Allen, William Andrew
Allen, William Andrew
Opinion
4-e~<e:f a~ (!.a,ffl,~'r'l ~p~/s e (j (!)o)( /2. ~" t ~~ ~}_J~.~l~~~IHJ :5f.r.-ft a.¥' <T'~.xJts ·· ~~ · rRt, wQ-;tz; tJtS. D~,'f)c:;...fL91i> -ar.,q::;-,zq~~4)~M~~- · C~t.n-n ea'-'(.4;.+ Ho. ~~·,.o<:f-12 97~ cxP~rle.t.?!; w--:il,~nn An.da~ ~~~~- Ab®IAcosta,Cierk (!j~JLk: . ·--A,~Sl.P~Jr- 'l<f :::h-t f?~SfcN'Ce fO ~£tJ?- ly\~c~l8 Ja... tvtli!tr.. '10 yau . fYl'/ ~6f f~qCJ W A:..J+s wo..( 9.·/LJ IS'! ~s~c..l-ltf?\ ~tUm tVUf (JQ~/ <2~1J»~ 6/}(l,ll'l~ ~~fl.F Y'i«j rpi/l~f A~~A-/ ()..HJS E)( h~{~Jo f/!J.J~ ~ ~v. ·AM.( I :JA 14 ~ ~' ~ /4 tw f. A cJ {s£lLi4x ~4-., :JSlj.. G~ cJ ~~ nz~--1 t1A cf V ~~.6U.i A" ~~;s e.&"' --the ;.:s-_s:l?J~rsh.?cl /(:) -rh6 S0-'23 .. r HIJ.Vc._ . titJ ~6/~ J,u7h ~«l ·-tlJE (J'I.IJ b/a...n, TCS -7J741 6"71 . s~pfedJ/;6~ )~ d~Of I.WIJ'S --::J:nc:},cfEJ tJ?71 //) &tc..n~ 11 ::f ~AS #of- ;::J;,c:J,.c?J' (TA/ 6f--6"T-1'.2_9'z7.
~-(h.., ·XJ,'c-bn~ir l'&tl~ f(o,£ &~J J1-t~ ~ ?ht. ~tb?)Ar af'bJ~Yilee..
IJnJ .. fht- ;Sf-rJit:_ <J'.C ·7£w~, c./I.(Jy 6J~e.:h~ %'1t1rp~c.ff,,(l Su;a~~ G-RA~J,. ~ tJ t.(}IJ'Y'n 22.J AS .Sud 'Aj --1lt <i- J'14l1l. ~/l47J 1 /J_P,. dL»8 ~&' -{71 E..
Jo$'2 ·\JluM:; c.JA-1 <u/-6/e~C-t &ul!:l- ~~ S'tJ1ol Ck,LL-1\ kt 1 1 H£vt/f2. ~Jl. r:]\t_ C)~~~n'\~ ~ ci<A··/~~ \fh! fL.L~7~ A/J..~Kt J "fl~ ~,e..a_tt~ J\Atta, ~ .s~p~&iflk:R... , ~o"~ -J.lt 4-sr i?1tmJ~ ·:R\_ s¥+clllht!L '!'IL ff-S"Z1~cl)c/~ /'7)/s/e.,;; I ~u.JZ/ kl~ f 7lJ ~6-HE ~LL-tl'f-r,.. :£ LU,Jt~ ;nJ~ /.JJJ~ /Ptrs ~~~.t 4afccSiecl ton/;/ ~¥f~ise </ ;}o?JY>o ::r W4-$ ~i~cl OeU416d ~!-I SE{/-knt~ J<l otJog PJ1 wt,oth ~ Wh5 AI&> ~J.~+~J c..:fh2- $4-m~ ~4.0 S?EpfYnbo,e.
