Kenneth L. Hill v. Texas Department of Criminal Justice Correctional Institution Division
Kenneth L. Hill v. Texas Department of Criminal Justice Correctional Institution Division
Opinion
FILED IN 14th COURT OF APPEALS HOUSTON, TEXAS
APR 13 201!
CHRISTOPHER A. PRINE ifau t*M4'l4-MllM-&i CLERK
d£zju no gnt^
^mJL d /Ml typM+dr Oust G\ww»<l i\ fbifi£S fhhn ti „ ^wkntw fit (bub J erron &
ifitriti m Mr/..', f
fa I b em\&rmjQ3N'<&&»'Wo Clb/to* Qrwt'Jb z^>9) fa 9
CtotMhtr&aaihp lm &»&&&&&/&$) r 4 d M \/k6^du6tf^r^HVbllui^^x^^7^(i^ tew) & r WrM & jmm&JJJi a? Ssasktot *&/ *r u 6* Gortv is $/M &&'S*#J fai &b •T&cJitr' 4 ft f/fme// 6 S/a/wm* $WSlo& (, HtototaJ & t&h fwbr Gb. msc^f7tW J9M \
titicrte tf/fcM JtdstoW syy Cftt2x> ) J, b to DoonAt vf&nlkv Jfi/ao&?rf fl&MfD*Jkr tfru) b
W^M^m^f ****** q HmuJ±LlUi l/dliunu3 ftJlJ-A3 tout* ftis-jpj (toe .tos'-xfcn w**r&3b *>.£&$ tilmrt letter Qgt&rx &)jc/Mjq ^CbnuOL LuaUmo iD^4/Mm V /mad mii&> Mm 3 dU ft<tr fatr tJhxJu ^ &> 3? « 1
Pago /"/ I/ml IU N-N-DDtLHi/
/faawt&.Awtr 77-s?-?^
#77*27* ft/yj/ffist /0&£a/ Afpr^/4ecfrsjPMJA*y^jA/j^^^^*/j^/te«f/fita**/. tifato^/i^la^p/A^y./m^/^ Ik*#&/ 00*/** >£*r * ZGfay'/%#&#j&0
rr~ „ At dr;7j£0A7J2?f- ***'/P/^SfAaittuT* ^/2%%^/jfjy &^^s0&Zs/s?*z<S A2&W ^J^AZh^^s^/
A*.-jU/-jt A!* dmzf~
^d^J^nuidA^o <~6fot-
7A7/95 2a7^A3(J9///(^/r/^/xM^/ya A^/lla^^yM//Ae^eM AJ/,77
^^m^Ade^ jua^^JIus*£ahs,l -£ „ „ JiaMaaiu aU/U&2# ,*£^*^^ $#*'
7J?J/o^f/y&rfifc/&;JJ6o
\nfo>/&8i) fimj^ Jj/L/fes f*& A&U<Us jyTji/etd? , 6k* ,,3 m j - .fajJMita J*ut^-/jwtte&toAf OL£l \///>,n , /%$As KM;* sA»a>S j#^^S Ad. S. , /yyjfJf^A /JSfsW/^ . dh7/Psm.jJ >4hl 0toc & aZ/J&U' Ayc^ f/&SeJfJrTiMs f/p&M</7°J.5 /MeS7/-<2S
Ta/at/A Mi±s fe*^/zAu/J/7/MhJ^ ft' ad /kdiXeAtMJS' &0k^/^ MtA, Mm 3 M>/^ /9w. /9<&& w**j /&/»*/f&hirjj? /MmJ &/fcf^7*\r, tf&ss ^ fefa/j/ Aeo&l^ to at*st»t bf "Atk />t*l b the imdtJ- J My AfaUs €J>da*e, iS IDcrt SifoMlTv £>r £U£f&0*o brfw 4&ak uhcb //&r of iM toed rut tWh &fM77p<s7ratf/AA^//>/z?2A^ &A>wctm/A/aa&v *rt»6*AMf&htir jtt*'</Mt*4&S2 JJ^^STZteazrS&**A&sjAAA/ to^^A^A^m^ AZWf&P J*J%bfof& /te^AS s%&&&ifc6/aAJht^-'A/A04?/M>a6r a>a- &/^A&f/7/&7A%zfrA?rf AZ7sA3 JsfAA&t//* /2u?/'j&Mrf /kattfat&t*?', A?AWA?A>7&sVA6 J7sj&&&& JB>4y&/j&o* s/j^37/^^ 4&g& j£M$A Jff-JZ,*/ &7AJ3/%yS7As3% JkAtmJ^J^</^AS!t/3l^- Ayf^AfrA?/Z~S7AA^A7s&s4^^/&&/^A&&A:M//„ J6^/faA$6^Af&&&A/A&^7^ dZ%&6tter ^ &fe£j, a *&s^*6 A0ae6r aaa^^Aii^^a^^ ^ J^^A^a^ AfAc/A%7<7'*fioh&& A0BA*4e/^j:^b-^^^^x^^^^^^^^>^^^- Sr J7*f/f6J8~/&£r A?' j&AJfa&to&JfrA&&^
