Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Pirpich, Larry Eugene

Pirpich, Larry Eugene
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided April 28, 2015

Pirpich, Larry Eugene

Opinion

@z.\`lY/O' , »¢/zk; 2/‘@/5’ - v _ _ RECEN§:§'§ §§\§ _ " - - ~ ‘ MQW~FQ»§ md ¢=\FEAL § APR 28 29"5 z¢é’€// /¢c@:r_, é&..»_/<_ . Ab*@§ Ac@s":a,€;ietk ~. dew/if é%¢M/MAL j?’/é%é$“ ' /90 501 /z_, 08 M 734 787// y /€Z/:’ ¢¢/K” 93 //é'?_~-»<Q/ aff M[_Oé/;C§Z-A* z,@¢;;»%@ M,Q ad_/__gc,,¢ gaf/fm f /z/ "/%7¢2>,1/ 75 '§/Tz,j/@ ': AM</ %f/%¢'¢.J;_' WJJ£J:,-/i§ )%Z)z 157/ig _/;1/ 773 ` /%’@z@ /M@&@¢OL /¢M _ %Kc% /HA»,¢€; 'ZZS/ @.ez._>¢, /;\MLAS /71/ 725€/ 54ij ¢Wj; 1a ¢XM @M.@;z /¢/@?

M/<»A /12,?;5@ ¢M>@zzA/i;. 7: %A, %z;/.Q,,/Nz/ _; Wézwé/§G:-_J;’A£.</ JJ,@/M,dé/;é ‘sz/ MYZ/%' X=¢\ M:,¢»?/Hé¢;z ' g%/~é_jm` Uc)é 75@6> Aé:-;:{::z:a¢/”“>< ` , » ` : _ _ -M;;? A”?M /l/O. 06/ §5"2 » /4 Z)< /p£/€ 7'€/ § Zq’?;/? b/;s”?»“%‘/;/" fw¢¢/??" éi:v€»€'///S 0/1/ § <QM/z/"/?

» . / [/%£V _%,QW/¢"// / _ § ‘? h??£;¢?fé; @/ 7;.")(/?;5“

WN/‘MA/ 731 @/j;¢z;,\/_§»

7: ZZZ 377//71)/_§’7£¢7 55,¢@7'° § dca/1765 jan/cy fagg/a )€/€»;?'E#/, /¥/€@%¢:.,/¢ ,\/7' ,`A/ sz, AL~/ew »/zéw!é¢z£é£ 557/ida wm /,’/,,§/6 742 /+;/4/¢,;/¢; UJc/M':;'A/.<» 7:; Yz:Q/£M/-@»’ /?/¢NMM;¢,,\, " AA/z; %@@@¢: %;/¢'4;/6.,» .,/ /Zc)" “./ Z"m/¢A»:L;M/y of faa/f 54;¢& U§§zczj.§»/r /7/€£, /?.5' f§>///o;/:' z /“§Zz>/Mé 5“ taff/icf / /¢///¢'¢:'Mrf 229 /I/ 0 7" /%M@ 颢;/r;' @A/ /%4/€@// /§' 2@// ,¢5 YZ/~z, £;>Mr 57~%1725; (//l//,J(r ,,//¢7' //./ /ZM;_, /) l 7@ ‘%z, &wT/<'A€/ /W¢M».?'//M¢(; /M/r' /_m./(/ //Wv/Zz@/,T,¥ 05 L<¢z;",./_z» £x Fm~zz: %L£»,¢>M, /1/@. @5/5;<2 »~/,¢ /Aé.£ '72.3@ AA/'/§/r/'(?F afa /;¢zz:»_”/" _ /. (£o#f'/J) /v/O/»/’%‘: »¢,1/¢€ Mé,. /z.z¢/e., 527£.»< ;» 0,/ Sz/;’§¢ gen § &/2. , (/7§, amf »3 k;:é/;»fz/»w of Al¢z$,’@.j Z. A//A¢'¢M:r cj¢,§cz? 72 7%'€, dea/a 731 %//J//'A'/a 722/f d C%€/;:»'°'/"'SF/€,€ /é ~. h/_ood/M¢€aé /;/':.yoz/.;¢/€DC % d`l€¢’A,/!!é£., jr(/£}akdu¢“`?: b ( /{A.éé;;/.é /!/¢ 55", Wé/VQKE‘M/Jé/¢/"?") 5/}¢/=’/7 acci/y'?/`Z`/Z h/§W£Am;<¢£s" /f/€:M @/ é'c?? mz;/,,,r M;,€;£zz;/M d,zéé,,;\/¢., ,4-/%;%7_' ma _ AA/ 0/’/@/<%;//}"7 7‘;;` @/¢Z'é /€€ZM zw;z£_z\é;/.

