Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Dukes, Mark

Dukes, Mark
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided November 17, 2015

Dukes, Mark

Opinion

y 610 1151 f 1 , _ . <111160-~@1 @4¢@ `[" ’_ ~ ‘ v _ _ j I\/7_/16 015’41/1<7"(61611/?k 446 5\:5 mt 656 M mmqu . 316/_00¢01 1310/10 m 61 1/ 4<5 0 01 KQ§ l 4 5192~@ O_;;._ 1__;31<3 Oém 500010___ 500031_10/~&>.€_@;5..._._ 31\..15 nw v;:uuv lvl\h|vA\lllUO JU .LCH|U\J PC41 41 131/1 Féf wr:"\` HIBNWMAGH/ML_L_< F¢e lRECEU/|VEDIN :_1:0..,.6 §.§,¢1€ 001010_§_60@05.__@_15_0`1;5.01 _1)_11§1§00 00000_0m/1PPEALS mC) mng Om%_b~£mx.éogg_f<[_/ _1/ _ 1011 17 gm§ w T@ T4\0 72£§<5 `,_ 600/1/~ OvLé/WM/@’;?/@S ., Co/h6 4\400/1 M///l/< UM£€>“ /501-`111001_0_// 1/1 0500@04 540/00 611/101£101/1/110_6.06124__60_1,106§1€5 4_11§ @f/+ @7[ …0»/)040/)1¢1} 61/:10 11.\_5_01(!0_<1/4~ 015 <016( 0011111\/1 - UL)QLLLCI §41010 T;W 66an 534 ll//€Q/< 4007{:/_0§001,/010? _.m.

._,_»`.,

664141`01’)@0 `15 1440010//10 06/7)£1#1_6¢4 m §§>/0</ §0/1/1/ 43<1741144 00040/144101/_1 500246,6//1 7LA0 6'01.4460161 01[ §M<@%_ QMM€1F4€6110 506/ncc 7£/'111y /0~€16@1/’(006/7/ 76><61< 61/70/ 4\014\ 4)66/1 56 60/)7[141€04 5///106 441@/ 64614€ 01[/7/6 04%654 on 401€_ 67 6401// 64 :1)1`1/1€_ `/ 2605 ' 4)=€~411`107\€/ 15’ C(371T1[11’\Q64 DL\{€¢/U/W/`/ILO 6/”1/41/?1614 30/110/41/\4{\011\/1¢43%2@[§@& {0@63©1£1 §1101:3 11\”441033__OL q\»11€)\1<:`161(431<41116`4`1/:/)_;_0/’4# 64 @6>66¢/’ 60047:1/,7;©<@¢1< 6410/01//10/ WF/H¥mn€f 031`44\ »HEQI 156/mv 1')3;1[€//15€ 031@ ' 12__;101:!{0/ 01¢110111&<_5 4€1¢60,_19/1§/041@71 015 §06416/132‘5 a

015 W,_j:f>,§_<;:_§V_@A§.i/ii§§iih,§rmi 5§§i1/5§i(@, n

_L"’_' -

__ P521i1(1/\Q<1§ i'\_§__4 751iij§d ii§ bea 5§//€§4~ 015/11/<§@/ 6 ;B§C§w€ 555 @§§b/€ §`€OW§/c)i</ am 2§€___2__ 2 md m-r£/iwz Mj$i` ` i/\G 5@§/2 f€o§€eié@i i@€i\ir€)mu;mbf@§ ¢/Y b€y§)_/__Q____ ”i'b§€_ .;i____ 3116)16(6& 6621/2 fig /Q'Q)C&/ (@§m,_ @_/; 221§ /§_/ éi§q 615 D§iGiQC/` Q©i 5 ,,_l:§ /§§/viz @ii@i 20 fu i_55 _0_/_1 :2\§ pfizi¢on€f,¢m@dfri __§f)§,\ f_§.l<€iz_ 15f §n__§_aéi_iji€fmrwci cwi`€ ‘ ~