AW&&& /Jtgt&itstit ^AT^aAm^^T^^A^y^^^^ &^/?s2&&Ma /^a^^y&^kAC7*S^A^^^A^/i^y^a^^A^x &Mtkte/M/7AA^077^Ate £AX/s/2& J&sA£^4?.JS&#i460r'
&!fcc6f*3& a ^aJ&Ae£#AO%£A&A> A0W&?6># A&"04%^/!k4^?s^
&Ztj£ TX&f/fifcfoafr* ///wd/^Jvy>%5f/' /$^4/^/A7^ AfAs£7&. /7SE"7zjrz, r, 77T"r~ ^^%4&*&^rdS^^bsi?^^ Mmj&77fi/AfrJfAJdU^ "**"*"'~w 7k Jp/cr ef frrJ dm'j/(/#u) rcQ&TZtfjtfJJi /%vm£s /7)o/jAte/xiw jfot T0 1/J/xL;&fc«f 77/fa-'jfa, fai&i/fajfti 7?MQh7tfj/Mat #^a7/h#<s6 $&*7jw! ybrnfltiW^wS^ d*^' /7P#LJ/£*z dj*>7/fetk Jtie/^&fdw a/^A? d/277fo/z 7g Ab e^/JeJA/ t£>\J^'/yfaJ^A /tfa/f/A/hw/k JcsAA /fa/A7ofJ/c7<:>rA 4 Jt&ptAA ^^^thtA&rJ* 7/a $**/ , Jtfm/j&i/A? -» i^//W^///^^# /S *3&/<Aec£A? 7/% A>A$//wfr&cf 7fajf77?£ &?A?$/&//t7& ^m^M /&#//*/'%b JKTZ-vh* //7%t &&* S&hLS; &» &*bk&*7& fffiftib- Vfoo&MeUf 7%}77/&^£d/efr£c/f4to}M*//0t£*W^/ //k. &Ja7 &,+/'/7?aai &m?A7/7 /ak7,7j?t 'dLtf&jt^'S^J,, fo/'M* &WA-&tySAM*JWy// AvaW&**JJ/x. A^fw^fi/j?/W7th&£ ^M>t<Af Jt 7wU&7/7fo/s/7#J/?/PA>&7jhh7^AA/fo ^ Abt #A#f/A/jm?A S. erAfr aJ%^0A7?74j^//J,^/%^77&/to^ 7/7 a /ZatifaSA^ /A/%/AA?&fA%?*7L7£ ^^s>™AAf /^A/re^7/A?3j>rtks$ ?b? ~fif>6 /&/&. <$L jty&fr'*?/AV&f/^6 Abrt&ijAhtAa Afcrt^AA/iA^aA'dA7?//fe& •TfedsSfoA70yAZtyk?j&^ /bt /vt^s. AbzT^T^/Ti^AT^A ^^/^^^?^7^/JhA/Y /7? W/7l%As^^A^^ /jA^ AKsfS/W 0/7 SAA^/&£/A&yA7A&AAs77& 77l7c' A%t07/£sie/s^ A7A?A/A/A?/*A ^SfisA&cJ&f'£srvs<. ?#/£ /Psa^c?/? •sT&ea&Jy* efjdae, sSA%Av&A/^/A%$AA&7f&Ji^/ Shk/JtML Mtdj' j!tb 7fr/M7/0Az?AA^/®A&^/7r/74f^^ /*£& ty&eeO'/fcc.*j^^7J//7z/fcJ^<5A7je/??6 tfdhrtAMM*, /7e<?77&m. /^C^cTTc^^d^^AA/f? /AJ&& £> &trbfijfaf^>.fiS7t0k „'''&7%bi/&f//Z&7& ^/stAPAAPt/A-A'S/frieA A&//faf/%&#//,, „,
/^M^a ^^^/Ml^Zl^ImU^^fj^sA^ ^t Jn7/*7- &aU?a &//& JA^/A72#cAer?//£ A?A&sAaifr/AtA7 /fa/j77J*fi/??/+/fav >r j&7%h AAA/ A*S^ZS4u#</& &A*A&AyA7^Afr?A£v V/AS^&£/&M^ AZA <7 /&r Aw/7~££s ~/MAkv A^fA^A^sMfatJ**<p7A*£e> #/6l^s&jksV72AAAb&\>yfo Afr7tfJ?m&^^^^/!35ei^^^s^Wyy^^4f d&»* &^7^A^^%7&*Ay*/7?^ & ^}k^teffi^AP/^77^ #A&fi7Sj7#//<t//^/7&& lA7/7mMfrt//LAM77A7J73//S/s^^^ Af <?£//**/^ V-/7-A*/.
