Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

John M. Donohue, Owner 2005 Dodge HD 2500 Truck VIN 3D7KS28C2560708438 TXLP 86ZZF3 v. Daniel R. Butts, Bandera County Sheriff J.J. Martinez, Deputy Deputy John Doe 1 Deputy John Doe 2 Deputy John Doe 3, Individually and in Their Official Capacity

John M. Donohue, Owner 2005 Dodge HD 2500 Truck VIN 3D7KS28C2560708438 TXLP 86ZZF3 v. Daniel R. Butts, Bandera County Sheriff J.J. Martinez, Deputy Deputy John Doe 1 Deputy John Doe 2 Deputy John Doe 3, Individually and in Their Official Capacity
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided September 28, 2015

John M. Donohue, Owner 2005 Dodge HD 2500 Truck VIN 3D7KS28C2560708438 TXLP 86ZZF3 v. Daniel R. Butts, Bandera County Sheriff J.J. Martinez, Deputy Deputy John Doe 1 Deputy John Doe 2 Deputy John Doe 3, Individually and in Their Official Capacity

Opinion

/ I V 20I5SEP28 PHI"32 « "t K r i ^ \ •i ? * « K \ > I t u % I *, k I « C JL

% "a > I I \ > ^ a s" y Ji i %i 'i V •i I s. t ? V <y <0 «k I T 4 V \ la I 3ft X I X -Ji V >n» s <1 j •j «.

I s <• % ? i X ^5; !?

I H.

V t I \ s V V 1 « X w ft (5 V. S I X I > !

X I I fJ ($ I d ( ( fl./'^4C//''M'' ^75/^^•v

y , _

/ jrv 2. Si'y^f tfL.s^ ^t^o/f.,/^ T

.A /:^<)A^^'^*^.

C fi "L j?* Z-''"*'?^

/l.t/Ji-}/f, ?^7^/ ( ;

-'Z>y»^</ /<• ^Ac^ /.f-, £ji»Ar-yy.

.A^.^-!<^.f-^

y i cj* j>-?9r-t~ / ^ ' r y 7 7 ^ &iu>3 7yT/£

/^'t--v**> ^/if*' -O-v ' /~/i^/L. ^^vbTZ/"^ *' <» / y^y<-^^.t*r£/^n //'

y/^S/c- ^ ^ ^ y. /^/fcJif o y /-w^ / t

tfV* /"/'/•jT /f/l.^^^e•^^' /te.c^/' oy ^••^^e.s^ X

0^ ^/t^CAy%<Ayr' doty.A.~ y/AtJ' t •^•re^t o/^

/ ) A A f f ^^**j^<ACjrcj» yS y ^tffeArAAr*^'"^^ yyty^iy''yy -?

/!/• Jr'/lf'tfS ^ /VA- «^>vO C>/^c<.>y ^g'tAAAA ^ t/ /i/i.^vA^'CMr^ Oty ^ y^'^tfA^^/^-y e^ y^»' ^/t.^•»'**««'»'»"- "Ti* •f£A»ycA^ ^aao^/^ f/Cy1V,^yS & l/'i'' ^yvCytz/XJ/^ ' <1^/ ^/cyty^i. y y e lytA.f /yo^yf"^

/' //' CfiSv fl/tXx

/. ^ yitjji/ y

Z. t/'/^^A^cM^ xryj-^S" c^jrcw 3

3, Ctry fi/ ^yfyx^cytsfcyt-^ , rvj c-r-i/^Cj-? Crcj, 4

W ^c a., y3i. ^iy 3^ 307 Crci^ Ao7^J y, 3- /Vi//vOVtfiy{4. CSS> iA ^AliAx^ A.C i 3A 3ZA C/-<jc, fi/y.- CA/* c-i> A^ rJ / C Ajl yiavj<jc/* , / y yu^ jy 2 3-0 Cr^ /t/rr - £ ' - ' ' ^ ' s y j 7. Cfkr/u. yijjf/^ d.£A fi/y/r'iAy' «

