Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Hartwell, Ross Allen

Hartwell, Ross Allen
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided September 16, 2015

Hartwell, Ross Allen

Opinion

XAiTWECO^STOP 955 - IS p<T /\^ST\MXTE)CA^ ORIGINAL VS. THE STATE OF T6XA5 Pn^^M^MT

cause MuAAtePsD-i'Oc-\i>'-9oqDS(1 Mb TtteTmTE&Arm Co^kt or

TOTWeWoMO^A^UL tou(?xC DF £P\\MW^L KPPE4LS £FT£XAS '. ^TXsc«T^rv£»(Wvr IWietaj, \vi flcm^li&iwle vjrfy 4^Toeo5 vKAfi£>-<?r AppelW^

*PE.TlTlc*lE(\ KE^Ebi VlMMK> O'foftL KW^MEitfT TXpETo His U\cvC0F EX?\^lEMCE- AMb5£\LL MECESS^ftV R?^5ucU A MoRLE OMt5E(\TftK\V6- RECE1VED IN COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS RLED | y| IV^ed^A, Sub*fc*V* % SEP 16 2015 C0U™«*UPPEALS ^^a/fefe^ SEP Id 2015. ^DSS ^UEM U/\Rv(£U- Abe! Anosta, Clerk TeV'Vuwtr ?ro Se.

Abel Acosta, Cierk -yocs /Xb4t |<ft^5& TbiW CJLewuwb (JvuV %CA Spur 5^ I UsTQFftLL?A?\T\e.s

U^eVl^o^r Vro Sc

IWmti\W (Tk.~R ID~H&?6 !L.Y^pc*uW-V

•3/)CcowW Vfo^LCtAbr

M TA&LJE. OF COMTEUTS £CNEv\ . . - . . . - i U5T0FAUL?AJKV\es . t . , . \\ W&LEORCoMTE/^ , . . lit STAT£A/,BfT ?£6-Atol X< 6- C^AL /VPn&OMBUT . . , W XAATO.DFAu^0(MTVES » » ,V,\/f,Vu ^TATEa/vEaTcoFTV^ECASE , . 4 t tv|u( ^TATEA-AE^fT PF'PftPCEDUftftL UVSTOM . • , . 1X,X X. frL9E<bT\0Al ^ESEATTE^ R*\ ^ \E^ . vfo ^Tk.^aMk (WV V 0£ App^As deCcS(6i\ re5<v-Aiv^^eti4io«^3aAv<e./fec^t\ie Ass^sWce. 6f6w<^\ CWwvbostond«^ untfCaaoAAMi&^ertlliVY&OH ofA^stfucA^ iwJ^Vvt ofi;UiL evyi^v\Ge.9^^vi^^A^\jA3^^d^jCtSibA CcaHfftJft/ 4c>dG^y eskkUstaA At\GrOAAEMT , „ ,*..,H*

Aifexr\ co^AvEt vjvtyv Rcte^a Vaa cV Tetf&s ?uAcs of t\A&*«u. {hXs& 1o\ aa& TO dw& 4lso cMle^gS lowpsWidi^ ccc&s WKfd\ dafcm 4ke^rUcS, *fr6uME)aT % , , fc<H4 "P^^EPv . o . t • * \*\

-£0KT\FVCIUE~ g£5E&£i£jE- : ^ .. .1^

»«• 5TflftEME/UT ^E&APhMK&- DfrAL IW&OtAErtT t)eccupsc oF^vt r\o,ic^€,oF Ata £u£&Vit)ws <p<tS£vi4e& ^v^^^arccW^Wt^-S 4Ks 'WiAVm -for D(SCre^owy ?\£v/\e*a ,'fctAsW>cA<MWG20/-V Q^^t <ikfl_

•Note.* ^ ^ocomev\\ filc^^se. sho^l^ Wtoistoe& \iWa\Au. Kum^rey vK C<</t\_ " |£oF.^5kG^5^A.^5^6r-W7)j&i^

"ft-espccSlfoUy ?ue^ues^i

&\VClwvtt*tte> <-WA %OlSpuf ^/(

iv/ XMt>L.\ DF Atm\D^VT\E5 F.'PVYi Me ^Awiener , , t 5U-vVv A<n£»u*W*M- , Federal SAaVAeS Civ/A Zohti&\ Vw<LtdL>rtJhi\&> ♦ > V\0\ez> of E*]ldwC*Qo\zr)0\ 2&D.S/.A. , ,7,W ftyVes of Ev/'i^W^We loa WU5*t^. .

And£f^ \L C^li'^^CL, Vlb US/T^ (flfri .3 ,B^Veon v. Ke/iAocbU/, \ou sx-t n l<2 t »93gD -V BreoW v. Abac^MSon(l^^X-\nic)0993) .b A &t*a/ V MfSSiSS|^('jDl5.Ct^5(1^1) .<4 fi^ceA V-'3cfrwv«^1UfcF3A\v\5t5^ar.W) ' •\ Hftto. v/- G-ibscrt,aa7 F^A l#?£(ioAar.^ow?^ ; .5"

Xrv/v/lxl.DoyiA^U^Xn Wh .3 3cknson v. (K^o^faA x%{ JtZAih ? (B^Cir IW) 5" ,3,5" HocnL\l.Tdw&>*<W WA <=%(*> IS&Cirnm M team- V-va«.\arow.«l FMlSW5(£*ar 19S7) . A .3 us Y cWis^a f^a ioocs* c\c.m5} .

