Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Benjamon Ray Stewart A/K/A Benjamon Todd Stewart v. State

Benjamon Ray Stewart A/K/A Benjamon Todd Stewart v. State
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided October 29, 2015

Benjamon Ray Stewart A/K/A Benjamon Todd Stewart v. State

Opinion

RECEIVED co'JRToVappeals epcono DISTRICT OF TEXAS 0CT 29 2015 „„,„«; courtofappeals OCT 292015 f "^"SSKSS" DEBRA SP.SAK, CLERK

T~hl~sM*- o^r- T~<&<^> Co<uA~o4 A$fZ2js £jlsU^&£>^ Q^Ls^QoMH-cR- o k- (sr-fio(fc-o&- oX-tr-ooiU-ce.

0Z-/5—&H17-UL TrrU co^ri-c*^Mo<>r £32lAojL3i£L QAAa13A

[i&oc dlojfrko (~ -{-U Ce<^rf

My A-qQ&<£A>bk>rr<* jflfLSj-* D^>l^t K^i kr&ia^ JzJL Lg~kj Suffer*^ pczJrc-Jlvi^ kxS-Qufisi- l^~ twice. J~A* /oor M£L si-* DvkA^ Wt>(jxU& >&*<* fc&^cU^fy jPrputeh&A^ oV ifa T*£C£&. 4citzJhs RXpV C**zX /^W by \rro(c4M$ A4^Ul6rv6 %C,o*4Jl ^^k^

]ft£ r^uji^ix7 sX^r^l . \/» / kc sfate- of i €>c^3 The. Zec&Ad flistriuh £o^rh,>£ Appeals T^e^s (Lc^c r 3£ Appeals Cja se <stc>S, I _ Trial ££v£± Cc^$><l Asps. : _ „

(SW^ClcMjcJL c/-inv*-J C&w/yftfeck by g0o&i^i^J 6^^v5el^ /^7ni~fO^\ -Far £LgjLfeA \M!!£I**±h £vr~ Affe. ([4*+ faj£oAsuJ+ jr> Tate*. Ac^tv^ Q<s&<jCaa^ -ho j-ke, CocS<l cf JtJ?)cj*-t CaAtSi^dt Ca^o^ ZDI) AleriiQA for 7** Orjiqc* 6*urj of^rfP^clS f-g> TcJpZ Action p^OSKsC^ "H> f L d~o<J?*L Orsfnt^^gurf o£Atf>p&ds- fo disregard Appe-Zlc^ts: &nte-£ SlJow\\j^^SJ by sX W^i/y^v 5A Jol^x \Ark^> yi oiccfej^ j~k#- Mdn^hery protsisfoAs t/\ 7~Ae T'K.aCp, A-HrcM^s 36< o^i (IaA Apt/ by spz^SCicMUy \zjo(clj4^ AcJf&^l Z&o^tt* q/vj? /^gr/faJ ha Ji/J^e WtscXls S?^^ Qi&lrrcjf- Co^rf fo +ke. dUinwie<£ of app<zSYc<vfs Qipp^^l Uy ^rch$ dff*Jta«.ih Yle^J -hriaO pz>Cggi>iU$r, T~k^f Ofe CrJ Heel sfdg-es of q £rcshAffOecJ. Mu^reZ ^sfz*M >$srU &c£A22 » / optua.f- Co^a*fy Soj ( fLas^rA $ *f^r irrs tj&4j os^ OaJL Wad roc?efv\ urlli pr^c^e.Arh^h^tty Urf^^M_ bejfo>r^ Mb fr.&s .for /few fr(^l prvCQeJtogsj 3%ij ^3c/5e o<vdLpris&^ r^^vfAs w-t Ll S^> <^> *kh*jj Md. sL cry k^ claJl n&t /kjJcu 6x>^j**<J:_ly)^0^ -for al^±^sjz 6 mlqMLs,

