Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Ex Parte Billy Max Collins

Ex Parte Billy Max Collins
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided May 7, 2015

Ex Parte Billy Max Collins

Opinion

f-~w_-' ______v__ k /v wm wm ¢- 1'§514;& / ~ h W‘§%°EJ`FB$§§%@@ h @b,\§» oo<>€€>~@& WQ~;,» (§LJED»,'¢,`Q/S" S'rxth D ~trct eeo m °f App€'als

MA¥ o 7 2015 ` BMC®M ~ Six?h ‘Dis‘trict Te,\a~= ~ k C GWN@ 7 gm . F KW 3 KBGV§ mw\<z>((:v_s () ~ ¥€?P@e~&§ 3 `\) / ' D€‘b radf‘;K::; TQHS § / ’Ey -'.l"}lm weyqu _ '> \` \`€`I`CU(\?~QM, \‘€ m \ ~L~;<~. e_

§O_§£\\L \\/\O<§\R::S-:Tll §\{\0",10\§\/§>\€.@~¢\_\(\… l \ O\\> @®K\/D §:`S_S CK‘Q \ OT\r\< \§@Y\O\’€L§’>\C 3%$'”¥¢<;_€,, IMC§r\.c:/‘C QTK§T \{wwh`o\ R@@LL<»_§T §§ PR %@L\§ %_.§MGro.\/\§~§§U \ N C,c,gu$e_ ' SC~> lq- <; '=Qo-CCLO,SQ 3'1‘1§ @¥QWWQM°T,_ .__¢§___\<§G~.U~A \`C>@_Q~<Q Qo¢\§\~¢_,§ 311/\<:€`$`€@=1` 3~§ 1013 <\~o CLLWQV\I` Doc%<,,, T\r\e \OS$ <3"`\d `W\v FG`;§-@~Q:( \IY\@S| R€C@_§\T _©LQ, L(»'… Le>k'~s_~ \\w?> *&cda<v\ §§ qmo;zz~ _O~/_W\Q)wv\k<\ G‘:‘\` ¥“g(,\l` @LLT`C)§: ~L~<l\\$ ®\D @a§£h§, .`_`.d€/\/\ “S"\/\@¢Lo\\/\` *\-*Q/\Q. NQ,@,J L rl\,;J @_C/_\ \D<:)v\»<;§ %¥A~L§S €»51\~ \,@¢A facewe_mue»’ \Owrs, Q®uf\ Cch\ §<'v\\;, \bev\:\. \+ G\\S“d §§¢;`L<s Xv-\r\e<./T \“\` \5` Q,( CCDOL(”\`>` \BC) §CV~€.cL-§»°t~)v; T\<\Z 3 §’~(<,¥<)\\\/\3 A-c) §7¢<3 F-m)w\<\?»"\/ . § €Ou/\A§§`~,r 34\`(\ <$’MO:§»§/¢c,'(` (]:J_A_Q` /_\)`@)`°A_'('\C_\;\)r%" \)L&Aq€_-

. :S-S @\‘A OY\ %O\a\§g 33\~95\`&\<*\@/\/\ %7 §1‘? 9 433 \€eu/C<" OL\F`£: L§&G¢B§` @ql\ P<¢v\év~c\ \~LCJO@O\S Co)r@u$ n©O-@_O`A \-U®Cgié», O\.\)-Q k C<‘d_c,\ <OMY\ V®WC§_ $FO_<: "'d“O\/\ \C`) C\;\’U\,A'\` R~€>CALX~Q%'\/` 641 \\;R C&_Bcw\é§v ®\" _C`,c@§(f\ @;»\-\\ @W§OOO 00 \§Q_§w_v\a£v(e.

MPO/\ COCU\ ®oc§<

K_)Q§~Qv\§av\,\ CC@W_> z_\j<$ §§\;.S » z knew § \ \/~e\lf -L~ wm U eS¢\~r_\\r:-(\ . \O/\~./ S~Q\‘%` 350 N®\ ®\&\"Uw\q\ cLY Q_\\ :-: <SQS`PGJ~§¢&K» (\)Q_@JS;€¢W\& 3\`<» we acme 9 § ®,z<~s¢¢\.w\ P<FFQ§QW ;C_\(_\_C{ \(v\,( F<Ly§-(/\Qr§ D-QQL~.-\~C'\

\\f\~( O\CQ@(~\:\\L&~&JO/\ \<> <P¢~S°\` `C&KERQA <”M\>~\Q§»<)»\€\ w sk ~\_ \v\-\<~<L. Qg@ \_m~€ \).‘ v\é~¢a@`;\_<¢ ov\__ w®u\§ w“\\ \Q.Q` \v'\jd\r \AQ,~Q¢§ \07 \‘e;'H'-\` f\a\ §(f\~§ _Cou\xT ®MV\ u_) 4-9\ O\ (\'-9® §\\QW :\:<.Q®QL\A @O»`v\\ <3&&\ “S<~S`¢~QY \\-S¢~ou~a(,/\ . _:E<\ `QK<_¢\_§ \©7 g$"\" \5:5=<\< ~<<_,\___0 _J_\_H @mum <Hw(g\ bv Cow_f;a§>@> \/\-1€,._4, ______ _`§{;a_v\_/¢;. \k.)\¢\o_v~_»\ :/~Yj/‘~L¢<L _A”w-L»Ol/)( \ék€\-&,U: /\)7:§);4; CULIVI§@/ WQSM.‘ C,€L 0 7

0 m @mw§¢@\g\~@ S._JWAS wm q\\{SS‘\QQ/u~<;(, QAJQ»¢\ APS;U§K(/\. ` T;\J Q§S~QS` \u~< Q@¢W\SQ,"\ w \_.\v\§e_v\,c§.\eé ?TO Eo\/\ § GL»:§:L) @v\

_ @@,@U\ s¥\§ \.@§»'\` \<+Q C\;;_\mm` .