7/t77/)!?7/ej/j/w#y7 7& M7>/^#wtf/J^&/nzi/ /? .I0t^&;/fau&£>*4r jtfy2&?& OBAA/&6 A/^/7A/zA&a7ArjifA/77A'/»7SA&t, Attn ,3?£W*A&A jfearaS *•• "'•• 4%£L ,/Jl AAzj. tf79Mbt/X£A7/f A&7• Ji£4jzs;A£ A0aa&&*/tA> A&& «5^j^^ ty#o^ A7yAbtf/y^7£jtf/&&j/$AAk7'^MrATt^ATTA^ 37VJ^jy^^^/ik/ J/P JAXViAfo 7*&)a /?/&%fa'J M$7y ^ / A ^ A ^ y ^ /5fe T^Y AAAb/M/f^A Y^'JTs/MsYY/t ^y^^*^^^^^^^^/^>5^/ AZT^AtgAsA*'d^ArfM/y/sc&AASA%#A&l /7&Yt&A/J7ife/'&AXTistAAjtySiYY*?
J&SMAfcAh/jfa*/ &7Jk <£/A/*r *&rt Y^zL/*u^ .^ ~~~ ,^ •f*> A&J7 YfafaYV&xYJZTj 77% AHMfar a^tohJfaitAi*, ^e^AdS >?/ 74?/A?AA£ Afr/7 *f/SAut*r< l£ &SSd*H*fc*j AtsA^yfefr 7//$,#,.
Mm/^/teMm /&&***./*/ A/^^at&M/bi £YAkY* #A»7b*J/?
7A70Wf&cr 7£<^&A^y4/Y YA /Ip&T^Tter^* /s&Yjfr ed**/* *74x <*/4&^/&M^/J&^.J9J&r<&> f?A?S7iy'/7l3%A7<f77X ~Yfe A/juz£*£*;# A72&cAaY^»**L As,«Ay^ A2>s&j&##&t A%<77&/stez //?7f27.
7& A&7/>/SAr T&jfoyJA)4t^4Arf yp/vAT^J^ 3sb»9t;6/JteA AtAatofYji JtYatodpTl* Y^ttiAA Atit006&/0/7&&A6tWW Jbyt(./tototer A%7y/zYYJYk4*^+Ate^Y9&^Z+VA9 AS '7&2?fM$ ~&y<£&7 Jew #/ Af^jAT^^szv/t^jjfr?33 M iGfafWfhfci 4/JAft.