U.S. vUxy^fe. ,Mc7 F» 5*3(5* Ctrl^?) .

U-5. y.7*StaciS«\,1lk F£A 2p\ (S^CirW93^) U.S. V, 1^pe\ ,U>& EM561 ClTOCJ . .4 Vl'otil V.Dre-V^,M% F^59t (5%rto6\. \AlcfAv/,^orr^(577^A1^5(^tijCir(5a^) , A

Tey&s S4*Ae S^U>ks> 6dAjloF Cfi(/n«"na I Pfoce^^e. SflV.CS, Code oPCfi^WV Procedure 5 AV.Oi -.13, £aU- of Cc; wired ?<oceA^e § IbS./S'M . (Lock, Of C/WKkLl ?rc?cedore $ 1>5.\U CbV^GOOO Ccds- of Cciv^la&A fyoCodure. § S5.P& .a Co&L, of CfvmiYwA ?(ro(jeAAPe_& 3>2 ^>S »

IWaV CbdLe 3 l.oi . *

?ew«\ CccU 5 6?vOV , Vem\ Codji § fc.o^ . 0 VewxX CcAsl ,| &.o^ „ 0-

itm\ (bcu 3 tos . r * * ; ; ; ; ~&

WVCak§J9.03 . 5,1,* iwv cau./Uidi*. mo^. , . , . . „ . /a Wt/of Appellate?roCedarcU.,S(OaVn . . . . . , \{\ YxMz of Ev/^iwde no^ . .... u ... n

Texas toes

\WdV, 5kU/^3SwpAOTCTc^acvnlAFP-W7^^ J 1 /*7 Cfi^kUtS^ae^SW2A75<?'(T^^pr-m^UsAm9,> 0 %(eV.S^Wt^5SW.^^V(T^^prTv,WW^ . . . .g EiCi)MeHMK^,fe^^^^^eX*CrivH.^ppl<m^ , ,,..(«, F&lfoW V. 5^k.,ciLl'!>SW.M^5(TtXX^.%W7) 1$ &/xtxV. Stak,ai3Swi5AWCTeScX^««A.(S?paoo^ . ,X t\ermv\afiZ^.Sk\e1WSvVi.^5^(Tt^.Cf^«fVv^^ , ♦ * .H ^o\\ovAl/v\/.S^tM(c^aMloHCT€y:.C/lmA^i9m A \VMaANl.SUtlSSiS.W.!^\SlCTey.^Wc(Vpp.ao\0 vVA -Sov\£2> V« SA^k ,Ho, ol- l«rC0<?a0-O\ (Tex.N^ V*^ ^>V5\ , 4 ^V.SW\e(<?5^Sv(,aAflfr6Cr«.Crim.A^-W) , * . . A?> Lt>(AtM«S4^.1^Svl.^7?^aoc.Orlvvv%4cl^^ , t . , ,ll Lev4iSv/.SkV(5^^w.9A55^(Ecx.(ViH.App.l975) ,W LW(a^WN.$kk,73^Svv(^Sl\CTex.(jr^.A^.lW^ , , s A1 Lopez i5Wk1W5lvJ.3Al37ttex.Cfi!A.^atAvN . , . , ,6 ^Aene«^ec\v<^LU(^3Sv^/.^W(T^X^>v.f\Pp5d^ , ,£

Vi .V'V VVty MSkle .SM^vd-5& W5 (Tex.OrCm.fyp.im^ , ^;Uy V.SU-c,^SU^^UT^-6r^.P^p.AcD^) . ^v^^Mc^k^SW-SA^CTeX-Gr^.A^i^o) .

Itaki qxzM&J*.,W SWS^,WOde.Ap^r-SfiivAnhwofcto) WifCauez>v.SWe,W7^W.aA^srfec. App.-£w A****'* W35) ,T S^ate, yT£firWr\tVVlA57S.W.3AMS(. ^X-^«v\% fto^) .

SHe USUU 6(4 S.v^A 111 (Tac.OcM.fyj).^0 TVcwps^VcS^tflSU^^ LTtSC.torm* A^lftf) TV\o^psonV,$^k,(e50 Sva2AI5k(TeX.App —WDcsO .A VKUnu*s v/.Sfekl»35Sv(^WC-fcvc.(V.»M. ty>Jbcrt) >1

Mews feev. t . * . * »- v/lDle/ve*. b , ,. * „ «, <ST/\TE/AEAT DFTWE CASE

CWv csV w\a. Morrow (ccw\^cuy\<^M^ ta&'Vp^ Grtc^eA W ctesfa) doVtesv ixrt be£rft le&vK^^^r^cp lt7t,^Lf^\(2eA 4uicV G>nfc*W <3e*vtti\wnj. Mef tartar vjeVucVn OJ^ni^f^S^-W-ew^ \\ASiAc4tf reVCevfcViprc^a^M-

-\o taacxt Ot>V of-^taJ^affcivvg S^C^w^^eAtCMc^^s-^Ksu^^s^r tMk&ccawfUcz.

