Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Wilkins, Billy Charles

Wilkins, Billy Charles
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided July 2, 2015

Wilkins, Billy Charles

Opinion

3,)/ cw.)kn;¢ziv¢q?z _ . ‘ 50¢&5§“3 Zq,jj_ /O_SO W, ("eammefc€__ » / v 7 s Bro¢mwood, /©%/,7(090( _ l __}cme_ici ) 730/5 7 _§.3__1:@_33§;_3§_§,001_£@__/?>_£[/ _CbQ.;Ze,;_AV.)../'_/Hos_ 3 _ _. __ __ ____ ____ famp_A/Q_/A}_£§__._S_‘Z}_S_XB______ 3 3 ,.

T'.;l_(`+/\/c¢, _/3_}'___37_2…___3 _ ____ .. __©P_ar_,gbe/ /QCQS:§Q_ €/£rK__ _ _ _ ________ §§ 323“ §_7._@\: ~r me __§/;_ §§3 S*k @,§_-}§§ [§,3§£/93/_§&7§2_;1'_7§ form.rc\.D ~/O dump [¢3¢»/-9 gna//(‘e»¢:n/\ f3/ a ero{_` ha 6100} f_grpu£`__/Qur;SMQ/_zi;'véo__ _/)/:9¢_/@_//,_0'7 '\¢,._,Q, ("(`3P /3 372 AF_ fe _/__3 579._- 196 7_'/')0\/3_ 6={70/07/€¢£ _ \ m +k¢z 437 53 m/,~m </P.orv 07 __ir_\jj,_z 43 ,»orow ‘/ am 1n/)0ce/)31[09~7/~0 Cfm/\L,,A ru¢\cc\-.\ f fqu [O/\. \/'/(led., `7/3»333_1¢\ \/€S+.Cn¢,om-. _¢l.`.O_mr".\r' 7/,/_13_0/‘0¥£°£_ .c,nL\m\c G>rr.e§a(" 099 .da.v.-,L. and ~/</\o )O¢’O§so(`u{'azq____/ ndJ_C‘il/Vz_éaf 0»~3 Q// __ka ;.M~{Q 33$£€ __._m_L_/__/_lamzf _Q_Q_c_t\_@9 ~éL\_.ei@-_ ~_ - w_£f..d_€__@;¢f€§o&é__£u__$§p__ /¢ cal-1'3r\ /q_ l;., 71@<~€.3. S`d‘mé_ docum€m¢f Q`/<`a 000/q 392 771/3 /0¢>-)[¢-19’,;;,\(').€_ ___L_qn@/‘Prv“@.,. 333 J ___ __E/e§§ §§3/7 @<// §§ 333 37,,3/3_.§,¢ m¢§/§ _/73» /,,L§D§_§___ _<9_9__~.733/ /zju r-/r L>!)mu>'€ +7 f¢ ma#§r p’_€z<ad~§]_~j/§ ?0»»~& 05 Q¢//Gued_ /n +i\¢£ WV'F|"$,.-… _7,7)’0/1//7@>¢_~;/ CIau/‘é/m~p /`//!c( Aé/0 /A/ -/L._ -/:L»//_ Ma#@r. _ _ _. __ Q€SQUMC§;//( .(./_/r>uij 7 __ _ _ ___ ____ /<%§_3\/3§3§_

im Fu\m FGRTHE coum"o)ra@lmr_um_ APPEALS OF TEXA_§ “ J_=__>(`_._PA &1'.;__._. …_. . . ._ - _________ _ __ ______ __ __ __c:Au_s§___/\_/Q,__w:gvg¢g) 553 _BIL_LLC_\AA);LE§_:@)<IM<__._____ .- _. __________ __ ____R£__TI_T;_QM __QF._J:NN@C_ ./~;MQE_ __ __72:)_711§_1_-1_¢2u_QQ_a_&L_E_}IL!_D_G_E_QE_;¢A_I_D_CQLLR?<€ - ___C_DM_ES__NDu/_,__B_¢°_\L/Hébgdes_hl{[/<_lfns_,_€&-H:(:§A@_c_;_q;{:h&_a§ove' QrL-\:f;l».led_czrd.m umS€/e¢ca_¢¢.£eT _and_vl\o_\ce$_+_#:._e_(<`>.u ¢-L_'¥_o__gr_éex_d__per__€_u_\::a_¢z\__€_m)QaL_mc,_P_raL/;?ed¢_'cj.:}:o_coas_£Ae¢__-&L\_Q_lq.na_<€_ _ng&ar_w\_{_l_le?aL¢'_r_\co_r;c¢r_o:_{:{.@_v_\,o_u_r.s_¢;a_A-A<_%e_._~.L_141_'._5_p_e,_-l:¢':(io_r_>_¢r_=&lr.___¥\-Jne_fou.r_~\»_ha>;b_el_é_-):b_a~_\~_ __~Ee.cl_eca\_c\u;€r_pcO_ce.S)_l;<__\[/`:o_]aieé_u¢}_\e;a_a_n_/:m;\oc€.j_\:l-__P_e_m__»o;\_¢r __s'nt‘d rre{a+ed, `

____`.‘Ij;)e_-ch§=uql_pr_e_<_\_¢_cqr\ve__§ar=ih&_da£w_\_§auld__;w!c_kay§_heeq_cirr$.£o.\¢cs;€_c§_,pre_v[o_us_lj_-H_\.mu_j.h.__ ___d_u_e__ci_/fl/.'j_ence,loe_c_u_u;eit\¢__umie;lj_;Aj;€¢_cé§_,._ace.»,.m.al:esla[_o:€_{he_pco_;£cu&;ng_q&_czmeg__thar\; __C._LJ_€,L€_.O_.r_\_\j_c_n_a_c{é__o._\zq_lr_lq_£>_l.€,_~l:o__#\:k\e,_cle£eo§_€_d~léocq_€_j_£>_€j._o_cc¥_€r.__c>§_:kb_e,_co_u_£:\'__c.m__$€( _ _Prr;\*l'c.[€,__~'§i._/_§/,.j:€§é,_@ae@._€¢:z(m,£ »_.~¢;&mél_,;=a:n_;€_-M__~Eé\__/~Q_Q_S_;__i®.,.