J0TS&W<AA$YATV&A J&AV&12A-4? A&/I&*,,. *juk*^ ^^s^r^*^ ^„, *, , J&3J * M*7fw*f y??As*</^ *J/yA»4*&** A/y&A>y4Ss/fMAAAA7J£AY ^&<A?Ab£/*A,^^fAA7&A jrJJtfyO *%XfoS& A(A/&A70r, A&r*&& A%l/A7 *7!&A~7£AW?y^ /Y&S^AZAP^/ArAfrJlA AArf/&/&<YYsCA ^f^A/yS^Aky jtf*j&4k3L-< fe ZToA^ tYMcY Afy/#A% /J%, IcA&DA 7A%A/cAj^^&/7 A>€fA^/ku7^<Ay^^ycA' AA77yL"'?'Ayj£7 &\A/A»AA')&6jo *& &*>7/&(2Si0£ >£-<*&#&&&> AAj^^Ay^A^/^e tJUvWa/ZA A& A7±A£'j&*Afa'A7AhAJ>/ YA &&/'*Y#?/7 <?^y%4&A /&**, />/**/chC£K A7%?A>Aa& a^-aaJa ffyj&b/&/&AjHr*A&
YYlijt/mAS >&Sr's7^S^M/A^AA/yjsf Jt7a'£> cYY /%//$ ,;J// A*Af MMffiuM' £M mMvu7$u&/wl & AudL&i //m*fJfeY'-j* A^JmJ&A MA> Jm^ YMdod^ dmyyY\ .. /7^jrjte&A$AO'JA(3 lY/**? . ^ __„ 7&&.J* MMr^Y\ /M^//m, ^jJkdc.MSii/yu't ?J~Y^/ZT&^d&Lsat? j^YaI^&t^ JUYbmkY ^7^^YY^YyA7y&Ay^Y; i^J/A^Y^'"**? f/^JA Y%?/^Y^YP<sf &%£*. ^^##^ /k/AtwOu YyjOJ^^YlAk//WtoA* a7%£& ^UfYt? JteA Y&Z&&*< JL ^^/y^A^AO& M&#& jMu^'tedY/ 7 M00Y4** AfafoeJT^^^^^O^ AA^O^ATeyy </Z^jYm& ^/Ji^A^^A r&~~—v - —2ifyy'dfrY/%*Yy$AS A%u yTZ&TA J& A&s&fo&yd&Yrfs&Yd^ ZmY/0^Jy0AM& YAeftfeuJ' Ator&skcds JL> yk&r&lfe, JL jL&>/?72&A# Y720oY Je - ' - ^ - * - ' »'•" - ~Yytf%8%A:. iYyfc&a. 1*&,A!f&eY&£ MtAtodrtu Y*Yu *A*A0 A / d &" 4 \&Mcfc M?A^^<?Yte/Ttus' 'Y/Z/7*u -AtcAA^ J£lj Y%^Atee4£%^v^
._._ YT^A&tyJ^&O /fa
(2a fa A^/J^j^m A^M^^f/^^^Y ytfSJfY-e/T) ^L^^v^^i^ Jfr /%4AZ0 A%AW tAZr^r, „ „ r AtAs^zUkja&*£AJ(« YkJL 3^d&A#Mty Ja ac A$W^he/£j VcfcJ^T) Y& AZ ,Y& Yi &J22&4&AY£fJ&rfi?
7<Yt?J-Y?7d £*%&7ss Atf^Aoj /? Y/7 J^^T^^^^ ^M^-JaT^cJA . . due* /lAr/SAYr rtstYTfAW MJl * YfaAJ y§^m^JYAt^^MrA/)0£hyMfh- yte4MA<2 /%>qm*iJs4k Y^Ctot^J&M* ^^MY/MYliAA YZto^tok? AY" 7dteY-A?Y% 7^/^uy >4wZ&*/^e, Y^TS^^jaSa^A^ *SyZkYA?yj>'OrfdgtfYY)<Jod%gad^ /tot'Jmtt?JJY%&uAk 7t£O0q& 0ipU7l&£j> y^AA^J7$L, ^2^5^ A/0&&6 /27^fyi^&J AsTt^tL^; Y^&YAfc. sP&A&z**/ A^^c <$A?A#A7Jb#£AA/YvaJS . >reJ-7°A'JA,teA7*e7^S^/f7%>&SSZ^S&J- y%t^ A2&3JU#luY J0£^J&7&Y&ZjLf*. A&6&6^J%S!®i!A£^jA?L^07 x Ttedr 7a7, SYtLs. /MM&a$4%/#\a&. Mu de^A4<u^JteJ&Ad^ 76S&AV4AtfA/J-tt YsrJjc7&mr£WA7^t//7&6"& . , , 7&, 4Af?^ /fa0#& yfote^&tto^ »£*»* *Y /frdrsZmfS<-Y0 y?7nrYYA&YAYYY#/Ak^ YTit TJaYvAi AA&J&syjfr?4t/%J,/&*6a>7 AY&*#JA&J^A%Y7A2ff JA/AcA, 77tfe/*&/&£ 7/AYm*3 YfAJanYAt AfYAtfTW&mYteYdm/^ ?-? Y?t7c77/c 77Y/J^YY77 m^a/Y/^^tUta/fo/vY/^c^^ lYA/Mety /*^JS^AA,3fj?*AfoJY/%//ei7f?77fSWs^#W VMM*f 7*73/~3A T^O taA/YJL && PA^tet, AA JYyYA-47777t A*?J7- SJ M^f^^^A^J^ ^7fA)Sd, M£ M&Y'aZai^'^^^^i^t/ JL* Y^JdyQim,
7Jf7m& YA&MMAA^Y&rtmthfiMh 4fiY0f4 AA&/77#77747<&m>> zli/jL/ixf (fypiJM/Mm Md£ £ /f7%aA/M7%^Y70M/^^ ,' ' (?YY) ^um Ymt£< ^/^y&tyM&aj A/dJJ)
>/VMm ^
u . (knYMwMAiA Jaw imiATtiity^ of (kau /^Mo/TtU /TtdMeYlM^ ^J '""* ' ^ TlmkdeA^ Jhbtki&y,^^ A A&Y tfmtdY&i; yfa& ' ' - - yYyiAfc&d ^ XT ^
, Y%&2&04[^777f A&YA ^^^^^^^SV^^^/* Ma,J,J*3o(y/£6.
