Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Ronald Dwayne Whitfield v. Clear Lake Nissan and Santander Consumer USA

Ronald Dwayne Whitfield v. Clear Lake Nissan and Santander Consumer USA
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided August 10, 2015

Ronald Dwayne Whitfield v. Clear Lake Nissan and Santander Consumer USA

Opinion

CLAuse Mum tens',

?rotoefc^ora\5\>LL»a4ne YiniVPle\A I In The U3L23S* e o B*e5Var YWhi/CWar \_-aKe l ^filnc+ • feBft/F.rsV SerMite CfeM UPlion, ' Courts o£ I^QeMml 'Houston Nissan, ^jndjr ^rri^un+iTB^ J g^sumgr^^j^ gJj^^M: I \W THE I FirA 3nA Four4^h CW <tf Ufa** < ^ °l nl^-MX&WT-rX •

gf /fA//) NOTICES TO THE ^KWeLlate Coups' Jusmces,Tf\\«L courts I° Aim&ES/ ft\STMLT CLBRVS/ <COUMTV ftTToRta V/ r#tE*6«SH IVTTdRTUESs, ^fE^UTS/CO^RE|S 2' KcUJ, ECT. I kub SUPPLEMEUTAU --QuESTlOM cTo 'FIRST SERMJCE C.RH}\T UniOil Amd HeR UETeklSE x- <A *L€ hTTDtUieWlS^y) —• ^' TO THE Uovlfc^LE AlISRCeMlD JUDGES 6FSA1D COURTS, ToTrt^ rtoiaoWtt>Ub District clerk! • 2 Mr. Daniels/ \r\ some a? \\\e cases £\eA A^\-e./ Ar\xr\&. ajnA r\am&/ \V ro^hi PveServV/YxKe. W Yvas ^\re.-a^M ^JSfserAeA WxsAtcAroriaY Pvok\ett\S "Por <Dur Cour+- 0-F CnmVraA fcPPea\5 D? Te^GSS/ 3 iur\sa\dhDn&\ ^UesK&n -for -The iu&Kcjes £r? 4-he.

Or HQt 4r>eT\v COurV iTSe)f V^as JurlsdibKon an ^he mervts/ +d reMar "a. Ji^c^on &ui<\3 -file a (\o^e a? aPP^ai aAfr +he -Vn-aA -iud^t- Ci\ or berVh 4na T*efeflAaM*"9 Md+TOos 4-o Q^fttei WVvVr^vOn. \ re<22d\ asftv\3 b^u -to \<vfca*i eitover Hour ftanve.'.or 4he -ftme ert \p ma tvo-rice Or aWeaA-tiia& riled ^^Aauier^ Tntftosei £>TAer and <3BM£ Sam-e. -te Moul +a -Pite/ +ten -H^e a?feaA rnus+- he. dtertfeS-eA ^s ^Pre\^^aAyre.lV because I-V Wftel^ \s/ \ ui\\ haae aVso caused ^10u +d -Kle hurfiiaer tff fYta+ronS -fer re>Y^&r»A3« 1ujfluicl a^K/ in an3. eueM-y ^^u wvtf lemeM- a *%li^ *aV ^nce TEAuirinS even eAec+romc •FAta^s \nA~ca-Ve 4fce T\kah ana Wftme ^ Maor ^ei>u4?es So necew»/l.3 a*a -fitfflS ££DE£^, h ku-v ?nfc»k\ii Mujor¥>\r\3 4ar a jAj&v-ice. _ catted me on tiefeaSS, BSYftrtS 3W+ uAwaAfcer Soul a^d^eA vne an aA^m^. ecV. and fDsed erf Wti tYM>\to\ Vd 9m£eed loAVwu.4-

'•twc/ Y\nfiL)in3 ^ -Hie. a*feaiS ££orA- \a^ JurfcxL'.cKo* AV/er ^Our Order 9rariftA2> K\oKom Afc Compel arb'^r^Jon/ \ belike ^SU ^e fee «nM UiiW be oVsYairxecl w\ -Vv>e- Vv\SD/ Au^Se tsaVver/ P\ease be or> m'»\W\ - ciD\W^ XaiuLi £-\Tm5 C +loo ar more -\rt> SuVepm^e EKciv cmveiO in ^he.

