Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Johnson, William E

Johnson, William E
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided August 3, 2015

Johnson, William E

Opinion

zi' ‘7;,§2;/2¢/,<“ "‘Q/z>vv

_4;2€)/ g ¢~//"`,¢£/ :_;£” /0¢ ' ' `

§/¢§z_ ,7.¢§; 7%`@/ ' , .An@zm@sza,©s@z:<

ln§Zd»§/£:p_ Zoa/¢»Z/.§é/M§€ €;_%¢%M/ é//~/' / /L§)Q

' _`¢7_@7% Z{;,, A_M/w,zi »5,404 _,6§7@£§6§.~ _ _;%§_/%§M M§§;:z;@ _I_j§€/§ _9&~ (J, / w¢g/j _z¢zr __.,_4,_ 42§7£)§ M/§/w§__%&§::__ ,-§Z;£§ ._-W§z?f_/§{ §§/,v {_7/,4»\/ ,Z@,é/-»¢~§§;/ ` ' _ _o_'r)§./_Z/‘édj/¢A¢{ o/_W¢ § 2"/'%/.:§_% §§ _§ § . _§O/M/§c_-cha/~&_./_é_é_/&é; /y/,-é 020 arc //%e~n~ ¢/ __m§% 7»¢% §/2/_1.¢_ _ _,zél§§,///v/_ //_.// &9_ 42/6%_ §§ _ _. W,é,¢/,§ A,@ 6/4/71/¢¢»`\/¢ m» ./’7%_:*> _ _ §§7.7§§&@,¢_ ;_7,/¢,.//¢/,¢;¢ -`

/

z §§ §§_,`¢¢,.,¢.4,§.¢,7§@:},§__l `/<r/_&/M §§ /JWA»@>¢ .

A///_M_ ,f» _§§J//».re/§>»§ /Az_xs::?é§ 77 72~»_4_/;_%/~7£ `- l v 4 v -/Jw /:/¢ 4¢~:;’- _ . l v yo_>:'jé.{_-@:y§/'/-@z&§r 7 733

:,¢,; _ _£_J,/.’§M,r;/E h ` y iss A/§)r z 4 z »/¢-M /:;_J_`QAJ/z __sz 5"~ /;¢/2 2 le)¢')» ,%//./»~; w § _-

szLaA/§zz£@¢_£§:z;d_c§§£,zzw@_£;¢§§

sz§/¢€_Zféév_¢_¢zz_):;

_.,¢§,§"d_¢§//§M@.§.»_'_,,_/,J_“Z%_,_éé;@_/W§.¢d§j_;§§l;§/ 411 ” 7 :::j_d:h_<).n/j/n,mi/§é_¢//o/§@ _d§/§;?o/j§é¢/€>y_r a h / d __ ~é¢z¢§m.w§£¢ d/) /i-f~f <»;c~¢4 /'€/4:7_‘§`/'/¢ AZ_A¢J__I/:_z,/.§»§//§Q_Z§_

éZ/¢/_z_[§a£/§Zé_@_)_[&w_/¢¢¢JMZL€:/eoz_/a 4»;_;;¢¢.¢¢¢¢!§7:§)§ _/z¢w_éa;¢,[email protected]_//§Zezr_//_»¢'/_m_@./__z/_§//§A<;;§§Q1477&6*€)_/¢1;6_¢_/_‘¢¢_!§§' .¢¢L_¢¢Z§%¢z¢!/;<;§Az§/ 6.'¢-)-¢»)`_>" 74 /w//)'¢;z»» »» / \M§Z¢)§ A_Z£o§e»§c§/§//Za¢?f§§ AM§ALWTL/;//;Z,_¢;,_¢_,§,£//?_@,;/,§/F§/g¢,;-_¢¢m§`j§§,n§/§ _@£<»,,Q§,:§§La;§_,¢/;/_AA¢,§ ,,4>»_ 30 /1/ j @.»_.»»_.§§'_ ,,/,§Z,;¢,, .~»» zu§/_'Z_¢.//Z_@»_L¢¢_»é§&£e_r_// /¢¢./»< ég, §z,/§_,:_/Z¢,j§/A z ,/Jf n / zz;. _:,_//§Z§A)§§,V§¢ §M / z ' /,/._r. ¢ £_z ¢7/ 7 w:¢/_A,_£;W§A§¢£Z¢§§/_dj,,%§<§, § _