DENIE@ appearasz 1953 Ls.mucg __o F cow/55 L_ _.___._P_Q-L'.-/:{oner_¢ha_l.(gc_ges._:££\_g._eo_n_\/_¢rc.+¢'¢).¢_\_;)_n.:!rh_e__£@_;'$_-kP~_Q_+_‘\:r_[o_\_c.o.ua_sel.alcz.$'_{o.e&&c.+a<&_b€,; _ca.usé_h_e_-$§z_Ll_e_<l_-lo_.ma.)<@a_va_!_)a.tle»_alr._\.j_ma_:-Eenial.»_.s_o.¢j-b+_-&h.¢o-q .&.\~J.¢fs_cé\/_e.v.j_~Lv_p.e_-H_-Hm¢¢,_ _a_e__£QL/QA_.JCQ_£@_\/_e&+_§_ai¢;;_L£Q_ts__+b¢_g,;;@_v_@_p_&;£é_aers..`»'n.o_o_ce@_c_e__{a..;l_ea__b_,f,_\£o¢m. _ _=ll:;;~[:.¢'_an_e._gl:é_ac|r;q;$:'{:cl_+_t_i?__m_-S§C._Q_:{:_:.FLV__Q_t€d_.£»'_\é:j=._<l_`lll_€_f\_d_.._<{;be_..£{_c_£e_$_rf;£;§`,:z;<la_w§l~._@€_ér:$__ _: _.__£{ag:\'_c§ecd:r'n§._g_._\¢a_m'_ca_che__|o_einLe£y_\_-kh_e_:h£_cma£iao_o_nd_-H\¢_C_@_mg/_Qfn+ cm wL"'d-\ I-L .-'\‘ __ha;ea__@_s__%@- -~)`+\e_. comm¢'ss{@.~ -o£.+h e.-f-;|.- .com m¢_'+Q_A_)'$_'...EA»Q\__+_Q_‘I:L_AeJ/£[£cl¢g_j_<z&`_-H_\e_zl\_-%_cma;lz§g,._ MM%_{LLp;Q;Q€_u_+iQ§_a_+£oJ_an£};o_he_+hegaarer: _-For_ _-l_~A 0_. o-F€»ns~e/;!€@Lcle_d?_€$_g£g_;milj_ _»S.-z(_n_c_e=_+h£_-_Q_-'EE{QS;;»_v_\_}_\c(_§`_-__O_l£§{¢§g¥é_‘»;l:a_é@d.~r/v §BR;M_QJ'_M§U_;CA_C_Q@/n¢§§_€i;§om¢ ._ol&§z`ea_$§__c?§._a_fq.ei::l~£&[é.o;.$:o£:+_£_e_~$_+g~_l;e/_amd£ileiqb_i@€§_-H§Qj:>_?he_£a§ibq+*%g;* _F_/._ea_éhj_z§_\»_~f;i'~__€_.{n.d£c,+m.e,+.,-.'s_-FQ+Q/./j__ de,€e@¢_§_\é_i;gca_¢_x_§e_a_gm;@ed:{nj_czd§_m_ej__/l$_ &="\£WH\OC¢‘Z£¢_:}:O_¢(Q5'_‘3(2‘:¢.17';€,[£fO$€£_u:{'z(onS_l:n_Q_C‘_¢():/;f_¢lc‘}:_£©_q_d;g/Qon_/w_r$__¢r_fdao_’-

e,»_-L<le¢\~{:_ q_¢+ o_r:_o_.-F_`_ ):115_00./_¢\ M¢>L’~Imn ' ` -'~» ~~~»~~-~ -- ~~-~---»~- --~- ____Pe.~}_~,:(:zon¢r_ aq__€_$,__b_s_+£zal_&_b£y(ne¢j_£;u[ed +v f'€AAe§_r;€g.$_o_£\e_¥zl_e_€_'EEec&¢\/_Q m 1¢‘}@0€2_};€¢¢1¢1%_¢')€_ _<_iCJ/___qo+_r_r.)_o._\_/e__ ~):k)_e_+nal_ ®qu_§_c;£_er_+b¢_D/_~s+;: tf~)#vme<j_-/z)_m_o_/se_c_lva¢/QL/e_a@__re¢ _L_\_¢ _m___+o__/_n_p_€c_l~_anc\ Cvp_j__fl£,zho{v_j£gfz{;\__ all_u/_)He_¢_\_$_~l:a'_l'_€men+>;_ conc€mmq_+#&€v€r_rb a£_ih_e_ __Ql[eje¢£ oFF`er:e__puma¢JreAL. _maJe__é_\,__a_r_\_j_p_eg_Q_€__O_£:`Elc _e; or ema/o_y_e§_ agm¥__ or 099__'_¢[ ¢_\_ 0£`-+»5€ ~g*lu§re_a-PT_mr of 0§:#1@_ [/n 171ch j+a{*e§ _leg__l$ig&g_{§_£€£a EM_LMLLHMz S&HC_D_£€£Q;{:COnA¢/_d'€é___ I¢j__D_£_p_<'_L§S_ 5[1€¢`1§_'§\[0_£\£&['{1 l _l__ _<Lo_a;__ harl`:_gip_\¢_s_‘/\ §C[~Ma_'{:_+h_€_whd€/_m_gl&$€€(\d+b£_£€$z_é__ -i-l've¢;__pur_:_o_l__éa__ 59_~1'.;¥1_€___.._ _comr/ammj_w::lne$; 5';'0__¢1-l:$_\_o_r_\_¥;\_uj_l_?_§!_+o_'l:he__@io_$_\/_¢_no_r_ a;e_r_l a<\A d_o_u)r_\_ s_ome_CQ__m*~,__ __f._`o_ 0_5_ §._£1_€_106‘4' 06‘4'_-:1& _~H\Q 6 aU-H\eas+ew\ por:\'.co.r_\_oac__ @l€mm\_&<.;n~\z_‘_u/a$_/ r\_‘F¢`:'c.:\'__+i/)e_$ Us.p_e¢=§-_._ _a_$_k a_v:l;_-La.ms._l_a:l:er_.`{:€,m$__&_a?_e_;§a/Q_L_j_§r_u_sb.L¥___l_O_cc>__‘f_'_e___A/_\_eg f 3a nj_$_._`f_'é.)sa$]_ah¢§__~ho_keo_ux&o_ _C¢/£q':odj,__`-T.Hacam_p.l111'¢_\_0.¢&_111¢£_ar_\_a__cel/uiar_,gbone_g131¢:m_j:£he__ci¢_(r_e¢_~lio_¢.\_<z%_~l<m\éo_l,-S`);e .runs_o_h\¢_{¢° ___ _-___ ___j:&_~§;:li\£._Lf_o€(:_~?:)\_€__>;y_§p@d:_\¢e_I_\.¢(J¢T;':}__l=ze¢(»z¢i_T_z<'__(oZYL.-§_I)§__IL_e__£u_;pec£'__\/Q?¢£de,_m§l_&r:\be£_dg§a[loe_£ _as.»_§~_z1_»_.-¢_3__5_¢_<2;7__rzn__Co[o_\<_u.¢g_i'L_a_/zm¢m~_\_£o_dvm.4- .» _ .. __ . __ ___ _ _ ____ __ _ __ _

