Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Kirt Allen Esthay A/K/A Kirt Allen Estay A/K/A Kirt Estay v. State

Kirt Allen Esthay A/K/A Kirt Allen Estay A/K/A Kirt Estay v. State
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided March 27, 2015

Kirt Allen Esthay A/K/A Kirt Allen Estay A/K/A Kirt Estay v. State

Opinion

March 27, 2015 MO. 03-\H-oo2A3- c-R JIN THE THXBO OTSTRrdToFTEA^S .SUPReME JuDTCCAU CouRT OF AfffeAb KTftT AllPN EslMAM, APfklUjoT VS. TWE SVOEOF Texas

/4TP£A\ OF CAOSF-"K£>- DAS-\3>-o\BH<:\ Fro^ THE" I iq™ J uDECXA\ GDORT OF CoTUCMD cooajti' Mtfl!roK>To SOfPUroaKT OHiGiinal RtoS^:

ToTV\e_ VAotuefoXbW. ^osWce.^ eP A-VveCoor\ or/^ec*\.

Come- riooo \AxKY AHer\ ^sTVUH, AfteWw^Y Pro St, F\t5V\OV\~TQ SuP^Y\vr\ev\V or Avrvend Oc've£\r\<a.\ fL-V-Wioo as PerTRA? fto\e G8AO A^tst V.VieprK is ertVl-Hed To AvAevv^ or So'FPWvrvacxY e* fterxdmq ar\d/or \r\ 4-V\e. For-\-W2cervce oV ^osVvce as needed "^ 27 2015 FSB®*.

Oi\> SeP+emUr^SDlH a^^vsV recelv^ noTioeL loS -Vbe. Texas DeWTfOR^ oV cr\fn'^a\ JosTict rW'A room, aV 4W CfWVA uJ- sVAe.5.

UmVj etV '3obOF,m.3sm. feeautr\or\V, TexaS T77D5 TKaT ATTorneM Y-vad 9\Ved on Adders brief and AfPeUanT^ fSejrtV Vt> Fv\e. a Pro s^ brie.*? or ffe-S^rvse. ^o *V\e. AWv>^rs brleP.

HT. orO 5ef-tember S, "2.0\H, VKe. fiiPfeWcxVe. ffeCoTd w>as rJrsV o~vad<s aVadabW -ho VWe. c^?VeA WoT.

Tke. WoooreibW coorT ci>el e^ve. VWd^t\Vn\ Tloc e_x-VenS\orv VY\ece_9oi-t=L mo^a-no Vke deadline, Febrocw-4 ~X7, 3»o\S "Poc P;\vrvg bc\<£V©r resSWx'Se,.

JSZT.

XVAis \S A?PeAWnTs 9;^ WieP, AV^eWo^ Kexs "vereS UmrVcdi access \c Wo> t-iWorH \o 'boor's q ujee.^., X^ V-ucYH* V^<a.d o^orve. \W00gh c\o^e«d 9o-r VxoWd&Hs, aY\V\W\T Vxcxve VeCeH \CrvV\Ved 'A&cjcd Y^ooo-Aed-^eL « x3£ /IPfkllan-V iS asKlrv^ VWe. Uenorable Jos-Kce. To q\Vou3 Wts Second SufiPlenr\eLrtY or uorve.nde.d' bneF !n^ FRCP \Sy role ISd so^lerv^en^cire\ocjleave cF vbe CoocV £*nd SeV.s ForVh excVs v* *..» uiru Ok KovVe_ WcoPer\e^L Since Vwq, da.Ye d>P VY\e \\e6\dilc\a Sou<gVd" to be Su?PWrner^Ved-, UmYed S-¥o.Yes V 1+ is c*Pi GJcx>se. dT d»5c.r\sA-iorv Vo denA leave Vo Qpnend onless YWeVe \S SOrfvo\ec^fteaSor\, SudK qS undoe de\eH> bcxd Vq^Wn c><c cTi/eiVorH rno^ve on 4V\e ?cx<r\ of rr>oV€vn?t of ondoe voeAo^uCe. Vo VW oYPos\no^ ?arYM, free. ^S3D& V- Bredone, ,76 Y3A E>7uVr\^rvV CefuSctl To cyTemT VKe. le-ave. fo <surr\enA dervvcx\ \s^^ noV an exercise gF eUscreVlenJ IV 'iS meCeY^ an ooou^e c5r YY\ckV d'sSo'feYvon cxv\d Wc<DnS\S-Vct\V vx>VVw -^e s?-?cvV ov7 A-W&^AecaX TP fif^ciV Roofed ciV\r\g SsssoctiQ V OcxV^3;&3, Y&c -Vbe. CeXiSorv SVcited. «iVx>ve; APPellanT res?e.<£TPo\lH re^oe.^}- to be ©UouJed.

