Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

in Re Ted Lawrence Robertson

in Re Ted Lawrence Robertson
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided August 4, 2015

in Re Ted Lawrence Robertson

Opinion

'."juio. ini'^MWj)iua*8WHgwwJ«i|J."-'..'i-|W'i.i i-ii' imni ji»it»!ujii^Bgtjlf>s^i!«wi>»«a«»t.»mit.<»iuii jiuii.ii iiu..!ii»i,KjiBH!.i.ji!i) uk»^-i

la&ttwwSa^it^

i'MIWJ;wj«iaaij'3gs^r^ Mi«l«IW*fiW»ji'g«IB'9^^

»-, i.-IPII.. |l !•• »IIJ_ II •••—»»——

FILED IN st Hi iii>m« i.i jim i^nyi!. ••. i.(i ... i w . ii.ii.. i ,11,1,1 i«.ii._,..ii,iw ini^ ,.,lmii»i.«i«iiiiiiiiiiiihiii, uiJMii'Jiui jhi wt i'iiniiii—*iiwi COURT OF APPEALS i'i>m,'j.iUJHi|ij.i-iiiii imw •• . »?>-^"-~ HOUSTON, TX *-**yt>ggi»f4£ilfdtiififa AUG 4, 2015 iiliiiiiii»iii,iiij;i^i ^imiKiimiumvi j.agijyiiniU.i.iii'.i CHRISTOPHER A. PRINE, CLERK H>WIWjji#iiM»lWIMjW^

mm mmiin mi ii ii .mi. i,m 111.1> iiinmii. •, .^....-.,,., . ....-_w~-~_-. mini (f,p.^i» . » , „ ,„ »»i»—«Ji •...» »..•.. -mi.*~mf+-n*rm <or*mtm*>0'mm •n»miiM'.>

"" ..— .i— . ^ —».,..„ , , . , , , - ,.,„.. - >|. | mm ini,

^<gB"!~iii!iw,»ij.'Lig '•••'i-g .»•:'«».'•»"<»' w »4i•"ln'!aBg^gsaa,iiyiC^iis^Tttir^^

gtBggailiiViiiiii'ffii., 4,iiwii|ii^giii|fliiwiiia»iwi^tfSj^i

«•,'«ar-*r;TW- a iiii.iiiimiiI 'jhwjj»i,b:wJ"'|'.p! -"-J-'.-'...1.:1" "'. '- tiirt-irtr^-" "'''""'•""''"'''"•'•'"• *— wtajBM,'i;.i<iii^.ty;.i.ijiun ipi i i hiji'ijiwiWiwh awl**^ •j;^l|iwi,i#il1lMWW^^^1Mj,piffl.Wiill»|

^..uii'wuiiMiiinwi;.,,'..-j^ •' ••' HllGi!!tiBim0il0i0m*imm^^ •' ij^lw(Wi»»j.«^<lllj^jt;»a<^^

ii'n>^,> wiiiimiw «*•«»• |ip,w'.jli.ii wurinn

• i,ipi.,»i|ii.y<.liii>iii.i,fn ii'jiiii.iTiiiwMiii^iif lfe»i'ji;.h.--- r.-. -,:;----;j^7^*-*'-'~-^"*-"r"—i—••s"-r~—-—*^,».«W'.i^'i<».""*'.»«•«•* "'*•"'• m ' " I III » I . V » • »"»•!"• «»«*c%w'V'*i«»i*"l»*->^^ KjsWfBjsu, ..ir, •\<Mm.H|i?IWBWWWr^ IfiGff*

jjwrsff t* feu ///

Tsms l£t$M(j J

iG h

•--•• S^SS.iiV'£aiffiL»-- %&lf**m 4*«.» Iff

„rf

•^kA/4hih^m&,Mim^ -If lli;Flci&JJf^^ W *iV Wc %w<?fM -15 <wl y «*•-• M^rMmm sites (*& - til -If (fiftf IfW fylTi PM:fi^&^ZM$S g»;at,iify^

:'f*^^y^^i*^^^»!Wy?

fr/fl?

