Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Allen, William Andrew

Allen, William Andrew
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided May 13, 2015

Allen, William Andrew

Opinion

tkt<fl+ a.f' (!p.,/11,~,.4 ~p~/s (} <S (!) o ~· /2.. !u:J 1 ~ 9;f;1,~l4~~1tfJ :5~fe a¥' <f'~~ Q(t.

CtLh-n 1/JQ-; ·· tz; ;Jc;. t!>~''t'>c;..,z..911> -aw-~q::;-,iR~~7) &1.-(.A,..+ i'io. ·ef{;,o'1-12 <n(p • · • ~~ :V.~ • cxP.tlef~ .w-:JI,Jnn Ada~ !J,JI~· AbaiAcosta,Cierk ~~~ILk: . -p,,~9.P~Jg-- ~ ~ ~~s~c-e -ro ~11J? ly'\~c~~s .Ja... t~+IE~~.. 10 yau . lYl'l ~6f --r10u W A:..~ts b.J£L(. 9.·/LJ IS'! -:ht5~e-/-IP'?\ ..tftUm tVUf ~LJALU/ ~t:\,JJY\ 61}/l,llr~ ~~fLF Y'itAf 0Jill~f A6f',;A-/ ().r~JS E)( h~{~Jo f/!J.J~ 0'?\ ~V.·A~ ' :J.IJI'/ ~~t-$/4f1L>~ Acd-(s€<!..,-t~ ~4-p:JS'/- G~cJ~Hnt~-1 ~~i) ~~~uJJ A (I ~~:s e$' /fhc . ~:>.s:l?J ~ rs-hvc I -721 fJr.6- SOb a; :1: /IIJ.vc.. . tic ffoa6/~ turh ./l)..."~ ·-1JJE (J't.tl bla.-rrt 1-s 7J1A/ 0'?1 . S~pfedJbc~ J~ d<Jof r.W~J-s ':hc:iACI~J ~ /l> (h)tc,..n~ ~~ ::t toAS 1'1~+ JncP/c?ol tTN' &fres7'-l<?z7. ~-(h., ·Xci,c-bn"Yl-.h f'6441 f't;,£ &~J Ju'"t ~ 1ht ~"'1?/y aFbJ4-/Jee.. /inJ .:(ht- 5h:rk. .C ·7£~AS, c/... lf :S.J~c:.:h~ ~IYifJ~c.t/,J1 S too£11 _, c.iA.t.g-J,. <j-.

JhJ tJ f-(j twn 22-J IJ s .Sud "Aj "1l s. J 14ltll. -;;:. ll4T1 1 IJ_P.. ~8 tJ &' -t/1 E.. ;6s-2 ·v}vj:!:; c...JA-l'U/-sfe,c..t &u.,c.:l- 8cf" StJ1d C1LL-1l 'kt 1 1 ;/uUL ~~ rj\ t_ 8~12-~n\~ rtQ cQ i't'tJ..!~ \(A t ;zl.L $'7~ AfLIK.( J ·"7h ~ 6- ~"f J"tta, ~ .S~~IflbeiL I ~08~ /1t 4-st Jr/l1?1J~ ·:;;n, S"¥fclllh6L '/JIL tf:rsZ?JV:licl~e:,P.t /'7)/6~~-c I ~u/l-1 to~ f 7ZJ ~6-HE GJ~·k;~ ::£ /V, Jh ~ ~ flM<) /J I~ tp/J-5 d,rt /Jt<~sf.~ ton/;/ 5'~~G?/1i.s.e </ dt)?f~o X tu-45 ~il!-cl ~tU/6£1 Uvn f,~ I SEtJ-kWI~ J<l otJog ::Eyt wt.Oih ~ Wl'r5 Alt50 ~J.~+~J ~~ s4m~ ~fo<.(tb S:epf&nh61?- l~. ~r A·r 1o:J-J Prtv1) t7n to <2i "'ff.cJL:8 u.J~ 116< (k~~ -v; J b

1\]aJ- 1-/JiV(_ '1l1"'i ~~~~ &, ·c~1dr--- o~ 1h ~ I E;$"':0. "TJ-sf-~~--c) ~~.<.J-.

