Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Coronel, Israel

Coronel, Israel
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided May 13, 2015

Coronel, Israel

Opinion

7 owe viii A/o¢ wo%@/el»-T(Ai %§i:¢s§§zi’,i 1 1 § 'RELNOR, ` § m ine:z€zmbg§,gi_@ M;§§g”\,/§DAF \/» § » DisTRicT comm MAYIS 32015 PEALs Ps*:iizii§'ii%:zi§izii,:zii § ‘>M/“S‘M R'Espowoeis T‘ ' § C°SFH, Clerk A,, BLANT:FFS' om@mi\i APPLicAT¢oN FoR wch oi= MANDAMusTon; H'owoRA.izii; Juo§s oi= sm comm “ comes wow, ISRAEL coRoNi:L, Re,laior, pmse in Hi¢ cibaim-s+§led and numb~ emi Cciuse o(:ac’riovi and F€\esMis Ofigi‘via\ Appl)ca+i"ov\ For \i\lr\'lr 0(3 Mowdamu s, pur- SuOi(l+ {`0 /\\’jr\cl€ \l 0752&`\`0»/1 :S@ <>§ JCM Texa$ Coc)e 0€ Cm`mim\ Pmcedure,/ and wouh} show jr\ w \'Coui'jr H@e €0\\0(1)1»/1§: B _Eima I» 0\ ls<ae\ Cmovw\ii)c§# 178056‘1 is an o(Ceviéer inmce_wi¥ed m ‘rl/ieTexas Depovim€v\+ Oc Cv`\w\\¢iu\ jud\c€_o,iié is appearing pro s€, who am be \OCaJ(€é Ci`i Rams€§ Om 0an 1100 mass RA.,RO§hmn,Temg 775233. \.OL Rel&jror preswi+€c§ his remedies bujf, ‘lr`\iere are oier issues Jr\/i<x* s\m)u\c§ be imm/1 'm cons`iéemjriovi becau~se'ji\m Ccise was <c\`\sec! ama based ivi oJi\m case which 15 R%\oijroi'$ Sovi and ‘Hi;.police repml”<,)as OVI\J ovi fieldva Sovi§ Ca.$€» \.05 The adc soug\nli +0 be compe\\€b is mrnislieri`a\, wolf discve`i\"onarij iii erom,T C,C, P, A<\L. \\.O`l Se,§ri`ovi S@ uni'ies R€$povm\evijf Jm immedi`que\g+mmsm\`¥ lro +Me Coi>¥ ¥ o(" Ciimivwi\ A\>pml$ q Copij o€ jim qtpp\i'wi“ovi (Zor ci)f ii 0€ \/ic\\)€ (15 ' . co~<pus{oivig answers F{`ieé,uvu§ ace<lri‘€icaie mci+ivig im daer iupovi which ibid §ivdi"ng was ma€',i(}lr\ne Conui'cjri`ng courjr decides H/w.`r jr\ne\'{ m rio issue S +O be ie,..<,olw.dca l\la copy o(l"r\,ie qpph`coijn`on gov wr€+o (' habea$ cargo s,cmy wis sweig meal and ace<¥i€icajce iedjr\`iig Hie 6ch upovi wl/u`d/i ‘r\/iqi €iv\ding was . 'Fa§,¢ \ bg 5 ' made lieue beevi§mvi§m‘lled la lli@ Coui§e§Cvi‘mi"iial Appeal.s' lle sucl`vi documevils loeevi §veivi§iviilled le §lie Coui§o§ (vi`mlvial Appwl$ §)9 Re_spovidevilais requlred lou § §§cilule, Releiler woul ld lwe received m§lee §iovi/i llie Coui§O § Cflvvi\"vial l§p peals , ll. (. REse. uiiiii:ii'I _ - Zl» Ol ’ §€Spoiid€i'il GAll`l FlTZ-$\W'\GN.S, iii lief/lii.s eqpoic`ilu eis §)is§vle§ Cler lie §l)oill<;i$ Cc>uvi§ii,lexas lies a vii i`vii`slevial ldui§g§e iecei\ie evid §`\ecill papev s `ivioieviviii`via\ ` ` pie ceedi'viii evid pei§ovm cill elli@i dulles imposed ovi §lii c leila logl aim pursuoivil le l C C A A<§. jt il evid` is iespensil>le uvidevT. C C ll ll 07 SeC 3(€)§0 liviviiediii» §el 9 l§mi/i.sml§§o §lie Coui§o§Ciivviivvil llppedl.s aeopp olllvii cippl llcallovi §or willo§ habeas Coipus, cupp avisiuefs §il ed evid aceili§ievxle reavlan llie dale upo vi culile§ii §\/i<)i§ §lvidi'vig weis mode `i§ §l.e coviulc§iiig ceui§ decides §l/idl §l/ieie are lie issues lo lee iesol liled CAR‘( l’|TZs'it/iiloiu$ bis§ile§l Cl eve Diilles Couvil§) mmi lie sevved oil lW /liis place e§ §-loii.sl lviess ci§ 63 il Rivev§vovi§ lSl\id l.B il l)ellvisll`w 75107 _' ll l D. vic)iiiiieiv QEAiiiicii; ii,01 evz‘iie‘iegis code de cviivviiiii iiivi;izviiivig 1’).0\ Tlie Respovi€l@W/l VlOlelUl A‘llc-le lL0'7 Secli`ovi S(C) 0§§lie’lexois Cede 0§ Cvi‘viiv`vial Viocediire bg §cii ling §o provide a copp e§ §§ie appl lieali`ovi §ov w ii‘§o§ lial>eascoip iii cupp answers §lled evid acev§i§ieo§e ieci`livip §liedale open §l/ia§ §i"vidivig weis made §o §l/ie Cc)ui§ e§ Cvimiiivil dippeal$ will/iilvi§lviel§iiie prescril>ed log lam evid wl§lii\vi ci iedsovial)le_ v §iiiie §rovvi §lie dale ovi uiliielil liedoeu mevvls were repuesled le be§vaiismilled. '3. 