_ wUMB,'•l"i*"*iTiiini[' liihii^tpMmrl'i^'^^rrTTmTy'rrirV'iiliii " • '••''"" «*••'•'-'*'T'^A,7^nm., l'ii'»«ihi"-'i,iiiMi'ir C/lMif'' J^M ni'mr •" <nr r'ur ,wn».»p»>wi-";-*»»»»i»il»wl|l'" iia-min.-.w».ii«.iiiiw»i»>«,i«i'i.«<»«-«.•. -

^efSBW;>»>jBM.wry^*

q^wia»^'ri«Mg»"gwM3»3». i,-.J.^-.j,...- uiiua^.jiiji.itii.iiiriiiTif^tfii^jiiT-itiv.iLi . r.L : -••-rr--^--------^•—•----•-•—-—---~-~~;'' j '•" »' •••.•i».-»*»ii».«i'i.-fi k-hi-i i mi i Hiaii i*.i.iJW.i-»iw^^iV»'!'-'->~ »«*>ajj»Sisr?«j'«iS)"^^

^// v&ftfr ^fe^ -J*. Mf^ -,• y-

W/MfrdMf) "J^dM/'M ~A</f /Art £^***£#w*^

9£ i«aft>y;k|f*ja*»ifi^M'

^^^#^^A«S*; :j*^aijii'o,-^B*JB-;-.

<^i)i^iKy:!yt-r->*»')^ ^^^4i*«^MsiitMM^ •Me ^s^™^*sJissrtv" ^>***w»<*«^« j »^^iMPS^™^"!*^^ & • xih";1'^!-*"**'-^

•(; --.'^.w^«i**i^!*jAi,.S f.•'isEWi'^*-'''' •-•* i':~--.'•• i./^^;^!:^:*^^^^^*^^^,^*!.^^*,. »r^iii^^w^«sar™-.iv- -

-tf^p*~¥?&<^.^ f^W*eii*f!ffi&*^^ %f s.

//

kird'A^t fa#sr Z6i»*4&3& //.. m X7mu%

1/ &mjMM. mt&&.^i^fif///v *! iwiii iii i '"" hUA

SM^^^h^^^^MM^^^^ fyMiM /Mbiu/ltJ WtfL Ifat'fom '//at* m/»j m\m\ '.'•i-'<in..,wii i.iiim »ay«tmmm mi [•&—**&* / / / 7*t^

.;/ V-/'"1'"""'. f ••••• •- -. . .^.Jjfaj**' j / % '^'tMLMiM,

'///T' "'if . ., i w& rAgjMm.

SL /tUM£±

id. mjmmM

W^£&^^i2ML '/k ^SSii^SiM Ufa j. . . I llltl.Tl I 'niiji 111,11 IIiHii .11 nil I IIIHIIMI mm

4^ 7f tij jmlIuM^L

. i yiMij ni.i iiiiiiuiu. i^tmjiavvasmiuti.m,. . .' —mmT 'i;yi ;•.; jjj».j..!y'.»".'.'*>• a , ^— '" -#rr' -jr.. • -~f,^f..- .

iff . I I..IM.UIIU

"•^ii'.niii iinjiMiiii -i i .. „ '" 'f-™"-"—i r >• *4*u#f&M"$fcf/»fiJCfit) '• " • - i ' •» i. iriii»iiii'i~«ni iiiM»niini»»i»»»« imi

..-«•«-> ii-bi wi i hi .--.-i-.T-—-^-—r—T-ii™-.'.-^ -.•-.'• • •- .-.-....•.- —..„ inin111. iii, i..yi i. jum&rmmmmm*^' \ ^ *tf* *ww • i-iwu» •' rs

S&farz/&&W&T' "77/i M/ ff/r,( %-^/y m, 2*. mm»MC Q^*Lb£

f' ' nm.m^Jj. *'** '~' n• °^-~— f* .infill, i""-1— J L, "• ' ./ •# /

Mi T^4?