6YJ 'S'epft..trl b6e. jg . d<J6'5 fh_d /),d 1/d-/ f./AVF cJ~,t.,Is&tefl~ ~ Stpf~ bu lf- ~a'b A-+ -r: m ~ & cr· Al<IU~ f .As :r: J.. FW\_ ~Ari-J rn.~ g 1tfS7"n ft I .£I, ~ z.cJ~c. r,48m 771 E. ;;t:ir$~e/~ ' ~~ /}11 /J-tf~/Vf1~'1 C!tt-lvm ~IR'6 ~.· .J...-.1, ,F~ /JOt~ ~ ~~~ J<riJA .;e 16&//iv-s.J w-A-s Gdwnd "h,,z/A-~tc.Jr:a-,...._·-s- 4o-n1 I'Y'Af JP-1/F-P'II~b ;:& . HIWe ~~~J S to~if-> 6-{:' fk/;6RS Cb¥146, ~E tA-srf- T£Vd W€11- lfbov,.J-' f\)EWI~ ·-p;rS<:f4()U<!;c0 6o~Cf:t. k)h.i'-~· ~'-Aj~ d\<!GtA'd ~S l-\p Lurh I J S¢tp~A-J ~ 'X cl<l Nof <ll(}lOo :r: Also· ~n~w \})\~¥~ J~~<fC Yl\c:_CA-{5' Jlt5 ·f'it/>'1\0'm~-/k..,l .JJ~ ·to hf YY\ ·n /J, If ~IV41 r;y.fl&~.~ J ~@lP~·~ls FJ:s ~l~-ts em 1'1 ~1 ~ k~t.~S 7im t Ts ~E>Iy 4) -rhE Ct.eP-J~~J 1!>7 -~J?r /f)c(!Alfj· f/3 :TJ' ~~ Jo-~JJ,<',~l f/).~-sJJ!Afj 1-/Aei r/6 0~~~$~ic::J,c::i-v- ~ cJ\..\rt)s~•cJ, ~ (}_Pr-1'\ f\JaJ & V~~ '-r6 ~f O{)lo~.JI{J,c,:T (J);~~~vd f.. ~~ J.As. f l;'rrJf. .:C ~ Rl<j &~ 6£___{ Ch/o rn 6A-Wt ~ l£J.Irs 1\r.RI ( .d3 db JD. . :;i: J/Mt h0.1 ~ fi/)l>~ ?a_ Clz>xeP7Jf ·Jb ~ /11~4 v&' J/pjJ~I)-f. CJI( l#uJ ~teL ,,c,·· _.- }..b7;r/ mdlct?"s~ As ~I QIJ{viVl Ji'tr. A,~ rr?oi:~ WL- /II~ T~~~l .. /!Jrtcl .£'/s:cJ Jh s ·-.:;::n 4de:9~~~~ 4ppeiJ/ ~~~J~( W,-?JctA f /tJ'f ~lfu!JpJ/-s:Jf!L a:n.4 {j;,-j1a~-ttf rMj ~~o <1~t J.Jk/G t:Sfl Cc,GIJ;'i-4Ctt-lt:rVI Q.c_ AppSr&( ~:S !Yorf JhJve= /iUj s;.gn,.!u£6 d77 '/·~ turoi ~ o~~o<=J-IG'i1Ct1) -8~-a<;-tcctG-(&, 1J H.lr5. ;~ai-. ~ 4~tueR..r:.d &y '6(n6·~<- -77te-r-Q;:s/;zJc;./ ~R./JI~s oi£;-c-; ""'e 4 7,)iS k ,s I d'w~. - /A;!/-1- ~-;-1 IV/1'5 m,l}r/:J'-1 6-n '-:/)G{!'G7YJ/,6,t ~e- ckJI£/Q ~ . /JfltR.;( c!)'l C)Ois ;:L ff/e k..JJ.i( .4fi',a<;-)297~ -8<?'<:J9-/2.-Cf fje:, . ec:P ~-~ittsc9,e::{,~ Wh'lcl.. ~l... ~f6J,e,4,dh. ..:T'=:;-~u~-~ 0,4n be, ~j/JI;Jk/ AJ IJru-t I r7Y1 f /h d CLtn, n7J / 131 kJAJ /.J.£ cfl~ 91 SW :g~ &'dS". . \\X+ Ad,'~fp_,c} C!.vua.·J- ~-;fs _csH-4Js ~~~ ~ll;;ct;;_k;l~-~-{ ~SRAVJh;c Aa.EA1 ~ase:.. @~Q~~~s A12.~ ~4 Kk~""+l\-11'1 of. s~a>t. ~-, ~ .·,

