Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Allen, William Andrew

Allen, William Andrew
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided March 2, 2015

Allen, William Andrew

Opinion

101 |UO v§gl%q:qo¢\-H ' LIZIL'§IL'LI/LE,L/(p , . _ 4 wm q - é<@@¢\€ Q\\b.~ O§£Q-/Zq 749 6 "' I/l[ 7'/~/§ '7'£/\'»45` C,QM&`.`~ 8 §§ ov'oq»/aqsé= 8 § \/ 5 by CR';“m-» h w ( Qpp<slals j n 5%*& g @g»dcr-/zq')<¢ Q.- ‘ /T v l . f__ _ ‘ l . v _, " gm @g.gq ,<c.@é¢, Qw,+.¢\ Tw$ RE@EMED m §§ couRT oF cR\M\NAL APPEALS Bg»oq»;a<?w'b ~` o'-$;`»cy<:-)qu'(o$, t v l ` MAR 0220‘\5 § "Té Thé; Ll<» k ' ' b waak|é.,. QleLl< /~\L>s`\ AQ®S‘LA‘ Abe% osta,Clem 4 /‘/ou> Q@”Wl€/S ))L‘)",H`,M Axoqaw Q')\~Q/'\ j 2=6 6715$_..76 /.p\z OSM&L+ 63 C\QT/mr\`¢\]' A@Pg,q|g @@é,gn y 6"%\02»\» I? 3014 j S¢/,,¢ werf' ~ »' d o€»c>€-lz.¢i‘€¢v@_ 75 fha /{§B/@;$J»<i<f difng §:F§/j',%g:j£ ’L)S"w飑;¢a n"‘¢! cQM/JA'K<B¢<D’B /|}lL'/b;§‘;£"€}’ Q-¥JGM¢¢J, /»h\c}\ W\E, '6§7”"'_5;‘5’[”"¢’ a‘wMLf %)50§,//;\"$ /DA]Y& Fel)ueA@»"j \Q) 41fo '17\;¢ \-1/)5 N¢‘{ rB£z,/~I `_D¢sn&. DA/ £'»[ 7 paul _F ‘Qgg'£)éc¢° il GA.€J<Q:'>," ‘~/0'4 Séqrrf'”b ,/D\°/+ ‘§j<m ,l//) @C"éio.c¢.a //})z AW/;<Q }13-~ £,,Q //_@7 w€'»f §§ F/@béas Qee@&€. //<m/ G¢m¢+ /\/d. py»o?»/z.<i%g W,¢,,,¢,J¢ 0§'0()°"/2 ?Yéés l<)e*?€’-Zs’<,~i¢z‘?.¢¢¢f{; w.e 79"35?¢*9<,€, %M /.//Vlw, //g,,yg,<, . fé€é?~vs¢@ A mw€@ flow ~/v)z 553 @,z/z/C/ d@wé, g;/ . \/¢Q)/A//é~\ a§`/l;€m Q@c?a'~'@§»@p:vaA/| %Qbaécp»/,ee 1107 52’6,‘5‘“ 5@®` //775 Q/Ze' @<§\/SK"DFD,§S/§e/c/ deu/JL Ld¢}//é£ u//HLV“/”j /}/56 jan U,a/»,l',é§- §§ //.z>') .§JW~BA. md _§%/};r,\ 3,@, %.3 LU`)Z'{ }//J§ /,/zaz/z &z»,/ <féew.mof,r/ 76 %z /€€F"D§sfe/G-/ C@L¢ du /.l%z_ qu\u¢o,-\M_\ Qj$%,@+,, 3d g/s@ '%z_ Q<mw_cj"' , &)cm,+ }-LAS /)/0`!' 56¢/1/ @< 6?€<’3 z<Q cm "(-hw( F»zsqz<s 0§»)_§:;?($, A\S<SI_T'/n'\)ié\@\`c"\ 6¢§ 1107 §e,<',~ho~\ é, W/aea w#$ n/<<,.')é/&. 4 'I'/£A'K:v~#`.` m 'j}\Z§‘L 'FSSM`Z'S. §§ Mz \.(1»¢6/$,¢, 506le O@'n@)'lé,{ , Q-@»‘£-" HA"S /\/c"f` 555/d Wh’é .¢UA‘;`/S }/.d_”)_ Jqé€$;z Am,qg,$ )/esskm» /Jlsq 711 \)m|/»‘(.o'- §§ 1107 gzaj.;m 7, HW\,QML;P v),/4\"‘5 /'\(<>TQ£' U£.`C( ANSwé-L_ ¢s-v\ OF>OQ-/Z‘?‘?é 5 »- g€~cq-/a<;s;¢g de Als<> a mmi 6§ ¢{/al@ms ¢.s //,<)7. @F.@€¢/z§\?q,a » a§~a>q~/[email protected] M <@ wm’ d ~ ¢/@éw§ Q@Wu$ ,~/¢'7 g>@%/ZWQ> h@$r'<$q`/Z?$(o’l)¢ %/'é. dewa ada @Z/m/,§A"/ /QWW€A.Z§_ /'7€}5 /Ln//¢’J AW|T@ALA- iz<i`€é>b H§ //m,O@»W/,,;,,C&_ 7,,5 bdng was/744 Camof)l§mcz. wL¢/n ’h( was /I’)¢)F/ 72 /Ma /§§F\/D',dz/'cl' flaw/nl QI€/-\I¢ QQ)HU <~)-<§’ Q'pwmh.~,( AW¢A(§ |\/¢»s NA')L FEQSMFQQ ,C\ /\$#»wé/z< ` /FS”FK/D,~'s//z/'C/ @@am/ W/;ca`/}`¢rr\ ZF?~OQ~/Z'??G¢ "0$""(5¢'/2$8”§& §’L pr)/`qul'c-¢~ SS"“€SQ’/§’)(<)C'~5€'~6§;»/2<2§`6€, /§1§ , 555 HU,/:S` ///»Qyz /)/6/ éw»», W,QSSM\'?%¢/ 70 %z /5’$’/°? /D;ls'/z/"c @ng,]l': ' ` 'F?”§@/ 660<;~/2€?7¢>¢ %@Z'»@q~zzq’%£ ..@Q»@°¢~/z<z?<»€ ~' 0§10?-/;¢)§4,<:. ©‘E'o¢?~/Z<?T<@T' ~ 9§»<3<?~/2,<§7@®\ . loaf Qpp\'_,w~l.z~\ @€»OQ~/zq‘)e»’)> 559?'09’~/2$’€<,®€ 1313 ,./a/ A,‘i¢¢~\ AS)?LU¢,< aj 67 »£/."/7€/<- KD/MSA@/é/ §'/;%¢”’5‘/ 766 %6 /§S*'¢`.