_§m_gé§/(Lzy§/¢_/o/¢_Zzz_ §NAQ;§_/J§'J_A//W_é;§%f.¢yxQ”§m§am:j§.§ _,ZA~/`J ,%/'/'7 7‘¢'¢9;’=0 é_r)-¢/ -J/-éL/a/Q/§gz¢-»?£ _%)_e,'o//)' 74»,¢/¢/ 70_&»;/_@»!§@§74%/;:'__./`;/§¢?@ _/:g§-/_‘/.q_c§§4;»§4¢/_¢4.0~_2€5;£§?214§¢/§ _,é¢.f?_a>h~ , §/_./7_¢¢€70¢4»¢/).¢7§@_/4§7_€4§/5:/1@4_-§/:_£€,» x

`

@

_22;1!7&/1__%4_// -r:oj/_M_‘z_é___, 274/47»'_0/<?4¢.:4»1€7/'% 2374/2c ;/ZP \5::¢7-7[2:£>//;::)1@4` AGJ 741 …»éc_d:z:a¢¢/ 70¢702&_4/7` n_.m.¢¢._w __*4.'/1_&§/»1_¢_¢72__214 211%1/0 Q/`._r 127_”447_4_2 :.,:22,/ _.LQ,,,,.,_ / . _ .____/:€2_/2 1222_22_ /;’/.22~1_22 v 122// 2/2222_22121.,2722~222_22_"_w _/422~2227/. 12 212 2272/122/) 2<:¢/. //§72)_221422.2.14/_:_7£/ fra /:2'.2/22,2,_21/_4@_1»_¢2444_:;&;_//;4/227_21 2101/2222/4/4.71¢_7/___ _,Z_¢»_/Q/¢:Lé)_z/LJM 2c _J 2254»22_.7§24/ . ____1/72022;/_2;22£ _7,14122££;.¢7 /QM4@W__ 577/uf 1222 122 227;2222/ 247 1427._21212_ /’/ _21(2 2222222_ 2222_2_/_2_'2_2__ __.;72,2%_ /L 22,2272_2,2 /2-/1-2 // ,,;2: _7_52_2/ 274244_ _2477/” ¢._2_._ 7/ a/é_¢/.r/zv,__,j/__/A 5324 74

.' 7/;2..;: /9177_/// _.2:721722_47¢/ "M///22_7, 2/€. 27;17277>2 /73_§"'"7(4 cf 72222// /¢222<1 'E2_212,7222). 7§7272 2 .-;7»7_<"73

-¢_/`~> ':,_/_'» 5044)27 07= /..‘/?,;/»1;/%42 7¢/"/”§/,¢2 _;_ ¢F -'V 5_ ,é',?' f/¢l£f/¢' d/;_L_LL'¢)_»?_LJ¢/W_fc'/w /; ‘// )ZIC) }’l ~&l" g § A)_@z/".'a-A)Q,: n §

»M¢Q fz_M.é"_a ours 7~ c /¢’6’- 73 ,)‘O&Q¢¥_.¢:.Q‘L_`___- Z/v /"0/€/4'174~ ";;'04¢7¢_/25_£__2: '

§ 77£/-'_@ u}z 7//£ 67¢477./': _ 4 _'c_olzu.,~;s' A/zzz z¢¢)»¢ ,£ J'a/%W_s'@?r// ?97 // ,//7777'7/__£_ _5'_'_)_7;7 77¢».{__ ‘/;’/¢71 ,A/’; _ l;/%dAz/»,__I _a._¢.f 1 Mo_é_w/ .z'h ;07/1»147 fA/%£rij / /A/_`f ¢£. n @/ 47// /}44/%¢¢- / < ¢»M/n¢» ‘ _/ _Z/"__ / .>'_<’7»+¢ %/% //¢ Q_F_ d_/_/:_/ e/¢§é%é¢=f .5<7~,»/7777_¢

,/ /)

_/L/_.f/¢h// jam // 4.__/ a/) JM.¢_ 77(?/. QZ€//J` __Zf/_- _Z___-__/ _L/__//_ / 7_/_7._/_7_7/7 //777/ 757 77/ 75_/@_’77_ 7_ //7 _,>_/¢>7__7!_7_/ 47_7//7_¢ 7_/_ /»____¢ 7 J_`M_ 7:/_»‘_ am 774_7/_»7_¢__0:1:)_¢7¢:)___27;/¢ /_c__ __/e_a /.em_ _¢___I"A_____ ./;e_é<zz_‘g,__Zz-_f_/Lr~é°&w_k_d..¢¢a_%%@_é/_¢_AI_A/Q_L/Q@L___ _,Z¢'¢eL/_a_c_c_ QM 7’,_¢/_/_"¢7¢_€_£_.!_¢_17_7[177__/€¢7/ _z_ v /77 /¢- 474 5,_{_¢7 _,A¢__r_ Z_¢.»_<; ¢¢7¢7¢7»¢_7¢__,:7_4__{ _/_»L __,ZQ/_/_/__ %7:_7‘7/ a_ _(_' c_»g)___ ,/ -¢'é’ 37 777 /,A.`_. §777/,7 //7`777 7 A_Z___L¢___z,_?¢ _'7'57777 7 27'/,'/,7777 777/77/7”7 /7 77_7_7,~777 7€_/_4 74~777 74>77 /7 7477 77 744 /77, 77’4_777/77_._7Z

