Esthay, Kirt Allen
Esthay, Kirt Allen
Opinion
AWeAW ©V TEXAS k^ta^ wvwm ORIGINAL V. Tc CV. W>o. OAs-\S-e>SW* THE ^TM^ O^ TEXA S> RECEIVED IN AWeAWe, C0URT 0F CRIMINAL APPEALS , ^ xx _ <-_ _ JUL 17 2015 Abe! Acosta, Clerk FILED IN ^«&e<£YPo\\H SoWxWe^ COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS KI*V W^ 9 A JUL 212315 Tfc C^> vuo. \^c?TB^ SoCo^Y^XH Abel Acosta, Clerk SbecxoYv^or\\7T^Til0^>
V.^ WXW> A?fe\W\ Wv\no> Very Vo^er* Wat^ \>r\ VW\5 \\©^r\V°o
T>\ Y\\5> OTO SV\Xe/»
9<*>V TW XfteYW^" X<YKT AXW ^>VW*MV.vjlKi^ IxN^c^e^ on tUds/eT^Xccr SlS A°X3> \ Voo AW S*^ ^^e-W^e. of
oWeXVc^Y foe *>U -^^Ys^c^Ys^ W^v^^ unV\X\ Au^yIs^oY^X ^H W o^ VW^vrWY ^Wri«^ diSoc^eYWM oo^AodV ovtn^ XD\3CL^ovoie./D\^>Xcxoi Yvce, Arm^Cc^ Tt^er. Aoc^o^X ^% "^oVS AWbVWoV W cwrcxXn^ ©Npvce <sl^<svvo > YV\v"S Y\rv\e P°^ c^gy^fVaYeei cx^SavAV uu\VX-\ gk &ecx^\H uj-eoSonj
9^. ^ V ^VocjsjAooqA \A\sYotM ^©r
-\-o YW cAecYA of We W2^ dCsYr\cY OooeY ©F C©*nv£Y^ C^y^^A T^Xol'S ^To ?r©vv^ue, Vv^orT feoar^s o*jV^ ^C
3«) AvVkYWx^Vs ywsV\€>\-n Tor YrooocVxoOi o?" ciocorr\^x~xVs ^olM^Wew^ Xd^ YW CoocXs ^ecexv^^r^;^©^ ©^eX derx\ed> Oec^e^r^oec ^^oW- V>rveV w^ o.cexWYed , OcVo*De,\-3X "^oYH ^-^ovxrs^ do\e SJ S*e.ae>rvcY Yv\o\\e>^ Poo e*Vex^\o>n Y^ f A^ Yco S^ O^xex OiceY^X^ec "B^^YH Y*>?eW^oxM n.'io^ O Ocq\ Qro^rnenV dtenxedi .m«c^ ^"aoYb!, TW AWeXWxY V\€xa rvoY rAeo\ ^©0 otqX cx^Qorrvsr^V • C^o^e, SeY ^©r SJckym sS\vorx cdx^ Vco ^ W\^ Xn^r^dcivx , X^ov^rO^ ^SV^OV^ GcQ^Xedi, Wovrc^ U,^\V5 AY?eUcv<Ts .Seaier^ ^ Pro 3E brve^ Xl^S, <^r«xY^\ej& Q^-uae\V'5 ^©^eX^ 3©A°X^ • &) AVfeWovY-^Y ?e.ViY^r> 9©c t_Or\V <sF XVX<sm<Ycx\^0"S 9\Xe^ A?rv\ Y2>,"£oYS, cxrvd uoov^ S^\A X^ \W VVxr^ &\^\r\^X <£ e$*V\Xs, W^Y Vo \~tovve, •\jC\>^t\cA-\<ao Y<s> ^rar\\ 9W\\e>rT ^^ r^oXxor^ foe ©S?o\nYr^ev^X <s>? Ceon^eA &e~T\\eja X\J)<aVexv>Yier 10.*) motion Por T>&ViS€m~ cUrvvec^ i A?r\\ Pi U©V^ - \\."X TXXlccY OsovY ©V ©vWe<oXs AYYvC^e^ TrvoA CoofV ^>oAe,T^e>rsY. X^AevCoV ^1 ^dY^>V
\^ r«\«>TW» Per oAen^onS Yo^Xe^AX^s o^atxYcA H/^S/^cdV^ ox^YvYY boYAYl^YV-
V^M.