L/a@J/M.<z€s" N’§$A’%w/'l£ 4',»/§7/\'/§‘ __Aé,:>;_¢fi: "7'.; f A’, h/Qoz(/»A¢!/€.¢é é'/.d,/,L»~s:' ja 57ng ;'zM;/MZEAF'/a.

7/:;~;"., .¢¢g»',_',,,m;/¢ 772 amf 431 /;/ /zM,,\/ A.w/_'_ /,`./ w',z,,`??f/z, iq /y,,/;(; 75@7*,,"» 5/,§,¢/,’ %,i/;,§;L€_,_ / L\/o@_ WCM,@C /l/Wz/¢ metz 73 /7)@/€¢¢}/,~/ ;/z/M_

%/”/p颢?a/»/‘/';" 675 lzcj;§/»d<' ix /‘2.,27<: H@`f/;¢A, /¢é. 04 /5"5“:2 'A» /Aa€., %Te/Z€. ¢z. (c¢wrz€) %z/ a/z//7 ;I/$'J’Z¢€, M"/% ///0,%¢'¢/,\/7' .J)A/ ?7’"270 océa_"¢¢bdy, /€¢2, ;:»'A>/e¢?” 5125‘5¢§>,»!:/ ¢»/ML fico‘e¢£f A/ZM,<.S'/@¢,J/' . M>@¢&/A,<¢C 52‘22"§~.: A/z zA/zA/'?~“ M z,z 215 d/'SCOW.<_£/g' /io///¢"¢€&C, § 715 562/723 A’//af, , A,?" ga x//A,z££,»z;/j c/é.,/¢/€_ -M£/ éw`¢[s//c:§../ .¢z/oa£/€d€ ga _:’.¢¢r'§:z'c‘/SA/T 75 /é;/p(; /’9'.'<5} Aw;(`/?

752';,,7’ uaw/56 /<-./ a ZZ`a/¢ '/`Z'@MGA' //3» A>H"¢Za,yf /SZX 75 MFMZ‘L.§A/ ,},’ did >7/.€@/4 //.,`/!z¢> j/¢/@poxé 73~////£¢`¢,\/7"<" %M/»l/\/ aff /Z:C é.ci_?./ A»A/¢L ._/,%<<'/Er h/@Q¢FM,€.¢Z, 5@{.4£, :,///»'/c€../ /‘/)/ jiZ??/‘¢g»\/?? 75 //;é¢':<;~/ »\/;~:/€<, /%B,e_. 7; M/ /7/£?»1~,-\/¢€# M/A-¢eA/M'/z,/ ,M/? /‘1/ M'/'Q: .'z .{/4:7§;.7£/\/‘7' aaa 7§"5'///'»1‘>»//¢ h»{a/,c/¢C ZZ/ dial déa/;/s”f" m€..,,f

/7/4¢¢»73' 295 ¢c“Z;m/ {)( .K"d/<'?"E, /)/AA"¢/ /. 05§`)€7"/4 /Odé§ 5 001/il ¢- M§Q¢ZA/a,e¢é mfa/2229 w::/<‘a;, 274 //a?”°' /‘B/<£.

