Harris, Howard, Jr. v. State
Harris, Howard, Jr. v. State
Opinion
To the. court of cvuiavmm- &ppem.^ of Text*^ OP'CMM Al Wou)cxfd \WeVi»3c» PeVi-V\ o ^i€_r COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS V. MAR 03 2015 The. ^sVak 5-F Te*Q5 ft«sp&i\de'rv\ Abel Acosta, Clerk
PET\T\OKi FOR \Y\SC9vET\ONIVRN atMltw
C<kxc\ a? &W«a\*:- Cause No. \0-\V OG'bVb - Cft s ?co^ -VV\C $5*V. W\*\«c* Court of ^faxo-s Coutrrt^ •» TcxqS.
Fll, FR IN COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS MAR 03 2015 Abel Acosta, Clerk
bft&l MK=U0c\EuT W&WJ&fe 2>%°A 5*a^€ VW$ <V6
PRO SE.
TMV__. of content-b XkcW*. o? Av*\\\oc\Y\_s._ ____ _uH NAame*_> o9 Parses ; 5 ~AaVe.m_T\\ 9v^cxaf_v\c\^ Ofa\ &faum<e/\V. \d S^dta_rt\«.<v\ of -We. Cq^ o*\_K Procec)lu,fQ.\ \\\s\ck<^. 8>
THE. TEk\T\A COUUVT OF kPP&(\LS E^Efi M FlNftltoGr Ttt&T THE TR\kU CouQT fc\fc ^oT £tf_US_ ITS blSCaET\b?s- t ^ MbT k\_U>\jOm_r r>E.F£.ls.^E COUNSEL Tva CcmFRouT c_a <Ltt.oSV- ExAMiME WITNEY RE-sNa^KN-b XK\CO*.S\S~Kl<n" ST &TENA& KIT'S OR MEft\C(V- fttfc&NoMS IM VlO(_»XT\oKi VaMTH &UL_. ^3.\ lKU\TE ST M ES eaK-STlTUT\ON KK _N-T_M_,MTS 5"vX fcKifo FOVXSLTEEKi ,
Acc^vxrf\enH ut\c\ ft*_AW\^N€S. \\~\\o
I.
Prcvuytc \v>r \le\\eP Ce<-Y\V\e.aAe of CorvNpnaoCe.
C_^rV\Q\<iaW of Servnee ___
/^??£ts-^XX - Co^ o? A\\t fcp'xAM-fN f«A_\«xea W We.
a.
Tub EX OF ftUTAOfcVTNES
Loc\*_AiA\_A\0«\ i\cfN<^_vmer\^ Sv* a Ad Foa.rVe^A« \^- CrtXurfura V. U)asW\A<5^A> UH ^»CA. \V=>H \\ PomVtr \/. T«aaS > frS S»CA. \DU1S . \X be\eU)Q,«d. \J. Voon kcsdaW* \bVr> S>C*. \MT.\ « n Al&rd M'. U^Yed SVaYes* *bl S.C\. Silfc \H havA'S M. ftUsVUt <V4 SiCA. v\D«d \H <_ri\mof« V. Tav^Vw, Wl> -5,0.4, 2\U . \-& U<\\W\ SVcAeS V. NAaC\u(t , 54b F>3lA. (_>1b. _ \s (Ai\W V. 5W\o *bU S.U).T>di SO~b _ _ i*> Lop-t^ v. skk) \fc s;uj.'id aan ih Vta«\mer \f. SWWi 9,qu S.W.odSSS. m ^KeAY-u, V. sVcAe * %\<\ 5;u>.3ia 5HH \"i CarroV\ V. 5 WW i <\IU 5.U). ad H^H _ !— tt RscWdtSo* V. 5WW i THH S.vo Odi 0)5 . *5 TVU V • *b\*At * <\M "5.VU. aa \«&<\ ^ To\\**ur* NS. SWW* -4-. -s.U). -ba ?> . \l» ke.WsofN \l. S\a\e ) W S.vo.3i<_ 3^0- iU
T^tx. R. k?p. 9. Uo.^CcY <\ Tt*. O. ftpp.P. (oU2> CD . «\ Tcx.a.-fcpp. P. 44. a . __\Yau T<x ft. Ev^a \04faY 13 T*x. R. EvtcJl. vbML'oA ft T^* . (1. Evvd 4b\ . \3l Tcxc. ft. £v*a 4ot> ; ia T<x. VL Ev\a 4bM . __ \% Txx. ft, Evt-A 4\3l . : \* P-A_\\ca\\OAS • tCetN(\\W fcrouta E.A-. &_-.<i M<_ CotWck _a E\Aa«A_«_ % £S et* 3fc-7A 7o\\a Uj.\\\\aor* S\ror\c^ ed % U)esA flA\_\\«_V\\n<} Co. 4*\\. ^a \°v^a
4.
