Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Allen, William Andrew

Allen, William Andrew
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided March 2, 2015

Allen, William Andrew

Opinion

v ’»\Ol ,@©U) '€>Z,BCI,UO. \H . LI'z,uZ,$qéqg/q@ <S<@¢A€ Q\\M" 0>?'6<;'~/2¢; 745 6 g in 7/4§ mms (',@…v&- l 5 §§ ov»aq~zaqge 3 § \/5 J§’ Oa`;'m-.h»( Qpp<sels j ` $Ak ap /_ @Z»o<r-¢zqvc»¢- lam 1 zsw<a-/<<e@¢,c-,. LL@+.'¢ Tw»s RE§E\WED |N §§ couRT oF cR\M\NAL APPEALS ` ag»oq~ia§’w'z> -~ o”$;`-G<.’~)z¢iX(o'D, 4 v 4 MAR 022015 § ‘T¢ “Thé. l ’ ll<WU£»/\L)lé~~ Q|€Lk HL)£\ AQ@S`(_AI Abe\ OSU,CIGKK v /\/bu) QQ`WIZ./S wl|l}m/\\ A')LO€E,€¢O Q\\.a,\ fn §§ arise ‘~T<B /p?z OQ'&¢~+ 6<§) QQTm\r\`¢\]` A@Pg,';'g 5@5,£° f 6*\¢?25£».\¢» \? 3014 ;:’ S-M,¢ M,.» , -. w o?»o¢i-\z.¢e%‘cj@_ 73 fm /z§B/D:§J</;}f difng §;7€§/7,%?:£ 95”/*’“<;“0 mcf ch¢/JA'KJ):¢S> 13 411§®:5~1£"<:}’ g+laznc¢g, lfh\¢}\ W\E, l§§TH/;;§ln/bl td,‘t¢»\f'»€,`)t`, 105 §§ /[;\'\'5 /DA+& F£,bq£A“_._/) \Ql olng %;6 H¢)s N¢'{_ vl§’ss./~I Dme. 2)/1/ .€3/ 7 901¢ F ¢Q£C£)oc¢l) a @A.eJM)/l `/D"l 6{7°*¢""°'9 ,/D“*"“l ‘}'{'5¢4 l/A &Gé)'og¢a //71'§ AW/,‘<A )/¢é- £,,Q //,07 `w€"f 6<? P/»obéc>& (leegu€, 721»/ QM¢+ /Jd. ay»-c)<i»/a<;%£ W,W,J¢ 05"0<?»/2 <P§¢é, we-'?€)-zs’<:i¢??z@¢gg we 79 ”352¢ '¢9<,€, /M /%;y¢~ //a%/<- v %éaéj_’v:Z/E"'D 14 405¢‘)5£ jlé'??? 72! /¢5"\$';a @/'S/Z/EZ/ d@¢{,¢‘é f/l/ \/¢b./A/'i~\ §§ //`5><`11$ Q@c\)€"@g'@i'mv'\n/| W@aé¢{).,mz i'.o? 526)¢2"\ 5®. Wvg Q/z¢é- af /sf<Q'D/.;z/zr¢/ GQM% wg//g.e cam/17 75 A/s<s 321 Uréz}@{v<`:- ccc //-Z>’? .§»Jw\$b. @m.c/ S»¢/}~'¢~/\ Z-Q, W'¢s LU`I€‘{ %/05 /)/.zi/;a égz,;/ ¢Qeu¢ao/;J 723 7)15 /€§F"D;s/£/G~/ amc L+, /w.. @mw@\'”°\ Q§M+Q 3d ,<)/S@ wi @Mw@r~'~ . cba-d },L,qg /)/ML 364/if ac 69¢<',`"» ch m H'h,~»( j,zsuz<s @§.]_§":;?-g, A\S<\I_T/v\ \)\`<BM~\\?S»\ aig 1107 §»;,<L~Lm 4>, Waea w#<.~ /1/¢<,.-)6,£. /.1, »I-JgA-£Y~`.l m 'j')\z$i.. lFss`¢/i`z";. §§ Mz \[¢¢¢/S,q, 635le qug-.