Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

in Re William Isaac Hoff

in Re William Isaac Hoff
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided October 7, 2015

in Re William Isaac Hoff

Opinion

wILr_IAM ISAAC HOFF '~ _"£N THE

6- /\S_" d& /7 "7\ RELATQR 7 6 66 4"€011)111 OF F~ 1~_D1N HE_CE \1 D 11 ' VS 7 The §i cti;:[§\l"t ic?l:als 7 Ap/H&A;:§;§'@Of Appea{$ '. 97 FSUICT"" _" m 7 CASS COU/\/T>’ 1 777 7 7 7777 _~ '.-'9€1 1 121/115 v "" ; <. l EX~S \` .1 ,7 _MB_LA]__LAW . L:J gri 111€{ CICIR rexamapa drean RESPON DANT 799777777 K /‘\U< ev C*¢r+<

PLAIALU;EES_DB;LGI NAL_ A.BPLIC/A`_TI_ON FOR 11/R_I‘r oF NANDAMUS

TO THE HONORABLE ;TUDCE O/" SAID COURT Comes now william IQaaC HOP?. Be/a+or‘ PRO $E m +he nbm/@ 51>'/'621£ and numbered cause Q(` 611;711011/ amd 911€5 +hiq originaL@QQm:¢1JQQ £`Q L_QF_LLO§ hm_a_mlgmMnd_Lmald§bawj_/)_e;c;oar+ 1116 Pol/ow)no :

7 _1@1_;111:1:1;1:11\11 151/10 11@11~ TDCJ 110 1<103_1_8715 an 0¥?1~21111@1~ mcarcer‘cu‘ed 111 17he Texa< Depar+menf 010 _ Cmmina| 311511€€-.@1110( 15 appearina PHU SE_,_who_caLbe_ /oca+ecl 611 The Gar_za Eas,+ Um`+. 1301 11101111)11_\1 202 l Bee\nl/e TexoLC, 78102

1,02; Relaior 1151¢; Qxhau$,+ed 1115 remedy$ and ha<; »JJ(LOH)er` a110q11a+e remedy 111 10111).

l 0317`1)€ ac'+ 5011€11)+ 10 be ComDe//ed 15 mini§ferlal.

1101 ci1s,c;1`e+1‘onary m na~+urp?

A) The 1110110 peroi<i§ 531 {`01`111 bv V,A,C,C,P..

A{`+lCI€S 12 02 and 32 01 11an €XPH`€d.", The 31111511> 01 1119 named co111+ has 11 m.m$+ema/ pA(}\F 4_ Op4 pl HC q /l+~+an\m/)n+<

duty to (`€1@1 pond to Relaiof_$__mof/O_/)_)fo_c//$m/$_s ill _oL +Emelv manner

Mi%sepsnee_ni£>£;;w mm B_AN Ks_)__ wage s£ _+he__C/t§_$__ ammiyl:o;m__m~)ier capac;§+v aa Pre<;_}dms`z Jud_qe o(` the QQSS_C;ML&L)'LQMLLQ(`_LCLMLQS__a_m_/_m§>i€_£l_ql,d_ui_y_t011 i€§£QDd_an;lgLasni_B_e_/tlipl§M/DDW)AQLR'€5 pondem} _ may be Ser‘\/Qd at her place 0_(` bris)`n€&€) the locat{@n 09 Mhmb_Li,‘ PO BOX 835 L}nden Texas 75563

31021Requ€511 ‘fo be heard Relcu‘oi:$ motion to Mmmb;/Mlatof1tljamie A 0 'Ra nd Cn$s §Quni;;@]&£kj££e§uenilc;+i)£l€;a$jaj€$_ Oi`_ Coa r+ S+qfe as Shown upon EXh}bn‘S H~C_’_L +hr_oag/') G 3 1 and were Msl_tolhe_é'es pomeai_as_$beem_zieo_n_&x_mb_ £_C11'1 JLMMMMHPMMMMMLQQ_ 1£€_@itasb£d_a5_EX_-htb_1i13_Lt_rogg b__L,_a noLcLee_//_)co£,<m£aiesl by feQrence herein _Qor‘ all purposes _

