Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Allen, William Andrew

Allen, William Andrew
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided March 2, 2015

Allen, William Andrew

Opinion

qog pay ~53,@€1,1)0. m . L//z, uz,qL/,L£§,L/w é(@m;\€ Q\\<»./` 0§'0<§’~/2¢??4:£> "” ,IA[ 7'/~/§ '7’£.)€45` (|,@Mn,`& ' §§ ov'o¢~zaqslo 8 75 \/5 _ _ . ay cawth Qppé,glj j ' SM,? g @$»0<~2@74¢€.\- ’j` ( ~ .- . 1 ` ama st-a<? /<<iaéc. Qn{.¢\ T`zms RE§BWED|N §§ coURT 0F CR\M\NAL APPEALS ag»oq~)zq’w:> - o'$¢`*c¢-)zqsa;b, ` w * _ MAR 022015 § ‘72> 'Thé; l-/<, z L=__. ' w Ak Qled< N>s`\ HQ@SH.¢ Abe“ osmggnem , /¢ou> Q¢zw{s bj,||',,m\ Andp,w Q\`\.Q,.\ jj §§ dst G°é j?»z O;w`¢:l zs<§’ C‘Q'¢'mml~ ]` D@pznls O@飢 y 6%“§'_?5£~44¢» |? 301<{_ if 5_¢/,7% w,Q,-" » »' w Of`rO‘T-¢lz_ci€é)jé. 75 7)1<<_ /§`§B/D,-'$'/<i</'f Qz:/LO{'? §;7:§7,)%?&% 95'1¢°“£;‘0 3"°' cQLUA/Kcogcp"\'<`$ /|AL/D;Sl£'é\' Q-}'/§Loe»n¢¢g, /»)q\.:}\??\{-,, I6S_"7`i/'_B;5</a/`cf azu`L`/', )()50§ //2\'&5 `/DA,*& F¢}>L\QAG,,] \Q' J.Qg§’ 771;.§ l-l/)S N¢‘{ _13£:,»~! `_D<sn&. DA/ 331 ? 5101¢ .F pgcé)()c¢,o A femaka `710‘4 56’**'5'”3 /D‘°l+ ijcw l//l :@<_Zé}'o~¢¢a //71'§ AW/,(<¢) l/¢;-,\. §¢;,Q ,/.07 we"l‘ §§ I~/Qbé.s>a Qee@u,€, WM/ QMUL /Jd. @F/c)<;'/z</`%B W,%¢,J¢' Af--O‘?-'/Z §’Zé>és we~‘?¢’~$§<,~i¢??z@¢yg wa 7<;~352¢"9<,¢_, /M /%w¢ //éa¢</<. - %é€é.~,-z,@@ A mgm Jm w ,5»5<@ /@,z/<;,&/ ;/@M#a inv \/¢»’&/A//é~\ a<§\/I`EX'NS QQ<QE*B§ Oi)m§;\A/| f£bdé¢{)mez /'.O’Z 52’<11"3"\ 5@_ m Q/g¢z» @<§`/$@@'D,.:S/¢,~C/ cwa m//H wm; /)/66 ;'n_ l)ml/,{»,<'Y»~ G<§` //.07 .§,4!¢,~31». MC/ ;%-/}~'M 3,@, %,5 LU’)€"{ P`//J§ //zdm égz.,/ ¢GQU_A,QO//J 723 %z /¢§€W`FD/'s/z/C»/ cea L+. /w, QWQ\M\ Q§»¢,¢+o 3d @»/s<> '%z @chf'~ . dba/dr }l,q$ f)/o`)L 664/1/ ad dead z<Q G'T\ "Fhw( F»zsqz<s 0§)_§’:;~7(»§, A\S¢,'Fm‘\)\`é\$\b\ mg 1107 Se<',~h¢- é, Wé£z, w»‘r<., /1/£.»)<5/5. A,’ .}_/£A.£§~..l m '1)'\151.. 'FSSQ`:'§. §§ #»5 _`_(¢¢.¢/§e, 505/pm @@~ng¢é.{/\'<»] Q~@¢‘L" HA”$' I\/o"f` Szza/ W'h’z' .{,<)A’;/S //.07. Jné€?z Jmng,$ ké€skm, msa 711 0\~»|/»-1,¢'- §§ wm SZQJ.;,~\ 7, HW\,Q,,,M+ )'/If€> /{GT Qé;§v£`¢( AN§¢Ué-»,L m. @F>OQ-/Z?'?é 6 ~»- 36~0?-/;99¢¢5 /9“'1.€1 m` L 10211 §§ HA{a¢/?S %u.s //.07. @5”§€9'/297(93 -’ @§~@q~/zém».c M OGZ wm’ 6 y ¢//,é€,¢§ Q@Wus 1167 QWJZVHF> °+@3'<39“/2‘1“$(0.’3@ /H/z. d@w¢f o<F" @L»m~'m»/ /4%¢£,4.[; /r/Z<§ /.Dw¢(/¢'.=§ F\pp|i@M/a- izq€@z§ ns //¢m OM¢/»);»c&. 7,~/.5 00ng .w/r$/’*’V\ CQSWJ)MmCi. L¢)Lv/n /)'~[ LLMS m€\?/ 73 GI\:»; /§S`?\/D')S“/£l&f GQ\.