Q€il ”HCWQ§" i/\§4 655/4 §§§/~21/\§ 21_//4(. 5//'\5€ 77)<1;_5___ §i§7/ 02 /imA/XQ i` 295 777€ 5§§//1" )/§/Qdi am 565/00_6§& _§lici££<< mOi\On/j: i§¢,q,(i _{@2¢`7¢0 55 54656_ 1’/'29§6§i rm 1201/15111§\1;11(41\1/0/7 2k2 §- cic:\\/ O`€DFAWVW /,QOi iL"\ A?['i€/ w/’Ll 521 2"//1_@ 5062/'2' ' 141__722;§`_15._ c,'i_'§L// §75#£§51§_/1_2§/2@/§"

' F€iii`mn§/ §21§§15221/122M 2/121/¢5¢1/25 §§?Lim //7' 56/§1§§2/%/§ 22§ //§!€/a2\v/7 2§5§{ 1111 124 751 1141/10 75/2§2 _221_€__ 52§i22 §mcim)vm §u\di€m§f 75 /€/</§///1/)<¢11@@<1212710 _5_16//)`1/_1` 52 226 d§[§/vciC/M`) /1 //§)./)2 ©75/ 27/192/02) 20 §@W/H/§§§

@61/1/€/ §rc:m%i /fxi§§ 7500#1(%/6/1§//1/ am 51§£{/1}224¢/, 52§26 \/

. =»w~ 4@[§44/:4/1 414/1 3 345/j f §. 41/, ~3§1 94044:§>§4;11_§._§/7§2.44/).

11 W€i~\¥rO/IQ/` Cw<<=o\ 61 C)Jf\`\* 1515 HCJ/'€a§ (0//¢1}- D§/MQ§.,_EBM%€ éz§~_.. Q_@_u_\ok€~l€@ @Q/é’efcj/\/ WQ Cc»¢/zu`\c¢<@r\ ©`F __EC-Pf'§~\O/\Qf C,…§Q P@§\L~C<sq@¢chom G?[/ (/'6 lOe`{-me/)Q/K+ b _;$3_1:¢1§1(€§§ qau§ Héww§ _ , //9@£1+111§/1€/§ C@~O{Q\CQ@¢(€/HL /141§ €IWLQCG( _(._QQ §/>§ l\/C $£§ /1`<@<¥\`@“\@@§€/ M\UJ_//’\ %M€_C(id§€ NO :5`__.

233 §@4({/0$9#?&5/20(@/€1?10%¥1/1) 61/14`1/)2//14/1 7L/16</ 01/1 "f[//LQ.._/?“ __74___ 1 V)94F /,2@‘_1 :)`_€41¢4’1/0(£/ 41{`11414}1<"§ 141 04 iv”)€1;16%1 ~Gr/M<‘ wL\Q/l l`/)o+l/\ §16(€5,__:%411,11/61_/1/2©0/4€6( f€ML§ o§/!j /{;_V\L__A&`{€Me/U/\ !/\414 €m+i/~€<Y A 16 /U/441 éa//QAw/< 1/ §7[@¢4 < 15 311 1741/111 19§/ %/1»1§§/1112§14> Vll p€{\r~UL/\ €»f 41/\@(_1,§__,@0%% € :9<9//41/6/§/ //1@/4§6(@§ //C})/CI(%( [€Afo/Qf ~@{__/._L.d}_\_`\d\ 11/\€_4_1,11’§ 9¢%§1“("4151\41/1 411;1 15541€ 4>‘1¢ 1\4§19/~4 16514?/‘/( 1@\§142 A€€/§ dw%//m/had bd § \/é<l}d( 411§§{ @qm( r\:§§\@li"`?Ll/M`(§jq€ dann§ov£'/?€ /17416§11[60{ 61/0`41114 _1_1>1’1/15@41/\/ +114 game 041/49~45 A€}) 11 51,11§/1§641 361? 11 § 90 54 +1?9(199§> JF' _ _ n Vj€ 1b1 ~{\:1€»`1\415 141.4£< ”H‘\ct(` 121 be 4(.@1`4-`4."/§1'/"/1€4{ c§zh€f}\e/ ._

..:.--=-A_ .. .