3103 ‘._Tc> da+e/. Rela+or hsu received no respo_n§e §MM@MM_QMQ/ Qc>it£t@i`l_a%_ Jiano£ab£_Jx¢LdgLBe;©’_M/iitbgaks__rple&dmg_

PAQFOAWP 131 H< q A44,11L\msn+<

3,_041’, 145 13 clear \C`r`c>m the l:`xh}_bii_< $hownj‘Relaior‘ ha§ Du+ ReSpO'nden-t con nof/e€ lhszi Bela+Of` Se€ks“ to ~ ilaile_$slid;;l)slrge d1sm155ed ' ~1;1:1_cci)ire5i_toifle lsc io_):$_e£€oi:is_,_!§ e§e<lr_ldel)i iia$_uihgl@l pai_/_ediOiCQmM}Mz_thLi1c 05121_ O_ 210¢1_01 _LQ.’Lji§`slllesl_lo_ie&eQ ndimcl_gfsmiiBe laiofsi __ _ iflicl.£:l:m gimbad_?cuib ,_cLQsLlnus _<J.LL&O_ Qll`l€_e0l0_a§£0_£cl` Relsl+or‘ ihe profess/Ona/ and ec)mmon couriesv oi` rlr)v wsiHen responees +o his correspondence and reque€+.

_i§lli;lbeiélf`iiele_mlmilee$_are kee/ied upon +he 1110+1011 ei+elsh_es( ("Ex" Di; 05 )

PRA\/'ER . FOH RE/_IEF

\A/he repore prem1_e.e C`On$/s(efesl/.

R_e -la+o r/. w 1` ll 1 em_lseee_ilcl€i`i€&&;$£+£e§;leeiihjl)li ` Megeeme@i§mmileelmw _;i;o_Be_lal'lO£S_in`lGi)_elm _tilaLBelaiQ£ brilll`g_ llfilkl`ls Mm_ximdihmn¢wiwianimj iy_ PI’T€ ch led digekltempiey$_€eeenizs<leed@sinigeseandeni_i +0 arant Relaiol`$ mahon and leslie +o Relaior ` prooP 010 the Same RESPECTF ul_i_ )’ SUBMIT 1 ED 0¢]2!7// ¢L%__.___ DAm: 2,11‘11 Dl11e Q 1111/1/1\111111111; "RELATOR PRO~§F

U/\ISWORN DEC' LAIBAT`IC)N

__Ii$i_lleoc_[`_undei“_©_cdl) 1ha1 1119 pad i5_Cl0cl alleged/o 051 ihe abov@; ll App/1ca1100 per Wr‘11 011"|9101911_0¢($ are ime and correc+ 10 lhe besi of my knolage_<:ln_cl_1i_ (11)11111}/.,

11111111@11191111:11¢0€ ‘ 1103187 mfgng %1;2 _Ga£ga Ea$+ Ur)11 TDCJ` NO. Signcdure 00 430;1 HW`Y. 202 Relai@r‘ PRo»-SE' elaine T)_<., 73_10 e Cc,<rren+ or iad . wommdclce§§

v MElLiipmdibisllB:`clcly_Oi`lSeelemb_egiaQi§1

DM~?FAAM 1311/c 61 A+ip.rhmoni<

cASs coUNTY cLERK MISDEMEANOR RECORDS SEARCH DATE: 'LQ /3'5-~\5 - ro,wHoM ir MAYcoNcERN _,.

I hereby certify that l have searched the records of Cass County Court for the person listed below and have listed any records of Criminal misdemeanor offenses for this person. .\'.\\`.";‘(\\'>' '.",-'\.