V^KtAES bf PMkT\£.s
peV\V\OAer Su\>*mAs \\\<\\ AVvt &\\©\jO\i\^ a«. \r\Wei>WA. parties'. \-W>cvrd V\<xtT\S » Tc. Aopc\W\-TbC^-\t, Xr\tmW Karov Co<wYe PfosecuW fH TnoA Ekaa AssWiW Assv<Ao^\ 1-\s-Yc\<_A Attorney *iOO E. -LW^k -S-VceeA. SuvW ^\D Wu^ars% VexQS *V\<bO!> David 4\\\WtA Wfi^se Cou^s<l\ (\\ TfYoA SvxiV. SOS ^»rv^aA »Tow nnftoa.
Uon. Xt_. Lav^lev^ P?€^\d\Ac^ 3^Ad^e %^W \Y\s\nc* CockcV fVra-xos Co^xa\v^i T«.x<vs Am^ A. £*xaVs fetf^S^. Gx*v*<_A oa &9pe_A Sod Ecv&4 Z^W S-YceeA ^f^Y\i "T^XQ-S H^oS 3ess\cc\ Eseue SWWs AppeWaW Couas<l.\ As^i-Wry* ftteW\eA (\H0f0e4 50O E. aUk SW*i SujW 2>\0 \bfu^ , T<t*q 5 T*\ ho Z
5.
STkTEHEKXT REGMKbmfe oaM MifeOuA&^T
Pur*<a©.«v\ -U Tex. R. kpp. P. ^ s PeA's\\o<\ec ukuVcs DCa\ afOjUrtN^A^ ua\«s$ W< Co\x(\ V_e\veV€S -VW -A*c\ S\o<\a\ process \juou\c\ V>e s\c\c\\ ^Ica^W^ ©AcAed Wu Or\\^ QCQum^r\\.
lo.
TO THE COUJVT OF COAbMNkV. kPf>e,(M_S OF TEXKS \4bvjocvc& \WstN*- , 3"C.
P<«.-V\ V»oa«x
V.
TK< SWW of T<xqs
Pet\t\o^ Foa ftvseaET \o ^ mi\\ aE>j\Ew
Cuuu4 o? ftpp€a\-S* Cause Nio* \b- W- OOl>\"_. -ca > APPi rm\a^ Vke co*w«c\\oa \<\ eo.us.-c ki*. \a- 65 ana ~c&f - <bs ffofw -Vke. &S\Y\ V.i'-WxcA Cu^\ cP PtfrLos Co^vVv^ »T«.xq«s .
Tc> THE. VAoUoatXP-^E. TuftbES oF TWE. CouaT OF cavwwK-fci.