i^iov £>/~ F^.{dc^cs_J^ f-o presetfa

IrrSWe. 2jS^vM^22

i-kjL yy^.c^.c.p, Arj^ccU^x.__2J>,of: o*~Jl &*>ry by ifucr&CA</y

purposes. oaJl bejixfihs o f P7z>Ho^ f-t>s~ (b2^> frftJ Oro aieJi<\«s -WJw^___JC_ldrgc^ /uw-c heje.1 clIqU- tKp ng fecJgw. d /ueco fr**&i a ac^q iWa/ aisoidfa. ^ £ As^^^^ii^p^iS^c^ //i f-Ag. QffarvuLiJv*-. QJ- feast k*- jgA/jz ro f>re-£or\s*. Q-rrgrs Outside* -fUrfa-carcJl*; SofUy CosJA be. Ugrd o*~ c#i«re-c£ A-ppdud ; /V- -e^b^o^ /fr^ -/rfc./ sSj£sh£-Jbc.p*r£ cicxzlde^h f Cc^/^sicvdJ^Jzh, OaJ! Sold _G2#oPAjB!y q/&o H%(*Jl fc> U5Q &IvcUt -establ'skejl Si,ry -hUse, errors ^dtiis ideallyOAcQ Co//ecf\u^(y, 3: u^<J( ft?&, S'firJofa nas Ucrbu^dy use-d perSurcJ i^jjj^My fgs/f*m*y t/s. /t?^- <x.p^Qd foNef g^ f&CfLs&L lifes -fiUdP, iv7f^ JTl/ffie tVttck ^^+-U Z?sl** "He dri**gj L£>t*?sr? Jfj-eJ} Against- /^e g*.J rtyofpeal fey /#& &irSz>^* JTpor^a(y reff-c^A Tk* Ce><Ao£App**l$

C$jA*kl A> ^^^fa^__<kkJ_.:^^c^_j^Ar(e Mon>'+*~^s <?tftm/$ -S&hh^h^ ~\-W Cfr of A$&4s .i)cvSc4U fo ^fete^ spa, 4^: J ^t^v /JfQ.&K&b^ ISf'oGii*ctj OaJ Hits afhd$S sny Cfp*<U.

Jffil, &-£\.3?h*i h>L£„ tt± by his r^.foscJ2 -h>6oh7*^c*k 7v\ \stoLcxHos\ cf 7:>$.jDJs<rlpLhJvy rubs s*cfto^ /^^y o^ IT S<^ffe^ f"A^ Pftoffec- _(s^\S*fti**\t*-* j^JC /?/5 cpl*^o Usfe^ of CdA&S? *$» S<P*c& Q^/^g- /-3 y*^/ "H*~ iecWrJfifcty Co^rf o£ A~p.a£cLs„ or -f& CT^J?j^ Ur/scA ,5q -f-A^f- Aig.

CoUJ hxi-lp /yte S*e£_ relief\; ^cA gL3 o*J^of-j-A^^ /Z#/~ A.4?^rR ^nyy^fpSL^ fP.A^if...t^r „ iykc4~ H3 \ATorSAv_j3__hk&jl CT^Aj e tv"i ScA q/.5,g *Af 1M-ft/ tfy CJU>C>5€/' t/v /vs.. „fc*&.J^dlM3Ed*^ ^° /VIZ s/v

cArciSjiC CoASQft~QAC4-5 for /%& shZ&hts Ofjcrptp^rry fU^L toU{&>{ KxJ* by j-h- Q$or**yS/ JTcsJlj k^CojU. *hUy ho+L \Araj\h /rut fv $cf£t% ^/- H-*- cn*** W<U/ &~5 q 6wcU /"i5S^«-.