CJR..Jtt.. b~.!ol an />I!·IYl 73 tJo,.J) 1 Rtskes.tt. \1 Lfowqv~·]ss,~ .C~ ~~VI-- 7Aw?' -J~Lu.d1 So~ ~~ ~Js n1~s-s., :J?-/s ;;J/ 6c<!446L ~ ~ ff.f.krut~ d~rlvm GPrMl~, f2~cf;~ JZ) Pt.e~i &;J5d.JWtc~.., t&;,JfULC.l rJh.¢- WtJS :Si.s/,ps~N-+ 2J lth.cl tVivE,( f!U-se-rzfzal -m ~~ C!..ev~L-J 61l..

7],1_ ~~' k}f/ntts~s::s ~~ W~"t- dM6,z., $t.. bftJ~/1,q.-d.., /}1a/1P~-~?7tJ­ ~ HD-f C2ec.fP-fl·~ '<(}b "'17t 7 ~ua.,{J' 6u;cl~c"=f. -:j'/1/.};l tv-~ ·rn~-5~./~l A'ncl v;l~t r -10 IYli..( o~L /~ ~r-h ;,~;J ~-~ riA "f ~-;:J;s)~~.,c.,l /kf/t;,vtt (j 9 PJ?vJ ~ ln<j C!o~.sd~ T A7n --::kr~d·<!fhl·l c;/' 7h ~S·E (]/(~ AI/~ A-sk 1"3 cr:L /J d1t/L lhd-72> & !Jib!£ 76 fJft~{-· (/J:14-/. dh·? C:U;d..l>7lc~ -ftr~:rl ..-;:. 51/I/ o~-l·fl~te? --:76 tf'A"vE- ~A-?~? hh~ /Jnd ::£ NE"S.d ~U>rxf ~ -:hd/c~ f' "R'--o9-IZ97·1- -117e~C. ~ .HI!J:f cnz_e ' ·,

Dhua V ~~-k. Cff! 6h2J ~~9~ fl. QRlmJntt I ~6:'~ 1 .45 o-1~ ~ C:iu'd O~s ULt(L,6c:jj~d,~ r~ 1\o-+ b~ ~"'b +k'\ f• A-ll'1 :J71 v()($-~ : ·:r-r €.1·-J1,u ANA&-r OIZ..-,f do~5 !'icif, ~ (ik~ 1-s QJt--al'\ C:A~ VJho~E.. (9~~4-, dttft~~1ctd-­ oiJU A(j>;a~· yn~ beh~ YYl~ R~l1 by 111A+ ~~~J/E-S f+pp.:!A/l.Jrna. /)~~Lt:­ /~z &vr~fi Rvtl~ 1w ·...;~~<SY\s ~1\ -r~x/15 ,e.,le:s e~ Q;v·,f ~~u.t£,&m,/JJ ~(i~,clrd\---.. ooc:a..·'JA""t:.. ~~ Cl-A-n"o"- ~c amP~~Jl u.p~ ·YA"t- (})1-s.t~Lt Cla""e..+ acl~ t'f ~'1' 'J}!"i_ tl<-'QI,\s~Js Prur?!Srt.e 4-YJCE) h\Jf 1- eki~ e.e::s !}, ~ cL c.. 'j

