Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Q'Andrew Lynn Shelton v. State

Q'Andrew Lynn Shelton v. State
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided November 13, 2015

Q'Andrew Lynn Shelton v. State

Opinion

ll:iL£oooc&-CiL Xhi "TieTVSfcCrTVl COOJCT c^ A99£ACS -TNL££./Te<AS

A9S>eJU3£.

Q^ A^£AL-Tgjacry-We imtV\ ttESttZlGC CoJd£C C>Y- StfXDCH C£*J*S\S| >T6>{AS

AttBJLMXS PCO,S£. &ES&*&E (3«I£5^-\D *»^££S <e&X£F

Oj. AtJOpe^ stect&N^/^o^ CbevD ujoir V^RLBfi ^32X Te^esse^coux*^ IS&o X££*JCrW CS? tyvCXBES Axiti Cco*iS^iw

„AJSOAi ^ei€,^K,V^C*^ U2_ €^St CXjJ£.sUJ3X£.^>^

TGXALCjaa^Ss&L.

C^^Kn «L«£.VCL^

T^USX^TY-lSl&l-

A^c3^e4 "Foc_TV>g,st/^:eo»vi appeal.. rrnrjku.€i_3*west

TttJE^Ttf 1ST (52

<<K>£XJLAJr

Te.^oesse£- colc^M^CIS^o

« TA&U=- esc Ci^»3\e»^S

TASLec^ COnS\€js3LS - LkL

ACL&utfN&OL X

NX

Co»JCua^IjOjJ AtJ£> 9£Aie<G. - <l.

<M TA<£L£~Ot Auawc*o3Tes

UiOXX"€S^ StMCS 5J^£LC<V£- C5XXCT1 wMiECSM .CALErbE^XA,3%(pU*S ^^YlS.CXa"^^^LjlA ^ h^> C^ly^^a-

_J^J3£b£AAL, CAS£S A

-SWicxjJ&L\tGA££**&l\\.{\. s.crr wait a<wh - ..T

AkSD30S>JSrAt£iM.'ib^o4.TJ^ V"2T\CX6*..aZirc\ APP l^tft^.a*V

UD^eZ-sjsrAre-^M.^rs^.M 131, *4S CT«=x.o2xn\ AWZouC^ .«.„ <oj~l cr\ASS£4_\JST*re,q£2> s.oo ^ \HV, isM CrfeX.ceim asp iq.q.&^^.si • ujAtsoNi-jSxATe^oHs.ui,&!b HoAjHix-HCt Cx«ycatimA9? 2DC2^..^A iUi£AVtf£XtXl£."CW STAKES' S,vJ."3>^> 340,S-H7_CtO/ XeiEQA9P 2QOC&. •> „-ST.

HI, ~V£HAS CjouxzxS OF APPEAL! ^A>^GAt>£_\l SSaE^tiMb5.ui 2£) 7S\ v2.2Jl CT^L-APP Hcx3,SvC>6 ClMBATSSSO IoR, ,P<£Cv(2j£5=fc,,^H _Hks^sr/et€^niJS.^.M>"2asr "L^acA crex-rAP?-v^^oNiQ^vscsn ic&Sjpev ^vtb «-4 mijvSixM GsCisxzALGS^^ s .u^o tss'.t.ai Cos*-asp- vvoasvc»^vus^tos12j^ ^^e^.«^s^ t^ZLAF?MTe}c.XiejpT.oF.C£x«\sustuce,c\M.s.o^.2>^> k5D,(oS3Ci&y.-A!?p HtoasndsiCWTO12DC2. vet

jggk US>-c»A ^QKiSC aw\£^«\£*3T AflN£*JD C>^o *. 3" at^kJCj :l\j «oo 9, T©6tS CUL£S C>T £JlJb£jviCJ£J _jy&i~jj ICQ.

l££>.

crwaK. cases R££»4 vi S£M£, (xm S.x*yt2A S4,~U* SL j-njppirsis^ejHVs.^^A^Mb^ri.._.!.