-JIM Yf- iW&fos-. %(itkrtsr.Waft; L MniL LlhiOu:, "A2k mtmlmffitMtmfilwMii' '/

I .»•/"./ J/-—T' -/" , "-, ,'.,/«-»''ITlift

Wi, AUluM- 7fn-(fo(&.,.'(? -. . %£AAfftH-myjH if. <•!& -hmttftm-

f c fa7* m %, 'M-iMMJimi ,r* rkgM£mM

") jf":-' —•jr*"" •' "''"'' .- • , 7 i/ _ —-ai^'.'v / /• . . ~/*\_ X/ v./ . -< /#« .., "a'..••;... . •>.-•..>• 'r »»»»»«—P ii i •il»»«i«i»l»»»»»»<««»«>»»»»-' s-s^y i urn I -waaaBiBi. " i -w y / •HtyTj-jfli rri-rr---, /,„iiiu^iiii..iiir..f^ll,.»"V ••iiiwiiliiifw^BiMiiii -.-'_"•-• 1-if.iiui / . i V\*» '/

tMdMjw Mtiti^ M .JtM

mm, . ,y., .-j . i, .... .• . -r:.-;—.-.. - , Til) ii ." \\^mmpmmmmm«mjii"[m*m^\»y'*^i' '<t^>^ v,,Mm j - ••MM mmmwmTUimmmmmtmmmfmmmm* P'•Wfrw'.'i'iii.Mi, '"• i• * lp>l .11 ii.,11 i'mnn— f

m a.

fo?te!4 % ••Hill r .1 I I Hi IHI'lW

-• \ ^Stml JlJml mm& d^midm^^ v.. \ \ • ,A, •'• • V W0$a/ 0WmM M: Mm7Mm: #. ** m % *Mlw9'. -nm.

Vt/d MfiOTM (tftiO&L yi- - // t ^mvi\mmimmmm>^mmmmmmmmmmmmrm '»// V •'

'— ""••; T • mAfmmmmmmmfmmm At f ^ ^ «.?iiii(Bti ijiiiim. mini mm"*" 1"milT "/V r±if* < j^j1-^j. -rf*

\tmf<r*^^imm^mmimmmmmmmmmmmfS^ HM 4 H ib-M**. IttJt^n^^/tUm^M yv*7 ' -f • ' "•'•""'-'.-'J, '-rr-T-'T™' 'J|J|"I1:*W|WI,W',I4 „* ^w*wi^»MWl>w^

^MmmJJfJ to,fo/fm£Em^El pMS^ •Imd^i ZckJiAjltin&id if f ' /'•'/-• • f// -• •- '%?••••!>, &&MtFjw<w/c^Mg^^M^ • • ••/ ' -Vr"^J - lA"11' iM^M^^MNl.llLmJj JJIll l^llljlu.im.llf'llil - ' rifmn' ./jff.^ WML MA Mm l'±M€ hSMMk &*&&*# 4 W//^ /W ~—* _ wA\lff~\ "a "~ * ! :"' imafai fiMinnfiyjAteJ^ fUt/1%?. Ibi/ha Sid fifth LWc) MfMrfafl 7uG&ML/r'7o A,/qiiijgj*ii.iMwdb-ji,f • J1 J'"" ".;.'mf <<i inn. i ii.';WP»r# , / - Wd', Ofttf $$&/m/?%wf4m i,Y.i,i-f.riT J ,"».-mi/i:r,r..'i „..• •_kmmmt

., '.-" -.IJII. 'ill'»l'.'.'liii*|lll)glJMl,l...l. •',-.> A ' IIIWiWIIIIill'l .."i.llii^l.l -.IWI....II Li i mmy.. . p*m*!,J.. • mOmmmmmmfm UL^.i.iiiii.111111111 !i^.M—" -|i iii.wni»i;g|fi i Mi.iij.i . j, —y iiiiuiuifftiMJ mmmm0>mm).\\ I y i/// wm Vh