£' /\/t/A<^A t^t/''t'y y >•>-Ti*/ 3/ A»*" (^VX*) ^/r'' xaj>-*-3 y

f. y///f^^AtroA^ 3 Z,/ yt^yy^ yOA OiTi y/a^ry*^A«r*y 7

^ o. J'/»r5'Ttf<'^fc/O ^.v/iAif^ iA y'/ttAy/' AA / "3^ 3 Ju/Zy C3 C '4>4t7A^S' ZayAj 3

,(. yt^yfyf tA ^<A* , ^ff yxyy ZA r^Of C ACAT • T>y///*-f / fff^ yvQ^<^> 3

/ Z. yy/AyX/Sys-Xr^ (y ye,y^,yvtAd ^ i ShySX y i'7 Zaoo^ A? /"^*X/»j Ay/Otty /AxA, C<,A A i,yr <fA/At^r4uy'>^rx/ , 3 jr7 Juy 3<^ •A C/WTe /9/r'~ y«^f e^»y\,rAy Z*-'*) //. iA//^y^xAA^, A yiyyZ* 73* C/'eA' A/*'' /U-t^X.'*'^ / f Zf Z y

yyAAOyA s TVs:*. ext4-. z^/jz ¥-/C*^ zu>d^ f/o/.txA i 7 /-••Of Cf^^. AiUtc y-yZi^ eoiAe. i /A/-roC C.*> 'A. r, 7 T}cy> ^ d£i^ itxxa f /77./'i* C <'-7 7

y^Ao Cr*'/AyAX.f y44^ Ao9t. f /3AxaA(,A3 s" O 7

rAA ASfOtAA d^-z-c ^ 3^*-a-z 3 OiCsr)

'^/^CAC.J dyKu- "Tt'C.-io^^t.t^ 1*7 \ /V/v/.t <Dfj<->t*<jr i V

^Le,-s>46iwO^^ •Ji/Cc^o'-^r

A-^fy ~ ^f^V. fr»

*p//?ey^

A^y^CZ/'jufrt

r'v ^yt ^oy^ tf-iT ^o f^f Ay0^-^<9*^*-, /^yta St., y^ArS /"yf'S ^yCsCry /^vC. y^ 71^^ y^Sf'^f'C. ^yp'S^ts^ ^5rt>irc.^ /^yy^ <us/^ ^i- S^tieSy^sAr y/i^ri.mj 7^^ —

d'ss^c

yC0C/A^r Z^/iT^ /<r.^j/' A^SaZ:>a-> oy^ :7yrASt,/*<yZ'^ M/J' /^y/y^yt. /r/^-^ ^y^j^oyCy^^Zt. ^y>yyiJ' /t^ Z2:£yy:<:» Zf/Lyc.y. Z^A. /tf fhfCJtpy yyy/i S ^yc. /-^ /fZf^Z/fy^s Z» /£'>t yvZss zyZc Z^yyo 4y/>V^Jlyj Ci'^ tHZ^.<J^ aKy <^tU, ^yuy ^/0>tS) (z.'^ • 6^t.l}^ dy y'VVlS^ ^, j/~yt,tcy: CVey-Z: AaT? rZZrJ^ Z^U'JS^aZ ys yy.rZA,o-c0 T-yy ZZt- zyAjt»C^} y*z^'^*-~ yi/i Zy tZ'Z^'A°> ^C. ztcy^yytAy^^ZS y9^'9 ,y2yhy^ Zty? y^y y yyZyW-C^yZft 7~zz< ZCCcyZytZ'f ^ty/yyZ /iw/cSi ZZ^Z ~tyy» Ct.) yiyyZr **/«-<-•. oye yyy ryZyr yty^t Z^^Ay\ yZZ^cZiifyyz /—^ y^Z^ ySyy /4yyyfCy%y7< Z^ytyC^. ZZo o>yt^ty~^ Z~ZZ^ zC*.4yy*,*tyy.-.'f (// / ** ^ C^A>ci»//e.^^e.^ ;r7#fiv-' cA /tS'-^'ity^^ /0/vD U^/*^ ^y/<^ o *y j-f/^t^ 2x>^/, ZOf/^ '^Oyt-<^f/^/7 / ^yij ir-y£.^ O^ vHV^ ^ ^yf^y /ty/tc-^ ^/9J- ^/cyty< y~//-£ y:',ye.y*~ ^ a / yZynry^ S'i/*y Cz./t, Sl/ ).