”D;-'$f¢,‘¢,t' Gmm'- 'H< w¢z/'@OF’ »//»/Lmz QQ¢»-@ws //'.<)7. %za.@</¢¢:Z mg A/é,»~d ¢§<)/c/Mc,<. 'Yf?/+`\',§o!’ M"'D<e€é-mbé,z_ ,QQ~ Ml¢, Wns s §Jic?mc.; gang //@4‘ lg£é@¢<,/?)z.@d 57 d¢§w@@ml `\M\J,’j ¢§?>Clo£)é//a ’7 90»4 314 /_1712. szh§"h.sp.qd mwc+ aFC£m/A~l ;§w.l°{'¢m S"'\_Féb 94 361‘\~7 33 101//»/'57,/\ Meé¢d Q}/¢»r\ ie`(:`réuzd /\/@/;C£ 720/v M.g dowd @¢f’é.¢z;'m,)~r{v ///rs ¢€é¢/;a£~,`j rml 1157 toan op )_M,E% ` CBLP*SAT\DO I-l'#§ @)£é.s;aynl’£au /f)|z/m 73 \77\£ debt/bly W‘|r$ 775 % l/"O’#‘l'w §§ v\/<€!»11¢>1\ Qm '*l’€wrs @@J¢&@@elm»`;wl F@Q¢Cl-Mz »4#/"¢/@ /`/~67 3~6. 3.<’. md 345 32 ¥7>1@~¢ wm'f 2?»0¢#/2¢;7@ _7%/2°‘..’8¢\ ,3?'0¢"/2<;?6)® )`/”S //d/ &¢v] )95`47¢¢26/2 67 £/'~%€/<. `7'77{v ’Dfl§hz;a’ @-Hz»wnzw 02 /57%¢ Ge)')wd'k»<?@ @mc&‘/ LU)\,<>'E._'¢§ .771'2|§§`?\"/_),"§'.1/2/&,\ G@,,¢,; cf w/,\,)[g/L §§wa . . _ gri <`-(x@»€é l/jdw,z' 4 §//{' 5¢02<,]_ g’g¢ },/`C/o &',/30 v Q@u,:z/o<§ O,Q“,m~,;,,,r[ pm}$ would ,,&+ éx.££d,__s,é j75 &7%77,/5,776// O,QTSFn¢+/ \{u,€/'§d/`c!;'m M¢/i=,,¢ 5/4.,,7 @”,55 w /¢;S ;} 56 iam NH¢ ”E F"'!;’/'z” 39 OW<‘- C’OW%A/wrng /`/éz 5'¢0.».)£)1 /\l/ F§)M[/Bn 6=§ aci, h/)e/ Z)zwy,ezsnn-/z/ 75 JWJSQ ag HMU,‘G{M? @M&_{; /Dé.g/negq.v`,‘x Eé§pé.<‘/JQ|["\ O`{I» a@up~--/-§ gp ,Q A O'- ‘Im&r\,,'l~' OQ Q'FéF/Yl Mcoéfi \ 6%0`»:¥‘51\»1 OC‘~L£,‘{‘_O<§_) ee`\m\"glp?p£;(‘,é&w_£.& {»\p_~|.`ch /`.O§¢ f 736 _j”¥¢!£e<';/' 05 \Saé/?c.z._ \fa$)[`}ci /77€»44\;"~47 /->ana<$)@/n¢,_& wm wm mms §§ ’/T§..x#<s¢ DS/"j » M` 'l\t§<»' Qe€ 82»){ €€~Qu ¢"Z»`( `lqw+ 711/1 Tv amc/aj o‘gp Q€Wm»m)/i ` 01 j;:):`§ §§ 67/6£[¥ §§ LO@//e/L; flag/47 73 @m[j wH/k %>.<zks ¢9¢ @QOB‘;>m,'/»~| {§g>,os:.o[¢ mé) <S<A>MJ ,4;0£71‘ //-O; O€Cq`/zqs?