`5§\§ <~&§¥§ 15 §4~11€1/11§11111§ 1'-0 §§1\`1§§1 f§§ 07§§//§/§€; 1§_)10_ H\§ 1541/1116 §1414§1'01§ v%§ §0§ /+ 1%7191[~06><‘@§1§§1§ §§§§ 'H\§ ATL§H< §§ +15 d§va.// 1/11111§ §0§§§/\§1: §§§§ /0§111'/65 §1/1305 015 §§ §§Mnu; @0§§/ @/&”M§//WL /_`//1§% 75/\§ 15/7’\§1/ §_{0_§§ ;‘§é(![ /§'/§ 15 §FM<SC_p/L §6.§_`/ §§ 5/1)§/1/§§<//¢/€/ /6/_75 @/0655§§70@/ §-,21§1 §< § 710/j 52 z §+. §§ /1/01122 11§§111113§17 111 _ 5 v 0111‘@11 5001 11 § §YY, //jz §13 21101 6/1112

Ld§l§f§¢w”§/ /510/011§§5 5§4§151(€/§§/, /7§7(§11§/§11:5/§__/_§,?§_§§6§§_ _5071'75 815 M§m§/(§§_/L§<§ 15%\€0(_ 149 7%,0~ 3013 Qudm, 91_`5`§7<6)[` Fo§/”{"§<§J §’6/7£1§//§§€ <16§<%1[€§/ §}/_/ /%€ 76>6535_.55><1/1§ 511 5/[1/111111:1( m14&/§;¢§<1/< §§ 14§ § §§11( §§§17¢ 6§111§§,5 §§ 51§11`15§§1{ 111111 5/§\;§16€ H§§§CQ §{;.U§§K\@§ jewo/M§Tw .» 1 ._,1._; 1 l§)/ )4_5 §h€fM@n/F/D §§ ///CM/)% _i£o.§§§.%_f_d§_/.Yd/_1[_1_e11_§/ § 50 / 1 _/ 1 § 11 10/ '» 611/111¢1§£€ 1514 4§1/1)1§1€ i§)€/€§\/ 6§/§ 15/`\1%7<1175 151/1 771/4 71§16 /q §/§1¢/ 1975 @/+%§€f / 20\5./ 61 7/’//1@ 671-§§ 60//€/<15/1')/7//10\75§§/€ §§@1§§11/ 1511§§@//1§1 50111311011 1@@/ 0611+ 015/§711§1{§11117§~ 15/11/§&7%¢;::55£1€ 67 §/§/7§§§ 5@/§116: 01§§11;511'7 7¢?`§/§§',/§ 655 011§§/63€0§61§§1»/ /\/06¢§ 717&104§<11[$6§ 775 7_5§1§3`51&1 Fmdf@ 01§757"1675` 515§//3€“ §w\§§ 1413 //§ul 0{‘5)§,6 755 1€?€)€§/ 510§111[/\1 1521§711§§ M<>rn§§v611)111@11311§1[1§6/€1€1§”/0/ 11§7\/6;§__ e§_/_éc@zg__

m_§1§/17;,(01/) Q 73><214 ;7?205

jj/4/ ;§g/L

%2 717§11)4@% 21<1\1 1111 120/214 1717-7 15721122 1§§ T€><\Q§j §2§2§§§ §2» M,_m___COW/\§\ 1>_§ @2>/221 9§-)§§7§§947

`1\.-

010127 021<@)1€2//// 214422/€2( 1442/47 :h</¢:§:_< W€§1 7411/121/ //7 7742'€ 012/1142 211/1111 §0/@291/12/ §2§`1§§041 1502 11111§4'77; 14114/111_2 761/1172 §§ ~,._,zsue 21%44@1§ 211411~ -' ` @15/1/114§<11( 521@<1<4Q §§ Uoum 42 :Y€O)QQ/AL§//AMG 1‘171;§“€“/ 221/121 21114/ §21101/1 272 §24 741177 77412 152/§§ 26/112<11122/ ,<>/2 //1 42 77/1,12 21411 2191/2217

' 3120/11 140 2411 6`12121( 04§4 2§4Q /?% 1121\/ 11§ JLZL/A¢ 4?2//57 ., _ / _ - , u//? // /7 " /7%7 4 ' dan L`

_-1'“ , SANDRA LNN MALLOY j%; NoTARv PuBL\c ~,.,,1..¥, sTATE oFTExAs < < ._ _ W< v‘_"f.)z.zb-.-`- :i-:~ . `._ _ * s ' l

\1 2 \fVV v

m § "< o m ~o o N m N 71\) -f<o V

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.