/-//''C Syy^''^-^ ~/Z^ fr-yyy!f-r f^'<-^ D* /7>^< r»j,yyj- y»yt^ ^'fi'bAucyyr, /9MH /'.^SCJ'' oyy /f^'VyyT ^ry^y^'Z. y7yt.*- yyvy^yS^O y^ ^C- ZluJO S'.^/^4/tyty<- JCryyy. £^y yy ^y^<yy etrx /y^y^y ys yyyyyyy^ ^l7eyC^^s<c tnj/f^yy TV^'^ y -f /Zy~y*^ yfS" o-fc-^ y y„t^yyyy.fy y<y^ _flC'vu***. y~^y£ yyxyy/y' ^y^y fi/St/S-CO yyy <7>• y£ytj^77«yy A-<yy-*f yV<^y^'>iyy/<~x>^^ yi/^•tVyyty^'rr ^y^y^y,/- Ayy^ y<f/y'^**t fi f^!^f^y»/>yr yv y^—^g-yy"^ ^-y^fC ^^w-«Vv4-

^/^yWyfhyy ^yt.o j"«_ yfyy^ ryy'C ^<£yt:a,y^J' eyygyj^ "ioyc- /^a»-"v/>i y^y^S^Ajr- /Tt/co f" y^y*':i ytyy^ yryyVfyycy^/tt,y- ^yry iyys/yf'Syt. y-". yy-yyyu gyy T'^y< /--f yAfCj^yi/tc^cjr'^ ^Ar~'Cyty<r- yyyyftyyn ySc. 'Z>J'Ccy^yyy7^y't-.

J'^yyx y^ y»y%yy •yV^'C y<ty*~ ^yy^Tty^yf yy^yCy*7y>^''*y>y^''y** y 2>*xeZ^sjyoyy^ /fytg'e ySS*y*~y /JytiLS'yryyy^o : y) ^^y*'y*/'^<oy. yzyy-yy^i^^iy ytyvy-y^f-yy^ ^yyvyicy y~yyyry yy^y yj /SytCK/^y/'" tyy*-^£yt. ^yy-c- y^y/yt/ Cz.y. yj, y~yy^ y/vy7Cy^y iy^y*y y-y ^Soyy^fy^^ g*- ^*tyy/ yic~/~4oyy £iyy^^ oy^ Z^yf-yy-yyyy*/ yf-f 'Ze^'Cyi.yS^ <®t/0 ggyrOiSy^ yj/yi /^eyAty ^AJuJe "T^yty^«t,yty y-e> yyyyC /ty%^otyi*y y^yye. y^oyt, /t /Z^yt-muyyutyt. ^/"/iy^yrt- r/^ ^<y>yy*^yy ey>y^£yy~ ^f/ifi»»/"?TS-t. Xi^ /^ey? y.fy ^yxyi- Cyc»»(-^ y?j- yZ<ja^40<f^ t/y^»^y<- ^cye^y7oy gZ-.o/C*-^ /^g^yy^y r^'~^_ 2.) A/'^^/''^yiyyy o^///yi.a^y%^<^y ^y<rto,^ gyz. yo c^ /Sygyiryoyy o f g ^ y "SJ yni^^ yt/o /t.y-gy'O^yc^^ "T^J yy/^. yyx,,y«y ^^ty'<y~ /7-/S\M'yCti y yy '2fyy£.>tjc-ryoy^ y^Xy^o^^yy^'^ /7gVi:-y!4.»yyy t yS'y~J

t'>j .jVJ<aA^/0 ^if*»<£- 7Vi<i£" 6J<«Mvi./x/^/;r>' r~9 /5U-»««-vS> /~//<. ^^,i*jj-^^ir.