' ,A.@*’”” //" /"" /__J¢Z ____é¢q¢o&/- _r_ ;é_m¢/_ é€__é~é_/'/Lg<z//y

_'_a/n-» _,r 657/47 74 754 ren/_ ’. % /" ,/7717..¢_7~ -A:,_»_/A_./__§_¢;J_~__{/¢: /_ ¢~¢M/ £ZL!~_BY)__ /::7/7__1»177_@ _Z_@_A_L/O/,7Y /47/72:< 77%77 jeaxé£,élz<_éj{¢aw@/_%j_é

~4 -" a- d»"'r:f"'x '

7 5 ,4 5 , §/575/,/5 /_,_/5/515/515 /,. 555 5 /z,,» 5 /5,,,-- ~ ..; . ' ` ’ 555/55/5_5 />//,,..15 5,/7,,5/5 /A 554 5 52%255)_,7£541£:_ 55145_/45555¢/_ j 145[¢4_>:~:57¢. _5174555155 1255€5// %§»W /2:»”¢-'/4¢0/¢/”5»1-4 <')_5£’5%31/_7[)'-’4<-!5!,4/__ /;'%,./5 5\//1`./’/ 5/1-/7/ 5//2,{5’5¢:4) 5555¢5,?5/¢5.»~<, ' 5 jlzé /r) c ¢4,/\,

/.// ly%,_¢,__ 25 i_._ ,_ 5//'_!_/¢6_1245£5_ -__fé¢_.;:_a)o 4/§.75'7&

519/me a /`f c 515 ,_e/¢ fz'c?/z/

_ 5/.!_/¢»///5&01157/;¢4 d/jJ/.g/ré__,é /A 7£(6¢)'42'-” -¢-/`%

j@é'_ZL 751454_//5¢14/' / 5/ /‘.7¢3(/ /'/_4755¢~;;"75,€4/.5!441¢5/ 711/of 77.5'2”,? '/n 7);'4/554»4)/» 65111_~_§_)5/555/¢'/74¢.-4 _ gri/j 5/_37<'. _:_z_z; 555/55 5555&5_ 5755_/ 5/5€55/75.5/5/ 5 545 __aar~/§¢7 5§&5:5554_555% /‘_r 7//'¢5 555/5/ 55/,-¢5.~/ 74 %4 _A515¢_*/ 152/71 _7/__ 45)4@¢<//41144¢ ~[

475€¢/5£!/5;_/4_5¢?_6 ¢{` 0&7 old %L/ 470/f

50 war '2;»1~' "22:222'/1/»22 222/222 xi

4/:24 2322 22 , § _~ _ _ 221`2212/»7 /' 722/222 223 § 212/1414 /, § 4 ' '

73/7//¢»<:/.')

42442_2'_2,€24422_/;224222_2£ ,_ 2242/y 2@,€¢2`522'2/.2 022

. .' ' 4 /4/74/A4_9:~,g4¢/4»<»4.f 7_/ AH/ 4442¢41¢¢4/_/4//_/;/7 W_ e_7/ 7_/4 44 e¢¢//¢/'-c, . 1 '*+ 4;47_,/?&10_44!)-/'/ d/%_XMI_£:Z,%”JMGML_/,Mm Ac{_ E,£/`a,€,e’ 724 41‘_'@_¢1./_27'1' '_444 4245_¢44247:_ 2_ 21 z/M44,_ 574/252%§_<2712 4_/_}>21,1/_~,_/,_22,_-¢4 404€_) _.>Qé/A ___¢J A/-/ vilL¢¢j/';'/"¢=/ 7(|[4/;‘9,/7!%4&4<_, § )?`d_A/ _)é_z >z/`Y’i'l”

v .4.4{;‘4/&47!/€~ d/A¢/ 4/( 07_/)/'_/€ /d¢¢r/g> A/ZJLe//' /:<'

44//7_2,/%4 4/4¢_/74122/” e,j 21_7£:%/-_¢ //a-j»¢4o4/_4_4/1 291/0/4)¢44 JW/e,n¢<_&//ead/-La_ue?:e£%//42»»)`_2¢/,¢ (2¢»¢. >42.