(;D '7714€* Og'Cq'/Zq§érb 73 '_/?z ‘.:D,§~/g,-`c/ p»;:;ln h `/' G@`”J'CJ' 3 ‘L/L+-:B’\ QZ`W\G)’A';/)cg LJF/’¢\ /i’\£ 512/mm .. n `l'§yo»< l § 69 §§M~m¢ pm¢¢w&¢ )/.O'v 3/@_...3@ ma 336 @/@.‘BHICF l 3 61sz ®€¢w m fhali /l‘“ `g“°oV G£‘m" ’Fh'<s mea/se @u¢su.o-n+ 16 _;-;-/Z»(/I§ Q,@c§£ §§ €g°é:vmm¢>| ymaggo.wgi /O§/ _ j:m€ Jv€_ lr?v”aqz;] C€£“J'“GQAL& of §é,€d/c$_. ` '1'1’ ¢¢j,//,h,.,` %/¢:»a /9//¢¢1 `§&n f' 0 77¢‘»¢/5 QQH d/ M¢z Dé_dg.£ HWO/,:r\»tLM-e-A( 425 |5_§/0" /\) SPL->Q.)' O,Que,‘{, 956 qugf;vn§f" umwij //?MG ’77'/{5 md 4 "Z) '77££ Qdaef `op' @0'07/00 / AZW€e/y £’é°/QBOY &Wi' ;d/ &f?¢&/'/M 446!1‘/)'1 (,/7;%/5'7577// M%rj /H¢ J¢”'/D»<;V afééawmy <Qo/§" /`L>£ \Qeg`\~#¢¢»; . z w,//M /HJM/ 4~//m QZ,L/L}` 47 Gz ;d/»m,y/;@~ 72‘4‘? /?H¢/ QJ/z/Lz¢,¢ ?> my ,K£A';if Md~¢»z %¢/»)»//75/ WJ M;;» 4 5><<€»¢-1[£¢/77#§ '%7 ~=7‘/~'”@47 dfé/g»cu#/ly cid/§ CQ</\sé_ /\l@~ @€»oQ~/zqve - o€<x<;-¢acz?¢, - ~me S*rmz 09 was , ¢,» wm 1 /6@'/2» /D,'§éz.;>r _\/$_ _ x - Goua.+-@Q' w‘,\l,;w\ wage @1/.¢,1 ' w@\lm QQMJ<L m . cnw-cma ~ me \S’ 16252> Q/O'C .J~"€ L'»'V”jq’?;/ /- @@ae,z Q QQQMTMMT 69 Qowz<d., 4 C@Mé'§ A/d¢<> mm cv <Q/L 0¢113;@0€¢11+;571,7715, cl.z§ms 11111%'€. 1 ' ‘A;@PO""”+ m°""+’ ;(Y\'Q@wnse| T<> Assi's f ' 'h\‘m "J>n R<<.§<zlv)'&/)M{/ (§).9¢1&' C/$\ALSM 591 1315 Aér)vs."$v£r»;,/zoe '(°AMSEJ puggu@»n,+ 73 V?€X% GZ¢%£ 653 G?~l'mmnrl F£acé<n»m€ Q/L'll‘cl& I»O§(. 1715 Q@“g(' }(A»§ QSUFZ“'ZN @¢£AAMR <;>é@)m1141;m Fn §HW,/L+ @.g> z,»zgz 511 esp @éd'.@nm 1371 117 C,QWS€\ 321/1165 fT\A/`Hziz mci §§ 75 heavyqu . @R”L)é@<:®€ /1>1~+ M A+,lc,¢,\ 5/;91/ 5& AW;m,/zj 73 amy J~z§ndlen{/ 6111/1611@¢1+ '17> TE;Z; Cb<Qz<d~<Q, @€"M-`h~( Pee><:e web .