Jg. ~~ A·f" ll>:J-1 frt-rl) t7n !0 c.J{i:\~t:8o /,(}4//~ f1a~~ 1);J f\}()J- 1-/fiU(_ Jh~ ~'-\tll~ Jl,·c-~tci-- o~ '1h ~. I E::$":0. ~t£,f-~:-/ci ~'-C.J- &1 'Sf:_ptUr. b6e. 1g . c!:XJ(j~ !h-d IJ,d t/6-1- t-IAVF cJL(;~s&,d/,~ ~ s~p+~ hu 'f ~a'b ~ + t: m 'b 6' cF' AJ<;u.<¥ f .As :t: htW'f... $'Ar7J (1\~ g1l'S~~t I £1~~ 7-U"E£.~ r,tUFm ~£ :;;l?,-$~e-/~ ' ~~ /h1 !+tf~J/Vfl~o; (]4-/vin ~Vr-6 ~- ~/1 ·:;js- t!K>l~ ~ .fil~ J<rh-A- _:e 16&//w'$-cl Ul-A-s ~~ --:h..z/i~tclr'd-~-. .:~ 40-,.,-, nut ~~b ::::& . HAV~ ~~iJ 0 tV/LI~"> ert:" Jhrh~ 0.0¥146, ~E t~t-Srf- J/.Vd W€11- /fb(111Jf' rJE.WI~ ·-p;'s~uu~~ 6o~cc,. l,Uhei!.~ ~iAj~ a\<?.C7A'd ~ 1.\p Lurh I/ S6pAtLA-{ ~ ·:x do Nof ..(1\()lOo J: AfSdi ~•\6W iThJ¥~ Jt.a~~ Yf)c.CA'CS' Jlt5 ·fk~Sm~-l.k~ ;.J~ ·:to A-: m -n IJ, ~ &tv4f 0 2 &~.~ j ~@,P(l;~ls lis ~l~-k4} -fhE t:Sn)V( '}A-k,,el45 /imt "TS ,6E,~ Ct-e.RJ.f-EJ 1!>7 -~J?r- J11c.CA'fj· 1/3 :J.f ~~ ld""~JJ,,,~trt))'.JJ!JiJ J-/AJ rle; cJLA~i6.9tc.·L<i-v- -~ JIA.~)-s~~cJ, ~ (!.4r\ 1\)aJ & V~~ --16 ~'t cS7:>ta~0~J,c,:,- (U;~f~,d r.. ~.t J.As I l?mt_ y ~ ny ~~$£../ Ch/orn ~.wfi~ lOfJS llfp·;{ .d3 dbJD. ::t:' J/Mt #6.1 ~ fi/)o~ ?a_ Ck!OhJf ·7D ~ /11~4 ~, /lp;jJ6tJ-/. l7< IPuJ ~frcL ,._, _. _.. )~ftrl m'li-ke-sl As~/ QtJ{viVl Ji'tr. Ar~. ;11oiJ~ ddL /II~ T~~~l .. fntq ~JLcJ Jh s -~ 4d.e9~-<~'l~ 4ppe11/ />n.i~( W~"t1c"' f hltj ~6/tJ/~~ 4n4 {j;,-flaJ,t;f ~ &w~o "~t J.sfk~t. tS.{J Cc:IGIJ?~cA_f,-aYt Q,c_ App~( ~s ~or/ ~c /YUf S':gnA!uLf. d71 ~·/;; tuR7j ~ o~~o~-R-'i1Cz'D -~~-o<=;-tcctG-~ 1J ;/-~n> JI<::J.J.. ~ 4~tc.JeeJ'd &y "6il1eft. ~er-v;:s-lz;cj ~.e-t~cy.s oJl7--c., Zf'e 4 T-Xs -k ;f I cfw~. ~4-f- t:<.h<;· f t'o/J--5 /1?,1}r/1=- rl 6-n ·-:D~&~6~L ~e- d-CI£/41 ern . AfPR.;( c)'/ C)Ois ;:L J7k k.J~/( ~y,ac;-)297C'::. -CJ~<J9-/2-~ ¥~ . ecP ~-~rtt"s~,C;{,~ wh;ck ~l... ~f6J,~4,d-J-... J"'6"Gu~-~ 0.4n be.. .6tti/J1;Jk/ Ad fPut ffl¥1 f A'ld am, nl>l &~ kJAIP~ cfl~ 91 s~~<Q lP'd-~. . ''i:'+AcW$~cJ- (k)IAa+ -&"its csHii/Js ~~; cfutu;'ct~k,;/~{ ~SRAqJh;c Aa.EA, <flllJSIO. @bl)(!«z.J.l~ llll.~. ~ .. ~hl/'1 "'$_~;.{. ~... Auf .,~
6·e.Jt£.. b.AS.!ol ern /}lf.·I'Yl 73 t.Jo,c:P 1 . Rtsbs.tt. \J ~-~·i.ss,~ £;,e. /-.JJW1~ r]Jrs~& !?I 1 )\ €.~ TAw?' -JILud1 So~ ~~ ?14,s ff/~s-s., J?-/s pJ/ 6ee446L ~ ~ fJ..fhfZ4t~ (}kfv'rn Grtfl..Vl~' ~~~~ IG> P£e~i &;5d.P4tc"G.., btJ1Uf.Cl rjh_¢- /..o(JS :Sis/, ps £AI-+.sJ ltncl II/WE.(_ f/2$-<i> e.rz-/zc/ 70 ~ ~ t!..evft.,J 6/l..