NAME;M\,L\\MW\ +\L)l-\D- oATEoFBIRrH; io“l*’{~lq@@ Be advised that Cass County Court has jurisdiction in Class A and Class B, misdemeanors only. ‘ ` Records of thejustice Courts should be searched for lesser offenses and records of , ' the Fifth District Court of Cass County should be searched for felony offenses No misdemeanor history found“' "lT IS E.XPRESSLY UNDERSTOOD TI'IAT THE ’UNDERSIGNED DOES NOT GUARANTEE THE CORRECTNESS OF SAID RECORD NOR SHAI..L SHE/ JAM|E O’RAND_ CASS COUNTY CLERK BY;@HUWD v (s¢ai) Deputy Clerk R ft ~ ' .. w \ _ i ` _ mr ASSQM W/Milu _\r\<wf~ ~l;olmlq\l¢olmc€ {@ewdu§ :“Mr$§¢cewa boil €irr>j oeg_r:°n rul L_Pei\rifm} jj

(5”

J l `\J/.

P-O. BOX 449, LINDZ!I, TE!AS 75563 * 903-756-5071 moa bemhe;) /i__' DA13M00894 ri<; ., ' - '“."@Ol§ ' Ld l q iN THE NAiiiie AND eY THE AuTHbitir’lllBt?Qiil£%‘rA'i"i-:l oi:=frEx:As: BSXST yir:iiy,'=;`,,» eas.-:.‘_?

BEFORE ME. the undersigned _authority, on this day personally appeared SHERRY Gll.LESPlE\ known to me to be a credible person. who,`after"b“e`i"ng' by me duly sworn\ on oath deposes and says that she has reason to believe and does believe and charge that heretofore and before the making and filing of this complaint that on or about the.20"‘ day of OCTOBER 2012, in the County of Cass, State of Texasl WlLLlAM H_OFF, did then and there intentionally, knowingly, or recklessly cause bodily injury to Kimberly Hoff a member of the defendant’_s familyl as described by Section 71 003, Family Code, by grabbing Kimberly Hoff by her hair and throwing her off the porch AGA|NST THE PEACE AND DlGNlTY OF THE STATE OF TEXAS. _ . ' s% ///Z f

cotnPLAiN§’NTV SUBSCR|BED AND SWORN to before me by SHERRY GtLLESPlE, on this the&§_l* day of (Y;ltdw( , 20 173 , by an official authorized to administer and authorize this oath pursuant to Tex Code of Crim Proc Art 21 22 ( /l A~Giwio~~sio~ tdi/nmi wm G©QWQW `;! NKT;"C:;°,:§,;:;ant?§::,;:;as Peace°Off`icerI thai'yl Assistant District Attorney 'z»~` Juiy i;i. 2016

lN THE NAME AND BY THE AUTHOR|TY OF THE STATE OF TEXAS: NOW COMES THE ASSlSTANT CRlMlNAL DISTRICT ATTORNEY, TlNA RICHARDSON, of Cass County, State of Texasl and presents in and to the County Court of Cass County, State aforesaidl and based upon the complaint of SHERRY,G|LLESP|E filed herewith, presents in and to said Court that in said county and state, heretofore and before the making and filing of this information, that on or about the 20"‘ day of OCTOBER 2012, that one WlLLlAM HOFF, hereinafter styled defendant did then and there intentionallyl knowingly, or recklessly cause bodily injury to Kimberly Hoff a member of the defendants famiiy, as described by Section 71 003, Family Code, by grabbing Kimberly Hoff by her hair and throwing her off the porch