Case of Wbi^ieid V. ftarvta, Vtand-u.^ / -ftsr \ Ad rio-v uj^fw ^lou. -hi a^iwp i nd in \i3h-F ff# irvaM-Autt JuASe &aKen 1 J>ul£+ cal\ed C -h*ia& i5 Sunday ^ Nuaus+2-OGJ/ttie PlsV Cburt Cpf ftWes\£>- AnA \e£+ a. message on 4ha Prwaie W\e o£ 4he cai\er -to Con-ra^r-Me ^&m» Ulhen 4he Un<f_ ansi^en^ \\ d\d W)t T^nDaflceA \ \\2A reHnh^i -rKe d\er¥;vs DiZica. cA 3&A coor+r Aor A\A i reooSrvae. h€r Niaite. as <5YAC )A derive fl^ftcelfio V assume She "is ^ 5u?fai4 Srk-PP member

To Till Ae&nsetK&Ad -H\e K4+omrf( +br -He Courrri! kWronxea'S tf#cc , 4he ^ e reived on -frovn LS+ CdA dea}Tn£) utth ^<karwie Cos-r-S ua^ A(=>r)b=> A on ^-^-rP. \auj ?rm<^P\^s? ao+ <sn ^ue SVdc^s^ rOles.

40 3ue m e^-Vher He -VnaJ Caurr5 or Tn He attetate cour-V-s, k^ J3eu iue c\*a^;n3 \ Ytete. cowim^-r^erl Per^UT^j /-Hven Slid m^ K^n\£i* she accdfis* *a^?ik^;fe cz^-n.

X£ ^6vjl 'are uttaaptfa a^ 4b ^mV1 Or \ec\nXc^\\\es> ,n nt4 Oom^lifiY^ar lj4v\ +h^ Su(Ve™e Cour+ #4 T0xa& uri+ten ^yt/J ado94ed aWeftsiiL roVe^ ze>/ a our raned^ Vs oo+ -v-t> XSuse cut tWI Court clem -Vo £'ile an WPiiaMW erf Cbntes-K ach / toa-F -Vo £it& 3 ^QweST/ l*AAV Lrd C&A\ a *YioVlor\}* W>\Sitl3 Vhe ttta\ juASe. -te n SV^e" mh Ho-WEfi Vo vYoceeci On Mf€a\ X&flti- bauia£> ±b S& "Teo^^ Vn 4V.e ^&>a\^ CourA- /C He \a^uVrS ^Cfirv^^ueS/ ei\AirL£} "in £ur U^.SuPrem^. dour-V/i^ feVrKo^ Hr <a tur4 C Crrzlerl} jSoond;nf\ In uCertiorari O/ bu4- iv&4 because \ We 4oo ?oor 4x3 Pahi T-e*^ ^4 4lvn^ o£ 5ui03 ^r \r\ ~^br&x\cj£* w^r because. <Y\^ Loalle^ ar 4d fak sa<\ CasAs CevlA \ hav<f 2£St^dl 4\a \esa\ ^ePini-Vinn #£ He 4erm "fYin^11 -H ML be \es5 H^n -fekrM reserve.

MgteS / U.S. Curv<inc^ &# t so tt\\\\7frn / ^ r anaHm 3 less Han His> Ts uhcv4 m£ cavi udf\a^s^ or *'Ca£rVO %nd H6r6f\,re S^ch cJai^ d4 Po^errti is uMWeV bu4 ^qul V)\JST CdYv^ ne^ue^nS He Hiat judse 4b eMer+as* "2nd e*js£ise •Vv\e"'aijlA)nor«-\^VA VV\-e tourV Sa^e Vwe. i>ud3e -Vb " SV^eu m^^Mo^or. -Coc ^>We ^ Comm Vm'v-Wi Te*. «. fttt. 9rD. /