_7_`€2/_¢.2/_4 _M2é4§d/4_1224/(/27_22/_/_// ,/ 21 224/474 c @/ /./,Ay __25424,4/1/222,,,427 1222 2772 2. 2223 CJM :'_2<;/. 2240/124 222_/{_/242)2»2/ 277 02 - /27’2) 712/w ` 27 2222 222,41» “2;2.221.7/1,_242111;//2 02 2254/vi 277 /§’ 210/w 247 2//// 7”//2»»42/_¢. _ ,KL¢¢¢¢JJ/y¢ 24/_7/ //»6‘7 Az/r/% 021 //4) /_..;;2¢< 6.7£112»4//.' 21/_22_ _/4 fweu/Qq¢42w2 742/2 22>/¢2/ /;r_sa¢q 212 ~;'_/_//_.¢:44 /W/`/ 1 ~ ' ' ` _ ,5/<, 2222/j yu/o¢njw/ /.4¢/¢ /aJ?L//[j/zz 741 /)/~2_ _'4_7__/2;_/2_222¢/ 7_/<» /2-/ // 647 A/,»/;/ 224 /&4>-/4 44 422_7¢/ ' G”MM-W-Zé_l§»¢é _//_2» 2221/_24,

/

` c‘L. 75/ \ '_ZA¢_ 5544// AHJ ~1/51-/..'5/52//¢~»,_77_417/~;17¢5¢__%0 Z,L.j _,5/),24__ J;L./Z,;S_&_z;; 55571

/7, 77 74 17 1 777 7111_, 555 7 571_75557;_71715571555 '7(4_/¢-51‘_‘.54)_05215/;<'_<_4¢547_< 55 //4! 7/_£_£//_1 /75 f 721/55¢117/

505/411

_ ._5//’/.' 555/5511112:1_<1_/' .47£49 \ ~» _ _ _ _Zéj_d_ f.o__wz_/{_ <)7[]7/5551_51»~€7 74 55 ha-/e¢/. (/) 72/1)//¢114€/7'¢

_55~27551_‘45//__¢?1') 51575"_` 455/9_/_`1~¢/ ,5{5/_/_/_&4.-_ 5115/ 127747¢7[<5_)5___ _ 5/5/151 ///75//§_5.51/-!.!/5.,/011 5 7501/6er l:?/¢A»<_A/ A/d,ryM/” 51

/""/

_.Q_>* ZO_/zM-£¢J_Mw/ c_£/y_/M_r/ Z'o,/_,A/Ar ¢¢/€_>* /5<,¢.'1./¢/ _ /_

_/_/o_ {//'// 5//¢_¢5&44»_/!¢57_45¢¢ D)»¢/// an 55 51éM 7%¢~/\/ /Z 414 W\/F}(/ ,2£2/<5; <5_‘/_%2_ Ac_/)/_M_épo¢.»_zjl 5`_7{4*/__251_21_ _/

l .M/%/@/@¢#z[_&;éd-/% daly&/ 5‘?»-("' Jd+£/ 479/53 )/_-& _%70445,¢5<555¢1¢__5_ %

;./0 _/<57/5_ /;_/__e.»» ¢x_/:%L¢_/: 5_47£ /_ZQ/.S;'_ Zz~_-z?y_/_ZAQ/_ jda_¢_!¢?_' 5 //4/'£/) /U@ l'/_'/;/;z /7.<'_5;/) 7//12/_ /€7/_'_/_1//)»¢/5 /¢<e,/`v-¢¢/ :?5%5'44/

/1/57171 5 511!¢1 7,1£_ 445/175 /57?4/1;_5 __ 4713550/5_,577_~/ 572~,/ _}15:1_5/ 71// _ _~<_;_/1/ //1_1 5’441/)Z

_1!>/_,;4_/)5/5_7_/¢ »¢_((£‘>Z/~% _5{}4_$`4_</»¢5 jr 655£€‘ /,' (lM// 146 _)’/-4571“1 M/'//y_ 9 /~'f)_»»l_/_`;__:_My.