\M OD'Tti£. ttOKlQfs^&LC ^>SPXL£<,OF-\ue Cou£C Cp«\£5> J^O^i jq>Q^cei^ S^gi^CM^^ AfrPTiiAvTX Awl^FlLfcS kts ftfcSJfo^&FXO a^^qs fceree.AstsefiSu £A£Se&s£A £&> uuS^vki £gA3flk^uea.i2A TO CiidV

QAiJlCiC£i^iaaA£>^ ^€£iCSX(XA9e!^AL UTS CC^^EDXIOn*_A»JCi^^ Se*^€ju^Xi3E^^e C^E£J^£: OF POF^fiSIg^ CJr A eo.3IX2jOli£D Sug^A>CQi.X»AAmyk„H££J^ Z£*^$£j^^ _3^^0£K££$LCX LA£\ i£A^ CXOL VS^. OV£L.SWfcDK*i v^ASX^SSO£X> FO*L-Ttf£*«ag€iaS£ xjo ^uti^oE^RXisnaC 1HTU tsrsreicc: coa&r of swttm toajj^^retASXT ccl£l3bct3^__

.*2o\4.A*^ N*5tX££X^A9e^Lv^^XlWY^ AP0£JLLA>3T (^UOSEL*AUSTIN <L££^XAOiCSfc>hi J*JBO TXLfcb AA^^fcS- GCt£F C.k^ **1^ £<ro«£ OL AttkUCTv£jOl ^iAS \i£}JI£UG^T\ieAP^£UAT£: dfeO><a^ X*JX^IS CAiJ&E- Aj^> $£LUCCAvX^ _CO>XJ-U^£S-Iiytt A3 A WAtf£R CJr PftoF££&D^AC ^kX^t^At^^AC ££££&£> CC*kKAX^Sj^D $£iJ£&S£- e,L^<c£^^A^:h^^ Cx3Uj^5feJs_ Cx>nSCjLU££5^

PCWG£SljCitJAL.eJA^uATD^ cS?~We <&E£e>£.^ ^erc\M^££OjsS& ^JtiNp^e^ASe.^ A£JkiA£L£_

i r

.£&sM*fcl G\ ^rcCse-iJOJL. u>AS» X^^Su.TFIjCI£>3C TO €^TA6>CUH CyCLU£r Ffc££,^Ok^, ,X&j&iY\£jjQ___ A^ eou^sedS siAT£.«veK3c gffaccs co^a&£XCH Rj&cxxeSTtte. u&gac eosu&e, c^ x\ft€^_ <LAS£.. H^sK^vife^ ADoXObKiALFACXS &^Ck^^^^3^X^CAlfcCjaa^ A££, *^.C££&A£4 TflSg-

I OmrC££-M\J£S0f^iO££tIXAkj^

Cteftft/L^N 9A(X c>Fx^u^<gLg^Sv^>rrT€M^Lv^e'g.^N.U€.c aw^ Xk5\o cc»jyacc vjxxw AP?euA<sJr_ cot^> L^iu^ss^cx^ttJ^^ A'(?p€JLiA^:s \>erccu£. uA2>

JXSs^Ttte€L£<y\£.aJTfrpTtt€XkSp^rrCTO£jJFC£AfXtU&TEG&L~Zc*&-* 1H£ vjnw£S^-T£SvX!FX£;^__ft^ i

X:fcJ&fc~2ANie. Ca^ Rca^ -

J^a^J^Ji(lC*^ XS"C^e-Cra^F CCc^^SI^Mt^LJ^^£JC(\fca.&eJ^ rcAhiAG&.M€*X FoCLXISb AOCj Auscx^c enreFxjf pycrceFca(L-wex|uE^ XJtespoJoe^ 5cto^_\5ssv«xcr.Q.^ e&.'U^T) . {vi ofa*>s twnx^- ^ ^ A^eUAjJl' GtU^SQaAeOXfte uiEm€3£> ACcUX STAT£S> O CA mAj^JONLCfta*!**^XeSvLFl^Att£

(b. XACVUSOKi SVA^CiA£SXr_v*M£isi A OXirOAlftU _CU5ur^-W^T>e^ XS Xa^TFXCXE^X _£ijrti&oosi-to «5iu,ppi^3x~w.€ cxbxxacxio^jxr musr ise, \^er6.<2ivXKi£.^ oJcvexve^ATSC-Oi^sii^ox^y^

3iQ^CuilXBA\^FiU>^F^^ A C£ASONVA'Qk€. C&JJ0T..