lcs:ki/Y? cSP A- ~kn..y ::hd~~~f 1 a.e. /A"' ACt!.wszd.s ~6~A( Alfi~rn- 7t'u~ WAT?.Jc.-1.. -rh~£1!- 6~ m.d 'lk~ ~s/4~ a£' A t./41/J h/~ ~/l/y('l~rfr~ u.pon ~(])IAtY\.+\, ~\l~~t- asa~~ ~o~s rllJ-f hAOf- A VA,~J ~~~~ :h.dlcfmQ-v\f 1\5 ~~'5ep{em~ JY o61Si. 0'1( 6<.1~ S~kre. '1- ~()f: b.Jt,y/16-L ~kt '1);J fl,:f'l. ~~~~ ~it~&,d_4t.d-Y- .ou~ fl,~ /:>s<V~ "lJ;JlR.1ct Clsaue.+-.. /h, du~6~t~A,~ & Jh~ /D'S'~d4~'c.41 u~&h~cl C!.ouR.f iVJl..n t- r Ue=o---h:.J 10 ~ c..:·l+E CklcA\./y ·~ JHtS ~ · Ve~ ~f\ 'iixAS (3.f)t}~p.-n me.....~ CkJ~ d-cf, ':J~ /~s-"22! J'~J,~~.+ I j);·~~lcJ (A,")Jm,~c-+k, t11L& w~ll~fl ~·h~. . ./:,1,,1' (C?t)·-Jh ·f_ ·nA-,11s ~~f}l ~ 1~ -p/:tyhvc.t tkJ,/iJ- h~$7'1 -: Q) ~ tJt..s-/r-n ~UAJ~ d'1'1 ~F .:::fliff:;'"/· fn(jnJ.ibf -~ IIQJIZrJ IJn.o/ tVi'b£mhcR ':! ~;;:;;~£..fk (1~ 671'/}Jl fl~t I(Jond,. "7'1\ fZhR"ik~ hh.d ~~c.L'& @ 'Pn /).)ht-/J~n_ <kl.tA'\-kt on -j}J1 -f'd:,1>i n1~~ -:vn JA1\\AAflit ~ clune..: v~s ~11 "T~X-1-tS ~IJ6~~ a,_J~ ~, e09 Jt..l6Z~tCit-cf->- EA~ ~t.tiL..J. ~~~+~ ~ -Jh1s St-t hc1PtptL Jv~-s "Jhr .J.uiLfso\ .~~~~ fPIXJ/ci.J bt./ (]),~ &-tr.J,'.h~tm.. Prnd -,1\<7 ?]Unc~4) /h'()s e ~ --Jh-r5 &-4/c Jde --o,6JI?.t} C1e (;t/1..-lo . "P16. &,"5./'-k...lrh h'>td /~s b--n/Je:l.s.J '1 911~ I ~·sl.trk/1.~ d~li'n£ kh~ c:s/,J,/,~4 ..fw.IV;J,~tc~ ~~· 41-; &s'l~;cf &Lc;eh c ~ Cv!!.fl~(V bJ,1~<J7\.. ~53 'Sw!lq </iJ,t/$;~1'6.K·f!£;m 4ftP ICJ~): 66rh YJ~Iif>&rn ~d( sw2..of G:IJCf 1 ~12 1 (:n-< Cllf7fl ~ ICJ'iD A(dlc)~ 8" §'if D~ --tlt z 'liMS ~sl~Jrcfrt. ,4-nd k/rdt l.j.~)' D ~ --}he. !~AS &c:P~ ~@Jnv)JA-/ fJ11aeeduJ?L VJI4c.t Jun.7sd,:J.e~-l>·P AJI f2bt &-s~1' ~ d/skcf &"-'~-. II~ .5a:z. 6rloe~~I &Je:. fi.t. c;.<t.,~¥, /~S"'fJJ.. Jud:c~,4l J)/;5k~/(Arb-lrn. 1 ~~*- uJ~:yf)ee. tt~!U-~Jrt-S) f