\DL 015/119 dead 09 prmh,»l AW¢A‘§ |\/As /‘\/ML Féa§mzop A /\$#lw飧@év*’\ /rZ-z /FS~F*/D;$//z/<] OML/ 671 /}M//`m z€”o¢,’~/z@?¢¢ ~~0?0<%2%6 ma pr)?¢ql,zr- @F»GQ'/zq‘%c-~ag"~oc;»/Z<?€é€. /)‘§ ~ 655 @@7‘§ ///Hvz A/¢s/ drum W,€s§¢»n'{?¢/ 70 %{ /5’5’/71 'D;-S//z/`c qug,]l'; "?#<;< / 0$§0€:~/2<?7¢¢ ~0€»@€-/2¢7¢6 .@@“~e<>¢»/Z_<z?¢€ v 0€‘0?-/29@@. ©$»oq~(z<??<'@fb' ~ 0§»0€?~/257@®\ 'm-mt`g?p\'_,m.~@~\ @€»0<.‘~/2<;7¢® »-M.<)<?»/Z</Q<,®“ qu ',./<>! 574 iq$/?wé,€ z-J 67 -£/"7/7£1¢ T/§/£/é/ Hr//%.eméc/ "6£> ¢%6` /SS..L’,\' ”D'/'$?F¢)`of Ol®w?/- 716 LUO/ cop /-/A/L€/=r$ QQL€P“S //167. _P;>'£'@</¢'-/:Z pcc /\/éi<) <§J/c/Mc.€. 'm/N"s?co M(Dé€émlaé@_ ,Q.Q» 361-\£, W:Ts //£ £\F}d?mc;.s_ w¢r§ /~/@*/l _£éC&/?)¢ZJ 67 dz<gléQ@-Nl` \,¢/y\J,’] @<`:lf)éf//& ’7 9€>14 3~4/171& szhs"hsp»d mwr+ z)FCAm/;Wl g§»¢s-l°{‘¢m )/@€ f‘€ L°‘*’"’*"J””J cw_&b atf 965 :): \w,//,;m /MM) tsi/w isc-'?wz@v /¢#¢£ %.W~'/“' M»z, dowd ¢»,f di;'m,;»¢r/_ //~Hs ¢€é¢//;¢,£"J mg l/.o"? 10an 69 ;./,0£§,9`§ - [email protected] liss puwa 012/m "-12 vii C/m¢,/L+g %rs 73 ~,,-,;, U)Z)/¢y~lr;m §§ \/é.@nov\ Q'M `Tey‘/is @e¢p;.¢~p Cei~m,}w'l pe@e».=d»¢,.ez ‘4,¢4,@/2. //.67 3.1,. 3,<'. end 340 :¢';'. `1)».»+ wmf 2€»0¢//2(;7@ “W//f<><¢gh ,@?'OQ~/z€e¢b )/»s //¢/ Aw, A;,m,m 67 5,~%€/¢ -/7,€, ®1'1`511»2»'¢, 944/asz aa /57//)1z dev)wd'k~/] QML*/ w)»»<*/B\TS ?,:,_';_x_,|§§?‘/D/`S"l/z)`¢;\ `Geue, cf w/;~)IS/L @év/h[<q §,~/ é,-H,aé ‘/¢a.»n. , 1//{ 5102<>,. FQSZ }/ dd @/30 v Q@ur:?//¢,§ O,Q~,,,.`,;,~I p;¢y)s mud M++ éx<z,earsé 1/5 [)@vs/é%o;)w/ 0£7' *_'/ 4/ \.{u£/f_sc:}/`c!/'m M¢/E»¢ :é/<fnj O/YS£ i‘”’ /‘;S '; vi bar baum jh,,n¢ 725 pé/;//Z')v me owz: }j>o%,emrvg `/é£ 5””£" /‘H ‘§’“’¢'5"‘ 6<;` HC/+/ /7/}6/ ZJ£M yi£§a”' n % JuO/?? cf &nu"c.{w`(j GZJM& `o /DéQ/nQQA-W‘lr gespé<-,J-QH\\ { agana-k gpi ,g A f-Im@,\.'l`“ OQ )Q'{’-Ewn M¢°écz \ é;n<;~:ngm @e>umt_ 0§7 Qe».mr-AIWY£;Q;J@L& {~\;)_Jich lL.OS`c F; 736 _27¢¢!.4£<;/' 05 \S¢¢é/?c.:.. Ju§)[`}cz, /`7’/6%'”'~<_7 "J/"n F\QQO'¢<po/"Cj& LU/`H WH }\Gws §§ ’I':§>¢'A§¢ 'D§/-' ( M,~` `A[s<s QE:EW:>Q@H €eqa¢-§_‘{ ‘/1»,+ *|'h,")"£y-H§ adt/dd dep _O’e'.m"r'\e/i . M AQ€§ /_é Q/g,¢[z § l(){°»//é/L dow/11 73@"4[! `L)T'H\ //5_)6¢)’5 Cpé SQOB'?VY\)'/)A¢l Q'o)p£,€)€ M (,G,€UWI /lj"):-;'f ,/_O; O%`»o<z~/zq“zo',l> "/714¢~»~5/€ og<)<;»/z<i§c’® 73 './?'-z 'D'§!.e,:¢/ ,Q M/;ln 514 / lhwij ' ' O@“~/L+- 331 Qz`W\(piA/mc& w'i‘f’¢\ /i)\£. aman/1 ,. n `l'§yA»< EOQ @e'inw‘m{ Pwa¢¢fme,, //~0`7 35.¢3@ md 336 . ~ @Q@MH»( . _ M:JZM @N~@@@@- _ @/19,"%"1/ § a

