Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Torres, Paul

Torres, Paul
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided March 25, 2015

Torres, Paul

Opinion

§1,'11’1 OLI

1 mmi ' . 1 Wri+ No,\A/R~ 191.11'1»01 , . _ '77»1‘11/ C,qsuE_ALa__i_O~_‘i_LOO /-1 _EX.R@RTE >\/ C_»uv\_+_€r/¢..»M/l/]ml< ‘ - ' 721131_6§#1631¢1€1<1 91 610 716,1,1_ 1 _' vs, - ’ _>< ' /Qu§ibu_, /6)_</_1_5_ _j:é)_c__§_iaic_o{ 1'~6)1;/'1§ ' @§Q§WZ §N ‘ " _ ' @OURT wOFQHlMlNALAPPEAL_S ` %@;I_CO CEO ~ A111111252115 _ 311£_€_1:::511@11@@111,@16111 ____I_EE H_Gl\/OR JU__§L _C_ES C>F

/\/0 w:C_Qmje.__$ RLO@ __u lj:o_ 111&1:;$__/!_01_1_ 6 5?1°1 qcl . _O_£+b~c_']:¢x/)s_l]_c_padm_mzi'_@j:€1411/11211611 1_77_15'"}1 ctrs _ _/_/_V_/Q_/_\Lcl‘¢_r_s'c>w£owu%y _-176,_)1,,1_.< CM{<_MQ~»_L Umf+) amr~] hart b\/ §£1‘€5__'1:};1_1`_5__0_&_‘_c_c"_'l:ll_o_/_\>_/_A)_'{;Ma_I_Cau_‘$f A)__a_l_é;"ll_b()_ JQ _ ____'B__/_"Ca_s’o/U__ £or’ 0_1)1‘€;11’0/\1 L_s_as_£______oll_o@_f_; (1 ) ` 3 1361 11666» 11161 1111 6,6,1_6_116 ,1_6_11_11_1@61~ 1161611 :CQ¥_‘W_ _U_S__[_»_O_[Z _I_/LQ_AM_L;Q_L 3 Q_O H {'0 "1`/1‘< 106 1161 _L{qcD_//c_La_I D¢`S_+L»/Q't_(:©_{_l_[_'{____ Of ID`€$ 60;¢~1>/.7;61/1$ l CnverNM¢/v+ 0 FP1'61'¢1 U o’f` §Alal Cc:zur+ //\4/10_/6 /_U_o__ _ _}';1_1_[_1,1)35 Or‘ §duJB/ucls off`a¢+< and Ca/\/Clc.l_$l.au_$__o/_\)__ _ _w 111 111_0__\/_11_13_ 31 11$01__7'1"11_<;¢11_111_1\20._10_\11ad_»)§__ l 5A161 Co<,;a;‘}_€_ 1_06_+_1.1_ llr'$jt__):/_c_+)_ _M;/v_ faward_ @J__ . _136111_0 66_16 6:1_11 <1_1_16_?/16¢?61111_1561~ 111/61 . _£Wm/ 5_@_ f_ :~_@(/_1_$

@&fv

___:¢;¢_§_QN_OB'_[R_ 1/£16_ l‘~l . Pcil'_{:foAMf-- 'Hv -c)v ?Cd |~er) ZL f ;M_O;~Lio_m;fof;MANclam.a-$_o$.l<.¢l¢ujgacc> lp 73,:,£¢2¢1.);%:_0_? ‘*__~,C§I‘_¢'/*_.')_L'A'zcn_{_£l;///»ec¢/.$_c).f`_`:]:j_:psz»¢§~,‘:/:r>~»<;1<:).'/rl./)_`e,l_`)'LLu:__LO*w.x‘sr;__l %CQM@_Q;MJ;AY@QCLY_ _J`\_foc¢ci$_'@/.uap_<§:Af_clg§»fo.)u§,_‘__*; QA)_<§_ZQ.Q,_`LQ@_LL/ __QA)_@A;,-;_l_|j@@;lj_}_/_’l@i¢o_p :Fo .r~ ' _MAqu./zl.as*w_a;,s_ahgvicqL\/s)_d.'/:w¢,dhw,mfi‘lrm_@__W)‘c"”» _O_N_§_[Z,_Z[£\o l 4 j P@H"H.o',uer'§ Fc§a:b_hié>'_[c)~ @_’CAFMG.@_QM.UM_ +w_Qf%LQ_c11~¢1)_{@[’[email protected]@£lm./_L@/_A/MLQLM?_@S__ '_,a)_'v__.<>_»:v_ _¢M/_a/qz/v_¢¢+¢aMA¢y/.L¢A../M@/,<@La;_\/_J_B;lel_l_bo§, ;_ _ QAJ_. \_ ,u_ _Q§_'L@/_(.C>j_é_l@_IH_)_.$A_¢:J_QO.u,L+_a. _ce_/Ju_cl~c,,zucfzalw_r;l;+__ ` `,_o;flm,g,¢v gmu,g;_(,¢»_,;%bj@_¢u%_w_hi§t{sz¢u_¢)_nd~_e/:,~_.W_R;zl.,_,l_l:l`_~o_z__