P'lilii. iwn,,. •mm*ggmmj*l*mmmmfmiamBy~—«am •iiiiii.i' ifmfiiimmmmmm' i / Immmmmmmmm-impimi iii..<r»iiiMiiiWM,-,, ' • miiiMMiir ii ii-inmrrii"i-r rffiiini"!' "i iV n ' """ V* rfjiiirf>-<

T ",- - i - / ti . yr ifii j . f<fc«rf-ut«t«Mhjr ii iH-\rm tftftbtfL- tmfrm

/>

J%dwZm 3kto&%3tIwfmfi,mum /?amj&, *!&#• <wm

*Tj(a lAmL^ttmiAsfida^ 6^ 4/fa* iki.ifi/ht.i, ma fay /]Mp. mmmmrammm X.j

TWuimZ'H *>Zf MM amMJLM •nputur:-/tot iMM ttfa/f (/•!• Mm'.JMuhw/drti

7m MLrf mttem2 Mm Mmf mMmtM) IS fit mP - S

wmm, La iU^ztJ&T&^mtfM 77*/ tjL Ml %m l%jM&JkiZ>MMJk%£ iH*{ JLmdM&mmJ^mjmmtmlSi i 'ft, it& f mlii tn jpSSfrS >'*gg? '**** -'•£"•• \ Immm, Urn**. IMMifmrf- 'ai, 'far gn TyrTTkm ZJkfflSmsJ**1&*- (m ik muiMLZ-MdJL mA mm T.

W*~- { {jLu77/l7i /ifrl7^J**<i*if Ulvttiy\,lJ!lL.S»*J /.'/ NjtVtfn/O 'f.*'Jl ft-f*v.

SIm'7?&1 Tkft£«~%

®Tjfa£j7f& ^M*iV?f ^iLtlW " » -[7/.^fr2?iS, vmmLm mljM 'i^!hms'ffrmt WZ/Li %&7m& $ fJM& iZiimfrdJfo &&d-W&£ 77M/I^j(i7^ miff, fl tdtiiifrf vf&M rtf, ft* ^./J * I / J ^'gjlM^ik mm %-ffif tit- mm (jMrcua.

Jfe? faux m fy&mw 'fc/kfw •V"

Cause No. 940376 The State of Texas v. ROBERTSON. TED a/k/a In the 174th District Court or County Criminal Court at Law No. Harris County, Texas Entry of Judgment Nunc Pro Tunc Today* the Court held a hearing,on D the State's written motion for judgment nunc pro tunc.

D the Defendant's written motion for judgment nunc pro tunc. !EJ its own motion.

Satisfied from its own recollection and / or from the evidence presented the Court grants the motion and ORDERS entry of the following judgment in the minutes of the Court in the above styled and numbered case to make the following correction: PLEA TO ENHANCEMENT PARAGRAPHS IS NOT TRUE. FINDINGS ON ENHANCEMENTS IS TRUE.

El If applicable, the judgment nunc pro tunc supersedes the erroneous judgment previously entered and attached.

\ • " Signed this date: February 11, o 2009. u S3 (X i o> W"> o\ a\ \o o

u E.

O o Q -o u

U '<»[«*• JUDGMENT ON PLEA BEFORE JURY COURT/JURY ASSESSING PUNISHMENT causeno. HAQAZA THE STATE OF TEXAS IN THE 174 DISTRICT COURT VS. COUNTY CRIMINAL COURT T£P Ko&ZfrTSohl ATLAWNO. (Name of Odendinl) AKA OF HARRIS COUNTY, TEXAS