01 Repues§s gov §lie§raiisvviillel o§l'lie qppli"coili`dii §oi wii‘§e§lieleees corpus/amy avisueis §il ed and ace(§i§i`é!kle sedlli/ig §l/ue dale upon idl/ilCl'i~ll/,g§§{v\d¢`iqg weis vm(}e,a)ere made l>§ llelal'ov le balla$ D`is§i\‘Cl Cl€€k GARV Fi'TZ€lMMOM_S DQlleis Couvilbi,l>§ vvicii led lelle<$ da§cd Mavcli IZLO|S“., cin flag ‘l ,QO'lS`. Also, l>§ mis§eiie was sended §0 lelles " ' page ll e§ 5 4 _444444 s * ' (l§v,vv`lg a P(av,-l;€é§ Oviglvioll Applicallovi €ov vilrl§ o§ llavidavvius poisoan §o )lv§i'cle ll 07 SP,CliOi/i 3(9) 0 §"lli£ Cod@» U§ C<\lminol proc@dl)(e lime avid &CCUvale Copj O§l'lie above lellevs ave allacl veil lieve§o as l`:xlillb § A and B avid ave liicovpovocled lig ve§€iv€'i'lce liei'€ ivi lowell puprSCS 03 To dale posled `ivilliis \ilvl§o§ Maivlavvio§ Relaloilios vecei\led no vespovise §vom Re~ spovdevi§ vegavdivig Relcdovs seqoesl §ovlravism`illal l@l&wpg O§ll/ieappllcciliovi §0< ai vl§o§`lio§oeas corpus aviiv avisaiers §`i'ledl and ci C€ll`i§lwl€ <eClllvlgllieda§e upon alli`cl/ill/iel §lvvllvig o)os made lo llie Cooi'l 0§ Cviwii`vicil llppecils d lls' is eleal §vovvi Relalov's lellefsl Rel lalo€ lies pirl llespovideiil ovi noll ce §lial llel lalov l seevs lloe lvoiisviill§vl o§acopp G§l\ve appliealiovi §ov wil§o§lioloeos _corpos, app vin~ saievs §`i`ledl avid a cell'i§`icale vec'll`iiip llie dole Upovi alliloli llia,§ §"i`ildili§pl was mile lo llie Coi)<§o§Cvi`mliiel Appeovls avid §l/iov§ sivcli <ecolds ave sepulved l’)p §loe Coi)rlo§ §v lviilvial Appeals lo oiol ovi Re lalovs will 0§lial>ee§ colpu$ llval iviSlviles§lvsl llespovise llve `§vioil Coo'rl Covisi"dered Relalol S claims and llie convlo§liig Coor§ iviadeavi Ovdev Des‘lgvloi§lvi§ issues o§ §aelual coviliove<§ed unresolved lloov§ malplse sesoli/ed lap oi§(;- davi §§ deposili“ovisl inleirogaloi'i`es, ov log heavivig)sl and appolviled A:pvi'\ l § mill/v le legs olve l\oe' issues avvl prepan §ivvl'i ivips o§§@¢§avvl covicli)l<;l‘ovis o § lam §oi§l/ie Coovl Tlae Sla§e made a Si)ppl ovieiilal llespovise §o llieappli`calloiil l>i)l ll is vvisvceess§ull lr>e`cause ll lis mevi iovilvig llie same as lvi§lie`iv §`ivsl Slale`s Kespovise. Relalevleis gone well l>epovvl avip, vepolvevvievv§ovol)llgoillovis lmposed levelle ll‘jllielexas€edv s o§Cvliiilvial Vvocedore lii eovilro;§ le Relvloi§ e§§oi§s Kespovideiv§ §ioos ai liollp §al>led lo Compla oilllii §lie lexas Code o§ C~iliivllioil Proceduvelo a§§o( llelilof §lie plo §esslovial civil coivivviovi COOll€Sg Ol vii/ip aiiil§evi responses lo lvils coivespovidevioeavid sepuesls 3, 05 Av§lile ll 075ecllovi 3(€) cleav lp)slales l§ialli ll §lie coiiiii`c§li/lg codllde<,i`des§lvvl §lieve ave vio sooli issues 'lloe cle.vl\ sliall liviviedlalel_y lvaiis"vvill levvipliosls oddedl lo llie Cooi§ o§ Cclvviivial llppeoils a cop 9 o§llve qppli"cali‘.ovilaviip olvisaievg §llevlla`vid acefli§lc<ile f loape 3 o§ 5 ' m\‘¥\"ng Ji\/)e d<r}@ upon whidz+hw}@."n¥wg was made. Fcu`\vf€ 0 fritch COUFHO wifan Jf\/ce a\lowed 10 days shall com{§jcojre such a (~iw}l`vlg; 'Te m Cod`e o €~vamm\ Pmddw. . !H’r§`cle 11.07 5<),¢ , Z>CC) R<;.spevxdev\} is `m veolq+lomoWs proceéuw,. mma‘s{zr§aldu+€es, ~ ' amd `st lr\ae law o€JMS S+mle' ' - 41 \/.