'AGAiNsT THE PEACE AND DiGNiTY 0F THE sTA'TE oF T`ExAs. ` §§ __: § . ::- a TiNA M. RicHARo oN g;g; §§ §§ AssisTANT cRiiiiiiNAi_ oisTRicT ATToR_NeY m <~.i cAss couNTY, TEx'As 35 5 § l\) OFFENSE ASSAULT W/BOD|LV |NJURY-FAM|L¥ V|OLENCE _ STATUTE 22 01 HEALTH & SAFETY CODE PENALTY CLASS A MlSDEMEANOR ` e)tnu_ij.Li `\\C,_'il ' - ~ _>~\ 33 1'\/3'(1?@§3"?“1"=' 1171_1‘:~2‘§_1131\31,__3`33 1113; chary c:»'F;: /‘\33333\/\//+101)..1_./ _33__11337` 333 331`;1 ~~ 1573 M 311;'>”' I.f" 3121/13 §7`~3“111`1',_ 91._;`3\,.,0§1 Hi i_/J\i`.__i ;3 /-=_1\3 13 53/\?~` '§`1? COD£ 1'1 _ Ccrnssr 31) \11/_11__3~1_13'1 353-1313 131/1313 born the-l? `. h C>~§` _~_I_t;_.i_z_)`_t§ lt~toO ediqi;’iel named Dt,clcm<~n‘r , banc 13331111:1 111‘€3,@111{ ______311__3;3'3__31' errtt& _<:Z__ i% tti‘ 31 113 3c1 311713@331 and 1)1”<,>€1)31/1,31331"501’3 w ”\c\,.$\ _ 53 3333.“~31)1. 1_:_\~33,31)311/131_73:1 1_1.¢_3!'1</_]1&/)1 aim lequcb‘r t 3d tim 34<13_,11333§ the C_r 311 t, J`Ltnme 13 10 13Jnct 5315`5‘ County _____(3_3_3:_1___33___]1__33¢.,_3__1_1__1__3____1__33 _113':;1<3(`\1__<_3_<1._1___£¢3_1;>33cr T,v__j .._,531_0’31'/3:£_ pi cited m 1315 __&olloct),n¥g_j_ , _ __ l xvi id P}uc& ;1/115 1,1:3,3)__@_3_<1_30“€ rt)CittiOitcct r;,3:_t1r;31) tc’cl|€mi§§ ___3313~_ ctmt'_' met l_otd.€ci bean twa rhr€e pages \'\//*w@ o++ccchment \/C pages t’tol? on 3»_133~3 AND

lt Tr‘c<'11s'1111"3 tuh\f\' 0§`; _33_133 same fc3_ ._ /3117 3131_/31_ /33_ l,f?€i/‘_f>'@ 303 f _____@3£33:3314!`)' 333/must Ji.tclqc 311331_13 30 1’§3'€. 1_33_:_313£€1€331 apc/1 _HwS ffr"ttit,»m 1ri ddt;m€i but 1)<133. m1-333e31. 70 '

3 owes 333 3333 331/firm 3315+1“1¢1‘ 313 _ mw _ d)ae+ur11 3_<> be laurent the 313 131<31<;33 Cerh?i 31133_ 31{5 ___i_§z_e_(j_i’__ ;1';__€,_ pel; +rflcnz____ic> t;ct£h 03 the ;;1 3101/53 _ __ __ ._ 3333>3_11"1‘111_1_/, “:' __ __ __ 3511{&¢1'?’°2 3%3"1£' » ~ 3 n ` , 3>1:31_13\:113111' r>311;31- l'\a r‘.__\- _ “

E XHIBIT 4 __ “c § 2 " ' 01323 351 cht‘“§;/ _fh<x`f_u <;©__ny O§ 1112 §©1_"626;}©1"1”1<4 62“10"1""1'63)’\1 26` ’ 6/6 1\*11,_11', 1112/m 11)11}1 1611 11111 1611/16112116;1 and udc/215 6`161\»"1£6 __6~,'€;_6_1__62’)11._.11__1»_2;(_j- 1312.6~~11:11 1711'111,, 612161.1_1‘. 1121;1"1;‘1 1€<916121§3113.11 / 1111 1116 L'¢ `1612.1 1`.€~5: 613 [\ j 1:.-161:1:2121:,1.61.:1"" 1211 1112 512-1112 1111

§_'_Gur’} 17 j _C)N H`li£'§ __________ clciy' 1351 _______________,- '§LC}]l), __I___C_€.s`__té§_>_'¢~'1_¢_~1_21_’1 1,1)11\/ 1;)1§ fha §csegorf`y MOU.C)!\ 60 .3; .1__ ;2§%'1; 1611/1111 66116__0`21__161;1116111!1€_1)1_;___111111 ufc.k\~ii`,/ neu/66 ___1)1;121’> 221011/@»£__,_Ler+1§11:1l mail __,_ 1121111_1‘11 1_‘€1‘;1131 r1~1<?131' 1121J /lmml _6lghug6gdmh6