____7_15 er-_Q_ uJ_&£€_§_ weld \.__dcr_ wécre$?_ (£. o_-H_ao_c_ la__ L~/. _e_mc_o_ rcM€/d:_a_€?_¢(€€r£__ ~€r._ 0_ m_@r:cz»dr_\_ @_Q: /€m am_couv£¢§tc_- _1;\_ '+k€_a£€£ _§;e¢_a_r_d_\m?_ orLN;_.$u S,oe_d'_ vehl cle,_;g_$. }10. tl-_`ii/!\!;_la_{Ii/~_€ 8)§&£@4_1\731: 15_0_‘0£=7_ G.r_c;lb. ))s_.___ _locg¢te¢L_-&z Q_£ucp_e__ _\¢e\¢';[a_r_\ea¢:-_B_cz/_g; _7§_)_@'5~ Tl§ade.\tcc¢' Be¢L_§_ uspeu|~wa:_dr,\,__q_;&ha__vek_da, __"1'._'§__@ Cpmr/a“\an+$`fu+eé_§»e_)o urSU€A_-l:lzp__s’u$/oegf:_\/el\,c/a__SLe_de$<_r\ so_eA_.czS_£>e_¢n<)_ _7/>1.17_ _1_»;\___. _C_o_ l¢>r_w_ riL a ma.¢_@@_v\f_ odom §Ae_.s_a¢d_&h a__<._~)_ Q$_a_fe/e_¢o_ge_~l; +Ae_/_cean/;/¢(_a¥-F_:&£¢_:usped=.. _\/_€Q},¢c/a_+_é>em?_ _)_(_é,Z/S_ 7;_<.__._@011_91:_¢_6_`¢;¢__1°£ __Josni<_ol@_$€n ___b€__:l:k €__Ye_wclé_l.e_/_o_cié&_md__ £jsz,<>__ _/> e<l__a_s_b_w_ H~_:L¢_c_g_/Qiec _£ar.»ger_£r_/_L_é;_.s;afd___ ~H\e__€££_i_ Leé_s_u_):¢_v_e_+_ was 1~_/~_¢,. _nj_ _~1:}.\€_\<£_£_\&_ _Q.n/j dc$€nf>+[or\_.w\ ~\'k!_i_\\$/e$‘f{€ao?w_¢.\._d:?=[zo_c+ jt¢_ _u_e_¢\_Q_'o_ m{_:£__é_.$gl¢¢§d'_L/a\`_&_hj£m/g mak b/. ¢{~L(Q\o_ né_@, h_a_t cc,_Tf\erC_ch_é_n_Q_pQ§ IH.v_€_QidS`_ Cf._ark_ on_£:_-£A_€_J<-(¥,_O_¢Q(' an A_C&L‘l_L¢_l¢.n!y_/Odrka_n _€___r war_mo:|'_¢d€m(:rpa€é_@$_aem _J‘_'Z\.C_ .S'L£$`_/D.e<:{;_§_/ne_/Q_B_Q_e& 0 r`_\ //a/V_,‘_Z__ 72_ SQu-A\ _{;_o.__ ~\L»'c)$£_ _c__+-_.In_€arao._v_ __;+Q_+a 3_0_ _s w_.zd_@_?:z_&‘ , _CC;_,_QW_/_?_?Q)_ ¢1_\_'.:_€00 $Ai§~_c_m _-\:\_\_€__r;€f(`_ u_ 15`__ ¢'éES-_D €C__arj_~fqlr_ar_\_a:EF_ALck[_O_l_/__com Pla.¢.¢\+_as_¢:{»1_9_rc¥er¢e¢\__~!o_m &1$1¢(_€__ _]__S__O._S)[_@=F__ o_u(._ @J___J_e) fo__&_u_/)/>l _r_ _co_Bg_/B_CQQ$_G_,_`T_;\/€'r& %Q_Po_l.l.c_€_`$y_$_{!€ck_€c_\_fl\.?__.__

_/_ _ `__ ___

_aPFM&niLe¥;kk@_60.1-.3_1_3_1:5$_;0.3_@5?_co_Lé>_éar__j_a/_\d_$gx_L1_aLQ-S$_q_u_§;&;,:kwr_l_a_c&z¢_'pr:ob_:_ _3)010__33 0:0___ 40_0 736 06030_ 370_1__;_ 330 010_-§44_0.',33_)§_\ 3_3+_€__2._1_,'1<¢_+¢0__ _1.1\541;04'_012 usprhera__-H\a_ ,0_0 l_,ee__.s?_c_/;,o ea'€B<L__€_,oe,+Awne_r_oP_~éA@_CO/wm 1521_03_09__4£)_4=9;% Q_r_\d Lu r?/er_i__E_<._»_{¥_/_Q__ __r____a )>_¢:c_L/Q_ _Cczc_c$_e_ _40 arrp,S’_-{- Q_Qd_;};&¢_?€_/_\_¢:o;\ we-éL\ -H\e _Chm$- _I¢»e_repo¢_i"_;/;Lo§ 651-4061 l:_sl:»e$_ ____Qn 70_2_6136_~900!._4:66_01_.'15414_ cbasi_weq,wn£_ I__Q_/L¢‘__ home ` 05___4 0_5;4665610\_4`0 470_¢¢'0-£.- wer€_rko{ojrarAeA_H_QBM_A/£aj /_\/Q_L(Jmh£m_\ol_e_'_ _pv;x_vv(~s_we_r&_[o_ca:ig.¢_,_'?l\'¢5_¢_3-4;0./1~'\¢0"10_0_¢_91‘4011\)5_4051~74_)0_1‘€.$614,0cabab[€_£a_“_$€_~§_c_~{:é\a____ __Q__cr_a§ k_`?_'h'e_m,oa¢+ clea_.rlj_$aé¢ ¢a¢4. 4664_1,060_\ 760&4_0303__0105* _Q_rre;.43i 0¥?1¢61$_&0_4_1_0_ ._Qr_.\ RC_/B_\._/£€_ an__a_d¢?r[n/_Saie/[ £e_ 3:7<4€/3_1»6§,!\/411_3_0+151'1+__6/_€9:_0/0¢2¢_&_0)1\@@~£-¢76¢/60~6_ loca+ad 0_$€0_70006_440.£26_@94¢16_1”‘€,~0 a'('jj':e_b¢s~¢n J_H#orné.>f___$_)mp)y_d _<4_.1_\_ _f_\a_\¢€_/o_r_o_é_g_; _40}4_00<¢15‘6_4§ 4360_00»4. 40_ ahme_ 13 a C_mpé¢d;_i'ée£_,ae#n(¢_eaer_c_ommd€aé__t£\a__ _<_9_-€9@/»¥3 0>_4§___ 46694'__@_0¢4 &rila_c?_cvf-` 0 66(~_401%_3 e_E&_ Eq._c_:f$_._a Ce_C!_€Q_f_p__of aha.r_.z_~._S 010/40 camf 0€_41»_61;~____0 w_b_c_L_L_e_@s 003 063__1) A6d;4_004_3e_0_16 ceQS___o/z__ ~ _.a BM_€_$E€QQx/LM__YLH_Q_AQ£_'E;QM_%e/%n _a_/__ /00/761`, __ _ " _ _ __ _ _ _ _ ______DEA/IEJA_E.EFEC_II_\IE H_S_&_;$JJE\_K_/_C£_o_/= 60__03/_$_£1 .. _ _ __ __Pe_~l=rk./mer_$,kal/_enges_.+_h6§_0_3_\0_'¢413_300_3_4:6@_410515_++_1_0_4_41»70_¢0uasei_was‘_1_rze€?@¢éth __|0 Q_c_g_ u_ s_e_ 13 6_'[§0__.1 /_e_ &_+0_.100/_@_04/6 1 /o&)[e_a 03_.0;)046<:_10( _5_0 09_!¢6_+3¢_0_..0/034\_¢1 ¢_s~_¢; o_ua_r_j_-)_z>_,o_ a_~bj:_- _7__012_€£/_47_3_4;`0‘_/_ed__~lv_{_3\/e5+.ja+€~_¢£:{¢\_e,:§§:c+$__~/~é»_a:l-;p_m_ve_pduke006€_$.011)1\0¢6060_,__£0_/_6<4__4:0 ddc_s$__w. 46700~1-04101_»9¢ 460-13 0_54<1+6{0r0 s_eL_c_sé¢_ acj_a+t'ome_j_fQ/z_>_ol» 4476&$1_€;4_0_£¥_€3_0__§1 _0:$`:061_$_6 _10_1¢:('_4:0_61'70¢_1;3_ pe-k:'lm/\€f__u.)¢ 413_+4\@_€0111/1/\15¥10¢\_0§__11'6€-9:4’__0#!:6_61.4/9_/&_¥:7_____ __0_4'.1_0;\6»40_4_;0_0_£>_ u-Lajfo_(_(€o_+€»\;_q_L/a r_. ¢0_3@<»_ l_<>_. emer_\_~[:t.\ .a._c 3390 r_ma:颧=>r_\_an__-H\6c0m,o_ ~ _/_o. 1.3-1~.03_0./6104\_14_:$_406$`€04 as.-_ 40._+4_\_€__€_0/010_1 ss¢0.o_ <'4`- £Ae£é. ccommLH-ed.z_§_:Y-`QM +~0_ _JL@_\/_QJ 1_344~_7._9_\°_+!:~6_11\4:-`0.rm04£0 r.\_ _,-0 \/_010<._~1. 100 '¢_601005_ co 629;4:4'.~6_}1¢0 Sci€a¢{'ng_at€vme? . _+v_he___'}_he___&£_£_u S_Q___f_»___-Q _46€'__)0_¢,1¢340_1;7_9§_12_)06614&;4:1¢> n_/O£éa_d__m_'}ie_ §Gf_'?r la ¢_ 04;_€$7¢!6<__ _1_€14_45 51me£_-F_A_e_q£&ad_l_m_6L5_c2;9£7.403(¢[;_{£1_<__€6<_400$_'{1&_&_447.cc/:.;Q)__/o_e:}s:z(_'_<z¢\e_(____ _C_o_m/XLLH€A_§@)LQ_¢§E@M€_Q?Q_crr_\j+__+b€_l€/UJS`_GF_"['_A€ 54-¢:1¢60 _7`19¢“_._(0_\/@¢4___ _ _ _ _ _ ___€_Q:l:?r}f.ruf_)&r_»£?_rj_L_/_€§/_41_1:$~_4'_£4@§_0:1‘.4:0_)€1_)_9_7£_61§)64_4<0_£&/_\<4£¢;!1<1$96¢26/.€__&Egéciz_(¢é__$>_£ir/_q_n§€__