APPEAL'S -- Cocoes \-\ouo Hbujard VW(S*b » 3r ^ Pro Se \ a^d P\\cs 4-\\\*_> Pe.Ai4idA Vor h\sc^c\\OAarv^ ftexrieu; aod Xw -support of \\\s re_mes4 W CespecA&tU^ sWs -V\\* do^r\ Ar\v* Vu\\GLO\a^ J X STkTtttEKH oF TttE. CASE. At^ P&AiCEbVXftfcc UWTo&M
TK\S \ *> a P«AaV\0a Vuf -AxScfeAsOAatv^ («v\eu> cxUsvr^ xcom cxpp^AX ouO<s "Vwo £oua\s oP aa^faua\ed <_«*ua\ assuU c>P a ck\\d» ^€<3au<*€ \\\<. \^xcv^ fcuAci -Wvx-e \W €.Y\\\cor\C€.<rrveA4 pcs\<"c\0^ca^k aWtLaloc^ a pc\vK CoA\ncV\OA oP Qc^acavoAed sexuaA Qssu\A oP a cA\\\a * Pe\\^\cme_f Cecie^ea Ckr\ au.\ow\akc \\$c <>v\\*lt\Cc oa eack eomoA pufSUatNA T*xai> 9^>a\ Code A*<s. % U.4a.(c^(aY C<^\C\Y PeA\4\0Aer to as \ndicWdt oa \T\Qaa *\b * ao\& &>f €\>^\\s +WtV a\\eaed\^ occuxCed or\ DC aV^ouA (VxausV \ )£008, UpoA K\ii p\ea aP r\o\ c^u\\\v^ Ve> a \*<^\ * uvn Au^u^\ „li ab\^b (UR*_.-nY. Pe\vAionef uoQS A<\ea \r\ Wc &S\k foSsW\cA Couf\ oP ^caxoS CouitnW Tt.Xa^ loVVW Vke WorvofaWle 3. T_n La^\ tv^ p^€V\d\Ac^ . Oa (Va<^u<_\ a<\ ^i0\^ be uj^s Cc_AvAc\ed gP -Vwo CoanVs 0-P CXOC^aoaAed S«xUa\ Q5SuH bP a <_AvAd» Pe\\V\onec qave \\kvl\^ y\o\\'u_ ^P appeal oa ftu^u^r %\ i 3lb\^ QAd UJCV-S appc^rxW) Cfcu/\Se\ W ftpces€A\ W-yn o^ appeaA.
Tke. T^aVa CcaacA O^ &9$eftAs \t>$ued Ou^ UA^ub\\-ked (YN^A^OfCXAdUrvN op\i\\o/\ a?ft«W\^ peAvVu^tCS CoavacAvoa oa
t TV%e S\iv»\« VoWse o$ We C\«AS <Ueocd vuA\ Vac «$tr«/vc«l CR.
O^a Ak«. f>a*« au^ W . CO. P^ . TKd (UpocVffs <Wd uK\\ Y* <efcf«nc** ftR. a*cA *W \>&W«. ™kaY^ &\\u~-«J b^*V« pay. ™a.<AW. (.Wit ^*).
THE: TEt^TH Cqva^T OF NPP£M-S Efc^E^ tSS FuAftvrtG T\AKT THE TCUfcL CouviT C_\ft >^oT kCVovSE \TS ft\-Sc.tt&Tvov- \N_ ViViT MJLOVsvnts-b riEFEN\SE CcfcAW^Ev. Tb Cov\ FA-Usur oft CfcOS5~ §.x*na\Kill \Aj{We-_.^ RE&kQAVrtOi T*AGoi*S\'bTfcKYT STKYEME^XCS GO. WEQNlKL hv (XGNoVvS \Ki V \0i_ATl0ls- VsntH CUA*wE HI'X'j UK_\TEO STATES Co^^vTvATvoKi AMENfoNAEK-TS SxX AM ft FOuaTEEM.
RcqsoaS \\ir R«u\tuj * \. TW T^aVk CouxA oP App^cAs \\as deodea cl-a lfAp6cVcw\\ aue^Vxorv oP Vaco AkaA (LgaVVcAs unAb ^u^c-emc.
CtiuA CvjAxacv £_a AW Same \ssue . v\. S. C«\iA. Pr**\ds Six a Ad FbcxcA««*n \ Ccaio&fd V. vAJa-sWaW, \3M S.C*. I'iSM'i Te*.£.