,,.__;.1;_121_<_1&2;_12 ,1)_1‘12;51'1261113§"@1“ 11112 ;5+21112 ___d_f_ 1,@116’}//,, O.z‘_') _?1’6115.______._ ¢Lai_v' O§\`__________/ 26`”'1"-_§`

_ __ _ JLGNYD l")r\ r"x 1` ./‘\ ,11` _/\ EXHIBIT t\ C` 5/( ' 131\1@31393“13 , 1315 `11/0 13 1310 155 1111 1311 3 _1: 13 333 l 33/1_1~1.1/111/1 1513/311 1:10F1)1T1;3C?J 1316 \1%1€?/ 5@313_3 1\”1;>111331 _,___111£11{;3:1@11~€11 113 _3“533‘; C/`Nrs¢'./ ‘;/15? M'\l:1 0§ 5131: T" .('.11/§ f.\:" t ____'_DLPA131'131L1‘»11’01~ 33311'\31:13/11._ -1_ 1151 TICE 33 1355 131/111//\ ____o{e;..l;u[__undei` pemuiy 0§ 13va 1101 ) mm l 113):1_+_13@ dec 1111¢12/'11 __ ,_.__ccccw»g<.wi 1153 533»'; 115301/_< 11011/31”1} 1:3;33 31 /3'~1‘3<_~1-1~ 11-_31;: §'13¢;_‘113:15 ,..alc>acc+m/Mg 011 fn<-:, “)am(/ are due and 001“~¢01‘ TO fha 13sz "f____Q§` m y_~/m<‘>/o\ 311, '

5.~.1..__.,.

1‘511:3 3513/_517__@ h J_` 31 L}' q _ _ __2015', __ \/\/43;1;1=1:/3133 1153/3131;2 1~1.0§§ _ 1qO&187 __ ¢J¢,//LA/M j/;£{_, _____ 1313 1513 \1\31: 10101\10 _,SIG,_111_11_1_'_1.11B15__0E 1351;1,/133151\11?

111.311311,33 1113\‘11"’ 1’1:>1;-; 11011<10551`87__._ _ _ 'F,’B_O_:¢§_E .

G'u.fz.c( 1:~<;1‘~»~} 1,1(335 v Bee\/¢He TQ,)<Q» 7311)2 _ __C__1,1111’31;_131_.1;__01§_1A31” .1<1110_3_11111_ _ __ ../_11335$3__..51131,1)__0.0131_‘1?11@_5 IN_.EQ

Dl\f§i: "/: 11\.1“_‘ 7 255."`!( /) l!‘T'T',\Aa\:\A.-".'A\‘T`(" E)( HIBI'T @W""" ~ \l C*q'_`"

CASS COUNTY CLERK

july 14, 2015 Mr. Bobby Hodge Linden, TX 75563 Re: lWilliam Hoff (TDC]) Dear Mr. Hodge: In reviewing Mr. Hoffs file and documents here in the Cass County Clerk's office, it shows that he has (2) misdemeanor charges pending. I have forwarded his Motion to Dismiss to the County Court at Law for the ]udge to review and make a determination on the Dismissal that Mr. Hoff has filed. Cass County has not ruled on his pending misdemeanor to date. l have also printed for your review, Mr. Hoffs status and information pending with the Texas Department of Criminal ]ustice. lt shows that his last offense date was in 2009.

Assuming that he was still on parole when he committed the misdemeanor offense, this charge would have automatically revoked his parole. There may have been al "blue warrant" for his arrest pending and this is why he was taken into custody when appearing in Victoria.

The.information provided by Texas Department of Criminal justice shows that Mr. Hoff’s last parole decision was denied on October 29, 2014. The next parole review will be scheduled in October, 2015. All decisions will be made through the parole department I hope this information is helpful. *This information does not guarantee the correctness of said record and information provided by TDCJ ot.i&‘QM/L jamie A. O'Rand Cass County Clerk Sincerely,,