@9%<20 ’<¥>€wa£ /DzQ-\Q/a~vl /1111, Jud%e G£My /m al w jt m 1305 C,oé)z ccc 610QVI,:VW\,;\,*| yma£cgw£ /0§/ ~¢<x 41 se @L¢BS lm j_/Q€ iv€_ lwv»»aqz;; CE»'£ “J"(?CA"& doc S$,Z¢J)c,;__ ':Z’ ¢J,//,-.),~,.,` /%L,¢/¢§.-<J A//¢n _§¢/r»% »<> 7//¢‘»¢§ @a)a»7 o/ M¢F ` aedex_- O/::}v/'m~¢-r\( 425 l§`§U"/OSHL 3d O,e,ue:{ 936 pu$o‘:én Sl" H€mp¢$f»¢¢l //?M§ ”7’)‘/1[§ ,¢7710' o 72> Mz Qdu»zf op @£/07//74 / AZ/p€e/_p G'é’/QBOY C,,U,i' '¢d/f?/'Y"/;r~\ »@'46{7/)') (7?)'!/1)’757// M%rj /Hz. J<¢”’/Dtv»/ aféé»zumv §0/5" /D£ \QE,Q]q/ilcs\~‘ j; w.//,>,W, 41(!/)»</ 4~//~\ &M.l;§' /4.¢\! Wz Zd¢m/y/m<~ ;z."§ sz M¢/ dpa/bed //<S m7 ,K£Az§ M@‘¢¢ W/»/M’j¢a/F W”J‘"”‘y/~ z 5><<<'.14-1[£¢/ 77»‘»< Wz galqu of@/»<a)r/ly O'w/§` CQMS; /\16 @Q~oQ`/zq% - 0@<)<; /a¢z?¢, 7’//5 S‘rmz 69 ’z><As . pa %/¢¢, /6@»/2» /D,'Séz.¢,r _\/$ ' _ ~ G©ulz:" 09 w»\l,.@m AM§),¢£@ Q!l@m ‘ w<a.\lem QQM»RL m increman wine \S’ aQsz> <)/Q'C }~» f L'/'V”j C]’?;/ /' ®E'D£€,'§ Q@{@?MTMEMT ‘€5’§"° COUNS'£L, 3 CO”\€’S A/d@ ’J'M'\<» A~ <§/L Un$;ooe&a+i~m 773 0|§§<§/§1\£ Qé?f/é§{/ /‘\@Pcéij:+m°»:+a 67§'7`0@ O@Awésel T)L:Ijs:§;“h\m im Q;§ol\)) h F:n 776 va"‘$ Séi uggugn 73 \/gx'q§ 6()}3&;?.§’ Oa\r:?o;\b~l p@¢zcs<fliu_ guide IG§'( WFQ@W`+ y{»,a/$ eson /J)é<@\c§evck ®eCTMLA-£l¢sv\ Fn Spro/a" af ;€£S,€{J UZ> €épeéoO/\"MW\ b“1 C,OU/Vlsé\ jimng mA/`H’éiz 64101 r{' 15 /'\é@€/)’“{ ®R/L)€R<SDY/)‘~)L pm A»Hcm 5/\.@!'/ Bé 03@@`”11§¢373 5“41'“ jzgdé'/\{/ 6)14/16¢16-/\+ '33 7760€ EZ;&<Q Cb<©.£ 69 G£nnmrv[ PQ@CLE_ wlZc'/ _

