V. IW S\cV oK \okP^> / A^^

* * * * 4 /MOTvoo for KcWj^-cx^ * * * 4 X-

Pro 5e RECEIVED IN COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS FILED IN SEP 01 2015 COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS SEP 11 2015 Abel Acosta, Cleft Abel Acosta, Clerk P 0-0^1-15"

"^^ G\e^ \>W^ ApM^V V.

"^ 5\e.V 0K To^ Appeal t c * * * st * * * * * * 5

RECEIVED IN COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS Q SEP 01 2015 ° Abel Acosta, Cleft I

^<N^ \W\ Art \ v

^^ a* ^ix oX\ttTcc-9 ua^ ^ ",ouw 0uc IM \w WWW Ce^% 0^ A?9c4t> erc ^^ -v ^-Aed *o Vwv& ^Vw^v ^ ^ v v DA Ave fa,.jc Vce,v\\Vx CsxiA- A A^clp-X.^ <?xr i/jW^ A CxA^d A A.A \\A Vve \v\rJ\ cooA AA. vxtA &Xx^e AX AvxGxeA\/yx v>q ivv\prOv>er\o^ CA^AAvxO^ e.v'.Aeir^ rA exW-^ftOvfS tr-Ac-_w,e,3 V\ ^OixVXKvv^ PwxtxL \>r\ \\ojwV cA lAuv-nAcXA v/. SVA-t. cx*\A evAc-nxce- a-C exXt^cxjNjs OXVc.w-*l VwA Ps^pcAXc^A lOc,s wevfr Cx,w\c\eA cA Ax. Ucx\A cA rv\ucAaAc v. 5VAc 1 A . qc^25-^A

Cx/,ckxACX..AVnOc.v/€..,- U>W, uje. Wk c^ \cAc Av Arur,AAA ^/AAxXe oaA^-^ xx,-^ o^vc^ c:^\n,on -W Xwc. A^Ac^ Cc-uA- cA (\{y^toX^,SA^ Wx CUfc<-\ excwN\vNcA XW Wy^Wwc WA=vL^ c^wd Ax\e<xV Vj>e\xvvA le^xbAVove AA x'yjV ^AwA A- ^bXul. XX\cAa>Ac<AcA cA-Wx^eS, Av-x vb\^3u.jAX v. 5\Ac \W ^O^A-A, courV c^A^AeA \WA "VVvG XvXcA CXou^V (L«-e.(V AvK\y'xC^ 'pUV\\.t>\Vv-^M? vA \XV\CXx^ Vxy cA:*AXVv-*\C\ evj AevNce. o\ uvxe.d^uAvc.xAciA c£\^ o\- h^sodMoA- c.yx\ c<^vyj*v\e<( V^ Ccube, £,.<.- c. -SML.V.O Ifio-vNN^wv^vA Wc--^-^ UvAo- AAicAe ^W^^CW) rvxovcx p^^uxwe.. bccAvbc XV W^^ovwLj^s e.v-A cjw<^ pAerA An C\\\ ^o^-^ovxS cA \W £>\£W c^A, \-WtcW- oAo^^d -A^ ru^A "^ CAo^AXA a SAAl Co,xA cx^X\Av A \W*e* ^\oc\lojcX\ v/. 5VAc AXr>p. io OxA, mo 'gv& 3.La aA IBM , l^xAV, L^^x^eAA e^A Xb\xc\CcoeX\ A>^\vxd Ww rA<^ (AlS^ SVAe^ U^uAcAt cx.^x ^9ecA^ c^A-b oX xvx^COYNducA uoe^ ymA OvcA^^^cAA^ A^ Se^V^^v-xC) V^'V^se ot ex YNr^-^p>\VA V^S- Vaf^^ A^vx„ \clk<x- CC.^.cA ?>Tb7(^(0, 37-011 fO.

