Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Lara, Israel

Lara, Israel
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided September 16, 2015

Lara, Israel

Opinion

L?w§./’/”' A/'?"f/’ii ¢¢>¢,~¢/ { k zimqu ECEiVED lN [0%57'//€’£§74//4/4% //’/?¢@M¥§F chmNAL APPEALS 1174 /7{//<577/1/; 731/425 SEP 1 6 28!5

/A/,€£/Jf/¢Z A¢'¢%:],@_/ ig/I§§),§!Acos¥a,§lerk l/.` ' .

WWW/f D/M/é¢/r @WBA, W%,W,M

P£Uf/d/¢/fz¢’¢/j'!rdf/V/A/@W/¢/§

y/l/ /’Z“'////WU)§/ ,; /M,€/)‘p//%f/?(a,/;//zm§ //,é 4 /¢/N,'/@/r/FMA/m/c Fia gym sp `/%¢»' ` 0'76‘)%]2///¢/¢/ ,D/J/z/z’/ fa¢/,e%/w 5¢//@/4&//5 &>¢/4/§/, 713%¢5 £4¢/,5¢1'/1//. //- /¢3£7~¢’/? , ( .{éé?/ »/L'QS;A¢/[’/KM " . j)',€,¢g£ A¢/,€A '*`/é 7{/37~5" [’émf ¢)/U¢//¢;//M{y///g J _ 772 172 ,Q¢&é/¢/,¢,,; » /?d,&;x /¢?¢>’0£ . ¢?z/M /M/f»a,¢eg /V,¢¢>é 770/sd %M/M/,~ 7¢?%5 757/4 y /l//W¢JO/#, 759/45 7'/% 3 F&J/M/@/¢Wz¢ ' )z’a&¢/d£ (,vea-¢s<g) 5»»'\::1..;0/(//%//@» Mg//j;¢?€ 725‘///%@//¢/4/ D/(:¢,'e/z/fm€/ /y/§'. faye/54 /f/¢/. 303 §gy¢///v, 755/fs 7£7/5:5; ` 7¢€5/¢/\//@"/1/{ -/¢747¢‘ /"'”/’5" %/:" `/,w A&f£az¢€rz/r rp¢%cé? : ’7 .

7'7£@/94”/ ,€L€V¢!z/é/,/}/ J¢/%/W//%§ ,%/.5‘ /@A%WM /é'é’ &/é//J/WA/@/%W¢/J; £¢?M/é/(/¢?¢¢¢/ OW/y%//@Jc/g{ //1/',%< /7<5`/% C/“-Zé//¢/,¢/ D/¢%z/A%[ ozaé% @/;%v/e/@mé//n/ éa/YMZ¢%¢’ /daA/j/,., 725,4%§/ ;é kwsz »7/1/ '”DEDE/? 'LZW//§l' 4 ny %€ z/,gya/m/¢w/ % £u_,e/¢‘¢¢¢'/ /%E £/L/z/MZ 56£0/€ //r/é/W¢/@¢w¢¢/z//f/i////J 47ng W€%z'//M/, ' ,_Zj : EAZEFJA¢/é/VT_ ' [;AA%€//\/ 7%5 Mz/;€ d///Z>!/W/%%§ 7%/; //J W&M//p/v /4¢ /(/,e// ¢/ /W/v%zw'/w, jay/wng 445 _:/t_.=/_Q "/7%¢% z@/%¢y/ 71%5¢/./. 775//¢¢/ Ja¢/;%¢j/ fé¢LY/M )4 95 M/WL¢IK@//JAW/A//§//Z//z/@Z/% , "A_/€_?"MJ£/z£//p/z//y§/ z/z/ /1//¢’7‘¢/¢¢‘- 7%$' 74€//¢/ f/¢/¢%//z€f )%¢»c¢z//%/z/j 76 f&v§aév;/:/ 'ajozs>? 99 //7,4¢5 //54/55555/%/ /@»é/Z¢’@//M///V?%/J //d/a/é’&'/r/%L!/z/é’é’. l Z¢j§¢/£§ /D/?Ez$¢?/c/?z§@