` `».7555£ ` ' `,)"“’571 7z111//5/2' Lf_z2_4_/5'555`_4,Z_2_'154751zc£1411'4'/> 41sz 517/5 0z4rzop5jz<kr 55 " 5/2'11¢'- 5117,51211151:5 71717'

' - 551/115 1771/11 /51/.512_71444 _J54 z'_¢ 2714 411/16 511 1555 1050 //101/7//5 455715131£ 413 7=’.“' 1 ,'/"*r\<jh'

go

`5 . . _ 55 _ 5 ' 5 77//6(;4¢£1)7_€6/¢417%0;21 7;[675_»4 , 704/17 /_.;Jae.,c` 577/55 ///"4/ 5_7_//_@7 0//76}./ 5/-=»14-<6_ /_`,6 /10 /766 //¢~'57£ 777ij W¢)//(¢/-/ /e65¢5 25/74'/4¢'»¢4/ ////66%/77/0f/`;<rn¢7/

7_/6_ 77/6`65~.' -7,7 677/767 76666666/_65 x 66 7_Z77666/667// 7 66<»/66,-6/ 66 »@/_~ 22666666 766/6,66 775/666 ///_r / z ¥5> 76 ///76~6// .: 7//'/5/ /&’<L;¢Qi//¢/w/ _gAg)_é/g»r¢ 7_/_767/6/741Z»i<6“74' ;%__766, 474/d /- ` 777/77 . _d:ou/ '/7/07166/~’_/7@66¢ /gA/AJM Zz/iga def/w _ 5 77¢¢6»»»»66//6 __/_1_5_/) 7¢%»_1g¢/7"666;_6Z 74'/¢1/ 7¢6//5 AW~_¢L/g¢/ 6277~/.3'6`»6677/665'37 7{..$' ¢/57_6 /577/6¢¢-5/. 734/69 6.52.5>6'00)/.°' ..§'4;.66//» 7 n

/65/»"616) 5`/6<~6/66¢ 461216//7-6,/6'7 522?53 67752$’3~)‘ 7/.<'.( 4 555'§

.__~ Mjé~<_%o < eJ_rgcv_?//M/_/gf /7_7,¢7/666%_£0 .6>"¢»6 466/-_< /l-</ ' &_>_z: /Zw¢_@j~ 76/*;,_(_7£_@/_)661/ d);¢g_/jré/Z_c,/-¢A/;)_g/_zz./)!/ ¢f;»\_ 747 1 . s 47766666 666 /6666_/ 646/661 676/ 67 767 5\5g_-¢76,6766 776 6<666/666656., /2`5? 667 '//z/ ?5(65< 57_:/ //77)")667 '5_5*£/7/26;»;6@,6-_ é¢'¢./_ ;6¢6¢57_<Z 676 \.’6..6.56-/ /d//J //7¢,7§¢ 7»-»7/ ¢Z¢g \_W 7>,;1666 676&66 .:_7/ 445/_7_'7= cza_c5/'_ ):). ga _&7%77¢6/ _¢m¢z£w_a<)é /771‘0¢»4 616’22;4`_7///66_ 66_7-;6416 //A// !/ /5‘ /‘ 4 fry /-7. 75/r 766 j_;~¢:k¢./’____ ///4'// % J/é¢/_j'_//€ 77//¢’/(/&.¢» /5;=/6/&/)_(_¢5 7/~4a:6<)/<6»c6j 6666666/66/ 66 77 7///5 667 7666/6566 /// 76666/6666/_,6 6 §66¢§66». \5/63 /'6€_6/6/5 /<w`¢/ 677 766 /9'73))5` 661 6 _2766666&6 _6;2§*7 /.'27 571‘57 6~_§”’%<5'/56, 57»65.) 572@@_<))6 55 5 ` fn _/§77 55//5 7_51>/66¢ 7j/61',;7//_~<_6//7%A»nzz ___/l J_a_,_s' ‘ 5 _gg@u*j¢u/é/~nl 55_/£47.5;_.¢ /Ma/ (/1/56'5(7/.6>67»-7 //1 /; w¢.....'zL