/2t y^^rriiA.

fy/-c /~A<-f/t-y JZ/<3jy<f-cy-xksvj/^^^ j-z<>^/-u>'erjr,o,^_^ ^^5 O-Z^/^/AtA-rr yi/tx. ^<.«r- (SyytAcxj!}

^UA*A.yy ^ y y-yy-c. ytyyfv^A^^y- /l/^£-//At.A^r' y/ytiA\y yyy<tA- ^av^yy yyTiexr^r o/'/^••s.e-vx yi eyxSD Cii^yv*<o<. ryyu Sc^*' ^y yyycx^ a»a'0 tfAyr>/>t. yy^t Cy<y.. f) ^ S'yytyH- © ^Af^/^yr c<«Vy9<.v^^'«»-i.» teo y3 ^-fS' AfAut, A>'«e' e>/' yy^*- j>>»j-«..

^fpy y y 4fy ly y/t^.'-'AncAy, -2- vy Suf yy s <£, ztuf^J i^j yyyyK ^ y^yic^rty uj/^ /tcy<'0 tuA^yr/^r' ^y-ry«-«_^tfjo«yv'''T«>v#' <✓ /v»7- y yyt," /'/yy j'/'/try yyi^y Sovyx.ef^AA ^Z? j^yy<^A^yyS' fi ^^C<Aijy a9au<. AAoar- /7,toyCyyx.o ^tPAA^AA^At'^Argfy /S^fCA,^ AK<-AA*yry yy^r ^ yyy'C. ysA,!.—, yzhat^j j--, y9^ 2.y Cy^je -'^Aty/<7y y yp?, ^ ^ T^CArAfy y^y-C. "^cx a^a^v— /3e-Cc-*tc. a7 yiAAtT-y fA ^ Saa- aa^ yiA\.t~^ yfyfO y^^AS- CAA*^/yA,-r' p/A Af^ tAAA/i-s'y Ay AJ yCiAtyA^ /y/iAAtM A^y a7 cf^A^^Ao-A^y. yp asiaaCaa rxyy aa^ ^Av^nAVAAct, /ixyxA yytoysxAy q,a/y yiyer ^^a^d-^y .yZ"S p/^jVij.---r- ^ ^'Aay^^.

/yy^rJ 'py^ jT^yy^cy -TfAivs*icyy. yytr^-A^yte-yVi </~ /Sl>/t aaaa y /^y y^A yyos •Dm/Z^jt ^oa>3J y/yyAu,A /j- ^ yA>yAAf,^^,ry ^ oy7Z<x. yyyA?^ a^Z'Ac.a*/ aaata** ,AAArA-y^ yj(Z^y 7iz*^/t£x yy ^•^•^CfAVAAtcA^y ^.^y/AyAxj. SiAAtft-yt ^ yy</tAC /J /\A9 ^AA'exA"**AA,r^ aAaaja- OA*- y.MAf-rap' aiAS^a-^'-^ aaA /iAAii aao f <A\A*A*yxAAy?7y CAAt-^A^yy ax ytz/Ajrx^ e--*- 3. 71*^ /**« tyL/At/ (SevtAf yf^AXea 1>rxcAJ'-/rA'A aaa J>AX'^AyxA fy yyyAC yS-*-.— yi-i.