&{/&.,] QJ@»‘L“ HA“S' /\/¢"/_ Szza/ ’/"hz 405/5 //.0_”)_ Jz¢é€$;z §§m,qé$ i/£€$‘W\» Als< Fn \)\`A|ra'('¢'~v\ §§ 11,6'7 Sz.ajv?m 7, HW\,Q/)(N'[“ L/Az /{<>TQ<€{ vi`¢¢ F‘»N`§wé-L m 86>0<?-/297@6 »~ 2§~0¢_/2_;%6 Hw.d MS<> a wm §§ flake/93 O:Hms /’/.07. @§0€»/2.<;7¢@¢ » S§~a)q~/?.Q%.c M <Qi< wm’ d - 569&»5 G@¢?% mm QWJZWQ> “*&3<59~/??$(¢/13¢ /Mz_ dew¢f odd @,l/m/,'m'/ /QWW,;A.[; kim /.Dwr/¢a§ AW|'I@M¢£:- i?$`€é>é F/s //M,O@my/,,;,,Cg_ 4/,,_5 w,¢;f w/)$?’r\ C@Wno')'l`dmci. LULH\ ’)-l uMS me?/ 72 /l)\é /§S`F’\/D¢'$M"Cf Q@“L`L Q]€LL' Q@)u.d §§ prmh,¢( A"W§.A(z }\/¢)s IXIH‘ FéQ§rvz-'<>Q A A$%W&£oq@ém 771-z /5'5’%®,~`$//)/'<7 aaa/dm W/,»a¢)//`o"'\ S“'?~C‘;'/Z‘??C>é "O?'<'$C'/€§gé£ ve F)pp)kA/zp~ @>?»@C?'/zq‘%c~ag"~oq»/ZQ%Q, ,;)g - _5;,£_ @@7§` ///)9% //a/ gm y,és§@'n'{z¢/ 70 %=; /5’$7'5 925/afc quz,]t'; ) Y”z</ 539<;~12<;7@£ -~0?'<9¢?~12,6’%6 0@‘:~9°¢“/1<?7¢»€ ~' 0§"~0?~/;9’€4;<5 _ ©Z`»o¢i~ 12??¢®‘ _ ~ 9§»0€,> ~ /2,€7@®\ 10va Q?p\f,w+.b~\ @§»0<2~/2@‘2@’1> ~a?'o¢i’»/Z$'Qc,®1 llqu ,1/<)¥ AM/>\ AS/?L<}é,€ §¢J 61 l£/'"7/7£,<_ /D/§/£/é/ §79%¢/1)£6/ "é£_ _.%6` /§S.»¢.\| /_D/jj.¢)&>t GQ>ML'/- 775 LU€?/`oop /-/A/LS»GS QQL§WS //',67, 'P,'z£'.@</¢'/:Z arc /Jé"<) 5)/6///1€_5, Yn/§`\";oo M(Décgmbé/L_ 321 3<‘)1¢, W,‘T!s //£ gdidpmc;.g w/r§ /./@<f'2 _£é(:é/?)Z.eg 57 dz§zoa§-/\j~ \,</y\J~,’l &>ClcéE/)z ’7 9€'>|4 391 1712 szhs/Dépad madr+ zf)CEbm/A~[ ;§m~~l’»"<.l==.@, ),Q€ 156 lw)dth»?j ®“'\_Fsb 34 36)‘\~7 -T-’» 'w¢//»/'@»m Meé¢d @//¢'r\ £€C"‘évzep /\/@//'cs %w’/“ 771'2, &zu/z,?£' afd£;m/ha'/ /!FS 'f颔gd£..<>p m"[ 1157 wal`{' ap )-//9£»8,6'§ - CQ/Lp»<$.md ms g)e¢_s;@m¢z¢€ 012/m 12 ‘<l’l\é leu-/L~/~g W)r< 73 ;z,, l/l'o/¢y\lr`sv\ O`§C \/飻rw"\ Q'm `T£y`i?€ @e¢p;¢"-Q @£;m);)¢y'l peo€§dw£"¢ ,4,<4»2;/2. //.67 3.(,_ 3,<’. ,q-,.,O/ gdc :I-; ?7>»4% wm*f 2€'0¢#/2§7@ "W/€<>c;g¢\ 'Z§"OQ~/ZC??&,D )~/#S //d/ &¢»q )¢}S`»nwé/Z ,é¢/ 5/%€'¢ _7'77€ "T.'§shzic’ Q-//vanz¢j, 3a ,<51771~7, Gg~/)())QJ‘-<T @gu_&`/ WL»cB\'TS 771?15§?‘/@;§~}/1/¢,\ deem of wf»\~)/é/L 619va ' .