_FI;_,‘,__'g*_)_@_/_¢)_g.é¢&§”_ba$,c;zcée,,£b.e_ilo§,;'c£mgemr;s)=’ae,£@}_@;l.y_§l¢§e;§.¢e.$.ecqasg_,@=p.':a;._e,;wrb§:)q% nato,m£:).-_/& nai“%+b,galf;£é"+o~@hd;£¢d,@p.w.s_._e__c._<¢éi§@s,»fr.\;_:£éle,;¢<i;§icdgé_-c.MLL/Ao,@<h£_- ; ,\

_):B%de/ZMQM'__QQ[__Q( 0\:__);7¢($`.,_000” _\’¢"?.]»‘¥‘~(‘0~'-'7~' l ~ :'~""' """ '“

_ w _ - v w l l

_ke_c¢z;l_$_e__l'\e_ move -H»y -l-(a( &ur-\- h_o(¢:/ar__:f/>e_ Dfs:ér_[cJL-_H-H;grnp~\ +0 moky aug [{Ql»/e_ _an<{ ___~lzo_p_ecm¢+_ +Ae__[l@§e_¢»ci_a_/~_-Lby_@_d_£b._ g L\_b./z_g-t(:o_na<j 101/)€¢_:£;_ ani_ cg;_)_j__ Of_.___ _p_hg{'_v_j(_`aph Q//_Ld_¢?_ Cr_an'§_ of_aCQ€S-{: 330er warm/)-€f and a-?%ia_vr+$_m_§up,ag¢~l;:l-he¢£@_@ _+_oje:£ber aL_-{-_A_an_¢_j_co_/_\S€/\f_~£a__ Jaw;ku_$€i 01_ exh¢é¢{ei_€r{:_+ke_~h _£._o€-.{-/»e arrest __'£T¢_\a__G§F_€/.\daoi_o_);:_c\ __`I.'£Q /"\\/d$:F/' _ __ ar\_gC_‘{ha_//egc¢i_g€®nrehafam ‘Dw /¢;umt__ _C‘S.ranhi +h& _ce_rzua_v_‘{i_'%_a_ra:$@@_¢a_v¢_é)a h¢_gL/_agy_e;_c war wei( 120/0 111 09 1£1;@10_92€0+,09 affome<j)‘ com p/am_+_Q_»RB__é_v¢-L__a£/_LO_Q/F_Qr_a_~/:é_a_imal commerce 01ij me_r,,;¢s, ._ ._ , .

Pe-}'rl_-wner__g@n+@/)cl$ h,_$__ J'nq_l _cr_H'o_r__/\e_j_-Q lai 40 move_+hg__nq\€og_r_&_£>rcLPre:~é-\o_\___ _sg_,o/:ca§$_¢'¢»_r.\_kea_r_mj /__ -l-v_mg_\/_e_~£hml- +l~e_~}:r_c_a\_Cc>uv+_$_u,o/> ces£ +he__\/_CK,_d» 9140(_$_0_ _Le_c_a_ ,_v_e_¢: _gr)A_9 cms _{?_o_m_ m~l-rgduc£or\_/ n-Fo__\/¢denga_o+_£¢;_~£r L__Q_(_ _a.l[aj_¢zg_-Mgf/_>_r_wor _Q_K_C§_,S:k_w_aagm; ___/_czck_ed_ pml>_a_lQ/e'_ca_ase_ _a_s_e;aj_<.¢, ra&_ky_@ c\-_rc_£a._ L$__O_$ ,_.\1. H _C_C_ I?.____ _____`IIB@_C@m,o/a¢¢:l'sio_+es_os_¥o//ou/s’ . _____ __ ,_ ____BE_F_D_R_E_ mij_+be_c.¢£é___$.}.g_M_.Qg-Uao_r_l_rb_y_,_o_v;\_~|%¢_»$_ia_j_)e_ar.\:o_-_=lg£lsj_a/>p_ear._"e:i:_ _ \/Ance.u[_-l,l/ t _ . ._ , ._ . . ____ ___ ____ _ ____[_,u.£a)g:F:le-;Sg.n§_|¢_d_ me_c[u§_$_wg¢_<_\_ og_@g+k_d€po:_es~_and ___Jg_j;_ ,_'D_\o¢ iqg__ _)zas_;_ 9003_1@_0$0 _ _ _ ___+0_\0£[)'2~/@_¢100_&0`¢$ loeb e¢e_+ha+__ hera~{v_-F_'»_re._+o_w¢§_on _gbau+ _+he_z£__*“<i'aj_& 09_.:50€., ____19_‘7§_00<1_§€-90¢_¢_1-£€_/_)1_01§} 09_@/_2¢/_-£_ lanj_Jih_$_Com/)ja__n+,_m _~.I'§n_e _(_S_unj:=]_ 09_ 800 0/0_0 . d .___5;!:0~[». QF`|/)Qs ______ _ £>,//. Char)e¢/_j,j/_/m; kefy,n§¢£lerq+Q/e_¢ 00¢01000+ _

..0.... ._. ..-.__..