To SofPUo^enT or Qrned ProSe. Vjri^or re3?onse (r\ Sor?orT dF AlfeWav^i aflW.

fcesfeoKlALj SobnVvWed, K.rTAUeo t-sVWi TDCS IWAWb18

BeeioYT>cnr TXT77Q5

-4PPe\UnT Pr*>4s 4ha¥ -Vbe_ ccxxT ojf^nV -tYuS rn6Vior\ To soVPUmerT or Arv-\e.Ti<^ £HSqi<"\q\ PeV»Vior\ or Te.5?orv3.e Vo Arvde.c\S b-c\e£.

Re-,?ed-9o\lH -SobrvVtHed., KrRT AUen LsVKqM le\vVior\eC, Voo Se.

Texa s Qe?a'<:TrY\er\V ©F CT\CT\\V\a\ ^osVvoe.*, riarK W. Stiles OnIV" CERTxFr/CATe D\= 5e9vV\cE X We.\*1 CcrfcFH 4-WV a Vroe. CoSM <dr +-be, eiboVE. THoften Tor Suffli naervT <oT amene^ed- fkV«"V*oirv cT VrieP uaqS Served oo F\c G^ior^e- fAcC^ed, Dis-Viric-V MVorCieM by Pi qc> n ^ <sc CoP4 in+be. Os fT\«e»v\ adeing-SSed Vo, Tora Green Coon+4 eoorVboOSe-, CoocT ST- A^tOeX, l"?xM uo. Beaom.€^*Vd, San Ano,e\<o,TexQS 7^03", oro Vb*s -Vbe d^H ^ FWocJn SjeAS.

KlRTAWen £s*bQS

TDcSND. YW078 TABLE OF AUTHO PQVTXfe 3.3 £.1W son V- -ST^Te Clex, Co A?E) H/S S.tO. 3d <©H^.

3.) JacKson V. v.Y^triiOiMM3 0.S-BO7, 3\&,«^s.cT 3.781,^789, fclL.E.«i ad.S&G,573(\«nS) ^0 J-asVec V- ^T^Te ,^-7S s.u3. 3d sFa.,517 (lex. cr\«o AFP a 009) £) ia, ed IOM, 44 U^d 7.d 3H"^ 4fe s.Cfc33«U- 7-) Ua-T^VSVad^, 56^S.LO.^d HfeSOSlB) g)^an^oLtv\\n Ocxv\d-S©n ^" A?PeHQnTV- Tbe, sVa-Ve. dr cri wslncx\ A??eeib ©9 TeXtiS tea. S.vO- 2<A X72;(JH8Q) 6 «0 AobnSonV, 5\o\c &V-1. 3-to, 2d \4B(jex cc\m APP tqeO \0^ btxcVvSonV. VJr§\n«*, 4H3 0.S.307, 3VB (jHIH) uD cfc K4les v. LublflH/SH as mq, H^Hj&vis) ClA.) 6* &<-Ve- oJelbon 785 S.uO. 3.d 341, 343 Tex asp(mo), 13.) tx Var-Ve WW^, G^9 S.laJ. ^d q 43, 44k(jeX crim AV?, \q£a) VH^ CfOZY SV\e. 3.58 s.UJ- 3^ 2>©4> 3>^(Tex A?P-4ovJs1^oo",) VsVDxsA- (3.00(0.. VOo PeT.)

TS.) £>ocw\s V. SVo^e. 73.6, S.oO. 2ei \V4,\U>JSex AfP- Hoo s Van 14"Th O; sV 1q 87") I. of 3 \Q F^uarb^V.sTaTe., IV3o ©7-05-O3W cft» aa«o Tex 4 PR kex'iS 3>&e>3, "3.0CD4. ujL S^.5o3fe^ a+ ^TexiPP )7,) HoB. 0S-cA 154. *>\ L£^ 2d l©42 «0. s.CT T63, )<g,^) \n.SOpPva\eoT evidence ©P^ek^AlM toeeiVon \r\ Alvarez. V. Stale 5Ub StuO^ GV2..