Cyy^yz. x/" jZ/£f y*^'yyy yT-AA^ <^y-yo I 3J «*-^ T/^< y^^c.^5.*'/»'o»'r

i/f<^C/<. /V*/»-r /f/'rf^y.re~ ^oe'Oyyyc^vtf*^ ^ /***/»/pA*y<^yi>y*'*-^ ^A:: Ay-foy^r /*^ A C.y A y/^X /S.At^/'yeycA. yt £.^s->sr> y/yx^ J^aaa. / ^ A ^ j v ^ A a ue^-x.^ yyz^ Si*-'3*^ 30 C^9c Zoy/*^^ /l/y^/iffyy y7/y^'Cj /\/V*<t/y<-ti< ^ c^y£o ti*jrJ^/>t~ fy^< S^siAi- c* /-v<rt:/-c /f w/7/<iy*,/'.->' /iA*}i tturr-Tit- -rAA. C-t^. Cc.a. C, z*J ry-^ ^^/V«» >"<_»_ yy Ayy,y?yty<f S>y^^ ^y A^-ryyAt^ //vsi»*aOi^A'^/"•* A. c SA'caA'^X £A^^CA<yx aJ' y-A-AA^yt-tyAAry ^ AA"* 7»t-t/yc. ys^ jy/Saa C<t:£.£ j.

S*j 3^ syo, 3 9yCy^»=> tt/V~ CyAi£A> Za>o ir) Se-'Cytay y^y A-^C^ jSAk'eyioy *>y yA-*—<.<otty «'Z 7~^< Xie-^Ax S/'K-'S yAy<A^CJ^, «!-!)/o- Xaiit. y}y*^/eej p ^ ey^'f<y-iA'<A.

yPyyU'/AytA. /y j'u^e.o ^y yf-ya-A-yfcA ^ ^'^CaaA ^•*/9f<yy3' ywvi3/*vO 4<v»/^ f~*C^*9X a A y yyAcA.-r, y i.<.^ jy y^aAy-MaA.r*<. StST7 Jlu JA 39JnCy^ /lA/*-y*-y.ycjyy-'''*< "X^Atf) y/Z-c xUi-z^y*-^^ yy^*c Sy*-o <-*-*-9• y caaaAA yA/triyyA. cX ^yy-rZ. ^yAAy/tyy /^/y/yrr AA"y»»^*aa)Acw^ . yt/ftaty £o-i—jy y M ^ 97 Xxju 3 a :?o jt C/-c*r/T-^-<S<»^/Vr <s«aftwzv> ^ Sc-cy>ofi^ yvyyAC /^y X'yy Sw^Tin—XAoyy yytt**.ir AAlAyy T't* ^At t^Xyyrrr ^yy-*y yyA. yXy-Ae^ /i'/'A*A-yy S ^ ^ y f y ^ A ' ' " y ^ X'c-'a XcAcyt a^-y ya*. yyxC*^) aa-c* yoy.yaX(yj XTSOy •^yvA'JZ-Ay- U/^iay /^A/yyX j?/Z ^ SIaj^ yt .

/~//c SiA'r /lyy^AyAyfy:rt(^f TS'CA^yA'y r-» Siy<t ScyyoA* yi/. ya C C^J ^yi^yV ^**Xyiy-ar<-y *7 A y y%/t.^tAo£^j7y<. yC/iryyva y a y 7^<- SAAt-A-n/y ^y^ Ay<s) ySa-AXAACA, ^}y}y(-A A^y ->Vzz" »a-«. yCA-cJitACAyy H ^ ^Ayt-ynAA' A^ta^yAy /~^-£. ^A'tAeAyAtCAfyAA lAA^fy- yZA^/fAtJOiAA^ Sa* a%a<~ ' X-ASyi-cy-yyA ytcA. JZatry-a-eyyo-y ^ ScA* . Z^/"- y yt-UA-Ai , <aia». f/»y. yoc^^). ya^.A<ac CaX^ Ay^f- -fCA^y y-yaycj- t£j»ArrJ tyy .yy^< ^ r^.