YLQW`/z/Qéw% %颢/%['as%¢ /A/j/J d%'W//W/%’/é/ /;J //€ f/¢%é a/;%¢' fda¢/ 0/&//)7//1/4 {J//¢’/f£>‘ 71%/¢/¢9¢//1/, 751/q j/¢J¢/;y//z//¢;//Z//¢//¢/j v 750 %6¢’5/¢/6,%/</@//7/£ ;ZQ //Wc%f /)1/4‘ é/£///¢//z/A//,w cg¢¢a{/zzy, /¢/z/@//gz/§M al¢/»_£_ '&/%¢% 'G/z/%§LS zw//J@a/JA/ >4/€ L”/é’,éé jay //;¢.),%¢//z§z///z/% /0 754 /d@/é’ &//77 /%_c, ¢’,@4 22 2//' 75;?, ZW />?5, ¢Z /A/Q//J,€¢€;@m/c:/Aé€ A¢ véz/z'/z/Jw/>‘%//y 796 EJ/VW¢,§A`/j £¢¢/¢/_Lm/a/L¢% N/Q/M/aé'/z/¢/wéz%, 41 £¢(y y/;»%! /W?'fd/\/ F?/)’/W//!/€/%W fD/I/L',- ,¢@u//d/Jwez ,5/@0/¢/1/¢>/€¢¢%/%@4/€,€5¢/%//? /i€ QW/¢' /uj¢z»w jc¢¢%#,é 55 ///Ma/z/ /¢/.fd %é¢@( /V/¢yé’ Zz)‘/"§” /?`éQ/e ¢=éz'/a,e %,;§ z§c§/y§¢/;AQ~.'/zgz/dp/VJ£/Q)w %/ ézz£/y/&/M- /w//z»l///@¢Z~Syv¢ %¢/é/M/,. 76;/<<)%; of //€ faa/z//c:/:{`/y 625/li /<‘Lc;/z@//¢<y i¢¢/A - £)/é b //7/74//¢ /% w/¢é¢€%@'/r/ng§/¢@ Q‘Mc€¢%/'im/§ /4/%(: V¢/Q/§M/,é¢n/A@; p,g ¢/S~ /A/QWLJ/z /{/¢</@{ ///@/4 da»e%/,~@¢/%€ ,éLCc/yé/y 7{/@@/¢74:! MM//a/%/% %¢/ //Z/MAVJ ;¢WJ/W,qaé? é(}/ ){/£ (’é/l/¢//é)?`/ly fpa/674 %$ ///J dkw/€éa /QJ/W ?¢?M- ' 7%€ 3 ///Mk/A/, »%/z%/¢J/»/%»%€ WW//Vy/@/c//m/A/n//¢£ %/¢/%¢r§¢¢&/é§ 7%¢’ £/,é£/;z//m?y/,%¢z //¢/@/§a/z¢/@A/cg; Z¢J¢/@/M/j/J ¢,,,/M,¢/W,¢M/,G ' @_;@’¢?F»z’w/¢/€cmxifw ¢/A/OE/?JI‘//fA/o /‘z»’é’w¢/§ f’/%z%/c/?HO ___

_ 7%€ /Ad£%d////J//JW§/pz/JQ//¢//m/ // law/g ,4 A/£,/ ¢//MA,W¢MM¢$ 4?,4//1/./5¢ 71 D/é/Z/c)‘ //(?,€£,. D/.-§%/z/c%&a/z/{y(/*'Z@/yg /£ fsz/j` /N/// ddt/75 /‘W %5/%}€¢€§05£/§@/@//<574€/0),¢ //1/&/ %/L§a /77,`¢/¢/ /¢5»_9¢/5 ¢/14 'W/,»//§-,¢/,;:£g§.$/§ % ¢¢f'/l/%,’ZL*£ »/éz/£ //£/CS /L'.//J/r/. wjsz /Z;/_ 50 r'/ /@¢/g %/://1/. § §,?.;7. 22/(/¢) [ l//;£- A///»/ /%Aj /¢/v@/ 97% »Q'?/Jé) /VM/¢w/JW/. /%U //¢%g /,€//¢/';W¢% @/g/,//% //L‘/%J////'/ 1511 /f/A//z/L’ /’5’0 _72'//1/¢ ma ,é//; ,% ,é¢;§%m/¢;,/ ,&2[/¢¢'//7//,¢}/ Ae($m/f/z,¢ @ #///`¢/j //MW//M/%/z/»é,é /Me/,{p//%zw@/%w¢/J //z//,<' &)¢,,g/¢ ¢,///jzyé%,/J_ ' _ 7%¢/¢¢%/€¢;¢ /z’/VM/¢%¢o %Wc/'a@¢wyw%/J/j¢/z///€//%¢”%O ¢W¢¢;M ~; 'é/Mz/M/gww //z/#MM>?/yw¢§/ d/Mz/%/¢%z%/J M/€ ”z/z/;MA/MZ/_Q ' /¢/@//c//z¢/Ma/_'///ij faw%z/%/._/¢<¢/ 76 [j,z%jg/z/A`z ,,//_V¢/,%e /}Mz¢-/£¢<W(M/¢/ ' [w»f<§///i/_v MA/gdw /W&M%///)/J/WM 3579/g m /6¢%&>’, 53 7¢5: /d. z@/saé, 50?/72/. die/m W /Wz/),' ¢ép 535 7&",)< »j‘? /j@/. _/€’ ,;?.3. a‘?, X/¢/A/L» P/'?O faa/4 .