715€._€£2:)':\.}0}.¢11¢.\:\'__ Q_[ /?.A __'l'O__-CQMp/.\F_w__ 1+._£1 +h€_¢.$`+¢d:u:{gr_~j__an d_¢uA »1 101 fu ~_. afe<r&ei f€Oum@_.-.’ m€n+s ~E:r a \/o / 14 mml)/a_,0_-&_1<)ecause_+he__co_m(_\lam+_d_¢_@_o¥_$~i:a;\:e__+b0_4_~(~11€_0¢¢q:e__ _k¢as_Co_mm.:.z‘f_ei _Some _O~FFe/\s@_ agaian +he [mug oP-.H»e S`_-Pa+e €r('her dlraeé¢\-,__ac:irho_c%__+_h£_ . _____________ _QEF_¢ga:%_ Ea$_gooé_r_eas_o;\_ -\»0__ hela_ eye _Qad_.d_ogs_be_h eu%ibg_&+he_gc_cm@_}m£_commlf_a_d_g_a£_ _g@§a;@. ______/1'\-) n~FO./_ma~hor\__l:) asei_u,QOL\_HE_CGM,Q/a¢ $_Qéo_£¢ /10/ _7':€ 10&`010/)0#00 QZ/jed' _£hq+_ne&gdqn+d!¢i_+hw_m_<\_+m@1090/1010t_,___),+hw+ +)_e_e@ce¢iwgr@am+_o§ ._ __ngan+)\o`Go\>e(_+ke.Qu/ne( *lfh_e,{e@:€,- _€s;\‘;'"__£_(& k\&\or+&-l~:.o v\.).. and 11 cl d-H.’Em/o.+ 110 f.`mmmr¥_.

_/\ 1 ' , _ w ' 44

_00d_c_om/1)_L‘§L_H)_e:[;£o&jomp_e_r_ _/__r_)_¢me_/9_.'__Q_\/_C__R_)_a___s‘_€d_a__Z/¢Ze_cece§v__e__r;_a_/_\i_jg/_)$_,_ _Lu_;#\ou+ ~{,:hé___ €‘:B"`ec.+f\/€,_an$€____o_-E_+h€ O_w_£l€f` a£_a_ m:gl_p mpaee~_'f_j_,_ oamalj_.~%manéba_____ _G_Q_____{oaf/‘ 5301/ml ~[-ke_ 13___€0€€_0._0____</< 01_?_1111€7_0£_~[~£@__$_-1'0+1@_ _ - _ _ _ ._.-._ ._ _ _ __ ___ _ ___5__\/0}, 11 complam-l» 15 a l.or@_reOc//:rée -_110 a va_/¢/ m-I-`orma-¢mn TE§< Con€ [grm Peo<p :H__ /\/A/_¢_Q _r__+_@Z_/ £LUl/€$'['_,? 006)/__\/1jja_rreo.[_ .7 15_~£0_~£¢’_/_‘2»_23__3_(1)__0@_3553_,_35£3.(7:€&_930_;5{___ _EQ_$.o_/_Z&?_Le_p_€_£>,_ne_puapasé_O_P_g_Com;’>_laLChiL£o_a,Qp_m:;eg»)rAe_ch_£€§_oE_M£._~@_d_£ _ __ . __-EL_@___ QEE£LZL7L£&Lg_i\_rfl:s_£g_1';_@9.~01.1_3_€0_;_=>_-{:0009_11_€_m_a_y_f>_):ep_a;ag_ie§erm 1_\/0//_3;, _ _,._30010_ _se_Q_a_ 511)__2_1_1/_5 1_1_</_ (:1€>1_,_;¢{0, App_ '1%<0_)7;}(;_10_1@_!_ , 1909 31?___;__ __Ll_)._ld l(.af 7_1(0_1_(_7£`>§1530,___"/‘/0.11¢1400_ [/Y‘“‘ 01§;_]_£9_?_‘/ mp/)@+,) THA_ oov~l~:gu[an'~%=j m __ . __,ol_e_aimj_~£hov(-rs_vajwf_a_&_-FBr__Q_n_mcl¢cf/nmhor an 10-9`01</1)014700 1<; 009 109111_ _rei _-9_`01_ _Q\ _C_Qmp /0_1_11~[~__ Qr_zd_Q__Cgr_z\_ Q/Qm_+_gl_d\_no+ E.e_ol_c:s;r_z)__<$_¢_é_d_ua/»‘b __a marr m.-Formo)¢°-h. __\/a./_lp_ _0/_77§¢7_'@&/__§`_0.2_-_1;10:{; / (L{,_&_Co_m.e_/a_¢¢\-i'__$l»a[/_ Le,_$u~FFrU_€r\~i~_u/¢:L:¢\m.d_regarJ_-i~_u__% r:\;_ §F_,_~§'_L\o$_ui_-be_ ~F_`_u_( 6__£0.:~_/-_@_0:\1__(..re_ju1_3 1105___1_1__$4€0_¢1./¢_4£10_7_ COO_E_CRL/B_,_€&_C Qw_l_a_ _/5@_5(£1_/¢;+_ 0200§> _ _ __ __ . __ .. _ __ ____7_’13€_-9`110+_)01_@¢¢11_$0_;+0_£1_4;1¢& il ,_129~ _\/,_£t L._C(.£)_ 111/05_0_0111'_ ei_fn_/_@_S%_as_@ C,___${o_‘/_;_ _5110_¢2._1$_`_€1[:/€¢!_1'1_¢_\__`7§90_$_Iaa/_;_$_ar\_C/_/)efnnjl».;_c,L/ohdi_pr;a.fej_a)_s_L+e_:¥g_va_/¢_JJ+?_O_¥_QL_/r\____ -$Sfma-H¢,n_/__ \/17_' -

5 \/amanaa_l<>@{-we _-.Me_m-Eormo_-lwq_a z)_d_%l_~.e_go_mp)_ap'r_\+ 00 101..'01\_1'4: fc__ _7_ -=___-Ll@$l 7.&.00$_~£0_+_}1€_€@.@1'5_¥_10_»2_0€1§}_\¢&9_0£,0¢ 4 _ _¢QKDMHM_/:S_£OiQ/_+£~_“_ ~7_7 - ___ __~l_-kw_ _\/a/1_,) H~_o¥+£,e_ 1(1'\1\;11/1'10_+,00 " - ' ' 113101,11_,; 033_1_10\ mal reap (_01 51 1950)§/;1_ § slss. _ 7 _O£e;z_u_a |_o 0+12¢/1%5_,_:_0_\_1_010_/arj_r_u/e_p___`l_`he_a/[ej ahaq_o¥_-l_he_commmm 09 4004>9 __ __pwper~:l:j_cammd{e_l _1_s_o1m>.¢1‘@r_ 055_$<.)5_<:£01\¢_@._0£_&_110+_<2? £r_/_»A anicc)_mo¢_loglaqu() ._q me@d_eé __L_?__§_$/$_ 77_@0;€_$_,0€1¥1co/[v_,_ghere__q_pm sem¢{no aH'omeq_ soda/119 cm<l_ _q£~£ar._./_w_e_a_n_n9_0_10:1¢11_0_e&_}£_a_vgg$_c:og_;¥_+_v_am_a_aé_a_com,Q_/_q_mr___h_cqrr_ez;hz€h_é_§jghi/___ _dgi€ 03§~[~¢\_€__©§§¢0;¢ ~tA_a_@)=.Lr;l;m/acl ' _.7 . 77 7__ 0 7 _ -7 7 -._ . __p we__ 13001_)_ o£_ no_ sia+_r_\:a__or_ au~{:hor¢ o_~£_ law_c_nde_c_wk¢d\_'t§:u£_pm@ea_{_@

can_b99_\1011'.40_'1_2_4_._Um.e_a§_&_+&\&dggke_o_&£h_@_o&nsg_)_)0031_\_1_'0_99_9_ __ __ _ _ co__m_pia_§0_4_0.054__1':_\£06_mgi:{or_\)_i$_ma<t\y_o_€.s_¢_¢b.$:\:a_nce_g_n_<L 0090»_§_`__ _Q>r_m/. ___ ___ _ and 1‘_3 0001_\_ 09__|00_<;0_5¢_€_¢,306_09; am_egd_§_s_imp/_V_u,oon_mdsz)000__.. 7_ `_ ___