S^iMg4Jg AffjQMWf.tJL

41 Svo.^a 3| t> .^"zru 3ucx£s a&e. OEKflNrrfc^ x> ra^imuotpuL G£Ai>^A^^x_ij[F££i^£^£_ c&kiGr as cAta x-?oF£-'R£tocexs Sc^wrccp G+me.-eiSD&ioce. ^gj&s&jxto ax x<xac

2- _^AidX^£foe^C£XS A^C&hMLUASlOjO fc£ACt\<JO C^ GG^STX^CDOiCy CStY\fc£L FACTSAkS^b£iiJJiXj^W

AC^uTxiePD^SL-V-bLfe. !Pfc£A*JXMG, c^ FACTSAofc ^nEX^sX^, ?Gjb^j^£^^CC^ax^^^£j^

j£_sisrAre. lA^Sj-i. o^. ^ £>,. Xrte Tfcstxrv\c*j{4 d^ACc^ex^ cieAxM csa^jts q>^ sp^c- VU. ATXOiJ>^X^-AOPJXSS^ i"CTCA*J C*_ AfdGMkb XAiL^i^Sm&A^^ J3tl& eSTACsXs WTV^SuCiVsfi^^O DCUG FCuLCZot^e, s_CA»JLJ&£«AAS>eO X^ A U£iiAL^oEFX£X^i^CSL A^AL>jStS, kecAuSGTJ" ot€S >i5\Sx^Pt/zt a*£C> ;T*fc£^FO^^/^^jCi£. OXe^^x^ * ixc^fr TAv/OC.A^L^TOX^eXo&HS-U&BLCgCC S£a£-UiATS&KiuSUSCe^M 5.U> ?Sr\ 4^4,4lT.~Ht%CT^^ .CJtum ^ACfe_2c^Cl. exo^jvi _A* A£&^ft\£*>T

—tfaji&fei^} SCATC to'fou VjJOsi v^ftfe. vto&G maifoig smodLXS ? a . ^s sre. q va^jr^--xs

^A£g£^.mATfco4 tux>— isaa ,AB&uTiubO Gu^u^T*sXt\ej^»tsvifcASC ttspj^cXE&A <\.n^AH, _tD^oU V^Oio Ae^xXliCi^FAa-AUAM XCXS*l A.TjAgi .<Trwrwv V^ffQ pap •Saute-** -yfrflg- AP©EiiJU3r' OKiGiXCbvA, H<=suSL t(CiOe^2.. P£_«jf<XSSUa^ XiT A\i£_XcXS ^T^i£&S^^^GI^3d5fc2^

_& 0l£baixSATQ^ OF U2-CoG^ JSKXG=Ol£j£ CiGFXi^IV- A S&EjLXttNXMAEH €tAlTCIW£TIOioT&TeS,'W£XSsa^

A. a?nxj£^\Mxsc^>x€£n33£Xsl ne->^» £2^ fl\&AsuB£=xs twb C5LsrAK^€-eerus€£jAXHe-Scrtod_a*m* THIS &=LSD^v*C£~CCi«-12.v?^ . APf€UAf3C Q* tiEfc vjoo^&O OsJTO QooCAjE rO*PS A*JK>£00&L£- C^^\X1^XA^VJXThieSST€SvSlfc^ AS-rcUJ^^SV uipc^ess'. K^>B,\khy£. i^sx^si^eo wapstwx a ^ lc>cat£o tfvcl all, csrFzc&as- t^at A&£.

Xj^€Stl^ATXviCr CtfLiJ^-fc^LATG-t} OFFOJSES V^STttl^ CjL.C&£_ P0OYXCCXX^ T2>S£Jt\C£*S, ^A&JiS,

OFFXXTALS AjACl OeSLCaM^©^ 0^"*%^WA£S A>^> A££~ ^OJCOGX^tti^&^-r^-Gc^iOAffilES

^AjJ^Ttt£4Xh^fi€J^^vikX ACa>XAOtfe?£. \J A«XCMS ^Cu£r-Ft££. Zoj^e^ A<££_ A<Kj3UKSC}TV£_ CXXM tic -yf CO \ A.-^tM-p^ fapoc^tgBO. tyniJW^ v\o^MoA.^iCKiXTS u5KX«I>3A(csx^F^^^ A-»^C>iS^_

Tt^_ wXT»0>e££> .SOREST kl£ XS A&Su^Ctjsi^TVVL^taAPS A$£-.Cag&i£CX^ AFteSLXriS: C^ufegna^vSL^C^ «F-

Tifcaft. *\0>JC^i^HAS>iC> PeCLSojOAL, V^C^^eoQ^^jXFH^SlSX^rF^J*^^ ©CLkSSC-) tarsus* »gftiawT^&.-r^ aaafl^gX. T\\eCou£A 1THATS (>J££&uL£At> .