"^nA SsKina V\\£ Jud3a Vina* -Vne Judse. reader 3n order Vr\aV \ be. ve£u\*ed -Vo eAher cuxe 4Ae Aefee.+ or else +v\aV VV\e jo&le. Order Vhe maVBfN Ar*\*>A. . fiuV 3o"in3 -Pur-Vher -Vb vfo\a\e. CanrveA \J. Tc^aS, 12o 8>.£V. \(aZo CZoooD ZuThe leaar resuW ca^v Ao T^kectlI re she SureV3"3Cann6-l- cb intMftecrLlJ-VYve Cori^ViVoVion <de"ajis tai^to Substances/ nsV Shadows vO, hi/ rawoin^ TrraA- £"\V\€r C&oe / lYlEdnOtt be dtK5m\&§ed ^ai dewed/ resfeeV.MeA^ -&r Pa.»Kft2 -H) cross a t ox AoV sm \ 101W 9e+ ^cu sued a\\ -He loe^ uf -h» -v*\e./ £>ur 03> SuPTeme Cfluf-F/ -for ^afiu. haJu£_ 3<3ine VhPn So -for <3£ -Vo UMLAVJFULL'f dePrvvie^T and dert4 Me #+ uH^V -Vhe. farmers caUed Re^l "6dk3"\\ien ri3Vrt£M0r ""im\\erfttal£ Tiah-F-s. vv Or ''-RwaA-men+a.! raVvVs." Dtke \ dectere. wW ^VVe Lfcwl i5/ -F\\en"\-V is \d\v*Y W \sx"l ^ioa neei AtvV luesVEn -VhvS ar&m&re.. See 3a£n Ik. n- IS. C EnalsVj s+anAard vecsnsvj / M-ecj fYmerica»o S-Vardant &.ble J. TD bo*Vi oefe^F •aJl FVrratia / aAVornea CS2> -VW VisV Serxirce CrediV uniem/ in AraAinfl fn^ Orfemai Ave Mfei\A\iceS. VVere •aVUcVve^/ bu+" Vil Tne -Vi>\\e. £>? Suwmar^ iud%me^i-V andkiuf^ vna,\ C i£ need be^/ \ \uiV\ K-axe^-fbr SfinVs d% TexX BtfcQ axAT& aiYd \irde® and ptc&wm sfed^en-b tfr M^a}])- -rrsvn our ©Her ffh&mbej-s* a£> io£A\ a.S Vrtm Ssfror* Bnancfi. I Crei'.-F (JniSYi^ ChSoe. ^SK^K/ee^. / Sucw s-ratei i n sadl PeVvrDn/ s^ iusv v«vse av m^ a-ta&r- Qre4iV UnTfivi C suffiO/ .^su., •^e^nda^A v\a*e 3uds^. \SaVer sea,^ m a cW, ssK^ WW her \D/<f&fc/ SnA Vvaxie out \_earrved Tud^-e si3r> her fta™e on a ,vPadu -V^ run a creel i-V Cbe^K. _Ste n^ier saia She. ura& SBnint S\\e. (Nexter u^bs a\Mev\ ^r& cofci ooy Ov»v<\a\ c£ Vms aor -We separate Con-

-Vo o?by\ s'"£m\na VV\5. *9aAv -Vo rex/re^ Ycv Cre&Y S4aVJS. Stoce S k T^ <a 54faL-Cx^rA- iud3C/ ®2& VTmfii V\er deioeFacs 2twd earns enou3Vi r'AftV -Vt> vePd^ d£e Voav^ C SKe "is tfY\& Av\ eiested iudae. 2k>A) -tt\efiefc>Te. Y&& r\D Kft\Gne2s,v2)/ Vhe ,x Onderw rder11 a^frbxj^el W 442/ d>M> d\r -W\S Maudt> w loan .

TVe ch\& -tosc \ePv -Fd Ad is prwide. her uidv\ a Cofft 5? dVe COrdracdry U\\vc\a £,he \=» red -Vo 3T3n. x£ She reafrW dVrs* \aVer/ SKe ia.ll read in d\vv£ lita&nSi LjinVr^c-F a reference. -Vo ^ V<^asA ft??\u:<3VTStt "3mA u\\\ LC^mV kiV n.

We "\Ar anvd \uiV\ CM. ^OU av>d 9t3la. <-#&V luUl -hfil ber .atu iuil\ be rrifiYP. £r\aua dhan CdusVO uV,a9p^ td Prtwrae.

W a Co^wbti m^\ or shaTfcomia^ \r\ v>er fcrson -Vt> W^and <s^ce She Ya4er re&^ \V ad Wne./ ^Vve m^h+ -dlSn. Su£ ^ou/ "SE^/Mfr Hbai_ fed dto+ YV be r Since "i-F -Vs- gegi&EQ 1 -Vo hero ca^ u_te vA^.^g Ver -VW abas>\<Vd ber -Vo recuse Y»exsei£r c\erteTnft ^ojr fliahtyi/ \eastv03 B. TCCotA TrvaVr \\&WdV\S.-fanA"\ n3 *a^ uSd^te V&uSS,lV maVvxwa W lYVAtt/fcaWi Sbe tvaV Yvear VVe c^&e/ S\\e c&n be "»mParVi-a\ or -Pair.