7},1_ ~~' kJr/n~s-::~s -::f/Jq:/ WifA..~ dM6re.. ~t.. bftt~/1.q--J"" /YlaiiDil--;;{}t,J- ~ HDf ~92-Tl. h.Jl "':b '1"h 7 CkuQ...{, .Gu;-cl~c""L ~/.J'l ~ '~~~~·~t mtcl vt'i~t r -{6 IYli..( o46L .1vtr? wri!J 1,~1.1 ~'~ fA~ f'J:);sJ~~.,~I /kf/t;,vtt (j 9 ~ ~ rn'1 dD~sd~ 7'A1n --:;h.,,u·<!Ch(--1 t:;/' 7h z;s.-z (]./(~ AJ/ ::v As-k 13 ~£. .11 &JilL {12.1~+/. ~d-R> & AJbl£ -16 fib~(-· (/J>·<e C:U;d~c6 -ftttrl0 51i-l/ o?t-1 ·fl~e? --:76 ~A-ve. y:; #m 7:?t4~ "···'s? /Jnfi ::Z 1'/,E-S.d ~uorf' ~ -:.hd/c~ -f I!J?--69-129-?·1- -11?6-ec_ ~ .H1/}:f Cf"JUZ. ' ·,
E>hua V ~~i q;q 6/vzJ <S""19., :;;n., GRJmdM J ~~-s" A-S Of~ ""l') C.'iu'd 1 0f.r'5Cs ULttL,6J,c_4,~ rtml\o-+ b~ s"'b+,Q-1\+·~ll~ ?7-tvol:.c.~: -~-+- ~t_l·f/fu ANA&-r C>'fL.-,f do~s !'lo·f, -~ llk~ I"$ QJ~d CJ\~ Who~ f. (9~~4-' dutt~~rctd- cvu A ~~b~ m~ beh~ YY\~ R~l1 b'-J ~A+ (j>AIZ-~/E-$ f+pp<!Ail./rna G~~LE /-'fhz &c..r/L.fi !2vt!~ iztJ ·v~~<Sf\s ~" l£xl15 ~Je:s e~ Q..7vd ~~u.!.f...,&m,/JJ ~t.\6c~\clrd'- ooc~·1/l~ ~fl.Sr<rr\ GA7'"oi ~c Q;nr~$j {)..ftP'\ ·n"t. <:V1-sJ~ct C1ot.\e..-\-- ~~~l'f ~1-j' )}t~ tl~\..\s~Js Psd1fe~~~~ h\.41 t.,kjwY(C::S /},~d~.~c_ /duhl cs·P A-~~ ;:t;d,~~f 1 ae /A1 .4«!.wszd.s ~cS~Af AIJiJe.ll\- 7'uE.. WATUC-P.. -[hl-£~ 6~ fflt-d '1hl.. ~~e-n ac:C' A c/41/J J;.j~ ~~pyflP'\. u. pon Ci:om <P lA~ Y\+~\ ~\l~~t- ~~~ cyo6-s tU;-f h AQ'e. A VA\~ J .£:~ ~~ :h.J /'cfmD-v\f 1\S ~~"5ep{em~ IY' o<SIS'i/. ot<_ 6V~ S~kre. '1- ,:Jl>(Jg>" ZU~J-//6.L ~fct v~ J ric:.~- fl;:ys~ ~i,~&,d_4,6-r _ou6/Z lh'f /~s-1-h 'V-i :~-1~,(: t ~u e.+-~ Its ~U~6~t~4£~ &- Jh~ /D'&-~.Jc.t~ICII.