' •^**' •'* ^' '- -^ ? <C>C-'.X»^*'-^-JV-»^ a-py^ 7-y¥^

•^•'®- -f««-»«' 2 .c> t'.ri^

.'«5v/v^«~»6-v/- » er^/:ry^y

y}.^f^ «^/<iV»'/--' /V**- *»*»• -^, T - rV -r r i — ^ i> vy tyri*ta o- f y-c/y-f^^ 7ff, - ^-7 ^ ^~y-<M. yy*^~y^uf^^ • • ft 'y'xr ^ fXf j3 x/ fj r.e 9^ -r-yx^ y£^,.t^y*xxfty-tyyiyyy wy .yyf-c ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ yi^txiy^ '~y.C/( •£t^CtyXayt^r »y, y^xyy '^yx^^ye^ ^

/^-^' /3/ft^<.^ £y-4,^,j^x9^ yyxy'y^o,^ yiyrt^iyyy^ x»^9 -l/'^/^rixyx/ /t^^H.-:* cxyx-3t^ /5«fcc' xu^xyy^'y. ^y^^,y >t-tf /R-X'^yy. /T:^. yy/^-ix*.'' r^'itisL r/fxt yyy^y yj ty<,<i /y y-^ fK^x,yxy*yi/t^^ »/* yy-c^^ ./jty*J'^*y^4-^ySx.-x'e^ yy":* T"^-^ x7t^y*^y-':txx-^xx~f x>/ yy-< /«^

ijjiHtt^ r^^f JS^ yx4Z./^y <y//4X*r ^~t,,^Z y^-^ x^y ., _ y/x,jy xuuy jgt^nff''^'^ <y t- fZre^x ,t^^^yyrx^ tyy>.ji *yL. f /•ix. y^az"C^J.

OA F£^ ✓/#«<'- , yfyxyx- £xy^*y>- f/ax.xac (4J xfy-9 */♦<OC^ ^xXxf»r-yxx>tx/,j^, . ^ fiCJ^^-> y^ <• - OyiZ^tX Cayncxxii-'J- t^ZiXXM't't. yixy^Ce.^.

I^vr '' ' -HtSO*^'" '

k1^' U C^A^c^ry <?yt- O^^Ct^/ ^^9 **>'/#<c-'^'C-«. -^/f-t /t^jr-fy)t/y :^,o ^•«-.<*,*- /ie,~j^ /-/'/>•''^^yinj-e^ ^/t^t^/'ir y£j/ytA/tyy^g-o ^ y o^y a <"t /t f^e-o C f/^e.ft / /^^t/'^^rv C^ry py ^^^cje«r<y>- tX £ /<»>*- <ge-u^ . it J J[^3<y c ^ CsT?

/i^^i/yufjCyy/' - '7>yJCoy^^ ^'•*y~'*-tCe' ^Vit-wX /lArS ^^%//%.r- lyy/r-tyy/c. r1> /tM-AvcXr" Ty*jr^/ej^,' y/j^cyiL, /'y^'9»^C*SL 4Ct^t/-/7/TV*^-' /9cy^'O ///gfyt^/y.

—»'<^ /7/^X^r^cyr^ /"TS^ /-y r~> ^yr.^tjrreu f-*t ^Ir^< ^eoy/t-ei^c oy" y//^ A^cya yjsi^e^ fyuvl ry y><^iytA /tJL. ~ y<y>. ytyf-y/tt>\,yyy'^ C f y :t,j-,-J Zto * X /?*-t_«^<-y y^„yy y^yJLCffyeyy'y yAf£ jyi.at<y*^'^ y-f C. y^''^Ci^yv^ ^AfiA^t^yrJ /^^<»S yy ^*).<y»<yj/y ym^/^yy /-» yf/^JV-'*^ yyA^y A/loyfyt ^1/f-c {y^/-yt^y yAAtC /^^cyt yA*-yc<AA^ ^ ^ytyy^.—^AZt c,^ yfyct. £»yy^*A/e^, yyy AAA (^ Ca^y^y y ytyyeAAy ' S'yry. y7yr^y"'> Q.MfyT'f CattJ'^ jL^z- juj S^ e yy.