50 » ;/27§»/¢/22,7’ fz‘izi~?';>,>/V we 22 730 ~/~:; m;¢,¢. M 1222 272/21 /£¢/,,;~ 255 t //é fail Z/,/J-' /£m¢/,¢Ji, of civ f ,,/(zf§A/M%q/"}` 721/7/‘?')047 /_,/ 2252/y '7’ /¢zy€/ ¢2. ¢Xa/~/c.éj: /,W¢Z. a{.., h/wp(’@.%@¢é 0//_7 /.,/wz, /'T $':»;5,. m/\/ 7,€/79.; /.»£. /‘7&¢(£,, /;:¢€ 1642/iga fewer 3.. l/V~/oo¢€¢/a@o@. %26 /f/o>" A¢J¢//'s"a,» AY*/€-’F.é?‘:.c:,////» 7"'““/3";/¢/7"“ //3' 624/7 79¢2.¢1. A/<:M,[¢.C/"_. @/£/ ;¢.s's.;_,a(§ gaacX/_>“T/“" 1427 ./:'v" /i`¢(£{<?m@ Qw,e?’ @1/;/.’2/1/6:/ //y 7/, 72%'3¢¢6% h/@¢,¢c¢/M¢z, /j§ M z)< ~» esq 2 /c;/,e»¢¢< /,€.p :£¢237274 , //‘M€, _ 421/m z/.~/.>“' W£acz;;/@a., 577£/€/`6/\£§¢€ ;n/ /Z/¢/:¢€A[ ZQM/<:/‘“' AA/:¢C, /¢/22¢55_' ¢:/¢z¢,,y / 2/¢22z 52¢€,/ gagged /¢¢Z?Zké’,:~. /¢/~z, ,éz:é,(,¢{.,_/¢/<'/ Sz;zs' 722 1245 /?'d’/¢ 2(/" dai$§,§.“ ind @.5’ 722.§'. /724/££'222 72 OAO»"Z¢Z/i;/\/s° Z>¢ 27227€ 2422/221 A/o , 22/5‘:*2:2? /'222, 2522 3. (€02\//’2£:) 7: 522/y /€2 2/0/2¢&€_ /I/é/o'z'/~?. 222/<2\/ 2,` /Zz .<2’»./7" /2"'27’ 7%.2 )"¢{:C:S“ 22122¢!52€/€‘252¢2,40€. 2%5’~€/ AJ” ¢/A//;S;'>’.s" 622/447 //22» >( /a /22<, :532222 2202/2222222.“7;2/227” 24/1/ /2'/?22:777`§2 ,;221/ 2/22.5‘ 2260/2123 b /:<:” 2222 c,€’om_s" 2221/if 2’22*’::2;:' /222};.

MoJWA/aa€, 225 /22.`.2€_. "S',Qo 2 “">""/ z;; 2222€222:2\/'7' //Ff/¢ 222/73 242/26 7227 /’/7242/$. 2/22¢2:2</2€?2»;'6 222 /2;’?2;€¢ 2573 _\ /73" . (}»€24'2/12 722/f /27‘2'"72222?7” 2./2.¢ 222%272'2@, j é./ 242/225 221/y 722:»£'“2:»‘ /'%ij ./2222. ML 522..§¢2/2,2€ 222/275- /%2,€‘?2{~ 75 522 25222%‘/2“22€ _.

2/2 /"Z‘é 6221.2<7’"._? /221/2142\/6 229/242 £2/2(£2</2‘25_$,.‘ 2/;.2_ /22!22<2£.` 2222/2 5‘/2‘?2/2.52/, 2422/ar 224 22/2`2/22\/¢ z/ 2¢§ 222/z H/ae_ 24/2, 2222;122"} 222 272'._'2@ , 24 2%22'@€_. amey/26 52€.2, /\/O 124 72{2?/' HFV/<`JM 511/y 522% 242/l //1/%¢_"3'7§2»2?/?32\/ l/\/ /?" 5 0216¢/2\/€-2, /4////2°2£2/7' 242<.5’ 222/2222 721 22.9`§‘.;~ 222/2 ~£><v 2227"<; 622/221 Aé. 22/23~2~2¢ /€/2’,€ 5'2>`¢ //./ (2’02\/7"2// /;22'2 /272/... 2/2”0222'§/277/?€"§' '/‘;; /2€¢> 223 220 §§ 442/245 ¢?==>/‘/¢1€2€/¢///\'7@ 722 722‘22€2,'2, 222/22 571 ,, m~»¢',_.,.,., /6222{“~:_021/: %262 713 242 //\/2;222€-.¢" 6@2,£'/232/, / 5`. /22€212722 22€_, 2a £{?7/2, /12/<=22€,2 '”Z¢/») €<12;2,2{ 2 522,,., 7?,;§ 2222/7 22/ 2212/322 22;/; 272/2222 22.222€, 222 22 M/’% 2{2¢°24/~7'£2\/22<22222/ //f 23£(’£/.2/2'7" 6°/,".22;215`, ./é. 272/2227 2§,,`222:? 73 722 ,/@22/'3-' 2252 2§2:2“2?2/ 2/22'2.’52"22?225. 2422/222 /2/ 222/2£._ ..2;2*‘:k 77?/2;.;/2 5222\(>'2(:: ¢/2,_2222/9 22 2227 2222/az 272 21 222 ~~ 222 2222/2222 n °_' .2./» 1 ' » ,;.’ ‘ 1 /~ ` T.

2277/2 .242?2”2;2.22'/5" %/£2.22222$ 2 262 2241 272/7»?2/22072?-§ 22 2:/.22 -'7 2222/2752 27 212/7 222/2222 222 N 272 2272/7 2727 722 22 222 2222/222 2622/26 /772 . Lz/Oo&€ d<\/d.@o@. 2</¢£,-§ Wk%£>~<;, 2 . g (/f//Z/J/sz(¢ S‘ af 2627 /V;. /cy /7'/€2 2222/2222 212/222 . c: / /2;/2%21/21’5: i:.

