ·-r~ s;xrfh ~e./+-fv ~£4/z:,.J llrw~i::tv~JI/ "'--LK C:t-(;u.;t/e{ ftiv seea-h.'--'s 1'{).,;;_ !lea.sed- s"f:ut! L-1;'1 L1k ,c,Jhf li> /} !7 //~ f~Nbltb /llt:.-~ 6'7 fir/ t~;-IWI1"-"7 df- fk %k II~ dt,cfra.l tJJW \{k- u~ s·k-11 M 6e.tW cd(l'tft!L~ 1/ed--~ ~. ~~~ ~ bl2- (tifv~ of-· ifL..L tAYut1-R-- t<J/VJ ~se_ of1k- .IJLCtt)IJfM~,( rft /;e_ &tvWJ Wl'fl, r{l._ ,_._,~esseJ ~;;;--sf A;..; dv ~ Cd'Mfv&il"{ f,Lou-S> {r/L &bf..,; w;?es)eJ f~ lu's (;.v~:.,e 1 t'IJ ~ k rf2..-- ~ ~%,~,.,_._ Jf CowAd (;f<-- h_"$ difvst?._. the .!~e. h7 .,._,1p/&,,_._.""J f+-f-rtel~tv-f A~> Rt~h:t of- (rJ-v~/~r~~~ IAA--5 det~ d~ ft<oU'SS u~~ fe;{(J-5 6 do ol- LI/IPtA-,,;e-.f t_"cer£/L@J. A-vd ~Y-a5 Ca.-sf;h~1 1Jt:~5 ~r/L (/le. tlv:-kcf !jrfP'~> Co0.hiu--/z~., A de~L~ b5 L~ Cc1d-t::l- wLe.-J f~e;~d.~ ;s ,dow"; fk-c~rr~r&~;.~ h.rfl_ ({k_ ~/-:;,.:d. t4 t( ~~dL ~ Je-~ ~helle"~<. ~- ks be.ev 19- /'1-~S(A..(t~t-t~P f- t :S rft~I S k-C k tfJ) fvt-s ~ .;J (4_;;t C/.1--!'<.., ~ t{ ~ /l~~J<i tJ tt (' rLJhAi/1/J; of~ c/.'~-f o~rkcn; ;(' 1k-- cb~Y<- LJ Iff~~ ~ CUSJ fXfJ/IAi:,~ Luv-dcl 1~ OjUl-r-1 CDux.-f; /1~ ft<a~ Ju (/k_ &11.-Jsk · t.A$ A en:M,"',v;;/ ()w ifk. K:-u.~ ~ ((k_ ~ t<),-vl /J d~J tJ-h~-L-fl!K IJrtl Wko r<-R. 1

3, ~eff!ecft:.re__ f/s~5~J/ce.- af (otA.~s-e/1 fiK- fp-:/;5 ~ hD/J A re.u.,v/1/t:~ ol/;cft~,.; 4 1k- due (Zttole55 t/t~U~ of-tVof-hp,~ A!/o~dr/o c tLo s5eKAM;tJL/I fk- ~l) w:t~s> ~ ~ st-k. lvrJ PJAA--s1 (Jk l+ffR-J.t,tv+, /}~ Qf puf- o6;;vft~ fv ~ (2oS5eJ$1~~ 0/wn_Jfl fjll:sf <{lL ~(Z~~~~ wfu 1k- .8('f~I~A~.-l~ ked #'o JK 75 o#" ;.>~C-~~d~J. ttJ t fL (/'V\..

tf, flv~( J~V~o~ff /tyl;J.elh~f ,') 11dwi~ t:;,JoLv.f0 (" its C/4~ ;wd .~ t"u wry wrsk ( S"'), fiq~, w (/1., llt-( _dt~-«)S dr/ l~ J,..mv,; lu-5 twe'f &t<- 1~ /..._ (Le_Sfc)~st b~ .~v.. wU LD~ JcL ~ d tr/ ~~ ./ll!o/e//o e>.~ w ~ k__ ~ ~ r