JYe a/in/1J* L YY YY •Jtsb* JITunit 3JZsi7^/f&kY
PMiJL JJL 4m.
A, TBfer-AJYY) Adz0&$L*>A
4A^S ^ 7Jm&ALY7UA> OAUS
YfMMtYb y AY7/ iti&tH/i/A *7£fYrsL AtL 4CvjA
>-'\ .)
fajiJO. JJL (fas £7 A§f *
jYfrZAUZsrfdYt ^t^^^at^ ^7?z/&Y&&k!>. y^2ey^tAA^j^AiXi^ M^^^^o yM J& 7% yMa^l. T^Ls Ja 7M/Y&M&^
TfYAAAAYYrYLYTtYY
Y^/Y'^j£jk* 7f'A&'-'?'c JL
M>YmL> ZAA&A^* ^A%A7AA*?AAaW& f^AkeA&* <&s ^A26*??^<3aA*^a aa^ <&&&, A0Ls sTVAAi&AL^
JA^^^y^^A^^^ ^ &3<^?AtAu^ ^ y&j&Ai&w ^A^^Y&Y A7^a^s^^a4a^ Y /2A2A?aY&skY^ JA%&e£*Y ^£aa$& ^Z%0>z^ AZA<3AZ2s^>^ <£<£4&*a ' -~~j*r^^JA7£. jA%A/ <Ay^£4S&00rA4z££ At y&AZO&y <%AS72zAa4 A&z^Cyy7P2a*A&s#%&a
**!***, A***^^^y^^f^^ rpOSt?
A%Y#&rj& y27?^J^Ayy2AA/#7 ^A^YyAY^y^A/^^Y^AZ//)K>r60Ts.
7&A>y^A?^yA*£^7y*<^7^YA2S%f WzAm^^'ZYM ^y&^LeA^y^y^YAA.AU^ ^2aLa% 1*7b/S3j) 4£sAa?jJ. A^kY^Mjyi^yTAU^YAfy&zAcYj 'A&Z A£ApAA7*^&/L A& 2%o £/Z6tA?0Ag'& A#£7^A^A?A&%p'i j7JhMt4, ~ Af?d %%&Y^>
•Jpfai h->^\YkAjb y2y^4jfe V ll^d^u^A^ YimMLYiM^i^ m md ' Id
(MKYtlMy 6MJJtal ^^/^^ ^m^A^^^ ^kht/4rMUt „ Hennthh i/t/Jt HfhuY ft/I-
C.UJU VLfifj
£01 ?AU*uY,yAjkY» YjMdiAy7£i&L> <77dP6>» A,* yJm&-rg<?f-e?j> 6L/7'y'/-yv-0J&*-£*/ 7)S0A (jPrtY 67€mA yn 7%gAc v^vaA 7&- YfAjre AtAxA* Ah* /7£tifc> SAa^A ^j^Y AfoATpY/At-S (&4.s^ YfeA?eAY0»Yj Y£Aa&a/ y& ^A<A/tve**Y A7777 AYsAaA? fi4AixY/c& a7a>«Y YfeAu770s7j£ YlAA**9 A a&Y,* y%*j9rA>w sA^A&y?*/' #/ Y&c caA&«~ Y2?AfreAy?sA A?^Y7£Y7jY-~ZA**^ AfAApyje-YA Y AAYA y^Aj'-d'70^YAA4A><A<AA ^SrnfAfJZ'i#YY 3-JfixYAZ TfAtfJ fiA?7?AYY77?AYfe *fe>
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.