h33\r\r \ voAv V^e, C-ttjVocC Vense^i 4-be dmms reaaretoia aoor fYaeVTce/ k)kcV\ ftppd iia aAdi+n>ria.\ Pl?oOF. The OnlX vud^i ^eu cvan Test ova crediV WorTWnosa, \s -Vt> re>neoj a cored. 4- Tc^&rV rdboaV two. and Vpftsr^ 2tfu. •™m le3diw a*A Y&u&u* c \ m2iKe \esai3/ Cwil? Mii/ Crimea* "J do to ao So b2stfnrnS .W <&i_ dh-e san&Wxe, trr (Ate* "is entegj cm ^jy Loan rrPPUcaVTCn /• *to Ss unia^oii^ Bixd U\eas\\a stee^M -ro^erber he- ceojse -Wie Loan F^rca-AdoYi \s KS&tted dro dY\e moV^er d£ dbe. &ifcdira ODnVcacF C A-au-VnerO / and under Te*s& \^w/ \* Va VneesV Vor dhe bean fvWcaA^v\ -Vo Yxs^e s©c uddn Vn^ ^defdaaMer ju;ihlAe SV\\ Pi^rrw^ -Fn V,Pr m^^r.. Ta 3leef LjvVVn b.er \au4b\\?h he -ftEd- muSV 3d- legal Aivence C "a -Pirta\ Aec.re.e. -bo J^ safe, a-gd / heann e> ctencfe £l e - iyqtK a nd eder\vsSsa\ _\ T_r> srdex -Pot a Covrd -Vo pn-rV,rrfi ^t- e^ffi^ ^ ^^3^ burden uW nfluJ SW&F -Vo ^ova -Vo A^a-^r-e d£e SumfZL, sv^ v\Aeo M- uYlswevfir \ .se&ol- ~Vd a(W -fV an "audb loan (xini\e 1 record — record— c>ja\d/ VWd m^ ruV be ldSTL.1 nor \a*/£d be^ju&e \ bJUuU naF be\ Q "ferV^-TD 4he record^ £» \ uitt iu&4 3<r*fo and aW^s -for a ned loan. todted- Tywl / amsate /eof. / are hereby II T/FfC$T£ OF VI &£ i,5 /S; -ft CerM r/pQ. [-£jr^/Y fay

r ••/b-f-k <s&*j ^ J^a/S CERTIFICATION ITAl I ;ORD

City of Hoifon, Texas '• • .I ;,,-. ^««-ow«l*te%

v • .•!..iiHi:>eobM%i^v y i '

!CTAfEJoiTEXAsl.

I. PLACE OF.'BIRTH .. CbUNTY' tyftj$i)* b'. CITY OR TOWN [»ouhld<eHylimh,'9i^>rKin»1>S:]' '«. NAME OF nfiK^iBlra^ii.aW'riNiWWtHJ5^---- HOSPITAL OR ' d. IS PLACE OF OIRTH INSIDE CnYOm^^f^^^M^' -K^^g. .lm^M'r-':S* ..•j.^^i ^.T£~ .. liyMalp,•,.,.•., N° el -k' ';.T" 3. NAME ;lP ,*•««!•, EF" id r^ 5-S.SEX Male.

7. NAME *• WW . -A.:.s:"S:.'. •!,*» MMiuiiij, J„,?ii.. jlJ6.'.-_'-: .-. :"{"'••• • JINESS ©^INDUSTRY,.. „, ,'. infocs is^tfwfdft^s'aawrjij "V ASUAt^RCCUPATICW Jffi19. AGE [AfKmi of*« BirtJi] gQtfH IP iHi? HlQIHEK «qrny».Tg •ii maIben 'nwseg^s- .AW-W' ••-•-•.•—res&g -f»VH*t - -;-s .-. "Ifeitgleld M. AGE [AffimoofHiiibMhj ACE,'£$>i* «J«^g|oijlinilJtJ J J_. ^ f f l » BORN.TO TWS M^ ITfadadb tk* eUdi]' JSJ daid[»MaidaatK..«ar*H 1 17 • . YlveaIM. •••••• Texas Texas ^^^ warabomalwbut daadH" waab pragnancy]?

IMNFOSMANT . 7T S? ^P^ ^tP^^&jjjFi'--;~ZZ±. JlLSL .-. •••• J »• coccm! gjr* •v.l~J -0-- 79b7 ATTENDANT ATI MRTHw.. . [_j ft. IK.r.br cortity fc.frti.iMd w/(«:;|WegTENtfANT^Gr^TJJR^. Vf.-^ ^..v._'t«y ib xmim 4s xaiifsa; mvj ofSiA aosa I—I PI ,S». on«w date rtatad abo*a * "j,*&M©P? ' 5^t</!9™ '"''j^J'JffiSStlH. UP. '^--•MIDWireiJ.-.JTHER U iin ' '"i^* |9d. DATE dG« '•a|«ipSnSp>AN^^ '--^4gfe*TJE!JDANr5;AODRESS.J.SS._. e_ Hm .~Z~*Jes> M P-4 1/ - ,L "Cr¥.U? G* MUH .L . ; - ai.. .RLE NO. lAt&-REGBJBfJ.OCALREGISTRAR ^i»: e,J jflttr- ^*.~ it A ^~

CERTIFIED CpP%)F VITAL RECORD^ STATEpF TEXAS AUG 3 0 1991 COUNTY OF HARRIS DATEISSfeD registered and TO. I. aLe Inandtheexact placed.«<Ue rA""*" BURE<U OF VTTAL"•JS^SSSTiSt STATISTICS. HO« HEALTH AND \R. W. Hanks, Registrar HUMAN SERVICES3DEPA< DEPA'™ENT- BUREAU OF VTTAL STATISTICS

This coiinot valiirtmless prepared on en A ;ing seal and signature ofRegistrar^.

LAMINAifeN MAYHW, CERTIFICATE.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.