Evxd. 4W. Too ft. App. P, U*,'b Cc).
2> Th* "WAb CoucA oP bpp&d^ ka^> decided an trwpoAaAA auesAio* of Wvo VkaA corvPbcA^ ujvVV» T«x. (I.
Evxd 4o\ i mD'b OAd HgvA. T<*. tL ko^.P, Uo/bCcY '5? TKe ded-Sxo^s oP ^W TenAV CgiaA oP ftweeds requires re\neio Wccuai>«. Abe CouA o£ ftpp««.U Vxa^ s& Pqj- depcuWd G"a^ Ak« dceepWd ar\c)i u^uc\ Cou<Se oP \ud\c\eA proceedxa^ as k CaU &r on <e*eccvse oP \W Ccxxrt oP Cc'wa\a<\\ App£a\s pao-v oP ^uftr^sw. "Wx. £•PiOO-P. COCP).
ST&TEHEUT OF FKCTS VWcr\s* At\a\ Cou<\seA > pc\o( W AW coor\CA«Lnc«_meAA cP AW Ar\a\ aAd ouWxde Abe presence of vW \vx<\\ •» souakA Au> tivWo'duce euU«ACfi>a^e.f Texa«* \LuAe oP ^\>\d<AGe. *A\.n 4kaA Abe Cocr\a\cuACLC\\ bad akaAaed Wr repocAed SexucA VmsWv^ W Wr pk\^.icioA a u»ee\c aP\tr \A u>as cixscoueted AkaA ArW vU)rr\p\a\<\aaA uias diaanosedi ujvVb £.k\aw\\xd\a aA W.r C-.A<NxAa\ LjaccAaAS v\s\A \r\ 3.0\\. OrvW af\tr Ak\s ?\'<\d\A^ ekxeA sW make a^ ou\at^ aa)a\os\ Waxcxs . CfcM'iiSoY Tke 5Aa\e ret-poAded AbaA sucb e.\jxd<ACe. ujqs moce pf€^wd\cxa\ AWxn proWV\ve \Ar\d^<- Texas ^.vAe b^ bi_^ce WW HttACk^c-Ad AkaA AW SWW WUtved AWA AW pro^esV^O^ ujouAd \<<x& \o sWuo Aba\ AW Gam p\a\ <noaA uxxs ^oa,. TW ^>\aW beAxex/ed AhaA AW me.d\<La\ dxQ<iY\oSis Op AW CoorNp\cvAr\<x<\A a«\d \Wcxs b)DxA\<d Vye rr\\s\eadx«x^ because AkexA, Wd Ob oPP^r ©P pfooP AbcvA nauxs wo as e\j«x (d\ctar\osecV _uxAb CVAa-\x^d\a ^ WA \A\ Q?cA Worths luQS _Axaat\o_ed \a £00^* vapoo CeAease Proa% AW Toas DtparAc(\«AA op Cr\«\\na-\ 3wsAxce •> t»P Wv>va<^ <^c\\W\ Wxpes H ujbvdk AW\C \S t\o CU(€_.
TW ArvaA aevjLfA <±«.(\\ed AW deAWse. eou/\seAvs re- QuesA Ao cy_, irvW GlAvj^ oP Abe -stxuaX brisWu sWWmeAAs made bv^ AW CucApWcNar\\ x oc AW cA«P?Ada<\A as Pc^c as cxax^ sexuaUv^ WaASmxAAed duceases uj^/e. <Lor\cut\eA. TW Wvo\ CburV CorNcAudied AkaA AW preS^ce oP AW StVs does t\o\ +^ac\ "W sWo AkoA AW se*ua\ qssu\A <dcd or cAcd c\o\ Occur. 4W«.&r« aqV reWxibiAA, TW Arxa\ cducA &<& a\\i*o Cdua^\ W m«\Ce a VwU . C\ia^, U-\4^. Tkus > AW ^virv^ \0.