TUy hpj-k krtJl * c&Ay, J~& G7* /*o-6h fiofify Vg o -

ruJL oc&ofj f*> r*o*r¥ <j4jl crimes* ih> :feU ^^D/u^J^ -f-h^Tj X/n /riat/tr hjzfvre. Co^rf Qjfok/>ey A*~s chiy fo \vn.A\e%tlately farM& 7^° Cc^rjs C/^e^Po^ £Ky ofj-LiLpotr'U^ or Cfjfort-VyS ;Vy ^ <^<gLS^

gf(XQp&(d$ A^b g/\ &£>(f^c~UuL<^ f-o <Xc&~ -hbj-h f3 /%cfacl<**y

C-Cla^^ o-EcQJIsl df CT~J!{cJsjt Coy^jL^df pnoi^rd^r ~/As> \ f ^forn^UJcx^ rccje.s<U hy cr^Ay^ norms £<J>s+c*lseU &'^gg'Hx'v 4.3 /o T^-i-e. L-<L<JyGj-s Apigsty fr^ytW*r+kt^csj or-fij-AjL-S} as /d+jyer j^v pj-Ua. r^yz&cj?^ Z?<jcJ<ulS^I/ \K.f^r^ office- of &^&ncJ2 ^ot^LS*-! 6 / ^^gele g^r SrToiPL. ck^££c£&ry -f-k^^L ^-at^Ls^x- o f- Ccvlq.^ rs a*t^~ PisJ-KJOTy -frcn^ eY^ercrSN^ /^5 j/yNLCLAjh potior 'fp pr^-fcc-f C^vf^cArc^&s^ p-^ CaL*rts OaJI JKS^r^- rpk^ _h&C<2SS&ry C&<^r\- SZO^rsfy {pcat^r&iia^jr or*- Co^O^J ^•lf^/^r fo <yrcii<.. f/x duihLsri ty Jop<±*L*L ky £t>A&<*ff <^~ <f>'i~U\N'is<p^ J/jT^CjAj Sos^r^/^**-* £ *J< ~fifU Suk>d 0,(00 XKS ; A/<rz n> -h)jL (kcJ^cJl c.a^^^x: Ai^t j>J^ U/isci... had c. JLiys &UL t-U. R^ Drs4^d c^r ofAflijs /Lz-f- ^foAJ^^_Gr jfi^^Ur^rtky Q*^^A,'- <#e /^ Not &+ CK S [ru(MfX^6U C^(\<Z*\T, - J^J?^c msJn is /lq p 6ns?i~UrsrfLy e^o.^L lo r«f*rt M.Q. si ^^ei^ «_ /fiAg)AJgl . ...

/^ 01 SOf {finery r^bo of p>r&f>eSS! Q'\<z( toAAv^h jA-e ~fdk& <&p(pr#p(<)cM qlcMq^. A JisJLfyi. AjlsIh-j lc^j^ujg4=_ Piscjpb^^ry ^SU/Us &A pns>-fes5!$/\<^( CoAAt^af jA^fraises Q. £ ULsi&rAJcJl &csc$fa cv> CL S 7^0 "f""- t-Cu-jyxzrs *U>1*3ifryf ir^iZH/r&ri^iAesjy &r fH*uLS5 a 5 a S&jyer >k gf^ rt^Jtefs ^Aatf BvJ&Qkx 7-/a gj6&e *+fA& 6^*rcJl C£>^\sd £>A f4<<z st^lA Sac a-/ 'pt>s£L* or taictL capH>pNc4*~ QjcJtfo^^t p6rfcc//v wU(1K3 ^o ^e/ /yig goffer fb^ ^rj q^ak^ flea fee/ All cheats flHQj.ss ^JLJjfAjS^k ^eAr^^i /t> tfe// \fo<J -He- fCcjH^ Qir^Cjj- jArs QclnA, acfco.'K £jts* c^aa Acf k irustei Y° cJJo jHk rr^A/ T^Atfyvj , fJ AAa TY- Ocsapify^rj rcAs^s \rT6JcJ^J 4^ /Tt/2, S^uz>k^ tScAJ^A *w y6u 2-*f p&j^c M&ti<i ifo c>-iw cvs^cA./ j:V-<S Jtlfr^JUJ^ji <x$ JO /us^Uj, pr^e^h -tic* p* y&^ <ls a _ef^*cJJ^ c-SSiSfaACjL rfcjz^sej -p-h^p -IAjl 9-*^^hhfA Afp^l £^Aiw Ibfll •CLft^iO I /r?tZ stJ*t* k>.jf cf/s o uaJ^v