Date of - Date Sentence Date uate of oi I * Judgment:., it "10 "^063 Imposed: i'-IC-2el3 5S n/l/w* Offense: PfZ-fZOOTL Altorpeyfor State: ~"~" *. | 'Im7""' Attorney for Defendant: HIM naf*efendant Waived Counsel YROS& Offense Convicted of:

f~l A MISDEMEANOR. CLASS: A I B. I,.C^-T-BX'a FELONY. DEGREE: SJ IWI 2nd I lsl I CAPITAL Jury Verdict: GUILTY Foreperson. L* * *j' 6£f(g Vl/RAffp (Circleappropriate selection —N/A= not availableor not applicable) Plea to Enhancement lslParasaijh ^2n£JEiujgraph Charging m Paragaphfe): Tnte k/ffiotJjje3l N/A True I(Not TrueJ> N/A innn^em: ComplamtHndictmo^InformatioTi Findings on Jst Paragraph .•—^*» 2nd f"*?™?"

Enhancement^): CTruPl Not True I N/A- -QrueP Not True IN/A Plea: Guilty | Nolo Contendere ([Not Gui Affirmative Findings: Deadly .« Family —^ Victim Selected ^_ Victim Younger —^ControllediSubsiancc Weapora^eyi No IN/A Violence Yesl No WM bv Bias/Preiudicej.Yes INo (N/A/Than 1.7 years: Yes INoUWJ Used to CommitCrime: Yes INdjN/Aj PunishmenTlmposedby COURT^UrO-^V, . ..• '\ ' (Mark all thai apply) and Place ofConfinement: IjKTnsiiiuiional Division, TDCJ 1_J Sentence suspended. Defendant «//.*- • .., -i %'.> - placed oncommunity supervision for *" I ** -7 <^ ^g- / « ^ ""TT> f •—' stale *" D'v'5'0".TDGJ • Hams County Jail Lt] SEE SPECIAL [NSTRUCTJONS, incorporated herein by reference.

Fine in the Amount of 3 hl/fc O Fine Only Time days toward days toward incarceration, o i Credited: tlfk mcarcernlion f"JfH -.tfincahd.costs "**l*. ..»••-• • •'• ' i in .fine and costs COURT COSTS :$ OOP .. (Mark appropriate selections below, if applicable) j»P fj Namexharigcd from o\ C] Judgment Addendum incorporated herein by reference. <g • Driver's license is suspended for aperiod of N fir days/months/years. © • .

5 • The Defendant is entitled to VIth days credit toward suspension ofdriver's license. jq Q It isordered bythe Court, that any wcapon(s) seized inthis case is/are hereby forfeited.

E •£ • Educational program waived in accordance with Article 42.12 Sec. 13 (h), upon a finding ofgood cause by the Court.

§ D In accordance with Section 12.44(a), Penal Laws ofTexas, the Court finds that the ends ofjustice would best be served by punishment | as aClass Amisdemeanor. The Defendant is adjudged to be guilty ofastate jail felony and is assessed the punishment indicated above. .0 Q D It) accordance with Section 12.44(b), Penal Laws ofTexas, the Court authorizes the prosecuting attorney toprosecute this cause asa -a Class A misdemeanor. The Defendant isadjudged to beguilty of a Class A misdemeanor and is assessed thepunishment indicated above.

lof 2 This cause being called for trial in Harris County. Texas, unless otherwise.referenced, the State appeared by her District Attorney as named above and Ihe Defendant named above appeared in person with Counsel as named above; or the Defendant knowingly. intelligently; and voluntarily waived the right to representation by counsel as indicated above in writing in open court, and the said Defendant having been duly-arraigned and it appearing lo the Court that Defendant was mentally competent and having pleaded as shown above to the charging instrument, both parties announced rcad/for.trial.and thereupon ajury. Ic-wit, the above named foreperson and eleven others for a felony offense indicated above or the above named foreperson and five others for amisdemeanor offense indicated above, was duly selected, impaneled, and sworn, Ihejury having heard the charging instrumcnl read and the Defendant's plea thereto and haying heard the evidence submitted and having been duly charged by the Court, retired in charae of the proper officer to consider ihe verdict, and afterward were brought into Court by the proper officer, the Defendant and the defendant scounsel, ifany. betng presort, and returned into open court the verdictset forth above, which was received by theCourt and is here now entered upon the minutes ofthe Courtas showi above. • The Defendant having previouslyelected, in writing and at the lime ofhis plea, to have punishment assessed as indicated above. And when Defendant is shown above to have elected to have the jury assess punishment, such jury was called back into the box and heard evidence relative to the question ofpunishment and having been d^ily, chareed by the Court; they retired to consider such question and after having deliberated ihey returned into Court the verdict shown under punishment above; and when Defendant is shown above to have elected to have punishment fixed by the Court, in due form of law further evidence vvas heard by the Court rclauve to the question of punishment and the Court fixed punuhment oftheDefendant as shoun above. ...... • i. w • it.n- „ rr IS CONSIDERED ORDERED AND ADJUDGED by the Court, in the presence ofthe Defendant, that the said judgment be and the same is hereby avail things approved and confirmed, ana that the Defendant is adjudged guHty o.fthe offense set forth above as found by the verdict ofthejury, and said Defendant as indicated above.