LOa^ deA\ed AW u\>\\W^ Vo Wax Abe proPP«.red e\>{deA.ee catyA ^Udae AW boeVaV\V Ctf\d Cred'xkxVxAwj oP AW unWessr ArauraeAAs Rt\d &\xAborxA\es
AppeV\aA\ acojuved AbaV AW \v?sa\ CbucA akused \\s d\^ete-\xoA V_xj^ r\u\ aWbu/xaOj AW \^cvj^ V» Wat eMd^Ace oP Cc-<\P\\eAxoq ^WWm^/xAs tv\ade V>u^ AW Comp\aXAaj\A 6c AW rrx^cbccA e\;\derxC<_ oP eoaPbeWa, <_Axaax\GSxs oP Yw^kVv^ coa- A-caeAabW sexuaWu VoAStWAAed diseases. Tbe T«/\Vk (WcA oP (Appeals cxjAed uoVVb AW SAaAe \W\ 4W Co«\p\a\Aat\s i<\e\or\sxsW(v\ sW\erAtA\s akuuA \\ix seXucA paxWers xs agA ev\d«Ace oP uSpeevP\c xasAoaccs" e>P Sexxxd Wba\no< A-WA U)Ou\g\ \mp\\eaAe UxjAe 4\c. (XAd VYweouer WeaAAse AW com- p\a\Aa<\A cAxd r\oA -Ws-kPv^ aWuA V^r WsW^ i St> AW pc\or trv_c_r>sxsAcurv\ "sWAem^As: UjouAd t\o\ W admxSsikW u_Ade*- ftuAe LV2>.
Pr\Of Ao Ake CorA^WxAacvVs diiaaAosxs oP Vxavncx^ CWa~ mud\a \a 3LbV\ x SW WiAWr rwxcse pcacAvWAer AWA sW Wd AWee (^ SexvjvaX pacAaecs > \c\dud\aa, o(\eCP\ xa AW pasA 'SvX fC\ rrxaaAVs* "5W a\sb sWAed VVxaA uoac oP* ber parAners V\ad ev^f beeA xtscacc^raAed. XA tuas a vaj <i«Ac \aA-ex AW\ sW xajqs W\d AWA sW Wd coAbacAed Ck\amudCcj . Tbe CjDjyxPWxaoaA AbeA cA\c\Aaed ber sVaAe/rv- ^aA-S j -sWVxao, AWV sW oa\^ bad Wd (^ S«xu^\ par4rv€r5 Cx^dx YNd^e Co^ \a AW pa-bA six mooAbs, Ak<^\ IlAp\^eaAed appearsA Por acAs uoWcb aWe^edVv^ oeco,red \n \k -lob 2 s ujbo Wad We<-> mcaccera\ed • \b^ Ab\s akaAo^e. ia AW CofAp\a'\Aar\Axs sAaA«<Ae<\\ > \A uoouAd WdWaW AbaA SW kad keen WcWxa^ AW CkVarAu^dxa Wc a\ <vxbs\ AkceeCV* v^ears \ LubxcLb xjo^aA xjiAAuAxced bv^ Wr or a^^ medicctl exaorVmaAioA^ pr\or Vo ^LbV\ . Tk*\s oAoa*. CouAd W a ceasoA W> cbaAcye ktr re$ofA*d WsAvkva^ Ao <5\xrcMAaA< AW SexuaA fpa/ArAer Absa\ sbe a\a\ra«A \i\ Wt P\rV\ sAaAej^tAV . TW ^U(v^ ioas "er\A\Atad V*» \\€ar ar\di e\/aWaAe AW uKv^Kt ano\ credik\\\vv^ o9 Ake exjid-ence arxd AW CGA\pW\c\aA4. Ua\*xA\a a 9 AW Texas fcuW of Euxderxce p^rm\As -specvPxc \AstaAces o$ ax^ aUeaed uvcAimS pas* -5eXxAa\ Wkaxjvor xPvAxS eoxd^ce AWA reAaVes W VW rY\oY\\K or kx'as oP AW oAW^ed vi'cAim.