'. //LZM) A/_zz_.r.._éu_¢/;A_ _ /i'/¢/ -_/ //W l,_<aur?< ‘%°/ é»<, _reve/v/_¢_¢r:/_ 54 __47_//:/_5/_7_44#:_45_/4/_72)_*45{/;¢/4_/? o 757 /L -7%*¢_; 444,_/5//44/_445 5/%_.,» / z 55 45 554 54,/45 7%;_¢45_¢?/7_/%/ /h)//a»v__£%»/¢//y /:)re)// A/Z)’ /L _>/%-/ _./_¢7/;~5_/_ 5)4;/-¢_ Z/¢M_Ma¢/jh£¢zzr/l»zé _4//5/% /c:/’./¢J _554_/444444 4 5 444 544-445 4555< 244 44¢4__ ,'/»4€4<)/7{ /& 54'/)¢_»__//54/_ ,Jr~»¢~a/ -azc§,@_zf;_ 2415<__-2¢¢/1/ -r-r/___. .4/,,4454/ 5 5£_52444_5/ /,44 ”., . 754 54444/,;4 j/”_Ah_w)f _5_¢¢£4“ ¢.//¢<//4_//4 71'£\61_\7' J;¢ »/» /Q_? _a_,;S/Q '_ r ("5_¢¢<4_/_ @4»5.¢_70/ _m?[)/ ej/.r/ _)_/1 u¢_/ezé_ W»c/ <2)_7¢44/4¢/¢. ' 44_ _7€@~%_ . , , 5/0 555/555 215 255 7_: 5 5 y__,//_,, /44,_ /;_/5 544/izzo __ ._ 5/,555,¢75¢/ 557¢54">:~55_ 55 7_5_5/¢/__7:<'9_ £,5.0_41_';5*/_5_/~ 4/_0’ 45/d5_ 4/554245555_ 5555555_,545 555;¢:555¢ z555_ 4_4/175544555_£/54@54;55554;4 ` 015/5 5 7/55'_ cca/5 55 '.` ~ /47/¢ 5 l 5/£ /’ 5/5/`7555¢£_%5@5;;//&/2?_/2/52;@_@774 ' 544 ,) 54/ 555;9 _ 5_4/44_44 4_/ 5__5¢4<__4/4,1; 444 /€ 5 ,/, ,4_4_4 4/,;/ 575/255555.>£55/554/ 54 545./ -/_2277 /:/5_5/_ /W/¢¢_/'</Mr¢/ ,é/Wf /é 7&,¢5¢ .:'M/_¢~_< é@Wj*/_a_ L’// 47£@_. ¢/ 2»~‘_/ WjW/p_a»v gm /_<> "_,5/57¢¢_14./_¢140_¢_444_/@=~/ 4 // /Q@ 34>4¢4 /M/ /44,: _;)j_)¢_ 440/_ [514/7_54¢@/“¢¢/,7 5@0¢’/ 7:»»:<4 44 f,i,»_u_// ‘ _ _/_'m y 5 % /{// //}142; 511 1;.¢_._/¢5_:4¢4_5;_¢1»¢/ 751/44 £r~ - _[455___4/_57_5%4444,_445 / 444 44 44 4 4 4 45455 _ /VA'//E/€_/M_A_/Q.@#/ ¢,;,,,/4,,:_444 .4/ 44/; // 5/5),_/¢5_4)___4__ . &AW ¢- %5/»7_2///¢¢£ ”f`_ 2/¢»»; ' 234/444 555/1 4c ¢//7/ 55 555 2553 //72;)¢&445/»/ 44/»,.4_4))__ »/»"

k. :'. n .

7,¢/?“~¢___£¢¢“¢¢/)"224:/__;!£_/‘32€ 767 (f!< dl,>'- [7'#)»)_ §@U/?)/.l

',////5£/2/;¢1¢¢_7_5/11,1_ `_21¢;114_/.%4_/_///¢. / 1711,4 4/. 1121/_;7_,1/_:% _z /4%@»42~ v Q_,é/¢F? 272/532 7/¢ ¢2~*‘1 , /7~44) 1202¢/_) _2,1/11_./1_,; _Qr1//¢_,_ 394/_¢'_?_¢/_0:?__2_/_ gi 11_014) 2_0<><1)_)_ c _fz§/Z/au,¢r-_@ ‘ /jz,¢e`r?/é!_/_%ZL_A/J ->"75-¢¢/7///2¢ &L/»'_2é/ _f./>;L _(07994¢17.1/¢/»~_1€¢/¢¢¢/{ 'h 1':_¢`. lj;me__._,:¢/_-M_~¢¢.l_

/ ._a/v_%dmoé,/207__¢_7¢).@421//.//217_£04/€42.<ch [Ifj 524/ca / /¢/ a_/ _¢74 111/111 ;//m_..}" (_A/ ‘/2 /?, M`/f,¢ <,/2. éf’LLXj/e)_, %y/ 1227 /_z - 112 1512 215-aap /¢/2¢4))” 11 1_,/ /1/11</ _74 /./M,Z /_Z`;P_;z/_j 1111/ D/'/.‘/)z-/'LQ__/_h_ 11//144 1/ _ _217_¢¢27_;@/¢_)1214_) _3: /_%,_ 11444~»@)_.(¢¢ /1 2_4 v ` _ v i//_fv__c_{_r,_.¢._vv/_ 021_§,111_11/14_1/7__ 1114 1/1/,_ //_,,7 Z‘ 4412 511£_ §`_.§:031 ,2_3_3_ 144 7/»//11, 0/ "../A;<,¢/ 1/1»~,`” v . o 714/_<__ ¢j_a1`,4,_%/12_1`_2__ __.11211;_//_7_12:)_4@1/ //)_c'» 20)/274_¢;1¢_% .r_d_§é_A/_ 111/j 411._1€£,7_"/£0&27“2-1/<“ ¢.” _170_/<¢/1`.,% _/1“4)_1.//¢1<__1;.4,/ /¢11/_¢241§;/_ Z/of 7 1144 %L ‘ ,AWA;J /_¢_e)_ /2_&¢/,/,`____ ¢_ 1/111/_141:_1,// I/// / / 237_1&1/~zi__ _¢/ i£v,_//;/_Z/m_¢/§ °La/Zy_¢/// {¢L¢¢z_¢//a/~QM) cz )%._ro,' /Z< 1£1{/1_/.0_£%/,%/2_/;1/177£_1/1/5@ 11 1411 /-'Lv