XU A'OGamtcn: "IL XTCAMJS.eA<l&U£.D Ttte^FQXAL..LoucST SttaALJ^ ax5CJ^£_ A ^ ^ XX v^ASXsiCX«2££^A^CbX^a2^Fcft£_lOoi: $£)l£x>An3C . 'CASe.O C^XSIS P&£^tIS£_TA*ATX«j£ e^x^ae^c^v^ASFALSG., APp£iL**3v a<&&cxs Ttve eviiss^jcvo^ ec^c>Ap^ XTALt-V/ OUTvoeLGUeCi B^XSS P££3U.XSLcXAL.£^€£Xa_ TH£. SU^"CAS^cF^£jJC£j^ XOL5>asC£:l^_fia£vJ AtoCXfXC WAS &fcM3£feS*£**C43& PPAVLeX^L- OOS^Xja.cr AjJiXACTLaE.._ XLD^5£j^U£>JC£XOX^C>£^^ ACXt£«siJ0\O&£- Og-LCSS eeG£Ae^X^«^XC UO-UJCi §£. worstvcuXTwe eJXS^JC^^T^.^>£^x^Mo_VVA^(lAC£jJSTAT£vlM.k ^A3cL.^n>2ZlCK^^y - HcusroKi Q^thotsfI 'Z-oo^4 ^ufi£Os.^ £asx^>c£X>a^sios" fci^fc^xo 'Pcoje- oe-Tsrs^ct^e^A ^fA^LtuLAeFACv ^ XTS=j-F TO ^ fc£U£S» A3v «/tfo vl STAT^nU^^^AS^^+Sbl CT£Y*A£F^ ttOuS^fcO /LlHbXsG.2O0S,6£\'.fc£Fti Xj^^AOjXTXS SvJCFFXCX£^XXFAH6-£>JX.C>i£*XLj£.f«o££XS& A SWAiJLJs^fcC^Xa^A^^ ssvsc££tt&*u ,At\ASs.£H^ scAce-A33S.uoao \H^s\ &oLamaA?c>. m£i. &iSL>~\Mcov-Q^XAe-Jfi^coeCb ^oes kxst ^ctftcallh exre^x^ A ejt^aA/sx^x^sxxxL XT AWeAS-To GeTG^ATeo AS Ohie. evi^^XF vS6v, A \USfi. \5l££- ^AmX>5ATIJ^ yTKT^^FJM^^. x^m?ex£^c£, 6"? a vJXTNiess o«_ t-ox.be.oce:, caa* e>e_ aqjGav£x» ok* appeal as a tec-os. ^\5^GAesyx^QrX&^a^>Jii^,xo^~io^. ^(^pjLessxtfcs oe^e<xxo^ JX^^^GAJ^m_c_ ir o A£&uA&L£_e>Asxs. e*jxAe>5*LoTa5rt>^iJ<^-raexEEALGxwcaseuix^G=v*vAScursmt _XfteZONi€: OF 0£ASe»JsUeLieoX5AG«l£tXV\£pT.T\A£. APPtUATe Ojoxx (WuSC uJtntoUb \^£XGXA(_- XLOu^SeiMX^^,Us^ATVk£-£e£^vJ5CAA£1lS S.O^ >^^„SHOv5y2JX^. OCZUWAPPJZCP>1.JftklS^ CCM.kSS£JL.CA>J KioCTXuSPuTt THTSXS K>S\" A*L&aM'&U£_. Ft»XA CeAXm TO t4AsJ>£^jsiO ACjGMA^uC^- CASS XjsiULAO jXOWaSv C>£. £>ASet> O-OX^tSS^JXACbLM. fa&CZXTLfeSS Lfc^LX5^Ci«H C£_<2>&_ DASCO ON* ^HfcU^X^C£jeoX^J=_t>^X<lil^^ ^ Lt2_5.u!L'SAi.^S>is^l CX£XAP?-VteuSrOKi£lH"DlJSrl 2.ae>S,jOO P£T.

&<LiOjjt>XOoC3\. XU€3FF£CTI\J€1A^SDS\A*XL£. CSF CCUV^€JL 3«XcAjuaSJE.Cs A/vi^feCS e>ED£F AT U CXT€S-*v\£- GeosC^ co.kjTAXn& OO coo^ao" tuat ojojil£> CXS£.TOX;\£.LfeO£i-OF ftjfc^JCbeKX^GrFRXAL OxxjOSfcL)^ A££LSJA^L£_ XiOCFFtcrT^ie^CiSiZX&FATVV^^ AP^OLAmI fcXSAC=R££S. APP^JJAjJTXO^XCATe^ \te. uoAS jOSt \AAV~>PM i,tSmUSSSSSSM^£^^^£L^. jC^\JlT<^'2-6Nk CdvxCTSoF APP&ALS Gr^Oe^AiL^ PjOC=» 06T *L£}JL£±S CUttXV\S<3F X^eFF€CCDJ£.