~ ~;/ { 1b ~c 6n.f,-/I~J ~ Act .. W3 f:.1 <-<--"! R.wfi-1J ·1/o B h~o IZ¢f --fAf- 7~ fkn~./;k..£~ lftLJ,C./1. S, 5j? //5 ,LJm~cJ~e/ f!_,~£tJvccf~~: .~e., -/ht.. j}IY-~f~..f. csP A?t ;:::t;d/c~r oL _h?ck/Z/714-..j/p-x. '721 A- C:1~..tll}- ~ tJ£sls ~£ ~1/,;f' ~'7/1 C.ftf/V~ci~-i-. -s+ ·~ t: C1AU6£c \l~tlshs ~/\·~~ G·c:nN..,e--y,~-1 Ocei~ ~-</-.oiL- ·-n~ ,&nr/ 5~JCS~s ~~nsk1C>i" frl"\d C.ii,t,rnu\n-{----:>,:-5-kz,cf Ck~ll.}- ho/Js IJ./ J.E#s-f 7~ ·~~& ~- ~~+ ~IleA v~frL, ~ ~ tieJt-l'l*f ~ ~' dJ'$·hu2.-fb ~\~~~ ~~ NUJ~If_ I~A-eJI ~~<;;&tc.J'io-n a_o fnt- ~~~-t!t 7Jrs-k~"( ~do · 4Z ·~.,rl I' AWl #a I A- l~"!,e.. :£ do dP·-1- ~J'aJ axArr/-· % d6'1. . "f da i<'IJoW ·f}l .,_.J. ad Jl.\n~ 16 .do I D rnLt A-1-L;~'f Chlum ~; 6 / A.oiSJLme.. /ell~ me. J714f de JPat.-tlrll w,:f'hdut.D ~ /J1..l.f ~/1€,; ::r..f ::c Lt.J~d~ Jl~ IJs-hc/ ·7£' I ~AI/ toon~cl ;~/i7r! ;rrs #f~.e?~~~ mi fJtfnweTL. tu~ ;/£11 Nz>_ ..J~r~J -r~o '?Jikrs 14-'.f·kte.,. 14 dJd /I(J'-1- I};..;T/bd'(~ ~'fJJ 'J)-;d dar/ f?z~~l -JA·~ C:U/c/..o.-;u; < --th4"~ ....:C. b/JO e J()'Y}. /hd Jfrs --::h1 ut5£/,~Jihi(,. .SUi/YI; . /AJ /J /J Is / IICJ urf /i ··n 0~ r:u:s-klci 4)~~11 /J'n_9J L1-rr ~t;- ~Ldts; :z- tt.~/lll:nvl ~dtuJ ttl/~ ~?/J~ ~trl yut4 ~( /Jt-KJ --7J:;~ /n-4-.f/c~Z.J?Jt'J­ f f1h? fi ;h,/la~l /&~. 'J:: .--z:>-;d do~ d/tJ ~-1h·~ ·13 ~ ~- o-P~"? --/J,/l£~i Gdso ;r b:Jr/1 1'16J" a_ulf ~f,/ :fJd --[h~ e~S<s:OJed~ .:£ ~AS csn/y ·7£yJ{ /2 -4-s:/' --/j, 7 C)/d?si- 8·/L I A"tv'*f ~ 1J ~4 blc /J7 4/~E~ J<Jk WAS A- ~ft!M[ oiG~Jf6R., ' i?~J21~ ~Qj1u)~ dl~'d--ltC(6, ~JI;s ~-;'f 1lc£1'1 P)11 ct?u ~o~l/c· ~~ '113¢-:!J Qsvc{ ~.(\ C: 4 +~ B~ s.;~(L-s ~ ZD)/I/ht1 fh._d~ 4-1~ Gvt.I::JY //J"'<s ~c... .-rA4-J t7n J/13 ~ ~ /Y)~ ~1-S: :X -IIM7zs-rn~lhc.P ~ C1>fi a-il- ·'1h-r~ 6'~1 .-;o Sb~ j?}~v.J,c;4 {'b)Js~cf OeuJ A\ ~f2.t rn f(\q ctd··~ J~. ~\.\J~ <?3(9 ~~'«Sf-. g4~, f-c $~7 - l-/wnf1sW~ 7·7q.~ 4ncl 76 -;7, ·'i tkJ~/J-~ J (}"'~-n~JI ~bA("S );}-30)( @c~~ <4r·f-~J s~~lb-v\ ~,yf-f{ 72xAs l<fif J ~.9A:J()QL ~·~

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.