C^vAc-lucV coc^ \vxcAv-ASSAckL. g-V -^^. AA-wxSO^ nors - CcO\Va\ ^^^ J^W\^V —^W^.o^. \W oAc^A (A^,ws Ax. \X\\gcAAA V/'- 3toAc_ CA/AexxCj^x o-~ o^rx. XAcot^ViCXcA O-VXe-^'Xcx UJ'xX VxcA^x^xcAcAe \xx AW. AovxX:^"xVs^c^ pVv-b^ oK VW_ V? >Ax AA-a. fAXAx cxc-cjueA. on x.pQeA VWJr xve cr^xrA^xexA -\o \Wx> c^V x~uV,xxa vn-x w\urpW/^ AVAe 177 S.ux AA ^ (OxAc, App IH^A Vxl| Vxol^J CxVVowiXn-xC'^ AXxCX C^W\stf;>\CXX O'A- ^CxiAU (VyAVxc \\se„ OxxA AetLXv^ rc.\e\'e.A\ \o 5ex\-WxCA\£A uAciudX'vg ^XAXA^ vexW^x. o^A^s<^.. /W^ \w WwXWcX.-* AX AA AXX VA^xV »^XX^ tXentt cX (WjudiuAd' Ax A^_ Lode. ^ 'VA> X° W*X ^W V^ te\Xo^5 ^ ^ W <^ ^-X..cW c.X does wA orc„c(e VW'A •; ]«^'» ^X X \ . _ ^" ': _ ..1 . X, v K i ,, , . . V

w. A " "^ ^ ^ CA^ ^ ^x^. ,v^W X ^ i— ^-cX^9" cfes ^A v^^ w^y ^ aAA;;a AX XxoAVc\vw Coi><v <*~-~* fcUw^v x c.l X KioVeA s V <k\Vb C*A of ApAuTTl\ T"X 4- (j,^^,cAAAAA ^AvAx xAA^ AA ^^^* ^ u y^xxxxAA. xra^a aa^5cWc' XAX:^"W A^ A£" )w^,AW< «^-wv& °v^ uAoAuvq

A^ ^^vxA.ox c.,^ A^W<xA\xj aow. rTeW" fvV^c >>1roi^Vc^ e^v^V AuAvW \Ae4nA ^ ^ ^ tkcVvw \vn ^\X-XcA.va5;^S Ccsi V - . X l ^ j i, pbV<v^c ^^- ^^-^^x X^vAd Avx rviorpV^ 1/.. 5AA<l yCWsWdv. -Ax,e, Ijvc^^^u 1/. AVcAe., c,,xA ^o^cAocA v,..3\cAe, CA Ao0 oJf 4Xe PAXXiCLOvnAxA AAA c^c^cXpcA rv\\" - XoAwborN AA "ixeV cCboVV \v-\ a ^x\A Cov\v\cVv&'«a V^oV <x AvbxW^seA«, \A^3 i^^o 9^<Ac\ c-A^-AVeA CAxAexvce- SVc-uXA vxoX- Vxc^e. Xoee.vx 0\xrX>eArcA Xa Vw<l '^ua^AVvvv-^-^ >t<xv \ i v j \ , TV AKc ^oc^cxxx cA Acx.CAAe.Cxs-r-,-. Ago, Arx^o^-K, A7,07Ji(cA (VA^ovx Su^ >VAA2^ <x<b co<^A^ucA Xd^ (Aru^'cAcXd v. -SVAe IX^ Vo excAoAe. C\VX rcAvcsxceS -Vo xAWe^xccxjX A^e^Seb VWxY CxTc v-xAc \x*A\ Covxv/\cA\c.vx.S1 ILx ^umcicclC VA AVAe. TYve. CxwvX^I (X\J>\^ec\ CcurV vv^cac^Am, VndVWxc^ AoAXv^- CAvxC^tcA VWA v?;v>\Ae<xce ot UvxcA^AoAed QS^xsc!b lxcs V^p rope.c \u> oA*vAWA AvK\ v-xO, XAx^ ^U^XVxv^eAv- v^Wxbe oX \W_ AxAX AAXvynA AWx-V Axc. cAxixXv^XxOvx ex XAxc evj^(iej\ax v^ocXj txvx rAocxbct o\ cX\f2.CvcxV\Cx\ CxvxA cxe Ceoi^xcA ^C'XX VjCx-^c-vxA cx re Jbev>cAAe. <Aou\A AAA AxX evcosp wxcAe. vxo G~xA AVivA\c.*x. Xo AW -posN^Vxwxe^A- c&sA Ace A\x<A tcc^-N , ^^ ^odc\exw^\ Axx^ puYv^Axv^eyxX r^uiA be_ ^^ex-<becA A*, 5XcAcA \<^ XA^ns'nAA V- S\tAc Av\uydccXc y/AVcAe canxcX AVcxi\a-.ocvV x'.bXoAe (>Ar c.v\\cA<x XTO'ifex^ Ax&. JWvcA. (A^A A^xj^o^A^ c^MvAAcd CvAev.ee cA u^dAvidvCixXeA oA^r^S GVW-^' c^^v.xsV x-vw. AXxvxSon XAxAv VcsuAeA w-x VXO AvxeX c , <X^cxX XsXUf Vwise. cn-c. c -m--> e