} I v~&h_,e:l Clou~f [;VJl.-7\t- ( u~'b--kJ 10 ~e-+k ~l,v{\~ ~~~ · Vc~ ~A '1ix·AS ~~fo-1'tme.-~ ~J~ ()4, ':J<5:<f /6'"6"~ J4J,;;1.+f 'Dj·~A~,<:J ( ~~J.:-n ,~~-rk, mt.& w/\-11~1l ~-h~. ,,",l ·:t~' (q,)-'111 ·f- -n~s ~~-fh f 1~ -----p/~,c:.t cte>~J- hc$A g Q) :J;, l}t..s./rn ~UAJ"' Jn'1 'lh£ ./lis-1 rn6'1LJ.~ -~ Apllrl &ol tV~b£mhcR. ~ ~;;:;:, ~ £--fk. Ck 4 671 ·fh l IJ.~t rr7ancl~ 'n\ .fZb Rc-1 kfl-t( hltd ~ ~c.L '& ($.> :1=n /).)~>r//etL. (k\.Vt'\-kr on /}1~ JAisf n1~t; ~ Joo\.\Aait ~ clune...~ v~s ,4-nl\ J.!X"'I'lS ~tJ6/hYWrA~ a,_J~ ~, e09 Jvt£1~~~~~J->- Ef.\dl._ ~{.(.n.J 1 1 l.;.f~J ~ -Jh·fs ~'-tbc:J,f)(ptL /)Pr<:. ~uiLis~.~~~<f.- f(l!;IO{d.J fhr be./~? ~J,'.h~IM Pmd /h~ ?JUnct<tJ) /~s o .C ·"'[hrs &4/e Jd.e -u,yi(.J- ~ Gll./1,-ls .. "VhE. ~'5./'--k...lrh ff>t.d /mas ~~:~ci-~J ~.., 'VA~ I ~·s/4-k/t£ d~rfi;,£ tn-1~ c-s~/,~4 J"'tu;J,~.ta~ c~·4A1 &s'l~;cJ 6utZ.h, ~ Cvlli!tf·v !JJ,1s<rn. ST63 "Sw!>cl </IJ,f/$;~/6x·(!.e;.m 4~ /9~): 6hrh YJ~An&rn <6d{ swzJ <dJ9 1 bl2 1 (1;~ C!!li?IJ ~ ICJ9D A~t41c)E: S" §<if D~ -tA z '!iMS ~sl~/cA ~d k/rclt '/-.6) r;J7 --:fhc../ixAS 6ad.t. ~0.Jm,),A-/ ~~ur/L VJI4(!.t .Jun./'sd,:J.ecf-L.._~·P All J1hrf &-sq ::::t:?..-11£ d/5-h.Jc/ &~t.is ... /1~ .5az ~M.Ibnn?fo?t-1 &J~ CJ.c/., :x¥, 16"S'-tlk c:Sud:c,,4f v/;jb~/(Ac-ro-i'rn) ~~1-<k 1 W~¥1)6-e. ~Ll."V\Jrt.S) ~ ~;/ ( 1b ~~ e.n.J,-/J~J At\ Acf .. W,3 t:.1 G?-"t f.wf/"'1] 1/.J& h~o IZ¢f ~f. -r~ fkm-s-l::k..(rd?- /ftz..f/c.J1. S, 5j?- ff5 ,4-m.s::;::!..cl~e/ f.,_F?4Jvccls:.~ : o ,, -tht.. fJ~Y-~f~+ ,:,-P A11 ;:::,:;d/c~r o £ ;hz~.fJ.--hlf1'1. '77:1 .-~ ~l..f/L.f !'