l P.O. Box 449, Linden, TX 75563 Telephone: (903) 756-5071 * Facsimile: (903) 756-8057 ~ 1 /§ 1 `_:S'. )\/ 1 /_'<i'_' ms g;Ti\'”ri:_ osi rex/1513 D' ‘]~'UL/§ 13 >\ _IN i_i‘i?: wl \ ’Q-f§%§ 1391 i"'\_"\ ,._`, l ‘\~!1 \ |._. ) 3 ,.. ,.`t__ ~\ \/\/_i_i_;: l _`i`_ /'~\AC' sC)-i": § (JUL … f‘_S/HM/ EXH-TBIT __ _ i\io_r_:o,»\/ “ro n:sn:: §§ ' |"D_"l ____ __”_` ` am A l mi__. _____ijor‘ie_§ ii<;it;>_ _\i/__l_t_itit__it/§i;’~\ _.1_ E'§§i.; §§OFF on in § § cty o§ :/r__iti l__y__ _ui~"» and `7_5335 _+r_\r__<i 'i"n. __S Liz_:)ii_ihi,g CC__ …~T ([_ ¢\,\§j §§ Tza;<,__ ciw¢yc o_‘€ /~i\>'ii.___ W/@c/L\ ;-/ Ii\i-J_u§>/ r/~MH.\' \/9<_)1_)_-_)\)1 ___Cl__as_;ri ed by Stciion 71 o<)_§ ~Ai~i`ri v COD; ~€t:,r which he __\C>i`flrid,b rlcc__ci§€tL G»§"_ Lr“f§ii'i.fic; ma O_I` <_L/~_;,_(_i Mrqu ')L) C?_;_ 1141/fl ci`:‘: \ _ '-_~- i@@ki‘j__ttllti_c.j__i_s._x_i_;tc, i_€.dz_ <,L¢~(/H &Xi~i.i.o_i_ S_~_ A and 5 cmct L)OcLJLL §i')c>z.u i'ficit, cil"i [l$__ __Q:i`/_H i_ici/\> §"i` I`€»Ut‘)<ffi'"i% _'l_‘O _<.`l Sm:BB_/"_ __fl_l>__ The fink pert»it'l _:sei §_`_‘<>r+h by i/_ 71 c c 12 _trii<_i_e 13 <3_91 Q_X){`if€¢[.__ _C:`)i?____ j`/N<, ___2___;$6(.~.1,}’ _C“X'___ OC+C,/}O€i 10\¢1_)_']_'_}_']_{2(3_ _&XC»€_Q.(.{l)'?C; ihe_ _;_i_Q fdic _o§"__ l»m itti.cn_in fine marie/9 where mere vh<<n j`~,w_)_)'_'i:_élfz hilt/6 E‘l}&P)i`€dt brr’i\..il ibid dd.i€ Q;Q____ LOmmiSlOi? §§ fh92 ,-___C‘L. I_l_gtj_éid_ C_/&'Y¢r`)\»e) . _

9) ih_e__i~nm» ocro.d _.€§e_i_ §c>i`ii\ b____‘/ V/§\ " __il_ 13 afi___i_cie_ 391 Ol lia_‘z €XP:F<¢<J cti we ’1 daly cg Ap_r_‘_,l 210/31 il\_t'_i_g Q_)<Cetdmcj hai await wl ~)~<tr.w elam have expired ~ an_cl__,_<‘,rp ,_m<i__:_i@ __+h_e_¢ia+e 09 ;f:z_i o: me ")._Q_i:>, ___@_t>___/__r_)__c_l_/_c_i_m_en_i:____19___<9§___i>e_e_/_:_____gr_e_s_e_a;i_e_<_i___»i_@__:r_h_e._<,:it_<;_¢_rs;eai 9

_i»;_r).t/€“,ét;» .n..tr` i___i:t/

Wiai:§i;~»o ` Piiml§»_§ to)v§_ti)ERcD) ihe. above named ___ ut:_<.ujeci fe§i°eci‘§:uii)/ Pi`ay$ into bour"i tO__ wgn iba oi‘<i€r` ____‘l`___(_".`$r Clic§m!_§_.$(ll ___ R[bri_ T*‘Li i.)’