C^V be =*^ V,e^,^ r^ «.^.Y^\e ^VA \VX X.lS Cru,r »*^ ^oU^.VuW Vo Vv yu^^Wv^A..^eXW ^ Complicwe

X XA°-,VAVWV ^W\*fcic«,A AX ^ £Cvt- JX &XXA" A^ V^«cj Xe wc ^, Vos-Wwc c,vAAxAAxA:-r A£AXdxc£ Av5^ v* xsv^^y UJr.oVd v,3\.-xVe. t,.-. 0—XXX \ \ AX"^ >'-wK'c-1'' OXuj,. UXWe^x ie\/vAe>f\y^L, ^tx^tS \x&Ave,. ^WVo AA^xXAvCxA^oxA AoAA Av.oA A- .lo^ xW. VbVtn^Asu^ LA-A AXA-A fc^^Akxx V^v XV LJ^ C>A^ \%/CA:vAA vX c ^eeWxc^ o'x UnaAcAa ) Ufx<30rt_., Vltrvc uj^A WA, 0«-x \o So^ W CX:,Xd AcA^ .

Yo Wi.w,m~^ y/i^ox\ prcAie^-^, On CvoSb"<iiccofv^ <x.cAx^x Pierre.

C^bxxcveA ^f>" taVxe^ cxsKM dce.b Ave. Vvxv*. AAAcoVV^ SccXv^ AVbWce... (So^yx tAA A) Wcx AVx^ ^xxAA A\xc S\eAe^cxA" .^xwtVwvcb bif wxc\^ vv-s;,SWVe-s rXcvvxAUv.eS Uie. 5ec Avvyjiocdy \ooA Xwul. So^Mu cWH CaAA X^e.. r^.\xvB tx. ^\sAlrr cA ^ T7 T , ^ 5\A^e,A- X Su^pexA Vw, <m VoA \WA ° X ^V ^-^'^PO^^^A) Lx\\AoA^daAV AxXd.vA

.XjA kAArc^v,A,X^X PrccAxc*. c^A Prc-ed^eb 5? A& *• 11 * l3i A c M °LCAX~C'X^ ^ Su^P^- Vo <A% cx9xrV WnCc^^\ _cxr\