D. PRME roe Rc~: \EF _ wl+ER£ FoR£,FREM\sEs Cowsloek£l), Re\a‘cor Igme\ Comm\'¥bc#nso§o‘f Pm_se, resp~ €c¥§ollg requesij awang JxMaH\/w R£spov\dev»jr M rw)f hamsm\‘jr éocumev\jcs Jro‘Jr\le Coof+ 0€ C<m`»'m\ 'Appeals edwin meager\o&)ldx`lm a€]rei lr\/le Aajce Jrheg wm qu€$wlea GM() +\/wljr Re» \<fmv broug\n& Jf\n`c_s \`L\L{galviov\ `u/l good Fo&\\A m3 has sdbs{w+§a\lg ?re\l”a\`\eésRe\qim pray S §of am ®vé@r étwc)c€ng Respov\dmjcjr@ ‘\msw»§‘} copg o@Hw qppl\`cd€'ovl €of wu`iLoH/mbeas wyo s, amy cowen G\eb,om) acef{€_€ kch recIHng jr\/»c dade opm wh€~ch¥\'u\¥c'\'w§£ng was mad do lane Co~ uch o C Cx}mi'm\ Appeals as divec’cec§ ha Af{[de il¢07$ec\n"om `S@ 0 @(')r\u“[ems 013 QOEG \“m,'m\ @s'ocedof€ amd as requesjce<§ m hide-ri \e“`e\'s \':)<H‘\)Fll`»"\’/CMXB;