514 ` C‘»'Mé ‘/M » 1//¢5@2@/. w¢ ;/;</., ¢,,30 _ Q@uf:zo§ O;Q:'m'.,=»~l Z;pp;.nls mqu /.a~+ éxac<€;`s'§ ’//s &v;[;é{h,y/ 0£757%4/ \_(u,Q/'__jc:[/`c-//'m ,M¢/g,¢ .36/<,.,,7 665 W/¢;S 5 v 55 iam 7)’#'7¢ 722 péf/'"//¢")‘/ 27£ 077<<_; €@)77€¢3,717»?' `, g 5500/en /\H F§/Q.r//Zm 6:;&;9¢/+ h”e/ L£W/'MSQ”M 75 J"G/§@ cf Uznu)`cl”"j @@»1&`{3 /D¢<.Q~\QQ,;.W\` fespéo,~j~g:u“\ 04/.6.,\5~ Q@,¢K-¢g §L ,q A O- jm<>/N'("’ N~éé/n 1145er \ é/Z/nmq Q»rm @é>'~¢e'\[`_o<@ Qe'»mrqlwp;e@z.&w£,b {lp_~|fclz, [.O§, ,f"/v -736 _j))vl¢!££‘;;/" aec \S¢¢é//"c.:._ Ju§)[`}ci ,/776%;%<1 TPn AGQ<S£<gc/"C;z burr/1 jim N}w$ §§ //ZM<S@ D§MM` 'A‘Sc eg:&;m;QQB/g €e§u¢$f( `//)m»+ ’l'hz");y',¢§ aa;'md 0‘~0@ Q€*.»m;»\.Q/| _ /)|. peer fe C?/€Llf §§ ZO@//e/L_; dew/1141 73@>1')5/' \D»`)‘*¢; VM}<S eve E)QQB‘M"/wl §g>,oé.c)|r, md <.<Q)<a)'>a¢¢r} ,,Z)£’,`f //~O ' 0€@@~/29"1<@7> "Wa 32 <>_?»o<;¢/z<;§¢,’h -/Q '/?z ';3,.€;/£/;:/ ,0 /u;lq h »,¢ GQWJ.'¢J»;W" Z)@¢¢/L+-H ®~MG>|A’.'/»cé w:'+¢\ /ihi. em§m ,. n `V§yK _@Q@`Muj ,_ __ hile @MM @/1@."%‘11€2 a ' 61sz ®€¢w a<:, , /D§§T‘QQ'“'& €M 3 /‘Z'L “S°LCQ'V G'e'@'"<k' /n'v§ c'/Lo/M @L¢£.Swo'/n("!'c`) 557ng C,oc§z. cf e»»v§'\./\@I . yeaach~v/zg /,M l_ j:/Q€ iv€` V?v“aqz;l CE:£~J;-.GCAE of §é,éd/c$__ 'j~"’ Aj,//,»b»>`. %J¢é.o /9//<4’) `§&n! 19 7/£'»¢»5. @6/447 G/M‘F bzdé/. nwa/gxwa Gz> agy@//D:'swfd. de. 956 pqs<lf¢n.sl» 'H€/"\-/)<Sz¢:a-¢l //ZM=$ "7“7¢{5 ind o ca 7?> 471 ada/cf Op' @¢W;',M,~/ AW'@L¢ M¢*?Qz<>? C,W,"k)/ \ »¢»y/»/;,-»\ »Q%A>,, ”_7§’%/6"/€7// cz*'r)VZr§ ‘/H`¢ ,74¢-”/047 aféé'Aa/))¢V 30/5/' /Da \Qe/Q]¢>,#l¢»< , jf'§`@wz md QJa/L£¢/)L % /747 K£i.&g Mds/z %¢/)m/é/ mp W¢J`°’“?" _ §><<<=.14‘1[£¢/ 77»¢§ %7 ~=7¢9'@*/ 4=/£’/%4¢~¢/~7 Q'M/§` CQMS¢ dan @9~<:<?~/14?9 ~ o@<:@»/aq?g ~ 7’//6 §m‘ra 09 72>{¢§5.. l j:,. ~%/¢é,; /6@'?2» @,'51€¢.;[* _\/$~ . ' ` 4 " O©c¢p.~l'- cjz<@ ' w`»\l,»`aw\ M/¢e© Q|/~vm ' WQ\]é/L QQ<~M<L m 'ol`l¢%‘cL.CLz., ' ime \§ 1955 Q/Q'C .J~"C’ wV"'jq"’;/ /- ®@ae.z 9 W%Q);wmaw w COU~§£¢° C.OM‘</@ /\/5‘0 77\7$ & gm &`HS’/Oo€&*h‘h;m~, `7//1<§. 01 `}\<¥ 5 ` €/ ~ f l '/_\~>@Poz`»»+ me»r\+ ;(@"Q@A¢,.Z;S;] °T{:{:§Sa's f ' 'l/\\‘m 'P/:<§y {€7[<<:,;:|\)»'¢?{ {${/ .9¢»&' n 531 U%z ve"% , 1 QAMS& ug§Um/\, '72) \77€>`<% (9€}2>¢%€?§ OF~"':?O;:Y] FMQC¢S<QM,E H/L}¢‘c,l& |,O§(, j/h<g§@b“a+ )[A/g Qé()f¢`€w&o ‘@é<§¢\c§/M"f Q>ec)ma~hésv\ Fn Swpp@/L+ §§ ;€,’S,Q} 62> €spQéOw//\Fm\liv\ b~{ CQWS€-\ J`¢r\/I`h`fs XT\A/‘H'évz mci ’,{ 75 helequ , @m)ée@€ /1>\~+ M ,<),+¢M SA@.// §§ AW;mM*/z w ` ekgeran @u/zéu.g./\+ TZ> Té‘;z; (lz<$)z. 619 Cl»e‘~n.v.~( Fea>cc-_ web _