x \u_^ \JcicuVVx \AxxcAA^\ Cc«bes XX^X ^- - \ i \

a..ddeA xXCL XA I ' > ^^X,eA. W KmcX ccXS ev vesAA^ A ^ T VA w^ c-te 'iV^^ ^^,X \o\CX Ao \w. XAA XXrt^r i\^t> e^y evidence°^-*t c*SV&je.d /wiWft \^A^\3s^le rXAb(eJ.f (AovAA Xxx. \Xncd Acx>A\xrvxo ^\vcSo ^-^ Cxx^rxv-^cA ^cc ^xxA cxixuccXcty Lo\tW»A cAoAAv WAX AXnCL \)CvOcAvAo;r \cAo^'x£x cAV XWx W^A^orxx-X.-v Avrx Wt CJXx- Uj^-b \^s Xc^cX >fv\<r *AAXyx^D*A DcC^O^<X 9"\<LX^C- xxex/c^ fXx^-o \VoE- X^AcAoe-^ Cxx\e^ Ac Ccor* (Supp R.\l cA n \Ax(X ^ccl^vxcAvcXcA c-WA uAd^AA cAVeAcA\o\x, UJVXcXx UJooXcl \AahM. \X\S \XCA*xA'X \-<£i AvJC, \AraC_e4>X ^Cr XWi„ Vc'\A. C_C<;.;A Xo XxcvYX dAx vAAc^xxu, \L AXcAe_ \X~01-Q0C>:bc5 -C^Z t 'AQG"k CoL aS7il 15" CTcy > to c^. V .) A Vo\- cjx^x,VwcAecX XAAAoev^A \Vjucvtr Vv^o: £><^xAcv\iXvx<A YxtiCxxvxC\ C€LvjcAxJeA c-jyext-A CXvx iJnA--\xx^eA Aa/^xAgaAov\ O.aAX^' ( V\v<v-x. £^. mufdtr PV^-s^vAA cx*b cxw. ^AA^xAun^n \& AW v^SA AvX CeocA aA A^rAx trv«XeA avA Cc ^\x.Wv«cA Wx£. cWx:,£- 0> vu'AuA\x<x.ca> VWOv \\x\x X^^NxX^vxeAwc^ ^^A clWacA A A dvAX^Vxo>o X^x C-^&icWwx^ VW o/i<Wxce. reaeAw AW,2_ \x-\urdei"* - J AWX Ccxe \b xxo AAAe^V VVxexx >fvAv. AcXxASeA ^ cA^c \y\ AAx A vs xA-^oAXA Xo ^Wx, V,5W^ (Ak^ AW. WA XoocX AuAcyx o^&e. VW :AA^_v-^x\ NV Ae &\& vrxA W<xvA Ao< Vroceed \^ VW ck^exAAexx rA Wxg OcWe^xeo^/x A AW £>WcL ^ °M^d v^^^<xpAv^^V<>xxcA W WXA ckx^c^W^. i HJ <^Du-se^ WA, d\bfSCVcA loWw We XAoo^AA Ac iiXWn _o VV<x aAe,xtx Wo^-. a,x UfxfA^-cyA / XaWy^A Xrx/<AX€^W A)^ ^n^c^eX^ cA^VSxv^ SAAXb AxXAA A< A&A>p £J? A 5^) ~Wx bro^W \x 5\cAc Xw c^^d CcxjA AXAncA^TW ewxve^ c^XwxxXVA Xvx WAV. lcocA ^A^^ C^^AX^cxXfx Xy\ OtVoxscX) ^ ^ ^^ V-^A ^^-X^- \.^. AeXcxX Ao Av^. AxA^A o^Vevxxc, Xvx Ac^A cA Ax Ax^^xd^ XA^udxx, ^W.LJtCA^A e^y bel^xrA c. Te^rvAAc cAuXA \WA \V«sl cAxen^ r^ AW Cvxd^c^ A^ W A,A CcurV AA ,xA CXxA,^,^ WVAe VXA^^ ^ Aec^c, yA \VxC_ AoA A ^CAS ^ Hu,^ OvnxcX \^ e\x< vCXxA VXrXV rx <v,-- V,~ .\A -- ^x X ,• x n (Vivp-A^c <• ^f l^^^ \«o AVeve. 'V^>0^x-V,:xf (cyAs ^v(- 6r^^^ yXA.Ae_ %H6. x.ux. Ad X^\ Acx .Cxi. '^ (A^) " , .Ao'aV e^ \„% (Ao^AAAX xv-A OAa^mj^ Avx WaA CourV aAuXtA AA cAsCx-^Acxx- CXxmA. \AoAxAeA. V\v. ^AV^'aAA tAc\WV$ W Ajsx ^><?-oce£>s V^a v^XAnxxIaWx^ cXi^^AA\rx^ cAtc^A\cxxX cxwd tX\Adtxr\OA ei^CAv-AX- Wx»v\ £>Ar, Aew-x^ CTxrApfxrAXA^ W AWe, CAW&Nxm/S ^cXAoec\ctS AacoxAxT A OxAd vacA Aaci ^cAw\e/vxcdl4 \^aVcvtcA Vrcv^ \v-ve evAcAcx^ce VwxV ^v\*-. AAx^<Acv» wA Ctx^x\xxA ^reApc^AAxX^ Ax- XV^y r.yW<x^aA YNx\<Ao^ducU •At xAx£- AiuvVctAX-. CA'vvX cA vxs^>e<xVb txv iA\txx A WXA \o XvA \vA Wxr.. W\<A AaAx^ dxA v-WA Cx^x^xcAeN- Avsja. «xx.cXcL>oxce. cX exXtcwecuS AXCcnSeS \*a ^iK«sK^ <x^^p\Xfc.vAe- V:-1ecxvj:-e. Vws. AAcy<x vxexer- ^xc-de, AXx.e ciecAXxC'x^v uWXw..r Xwr*-£- U-kXb AAAAOiAV <tX/id<5jrCe. ? —\\ _rxu<\mr'\e»A \\xe_ ^y^<ie\' CewfV C0.XXX XXV Wt^c \S <>o evidence '