BResp@cjr§o\; 5 §ui>ml`&cd‘ _ RELMO'RC m STME OFTEXAS § COUNTV OF BRI\ZolZlA § E. AEF\D)\y\ 11 » § l scows unde< Oo)f\a \r\m¥ 5€\/1@ ends avw§ auega]c\`@vls’ `WLWL above A\’PL\CAT\()N FU(L wm 01= Mz\m)mus emma aw) umw ,ZA/)/a»¢l @M/u/ _?\EU¥TOR _<;»;K;NF_\) umwa am smm=, ME, @V\ ms +\M, \\*v} gag 0 c mg ;zocs.

Page‘| 0(; 5 \~'.. C§m\\=\cm c)FsEv\v\Q hereby wh€g W§v wm m @C+W Q!MAPPucmww m mm or mma- MUS was S€NWY 0!!1 bands Cou!"wjfg C\M\\\)S pmch acopg iv\ §\a,@ U.S, Ma§\ac)r)<esse§ 3m `D\Sm\cr wing saw Fmsmmow.s m c\s. Rwej€ron+ L@ 11 vallm,T><JS 107 on irm é+‘*/ 509 o@Apol §015, Av§ was mailed Jto game 013@¢6$5»,. And Jr\n?s second +we cow 09 w aw@ APPLchwN For< wm oFMAMDANus was sawed on vallas val§i Clev§ bg ?wtwg anew ivdm 0 SM_@I£ adaws§@c) +00 OLST\z\cT CL&R\< came Fnzslwwa\)§ m » }\) R\`\)@<Fco\n§ LB L'L Da\\ as TX 7§2()7 om‘fhig+\/Le fl Wl ,§wd 0(~ Mm_, 'M)['€ and mailed +\/v; C\ E§\< A%EL ACO§TA (`o r lane Comjr o@ C<im\\na| Appwl s ansame dante Hae \lW §cv.y O§ MO~S 9-0[1)

j §K(((gwéroca# /`7@0 §0‘/ §wmg¢g Ovu>. Um"\\* 1100 FN 655 §§ ROSWMT>! _77583 Pag; 5 of- 5 ch§e- \4/)0`7l /\/0. WO%()/ 61~7`@\) ` ISRA;L coRowcL, § mw \76050‘* n\z LATOR. § \N me '.135€® wmuAt \/. § D‘\sm\cr could baum CouMTY msTR\cT amc § bALL/\S couNr\{iTEXA;$ m HeR/ms owcth Capm§g ' Res?owmzm; § O R D’E R , On +§»Eg §ag(came wire be\xeo.r§ 4\;1@ eoregoivxg Relajmvé App\i'cc§ri`ow §o( Wr§r OF Mw§qmus and i+ appears jro`]rha Com § Jrhajr '¥\we $ame s\'wo\§ be°.¢__,_..GKM;TEb IT 15 T`R§§EFORE OR\)E\\£D Mu}'lv\w`l)i§§<;& Cle<\<`\mmedi‘ajfelg haw$m€*§`\to §\/1€, » Couxj< 09 Criw\im\ Appea\s acopg QHW_ app\¥cc§dov\ (30¢' a)\x§w)€ \mx\oeas cofgu<,ang v answers G\e§lov§ ace<jd§\`m¥e`vecl"r§v\@ '{\ae/§c§e upon which §\;»&r~§rmsmi§a\ am madé ¢. '

SIGMED onjc\n`i§ Jr\@e.- §ago§ l. U~__;