’_,Z/’Z._/_ _S>:/é__{_'/ ¢_ 61 1_[)/_¢_4/¢_ _ _&/%_z'_.¢ _1%/// @7/_(47/¥_!¢_1_//' n &2/ _ _[:V_Zz_<i%/_Z///__¢(M ££_}_4;0_ A¢v///-¢,__éé_/a/_ _%£A”__p_ 7_/&.¢¢_%%47¢ _/_ myQA//_'/;¢_/L o_ ,Z_ /j_d_ '_) w_ai¢:a_n_ 4_¢1<17£5/_['.;5% ll j_;é_/_n_ 274 /_§2<9}_1/ l.. _/ja/-¢_a/¢ M / /,//, / /.7 072 344/j 514 :L¢ 1.»</4..41/7 1///&,.[1%/_» 721 _ W¢,¢ / _12117_/.1,,_/_,2 %/d _S_;_ /,¢W v/ 7;11,~ 751/411 1117 1 1111/1241 §/»¢&r¢¢/ /e/e.¢dw/

h

.§", `

471/_1_1"1!4:_1‘0 »Q_

b '/'/ej)/¢¢>//-/'¢’/HM 1111/544 1541~11// 7/, /&/¢411_¢_214:1414_1;,!/41511/

1415 17’Z 111/105¢/~ // 7d /~.- 425:/\1¢411.14-§,¢¢-1»7/&»~¢1¢ ,r’za-»/z¢/ 714

l 5174¢45§ 7£ __A?_é_’g__}/r i_S"/\/W_r </44»1//1 4414//_>//44/ 1411¢/<'111_/ ?/, 12@§/3 411~11/ 7%)¢ 4§64114+_‘/4444 ,4§11411 _1_1`4//44111. 41 1444 1414 1317113»./1) 1241 41/4,,4/,7 141/4411,1'4114 ,//444/// _,1;1/4/11 /§ 1444_/`4/444441 /144'/".},,1 171/ / §/___é/ _/;_11_,4-4 4411/14§-’ §/§4 054//_ 444/1111 04#441,7§-411-/; y 41/ /§ 4/~44;_1_/_ 11_441144/;74 45/4;44/1_444/4)411~// 411/111,4/4 714/4444§ _441_?4§:4} 4444‘“4444444/" 111 4 17 1,441 ' 7//‘~5 /Vow/ 512//A 6/@/>41;24»14////11. 114 /L é:§z‘?;§§?d§~/$`J§

` _74444/:¢41.//4;__01:1§%£ 7411§4¢§<>§£.11§1>4//§5/1/7 L'/?/é~ ,4_)@4,1/ 74711,4/_'1 :%4//;>0 //1:/_;¢/ 7/;/4-1//`;151117[ /é 11¢..1’¢4'/'7!0 )1/4.`/1 own 7!5¢ _'714¢5'<:_ ¢14//_ /_/4¢1/444 111/114 /-1_ 411_7[74: §?):'a M!§{Z&§J §/"771/ _¢7:§% ..¢'1444¥1011¢/

_)’§h h%/§ §.d_?/_ __e,j /auJ_A_¢-/§m§¢§§»ey_/;'/_//»_ §4144._ _ _41-4 14 §4_1§».14/- f'//')_¢-& ¢ 7/( dig/74 ha¢d_ja*f______& _Qv;¢§ 74/ ¢er¢<j¢\_ ?9_¢91-)£<111\ 117£ 7_4/_/,/ é/r@r'.¢,%-/p/¢_r_§/o_ %A/Wzn-’J 5/21;144141?144 /`/ 41 114/1444 g¢v¢¢%/§/g%~f 0141¢//44%211 d///L by 474/ 1////¢ ///~1/4¢,/