ArX" X^ X ^°W ~^e ^d^*^ vV \W is"'

cyye_c:v cwX WVaAA AAA AA" XWe 'tWL ^^ ^ AVvejcc * ^wxyxCcv-nY uO<x<a ^A^xc^ o-vx cxjV^cX.

SuAm-^vnA /** \ A - - ,- .

AW n pe.VA*^e^ twA. r CxvulA t Wve A-evx WvxuxA-^A LovVVouV ^^ c-Yxvnc_A?»^ t A\ L U A AW^ ev/i^e«v"e ^m^y<A cW VVva. Qu^Ac- A-. coW-V\ ^ A, rfcx,cxxcA^ OossAAAu \w\ Ac e A<- v, r V cp r W~ -xx \ \ J t^vCXfcvxCX. Cc>v^A|cAv-xed o\ rV\vc^\\ V-x^ve CXcvxVvA^Aed Vr XW- C \ \ i I • ;V^'^^ v, ,AA AwASr'x A A^ fXAAev^ o.AAoc.ed oA v,.x^ U^.,A/XA^AAX"" Xf- ^•v^ Ca,,w \^,:;i Vfcr: ^t -^«^*^j* ^ Ac^ c, box \WA Avx^. rkvJrtl^\ ^^^^^ \V xCAXAd Ae Cc.xCl,da ^ ^ Vu^W^, AW ycccd c^vl ^AecA vCd \w C-V W\ (AWA -^^^-^ rdAerx^. cix/\cVe^e. rxAcWcc^i +^— 7, vAcAv^.s Xvx WA\. rrc x xt $ ^ o{~ teVv^CAy •Vo. Csupp At 7XA0 ' ^ " ' 'xv- ^^w-^ pW.d(sd cwAW/ VvxV\^xfi> \yx C_exCVx CLc-jbC- WeAcved A^x "CcccdeH-vx^AscxA ovx <Ar', AoAxxt>ov\ WA^\\r Aw-ppAAl cA \4X\A^ /W \o VV\e_ Av-^rW\:bS>cd eAsvoocxCLOUS C'A^exx.'be. CoAevxCXL. Aw, Cc-L>fV CCAAxrd X'orxAd r-«*C\eA 5 6 OjccaCA cA A^Aa^-aca-Cu W<Xavx VAecrtx (Xx-xcA VV^x AnxAcAv^WWxO^ cVeAeWwc^feup^, 2:XL fe cA VA-lO /UjivA'x VuoO CAAAn\a CxAnvxAXcA Xvx Awtx vX~C-Os~d* Oa <x Pexc&rvw^t e.c/Ae.,%0% cX vv^ w-^cm, iv.^oo^aA vv. t AX Xt ^ucsVvcks sXcXs<A WN \-Xcj5-x-\s, vA SVAc ,"5 UjK<Aw<- >W Ca/A*<vo*. C^-^^Ye^eA r,C fw\gW Vn^^^l Q,tA«.\Vm AeA X rXA* A A** Sk^ o.^yv^a,«A ok Va^ eX^o^ AAA "X X"a c^—^ A <^vsci *~ W xs oA TAX"" X'.AiXAAWWA W&U&" Ws ^^^ cVVeo.A — XW^ ApWcVed WAA.ttULL tWiAt W,,^V c,,^ A, ,. Wa x 'X- " cAfi^cA^ rrA:Wts. VX <x^a cc^^ <,^w aA XX X A"e •C"^ wt'^ «A A^ x <^*~< ^ AAxA^xAr AA"w ^x <* ^ HX"X ^ ^ •>- ^- ^ aXAAA At ^ ^ ^

oAAAAA ^ ^ ^ AV<A XXxy A Ws i,--^-x -AvAXaauxxxwx • VVrX -^- ^x^,v VXxe Av^W- LXopp eXA cA ACi^-AWCA) X ' .^WCAfie_ o^ \^-.- vfws ^nx,