::Ph v.t..-sls ~£ ~//.;.;- £-v/-11 c.fotl/ucl~-1-.. a+,-~ t: G/}U6-E..c Vt:t6hs ~1\ ·~~ G-c:nN..,e;yuYII&-.'\.~1 Gcel~ ~-</-.oiL- ·-u~ .&ncl 5~4S~s CAc&.~ttSkiC-i" f'P"d C/tym,fin-/--;;,:-5-kz,cf Cki-1.1l}- ho/Js 11-d 1E~d _7e"UO ·ll~s e6 ~~+ b~oA ~~;;frL, ~ ~ (L)tvl'l*,- ~ if,l' drs-huC...fe ~\l~~ ~*' NW~IL I~A-e!J ~t.J<;;&te--~'io-n o_o rn~ t-s--s--121 7Jrs-k~,.( ~do · 4Z ·~Nf;-1 X Awl l'lo I A- i~1-,e .. ;£ do #v-1- .K,/JaJ cJi'1..,. tt.xhJ· y:;;, ·r de> /l}oaJ ·-J}!.,..J. ·tJd JL\n~ lc d.o10 YYLlt AiJc;~'f CA-Ium Gttf'6 / IWIIJJLme-. /61/~ lYle -:/JJ4f ~ J.Oa'-1/r/ .w,J1ldutD -~ /1Ll.f ~/JfW ::r./' :r Ll.}~c/~ !/~ IJ->hc/ -7·J"' I sAl/ tolf1?#cl ;. ./i1rl /15 #1~,1?//1~. . mi IJ<Snwt!T2. tu~ ;/£11 ~- ~"~J ~~C) ·----;;~5 14-'.fkte,. 14 dJd /l(J'-I- '}/..rJ/1Jdt.4<-0 t:t'i/J 'J)-;d dar! f?e~"~f -JA·~ &/cl~~ < ·f7,,.,..~ ...£.
6-40 e J()IY]. lhtd tfrs -:.:h11)~£/,f"Jihi(.. .SUi/Y1; ..1,/;_J /J ~Is I ;:1Jt;d I! v rf . Tb 0~ r:u:-s-klci 4J~~Vn1f ~ a.r, ;j~ p!2eiV.£dts; :z:- ld/llf:nvl .thz-dt~ Iii/~ (J)Af7 -/7t 1}-1 fu ~ ~-( /A-kf -"1A ;-~ /n-4-..fletZ_ l,gYt'd- f ~ ;h,/1a~l ~~- ':I: "7) 7 d do~ fi d/d ~.P,;-~ ·13 ~ 67t.e. o-P --?A '7 ---/1, ll£~ ~ds 0 ;r (!,Jr I I Jtk;-1 a. l.t I r ~vi, f, / . f p -J'h~ e~s<s:o/ect, J 20/fS ~~'Y "/£yJ{ f2 4-sj/ ~7 o/d?sl- tdJtz- I Azu'*f ~ 1J ~4 blc /7J ~¥b;(_ kJ~ tuAS A- 'JJ,eucf clG~Jf(iR.., tfl~i21~ ~QjkJ~ Ot~~/1'1'6, ~Ills ~-;'f kf1'1 P')11 C1W J
~o~-l/ !' J&Wt? '11Sef5 OsvJ ~Q, C: 4 +~ s~ £.tE~W,L~ ;;:z; 20);;; ~ Ad~ 4-1 ~ Csutl.: J:f ·-fA 4-J &'n ?J1., ~ ~ c..
1/-r!J~ ~ /Y)~ dOtS: :J: -IM7ts-rn~Jhei A- ~P't a--P- ~-;~ S~f --;o so~-~~lAJ,c.·;~t-{l),s~ct Oeurzl.
A\ be-r<.t rn }"(\<: c~f~~ .J ~- ~\.\J~ <6~(9 ~~\l 'Sf-. s-i.trJ f-c ~() 7 - 1-/wnfls~-~ 77C/~ 47tc/ /6 "71,-l. tk;4/li--J(J4:m-nal ~.M(5 )d-36)( <Pcfcp~ ~-{-~J &~4,6-n ~5Jn f2xAs l<?if J ~~ ..~ ,., '
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.