ASSISTANCE. cSF CoaiU^eL. CLAEmS TVAT YAvJ£- K>3C <bfc£jsi CAXS^A^ CfcroO^. ^X^mXTx^UxflS CJSXAU&ei TB£££_ BAS. C>e£jU sio oPFb<CX\>*aXTM TO> 'De^ELoP AwPjX^UU&£Xjs> KECoGis, €^Jme^iCE^. c>€A*cxo<s o^ xnejftxxs of Auj^c-^rro^u^s^A. comsc Atwe*^>(o vasy trtn^cLA

JST3,CfeST*oe»oxj&o« A. snraj^AjJbMXKLSxi^^ Led.-2A4i4 Cl ^^ ,TH£. SLvi>2£f\\£,a>AXZrJAeUiTUATT\^C30:i£^?iAor MuST tv\AUJEXUJO 5tViuSjOGr^ Xj^ fci&0&,£_ TO AJfi£^e^ALFo^XjsyeSF£CXXv>^ COJttdKfif-...

sS" \. 0£FI_CXe*3T ^GZFbfcXXVAoe T5D2ST^E- "t>effc-^"OAj3T {iVaSC SVW TWAX Co^Stt mAOe £j&R£>CS3o sej(txouST\AAT: TSXS ae^KiESeyJrATLDJvi FiEJjL XSEJJO-a A^OvSSecXxJe. SvA*X5A££> OF <££A^ok3A"C^^£SS A^C> WAS^ A4(5r V^XTVCLjsi XUE. £A»iG^_ OF CoC^9€X£.»0CE. T>emAtsyo££i HE AnD<2j0e^SXjO CjSf»Tr>iAL CASfcS;'

7_^XUv3LC£. jSECi^tij-mE. t)e.fe^SvAOT OVJSC SttcxO TWET CoajiS£L^XNCJ^^P€ieAXT^P^^ Pt£.3U£STjCfet> fctttfUXttt STA>JfcAGlvb FoC- PfttSsAteXXe.X^ UX\e^A€jR.lttV\&ftt.X4> A ^JeA^OAftjJe PUO<5lL3X^ XUaT> CUT Foe cajuocexs UjJpQi^esiiSk^^ ^e Cs££j5> xSCFFe(2.EiJC . Xt\£. CoaCXXi&TX^&O Att£ASc>OAm£. ^feyfeAeiJjpL^ AS A £tlbCAC5XLXT\( SUFTXC- _, ii XeoT TO U^C>ejCLmx^E-CO*iVXO€^C£LX^ LoPEZ.0STAre.v^U2s S^XSA- \"3Tt,m3CT€flC.COITYV>APP.20\Cl _.3C£C€&-^ DTXi A <GAC£, CAb^X^w**XU\ TCXAL O»J^siS0*S X>>eT^£CTBJE->i&S>S XS APPA<Z£*3T F<U*Y\Xt£_ U£.Co<^0 Aa)0 ArO AWvHL^ELC^xGX /AAM AO«>££S> A>£i T3XS»PDS£: bFXtteLLAXm OJsi TSIRECT APPEAL-

&£Xo(LC> &«JXOejoC£_ OF X>^eFFeXIiJ€jOeSS CXfcSLU^ LA>^S£jLc~X\AeCXS AmAXeiZXAL UJJXOe^.XA*C vo£jCj£- SHlLA^ieraPTlAiGXO LOCATE, Yp-»xl fctot^eaLo. s^^^eE^^x^jmHcffFxc^.F^ir^L^st^ acsuau_\/ GAoe-A^uj^ixte^ staT€.w\£>^x TWAX Va)AS PCO0l3ie.OJDXttS. QAS CSFFLO^. C~\ KX2M) . nvetfvvejJTS LAT£& ». 4* •-• - —.