A/ILl\‘C/é /,os’/, F)ccoad’m / ,7’11 §//M' AW/ow 75 /é¢/ '/,WMM md ¢,,»¢Mé$. vz> @NM _z,Y//& aj ,éWo/,§ -7)¢7\; /'/)’),¢/)[/%££ ‘ //Ama , A'WZ§§S\

z+ 7§ AM'Z¢/¢ named wyk /»~~ cary .,,/A$ dam gay/l ,56 SH»/)* 75 W\z dzgdfm/< br/W)? €/é,e£ @//41"1 C’dw/)L'

\S\O>G, l ?z&$i 57-%, R£&QEST <§CR C,@ud` HFPOIN TED Clown$el» @ugsuanf ”¢`<> Ae‘r"€i<<. l.OS`l . T&KS G,OSD£ 66 CEM:FNA|' W&aé¢iué »' qusz. »/o., of'cQ./z¢%-G?m-/z¢s:¢ STATE 05 ‘Tz>m$_ gm 'r/¢é /5:;'@‘ v , , _ Co>ud` o‘? _'wm\_lae. _ ,sz_ie¥_ M\' T;ms_._f‘ ~11)€3110\@3“1\€2, 'DA‘Z_ 6 &a'nj'l§ Q"/S/’S'D ,_§\,oz:: 7>€ hvh#g?;( THé //QMGF<QGL§ dubec». 0§5,9'13’ C@wf.?