V€\7) £>ec\Wv\\rv tWidscn Ar^ffeWcvX V-Tke sWte POu) TroTK SeeV^rM^ Vox"\cMot\ o? VcisA, FroCe.SSla,

^ 1^1, SS S.CT3HO, <3£> AV-R Hot. (See^aa.1 3^0The CGurT rec\fF0ff\neei> 4-his Principle in broader Verm in fMLeV. Kc^nSaS 3V7 OSaft g7 u fed aVA, 43 s,cv \-n.(VSH^) ^^ CV- UovPue VIHinois. 3(cO us. Zi<a^\.2!o% 3Lt a odiaVl, 7<lS,cT U73(^54^ "2.^ TrutK SeeVvVrv^ rorte\-\©r\ c>P VV\e VcvqI Prooe^S Id, Q+ IOH/H^ Lite/ ad 34a, %sc+ ^5.) bec\^v. OK;© SlSus.Sfl.ftS S.c\^3(\°^0 CcvnrC, yxqN PcoeedoC § 33, exV IHO^A^^ (Tex cr\mAV?aan) tL.eF3 S8.") (jOqVsoh VsWVe 3.D4 Sui 3A.H©H,HAS (Tex cri rn A?P 2.GO&1 5,40 (^VooneM V. H©lo\\a.c\, "3.4H OS \o3,7** I- &i 79/, 53 s.cT 3Ho, SB ALR Ho^GhBS) 3D.)In re.^iosh'iP, Ho s.cT. \ot©6Gn©) SO AacXsoW) V. V^lnxQ 4Hs. cT> 2.7©\(l4^q) 33.") F.ofte V. u^Ki-Ve, t-it S.CT 713. GttxDl) 3^ SoWWcvrv V. Lexj\slQoq, H3 SvOh ^©78, 6^3) 35) s^cteV. oT+cn, SIS R>£ aJi to©q(W&b) "TexciS Co<des c<Sto fyac

38,D3/Wrnor» SofiPaoog) TexaS fkrv€x\ Cetde. tinnf^.OI Rules drevi^ 6gS(B 6©^^

3©V3, The claim of ine9fecb\veness ©^CexJTvSel To Prejudice., -Mrxe cevie.uJvrv.3 cccxT mosT Ot.SSe.5s ^be.

C-Umulqbve. im^iicT oFa\\de9vc%en fecforrnemce cUirris5Forls^nVs,3g2iBSlVSz^s.,L 3Rfi3.S;V-\4: 3£&£&l2Az251 3fifi^);\-^H; There \s T\o^cWvo^ qbou+anu Ki'ds aoyt-jjbere in Vbe. Y^coc<^s^ixjrve.re is *be Ob^eeVton1? a\so.3^54;l3-24; 3ftft57;K>-u: W^ ST«^39ftfii-;) ao-^s:"M&r^* «v**i-\ >= inconSiS^e.n StcnhajrvaniVs «rstoe\l as c©atrevd\CL!Vvr\<^ res^monVj 3E £] 3KKL\lk~1^ and 3ftfrk1'. .39ft fc5?

3ftR4>H*. Nooo pVSue&bVofe VoWk !^.* 3PJR7H;^Q' ^P^-?s;.3- AFTer Vhe bceaVs, 3BP^i2?*- 39ftftfari? qUu+ 4be Knife--, see*, 3^7M:1-jh; e^a^jG&Sr gna noAu, ^BB e>*s; 7-u ; OFF\cep GeorGiWA

£raes-F Torres ', Mfiift3V,4dH: o^viR9v3a'\5-^a.