_;E\°;MHQAL~¢,EW}Q;¢):¢}>~>/___&b #\'scci$ +.~o - }Do'H/\ QQ¢,_LL~}_:{ ‘ , ; b @;Mw, 721 few I;’_¢_@@/JQ,;L+@./A_QM+; af . ` _G__/_$r__dA)';c$$/_@O_c_e/\_){} ;EAASj_@Nj_ZZ_L@@d`_U_€QKd/§ML* , ‘ ;%%;@@_O"£.BM-A§7_A.45_MD_ _Z‘_z;_?f£i~$_£cy_lr“_£cuj_u_b’_t_~/;Q____' ~ ,__A)lk/_)Q__ _/_3¢;£¢1-,£,€9~_~¢/:_%5,645:€{ l'o@ w m"l' h ,<w{ b~cz)\) 1 ` "_D_'/J_mlssi~¢:d*:§:`ol_A/_QA):_QQQ!QZL¢LA)I__OA)_£)Q):.lLQj_Z_ZOLV_._ §B~C:i¢:‘él:QA/£z_r_'maj_/zzzml:£_ca.m¢z_;t_oi$_u_cé,_QL‘»:.S"J_'S_S):O.@ , ' __ _ .-alf?ji/:);a.ib;c_l_'zu.=/:/_u`cf¥:§_!:)!l§)j_'ia/QH_LS~ZQWHLC_,WN ` ,"_`_l-a.A»,d¢/:y.aj_/,u;a$mgio_io*/_°@i,:{£o_/vcr’.<" l~eH~cr +p f)_L/~é H,g_¢)_§jzg/.“__;_- ___?@1;€):[¢`_`£Qr_'&am(~,é‘§C/J§L_/M[¢_%_/_rab_&£Z§AA$j~wMQS_aV/QUL~*_ _?.L)_b_ajfw_a'§_`}:/:c_<_$im§o.c$;a~_£ "L[vlljz¢~_¢>/:Lw r ¢/'}? ’, - ' _~ 7%//'! /‘cf/?<€/< 150 r ur)rl@%;wg¢;$:_e)_c./LQM)§_QQ@J_@,Q.a_l_'i,,_._ . MM¢;;M£@ML@//_u /Q ~30» 3 01 51 A/c)/u» GO»?,A//ayf,

-"3010 Ll'