Mi\‘C/£ I,os’/- )f)aeo¢d)m / ,7711 §//Mw N#om 75 /&&/ ,7),74 m,¢///%s@ ` /[Amz, A'DFZ£$§\

1+ ~ MM. 0»<@6.@&/ 713 1 cary .,,/m owe §/-,;.’,/// /76 §@5/1"/ 75 W\z' a/‘s§¢~a'/M/< bysz C’/é,e£ 0{/41"1 Czw/)L’

\5\<\>@¢ ?¢esm\fwb,' R£é>ues~r 562 ama MPOMT<ED cowgél. wesqu 70 Qe¥'ic'la ).OS`l . Téw<$ G,OSD£ 66 C@m::’/ml posada-az , QQ¢¢&£ /~/0° of'e>q-/a<z%-Gzoq-/z¢;:¢ STATE o§ ‘Tz_>ms- ' nw 'f/¢é /67;"1`. _ \/ ' ' COM&+ of w¢\.'z=,e. bril,‘m 911¢9¢:¢<) Allm. Q§M\,é ¢TE, _E ` ~~r`n€rli'o\¢,:>ruqz/ 1 /DA'Z_ by &1'0').171 [p"/§'§D ,,§woc 7>€ /¢v"~#_g?;/ T/'/é /`/O)»/GKQGL€ dubelz o§ SA'iJ) C@a¢ff.?