Qovnas /~/oa>,'r)\z O?z.,Q»./,Q»,\+ w.H`.`/w\ 4»»@0/1@ QH_M, 7@¢3”¢ 6/&3“1\¢@/ / mmi £WWS/,S .77)4/_ 7772‘ dea/mh /W/dznf ` aea/nse/ 725 Hs$'i`$?‘ Ai'm Fh ,€35¢/¢/,-;7»§ Wd,‘~a Q,QA£?'SW /”'£ nb°dé`S`/;//£d C*°“'$£» §)u/ZSL¢/,'n?(' o 7'.`3;><'»4§ each JCF`QQM, T"“’- V@QEJW» /4¢~//'¢ z /.OS/c 514#:~< ,@54§//.,@$:‘ /w j?"/c/i?/,,+ O?z¢@ném+qg <'EA//,'//.<o@ 73 )\/:,\)’; gm AM£.N&(/ HW¢:?\{”¢J] 125 66(?25$04\+ \r\\'m J;'n. ,Q/mj Q.(§;)g_g$,;p.{ \§uo\-,C,'A‘ 03@®<1££"601' 'T)\A»?} m\_{ £éSHH» ;'\ @“n',§kmwt bq QO_AGMS‘_ mw+.»@:%D§ch§q,»{~s ®£Q]A/zAM<;y\jjn 514 po,,_¥ ay E.XH. m 66>£&.$¢1\`/`4¢1¢¥\ §§ QOu/v\§€,' '\'5 _,,Q+./AC'[,\;_,_ md Tn@/a€o£h+_£é\ ` v 63 w ma s dwch Dilo?n l§z, umw g//ls Mf » 'll,zq’l rim QZD H'MHW‘LL£ 7va *'mzq?)

E)<aa-»}¥zci %/§ /f¢"a 94 ®#7 of f§~b'»e»m¢? <Qo`/§, jPaTE_ é@/m/ ,;h/ D~o/s/ l 55ij 54&¢’<~,\' amuL+\ £E 'LDL“J 6<9 'Ll/Ab£§ §;Qp:pdg_ }l.aj, ` C(;A;;:A?l£,€;fz:oq-»z?w, l 2671 ,/z€ 73“', /2€')9 ,,1 7 Gfb¢ /&%/ ,Ja¢~z<;, 126 53 , '/"29:§};/£955 "D€Aiz C\€RK ` £Nc,\os£§ @l€¢s£ ;:w\¢j mou,¢ml-g mo‘d¢'av\ <,Q~,,z C¢a'wz"l` /-\@po'm+zo\ Qsau/nsé,\., O/Cclé)<, Hw\ "Déc;(/>,Ke}i¢~r\ w §»\pp¢-.e+ _ 9§ K¢'SA[' flb @EG’ZE~='>'?A‘IH?Q\ 104 C|,ou/ns;l 'TD»~ /|'7\1 Aioovs_"’$`/'//z, 'm@\ /~/umé)é.zgo? C',¢_aus£.g @/e/zsé glz 77\sse @Wz/;s Hmd bpa/aca U'Mem 713 /l_)\& QH¢>-n"\*)`€'r\ op /]')vz_ Qeu&+, ` `/ou& ASST$"~/'A'HC& JLWA"W’\s mQ/H~s/L TS §gza<l~|~{ fwg:'m{go [, )1@@' 2a iii %2¢.4*> @,QQ»~ Pao§'§. w'.l|,'mv\ fw ml@"'\»

0119?>‘\\€2. . ' <c.|h's wi;wa\keiz'QQM/~q» '\Leq"l Frr\ C?S’© '

iJml@v*»l/z, Tz.>ms 77le Z>`.

