Court of Appeals of Texas, 2015

Entergy Texas, Inc. v. Public Utility Commission of Texas, Office of Public Utility Counsel, and Texas Industrial Energy Consumers

Entergy Texas, Inc. v. Public Utility Commission of Texas, Office of Public Utility Counsel, and Texas Industrial Energy Consumers
Court of Appeals of Texas · Decided May 6, 2015 · No. 03-14-00709-CV
Entergy Texas, Inc. v. Public Utility Commission of Texas, Office of Public Utility Counsel, and Texas Industrial Energy Consumers

Opinion

ACCEPTED 03-14-00709-CV 5166900 THIRD COURT OF APPEALS AUSTIN, TEXAS 5/6/2015 8:46:45 AM JEFFREY D. KYLE CLERK No. 03-14-00709-CV

IN THE FILED IN 3rd COURT OF APPEALS THIRD COURT OF APPEALS AUSTIN, TEXAS AT AUSTIN 5/6/2015 8:46:45 AM JEFFREY D. KYLE ENTERGY TEXAS, INC., Clerk Appellant, v.

PUBLIC UTILITY COMMISSION OF TEXAS,

Appellee.

Appeal from the 53rd Judicial District Court, Travis County, Texas The Honorable Amy Clark Meachum, Judge Presiding

________________________________________________________________ APPELLANT ENTERGY TEXAS, INC.’S

ORAL ARGUMENT EXHIBIT _________________________________________________________________ John F. Williams

State Bar No. 21554100 [email protected] Marnie A. McCormick

State Bar No. 00794264 [email protected] DUGGINS WREN MANN & ROMERO, LLP Congress Ave., Ste. 1900 (78701) P. O. Box 1149

Austin, Texas 78767-1149 (512) 744-9300 (512) 744-9399 fax

ATTORNEYS FOR APPELLANT ENTERGY TEXAS, INC.

May 2015 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

As required by Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.5, I certify that on the 6th day of May, 2015, the foregoing document was electronically filed with the Clerk of the Court using the electronic case filing system of the Court, and that a true and correct copy was served on the following lead counsel for all parties listed below via electronic service:

Elizabeth R. B. Sterling

Megan M. Neal

Environmental Protection Division

Office of the Attorney General

P.O. Box 12548

Austin, TX 78711-2548

Counsel for the Public Utility Commission of Texas

Rex VanMiddlesworth

Benjamin Hallmark

Thompson & Knight LLP

98 San Jacinto Blvd., Ste. 1900

Austin, TX 78701

Counsel for Texas Industrial Energy Consumers

Sara J. Ferris

Office of Public Utility Counsel

1701 N. Congress Ave., Ste. 9-180

P.O. Box 12397

Austin, TX 78711-2397

Counsel for Office of Public Utility Counsel

/s/ Marnie A. McCormick Marnie A. McCormick The CGS Statute as Enacted … The tariffs subject to this subsection may not be considered to offer a discounted rate or rates under Section 36.007, and the utility's rates shall be set, in the proceeding in which the tariff is adopted, to recover any costs unrecovered as a result of the implementation of the tariff. … Tex. Util. Code Ann. § 39.452(b) (emphasis added).

The CGS Statute as Interpreted by the PUC … The tariffs subject to this subsection may not be considered to offer a discounted rate or rates under Section 36.007, and the utility's rates shall be set, in the proceeding in which the tariff is adopted, to recover any costs unrecovered as a result of the implementation of the tariff. …

The Energy Efficiency Statute at Issue in CenterPoint, 354 S.W.3d 899 (Tex. App. – Austin 2011, no pet.) (b) The commission shall provide oversight and adopt rules and procedures to ensure that the utilities can achieve the goal of this section, including: (1) establishing an energy efficiency cost recovery factor for ensuring timely and reasonable cost recovery for utility expenditures made to satisfy the goal of this section; … (b-1) The energy efficiency cost recovery factor under Subsection (b)(1) may not result in an over-recovery of costs but may be adjusted each year to change rates to enable utilities to match revenues against energy efficiency costs and any incentives to which they are granted. The factor shall be adjusted to reflect any over-collection or under-collection of energy efficiency cost recovery revenues in previous years. Tex. Util. Code Ann. § 39.905 (emphasis added).

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.