HA§_.§ '@:<\\r\$>~/v’ F\\ 0 :€ 0 \ RM)Q`_ :\~_`@;~§S__M

_ §,O\)\(\€ ;v\!\n \( Cv\’\& \`\O` v‘\c§ (O\(\£> \~Q §Lt_~@-Q `. \\\GF§MQLF\'¥ w (( Ou$v»\...° 44 <K`<.) . \\~K/\/~ 5 PQ \\o W_- _\"'_`°(X %§O\:\§;W»§ v\(_l` H-’< w \(\/\cLé \L }'0 D»€ <¥Q_V_\_éw_ W_C__WQ_ >_ < (O§ ¢`_»;\g> , v:k:…l- \\\_C,\€_QJL\/ SGLJB o V\ §9/\@ C<» cMT @dc) W\ , ` `\ \\o~§ \QQ_QV\) \/oq\_/ Oc‘q§¢~m l `§<\\ `\vL)@-»\`\ § S\a d~€ `\\®RD \p OL\ b¢§_§‘l(: N@_w`.)@ ' T@QT ivng `CS ¥\Q+` v\\/\'§'§¢\k-Xv'vu./§QMP'_\: ,,__W_\L\;Q/M“~¢M \"L'L Lu `\( &im ‘E*E:#Q'\AS SW{~Q,:\`<_MCA”\_ ,L\- ______io__n@f (<_1;1¢5~\/,

. (`oh/\Q&QAB‘§:N\ @®Lo`,b`)

-¥~lb§s§ §M{. <M\ §@§\~\/\ §`e;>¢l~c f§‘? °<B \`>\(`U~>r‘<_\(` w C&OS\/~O\ §§ m Porv~/\ /CQ(\G~\/\~QQ\<¥\Q va C@V\S ARJ§L/\<\\\¥ov\g\<$+-/ O’§`S'sv\;*§@;_饧£('vf€,_ // m G`S{'F&:N\r\Q/\F Q~@~V`zm~\ _l___§_’§`$b§eé `(\-<D \ v~_<x` Q\Y-k<,./ -§@%\M l\_¥¢_\\ QJS_KQ>§~\A \\Q_,:` -(\-(/»E‘S C@c»ur\ \{,KLL\U QQ;M-< %‘1€(_3 Ww&§> \{\Q_GW& (`)\f\ ©W.Q:T C\P(;)-QQ\X \"\ §M"CCDQ)\F\_.. . T:S ®GL§QQ;SQ_<§ g\\':<>~f` LeH“ QMQ\'/\§ Mv>/'_FL _€\SFf/xg VY\Q\$(» \S'<\: A_`_ §§ wT ws§\/\ \"\r\$§ Q@JT m <\\/\~W\K ,L` …G\g \V\CLV\~/ L¢)C'k~(r \©Q;v\o\ ©_QT@ §_[:`~§>,A\ ,,._L, \\QuL\Oe,@\(/J \)@€,G,Q_;\J Ev\a>\ACA\/\{[ ;N <3`®©9 NOW~/\z, (T`mv\\ …S (\<mee§.’§_ cf @\-Qo`é_;`/\a f\\ Qa/r\ <,Q<§slr¥~odl£?gw§ Mé =L:; CL/W\ \!\Q § U J\v\ d"€ci~\~§& \/Mc/\ CAM OL/\\/J CiL,/S’ @<N`W \r~'\~L \ocpc\l` L\/\;§_-@_\s;__ . CQ\_§JL¢//_ T“ w€§(\~év<~:) M-QO\PMH

`\/\ \\.\

z_ . le.',.p_""

’,. BJ,(M, m@{\w x§BLQ§_CQQ

\'SQ@ P¢> ¢>SX" MSWTQ@W "1 Qs§z . ©\O\.M& \<Y\e¢(, \.s~’\` Q\_QLS'

TO T‘\'\c C§\~Q.Y\(L l

\g\f\\cg P<»Gv<,/OWU~MY d

:\@Q§Q_ §§ \€. CLWL \Ke:‘\»o/v\ N®S<`~*C€ \~:\d

. :C\PC>\` Z€_ ¥ec V<>:wv\ w\<?..'ax& \oC/V~Qé_

____D gm r\ CLC,@€,;;S c§`O T~¢ FQ mm \"\-e../ ' dc C,OJ"°¢V\ LS \ ° r§\\°*~¢é »\-C\jg <LQ/v vii ‘

_R€-S_ €>Q,L_L&-Q\K\/, <_\\ §§ \~C _~\__C_\_ég

()L!\/\&€X` §:or<?\\U-< `<\QSS,

_-_\P\€§;`@L €MCF %]S @Y\ @ov\é ),...SS" {/\,e mS(/\’L'K/Cw \/C&-l@<»`(§ Y\/ \~Q_,Y\ ~ etO"-'? § l(o_-1 C[ l 'Z/

©ww W<bmww R@§W_; QQJ>M,Q, \‘Qv\@w$> m \%ij&@\’ {~\/~QM QMOMJ @w"` @'@IO. . 303 ?w» 703@ G~Gccv games Q<o? @60 703@ Lq$( @dwés YYLQ/v\/ .

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.