Ml»C/é los’/- F)Ccoac¢) 1315 7b 05//¢“{' Av%M ppgwa md %»3£14€13§63 71 3;>//%< C/P/:Z Z§Mo//§ 7)»'/;< /")’7¢///73££ /)/m¢; A'DP£,§§S\

i+' 1§ 465/ng gaz>g,e;e/ /zW// 3 gary 6/,”,; dedée 5,»1`6,// bd S@»n* 75 W\z dz,§;nd/w/ lony C'/é,e!: af /11-7 dam/13

\3\<\><, z ?v_a.$¢ é$»/d,,' R£E\>mz§T §?>£ aaan MPOIN‘T<ED O,owng¢l» @ue_su»nf qz> Qe¥'icle ),Os‘l ` T£)w<$ Q,o®£ 66 Ceymru»l W&aé¢iuz .

Q_Qusa /~/0° of'oq-zz<z%-G?m-/z¢€¢ STATE 65 ‘Tz_>ms. ;m 'r/¢é `/6;<;§`__ \/ . , - C<>mz+ oF _w@\,lee.

LOTH,`¢W\ anp,w¢) A/lm~ §§Quméq ‘T;.m§ 'Toc'¢`li'ow.,?>“\`\qb ¢ 'DA‘A by §§on {p"/$”'§D ,_s¢.oz: 7>€ /ngz;/ '70 7/45 //0»/6»<¢)&€ duber: of $A',J’ [email protected]?