109/1 an ordpr 04:-34~105*011@99. _ ._ ___________ __H.u:EF_\/_ 5352+€,_23___}_'€`_)<,_5}2¢1£‘?/)__‘/_5,£5} 73?0__7 5_1101_1@1{ j_,_3_$_90_€1r.1:or 103491>;_ ca_$_€__'u~_/Q_§_cg mm13604___ wAe,r\_3110_a_-$:`990193_09 330__£¥25{0¢1-93`01'(¢0 _30_590119)_31.9<1:63}_90_055.9/_$€4__19115 comm1'31‘ed some0390000_0931_?13+__330_/0<_1/_»;_0§§360$31930_b03__3h_0____ _prosew~h'r§_a+£'or001__1'1\_391';_1'¢\3`01m031'0n__5'3a+ed_3he deEenj_a_a-k_ea+er_c_ 51001%9312)19 anc\,&‘cl atmpl~¢o_c¢mmn¢_and 501_»;111'1_159311_4_4§9 _£p__p p__\)_,_ng_me_£7_ _a _\/_593 _0_0_0130/_'/ 3_505@1</557_ 004_35111_; ____Sucl\ a_v_a_ nance_l>e,~l-we,zr\ go m pl a1r_1_+_ar\d_1r\-Formq4mn_1_$_'£a~\'c~3 3_9:)_ H\C_\/_a_ {17.'0 _ _70_?_3¢\0__ _m\¢`o fmc-31 on___nol:_+l\e,.€_om¢lam+ 5@0_\`5_€097_ v 530930 _9_8_35 w .2_4_$_/759__%0_6_7§)_<9_7@_8,9»,_/9_71§_,1___ _5¢1¢_19911$_91_5_711>_+9___7_‘/_5 w_z¢_ 2_:50, 233 67_'0<,_6 __Qpp_/_Q_z/),_Hq 111_$_0199 500 _29_7_;_11914 32_73.,_7_ _8_23_6_7_‘03,7_ 0_991__19$_7;) ,_91))»09+ 91__5+¢9+1_,_1za_`)_'e,¢,_€r_/a,__z_§‘lp~?$a_s 191,_13_ 3_2 __37_ 61__.02_)_' _13_'1_1_3_ _)@s_;__V__S_Jp_Qie _/_3_ 0__01_,_€9__0, 1_ 3_13_;1.1,_,94 053 6 /<)331 . _ ._ _ _ _ _ __ T?>e_ru/e__u¢as_$cz_u/el(_€f$a__}sh¢é L_j_-H_\_e_ -ForrYLer__C_ou o_Y_Q/af)cals_-L-ha%_o p1r91or\s_o»?~k _/851(__7_ f`a ___<J:l:l_ ne/j_'EQ//o. we_cl_ 1_+_ uJ 1419 0519_-§.1_ dba C__Xp)_ l_c.azL¢o r\,_§.___wl' `{_/16_1' r_€__d_£€_.$:{'.ro_r_\g_/zu_lz_l¢c_p_o_(_¢cj_amsui_i_ ___Q,_!rc¢-_Ln,-m< (JAMLG‘HM -H\P fu/@ » ‘ lt _ _ ______ ___.. __ _._.. . ... , 7._...__ __.. __ ____

_ a_/o r1mo9.r\]_p1eod_1(n 9_1:516€ c__ r'___ n ( na._ch_~(:/ao_ o_¢_\ _3h€_ __pa r_+_o£_ié\€_$fa.{:e:_ __A;-i_'isle(/_Z_`Z..C>_;,__v._&_£__£ 9,_,_0__0)_¢;1&00_}0]00_41193_1_5)__12}70/§ 09`_ M¢__S__~l~a_ 3077_701_700_/_1,7_ _71_[&4_<10___ 7_79 _p_£_€$_eai_€cl_é>.j_a_,é_nqsecu_hl_Lj_kaa551.55_€91_37003_1709_05»_0_55_1/_>:_€4_0¢1733\_0_0_<:9@€055£!~:_3:00!;0-1_097_77_ _00_;_>_050012395120401_+1_0 /0_0)__9) r31’1:_/0_ 2/_521 v 0_.51: 9 __111_9_01_1£0_30_7,0903001_;39 031'_2019:_ ___3_:50_¢_~3_3_00_ m 130500_4_-_¢4€1_ _/_)g_ _655_9_51_3'_1 _rlg_¥r_om__+b_e_ Co_r_\_ Cey_\_{:ca_-\:\Q¢>_ _7 _7,<200~_)€_5_ 1_71_\7_0_00_70.0_€_1_0 1\/_-_ _1'_ v_ 175111_09 {7_1_<_€0oLj_m,_Siai€_,_/_é)l_fé>§,_€c _71§_9__ 30_3_ _92141_§7_7&/,_.2-4_.2_9/__(}_‘7_5$;>(_0/0¢;\1'00_521\ math _10.1/_\__3_`05__@01:100_0_1_1 _0+@40_$1_),_31¢€ Lej._:;_ 10'/1,55€9_}&5€£/_0_0/€4 Q__p cosequ'QL-£`fom_)orésen{mj__c_m _¢fl-Ezrma:hov\_y_a_'{l]___ _/._0_10_\51§9_1105_£€@0_/12@_€_109._50% …Qha:_?Laj_+Y)__é__ cl££en_<¢_ omi’_u./ 134\ m_q€@a£77 _a£d_al§d_/.UQQ<_/Bé _:7'1_;1_€_ d€§:_€{_a_vr(:;l'p[(l~e_p 124_51/ r-`l:lq;tl:z€-_L rc£ucmqé;aa _5_9;31_'1~_10___ _9~(_,_ 22_,_§_917,0_1:_09_ _5:¢_/0_190_ 590§01_11~11+ 1_ s /_0_~{?5:0_92_@0_/___50 110/_>/_01_ __1_9/_ 1311 _11_+30__ \ t _