(_3) P¢ll lo Ncr'§ 070/3 /1 CalroAl_JN_Cd cl$;§_A/Oll_c>_"l_l@o;»q,wa$_ _A/_ tv_cr~ ay&cue¢:wl_@/u +h< Mer~zfl; by_wa_7_o;l:_l_"ac.l\sja¢/ucl~_»___ _CQA)LlyT§/'Q/u __Qf`_ I‘_~€_Co/u/‘-r~€/LG/Q?(/G/U ila ll)~€ fgt/afl ala _@L//:L/_A/@‘ //:Z/f_;¢Z/J_ Cl_'l: /_jc)rA_(_.< ' __ _&ls `.'l:/ c/.`AJ_~c¢CJ_ w_ wayj_ all S'/_'\ 15 S:cl_b_tlcaa$l€__iéz_l%_*“<;+_ £r,l~r /-mw¢ Qf<;@af_q:_~/m ~c/<_<_»¢e¢l 5@_ cl 7~¢;/;¢¢,;+ wh_ Ic;/)_ L§_WOLO./"\A~Ol¢c_l</MO_¢<LQ/U I"~le:‘zall ll 07 ~ jCc/Y`/") 610 0}‘1‘7(‘3©17 lO`l~C‘lw l~,‘o/\/fr§ £W/:cq /'G/U . `;F_c/rrh_ wa;l¢z)i lll//`M¢}_ o_/_\/_ 5 lm/?¢l" j ' _N_€c¢)_llculs_~c¢l @lmlwlsl ows_$uc£) l_ZQL/ cle wu `* . LJ/u~c ‘.7 l`/g AP 75 F~¢’l“/»_ll much Hemo/“a/w/am .- ' ' '_w_ QLQUC*$`O_ 04 cf)ijl;LLCOx£lL§QlleJ_l:o _chcl]l"~e§§_l/L~(_LO /5§_6€_ C_SHD_I”_C§;@/_\Ll~_fo/_lj l£:)_<;c;¢_/`//v _lo_ol_<_ w _aj‘_ 09~€:/1/%'0/\,¢;¢_5_/4:£/»1@ m/~¢lQ/n _J_ 1621 c~'eg@l~¢cl g_¢? 1117 w ,J¢/LQLN__ @/l_ c)_ /_\)_ W‘C~/~/Ho;wm»<>lalns 0_ N_l i__-_ 695/9 l / 561 ")L//u\/ _,A ll_}?£l)_k_ v j_/)`CF[/T¢/'_?(:l/_QN:¢ £_30_/[;2!;/‘1_0__ `l:lloAL;/`o__g ~c:;l;l/\L__'/:Q_ CO/\v Azllczu_f; j/?_M_’/'_ w_q,f_ cl~L/\,;ch. "l~}» e,\) /Ocl/l\/o/»~¢ r' 'JLS’ OLA/")/A`fcl /é_l /D/)_l_/c@al~¢o/\> A>__QFSAH~LVJ_ )SS.L/ lille buf;___ l l;C§ SO/\/ l)_ /5_/5_1:5.10 £_Q¢)_olg___»»\ w_ )Ll`_ w_QS;Ql$QA/¢l col ` _Cw`lj;_@ Wl:_c0r/ ll<,»,u Orcl~`gr‘

l FlofL/'

°“» @ <L/~)

CDONC/QSlO/U. P¢l>¢`l llM/~cr‘$ l'ml)+ lo rlu~c nr\()¢~e§$ 4 _ula,§_€cmz§‘l:dnlil Co/U§l/'_uc_l/l/¢¢_l} cl~c/u\'.~ecl a)\wl all ' \ AIU_/A'_"`/" ib O ax&l_fcu;wj_ '0 03 l.`l_'~"~c/ QSO_<,¢:{: U€CD/\»»x) lam/l l)/»\ ’F'@; >v/~F/,e|“ lc¢ V‘, , O,l} leallU/D ., -

C l@ l/~l \/er l _ whtrwel`o)“<;/, mr~cM/';'U 6 U/u§'/¢/¢cfcfl/. pf+llw/om~ef

C,Q)l“,l?ll$. /)r,/,}'f$//cz/u,l. l`DKH/“lllc;l»c ll{D/Y glenn 'l~o cl . <l~alY /”C',Wal-;cll /M/nwpl/Me/vf` 297 -l~/rc’ Dlr_'l`r¢f`l~ (Dl°£/“l<:)" C) V'rl£~c O{Vf:)f;!l/l)~es @0¢0\/`/*/1/ /Y@r,/¢l~§/, Q/!/G/ (§¢le)’/< él> l>l fg;/)A?~eQ/_s’ g)jl:'_` /w</_L§

`??~cs/p¢c_ll`%l l\/ paulk/145 775/07 #lé'y/<l??` ` D/+lc 1°/ 54015' l @€F“llplccle rs’l"<§er\/lc¥-€ )

. 0 /\/ .

§’lczl(rn~e/vlv’ m"-r ~l~rc,¢~c a./\/ol C@Wrcl *l\o l~}\~r£??<e§l` .

C)‘l? M7 l<_A,@u.\l~e'cl)o.e/. abel $a/// /’/07(/0/\) wa! S‘c/¢fl` l`o

;%H@l §+QHOUAU_<.+/m /¢,.X,+<w?)/ w 319 2315

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.