TWv^ PeWfeujirv^ VvsY \<s Cer^WYcL ©X1 ^YY ^TX^-s sxs Loe\Y^s Y^r^e^?«idLdLre.sse.3, d? etl\ osuoseU O JfiWW^ K.VT AVXeo tsYVcMv ?<-o SH 1 AT, ^©bB V„rr\
SYeAe 1iW TO©. \&5k&©(9©, \^ S©uXY^ "Ervvr^i WxKr^sX© TexcxS 76Ao2u 3) ATToroeM ©VrecjDrdi ©rx oS?e^\ ?or XWeXYsx^Y, \£C*Yx SAWj A^C^\o^e.*€x5 7^PlCfV»
C3vdoo\r\\sYrc\Y\ve ^>o^>e, u^>\XX\ cyrr> So>r\ Coor\VA CoofXVvOose \YdS yvNcx<^V\x-> VoY^ex \4\ynOj vS*>oy^ G?e^ir^e^Xro<jorA ^Tx. 7^(0^(0- 5"3 TKe Y^<o>oea\oVe, ^>^o\d^>tc\ YC YYoVr s-v-n^o ^YOOo^ VW\ls V.WveXX CoxxcVo Cooo"\H VXDn^YvYqA CXecK V-G/feo* ^B, Pc^v^Y 9s©cX Texas 7fe^>^fc-<&©qft 4) Tke. Koi-Aov-cxYAe Gesr^e -t- P^ c,Crec\ X^\^Yv\cV AYWcveA S^ru JYW)G6U T<^ov£ "7.^o^ i) TWe VioryDrsJbVa Be^ Uteodtoa^A> Yc^exY ^^e., T©^\ Gpt-eerx C^cxx-T^X CoorXXs.ovj^e jC(SofY sY.Ar\o><2X Y"XM \jJ) . Bejao co^QodL Sqy^ JYrv©>eX©~Te*a^ 7GAG3*- ^. TV^ Y^oxAoraVAe, ^*VO©a^PV^ .Xqv-^^ CXraeP YovYfcje, JOo^o ^Y? V.W l CWeJ \js\xol •> of YWTW^ CovmT oT AW^s ,^G,X^ w^vi vu^Wn^e*^ 7Bi\Y-a^^n 2
9^5. (3^) <&^r\^cxorV\r\ DoM^soo X^-JSPeXXoorvA -NA ^Wfeu.W SlO. SYd SCVS^ ftHBS Tex C^Vnrv AS^A : (g>fcoujleM V- "SictVe, ^lO 5uo 3d HV^.^HCTWX-Cx%rx AP? "^oVO^ © Boras V. sYoCt^ 73i© Slo. :uH!H)UfcvTexAW-YW>Wi- \HrH disV IHB7 P^T^Re?^: ©C^SYkxPje V-XtKrvs>\s. 3bO US "3Lfe4, a<b^ ,SV~^i adt pT^S S.cY \Vl3 (iHSHV, Mo5USccxY\^M;v 31, U z£ loH, qa S.cT 7fe5", ) Cleuois. V- SYaYe **** SuJ ad „UWL33,(Tex corrv ArT Wife}: © Cc&W V. Sb\XW*n v\H(3OS33S(]qfio): Cramer V* SWte. H$ Tex trior* So©r &8 s.vo, ^GB^lHH^M)'. cAivs vvsY^Ye **>& s.vo ^o\ 38^3*18 Tex AVP-VWW* . (^006 TOO PeT)
r® •E?/i»n-vS^T^.(Jfex-Gr^-.A,RR5 4iq-3Qd.ad:BU^A -> ,.--.-, dEG> exPacY^P^Wow. ^YS ^ ~x£ T33 (je* cc^ AYV VA^O fig) Pve^oeroov V- SYexYe TUo.o7-o5-o^\M-CJ^ (?.oa6T&* $£} Y=CsWr V. SWYe £>S\ S^Cr^ 3?\§>1)0^,(%* ot*«vn 5^?v«=\^) (Jj) TceoAo. V- S\oAe, T^TeX OrY^ l^VX, X%S Svx> Y\ (XHY&
^ Y^oWbctv-xci VSYovYe. ko^Suo 3^ va^K S7^\ Soj^ «\^e
@) XoknSooV. SYaVeCW^ Y5k su) WW* (ggS ^o\V4 V. SYcde foc\nn A?P \<\2l6> BlCTeX Crinri A??Att*) 2) ios^ Pw AWo^eX. V. SYcvYsl 5Uo Suo 3ul 4,13; 63> Kx^ V SY^Ye- 4,Hb sio-^A 7ecu
© W v. sww. =nsSul 3e1.su,snfcx «^av^ PYcUx^M V SYeaYe S^B. SoJ ^ ^,3X (Tex Cc\<^ A^\^T\^ mePrW^ V> R\oW^s©rx 3<r7 OS. 75R (\^Xd) @5 r^ej^ow^ UJinfraM Hcimmon^ V SY^Ye, 3H3 suo~3d 7fc3fc©\,a) Vno^Q^OiVe^ V- SYcYe *2A\ Suo 3^ ^YX7 HY^CXe*. CrYrrv AW -Xexso) fOefUo V. Vt-txYe(vfe5s) \HTex 3%7 : <5T?) PteoSct^T V SToTe (\^Ho) \Ho Te> c^<v> ^t7, \«AH Suj a^ 5ns:
PouoeU V* A\€*b©irvAQ 3.87 US MS 6^3^) ^ Simpson V.sYcxYe \e>«\ Tex Cje\ro 373 5uj ^ \^,\^,
sYncXW\^ v. vo^€>,s»X-x;ogYo\-Nt H(d(o us k(a% (m^)
_ Trt?WYY V. SYdVe. W)q..07-o^O\^\-c^, 2AA Sv^ 3©X 3o5, ^oo^T^x AP? V^x;s sy^h, *ajosA u^V was^s qvYH (Tex A^r Ay^€xcV\\o uooq oo ^eA-VV (£1) THujoo X^eo^rvoW PncCeTvrv VY SYt^Ye. c,\Y\r\^ ^<s 70.Sui 3a Mq7 frex. C*-\<^ AX*? 16oq1 AS? Vloq£) uo\Y\\c»rriS "V. SYdW ^g So31vY7MvH7S,(T^x Cvl^ XSP 9<3^«
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.