Xtt£, CcmjCJTX SOlA££. I^vxjfvscsJijOCs FoS.ACovVTtOUA«4CE.2. CoMjJ^et/.X AfYV, ^oa-tf _ <t£Se£> Qj^ XYVSS^AlXEFCK^SttCXS jViATtATXAL..XXWXovLTHtSTATE, UjOuu£>A&£££-XTAAX5tfe_ XiS mAXtf2XALxo W4. b£FOs£<£. .TW6. CcuXZIlUAJC. SOJLTOUkTttE. STATE- AU-Ae^uT^'oJg, CA£fc\ D=ooos€-ClX {^vitOe^xUEra ^xx\A ejG<c>|v\Ci»oGT\AAX xtoJs^A£UL£B*u} l^Xcsc^,, T&G. CfiuefcT. okJ GevULF OFTWe STAXE-^. STATE/. GASe£> o^X^eL£Xe8_XAAT,X Guess iWiS JUXX^ESS PCi>teCsG!0 W\(L.tfATEXX^ AN£> pOoJtXAeX^XOXTVej X CA^UisiviG(c^SrA»^^ a^„\^ G&&« flATQ^o V^OuLb:yJAOX tiEXOOTebSVXFAj . X Cx^ GtLX^JEX:XAsi CALL\A£*Z, AS A U3BgKi£ss/TI ex*. S^kV.

XhGS. SUAOLLCFcCk AXAOE. A uX?x.tt&.^AFTOJCi*<vJXT , STAXLr^Gr TtfE. yVOj^SJSLO lOSFTSOLO^Gr TOJ<VU. Si^TSnI JA^PEUACJC. Gx^^eX/FATA^^TO ACrt\X3X XttXS E\)X1^E^e(3UATCoolLC> We. ESTA<2^XSH££> A^CeJJAJCSX^M^CE>^OE^^X^JvOeJXfcEfJCe: C*X\ZX*i£r mtlS,SiKAClAjEF0En5.

XeSTXm(Xi4^CXi^AK^Tttf\E. -OoLx2XNiC^Xt^.X,GXAL. to^^EL^^eSiX!^^ vT\OSS^^CEFc*m_ ££^Att»XiOi>_jLK*&:x^^ ftEu^G&OTO,X\lE CXVjCo.\\^SXAKX£SSvxe^isU^^r^GrX^AX _SfSuE, 0i4 KJMI- n^^CXO^JC^TyiElLE XS SX?0<?U4 tAC^&v3u£.faeSYlJaiAXjA,XHg- <LEG>^X> TWAX THERE. __W4SAjO\|<AE/£ojO> IsiSlXO AC)C^XICXV\eSTATE^CT^eJJvSx^<cS.SvAACU:LEFdClCi u>SS^t>vE-<AST^tSCu.SSEC) •/FfCI jiffMN?t TftW\ E^XC^N^C-iSoXVvAXXVVETACT FX^OECS CfcUU& \}X£u3 X\£m A^XttE.APP£iMTE: CayaRX;. ._- -* „_A^AiaoG*a.£HS rAlLcvXceTb 9££S£*3^vJAlLA£L£_ PyfftufrJftttfsf exSXx^K^lj XS OCLv5I>^(m>{ t)EFICXE*SY UOUESS ScsTAE, COGGoT. TACXTXALO^OSttESL C^iOSTXefiAXXC^ XosTTFT^tS XX G^IFXXrO xj UJA££>iEnA (4~tO F. Z£> VS5S, V33^ L4TH Cl&Wtf^ Cx^<£^^O.U<S[An&ki r_JDttA«i^S, OtYXT«^. CCOLLECXL^G CASES^ j C¥ &£££Wet^ J X^^OiLKi>4iF>SA\^*A^lA^^ QfeOg.

WlV TttuSjJXVCXS ClAXxva WAS A AftkUACaLE. CASTS AS Lo^GASTWE. g£Cs>e& OEmc^SCATCS^ XMi COUKiSEiJS PE^roe^^ OCuEXTXV^STA^OA'CU} Or fcEAS^ioA'Pi ^MESfr ASA rftAT!E<L0FLAi*3jA>itvXAAAX NiO (Z£AS>\AfiL£_T^ZEALSr«AXeCA| Cc*ul£>jJMSSaBJX£XAL_ COUkASELS ACTS Cx<L OP\LSSX6nx5» ? eE&ACOLESS OF tO^MLttE^Su£5jECC£J€_ <^AS^>5i^G.Lof|EZ,i3S^^^3T^TBa^ .ASXHE. <LGLoG£\. fcGFLEcTS fMlSSttACKLE^*2.o wAS MAT&ZXALToxHE. CASE., LteFEiO<£X TTIEV3U&GE\ASKjEO CcsO*iSeC.lJk^S^ Nc^XOi^XAeSrATG-AL_A£»>JT^oJCLeASEX??