T*x.fc. fcv/Jd 4uCkYaYcY PP\o<e(_xj^r , \ir\&*t tt^Ae 4U(V* (aVtY^ ^ at> boeA\ as T^x. R.EvAd 4v>\ x^o'b oag\ ^^m , Abe propos-ed evj\d€nce \S admxssiWe. Pb( AW A<wV Cuu(A x\o\ W (xWouj dross- ^xarAxr\aA\OA o? AW orA^ uMWesses \acoo- SxsAoaA ^AaAerAeAAs , cxacJI A-W coaP\\cA\a^ rwedvcoA dxaaAa- ^s, <ljP Ake CompAaxAaAA and Abe dePervdan* »\)\o\aWs AW deP^AduAAs Co^sA*v\uAvof\a\ rvakAs a^araAWd kv^ AW SitAk Ga.cA FourAe-ervVb (ArA««r\dorxMAs.
The 5vxAb A^A«AdrA€AV QUxacaAWs AW xrxcpaV oP q Ccxmxr\a\ c\tP*\<daAV k» W Coa\Voa\€cJ1 tu\\k -VW \Aj\Ao-ess-es Q^aio^ WrA» US CumnsA. (AiA42Ad 1H . Tb\s txaW \> made GbV^o-W^ 6a AW txVaAes bu AW PourA^vsAb ftfr\«r\dir\av.K ft\(\W\/.Ttx«xi 'Mju u.5.4uoi 4b^. %^ s.a. \ofeV.\oiofc* v* Lea.ad <m(Wb6Y uJbe/t 4W ^xeAuded «\j\dence \s ^bU^W dud-no, clcoss- ^xac^AaAioA i AW CocN^riiAAaA\bA C\ausi of Arta O^kd 5A<*W) \3l.
CoasAxAuAxuA \S ioi\p\ieaA'ed . U.S,Cck\S\. ArA<Ad "3EL *> CravoA\>cd V. NWasWrx^AoA v SH\ VA. S. "Sb, , s<\ nA \Z>\ S,CA> \3>S4 x V5fc UEd. ad lV\ (^bb4A j \Y»\e\oa<e M. \laA KrSdaW » HTS xVS, UTV, LTIfc , \bb> SiCA, \47*W \v\?M-« , fe«\ L.ed.aa IdM C\<\W>. EtcoCs oP Abxs SorA oa-e Sub^eeA Ao a Vkaftn OAcAu^sxSt OAd taust be reversed urAess AW Court P\«\ds> k^ood a Ceaso(\ab\e ciaibA AWA AW error dxd r\oA c&cnYx-xWW V* Abe c&a\>xcA\oa or puAxskm^AA» See Tex. R. vXpp. P. 44»a CqYa SWAk^ V. SAota &\<\ S.vd.^d 544,541 CTex. Ou^ft*^. \<\<*\Y TWfe or* AWee rrYx\n purposes aP cross- exarA\aqA\oa% CO Ao sked \\<$s\ oa AW credxkvUAvj^ oP AW dUecA AesVxmo(v^\ Ci* Vu £A\c\A addxA\oAa\ PacAs r;c\aA<d Vo AboSd WouabA ouA on <dxreed\ ^d (^ \i\ SA^AteS &A\oujxa^ Abe uu>\de opW \Tu\e .
A« W'xaOj ouA add\A-\DAd\ mcAs AWA AeAd W \Wvxm\AaA-e aav^ \ssue \a Ake case , See V.e<v>xAb \orovOA E.A. (W_^ V\e Cottmck.