AU-<$a£5£*igar\ ^u.&mplcLcVYMA^ ^ ffoa ocA oF-^k re&Wm^VA^c^ At> ^ke_ *p&sse^er s<AioFAUsu\|«'hcc.lsL, As-^v^^^nivf&^ed^kCb^W^^I &\Wrfe\V or Was lwc\U&\o^foLq«tx*<X> (TkGwnpkixWM^ >ies^^<=^- to kn&'g. fay>(Uj6**H- burner; 4U^Av\v/eJ^V\vV WtA^vComplCu^^cAA viHo SoF«fe*e^ Sie/i"a^> bo&t\y i*py v&s e\cs\o^iA F^w\ 4W. vJeVucU as V\ vJ^^imW4Cul ffedk-scd*- cfoifaLA/lvt4Uj% TW^i^A^DfA(v^vv/W\evfcl^cr\a rwAk^sawiL iacv6V\WVu»Svf^^^^.T)ofi^ v*lWtver k,bxciei ojV. AAer fcsitsfsi^ ^£ ncrhciA &a>jp(fi.^r^,W fonn<^ vaI^ls "Ptebp(il or cJ$&*£><\ CoMim\o-{UsLfS\\ tfL\h>- udiccU. tIul&cccwpto \'£»A£^Osjor ^dpvt^st^AKjLsfkr^Ve cV^jj ^?eAHVa^^>U^&rtW i\a arcW Ao lea v/CAt^-S02.</Ul*

Vi ii Cy MkfcW, VflfioiQ.,"^VAriCH&r m(os a/feMeA (^etpkr- ex ivvk^osKon kcs<W ^ V^V^lovjx^t 4Vo^(3} Kcurs, was 6>rm&V cta/^eA wAt\ ^vz^c^ ^d^y.

Ibcx^ v4o.s sei tii ^O.do^ an^ StOl 9k. DocAd \6cEof iVi^/w^cm &* Aaw <^f*t>r Wf-fy AVPewcA CocU AumbtT, fcAdek atoms uxttv CcWckx^W C<*U ^vrffltot*: 4^miS5^HCj <*Jml fo(«W OaAcWrf f k* 15© ooo b^c\ \Jas ScV AoFuM^vv5eO>^ WvAM^w^^^AW 0^ gU iwfc<****v*to F<U& W^V^O ^M^ya^kAk^ 0,5 ^ S£G>i& CgotvV^cS c\m^A-tm^iMuVit quutvu^s ^ D<FS JlOO,CDO vd^> S^U&«X ^L04UiT^>O, oFwho^ ^oV bU ass^Uk*-C^*V^ v*o{*um wa^no^be^bw^ i-V AKw^W,3u^^?^^s((Vv^^oc;V^slV6r^^^l. ***** ?^4k ^uto <W4erf %^'^^T^^tw <T>WaA MoVTVuc ^ 4(ajl e*WvcewiM* vj£V *U. £>«4^>k^V m^% vuls ^UcV ..AaS a\W^5 op i*su*fc-ctci* <mA*c**A iVitfBu** 4^Wc* Vl&s FiWJ .T«mv/ts CaMui \)^mEv As4Wulms <^^ respoackWtth ^l Sfc^s Un^.^a/u qfriS. W^ %M TtfefCt^y^-Sy*^* A*.W TK^Wur Aaw^Cb^VoFAp^cVs, Affifi^cUV^A an^iWv^an(VvWc^pcU<'V

AW^A\nc<A CtfuA^ ^u6^wt€n-( &ev& (fcmaq.^na ft>raeU\rv( 4^u£V ott^ni^i^fc^f.

Xlv| jl^,^5") Alcd. e^n? ^ Ko^-da Tc^ ^U^6 iK At^-"TUc<r4d£^tK(Wt 0(F ApatAiS b<->Vvmc^ \)EmE^w^Kjlg(^u^u)vSAW-F'Pc^'Wmc./' t<» hdFeni'FljLcX Vo V\^nc\ rtpirc^evo^eKo^ twAKat(xuAcl^VvA-^c^^^AAfi^mAAe^ oo-Vk^s HoVton ft?/- EyA<-cAl\5vv Ao"^W ^^eAiVowv Atjr'Discvt^o^/ty^cvAev^ Qyux/mm*^Uji.

CaiuveV^^ i^FftY^ajticK vvv4KsXTbc^s<!d^VflrCVimi^fl.C ^^VsVaVv^oVu ^, ^o/5,TlacSG)o^ frMM^eCs ^Lfie^^^ ^^y°/5 u^V OdoW^/d 4 iX Oi/v 3oV( IP) %Df6 .lliLSUt FiUd A. V,"b.p\. o»A <4ta- ^mk&iOL (t\a&x I. VeVvW*w oAs<9 FU(V c^ McAibvi ^ ^iKS^M*- ^ta- Motion For V\ehMA*? (&>r Mhibwi &JU)

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.