Qowl£s /\/0¢¢) , Thz oqz,Q,-¢Q¢>-A+ w1‘,1h-rr\ 4»»¢0/16'»<) (;}H_;._,`, TD¢T¢ a/A,B'Wia/ 1 md ,eé%£s/"s Wwf 722 dea/uf /Wdi,,/ ` aea/nsa/ 73 45§'/"5¢ Ai'm 321 ,€é’§¢/u/;¢p ponle CLQA~£§;ST%I 771£. A!oou¢;“$~l@y/£J Cst_z. pwzsu/M‘f o 7`.30<'145 C¢c?é g¢F‘O,azm' ,T~IA/_ p£e>az¢/wc£ /42%2.5 /.OS`/C 5/'9’¢{\< A'§`<E//dw$;\ 74/\/ J?_"/Ji§z/n+ O?z¢C/»AM+ '13 éA/{»'//.<J 725 )m\)a 911 A+{'oe'wé¢/ pr<smhl] 76 @€(peasw¥ \r\<m 321 §ij A<§u.¢.a$Mh/‘ duchch Q£Q><\_s€-@Vr '77\/++ rn\j §§st Fn 6>»1111311111@111’ mt G£m§’ms~ ynom+,o<,:;§Dz§;»¢§q»\z ®£QlAaA~\im\j/’n S‘ poa¥ §§ ,Q.'X?\'l* TZ> ey,ze¢_§@»nlv,{'wv\ §§ Q@u/nsé.l ’1°5 ,/~)+¥A<;L\zj md %¢O/a€ozh*`¢¢\ zim w AS &k'k‘+ '° 63 331 s b 11 00 ` 63 ' M VY\; 5 ~'r‘r)c;w! ,0;3£0%‘1 1<1`&» umw g//Is M»f .- 1129'1 1211 QKD )-l-MHW‘H;, `TZ\<A€ ~1")%<¥5 £x£G¥P/ic] 711/ls /92. 194 ”D/e»y of Fs"b',ewn¢? 310/§ _'PQTF_ ébm/my 34 Jo/s/ ._| 55 ISK`D`¢ 54'0.1’<>\' C¢au'¢_ `I` 1 £E LDL'~J c<$` J.M'>£G §§p_,p¢§‘ mm CA“S€~ MQSOY~o<?-)Z‘?w. 1347711;€?¢,/2€19 ,,17€5>1>, /&€€/ ,j;¢zz:, /é-¢/' 55,}`2$;<[ ,~/2%( 0€6€~/1€?§- ,* _ '_D€A./< C|€RK ` £Nc,los£$ @le¢si. §i/ml mousm-lz mo'$'av\ ccpa Co)wz"l` App<)'m+£o\ sznsé\q 6,<0\£)<, w `FDéc`,(AKG)li¢-r\ 774 §v\pp¢.e`)" 9§` K¢SA!' "J`Z> @5€’£&¢§?/\`|4`(76»\ 1011 G,@wnsz_l 'TD“ ’V’hz Aloovs_"'~§/’f/E, md /~/umbé/asJ Cleuaz.` @/e/)sé 315 ’IZSS€ O>Hvé£s H"\O? lax/nra ’j’)lém 'R> /D\E QH¢>"\+)`<>‘*~ op /plz. QQLAA“{., \{OHL ASS?:S`»LA'HCE. ij\/n\’\s mc~y'\~"s/L 73 é-gEACH~{ /%[V&'m{io {,hg@é 22 %z Q¢...> @QQ» Paarg€. w,\|,~m,\ .€z,'»¢> (l\l@-r\.