39v?v\Qq%H-S: ond no^,3J5^Vi5ii5zD^ also 3ftft33;tedS: Q^d SWSjA-?)", Qv^ar.ocu,3RHl33pF^3: UldTtgxm*, v.Tt*4foc 5^ OS 3t>2.fr©oo) Also e.c^^ lp.'^\y^_y. Snd.Vb. VolB s-c-Jf. 3527 frool^} v,po>sYt\ncjfa> V. Srvd Vb> SU4F.3d 6^0, 634-3>H> 7TWdr^Doo) IF CconSel Y\e*d imfecxcVve^ +Ke "hasKmonles oF 4he sfafes ujtrVr\esse&j ^icV»cvel CerN^nles^ GUadQUuf^k LuroA Ar, and OFfrceC G^r6i<nq n^rltZ.; +V\ere tesi\monH eosold obvieUslH been So uJe^K qS 4o ondecvn\nA C©nfvdetf\C^ in FW Verdi cY, See°3 JohnsonV. sYaW. 33 s*vO, 2d //Tex crttr\ A?P. "iooo)' AaWe\WnV ckumin^ 'insofFvevencM bectCS ex KecCvV b^rdervUnifed f\Zi'dence vs leOjeiUH \o.S&^Fy\c\er\V Qnd f acAoottVl ivnsoFFiC\enY Yo SvjIuorY Wr\e 'CortV\cV\on- OFficec f°>Q<SYz. of YWe. GTFer DefetM uoooW noY V\^ve Meed>ed ex Se^rcYx vxjooTCqnV if \n^cY +F*qY Yhei +Vvooo)aY +helc u)as q Y^Fe,. CcAp qF GcknLpc^ P^nc^dore^ AcTLOk SeafcV\es QncY Seizures no? u3\YV\odt ProbcibW CaoSe So??©fT VdH ooA^ oC dPP^rrncrHon, ,4cYs \Hfc5, 5RTh Uo^ Yol^u ?2>n ch. T^eFr^anU^t; See^fiBd^H^lkra^ 3ftfa^>VS> E-uSfiASeU* RbtaqkAe o.Qose.j eff-i ce ujFio ma^e VY-ve challenged nr\TesY or S^aocV^ 5oV)<iecYl\/e\y> \oe\\eveJ V\e W&d cjPoonds For \\\S QCTion. Ks emPlnQ5Vz.ec\ in Bec& V, f e 2>>* us,8>%85 jrvidenee in A^Pell^nY c.onvCcV\on u_)ill reverse on fhe boS^b -oF vnSOTTva\er\ci)bears ck VieQVH Cdbeo adeFendarvTisc-Wi^vxing tnSuPp£c\encH ©P-feV-ve evidence? Unda^ SYoAe-s v* HalisziBUJsKijia Faa SYconQ SosPleYxon Yhcd- someone \S \f\vo\ved in crimincj dcVJvt^ is no SubsVvYoVe. For PoaoF oV goil+ beyond <q \Tecxson able doubV* TnPeinencje. is Ql/<sxx?edr sPe.cuLo.Yton 'is noV. Loich V\wY^ \n %-\e chain oF inFerence^S musY be SoPFcoenYlHsYrong +o GiVo\d ®i WPse tn+o S?ecolaY\on. foot sKe^osK\ V.EU-V PcoSeCuY\en need neF negaYe <cjl -theories C<9nsisFe,nd tovYh mX\OCev\ce.T^e YfesY isuohe-Vhec ProSeCurVion hoS Proven iYs CaSe WMond ©i reaSonc*b\e dooV>Y. Vcxicd V. UqcVV 88H ^^A Hya (£H\ Cxr 1^18^) vrooV loeM©\rid recnSon^bYe doobVm^ans Proot ujV>cVi vs so Convincing YYxaY ^eo uo©uld noY VxesiYofe Vo ceR cxnd c*c± onWlnwN^ VW*r*>54 imTorYcin-Y oWcislons \n Hoor oconVvVes, ^njYjsd SYcdes V* sY-euoarY 3ob FBci 3515,30b &4b Cir 7^oo:0 tn61 no, of >ArqpmenT Tbe doe. Process clause, r-e^jifes 4-be SicxVe Vo Prove eVerM element oV Vbe Cf\me beaond e*. ^txsonobb doobb Xn Qg-U insb 0.3&.

5.cT, iD^Cq^e); Jaebson v Wcbo^, 44 s.c\.;q%\ (^7*0; FioCe V Wlbibe., \3A S.CT 7i3.fe.Go03 SviWWnav Louisiana V\3 S.cb 3.0786£IH3»\ loFirsVo The AF'FrpAVXT creeded bu> o??\os^ GeorGAno. P4ar'dZ. sVqWV-OHQ bad advised be Observed AYfeM&nb Threafenioc^ mvCcWunVs.

C<FV, ?-€>• i^r Luoq besV;9veo. be s^ bis torcAbeC-\n-\excu u3iVb a S^-ic\C in bis band, and bbe.n He Sa^ AWe\Wnb ujiVK q bbxVe \n bv"s band. 3S^^^^^ 3^74} \-2.*. A\ so See S^B^MR: FinaUT, see 3P&&5; n-2A: -^Tbere. Idas noTbreobrvq. dY^ad mr buna seen Pfcn bbe AfPe\WbT. Ue. weve<- fes-PiPied -Vbab We Seen A??eManT TK^vsaTer^ fnr Cervantes. oVTV-ve. c_cedib\YibH cP uo.Pr\eS5es ciod cledecmt n<23 lObe-Vbec in resolving c^nC'ba-Vs in 4be. evidence, Vbebbe^ cFRxcb bs4 iVs aJao> cond ccecded. Sucb <sx to i SCarf \cxq e. ©9 S\J sVi ce Vbe\A Vbe convicVion rnosb be Vevecse6 av>d ov YA«yuO bf4ed ordered- Sbdrf V, Maxbkx \-D~8 ^G ^d 7(\4SS) ', 5W^3^ obj-en. g*S v0£ gkd leo^ (XHttb"!' tf5^^ 0 ^

c -4 •i % go

y x ->) m ~

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.