"4.4`4 _L,§/v§o;z\§///_`_ a /»1/7//1111_/1041-/ grow/11 14 75 74 /5_`1/ 154 114 :/:f A'-)'{LZ£/L//£U""'QL‘Z_M’-Z/_A_~/¢S// 7_/”§/_/_)/4-44 /zm/§/_- -,/1¢'/`@,1, I"'l _. %¢14.044&4/_`¢\ /{JF:)_ 1¢_¢¢2¢_7_4_,:__40_,_//_0_)_,)_

l 1011 111 _ . 5/#5. 513 Fd£fz /1\ f )// //`oM _&1- __»"d /1@¢-4\1_!`§7£%<1__!¢¢.¢._,-£__¢¢7@¢:14 / 241/ /_& 111./§¢1 /g§‘v_/AL§AQ?‘_!-$§pc 44 _o./ /44141§%_ -€4/:4€4/45_._)"4,74/1_/ _14\-_ /4¢74{€§44/}§ 447/4§/_’ /_¢1_1»1_'¢4¢!1 4474/44&44 445/¢%4/47§ 5/_‘/1_1§/.5/~5 //);1 /@ ///& /e,w-v _/0_//»71¢14¢.14¢1!144/?£<../_ 9144’4¢1_12414/§2_[, 7¢5 ~p,_ l//`_o / I'// ‘oh. .»’ 0 762 A/\`¢

. 41

_{'/l///`}/`/¢,/%J.¢ 711/740wa /‘ 144.¢.$4?-{__4_'60}’144)’ 4/4¢'7“4/»\/¢ A4¢ /..~'43444»¢/_4,4'4/_444¢4 _404)544/4/¢_ M444L4. d'¢! /L¢ id 777 ‘ 444 -:4,// %,4/_ / 44_ 444_44774/4:¢1444<_/_,4/_£¢4,4/ 424/444 }44>¢44:_4 __,4,4 42€44/,4- 44444/4`»< 414/4 4:;-471 744 44 44 7 \ \ , 4 444/4 /:":~47_/444444» ;/_`44 474,_,,_7¢_74/44444 444 44

`_,_ /@-Hé/e_c_4z£4z// 4-//4/ 0/7 44_/_)144/"-744! 7[0*_»_

` Mj_/¢_/l/¢/%/W 6_0_"_44’7,4%_ //4 54 44014:--_294{] !4 A:c)_ A.¢/?//c/_<,_/{““JJ _44.74/,0_ /d./><_L?_/@_.z_g_'_ 7-/-)014_ ~e a v "4_.__444%__/4)_/}`_0_2)4¢,._4//// /"é_!_ /_0£44 / ?Z/dq zd.-/€’”¢vrw jg.¢u 4/

_%_444{ %0<///./¢414_: 7_0_4_6474_4444 /0._ _zw_);¢/ 4444_/044/ _/____ _4//‘ /44/_ 474 44 _4#44/44/ 444 -/,4/ 44/4` `//_4~4_4»_44<4 _4447£4_)_%_/_/_44444444/_¢_/7/_/ 4/4'44.7/ /_44444'4) _4,_~4474 4/4_, 444 /_4/_ /47,, ,_4

Z,; 4///_/_4444/ %4/_4_/_____ /4//4//4 z./ 474/wy- ////,'/'944 //T J;A@_.»/H ¢/?34>'74¢`4 ¢4._/.‘ 7;,_»,4¢_._//_%»,/ n `

4'/3'4¢0'//'17. 4 .STF_ ZQ..,_//_M 474/444 7 1143

-7,%// //IArn g 170/rrij 70 6 /{/’o 1 ‘/%_Z`..S 7&/,;~&//./1/4 n /»or¢_f M§__ /__/A¢?L/é_/_€J_’?_/r_'é_w_n_af g )M/~,,_ // ,g.¢¢- 7/\: /», ` M,,/_//.»m _///_2’ ¢/_<< 3’,?<// _ ///¢ 70 c.J:-~/z y ___-_4_7:_;&/_/_€__/[_§44/%__ <'9_¢;_¢:_ _¢4_7{ /?&/) fn § f$_`

poJ%/y/-w?__/€/;/¢.;___Z? <S:Z_T__Lw_,jfé z¢rr'v_'_ ¢\ ' /¢'WH}{»//z __o£¢a,/Wr-. ¢,A:._M ¢&¢*_/Ae»n ¢/é_@£ ;¢;/~/_ n/~]___ ___//é Z{_%A€»_______ ' ___.%/'~e, _/_):/r)_ d_é_»'_c“m_e,w;_/./___M¢_ __-¢$<,_¢L;n__ _c..e _»;e__ D ,./(, @/z _/,7 /MW/_A _ ‘ 1 '

_________( ____M_€e/_%é~_f__'/La?é/LA» rsij g¢’//f

/J/d}v/ 4 I¢'AW* I/_/'Z'%A/7

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.