E’X/-/,Z'AYT / ’bchA'kATfEM :IZN 514 PP@€T 0¥"1€¢@1+1‘ §§ fs¢£st/~/mTI-”ow¢ ag C,our~z.§él b ' Aoz{’\<|e. '?.OS( "Téms G)O‘D& O& C£;Brr\j;h\m_ F@Qgpq@§¢ § , § QAw/' ®éCj/*’<”¢é'". 75 % S'»zp;wd-“ af jai/cls '7»06'/ )6{£/' b o?é £s¢>:;'hjl'®\ b»z Q@wns¢:l jim /_fhz ’l`eunz Q;wh of @/¢im~r'n,»/( "`\ @az.ae ua,z., » ~ ` ` ~ - - - \`§ /</o¢o dev/163- £25005¢!£//7 /J,//,).-rm ,¢w//zz¢¢! /l///»n @/43')!?2, 573 "~A_»h@l clad/weis W»@/ 171/fm .L¢/mrb/¢ 7b y 'f/¢z @@#ML deals ;;, 17,,5 AC{/{o‘r) end ié?aéS/_g /zm)a aff)lz de¢¢&'/LU /,€ACSZ@/ 731 £fm,q» Q;;u€é¢"s Fh,‘W\?s A<‘Q§m@mn?¢h\§ AC)[»'M mw\ 'wowi»eg 3101/dna un,| ’U\s gl`/wo" ' @Fm pawn/17 Zch/zcazéka/ F»» %z £///:s M:/ of W)a 7`9<05 /Ds@¢)g:hno“{“@<§`@élm)§\a[ \Sq’o~(»'cz. wheel 37 Aw\ ND+ (Pé£m:`pmp 7b lw]£mméfz/ @SF //sz. //`0 <Souzcé of%c'¢ma _0’£ gpausA// F»ceme., @FQ“M@"’L/f/\Au;. /\/0 ,C,ZEJHL ’E) ma H 732 ';/m.<y'é ’//Las/ £”do @ Dur<r`-§ mg F/'ncmecé»z@lf<w\ 'Bh 771'1 7;>¢'/\€ /D'ep.¢m‘m¢r\\~ ¢fOe“)mn}m/l \\usjicz .T"|>/m)£. /€éc€')oé<>p A f»Qo¥'lm/;.\Lz.‘ ' 'ND /nOm€ 62 M(M'M HS é)'§’{'< gm Qé,‘,g'}'\u£s ind §>L`)`e)\r)g`/@ _ j 150 @I//€?/YM dam we /,4% my %¢€m¢s 7>, en »€M'/¢, §/@-¢ég, M, J£ /S)AWL ,QCIZ@c¢/né ima/j ,&C<€/'us /L/dZ/éfz$/ 62 67//'07*6/@1,¢/§ %C’@WE. v@ ;_1.7 /-/m/a 6)1&@&,@%6?¢/15/. @f%”i 757""/ @/é 61£5 cf H;W£@>(/m,yfé/¢/ ¢Z/Jdo"’/q' @Z"Jz<)z /i/z> / ')'€z$v//'%.<#,"u. _@mq racqu €W%<Q /w. AWM,»¢;MV 31 :/Y w>//,"qm ,AJ¢£¢<) MM §/éz’)z§z 55 /Zz$én'¢/y %wcezNzJ) ;, 77,z 5)/&4 M’.,=/ »§/f}¢z 7501/15 ?D£F,y¢h¢@,,,byz C’-/a;mh/»/ Ja.z,£(cz w»el&< bunk-l T@MS~¢ 'l)é£l§,€/ A’hd J£C/Pm,z U/wf'e/L 4'7‘7 affé§;¢ ;;@&%?- Y¢_£Z/,°}~é 51':¢¥1[2/¥|94\"$ HLL"TM§ W"C/ dal££<'/L 75 ”7 & d .. amy }XMu+/z¢/m %qg %Z 0/6'-} ama 01°/‘5/ wsi/mm nw ,M/% 3/¢¢37» €a.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.