Xj^ (L£Sfl>iSE. SVA?v-E,0\XWOvriaE^XMeS^ATE\ UiXTH EviE^TWX^&TW^LJDAS.S^ACUJ^- FbpSN v>yfc£CE « ,6n«X2- HjSj^T- £>XC FAXLSXO XjsS^KoOUCE. eAXT>E-,^C£. 0Tf AP^EUAiJCS X>i^OC£j^je.ToX-\eFACvFXj^v^GJLS w i*J HE>JX(2XAL CCU>VS£L WA^ n1<ST UAO AjO dPCtCSAMTTV/ 1Q_ G^LAX^ WIS B£. ttE)R.ACTXOi^S OfLXfei ACTIOS,A>i APPEOATE. CoujGX CAMNioTTrXjOfcJDETXCEEiJL^ Pe£To(LmAfOCE-AxjooESSXtt^ C&js>fcACC WASSD OoX<UvG^jx\S»T\JtAX>^> ccme£xeoT__ , AUnftK^ uJi^U^HAvJeEjOGAGEDXNiXX. (kx^c^EE^xiSXAXE,^^! S^3A ?flC>t>a^#rgy <yra^ Ap$ Tco^. AS A&aLE. CffTWuxnCi. COAiOSeLXSTK^WECXXsJC-^vVEj^ t\eFAXLS Tc> o&£.

I6icuihiCiKA^[e>^i£NK^.si\aL^^ Cm<ax» "7 Coajs&£.L wASXNiEFFeCXXJ&. XctfG sio^ S\XPPUES.SX^GXWE_ fe0r£>EjoC£_O<£_ Jd53T^SXSKV?o4 FXLXtOLr A rwSTXOrOX^ SA$WGSSX\\GEaXL&E*X3E. OC5\AXjAGC> AS AX2G£UCT OF CfXEiXoFQQ.(Y\GToX>^FOai«\AT CiS X^LGvGvY^ AT62*<&LlOSl QGFiG/OS£.Jtou>JS£XQ..Xisi AO\XXXXONi1v-oHGiOfeOEX.M«uXlG.xAL\O^GXO_ mSS^AOOGFoSSi ATXE^\PVIJO&^GEXXS^Cfc»oS^ (SXiGO^SE-nSTA

X^XCefe.tiUV^C.Ki), AOfCCOTGO t\G CXEOTO •0\StS^ACVjLGFo(2£» XO GEX CojOSEj^XO SEAttCW H^yg Bco^e.;, ^BBB$ tteXOUk WEXZ A99eUAmC AOWXXTEDTO HAJXjOGXXXjsi CiCXsEX^XvY^ETX^SSvUClOG- Xi^^SCAKiS^^J^XO^EA^Cbi ttEtf-Wtx>S£L WttECG 0£UGS. A^O GAi*iS F<suj^AS £^ A*JAS GWAgj&E-D A^JCXCOjOUXCFEO 6F - TtfXS Efctf- CAjO &G AdGUEO OJXTt\ G>XL UiEVUcsJX— Cr ocsrecxioiOj^XKixae. asx&^srjxxioio acy\ejjoiy\e*xxv L.n°irvTttG <2XGtcr ofxwg pe^rev TO CjE. SeouXZE. X.o-^\EXXL 9Ees>joG, tauSES, PA£E£S» A*>0 GFFECTS, AGAX^iSr \>jO«2GAS6jviAr3L£: ^S&A<2£ifeS A>Jd SEXXuiGGSjSWALLAJvSV^OX^TEb.A^ .^SUATOCTi; >ATW OtL ATTTXUAATffi*^A,J& PACvlxULA?»ZL\{ OE^ZXCX^C-XfcG \1 PAAGC X> fiife SEAXlCtfEC), A>JO TUG ?E£bC»0>S O(iXWXi0GS TOCbG SEX2jGV3 , 1T\<2S SWACVX^Foeu TESTXFXGO Ax6,A ti& rf* O.. OOMoo. fcECALL WfctCCU CFFXC^^SoO- GAoe JXWAX.COjOS&JTXOE^A.X (5eCTEOGXT\ioASXAG^rFxCE(CTxUSkX HA\>> OEXAXiOEJO 'USfcX^ .