Orx Evxd-tACe ^ a^ a\ ^k-s^k ( 3oW Vjo\\\\am SWaa, ed>, bJesA fUkUsWvAO, Co. 4Ak ed, V\<taY See a\so Gxx-<a\\ V SW\e> <\\L Saju. ad 4<\Mx ^^^ CT«lx.CaA«x.&99. \<VU,Y RuYe \b4 O^s/eS AW VcsaA CourA CQAS\de*-ab\e. dxsc^AxOA \r\ _AeWrt\\A\AOj Abe adxx\xs€\kxN\As^ gP ^.xxdeACc. T*x. R. %v>xc\ \b4CaY ftuA U does r\cyP VxcaxA AW C"xa\\A oP a pacAv^ At) \A\foduee be Q>ce AW \utUj evid^ACd Ce\evcL<v\ Vo U)e\'akA e>r _Lved\krtiA\y \d, \o4(eY XA &\W>s AWA wWce Abe purpose bP CCosS~eXa<r\XAaYxoA \S A° sWd Axc^W o*\ Abe OueAabV or CAediVxYxAv^ o9 AW \es\xrx\bAu c^xie/v oy> dxTeeAiAke A-rVaV Cfc>u\rt*s o\\scre,ArxoA \s more aAAeAx_\aAed'» a deP^vdatxA SWuXd Wv/e an oppot A^a\-Av^ V* bfxcxa^ ouA PacAs uobCcb OoouAd At-Ad W cdv-scredxA a VjjvWeSs bv^ s Waring kis A^sAxmoAL^ uoas laaAcuc oc bxa^ed. See \a.*> AxPord V. UAiAed SAaAes » a^a u.s, u^i x\o*\% » s\ sca. a.\<&» a\a ^ ns L.EdL (o3m. Cm'MY Cross- examVoQAxofN &< AWs purpose, is ' uWax^s fe\ex;aoA as dxseredx-Vvrxa^ AW bjiAness acxd aPPeaAxAOj Abe ujexabA D? Vv\s AesVxcAOA^." See ftavxs V. Alaska x 4\S U.S. Zo% x \\\o x 3H S.CA. U0S , \Uo > V\ L.£d.3d VA1 (\S14Y XrN s^ua\ qssu\^ cases » u AW dredxbxAxAx^ oP boAk Ake eorAp\a\rNQA\ o,Aa dePeAdat\\ xs a Ce^AraN \ oPA*> dus~ pos\A\xje > \ssue.11 Tbe Couc\ oP CcxcaCacA ftppeaU Ws W\d AW\ tl Ake $.u\es oP Euxderxce i especvedAv^ RAvXe HoVi sWud d ke used spacWaW Av> exckxde ce\«evaAA x oAWr- Ooxse adoA\<s.sik\e evxdtAce AWA m\akA War kx$oc\ AW credikxlUv^ oP exVber Abe dePeAdaaV or CorApAavAcuvA \a SvjlcAn c ke Sa/xd n sW saxd* cases." \Aam«x^ v. SA^Ae, aAb Sbj. ^xd ^SS * aoo. Tex. cVv<a. App. Lexxs svSxS\v©> fTex, CrW App. aooo?) CcxA-\n^ *,cjk Lopex. ^ \t> S.u3. ^d aA ^TH (keAVer* "3v CoAcurrmc^Y ao-Vxao^ ArbaA u>k\\e credihiU-tv^ \S txo moce vrnporVaAY Irx SCx oPPe^sc Cases AWa gAW Cases x xA M\s more Ukeb^ k> W AW oa\m> PacAo* \a sex: Cases AkaA \\ \s \a gAWt Vv^pes oP CQses !' \a wkcV uone C<xr\ expeeA cocroWraAm^ e,vxd*ACe"> \Ws AW Rx^Ae 4ba WWacxao, approack \_oouAd mosA oPAen r«r\der tvldeAce CXdrY\issSb\e I a sucb Cases. TW CoucV oP Cr\m\rxa\ Appea\s Ws a\so W\d AbaA a Ake Texas Uu\«s gP ELvxdeAC« pecmxA +ke dePeAdaA^ Ao cross-excvrvNXAe a \4.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.