Pnssabwc. mcf E><…@H "A § 1071 w " _ 7?22§ Cao*se /0@. 1500 ~éOl£/'CK ll/n`Hl/l§, WU¢I~@O!@I~T® fx 01le lsmel formal H¢m.lsm Co<@mlT cx# 17005‘0‘1 t 001/115011€70/11` 9011_711711~1;11 17“;10015’7 _ 110069;11 695 1307 RDSl\wvvl`lX 77 59 3 TO CM§§ \`l"lTZSlHMO_NS bl§l.'l§l_£TClEl§l/\ll\l l)[&\\l§$ COUlkll"{ C€;Owl£(:} 5 Bu§l§ ll/\Q zng V\e'1'601/1/, ll$ 10~ 1 ` Tcxas 75007 “‘l§l$ REQUESUNG 1111>010/11€1101\1 H<oM wmmé) wf)€l 00181“T(A3P110 515 1011111\10751:1\11) 707111: com 09 cu1w11wAL /11>1>1;1115 \ Dm C1e1<1<, lam lsm@\ Cmom\ Cuwevxllg llv\wrcemle§ 111 §amsel€ One 0111 l~, wl I'm §e<;uesl\vcg _ §lwl§ 011 becem§>er 9**1000.,1€0¢0 ml§ew§om Copg el cm applicalclon §01010111§ , 11 117 1111 se 1111 ¢111171 11011011 was wheel 510 1110 30111:111L lilsz umw comm DALL115 COUNT\{ T;x/§ €01@:0€€551119, CCLS€ 00 UO‘l -00101 T® E£ §a§§€ lsmelColz)mal AW/zlgm{~.

11 IM\ C»W@ waived 1111511.§01170100§11 11111061011 1110 0111)10111177,1 111Lh lLl. Tlm Cbu'll(~"\wds §llccl each O'§ 010 allegql€ms sel lia 101 lvll"lle app 1101§1`01/'1 M 001160\1@1§€0 131/11‘€50\11€0 gaaluoll lsswes cblllalm`eqc)l"ve mlzlll§oml 0\1 izlmcl/w’wl /01( §es§i'~ w101'115`§0 l>e 0056§110§ lea lale( frecel\le(l a Slul'e§ 50 pplgmev\§€tl §05\§005{ lb applicalwvl 61 1010 o(§ habqu cocpv§ §i le(l 011 §elvmmg lO‘C\*\/lm§ B¢co.use 431;,11_(»;0111 111/100 01101001 desiaml\wq 1550@5 1_>1011{0111§1 11n1e50l lue¢l €acls 1110§1:11'allo §lle legal ,;,1 000/10 gggl lum/1515 cow§lm§wll 011`5£ Ml1'1`15l011¢1l`5 311§11 15, +o 1001\1127(€1l01111le llmelg llocwcuzl appl llmll@yl €@111111115 o§lmxbeas ;O€QUS lo Coc)r§o§€§lmlml /\ppeal 5‘ ll 07 § 500 l§<xs loew §\1110@ 111011§\15 yasgerl §ll l\m"s dale 5§1/1€€7 §sewl l\/wl§ qppl`iall\"o§bl lvj lo long??? l>agc l ali 1 _ ` ' l 100010 l1`l11l0 melva qmllc¢e €10111 Cb01lol~_€11"m100l llppwls wl»ellze'r or nol ll»e C01)1l0l%C11100110l Appe0ls 10100110\]1\011¥¢0101)11`10*1{010 001 010l'll10`l 010 51 1001 \110€1 ~GOUl'T(/\l 50 llcam 00711010111€§ 5111§ 130111/001 00§111010 me 4110 pmce§dml 06€0111 ll cleml@ _e§lalol{she§ 010101036)l 1000 11l00v1 because ilwas \>0.~ 1110 ell/101 police 10001)1,"0%11 policeéepilmwl: `1)‘ll/111 605 0/,/1001"0/\/1 ll 1005 511/melva l>§qlm£ng) 601v1ll10`l P@+;~lp@ 1101"5 3011[11\11130\ 0>10 1110 001750; `l’lea;se, 5000 me inlmmlaam 0l’»"c0l10ll100 0001101100 000 l0011 00 l0013 0Cl11111 lo 501/1000 ll,O`Z 010 50 applime 500 l\/117 C001l0@C1001`m-l llppealgow)§ all/19 nol 010 Cou 151 09 C1lw11`00l Appeals '1eceiue.1l ll gel, 11)0011 0l1e<11l1§ 005500 *ll11e 0 m00l015? 900 me 01005011@01l@1111‘1/13 ll100 l0103 0lea.5'e. l 7/1¢1/0@00 very 1101/chi /3€5/00¢1[/1///%51)0/0`#2/ " IJM cM/¢/ _ SMCm[y by IsmelCo¢?))/)e[ TOC”.W/`lBo$O‘/ 1710 ge Ram$e 001 000 l ' 1100 01 555 1107 R@sMamn,TX. 775 9 3 519'1100 010 700 /7#90’119 015 W€/1 1015 ., l)ag<>, lock _ _ \A…BH