CaAj&rv ^D1 <ShA^s

jAah QAefi^x JTldk*. A&S C-orn/i\ltfeJL a. irfo(<xj<os\ o-f -ffrf5 CccJU sAocxtJ -pydot. c&arztp/ycM. O-cM^ * A Jj^AgL .AojsJhl ^LAo^)UA^ Ar^A QAt?A^ J/W^je Auj Cams* J-&&J <\ o*£ AAs c^JL Al^A COXS^jSI c sA^ht^L g^slfax as /*> tHe- oAh^ Jj^-iSyo fdfp&M P*r &(#'<*- jSL*dll__^firAv V-£fc Sight £qjk**&&*.+. d^ D\sJ\cj*.( LAAcL/ck or |Wql ofnuK czngrvprieA* acAi JVA<l Wi&L A^s usr)U£U(p f^/uspoj f~ ficfiau* _Q#AL_r^_cJj&± for- hJp* Z:~h fh /2o-f- cAfSp^jzL^U AAs,f A<2 .c4&0MS Jlh> 5'/L«ri^ ci ^>^ cfifor^y j^rtioJl Cr\^f*<J fcp'^ c**-_y_AiaMJJ> _ftJ^A?_y -c^-^is*. / #e M^Ars Co^rf k>y /Try <^p^oj^i^_^j^rj\^y /??fL sjf<y*>^, X ^f/e^- )f ^ /P^^jysy &r~ ALl ^ /Or^Uc* Cr^J-^S A& fdCe. &<^v^__^Sc^?Jt <J^du- Wfxck , -T Aa^L.

"to SAcxs^ix'^ tA>_±?b!^_^

z:/- i/^J^ &*. horA^iy iyvnp^ jAcLf- rsL&uj Co/viiAuclly h(A+^ fo pisrppSel-Jly y<A} (tfjl ^*AAk*J- r^r<-S£^TvJvgyv ,o^ A^>/3 c? -f A^t/Kj ft) S^f^er:A^.rA(J> QlcAvcJL c^riv^s #-?/*t} Wz£ Outd^ff^ /rut GwAL _/g?ly_ Q^jl^a.1, T~h£- /Aa^ (^oAcJly \A f€k irC/\ally .u5.zJl p-£-Agw;ejj ^e<sAW°<\s 'A Ply App&A IqA<l( Ad k^ t^Aj^fkyf h& Cg^fic JT Ctw\ ^Yp&SiWj Ms Crlv^S, Xl^C-^vv pro o-g kdJxd // or^ p^rpp^u^ , £fe /csuz^j i^Af^1^ /A& c/SeJl -At.j5 fi/viOAy fr°f7y. Ahn.jSTj^J^s\_^J^?A &Cc}J&aA r^C^^^ef/^ns/ 5^,Xg_ 22 AA O^d SkKeJ 6>c/T °l 7&yoft^ <LCLMery/ fir oa~ -f^sr^ fp AA Q^Jl I&.LI f-U-ofx* T'f^f rs pir2Jisr*A ^3^mv I T^h- SamAZ ^ypdrf SCttd o^ A~U. V^1 Pay of fri<^( — ^ KM Usv frskzj, —-. = » -w S <o. Ar[/ A^A s— ' ^ * = - -J^^