^ ^ ; ^ \Ac-oVAV- x^ f v" WWa ^ LXW^t cA TSwCWoxX Ax OA^exA'A ^AxeA Onn We, Audc^e. KWcWxoa OV •AtxV^^^c^ A, iWxce xrxX b \j\ AexxxAx \o AeXex hn-x\^c.. u AxeWc- r- <5r HcV 'Wvl t^V-coc\to-oS exAc\t!X\C^ CxuAeA Wax-^x-Xl ^Qujexicrx- CA\^x^AA<xou Ub^'A Xxo\dW AiA^eAoW-CAxirXs AA^A<^ rxW AeVm^ W^Wa^ax cA etro, aa^^ A^ exc^^^ UoVvtAAc^c- XXvC^e ttx'b\SV Cjve<r coWdvx-XNxrvC^ CXvLde^oSL Vo X)uppc*rV de^oAcWvA oyudV. &Atb A^.Proc.^ £A.e %\ (bAdA JWx WVxcOxrv\<xvx V. CcA\ Wwxxcu Cv-xA \\ax-^vA» AX AVcAcL ~YW_ f\0£x>l CouXXs WeAdA LuW_xrx use. xaxWX ttrer Xv~, Vwl ^TOo^t^w^b OX AVxv^ CouAs be,W/ \W. e*vor \<a cex;ex-xAAe AAAexAf <^e^ <deW^vx^xYxevv\Ae(do^d a. re^ovxx.AoXxX AcAAv WAv Wxix e^rcr rvAcAe yao c^pAvAAxcn V, \W CAvw.cW^ o* V, V* O^sW" CAa^dwxc^a v . Cx.VvxXr^vxcx , SAG UA, I*, AH , A7 A. cA , ^aM /ft *?A , A |x:,u *A lo^r CubiV HurriS A 5AcA^. 7A0 S.LAi.ad qiL%A A/ A^x^ WvcA Arvx^vo^fcXuL cA^xAXed ev'vd.cj»-\cc vX> c\rx abybt 0\ Ax^orcVxox-x uAmcAx W c. Xew*sx\Ae exxoA cjexe A CAavxA be AcaA W^OrA e_ veA^vxwAtAe CXo,W\ XW Aw CJ^devvCi^ Cev-vOUvxc4 OX fvscA^. vr^ LX>xAvcXvAXxcxx W Vw, W *nxA A^>x. AoXA a-. AWx ^VXCaXLa VCAAWWd 0<AS<;S XX~\~A \ W.^ Ad^ \\ , AA xA ^ Vv • Vwx, -yx X- \ ^ W \Ac\AxOa AXxc OxoSC ^ ^ . Aov^ov, xA^AA W .ccve,s*A c^A x^c^xded, l r;Ar\x)A\rA-A ,iVb ^W^AAcaAVAXv^ ve-cxucW^k VVAx \W.b \3eVAc>A de,. qy<x>Aei CWl do TA^AWWs^ Ae<xW^c*j dekvA V,cseA o^> OA^Jxded. \\<L><WCAC\ cdvAC^AoAxCvAA -* =-> Aw n^tx VAAcWcxx \UU\CA\ovN ,-A o A V< V\x«~> ..VU, t-\C\Y\YS 1 I- Ao OWX VVoceSS oX Ww,WW AxXAYacyxV Wni.x U - ~' A xx x\o»-vj ^1,2* *XV_->.„ .x- v . "~

A^-^^x -Axjbv^-XVy<5\ _ x^^'*— l-'ro ^^ x.Avvvi,c;v, Xo\ bc^W,xA-o,l^Aoi»c 4c^Aon A7K 7 70 OX CAjcVx^oAe, Qx- f?eW\cc A Cex-\\\xjv Wx<A c Woe corsck Coct<lc\ Ccouy o£- AVx£^ HARRIS COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE JAIL Name: >^/AV<».^ OcvWAjg>e*\ SPN: CZfe6S >fr^ CeU;-7Ai - Qj S Street: ~?ot F>^~ A^xAo HOUSTON, TEXAS 77002 L>or\ App^l3 •P.O. b-x 1»0? /WW~1A '"7^7)1