Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Stiff, Devon

Stiff, Devon
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided August 14, 2015

Stiff, Devon

Opinion

/0*6-15 >m Ri.GINAL

IN TH£ CoufCT OF CATMXMAU APPEALS OF TEXAS

„ RECEUVJED'iw^ courtof ammmm^\ *• OEVOfsl STI FF AUG 12 2015 Abe! Afios&a, C!©rf< V. FILED IN TH£ STAte OF TEXAS COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS •AUS 14 2s:s Abel Acosta, Clerk ApPkLtMTS PETVTION fo£

0*/on SW£j6S19o£

Pro-S<L, Lists of parties APPELLANT QEVON STIFF ^

APPELLEE- The STATE Of TEVAS

OEfEHSt CourfSEL; AT MtfTjoU -A-o SuppQESS: UK 1Waw D Co% iHo\ Elm SWee-t- $u;.-W 33*o DALL AS ,TEXAS i^aoz M T^AL; Calvin ~3<3Y\f\So^ n oo Commerce -Suv^e 5LI0 Da Was 'TeVaS ~75"?-Oi 5TAtes Attorney M-nriUAL A-V MoT^ofvi 4^ SuAfP^ESS", CfcM«ft**4 5^ ITU DALLAS coukttv District ATtoR^es^ office PftAHK CftowLEN Counts gMvUi^g £ ALL AS /T 6*AS 7^ *T - W<1

II APPE^LLA^TS -ATTofcMEN Or4 APPEAL- -Ju 1\ <L> W o odi S OALL/A4S Cout«ni PueWc DEFENDERS OFFiCE pRA^U CficyJIey Cour+S &nl<Kog VIZ W. p.WEAFftOKT 6\vd^ LB-O.

DALLAS^T^VAS *7 5r-2.oT- ^3^ STm ^S ATToAhl£V o/vi APPEAL C£fr\6 Wa4R<AS CfctMU>/AL 0»SWCf ATToRHE^ ASSISTANT DlSTAiCT fKTTO^B^ R.ANK CRoUtPf courts BuiLOitf.G N,^^EftFf5o/vlT BLVd . } L6~t<!

<> c - \ Ji Table op coMteMts p*ge List of parties Ifjit JC^oB^i oF author vt\e:S IV STATEHEKT tfEGA&D&HG OftfcL ARGUMENT" \.

STATEMENT OF CASE

5tatemEk|t of. (fcoceouAL History 2r G^ouhos FbR fiEV]EW AROuMCfsfr 39 PRANEft Fo# RELIEF T.

CERTIFICATE or Compliance CERTIFICATE OF 5E&VICE g.

APPENDIX Xr^JOE* oF AOTHoftmES

Balit v. STATE 530 S„J*L 2d ^ V23J15", l^fe> JTI5" CTey.Crir*vApp;> 3, Ben-H^ v. STATE B3E S.Wc2cl ^sl)(o5'2 3<9lfaCKx.C/?/M.App.) \ "3- Davis v. STATE 319 S-Wl^ 3-19^19'HT8 CTe-X.cRlM.App.) <*, 4.

Osckev v. STATE 5^2 3.W.2d-UbiMQTlCTex.CAt^.App.) Segura V. STATE %7io S-W.'ld; tig, W CTex. App. DALLAS) mi S0K0I0W V, M.S. M90 u.S.Cf. / CI989") M.

TERftW. ot410 3qo U.S.C+I Ci<?(o?) H.

WAOEV. STATE U>l (oUM; lol-S.CTex-.CfiM.App.^ g. ^TATMT^E^ 3^ ^-S**"2-*,53*'55'** trcx.cn^.^^.-i^O cft V.T.c.A Mq.ai 3.

Constitutional P£oVisior4 U.S. Coas4 ar^e^d IV g.

(?ULES Tex.fi. App. P. bfe. 3Ca)/b)/C) andCd) 2# MiSCEtLAjslEouS DART CODE oF CorfOucT -5S 2.01, C^ r

Iff STATEMENT Of ORAL APGUMEtW Appe.Ma<\4- w<v'We.S ©r«xL <x rgu or* eo4.

STATEMENT" op CASE Xm 4V\a ms+ar\4- o£4eAS<L 4Ke 3(„3^ Tu.dio.iaL Gis4ric4 Cour4 DailaS CoUn4^ "Texas Caui-t M!0„ F-ok|9538-W darned Appel1at4s rv\o4-io^ +o S^rpreSS, A4 4rial 0-Pficer T, sWo« TtsUAei W S'bserVe^ App«.llay>4 \oi4ef»n^ 3o xY\\rt. be4vJJee^ 3 C'»4f V>US S4op5- loo and looblo^'S S.Lamar and loo UooAs4. S4inSorx +e$+,*»«* ' Appellor*. S+ag^ered aS fc«> gjat k«d 4o+W* location Suc^d-m^ 4V\<i iwflaena 0-P irv4o*(ca~UoA ancl V^la.4ion o-£ 0<xr4 UrUnVxQ poltcsj. §4-iason pulled aloA^\d<t 4vv«. cu.rb a44emp4\Acj 4c approach App«U<x*\4 ac-V\VA.4ed his d^iCViaA ij^V\4s a^d 4-ur^ei on ^iS Spo4 113K4. Appel\an\ S4ar-Ved jocjc^acj a4 ex Slou) pac<2 } puiliAa a \oCge_ MacK $M\-WeaSe,54iV$on AjilWd *"'S4o'-pl police0. AppellarA- did r>©4 Comply a SWorV disVa/\ce- a£-Ur 54m$an amd to.acK Up o&P|'ce<* Cc\ugVx4- AppetWA-. S4»ns©»> s4x-Ved Wt\G-Wce<l Appellors pupils WJkf«. dilaAed Vw V\cv.<J . SIWfe d Speech 4Y\»ic-k Vouw^t, and Smelfed*©4 no alcoWol. , $4»aSoa arr«s4e-d appel-lan4 -f&C public lo4oxiCa4voA dfSOPcUr|\f Cor\duc4 <XAd av/adei^a ara5>4 / d^4«a4ion, Appel\a<r\4 r«-CM.S1 4o $<K\t Ol«\>j4V\i*v<j a. SearcVx of App sl|Ua4s person rev/<iaUd A<i idenAi^'cvCaiion rvo op<n aUo^o\ cor4aiAe^$ of <d(TvAa pafixpUemU*, . Tw o-W'tcers Se^fcWei 4y.«. SuiAcaSe. a'od' discovered ex. F><x.v2.\<v tome box U3i+U v>j:Wo.4 appectred 4c« We 01 46 Jot a£ / C©,CaiA e IfvSide..

O-f-fiCef Sdv^Son tWa ^r<xv\Spor4ed AppellaiA4 4« OallaS Cou.«vVy "Ta»L uxWre Appellao4 uJas V>ookc'di \r\ -for poS5e!$l'oA UJi4v\ |r\4ev\A 4o dclivier oVcr VOo ^ra/vss and <<2Vad<ii*\ q arrest / d«4er\4i oh.

.1.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.