(S f /Wy cj\ €scfS p rch *sf> Pitt Mo h Cc n^. Qr$ av jpefttAg p\^ f-^yoAv Caw-try7 K~/fe. Sold-. A) H- Iggt/gg-s .&-&! V/rt</r c//6\< SU<Lrv4j of£ -pk^frLjy Q*AL kA <\ f&n>p&rGcy SJjpn p-l^cA Ca,U5eJl ]A<Jp c^^fue IftrifCcJ Creech )*>k fas lcK"~p)*r} QmA y<oucux^ .jgee ^oufc^/ q/v hrs f&Jl*s- oaJI i«tc&d {pos^ A-k- ScvAl ^m* iA^Ji holes!** At*. sJjSt^ c&ooo^ . 22 Ag^L ^.ypCgj^^J Art A* C<p(y /° o^y of Wy K^U^rgj^^ /pl_ rc^fu^-o po tXpesSS Acs Crtv**e.-s r~^P /3 °^ CLC4A&&.S0X faSc-g, A* 5 CC£xs$(JL fo Co^'T^'rCcdfa m<i(dtfe±s 7^ ghrc. r*-*(< A-4& A-e. r/ <z: /n^5h prPA<£^ ^AAL Ae&'c*. j~o y o*> jA*A C-D/vh^s Q..c-cA Orsc. r-l^ i^ro(Ate/. jgA n> A^e 3*^ fto4fOL £g v>W^ u//5cA o-^ & £yp^£t4„ /A>L^> C-QiA-Q Ae. cA?oS<- /2*?A A? OL A^-*- *L*si>4n^KT At^/ rs o-?Q<ni"bheJ{y pei-^r^T^l P&ati>*-»svy ff /??£ SJvcJg^L tv^6 /Is A /teKg j^ayjL. AV 1^0^ -gy^-SMj /y5 CpfU&-3 ?

7"M sA$A&3 &^ ^ £ycp*sA \Arlll fto^ P?SU* £y A* r i^e tA V QjcJlZ & Al^J j^Al / jA<lp j A w*t$> 1* / /?i^ \Arhx>hrf &*Al grfelloJi ouAAU flA^±r\y Tift Hs hlo SCAgjl lMcjhfar.

Ok>irft>is&[y f A^ /*iy JcucJl ArJl ft*>f~At/-.<krj!sAUt -Q.uA A~kc Cj&^*cy ^DJTULjp^Jy ^isg.. Qlt-b^jA^iA f^} hcJL h> rAc if. j-* HaM<r hi^ j-bri- Cam-try; a^A Ay app& lA^cJl AAfartJiy . UPL^GsA AA*- "/<SA moav jAap pr&uzs if/ c\aJI c^s^J] fojzn^~^ -A^sA^^av u As Jon-e/ t^s-P^A A~^lf T/^oni^ti^caea ^g> //<* Acs 7a?/3 /3 /tc A J^v^y- ^no*nl*-al Gtyr<£<^ha iJoAK W kcA <c*o^5 /tg Z1 £&ks fy i^^ Ffs Ola. tuA 6f T^rbm - &£ssA*. /p<e_ , p (&xd& Ir^cg-U-g, Ai-e /Asrsk/l&Sf 6 -fAfas CtA-cl&^y . JoA Ao<-j ^Jl^ UAC^p&AfMJt jgg/B^ J^A^ r^pre^fz^f- r*4L, //^ u$*zj? /Piy, a^uic^oiacj</ (s>^v A> "£qpcj4L, <HJ? Aos-(<&) rnyr*<jLPs .A° /*Z:>Pv^ p^>/- a-^4w<l£ |0^>o2Mav^j -£iAj^ .^ &fe_^y^ fyyC+Cjid- fp CQ^^ugr C^rcQ Ao O iU.A-^5 A^fjU^ly ^q^jU~ oA~ AP ro4^ />?-y CjapiuJ ky^^P J^sA fo y?/f /»-<> qaJ V7oG4e /*<^ ^^A^jJ^^ J^L/cflj)e. Ia/jscA <^*AJ /?^^ £#r•€ £*l£5, ^ ^£1 <S.£ -^An /j^3,_Ar<gfo^ fA ^a^j^ Ae. O -pry/Kj f-o cAi5Jr<*y A?y:.Atfk.. cmAL jU- rs Ai^fcr/Aj a