V;S~-f: fl(fe/~J ,j._...f0 A_e- "} f+V-k/~ t;MxJ of- 1)z,S CK~.ffoW~'I,..i /ttvJ ~ tS t-/cJ >/,(ft!,;J ..ev:deMut.- 1v fJC.dve_ ()~f.,V~e_ ~ t'k ~~ C~ W/5 rt'v~sed A.JJ_ .Jt;c.aw..J az.vf cf Ca•~"-l £'/ f/U- ;/tJ. &,,.~/ of ~h 1 rfARt~ ,5 po eJ~~~ af11L ~ vvk,_f-i.AfoS ~u~J (;._; L;:r-ckf-s /~d~ (U- WI-S pof ~ fJ !lrtddwf. lls tS fl.-,Ck.PL,tft.- f/))ue- /) A}i)f- 1/v~ lly;l'el6vf 15 lt11#Dce.vf iu-i wl. e.:(k~) LlA~ t,d A- Cot"(Je-1-wf ~7~ li,_/J f/J{ llrbuseJ /7 r(k C.•«A-f vJovid /.L/v.,_,._ M /J- lf.-45vlll~ b k ~ce, (/f,Mud.vr ie SO fetU~+ of-Ill~ cic--c-e.: fl//,/f~~ v' !J~~!utJ .). )<; f?J Lj)~ lf)? {?u~ Zol0.- 0 (- h~~ ;,vdc~ .AtJJ tJj;_,l/eJ) 9t~e,.; ~+t:tU:!-1-' lhuJ{ ~ (({.oved Je1 ,1J. t'd- ye_Mkf._v-4/,t_ dov b~ f U:, 17 o~ t1j.: 1/d -9 ;fc, -4tl'ef~{- J. c/ ,._..rf~ f-'-"fk_ (fl'-L fl "'1 B-c:i.~tss;_~,; /v fV £~t /ltV</_ rflR_ r/,-k_ "'~Is he ~;(K M,j ,v.J(l, '.:J ~ !<VJs u,./()~k )u~oYlJ' Could ~ befte~ 1/wf ;4p;t-el~tVf- t41S fl-'1-r?,te bRtttJ 7 U.tJCa~>f~·v<..- wi1h ~ ~f/c.fl-/ A-'f-'fk if;~. aT~"f~S fJr,c/t~ • fJttf~I~A' tJ~ ~-e ~t-1( t+dti-uss/o,Js ·-h> fk (()//~e-, -tie close-sf~ -h J, ",__e ,_f e<1 /Jeycv t'dtJN<'c--1.:-y k:. --/v to- C..!<~ W'IS r(l. ;/,~;;(;;, f- P-rt lwdd's. ;/.d 'fk /~If h.tA"/ -fe-s-1,/.w'f ~ov-. ~JJ1 /t~1~ .A-- (l fASw/Jt /L- f~u£~L"-"ry of /Jr d;f4_ev( oc.-t fc,u~, . fbtt<- <f'k.._ ~IU~O~ fU4 SV0/ ll(tf.e-/hff~AJS fh,~ Co~~j~ifRjlM;~ i/..J. ~)C.:-e"Rr,,lij I(iV bJll/(_ L d ;::.._IV~ ~5 ~ /-1-- iU J f1.v>l d f-(/1._ (l•s;es;to,J c~5~ ...,rvtl fi,V( 0~ //,A f',,u<-rfl: .eetel- ,.A,;J, 11-- 4vt~f dRJL,vr.-5 1~s-f /J./d fP:..:>ftt::... u,.,J.e~ \fk CiflCcuvzsio</t:eY~ · · (te Jf ecr/t!t/~-5~1/kl ~/ ~·~ (~). rlrt~ll@v/- l ' •

cflr<_1(eAk df >u-v:ce ti~ lh-c/R,/s ,1-veJ i ~ £7 c€"'f,f(~ '1/lPf t&- Cofi of rfl.- foJ<e_!ot:, IA/J-s /IAJt.eJ 1 fof)~Je (!df/.'11 r(lus t--5 J J; a-f- Fe btt«tr( 2-0 I 5 --/c / IJ i.e/ /leo s/. / d.P,.j d ( Ca ~,._fs !{,,. rfk- Cfl~~;;.~trl Co~v+ oriltfMI> Ro, f1ox 1230t9 a(//lu/ >i#hD~ f/-L-l ~ .ft~ ~tr> ?8 7/I

[7)1 • • ...

&-7 iu fJt,..,-&»~, :tt-mJti'Ia7 S1eue~sr>.~ t)(l/;f 152-) fM 166 tue~; few<>, 7/~r-z( /)MiL Clew~ flM5R- {;f.- w~ jL r[f_v_ e, ~--r l j (1/./!:W ~ 5'<1~ ~J'rh.;,.( Ca ft'es 110f ~ h-ftfz~ /u.._ /}tJf;,W /'nt. J?eJ~,:r & f5r1~- ~ d~/l ~;;,._ ~~rd c~~PKf,;,_; ,;, t$..> ~, 1U 'jD"' 7 -:L. ~-r CJd~f'[ lll-f'7'

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.