X*\EV XGCoGCl fc&FLECX TUAX vOAS OFFXCQZ iAuXSOiol Axmc^xrvf--"3^ AFALSC STATGT^^EJ^XiM0C£(^^SIJOGXHG $05£E<SICiO<SP A WA«CAsSv KZGw^GeSxrtG C^SEvJTXH- \JDUaOTAX2-M .XO C*xi\V9Ea>J Mo<iTH CA*bXXioA^4Ly^Ji<^^^ C&£&L- XV<E.?,aS>aeo\GCouCT tl6CoTWAX LiERG P&LXCG-FALSEX4 GLAXmTU*TWE\| tWEASEAlZCU uATZEAjoX AO^X^GPeCZSDjO COOSEN^SXaXMESSAXZOW CJE^AuSEOF-TVjG^CXAlJ^TttE^e^^ BG _S^PPRG£S£.C> &EGAuSG,Tv\E PiXXOG tU\OC ACTLVfELis( <YV&SX*5rfc«X^vDTttE OECSOisJ ASXO tflS SS^VXAXXOa^ASXC^XlAXL flGSUCX (YVuST ALSO OCCUJ(2- U>tt&^.XUglPc*X6£ Pgr^Tx^rs C^oSEwOT^ AFTE^X^Co<ZJB££XL^ j£heBKS*2&t. O<UtviX^\XXLi0&TxAATTttEi4 HAOE-TttE (2X&tf\XO tVUUG. A UM*U2A*3T1 Less SEAXLC-M uiJfre&XW1 CTfl fujviSta^ CeS. XO A&exn£>,u Cou»*l£J~ tUST3^^vl FJsuniD1IX GG % XNETFETXI^E.F^FAXLX>^1£FXUE_AT^^ :SuW<t££&I£>iO <fAe>XtON} <SECAu££-HE fcMfc.

C^OfcUCTEO JOOXSSCJCOe^^LACoUljOG U)OOEG,X1E. \V\XSTA^EO JOCSdjLiJOXWATXUGSTAXG. UiAGJ?EciU£K£=D TO XuttKi OJfeG- ALL X*^<U>LOaTW24 EvX^EiJCjELXCTWE, teffetK^- &e£- \ftin(n£U»AkO UJVfeClKESCa.y KTi u.s^>«oS',ioipsoTJ2^'xH><^l L.E^XN.uoaos'CiqiCx^

OsOClLU.SiOtO AjJsO WAtG£_ APQELLAtOX HAS WAPjG A S^D^XjOGt XVVL. ACfiJG CO*Xtf\S UAoeA AXLUjACLJXCASISXjO. LAuJ l\r\e#GF©QG GAOJsiolXG. SXStflXSSEfc ASF^LX>JOLOJ& js>€^(^Zj^^ ^5vXSnXE_iA4 S.^,S^XSOv ^SiCXe^^AJW-Woa^vs^r_WTtt.5Slsfl looXPGvX^JIEoV^ uJ^G^GTt>ClE\1P^WTXS£S CjO*^X£GX&^, AP^GGA.ot P^SXUATxHGCOAltX, APPoXaJF GoooASGXxO AXGOGvXttG. ?t^ExJCXAX CJLAXT& tLAXSeOTjOXtfXS Kl£SpfcO£E^

XjsimAXGS ^EO^LKCTDjA, X SoJGAg4x*JpG«.Xye, PEuACTM (3? SEKXtfCH xeXviFoCUY^XOsO XvO XWXS T*iOJ4Y\&oTXST(tu£L —% S-r-—jtiZlSfaf- , C^AjoPAIGxu SiAGLTOKi C^zrixxcATe C5F sgxxxggC _X GGStTXSMTHAX AX\WG AsOO, CofcftECT GoPHoFXWXS CJCXfeT v>jAS v^E^SJECECiTC^OaJ^^EX^ FOP-XWE.STATE: CH «NAXJXjOGXTXTXttEC(\ e>S TXCSC CLASS (TATL^ ^4^ ~x O-^^x^ OAXGL Qj A>Sv^GvO SttGLTOKl

LEXLTxrxcAxe cf coe(\axA>xjei CE3ZTXFMTttATXWXS^GJtfAEjJT CortVPLtES LOXTHXUG ^£.^UX££faE»Ji:S Qc<2j>U,.G OLH ANO> COjOSISCSJSF^'iAt LOcsCOSS y ^ _S^c<, Q' A^oCGiO ScfeCXbro

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.