\j ot^r t^a^r'T/ QwAt Ur&uAl..._A&+< y?o~> w*-s& s^y^v^r- /-{wml o/v Gu^- Oipfl^riA Jtgt f ha&Jl 6?yy / is Ai^r/Ar _ 0-<JA*^ 5 ra^^_(viMj. .Jjr^Lf^P^^ , T^^A^ti CeSfpect figc y our CQur\~ Qj\c£ AKe Os-^cJ gy^fc^, JA Ay Hoj^^qU. £>plKJO'^~

for /51acA WoSfQJ^^ Ao OiAS^lf WtfL AiUJ C&^Se-i, />?£> /</*>*> A?>r cA oAApped* A° Take. .A<Ara^ o#Al*^ CxcAu 3/\

30X; /fyoAo^ f^rcA oAAfpjzAs pp f^cJbt A*Ajc^<-<^^0**u), \DI_j o^Al kdoPrc^ A*tr cAy a f Atfp&Ai fa cA& r<L§cr£ A-p(&*[ hn^P £AzJ toy /WCl sA<5zIvk AO y S~ /IpffOoS A0 <y*^d?J-e UWScA^ A° S^pp<>rf H-gfe p-L /cuss fcr^fcc^ hy /h& sJ--2rph^. a> r-cAjzr-s orJiQsr^rx>J^^\ Mt>4r^r^ fo <fcfeaA- A^u^A^vA 6pi/*i$W (g> DrJkr fiqyU\fi ffloku/^ fee S^icAUovrfr^f- h> Tafrcv^6p; , <<g prefab jrt^JM^/^o/jg^ fa-Agf^p^ A> Tfr^>4^*^t<Ajk^ Cfeuto^^^ <0 c>r^K ftna/ijovc /VLoi>i"0^ £ar~cA o^^-ffipi&s A Tfti&2-c^k^iVU&K~ lA^t-c^gfll ^ flpr<A£Uj k, A7Q- J^^U/cvyNg^ ^ACrz>^vv.,

T of. *^ ~4-fp£*M> ^^ ^j*^ e g/eco^ 6o,4 oA App&clS Ho* r ox~it-dol&**-<&* 0%.-l<r- oot iv-cJl ax-lr-&&(£& -t/Z.

OZ-(s-—oa(6?-<JZ.

Rey^^^vvQ.^^A^^^^ <*/£># ^^Ag^^^> -pj tUts-feu/cs^ .App*ji<bjp T/e- 5-/&A. a A r<yss£ ^faA

o refers /ff ^Tsfcy ftrt^JMjj fll#4<r*r^ po &&<jl± j^SjJcrjdAjsh, Co<^s»-i on&\ aQMrik C^pA^s f°r gWA Wvrr^jA. p> Hur^t gjL: oOirv CjfosMA^ M-tUti,^ £»r c4~*4-<4rtp*ds fofzy<k^A<M<^^^.Lc^^A30lL.

Cp O/cAv <ya^ftv» jjjgAg^r ^>rAc4- AgotA* f° Tflfe- A-e£**s^ c./v CgAg^OPl,

c{. gA t AfpcAs ' '' p^tex7$&jest-- ptppy-ys n-¥/ .iridiccfK^pt ?^jyg7 r 27 2015 20 i 5 RECEIVED OCT 2 9 20f5 COURT OF a:- ..._.; :CONDDISTRk*;IOFTEXAS DEBRA SPISAK,CLERK \ L&f\ wy S&co/^Jl 0isAn of A Ae^-cy c»

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.