yyty^^ AAt^yC y^yr-r? yyy-£ ^^yw y yvr-ey.Cyy9y-a) ^y>%y/yyjni/ A^t. A^tytyy y^<y^ J-^aSy^y**- Cc.yt. /79>iy*-^A^C> yy Dytyy* *y^y^. Jfiyyrn A'AA^AA'y /ZcyA^yy^eyti-^yeys.^o''^, yjry^ y/t-yo ,y lyy^nA y^y^f^c^ ^/eyt- y* AyA*- J^ytjiAyc^oy uyA^f 'i^ytyytyfryA^ yjAyrt jy^e^y Tyi-yy^-xa /-yft. /Ltyetney^y— y»^Aay>. '^'yCAoJvytA. y>y y ^yyyyyo ySczy y-'yAc'^ yis /J yr'i^^ATi'^ ^ 2><s-u/V'«y 'Dty£/aSiy»<-t~ yZy^ y^ny^y.- y^yA/txc. ^<->'/C«.«*w'*/7»,r ^ C ^.d- _j~>C<«''»/" y^yt-f a A' yVy^y ^^xo^e-s»<>««. "Tjp yyoy~^y<~ yyyy 1>tS'y-y%.»-cy ^Aiy.*e ^ y _ y/Ao- /7Mr?<i*y'*y~^ A» Ay/ryyAya^ A^yy—Aoy^/'/ ^ y A A^:*^ ^yAe-^rTp^^J. yAt-o rAAyy I

yi Cyfy^jA*^ C^yyy, AA**- "Tiyy/~yy» Ayiy~^ CAyp^^'*-Ar yft.

r/^yC Xj/^yhl-r y^y*i/y y^f> ^ «. /l^my<Ay-A<^ ^c.-^ . r-^y^ ya. <£3t-rJ r/^ r- ^//1 //^ X^rc^ /wek^/zi/zn h^/r»^^' /fn~t*n _/UX^4f'»^ //x-r yt^ A/«^'/>- /=?/>--/•

^ z** ^ /»•/> •» -•' r/^^ 7-^.^ £»fcv-»«- /r^i fr-y

^e»* TV^ riP' ^* •"^ ^ ^/»J't-0 C/V ^1 *»«-c

/9yi-ii>"^yy''^ A^//✓77'Ai/'/'— ' yv Mt, ~~J fX/^ f ^ ^ yifTtXfi^ po

Ay*r yMfi- /Ot.^ ryyc,-*. y^ /-. .✓ ^/-A- "'- ... ^W,. 4....^.^^ -^1^- 1./ y.u J. ..y r ^ ' " '-"-^ -'•'•''''

' ' ^^ «fc r t-< - i'-y'"'-' Z"-^'

.^rtA-n.^v"^ ^ . o." —- " , rj r/,6U.1^- , y"" /f' ^ U*"" ,v"' "•• ,.y. fie^ /i/'o*^e. -iXl>,,o-.

;^.i- //ity^a./\^jf^c. o^y// Cjay^Jf=><^ /i^y/U ^xt- y/fi ^ yPtacA»~itfje'S.

J / 5-- .j^y>y - sy >-iyyy

tycy^ 1^ d^ --' ^ yx^yr. ^ Cf^oe^ «»<*' ^cy/^X yyyy xyy yytf*- ^&->. t^eu-- ^^eAyrcjo ,r»w y Z' ^fcywy^^'-ys«j».-*-

Zi.>u^Ze'trx^ t'lZ -y^->. ✓y' e—<_ jT" a<yyr /t y>**y y^i* X^-yy y y yyy< //yx ^ccy XZy/' X//i ^'^'' Z/yxv X oy r/Xx /"y^ a y-f x>X . y* r

X" '^/s/y/y^X X'/^yi' y*yfi^yityy iXi-Zy, X/^^^y-xyj Zy^xfyt^-sx^ ^ Z^ypucxy X'yy''<- Z/ox ^ yy^xty^^y , o*® ^»yx

CirJ

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.