Qovnas /\/w , T)n OVz.,C»/,Q»A+ w»||m-m A»A,,w Q.H_s.,,`, TDC.T¢ cB/L»'?>°'ll‘i€/ md ;€&71455'/'5 `77147(' 7}72 dea/cf kp/a;/»/ ' Qe)¢mse) 72> 175/sf 600 j>)\ fé"§¢/w" gamle A’ng;szw 7)1£ AbOUL“S`/;>//£d CA&¢$£, pu/z§u,gn"f /;DD 7:;>¢'»4'5 C@C#é 3{0£7,11' <I»JA/, Pe@a¢¢/u¢; /4,@/,'¢./3 /.0'§/¢ 5)%%:: ,es£//.zw;;" ,4,/ fdc/z?m+ @?z£»$w+'-.S gA//r//;J m mg w A+¢M-Né¢/ HW)¢'?\{”¢<I] "FZ> @&@eésw\+ \m'm JF». »Q/m{ ‘ A»c§uae$Afl~/’ \SMQ\‘¢c.‘/»l GJ¢QQ>Q&FA),' 'T?\/++ rn»/ Fésw|}' Fr\ @mf§km-M»:f bq Om\<§’mz~ mw‘+,@@%z£»$qn{z ®éQlA/zHi¢sy\ jim S'U$')poa‘\' §§ E;é>?\{* 173 ey,£&$a»n`/`¢'Ilav\ §§ QOLW\SZ.| '\`5 _/-)'}"IAC,|A;.., md jZn@/¢€o£h{`¢o\ fm w AS &k'l`d la Q éQ;sQ;'n 5 b ++ 00 ' ' 66 ` 14 m§ 5 #mw anew 191 way g//Is M»f llz<§“l F/n Q€D H'¢Wkw‘ll£ `»T§\m€ “‘)')zq?> E)<EG¥F/ZJ 771/§ /Ma §‘/ /D»<h/ of F§»b'¢ewm?. ¢§lv/_’>’» FDQTE_ §b¢»r/m§/ 3¢ .l<)/§’ ,..| SSI`"D: 5{0.¢'0\' C]_z>ua_`i" M LDL”\i §§ I-l'gb££§ § hhpd§. l l{L'Z , ` C‘jf~'g: ?l_€$;?~oq-:z€w. 1261"1 ./zq.?t, 12419 in qsz>, /a%/ L/;¢za, 129 55,}2</1<!` ,12%5 .'-` § ii l v l v

'D€Aiz Cl£a\< ` £NC.\os£A @{e¢s£ §§mo\ m¢oUM-[g mO-$\'m»\ §,@ C@wz"l` Aq>p<)'m+zo\ Q.@M»sé,\¢, ¢SA¢\é/<, le ‘®e<"_mm}i<m »;,\ SMW¢¢+ , K¢'$M' ')`o Géq>zs.;>P/\Jdm\ ky (L@w»$z( ,-p“ /rh.£ AL,<,,,£_»_</L//L md /~/um/:)é/zzcj CL'_B¢,¢§£.g W/ehsz'. <QI§ 725.<2 G>mpz&'s f~)"\d bra/msa q-)l€.m 'n> /D\& QH¢>#\'\')`€*~ ap 7")\£. Q.GLHL“{., `{Ou& ASS"l$"»LA'V\C£ JL\~\"D\'\§ ({\c+prs/L T% égza<f'l~f /Wg:'m{go LMWM CMQ»~ PQ»§¢:~ w.\l.~»m wo ‘l\'~¢»~