01£¢%‘\\€1?. ' sms 1//.:.# wa\l<é.LQ@M/~q» 1qu Fm ‘?S'f> ' llmkv'»ns, TE.>¢'AS ‘7‘73‘~}2>,

E'X/~/IATT l ’,"'Dz<'LA'kATi/’m :12~ 5a PP@¢T cf f»’@l+i' §§ , 73 £aFKJSE/~/m’rrov<! e; Qou~.gé¢ b » Acz~$?<|e ').O<S‘( ‘T`é><frs C'»O'Dé O§ C£;\Zm?,h\¢;\` F@)Qgpqgéa § . §§ gywa @éd/»/M¢é»_ s 3 S.W,L+ ar A@¢xc.)é »)»»1</ 656 1b 1, fe egan 476»\ ha Qewnsd F»». 4112 T`z»,vmz Qgé}z of Cl¢im‘r'rm/( ."`\ @le@ae. vu)yz.,v - ' ‘ ‘ ` \`e`: /</0¢0&>¢163 kssaoza/£//7' U-//;ia»m /¢M///z¢¢/ /l//¢n ¢s/`JS’H<;.Z, 573 A'hd clé¢/Alé$ ///'m/ F/f?r' ,L{/mrl)/£ 7b y 'fhz auva 605-145 % 5171'5 Ac//;m end lé?aé$f$ /Mvz, vff?/z 69sz 73 /,eonZ¢/’ 371 age/114 Auo')é¢`): 6211/1765 A<‘Qow\@mn?¢,‘m§ Acli<m A/no\ mow-loo S»Rou? 771£ ®@gua,‘ ’\7\9 gl/cw?w`a,;… j/??U/O£Js,a»n//y` Z/CAKCé£/'HLSC/ 337 7?£ E///ls hoff of W/.£ 75% /Dé@h£‘?n@n{“@<§`@élm)§w( A%~(\'cz wksaé T Aw\ Nb+ pé£mhu"‘p 75 ]M]€mmfa/ @.17///%/€ /#/&> SONZCé O<F’%de‘mé. di SpHuSA// HGM€¢ @FQ“¢£@"’L/f /\Ava. A/é .C,ZZJHL ’E» mg H 732 `I/m.o/é '//Lq>'/ gac/11 @ Dq,;,`~,\§ mut Fncmecé/a»xl¢'d`r\ ;D,.\ 771-1 7`;)0\3 /D.epme(*m¢r\l~ afcetmn}ml \\us-]icz.FP/m)z. /2<<_€€'105<>9 A y£omm,;l;‘ ` No /no'¥\€ 62 WO`YIM 4 HS éz'ff< g;as~m Qe,l,g{\u£s an <Q<"`~‘~*\@v$v: \ ' cf y 4 @I/)/€?/Yé/z own A/A/£ /A}vé_ kay f,¢€¢zsv[s “p, m/ ps¢/I(;(/§A)’c:ég, wl 0£ /gA'nk /)CZZ@a/né dna/7 &C<€/'u¢< iL/dj»)/’/€/Q'S/ 01 div 7~6/@)1.@/§ F/C@>”E. @ 17 /~//K/z 6*`)1& @épo'n¢?€»n% @F%Vi VZ‘/LH/ @/é év/K of ,G'HFAg)></mqu,/¢/ ¢Z[@'Jo'¢’ @FJZ<-z /1/0 /FzS!/'/Ln¢r‘w _ @ m~»{ MOY\`H\\‘{ §o¢vo~°»n£éir /?/Lz AW,¢ooe/m;/z/y &. :i’ w>///"¢»v ,AJ/¢£;</ 514/w 0/¢3%€2 &/’Z /éz$éan/y %wcezmlzd’ N, 7)12’ 51/115 dpr{rfef/Mz Emz®éfmfm@a{/y 0/&511/}1/11 doc-sugar wol£’£< 'u/n V”"'*$~f Ué£'£/A/nd cO£CImLz omaha 41 av[~) 6 ;¢ ~ F¢?_ ”¢£5¢:¢\}»3 SJA{z/nm\s ma 77sz %nc/ d@/zuc% 7;7%z &:Y¢I/g dw§.v §><6¢~#€¢/¢71 73@ F)z 0/¢)7 atf O'Ws/ wsi/wsm nw 1051/w 3/¢937)€2_

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.