Further Ihe Court finds the Presentence Investigation, ifso ordered, was done according to the applicable provisions orArt. 42.12. Sec. 9. code orCriminal Procedure.

IT IS ORDERED by the Court that ifthe punishment assessed against the Defendant is confinement in the Institutional Division or the State Jail Division ofthe Texas Department ofCriminal Justice (TDCJ) that ihe Defendant be delivered by the SheriffofHarris County, Texas immediately to the Director ofthe InsMutional Division or the State Jail Division TDCJ, or any other person legally authorized to receive such? convicts, anoxia Defendant shall be confined in Uie hsutujion^msion or Slate Jail Division,TOO for the period muicated above, in accordance with the provisions ofthe law governing the Institutional Division or StaleJail Division,TDCJ. The Defendant is remanded to the custody ofme SheriffofHams County, until said Sheriffcm :-\). ' ,.,.,,, rr IS ORDERED by the Court that ifthe piinishment assessed against the Defendant is confinement in the Harris County Jail that the Defendant ts remanded fo the custody ofthe SheriffofHarris County.Texas, unless the Defendant is instructed to voluntarily surrender to the Sheriffon the date the sentence is to begin, as mdtealcd above.

The Shcriffshall confine the Defendant in the Harris CountyJail for the period indicated above, and until the fine and costs are fully satisfied in accordance with law. rrIS ORDERED by the Court that ifthe punishment assessed against the defendant is for afine only, the Defendant is ordered to immediately proceed to theOff.ce of the Harris County Sheriffand pay all fine and court costs as ordered by the Court in this cause, unless the Court orders the Defendant to be committed to the custody ofthe ShcriffofHarris County. Texas oil Ihe date me sentence is to begin, as indicated above, to be confined in the Harris County Jail until the fine and costs are fully satisfied in accordance withla%v; or as indicated above. . .. •"'• "." •'. -. i'\ •. , , rr IS ORDEREDby the Court that the sentence indicated above is to be executed, unless itis indicated above that the sentence is lo be suspended and ilso. the Defendant is placed on community supervision for the period indicated above pending his abiding by and not violating the terms and conditions of his community supervision 0RDEk^) fay ^ Gourl^ mstBltnct im concurrent wiih anyotherscntence(s) unless it is indicated on the JudgmentAddendum that the sentence is to run cumulatively..

Signed and entered on &~* U ~Z-COB ...

x/s/ &E6R6Z Gcrptfltt Community Supervision JUDGE PRESIDING Expires on: t* fn Notice ofAppeal: C>'~f6 '^°6 3 ,MandateReceived: 8~gflg* AfFl^C P u Afler Mandate Received, Sentence to Begin Date 8P Received on at AM | PM. & o\ Sheriff, Harris County, Texas o\

2 By: u „ _ , Deputy 'iZ U .O SPECIAL INSTRUCTION OR NOTES:, 6- O O . i a •a _ _ . a> Right Thumbprint '•5 -^-^- a> U 2 of 2

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.