71a/fw NOM Fro'mf lsmel Comnel#l`l$@b`@‘l Rc\mseg OmLlell' uoo wl 655 §§ Ros§wv§{lT>< 72593 T o -~ * o tzc§lla§l['ozci$;g@ \LCG.§;)~l"\l'Ls\mv\mS Do§llo, gTexa,§ 7520“1-4313 Re§l)§snwe \NFoRMmo§oec§se\§m§o leo 9 mm T(Al Decm C\e§l< law §§quesl\llg €ol lv\&r\vl§l§ow nl~cw;,e §§ wo§vc;c)\§\ ~TLA\., would l;kl +0 Km§w' awol mg apph'cal‘\‘ol/\ llw'll 900 mple lo ser lo§wé lo llle Cou§ lo l~ C~l§vvl/ mall llppeals al A§sl`ll lng appl l§ml\bvll`§ am `\LOT ll<§\)ec§s Co§pu€ gm se ‘Plecls¢.

Sev§cll llo l\qe Coullol§€ll§m`ml ll\)peals. l’l§ polvose ls lo mo lvell§s mllen because l\/ee§e weoll/)ef \ssues lo lake §v\ cons§(lefdl§ov\ al)o\§l mg case issues ll lie lvl §§9 case zch wl engle a l><>l` lee Pepoll, m3 mae was mise<l w§ll/\ anolll¢ll pa lice re @ll mail ol\lw,~r casal as l lwe lmle o;lec), ll/w(e owe rules cl l/low lo Ol) lcll' m qy\ lvrllclmewl ll/lll lvul§€lv§el`/§lo)a§ made close/ll clear§ee,m§ all§rla§l lswol n Ml Uv§$`lgn€rl;r :lvl VfOlallo\/\ el Doe process el level \ Tlm`s` rs ‘lleell§?nl l§mell/ml Xseml lelle§ asking almolmg ll 07 pro se/lppl§cal§aw ale 900 d§cl nolav\sweml /ll$<>,qoocllll mlav)sweee<l lMAppbmlmlb§ \§lllolele/w$, av\ll l meal sow\e explaml§oms l>ecause'lw\l lll egally delm`wl well depr§\!ecl @§myl\ l)le¢ll§ l)lease answe§ lc> ~l§lls leller,ol Sevul l'\ld§~pyl§ca;l§owll. 07 NG WO°l 6019| 'T(A§ l`€) “l\/§e foul l' O(- Cl §w\lw:el l\l)l>€ql$ lo loe Ww€ll /Zg@q%/é/ Mn/bml'\fled \\ ’/ f g ! 5/) ,. ll </ v § much , 5 4 7114/l ga 3 y mccall 4915/ad Cowz/lel ::LZM ha 5e706]#[73050 ll

;QlcoemJ/gj j;Uhe Um'

posij 7§¢55' 775'€ 3 flawed and/md fla lee Mm‘/ w m §§1§5 eha ¢/f'”;o …§9 ama

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.