D/i/:;i: s'r)if'a’ Di n“Q ”)_ Ai'_“iAc;H/`\iiNTS l)i:FEND/§Nl` CUPP»O §§ /1{`» _ _ 4 _ 1991le L)$‘"§’é »H>.- § m 19 ¢_:»~ “‘r\§ 4 ltv 19._- C/&:";Siz` C;C`§';<~w\i' ;i < `ar._/ `><: `X.`>‘-’~ f` ~"\ .- ‘A.‘ "'~=§~ : i~ -' 1_,€_,':.!, 72 ,1 ja ( _ _ _ _ . _1_:'- _ t s':)_ 19: §DM I`S:»A §§ \l. ' i-» '~ "Z " w __ ,, ~_~-- r" .' ». .¢*. '~.\ ir\"f" - ' `~ '\(.,’ _CSu,-_»'__/_§ ~__.f>__ Y\l ___\_"\"/ 1 ;__;`;' 2’ -_-J'-:_~`.`~_U.ULL,»-_ HU_T§“ fin `H`Z' ‘:;~ \L')> Ci.<&__y (__ JUX £cI;)____+Q____&e__ 911 ftl § l`…\ ”` T.l: ____`i“b __'f_},\_, Lw~<.i ix Hm,?` c:§ 113 z_>:_.§;\/iz;§_§, amf § wipe/m s 3:`1_1»3";%51_(0';_4_1+ _‘?`C fl./"i#z’f;fr%_:§ /;_9» /.‘1.>"\~1 j ____?_`h§:_\/_Qdi__<;):_§_\3_@"11’)_’___?1_!_)__£1_}__{:" O';'~.:I]/J '<;4_`;/ .: . ~.

____§;`)_ _C` <t( _/__1_`;» l’_' ’.1 ‘:"'§(~ ii_.__

Tz-#z:m: F@_B_E___O§i:E)S'ED +i~;;+ +199_ i'~;/x_r§e:_c»i`__ : 1____2__ 11//}3©131_1.`>’ .L.f\»'IWW f'AMfi; i/I.Oi_i_;\ § !9€>_

Ju_z_>_<z_§ "U SU c`\'o Y”\ t w C`)

DA{;"F 9 mr § wich 9 AT€A(', L4Mn~s\1__1€¢ 1315\1_3: 1341.')©3(_§‘{"___ £XHIBI/__ _ __ __ L_)l)‘éi§§»x/_O.Q 1"_\1 D_f:`_fl’ 113 !“_“1"_3 T 7131\? " 1333 ' _ __ : 11/'1111~1_/-11*`3 IS/§AC HC)Fk) `_T UC?‘J 1`_\1'©'1 1__‘"1'1’}8§87_, 5:»@1`11;_1 13735131111; _ 111(.1.11`£_¢:!<,|_1`€1;§ 11”1_“1"_?\1~`; §.1/13-1.»;/~. _?:AS"'T 1,(?\;`]:“’1" O§ §h{:; Tj:`,¢',/;’\, 9133111111117 0_1~_1,1111\1711111.. 7111711_1~ 111 1315 1311111/71:'/ olec}aif 1111<;1€_1`_13@1111_[1y_0§ 1331ng fy) 113111 l 1:11)1__ _+__11@ dec;_ic<rQ;/)+ __ __ <11111311;§ 11" 713-13 <;11001/‘< /”<1#/`1}, ;'113 cf 711<1? 1513 §110‘11_111? __1_111;3_¢13“1011,1_11§ fn<:,__gc,m)c are true and corredr 10 fha hew O§ m 141/mem <11,, __ _ _ _.

_ \A/J.:LL.IA\A 7111/1315 1-1:)§§ 15081'87 z _ _ 111111 1.~:~;13 1111-111\'1§ _ 701:_1):_1;\10__, 870111/17111§&` F_DE 1-;\15_1*.` 11/111111111 111;1‘\'&" 71>1;11“1110.1€1176187__ _ _ __ _ 1°__ O__5E " enfch §1:1<'§1~ 111/1111

ii :B@ew 111 , 7@<<11 73102 s __CL1P1?1E1_\1_T §2?1_11351_7_ 111\10\11/1\1 3031:_$3 31\ D_ CONT~11, INEQ

D;§I'§i: Zm£."i' 17111(»/} n~r'r~,\.»x..,u.".'»u*r*(`

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.