_ME!Q_Q_§_U£AEELC1€/_L$,_O_¢/_V;_€t,£_€ .B_.ra_o_~l-h€,r_u¢bcci$]_a_pce£ec.cr§»;j_a#£coe:j_z:§_ao,£_au.-ih_o.m"zea_ _o_{ns~££i¢_»_f§ _,~p_m_s_ec;u.~%.ns313_%&1€01u.34;1_30u.3¥_up031133_1 n 01€,,1>1»_11¢:1_€:11»_30114_0 1'_0§`:1>1'_$_¢;11)__ n _\10\.€_4_»'0_1;\“ 1_<4¢111@1:13_ \L_S+qig_ _1$_11,3¢3,12_ Z_Q_S 11),_;26_ Q+ .;_ ‘,`/_‘/,_ _n€ __ma__lj_~n¢_)__iL_.~_»__ 41.~3_1;lai11_€_ ro_u_re_gi+ke_,o_ rosenu_~f_o;._m_£e/my _ca_S`§£,__ __._13~€3-0_ €___mm%rmahan_mus+ 133_133;&0_1_\ a_.r_o_mpla_éni _Qo.d__~l:l¢e D»C~&=nqo §10+@11 1a 1414 F<`wme_r mas;t"_i=»_<>_c1\¢11<:1<'_~131;1_2911_10111311_1!_1;1>_1/3511__¢ ha_w/_Ha_+¢,@+_.$+a+ed_1_v_\ihe 1393 cl__avjé:l;)a v, 's_y_ ._S_-l_ 1143 .2_7?4.)_1,_¢_1;» 111/4 1641€+ 11,101> 187711"1.»1s. +1111__1.1€'1111111\/.'-1- 1101'_1-3_6 1n1»`amZo-11on `_~l;b_ai __Sp.ec_\.'~€i€§_-l').\e_o£€ens.e__a11€9£11._~1.0_/001/3__ bee;\_cammn+€d._$_111¢4_+.11€__£¥1'313.\1111_1_1)3511ée__od 1131 _r_»)_a¢_/e_bg_a._c.fed .'1=_»/¢ /_>_e_/sm 3111121__132/.)_¢1_,01:0513:11_&'11}_3:11311)93,_

rl;a ‘13/1$0 1911)$_¢1\13_+1>€_%`?¢11\4 mo_j_¢m_eo_élw s_ 0£1_1 'ngi,_T_Ql/o_w_ %»`11_1,31<0§.£¢31_41119_ q:\éame;¢_-\-o_ Pupgr_+_ _~10_031_@_11_11_,311@36£1113111:1_0£,ano+wr.wo11/c_1_/_w_a_1/@_+_be_,aro_qer_u~1¢1'_-1_1»¢ acau_sec,wLL/.la.' _1€,_13€._` c_Qmp131. 1141/1103 _ba_v_& +h€,_»$_~l-Q}ui_r_/j_re?u,r@_"\€,\~tr 52chQ3ed_a;a_l_\/31_1_Q111:1_\]__1_"1;_ 106_13§_ ~l:k\€._f_\£&€}$_¢?_rj1 106.1¢13_0_£ (_€_._.11__ » __03_1_.,1 __ _13_€/_\'10_ 05_'1._0 m_i€&_b;x_{agi$_$_ 11011/_111_\?_'1> ro11>0312_C01/s'e.~1%_1_~111!;3123_?1_51~1»1'3;13_+0_1,an/¥)a12 a p 110131:3_. evalua+wn_¥or_#,e al[e?a~hm;_be&r@ _3§3_1'1143_~1_1\_4___01124331113 _[+_1'_$_1___+1\3{@_1__~\__1\o{-`__Cba_an93 _noiq_ 511pr411;§_‘5`_€13¢1£1_771€;&__€137_na{>12o3013/3_3Qu£€_$_ $Qr+h_v\_ihe_¢_mpl_amk_, ikL&cMi <=€__ _p€_~!:\:l;m&_€_¢ua_$‘_ll&?al,_`ll)£_@/5#11;‘11/_/517£121’0€3_51.11»1.;>5did 3011'._113_\3;__ p.f_Qb_.G_B/g__ a_¢zs_.'é_i`o_r i»é_e_ar£eft ng31_. ebg.\r_§£___ ~ch_-_€ii_€>f 1(_¢_\9_3_331:1/`1-0~1_-161\ and 01101 Uzh¢emni -10 cid/nm 151 and fomm}é_ihe£i 2111/gme 1411 TLQ-FQ/~K m -1-1~.€ 031r1r\z1+1or. romn_la’m-¥ Q< 11-1§ r€§ener$ ~1~0_1'__.31_.¢1:_[3__<1€3__£€_(`__€31; ,o_c_(-_ 1"+10.0.91. 1¢ mnacea+. 0£~11.,4_¢/1/“3 11\11`11\,¢11 1114 war mn.\/,r+ed and +L,aA~ 4-1\3 ~1~»1-1011 01+0/1\14~}1 111&_ _Dyi_reale__v€a$ona_é/a_€£€ed~¢__€_g_$ 15.13/13&_41.1¢1 nq .~1¢1»~!_+1 1 1111 DEMrE_D__&F'FECII_\/ E_B.SSJ:$ fm me 01_=` 301/us E l_ , `» '~ 131131_31131)12396;_1:11_32@_\1131:133_o_1111#1_1»3__éa_&;_£hai:£aa,\_c_omas:el_u;a$_icie££ec+_l\e_be@s@_}».€____ _“Fa1'1e_d_ia_mh.§€_d.\_a_;:/a__é_€¢r§rs.1`mHoF1Z1 sauah+ ';1'111»011¢~11\ df§m\/arj 10 pp~{-FH'/)ner l~€ ~l;z{ 1193 ~1-1. 1141/18 +1'101.» 111 303 +1.,,13 001/0003+@1,¢1__(0,_,_\11¢111,,_“11_»_111,+@,0@0_1/_111@31310£@£¢31/533£@11-11/¢ 1131:111:1:12133_1 1§11‘1211_ 1031?3,0_$_11/1._11`_0¢1§1:£0 aec_a_,amsa_c£/Lg_@%ai£g_ eadi%j_»e_a_mes_t&€§~i clay _111; 3£1111'£_£€133:1; 13_03331_ ~1111_51>@11.1_¢1__€. magi&;__iw_a_hg_lmio¢£. on_p_r§_d 101_01¢1@1:114_+_:1;»_(_301»1___ _Qnd_LOmm»+:_+_b¢£-Fi_@§`_pr_op€v;i\j_.nam el_j,`_.a_\/_CK. 0 <>11'_7 1-13/._;0_£211¢_1_‘€__<‘;¢];£3¢'_\£€33 111/er_m_1'_1113_1r\d12_t men-1- _7413 ~11`)01§ qre c/`eov -.1~la3 moserm¢mg_o-¢+o_vne__;_Q/nend_¢/~e m-Forma/:,_¢r_»_/_n¢<> +k>e__.. ad 1~la\/ 1~1... 03 \/am€ /`~1111.’1»') 0_1'¢1_9 r _~1_0_ show __g__c_Lv_/ge_@v_ .~11~5.1§.~1 and burn/arj. @.131‘01/5€ ~1-1,@ , _ ___; _'7_,._.`,. _ _. . ___. .. _. ._._.. ____ .,.__i_