OIL`¢?>"\\QZ ' £|h.s L¢m'.l‘ wa\ke'L,Q@wn/`*+» W.q"l Fm <?S'<'> "

lJmkuT‘/i, TE_>€AS 7734 Z), "_._` E'X/~/IATT l ’bchA'kATFM :IZN 514 PPO€T of £»fGI-H' §§ fafti.»:$E/~/mf’ror<l §§ Coum§él b ' A¢z{\’<|r~. 1.0<§< "Té><f¥s C‘»O'Dé 0§ C£J?m?,\\\/AL F@Q{pq@&d § , \§ §//M,,' Oéc:?/+/w¢<?`/\_ 75 7»» S»,,opmf af A»z¢¢é>)s '7».@6'/ KXK/’ q, £é 5591\ ’H°"\ }9‘1 QGM/n$&, T’n /.,)'hz ’l`édm'$ each ¢:€‘<{d a£imr"rm/( ."`\ @zq,ae ua,z.,, - ~ ` ` ~ ~ ~ ~» \\(;‘ /</0¢0 dams- ¢2£§00£¢/£//7 /J»//»zmz ,¢w/w¢/ A//¢»n 6/43')/<;.2, <7\ A_')LO( 6{¢5¢/44£3 v/7"°/ 271/fm .L{/nkl)/£ 7b F 775 emva &5.1£5 Jyn /'m',`j/ Ac{/Sm end &yaé$f§ /zm»z, vff?)z C'e¢¢,w¢ 73 /,e¢¢zz@/ ?Z, £m/L Auo:»a¢ws cvh_'TA?§ A<‘Q<sw\(p¢m;¢,'~n§ Acl»'<m m»o\ would Sle\d %a @_q)u_n_| ’I'?\s gi/w)‘ ' @Im /0,@¢%//¢/ 21a/ncaasz z 77,¢ £///:s a/,.:f af :77)¢ 75st /Ds@¢)z|m¢\{'o<§`€é:m»ml Aqs(fc.z wker;e I’ Aw\ Nv+ pégm?'lf'\"‘g 75 IM”A/‘mm@w @.17//002. //`0 <SOH_ZG<E O<F’»H)de‘mé. 02 gpauSA// F'»Gemé¢ @FM@"+/,z /\M, ,/6 `c,zg.¢v;¢ 40 ,,,W m »j;,M/z //w/ A,,L/o @ DHR;_"§ mbt F/.ncmedé,a@l,'d_,\ ph //'hz T§>¢Ag fD.ePAo`Q('vn-€r\*~ afo£c)m»}ml ¢“SJ¢Q.F»/m waged n w w M, m . , f Y'm/» z o'vé` 62 mmul G'Y{z Q<SM Q黑/M'\u£s ind §?<`»`.¢,>\o?l ` . 71 jo @f/'/€Mé/L own "/¢/@ /’Q‘Ué m¢y ,HIL€AE$`!S '7>) 611 psp/’z(/§/zcé$'/ wl gent ,Qaz@wné ona/7 ,écz/'us /)/A%&Qs/ oz 0/;{,7'6/@,,.@/§ %c@wz, @ j /~/»6*02 616 @épo'n¢?;,,q% @FM VZ‘/n/ 6/£ 51[5 cf AW£OK/`m¢gv?£é/c/ ¢4,[0'0'0"'?'5’ @Fazoz /1/@ '/ /"&s»//%,%;». _@m~( iflov\+]'\\‘{ §o<vo@n.<éf /?/Lz AWm/m#éfy &` ;Zw>//,"¢m ,AJM</ M.»:,»/ a/éz')z§z 59 /é§§¢;n“J/~/ %w¢éza<lz<? % 77,;¢ 5//>@ dwi/f af%z 7§0¢/;5®£/),9¢};,¢@¢{/5,? C'/a;mr`m/ J¢%\A(cz wol£’éc wm T频/\$~{ Ué£@€/ A/nd d)£€‘l»mz omaha 4])*7 giff¢';}§%] izath ’¢£jo}~é SJ»,{z/nwv\s -)¢wzz,T/wz ¢nc/ GMA.€<% % %z A» d g /d/’F¢éf ?Xc+d~~.,é¢/mq %<s %z ' 0/47 ¢£ 0`1°/<5/ zL)YI/l/¢lj-m /L.¢,u.) pQ///&r» 3/¢¢37»€2_

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.