-MM” W’W ?Z§W/?f?'c>’/$/Jz/AD Za;zz/¢j’ '

. 7%5 /W%W//é/¢`/”@?MM/}W//M/M 7401/z z//w/§A %g ¢g,%,z/E.fy A/ 7§)/, 5a W /;»’ 575 ¢’?/ ¢//¢/// /YEA//S¢Q;/% M/¢% 41 W//W/¢)`,é/Q,zg -JM/¢z~z/Azz ;l/,Wg /.7//75 5 "I/“<$` , [i€¢~°@// /;s //77£4!%//% /%'yg§ %¢7/%¢¢ /J ¢ZJ////Zf@/% %//Zz;[/@/§oq;/)f 颢£WJ¢Z/¢¢Woz//Q/%WG 4 /,:¢;zf/¢Z/¢¢;é ,é@/g¢m€@d/¢éz,¢m//é/J ,§MM/¢,§ /,/,,45 E/MWMZz»//W,z/J/W%/M/w/§/MMA< %:M¢»A/¢M,@z¢< M¢W//£ pM//zw/WA/Mwe/M¢/$MM¢A/M//W@/¢¢/£//%c//Wya?/;Mw/ ¢.¢///%%, 7%§ dM/w/z/J¢//M£E/i//gw%/M/%@és. EX'/Qi,m% WJ>%//VJ, /7¢;; J; m 5@/ z§’/Z?, é?»?/ [?L`% //é/w' %/W ¢'?wéj,'§é¢' ///<SO EX//z»zz.‘c=' ?ZZM/&)/¢/, ¢?73 §. w.' 3<9//?;§ /Z'F/v. 3, _ 4/'/@’ ’%5 W»é/?%’Wh@/¢//MMM¢§, )%¢’ &/6¢///€0/1/¢¢//1/£5/%¢'¢1/% Z@/¢//,éJ/§ yard 7%¢ M/%A//M?%W/MA/%¢ ¢Wz¢d/¢¢/M A/¢//w 1950 72///¢'. /"/W 5/££ /¢///€/FEFZ/§éi F&’E///J% L’m/J/O£/j’£¢; §’¢£z/%z, ,&§W¢ZM/Q/jv /é¢(';wz¢% JA/Q¢<z/j 7%¢/ i¢ér/M/¢»/w%@_é@/ Mf’~?éz¢/¢/JW/% Mg///M/M ,élédz/ag/mw/ A/aA/€,@/w 741/ue %p ;%¢' /M/u/¢/M/ /p¢///, ¢67,%//<17 j%Ay/¢,e;s /w////")¢ M ' f/LU¢/?/§WEM ,4/@#¢/¢/6/.4 L’E¢////M/€£L¢¢/ %/rj 7%¢'@!7/5’¢%0/1//0//% 7{//7/ A/;/@///z/ W//€S ////z'¢/e' éy %¢’ zm///A)¢//y ia¢/£;é ?¢¢AY/A/z wymz,l /z/)t‘/j/ ¢n/@/ *¢A§ ',ec¢l/c<///l//ui/MAL< /J ¢C/z/%%/¢/G//A/z/J £:/1/7¢/¢¢’§. l - ZL¢§/¢¢ZMA/// c)”z/j/W/#%/ ` ' €Eiz/F/zjffdr ézzfzz//cg

j/J/;%¢ z,/M m Wm: 241 jeang ¢W/,/§ .,z/,W ,zM///V@/ fd/€/ZL"~¢/ EW d/>f%é’/§/Z£;J/\/Yj /%//f/¢w,%é 4/,€//0//%/:/@/)¢)72¢4,; ;JA§/:e// /M///w )%6%/ 51 /%1// /a#»yf/¢¢;y,¢/@/M/ ¢é/€ /%%¢/W /Jgp/MA/% gaéf ' , /947€ 544/15 _%/¢/@@/,¢ %éé/ ¢/w¢/»/J/M /M/Q/ y/{%//W//M( %y/M»[; /V.I`/ 541 /@7¢)"££ %w/_M/, 729/v 7£ 7// Dé%/M l/ZM/ 541/d 47¢//,'¢/4¢¢//§ fM/j ,DW/¢/ z/¢¢/¢é /£’/ f. [éa¢/M¢z¢¢%, ,€/¢/, 505 5¢¢7¢///‘/,' _'7¢€\///25' 75/;515~ DW/;%¢ @JM§{/ff@'/;§ .. g§*/W//Mz /Q/<W,¢»;¢/JM¢ /'// 5 fam/§A€¢W€ ,@¢/,' 503 LFE; W/z/, 725,¥)%5 759/615- ' ///zw-¢/.' @~

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.