pr__;e_cu+,@_gm_mg_ameod_£am@cma£ 99_£941)__ JJQ_Q_&F;<_£Q W(;@§_amz¢hea~kh€ ,Qm_ea_s J~mg__+}@meama$_%h@_accase__€)__%e_p/ea¢i» _9?_9'9_ _-_£_19@_:‘__9___ d we,»+,_@emur@_a_,<zmser» 99sz _a;é€arnej_g_no‘{'g)¢+_honz@é_jo 1057(:,‘ _i'u_-¢a sorosem+.,-'ons bn .~H.~€ [’o_u_n`z‘_'a rouré moon _'_l~.$’ md _€p_€nd£_cd*_aci'_o_(__£iu:$__ _¢uL\__\/_afz;¢'z_o_r\_,_lo u._£_b_`_y_dv_s 618_$0 uJ.mL_4r_\_ _~Hmo_ r_’;m.o/am+_ +ken 497 -N~F~( _u_$.a_ ©9'_”/_'/.1.€../.0. _amaé¢f<:zr.\_b_€_/'_r);%;fz/E_)_a_'i:b.e_5ami'j__€o_u_f:/;¢¢,o_<za_i)_/J_La_d_ap_€zk{e¢li:_ac:l~m_@&_(`r_ _L $_a,un_Volcan_L;a_/:_$+{iai£__i¢LSQQ_L/:Q:Fp_f/_[m§%n amon +AQ r'nd¢'c-I’/we/):I: `/»/;)air_reaia o f_m¢a//¢j dairyth md c}'mpn'/'» TF»@~LA 04_ Couc-(- on ~H.o /S`/‘\_ doj 09_ mQ_J‘_L‘?CZ@ did 17thqu J_ur_SdLC)l/on cu_be/A_ ,':/'_ QAI_’_¢/_ciz_ccr_{a ne+rim/\€f§ ju_{_# and gen-fence L,'m` ~£U.__Q_?: _ _i _.€Onm€n'?~ l_'n_E__v_/;ar_k_$ja__c{g_:ja) a__/j__);£rmj_£?p,o,_Ll;XI§_éé(/ea_€;,m 999 __)__ Jana_r_j_/_!e 20/.3) +ba _ap,a)jc.a ml»__c;o_ rrec{£j_ol!eyed_+é\¢l-_%lne_£r_¢al_cou+_did nol~ ha\@_Jurlj_<iLc{-.o_r\_to_adj_ud .-_'ca_{e_}§ pp_/_¢k.mt`$_ _Ju£l:!~__ and sen*enca_mm_Ja_:._p_\/e_yeacs` 1m90$0_aman~k._7);4@w__s;age l:~fa-kh€_+c¢a\_aoa____lac if_a?j_’ar_u_d_{a .__~1`.»§¢29 _4:49&_(`0_ ar_ 4_€@_9_+49(9_5¢_992_999@;92/999%£9 l_Q_C_o dm_~LaLm¥_ac£ 59%/29+ esialol/_rk_e¢+her oa_ _Igyg,_ne»a_£ch-;,_Q\Q_QLQQJJ_AMM_MQ_QPPl¢@a:_%£an_wa_;).>a.¢_ced_-.C_~,»_om_coos{d_e_¢;a\i,b_¢_\j¢>_ac§am\_&$»_ _a_c\:._t!_,_()_?_§__q_.__")_'£,'_@_ma "o.r_{:\- _QP{,_\.L_-,_v_\_d969_a_¢~_/'eL/_r_eas_a;)@d_di_`s;m+$&QLIadge_£_[cala_aM_o_c_o@_§_laé _e=L M%_Qi_lhe_foud__gd__`)'_»l_m';d¢gi,%. 40 add/acc le.,’mm¢§_ _s‘ul».seqz/e¢\+ wr.‘(- hem/1590 )_»‘M ream'rem¢r_\ +c governma 5114\;@01_/£0+ ala-k 040 904- apa/aj ~4»0 a glle 4’m+_~.4rko .-\-na| mur¥ walked 3 un:g d£c,; _~]9` on_cmd Gi~iam9£1_\/9§__@1)_L~F_a*_l’w€___gu_¢_ram€¢zis_do_app)_j_)._a:§_ai$d_c-kmaal__cia¢m_ra¢_;eY_a_t__ ___§:4:5:4_1,¢:[:¢&:_90»_4_91_lo.lla_-Hw_+lna:)l:_§_ai9§4?/1'2$9¥19¢_)0-@9@499_4_9€2.99_&@_9@£;_._za_a;__+_<)._p_grmé_i_(_e'_iaa/_,_

4 799 cb,l.,+m,m;e,\ r¢»_»'.'@_c ,."9 999/2099 non~suk:@qu.en+_ mm'mn.r,,,_\_ 0,99/,',94./@9 __ _ __ _ _.

4 lserauso +w_> ~4-.~"_9\ Caur-¥_Jg_¢f’eé;ju_(g_d¢¢+,_@n _ ______ _ ___. __ _________ _____ _____________ __ _. _lii££wneaa;j_aa$?_mLm_jkk_bew;e_a£%hejmaj_a&ame%TaadeMic/e__g<z_/_<¢,_JE;_C_JLC¢U.___ _292¢_._999_999¢1@_9_59999@_,_9 999%9913_9999999_699949+99799999&999__ __Ei_.-F_ib,~_$ll>ab,__£_@i»}i)_o_o_¢F_?md_eer_zé/»_\_£maadMia}l£_[_m)§£ia飣§_&€_dmiad_$ia£e£_: Hmpm'na mem V.'@lak>`é_;la_),/s__.i'c_mf_\arab/F i'nJ_i,vj.._anA .~41,_9§_¢~/£.'0,~/'\/£_.~4=1,.€_ M_~llnnaf__ _.. iep a ‘F`Q¢*r' ;4¢:{0._4__%.?/)01(£\ _'_ _ __ __ __._ ___ ________ _ __ __ . __ __ ___ __ __ _______-____ ___ ______ _ ____ _ __ __ _ __

_w_ 3…; PRH¢ER ,611 _.__ wHE/§__FOR_E _r°e¢+r/-¢goer._pw $_:§;hor-_L:\;\:\f 15 MwCQ¢c:\;orAgr o ppr curiam ., .e n__bg;)c_..p mad/1qu _ _:[email protected]$n:{er. .-Lk\&-i...-_nnOC€r\c.L-L anal |{acm) mr'ac(?@rc\+,~(an ozxrc:m»¢\+. ~'\»m .~\'h¢'§ me=(-I~L.'mn¢( ¥¢,,.~ _

‘H')€ Gpw\"~}' 160_5 held +hCl+`FQdeG` duL 07`0£€$§ 15 VlD/a'{'&A uJ['er\ On N\f\¢)(€n‘+"p€rsc)n l§ /n(‘ar" CPra+eA _,__ _, ._

1 .1~:~ mn113 0 FCL n_ RATj;OM #”’ ` " 1“ “ ` `\5“"_`, 5 `“"`.ii“i I`,._.31: llj_CM/€i[dl [_ kla$'__¥;)e‘__ r¢S*p.££S@th__\.n-CQ((`KClZ£'@i_G}__+b€,.B f_.s!.pco.ur\_+_~j_lc_);d Yl/).S'Q._£»_L/,_Cczm____ _.merce~_l?>.rowawgodj .ems._Z(o.BQ\.,_~ dec hawaer +he~pemL+T_a€. pen '_u_r_§m+m;% +be ~&>.reqo_{ 133

§;zoks§+atzi_w_h,o_+_b1§L_Fe.3._+1,o._v\.01;_1`:na.<zgenceg1_;__~\;me anic@c@+~§@gh bes_+_o@___.___. -. ma knou])@dm> ,, , J J"j

_S¢gne__or\_n°_£_£g__.o.g o§ 'gf_l€; 210/5 …. ., , 6_ 6._ ,_….__._...,~_ _“.M.__.-.,...M.~...,.~.,_.--... . - :. ' . ', 191)\~ AQ@F,CL¢j_/j_§ub,@ #Qri_ _..-“_.-.-_-._--__…"_.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.