272 /Q, 2222/222 ./22/.».,222/ 7:; 222 223de 722/2222 777/2270 755 c)&/é¢zf;`,\/§ , fm"i/“‘~?; 777/74 775 0 é/zs~z.~ »A» /€767, 5777/\/ 7. 619sz )d{`ch¢/s¢z% _f (75/1/2'4§/./»§;/¢;,/7, ,77.@¢; b.¢?mm£,, wl 770 fy/ZZ€MC€//énf.)h/A/ 75 /Z/§€. MQJM/A/€a@ /7€<>¢7 A/'§ /}///7:7*/,.<`5,2'5:2/. .b, //7/`1'/7/§/6.;§;-./1/5.~/§/ /;’7/7{ 777/7 b777 72/7;)-/£, 7777.':;§,1/7797 ¢://'¢}C /7/¢7' 7775’.5'~7:57‘§, , 7a /77/ 721/§/ /.£¢7§" .\ f (é'./\}MA/6s“;. ./Z;/» /{"j 77;;, /€_g£g_;g§(€, £aA/Z§z`f.»[§' /VZ .4/5//..}£"§7~/¢€/ :>7¢/7€%<"7;»:/“?~.. "/°" 757 75 .5?>:'¢¢ 771/5 »- "",7;::/\[5", 7$¢{£.»/7?077 M%(¢./a;,z€ 5{,'¢;" 05¢,1/“ 7//\7.5"./,7,~7.¢"&;€7:€;1: 7%/5¢;¢1¢/57? m/¢ 777/ham 739A 772§§77/15§/ /}i,/ '772:, /Z.<sz/x/éz@ 5/`¢¢@,. a F 775 75 fdic 'c@,€,QQJAQ/a¢/?§;(‘, 72 d l ~.~.5..,,=.,..~ 7777?5777;"{£;€, 70 »5/57§7/7(57_/, 7 7737/77¢,`6'/? .

81 7777,¢'@}\7“" @§'7:471'<" 72: 279 555/2777 57’¢-'£7;/»'7;;/\/ 572/7 777 /06,,15, 777/awry o 777/757 7 721 57,5;€, 757.5,,7‘~ 777 377 5//2(£@ (¢7¢¢,`/57[€./.¢7\/ 771/aj 777 » v 1775/777 %é._.¢" 755 277/carry 775 75 77777¢`57,,¢ 7':25- 5..7%/’/£/1/2? 771/06 27§./ /€Q&.é£f/é{£/ 5’€71/€¢:7... l

777/5¢¢»~7'$' 67 éc'Z;»//_s' £)< 575/1775 770/537 /l/Z), 07/§‘.5'2 /f 754/572 752//7" 7. 547/4555»47' ¢Ozw'é¢:?? ‘/’5 77 1€/ d-.»>M,Q'??' 775?;?.€ /'7/:\// /¢7;0/\/7%%/7, 71§,2 /3/;/%€ 871/rudd /;//£’£/Q,é.? jé/\// 72M55.' / ,,`557'7£'>71555/722265 7¢€,/) 777755/5,¥;7; 677/§§ L f{éd.. //\/ YZz//s' ¢.’”62.‘5’5/ /5’% 60//2”7:</»74 [}p,\/M$’g/(;/,¢§A/.z"¢, /0, 74775{¢;75»7` 07¢7;€573‘ 775 272 457/537;7:'.2¢::7’ 615~51/<‘7' § /7»7 l 7555;575:, 75777§/ 57 775 5'7:5~5.:5-» 7575<5;,A/ 57 515 712ch 052/§ 7500 175;,5' 777/777 555/77/`5'§5555\,. ( 5,1/ 775757 35 ZQ/Sj 7575/,;/5 777,75'5”7 57 777 07-7%>/5 2517/fy 725 /_75 557/77 755/727£:@ 57/`5(7/\/255 , //5 777/76`777\7 776 7:7'£5£_ 775/755 §§5¢/€573;;' /’77775)/<’/6/\/7/557»7 h 5925/ 77755`{, /3, Zo/_z, //55/5 5\/ [/// diggs 527/712 571/727 57 755 7@75¢71{7 0£5€'~5,€__ . // L/ozmjc/. %/?//f/ 7/;/6/5'¢412/ 62//7{:§€ /B'IM.W 5//7 95 77757" 775 5,/7.,57,5./sz /`.¢ "7/'575:/. 77 775/55 577 777 13 25»/§; 77575, 57557 757/57 557 705».»,» //55/553527>2 75555,

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.